Content uploaded by Juan Carlos Alonso
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Juan Carlos Alonso on Sep 24, 2014
Content may be subject to copyright.
European Association of Zoo- and Wildlife Veterinarians (EAZWV) 4
th
scientific meeting,
joint with the annual meeting of the European Wildlife Disease Association (EWDA)
May 8-12, 2002, Heidelberg, Germany.
POSTMORTEM FINDINGS IN WILD GREAT BUSTARDS (Otis tarda)
FROM SPAIN:A CLINICAL APROACH.
M. GARCÍA-MONTIJANO
1
, A. M. TÉBAR
2
, B. BARREIRO
3
, P. RODRÍGUEZ
4
,
J.C. ALONSO
5
, C. MARTÍN
5
, M. MAGAÑA
5
, C. PALACÍN
5
, J. ALONSO
5
, A. MONTESINOS
6
and I. LUACES
7
.
Affiliation:
1. Aulaga. Centro de Cría del Águila Imperial Ibérica. Ministerio de Medio Ambiente. Quintos de Mora.
Toledo. Spain. (mmontijano@eresmas.com)
2. Centro de Recuperación y Educación Ambiental “Los Hornos”.Junta de Extremadura. Sierra de
Fuentes, Cáceres. Spain.
3. GIR diagnostics. Madrid. Spain.
4. C/ Abades 18 2º B. (41004). Sevilla. Spain.
5. Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales. CSIC. Madrid. Spain.
6. Clínica Los Sauces. C/Murillo, 3. Madrid. Spain.
7. INGENASA. C/Hnos. Gª Noblejas, 41. Madrid. Spain.
Abstract
Causes of death and morbidity are reported for 13 free-living great bustards (Otis tarda) from Spain. The
main mortality cause for the adult birds and two juveniles was collision with power lines or fences. One wild
adult bustard died of Aspergillus fumigatus generalised infection. Other causes of death for juveniles were
predation, septicemia, parasitic obstruction of small intestine by cestodes, ventriculus impaction, and
trauma w ith agricultural vehicles. Causes of morbidity were skin injuries, fractures, soft tissue and liver
trauma, pneumonia of different etiology, ectoparasites and hemoparasites.
Key words: Great bustard, Otis tarda, mortality, morbidity, postmortem.
Introduction
There are 22 species of bustards (family Otididae), some of them are endangered species. The
great bustard (Otis tarda) is a large, highly sexually dimorphic, globally endangered bird. Their
numbers have declined considerably during the present century and current populations inhabit
cereal steppes of Europe and Asia (2). This decline has been attributed to habitat changes
caused by human population growth, farming practices, changes in agricultural practices and
hunting pressure (1).
The Iberian population is the largest, being the size of the Spanish population at around 17.000-
19.000 birds. Most of the Spanish great bustard nuclei seem to be stable perhaps with a very
slight tendency to increase in some particularly well conserved areas (1).
Other bustard species (Chlamydotis undulata, Ardeotis kori, Eupodotis ruficrista…) have
attracted much attention from the veterinary profession, especially in the Middle East, where a
good amount of information about management and clinical aspects of bustards exists (3-
7,9,12,17).
Most of the references regarding great bustards are based on ecological studies, and there are
some published papers on captive great bustard diseases(13-15) but the authors could only
found three references on veterinary aspects (parasites) of free-living great bustards (10,11,16),
none of them being published in an international journal.
Clinical management of great bustards is not an easy task due to the strength, weight, present
injuries and stressful nature of these birds. The knowledge of diseases affecting free-living great
bustards could help in the daily treatment and follow up of clinical cases. The aim of this
retrospective study is to provide an overview of morbidity and mortality causes in the wild
Spanish great bustard population.
Material and method
We included for this retrospective study 13 postmorten cases of free-living great bustards (6
adults and 7 juveniles) that were necropsied in the period 1998-2001. Five of the 6 adults and 3
of the 7 juveniles were males. In one juvenile we could not determinate the sex. Included in this
paper are only free-living birds that were found dead or died within 24 hours in the rehabilitation
centre.
Standard avian postmorten examination techniques were used(8), including two X-ray
projections, samples for histopathology, parasitology, and microbiology when appropriate and
biometry. The condition of each bird was recorded as emaciated, poor, fair, good or obese,
based on the degree of pectoral muscle wasting. Birds with emaciated and poor pectoral muscle
scores were included in the pectoral muscle wasting group (4). For histopathology special stains
were used when Chlamydophila spp. or tuberculosis were part of the differential diagnosis.
