No full-text available
To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.
Metaphor, meaning, and interpretation
Abstract
This paper concerns the status of metaphorical meaning (and not the mechanics of how it is determined). Contra Black and Beardsley, the propositional content of metaphorical meaning must be distinguished from its nonpropositional content. Contra Davidson, nonliteral metaphorical meaning does exist, and contra Searle, it is not equivalent to speaker meaning. Metaphorical meaning is better seen as the value of one of a variety of interpretation operators mediating between literal meaning and speaker meaning.
A comprehensive collection of essays in multidisciplinary metaphor scholarship that has been written in response to the growing interest among scholars and students from a variety of disciplines such as linguistics, philosophy, anthropology, music and psychology. These essays explore the significance of metaphor in language, thought, culture and artistic expression. There are five main themes of the book: the roots of metaphor, metaphor understanding, metaphor in language and culture, metaphor in reasoning and feeling, and metaphor in non-verbal expression. Contributors come from a variety of academic disciplines, including psychology, linguistics, philosophy, cognitive science, literature, education, music, and law.
A comprehensive collection of essays in multidisciplinary metaphor scholarship that has been written in response to the growing interest among scholars and students from a variety of disciplines such as linguistics, philosophy, anthropology, music and psychology. These essays explore the significance of metaphor in language, thought, culture and artistic expression. There are five main themes of the book: the roots of metaphor, metaphor understanding, metaphor in language and culture, metaphor in reasoning and feeling, and metaphor in non-verbal expression. Contributors come from a variety of academic disciplines, including psychology, linguistics, philosophy, cognitive science, literature, education, music, and law.
The author endeavors to reassess how metaphor functions psychoanalytically by distinguishing it from more inclusive conceptualizations of symbolism and metaphor, and from the idea of metaphor as a primary cognitive structure. The author adapts aspects of Ricoeur's metaphor theory, and explores metaphor as organized around tensions of similarity and difference, and of something “being and not-being” simultaneously. Such a model anchors metaphoric meaning in the subject's capacity for metaphoric experience and its relation to unrealized unconscious meaning. The author suggests that this perspective on metaphor—which connects it experientially to mature transitional experience, sublimation, play, and mourning—helps us understand how metaphoric experience functions as our most potent agent of intrapsychic change.
The Blackwell Guide to Philosophy of Language is a collection of twenty new essays in a cutting-edge and wide-ranging field. Surveys central issues in contemporary philosophy of language while examining foundational topics Provides pedagogical tools such as abstracts and suggestions for further readings Topics addressed include the nature of meaning, speech acts and pragmatics, figurative language, and naturalistic theories of reference.
A comprehensive collection of essays in multidisciplinary metaphor scholarship that has been written in response to the growing interest among scholars and students from a variety of disciplines such as linguistics, philosophy, anthropology, music and psychology. These essays explore the significance of metaphor in language, thought, culture and artistic expression. There are five main themes of the book: the roots of metaphor, metaphor understanding, metaphor in language and culture, metaphor in reasoning and feeling, and metaphor in non-verbal expression. Contributors come from a variety of academic disciplines, including psychology, linguistics, philosophy, cognitive science, literature, education, music, and law.
This volume collects Davidson's seminal contributions to the philosophy of language. Its key insight is that the concept of truth can shed light on various issues connected to meaning: Davidson, who assumes a partial and primitive understanding of the truth predicate, reverses Tarski who had succeeded in elucidating the concept of truth by taking the notion of ‘translation’ (preservation of meaning) for granted. In the first of five subsections into which the papers are thematically organized, Davidson develops the systematic constraints a theory of meaning has to meet and shows how an approach to semantics based on the concept of truth meets these demands better than any rival approach. Sect. 2 explores whether one can give semantic analyses of quotation, intensional contexts, and force within the extensional limitations of the truth‐theoretic framework. Viewing the theories of meaning developed in the first section as empirical, Sect. 3 inquires into their testability: can we verify these theories without presupposing concepts too closely aligned to that of meaning, interpretation, and synonymy? Davidson develops constitutive constraints on applying truth theories to interpret the speech behaviour of others: we have to view utterances for the most part as assertions of the speaker's beliefs and those beliefs as largely true and consistent (he terms this the ‘Principle of Charity’). Sect. 4 combines these interpretative constraints with the semantic concept of truth developed in Sect. 1 to tackle metaphysical issues. Davidson claims that truth is not relative to conceptual schemes but only to languages that can be shown to be largely correct about the world; consequently, by studying those languages via the semantic concept of truth we can derive ontological conclusions. Sect. 5 explores aspects of linguistic usage that form a particular threat to theories of meaning (such as Davidson's) that focus on the literal meaning of sentences: for truth theory to be adequate as a general theory of language, it must give valid accounts of sentence mood, illocutionary force, and metaphorical meaning.
Thesis (Ph. D.)--University of California, Los Angeles--Philosophy. Vita. Includes bibliographical references (leaves 222-230). Photocopy of typescript.
The metaphorical twist'. Reprinted in: Mark Johnson
- Beardsley
- Monroe
Beardsley, Monroe, 1981. 'The metaphorical twist'. Reprinted in: Mark Johnson, ed., Philosophi-cal perspectives on metaphor. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press. pp. 105-122.
More about metaphor'. Reprinted in: Andrew Ortony, ed., Metaphor and thought
- Black
- Max
Black, Max, 1979a. 'More about metaphor'. Reprinted in: Andrew Ortony, ed., Metaphor and thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 19-43.
What metaphors mean'. Reprinted in: Mark Johnson
- Davidson
- Donald
Davidson, Donald, 1981. 'What metaphors mean'. Reprinted in: Mark Johnson, ed., Philosophi-cal perspectives on metaphor. Minneapolis, MN: University of MiNnesota Press. pp. 200-220.
Beyond the letter: A philosophical inquiry into ambiguity, vagueness and metaphor in language
- Scheffier
- Israel
Scheffier, Israel, 1979. Beyond the letter: A philosophical inquiry into ambiguity, vagueness and metaphor in language. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Searle, John, 1981. 'Metaphor'. Reprinted in: Mark Johnson, ed., Philosophical perspectives on metaphor. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press. pp. 248-285.