Article

Wake Up Sleeping Beauty: Strong Heroines for Today's World

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Fairy tales have been described as the remains of ideas and social practices of the past (Yearsley, 1924). As thumbprints of history, fairy tales teach about the cultures of people while entertaining and explaining the world to the next generation (Yolen, 1992; Zeece, 1996). While the tales are valued as a kind of historical archive and a great source of entertainment, researchers have found that fairy tales have an impact in shaping the ways children view the world. Bettelheim (1976) stated that fairy tales are instrumental in stimulating the imagination of children. He and others maintain that fairy tales answer important questions about the world and how it works. These perceptions of how the world works are influential and long-lasting because the impressionable child will make judgments concerning what is admirable in terms of acceptable behaviors and character traits of people based on what they learn in fairy tales (Hurley, 2005; Storr, 1986; Yolen, 1992).

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... Lieberman critiques fairy tales in El Shaban for depicting women as docile, submissive, and powerless (El Shaban, 2017). The bulk of female characters is valued for their appearance (Kuon & Weimar, 2009). The idea that women should be passive and self-sacrificing, as well as good wives and mothers, is reinforced in a lot of fairy tale literature. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study examined the similarities and differences between two literary works, Giambattista Basile's Sun, Moon, and Talia and Walt Disney's Sleeping Beauty, emphasizing gender roles. The authors examined how both male and female characters were portrayed in the short stories. To analyze this problem, the qualitative methodology was employed. The data sources were acquired through library research. The primary data came from the two short stories, while the supporting data came from other sources such as journals, e-books, and other internet-based material that was relevant. In both stories, male characters are stronger, more powerful, and more dominant than their female counterparts, as indicated by the study's findings. This analysis also found that both stories were presented differently by their respective authors, with Sun Moon and Talia depicting the patriarchal structure more explicitly than Disney's Sleeping Beauty.
... Based on the title, the content of the picture book is especially purposed for girls. Parsons (as cited in Kuon & Weimar, 2009) reveals that the portrayal of females in fairy tales and the newer ones often reflects the traditional role. Females' traditional roles stereotypically include how they are pictured to be passive, kind, gentle, and dependent. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper discusses gender stereotyping represented in two selected picture books, My Little Book of Stories for Girls and My Little Book of Stories for Boys by Brown Watson (2012). The verbal and visual texts were examined to reveal the symbolical meanings of gender stereotyping which then argued by using Judith Butler’s gender performativity. The analysis results in a clear distinction between the performances of female and male characters. By separating female and male characters into completely different categorizations through their appearances, traits, and behavior, the first picture book represents feminine gender stereotypes that females are princesses who stay in the palace while the second represents masculine gender stereotypes that males are outdoor working individuals.
... Then, a beautiful face is always associated with good behavior. The majority of female characters are considered valuable because of their beauty (Kuon & Weimar 2009). Beauty has become more important than relationships, humanity, and other things in the world (Joshi 2017). ...
Article
Full-text available
The stereotype that emerges from some classic fairy tales is a princess who has a beautiful face and an angelic heart, a prince on a white horse who is handsome and charming, and a happy ending forever. These three sweet things are generally always the main menu served in bedtime fairy tales, including the classic fairy tales Snow White, Cinderella, and Sleeping Beauty. Besides sounding beautiful, the plot and characterization presented in the classic fairy tale represent a woman through feminine standards packaged through stereotypes. This research uses qualitative research methods and narrative analysis. The research results found details of the seven functional characters of the characters in the fairy tale. It can then be seen that various stereotypical representations aimed at women in the three tales, ranging from the obsession with natural beauty, misconceptions about the meaning of ambition, and marriage, are the solution for all the problems of a woman.
... For traditional traits, 42 traditional role instances were observed for females versus 74 traditional role instances for males ( Figure 6 and Figure 7). The authors of this study examined female characters more closely for certain behaviors including time spent indoors or outdoors, instances of rescuing or requiring rescue from another character, and overall nurturing behavior, as these are the most prominent traditional roles of classic fairy tales and stories (Kuon, 2009 Along with examining a character's behavior, this study also considers peers' and fellow characters' reactions to outward behavior as well as the effect the time period may have on the roles (i.e., historical fiction). The following analysis concerns the rejection or acceptance of strong female role models by peers, the stereotypical beliefs held by the characters regarding the same and opposite gender, and balance or imbalance perspectives of feminist views in works of historical fiction. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study analyzes how 12 recent (2000-2011) Newbery Medal-winning books represent gender. The study counts how many of the books’ characters represent progressive or traditional gender roles, how many male and female characters represent each character category (protagonist, antagonist, major, and minor), how many strong female characters are accepted or rejected by their peers, how many characters hold stereotypical gender beliefs about themselves or their peers, and how many works contain balanced feminist perspectives. The study finds equitable female representation, but the study also finds a bias toward traditional male stereotypes. The results indicate a general acceptance of strong female characters and a balanced representation of females, regardless of a historical fiction classification. These results suggest that characters in Newbery Medal-winning books represent gender more equally and less stereotypically compared to characters in works of earlier decades.
