ArticlePDF Available

‘Mr. Larsson is walking out again’. The origins and development of Scandinavian prison systems

Authors:

Abstract

The Scandinavian countries have become known for their low rates of imprisonment and relatively humane prison conditions. What, though, has made possible this model of imprisonment, so different from that of the Anglophone world? This article argues that contemporary Scandinavian prison policy has been the product of long-term socio-political forces and cultural values leading to three distinct phases of prison development: (1) 1870s–1930s: separate confinement, penance and the influence of Lutheran pastors in prison practice; (2) 1930s–1960s: welfare, medicalization and work; (3) 1970s–present: a tension between the ‘normalization’ of prison life against recent concerns with security. The article traces in the development and interplay of these three phases against the background of social, political and cultural change in Scandinavia.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... The current studies were conducted with American participants and the vignettes depicted either "a releasee in America" or an "American citizen." As the United States has historically taken a "get tough on crime" policy (Pfaff, 2017;Tonry, 1996;Walmsley, 2018;Weidner & Frase, 2003), as well as features large proportions of prison imagery in the media (Cecil, 2015), it is possible perceptions of prisoners in America do not accurately reflect those present in other countries (e.g., the Scandinavian prison model; Pratt & Eriksson, 2011). The United States comprises a significant portion of the total world prison population (Walmsley, 2018); however, incarceration and subsequent re-integration into the community is present all over the world. ...
Article
The accurate perception of others’ pain is a prerequisite to provide needed support. However, social pain perception is prone to biases. Multiple characteristics of individuals bias both physical and social pain judgments (e.g., ethnicity and facial structure). The current work extends this research to a chronically stigmatized population: released prisoners (i.e., releasees). Recognizing the large United States releasee rates and the significant role support plays in successful re-integration, we conducted four studies testing whether people have biased judgments of White male releasees’ sensitivity to social pain. Compared with the noncriminally involved, people judged releasees as less sensitive to social pain in otherwise identical situations (Studies 1a–3), an effect that was mediated by perceived life hardship (Study 2). Finally, judging releasees’ as relatively insensitive to social pain undermined perceivers’ social support judgments (Study 3). The downstream consequences of these findings on re-integration success are discussed.
... The results also indicate that, although open establishments are far from 'pain-free' (see Neumann 2012; Shammas 2014), prisoners rate them as considerably more decent and less painful than closed establishments. Such findings represent more than just an administrative matter: as others have argued (Pratt and Eriksson 2011;Pakes 2020;Mjåland et al. 2022), the use and nature of open prisons in the Nordic nations reflects a particular kind of penal philosophy. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article examines culture, an ambiguous yet prevalent concept in comparisons of crime and justice. It investigates the extent to which culture’s application and meaning across research reflects Western-centric bias in criminological knowledge-production despite it being a concept meant to advance understanding on different groups and places beyond the “Western” worldview. The article extends the discussion on Western-centric bias but also on culture in criminology by tracing the use of this concept on East Asian populations and by identifying patterns of application and meaning in international and comparative research through a scoping review of 230 journal publications. The findings address patterns of culture’s appearance in criminology journals in the past two decades and its meaning. Similar to previous scholarship on Western-centrism in criminology, the article finds that this bias does, too, exist in uses of culture but also shows how culture’s conceptual ambiguity is conducive to this bias, in that some groups and places are given one meaning of culture while others receive another.
Thesis
Full-text available
The thesis tries to present the impact of terrorism on the legislation and penitentiary policies of the countries affected by terrorism. This is how we try to present why prisoners related to terrorism constitute an anomaly for the prison systems affected. The second chapter tries to present the way in which Northern Ireland, Italy, Turkey and Germany responded to a phenomenon that had a profound impact on their prison systems. The third chapter analyzes the Spanish political and legislative response to the phenomenon of political violence. during the 19th and 20th centuries. It also analyzes the impact that the phenomenon of terrorism had on the main Spanish prison law, the LOGP. The fourth and fifth chapters are dedicated to the case studies of ETA, GRAPO and COPEL. The COPEL is studied as a phenomenon of politicization of the common prison population at a time of interaction with prisoners linked to the peaceful and violent political opposition during the Franco regime. The sixth chapter analyzes the problem of jihadism in prisons. The organizational characteristics of the phenomenon and the penitentiary policy applied are analyzed. The seventh chapter is dedicated to the conclusions.
Article
Prisoners often talk about their prison experience using spatial metaphors such as weight and depth. Imprisonment is frequently described as ‘deep’, with prisoners reporting feeling ‘submerged’ or ‘buried alive’. But what about its opposite? Can we consider a prison experience that not only lacks these experiential qualities but could in fact be felt and described as ‘shallow’? What characteristics would such a shallow prison experience have? In order to investigate this I spent time in Iceland's two open prisons. Both are very small with about 20 prisoners, run with few staff, set in rural, scenic settings and lack most of the features typically associated with imprisonment. In these prisons, I found that in essence, shallowness is both sensorily and interactively experienced. These shallow prisons allow for a range of sensory experiences of which prisoners are typically deprived, and for interactivity in the sense of the outside world permeating the prison in a range of ways. I, therefore, conclude that shallowness comes with its own positive characteristics so that it is more than the absence of depth. In addition, such arrangements are likely to reduce the pains associated with imprisonment considerably.
Chapter
The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT), which celebrated its 25th anniversary in 2015, has become a major player on the European human rights scene. However, in recent years, the CPT has repeatedly complained about a lack of follow-up of its recommendations. In its 24th general report (2013–2014), for example, the CPT observed that ‘…it is a matter of concern to the Committee that, in respect of several states parties, it has been obliged to repeat recommendations made in the context of earlier visits, having found no significant improvement or, in some cases, even a worsening of the situation. In the same vein, the responses of some states parties limit themselves to merely invoking the domestic legislative framework, whereas the CPT’s recommendations in question pointed to the need for practical improvements, policy changes or even the amendment of legislation’ (p. 6). This (and similar) complaints and worries by the CPT may be an indication that the dialogue between the CPT and (some of) the member states is somehow being distorted. In this chapter, we analyse from a comparative perspective how interactions between the CPT and state authorities take place in practice.
Article
Full-text available
This essay questions the villagization camp as a space of incarceration in late European colonialism, as well as its legacy for post-independence states. The research on which it is based focuses on the networks of rural camps created in occupied territories in Africa and Asia by several North Atlantic states for the forced resettlement of peasants, in order to try to avoid the progress of liberation movements. In particular, the essay explores the history of the network created by Portugal’s Army in the late 1960s and early 1970s in present-day Guinea-Bissau, taking into account that many camps became small towns after independence. It reflects on the military archive through a perspective informed by postcolonial theories, simultaneously proposing questions inspired by contemporary spatiality in Africa.
Chapter
If we think of those who end up in prison on account of their offences against the law as a social group, the following characteristics are perceptible: 1. psychological traits reflected by (a) rough emotional life and lack of concern for others, (b) difficulties in personal relationships, (c) lack of perseverance, and (d) inability to understand social and family duties and responsibilities; 2. feelings of insecurity and lack of trust in others, often due to the fact that they come from broken homes; 3. lack of vocational training, and 4. immoderate drinking and spending.
Chapter
This chapter raises certain arguments and historical analogies which may assist in taking a few preliminary sightings of some distinctive features of the current British penal landscape. I hope to show that some of the present developments, which initially appear rather particular and ‘of the moment’, interestingly bear comparison with much earlier ideas and events. That comparison may suggest, at least in outline, a way of conceptualizing and responding to the contemporary scene.