Cause of death was determined from consideration of the clinical history, clinical observations,
laboratory findings, and significant postmortem findings.
Endoparasites were washed in distilled water and preserved in 70% ethanol until processed for
identification. When possible a blood smear was prepared to search for hematozoa and faeces
were screening by flotation method with zinc sulphate. Arthropods collected for identification
were fixed and stored in 70% ethanol.
Results
Causes of death in wild great bustards are summarised in table 1.
Table 1. Causes of death in 7 juvenile and 6 adult free-living great bustards.
Cause of death Adult Juvenile Total
Trauma-
electric transmission
power lines, fences 5 2 7
Trauma-vehicle 0 1 1
Aspergillosis
1 0 1
Predation 0 1 1
Parasitic obstructi
on of small
intestine by cestodes 0 1 1
Septicemia 0 1 1
Gizzard impaction 0 1 1
Total 6 7 13
Trauma trough collisions with electric power lines or fences was responsible for 83.3% of adult
and 42.9% of juvenile deaths in wild great bustards. Aspergillosis accounted for 16.7% of adult
mortality. Other mortality causes of juvenile birds were predation (14.3%), septicemia (14.3%),
gizzard impaction (14.3%) and obstruction of small intestine with cestodes (14.3%).
Other postmortem findings in the present study are summarised in table 2.
Table 2. Postmortem findings in 7 juvenile and 6 adult free-living great bustards.
Postmortem finding Adult Juvenile Total
Intestinal parasitism-cestodes 6 4 10
Trauma-skin 5 4 9
Fractures 4 3 7
humerus 1 1 2
radius 1 0 1
ischium 1 0 1
femur 0 1 1
tibiotarsus 0 1 1
pubic bone 0 1 1
scleral ring 1 0 1
skull 1 0 1
Pneumonia 4 3 7
bacteria 0 2 2
fungus 1 0 1
aspiration 3 1 4
Pectoral muscle wasting 2 4 6
Hemoparasites 2 2 4
Ectoparasites 2 1 3
Trauma-liver 2 1 3
Intestinal parasitism-nematodes 1 1 2
Sternal bone deformity 1 0 1
All the adult bustards (100%) and 57.1% of juveniles presented intestinal parasitism by
cestodes. These cestodes were identified as Schistometra (Otiditaenia) conoides and Idiogenes
otidis. The nematodes present in the caecum of one adult and one juvenile bird were identified
as Heterakis isolonche.
Also in the faeces of that juvenile Capillaria spp. and Trichostrongylus spp. eggs were detected,
but no adults were recovered.
Skin injuries were a morbidity cause in 83.3% of adult and 57.1% of juvenile great bustards.
Bone fractures occurred in 66.7% of adult birds and 42.9% of juveniles, being open fractures of
the humerus the most common fractures.
Pneumonia was observed in 66.7% of adult and 42.9% of juvenile birds. Foreign body inhalation
pneumonia was recorded for 50% of adult bustards and 14.3% of juvenile birds. Pneumonia of
bacterial origin (Pasteurella spp.) was found in 28.6% of juvenile bustards, and Aspergillus
fumigatus pneumonia and air sacculitis was responsible for the death of one adult (16.7%) great
bustard.
Hemoparasites of the specie Haemoproteus telfordi and Haemoproteus tendeiroi were seen in
blood films from 2 adult and 2 juvenile great bustards. However it was not possible to make a
blood smear from every bird.
Ectoparasites were found in 33.3% of adults and 14.3% of juveniles. Qtilipeurus turmalis
(Mallophaga, Insecta) and a tick from the genus Hyalomma were identified.
Discussion and conclusions
Mortality causes of free-living juvenile great bustards from Spain has been cited previously (2),
although it was not the objective of the study. Predation was the main mortality cause in
juveniles and collision with power lines was found in two occasions. In this study only one young
was found to be predated by a raptor, while other was hit by an agricultural vehicle. The later
cause has been reported as common in bustards chicks as they look after cover in crop fields
(18).
In a previous work in Madrid province (18) the authors found that collision with power lines was
responsible of the death of 30 wild great bustards in the period 1999-2000. Trauma trough
collisions with electric power lines or fences accounted for 63.1% mortality in wild great bustards
in the present study. Bone fractures and dislocations, skin and soft tissue injuries, liver rupture,
aspiration pneumonia and lung haemorrhage were the most frequent causes of morbidity in such
cases. When such cases are admitted to rehabilitation a reasonable valuation and decisions
must be done before treatment is accomplished.