Article
Full-text available
There is no doubt about the fact that women throughout the world are discriminated against and hold a secondary status in every sphere of life. They are stereotyped when it comes to their roles in family/social life. There are even stereotypical beauty standards in every culture to dictate, how a woman should look like.Women are expected to attain those unattainable beauty standards in order to be considered acceptable to the society. This stereotyping plays a central role in shaping women’s behaviors in everyday life and determining their status in the society, which is secondary to the men folk. The purpose of this study is to study the variables (the stereotypical beauty standards about women and their (women’s) secondary social status) to discover the relationship between the two. Also this study aims to evaluate the impact of the stereotyping on the lives of women so that some guidelines could be developed to avoid the negative impacts of stereotypical beauty standards on women. Furthermore, it could be helpful for the policy-making process to assist the states to achieve the sustainable development goals 2030. Since it is not possible to attain these goals without including the 51 Percent of the world’s population, i-e women, into the process of policy making at the state level..
Article
This article argues that children's self-image is affected by the ways in which they see themselves in texts both verbal and visual, and that fairy tales play an important role in shaping self-image and the belief-system of children, The images found in fairy tales, therefore, have particular importance for children of color in relation to the internalization of White privileging. This article presents a comparative analysis of the Disney version of six classic fairy tales spotlighted in Disney's Princess: The Essential Guide against the "classic" source text versions: Sleeping Beauty, Cinderella, The Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast, Snow White, and Aladdin and the Wonderful Lamp from the perspective of ideological/racial basis in the context of the goals of multicultural education. Findings from this analysis support the need for the development of critical literacy skills in children as well as in their teachers and highlight the importance of exposing children to transcultural literature.
Article
Gould's book is a praiseworthy contribution to the manner in which fairy tales provide us with an understanding of women from both an existential and a developmental perspective. In addition to a discussion on fairy tales and myths, the book presents a wide variety of characters—heroines from modern literature, movies, and television programs, as well as real women, both famous and anonymous. All of these come together to form a corpus of rich and diverse narratives through which Gould presents the transformative nature of women. The in-depth treatment of women's daily experiences is integrated with an expansive knowledge of the fairy-tale genre. One of the book's central arguments maintains that women's developmental path is essentially different from that of men's. Therefore, fairy tales with female protagonists differ from those that focus on the hero's narrative. For example, the discussion of "Snow White" emphasizes separation from the mother. Whereas heroes leave home for adventure's sake, when the heroine leaves home one central developmental challenge is related to attachment issues. In these cases, it is the evil mother who serves as a trigger that encourages the heroine to achieve the next stage of sexual development. In the discussion of "Sleeping Beauty" Gould presents the different functions of sleep. While for men, being asleep represents a potential danger, for women, sleep, like pregnancy, represents quality time, which replenishes the heroine and allows her to go on. Regarding continuous sleep, Gould rejects feminist claims that it symbolizes passivity and rather describes it as part of women's multifaceted existence. This claim is a connecting thread, which runs through the entire book. Moreover, Gould rejects the idea that marriage, as the ultimate solution, is a purely masculine claim. She suggests viewing marriage the way one views heaven: we cannot be sure that it truly exists, and yet we must believe that it can. By presenting examples from daily life and related to women's experiences, Gould maps out the complex process of the development of the feminine consciousness. She avoids the trap of perceiving fairy-tale characters as if they were simply characters. Instead, she invites us to perceive them as also representing different aspects of the heroine's psyche, thereby accurately conveying the symbolic nature of fairy tales. Gould's work effectively integrates literary, gender-oriented, and psychological as well as historical approaches to fairy tales, taking into account the existence of stepmothers during a time when women were married off at a young age to older, widowed men. This results in a compelling integration that touches upon the great relevance of fairy tales in the real lives of actual women. Certain feminists see Cinderella, like Snow White, as being a passive heroine who fails to take charge of her own life and expects to be saved by a prince. According to Gould, quite the opposite is true—Cinderella is much more independent than her stepsisters. It is not the prince who saves her, but rather the way in which she becomes aware of her own femininity, with the help of her fairy godmother. Gould incorporates the approaches of prominent psychoanalysts, such as Bruno Bettelheim and Erich Neumann, takes them one step further, and refers to insights that arise from the stories within the framework of modern reality by relating the stories to the personal narratives of various women, both fictional and real. For example, in the discussion of "Sleeping Beauty," Gould presents variations of sleep in modern society—addictions, eating disorders, and depression—and discusses them through the lens of the real-life stories of different women. This blend of old stories, ancient myths, and modern daily experiences emphasizes the validity of messages hidden in fairy tales and creates a living bond between women's experiences, past and present. Although some of these ideas are not new, the way they are interwoven with concrete reality provides us with an illuminating and refreshing reading. An especially important part of the book is the one that addresses motherhood. In the discussion of "The White Bride and the Black Bride" Gould relates to the feminine aspects undermining a woman's role as wife and mother and...