A frequent postmortem finding was a high parasitic burden caused by cestodes (Schistometra
conoides and Idiogenes otidis). These species of cestodes have been previously reported in
great bustards (wild and captive) in Spain (10,16). They also report the death of one bustard
following obstruction of the small intestine by cestodes. This condition has been also described
in captive houbara bustards in UAE (4,12). In our study the prevalence of cestode infections in
bustards was higher than the previously reported by Reina et al. (11.4%) in Spain and Jones et
al. (25.6%) in the UAE. This could be due to many different causes as our small sample size and
the different origin of birds. Great bustards admitted to rehabilitation centres are usually
weakened, dehydrated, traumatised, and in poor body condition (authors, unpubl. data),
conditions that may increase the susceptibility to the pathologic effects of cestode infections
(12). The clinician must consider these observations when dealing with this specie. Nematodes
were seen in low numbers in the caecum of 2 bustards.
Gizzard impactions and foreign-body obstruction have been reported as an important cause of
death of captive juvenile rufous-crested bustards and houbara bustard chicks (4,5). One
juvenile bird of our study died after a gizzard impaction of unknown aetiology.
Gram-negative bacterial diseases were the most important cause of death over the first 180
days of captive bustard chicks in UAE (5). In our study one week old chick died of septicemia
where E. coli was culture from different organs. The isolation of E. coli from bustards at necropsy
was found on many occasions in one study involving captive houbara, rufous-crested and kori
bustards (9).
After collision with fences or power lines most of the birds could live for sometime and also walk
away for many metres before die (pers. obs.). Aspiration pneumonia was found in 50% of the
adult birds as result of aspiration of food (normally seeds) from the ventriculus after the collision.
Aspergillosis has been described as a common cause of euthanasia and postmortem finding in
captive and imported adult houbara bustards and also caused mortality in juvenile kori and
houbara bustards (4). One adult female died four hours after presentation prostrated and with
obvious signs of dyspnea. At necropsy fungal granulomas were seen in trachea, syringe, lungs,
pericardium, air sacs, kidney and pelvic nerve roots. A cream-coloured ovoid plaque (7 cm
minimum diameter, 11 cm maximum diameter) was recovered surrounding the abdominal
viscera. A pure culture of Aspergillus fumigatus was obtained from the granulomas. These bird
also presented signs of external parasitism, but only a tick from the genus Hyalomma was
recovered. A high cestode burden was another incidental finding in this bird. To the authors
knowledge this is the first report of aspergillosis in a wild adult great bustard.
Klebsiella spp. pneumonia and pneumonia of unknown etiology have described in captive
bustards fron the UAE (4). Bacterial pneumonia has been also a morbidity cause (28.6%) in
free-living juvenile great bustards. In one occasion Pasteurella spp. was cultivated from the
lungs of a juvenile bird. Other young great bustard had a focal bacterial pneumonia and liver
lipidosis based on histopathology. Unfortunately no microbiology results are available for this
case. Some authors have stated that aggressive care of bustards during the first 30 days after
hatching is clearly important (5).
Hemoparasites from the genus Haemoproteus were detected in 4 of the bustards, but it was not
possible to obtain a blood film for each bird. Studies of wild great bustards hemoparasites
species and prevalence are been carried out by the authors since 1998 in the Spanish
population and will be reported in the future.
Management of wild great bustards clinical cases posses a challenge to the veterinarian. The
results presented in this paper could help understanding the morbidity causes when attending
such patients.
Acknowledgments
Javier Caldera and Centro de Recuperación y Educación Ambiental “Los Hornos” staff for
providing logistic support and Gerry Dorrestein for reviewing some histopathology slides. Maribel
Acosta and Mónica Luzón helped with parasite identification. We also wish to thank Tom Bailey
and Jaime Samour for helping with references.
References
1. Alonso JC and Alonso JA. The Great Bustard in Spain: Present Status, Recent Trends and Evaluation of Earlier
Censuses. Biological Conservation 1996; 77: 79-86.
2. Alonso JC, Martín E, Alonso JA and Morales MB. Proximate and ultimate causes of natal dispersal in the great
bustard Otis tarda. Behavioral Ecology 1997; 9; 3: 243-252.
3. Bailey TA, Naldo J, Samour JH, and Howlett JC. Bustard Therapeutics. ERWDA External Report No5. 1997.
4. Bailey TA, Naldo J, Samour JH, and Howlett JC. Post-mortem Findings in Bustards in the United Emirates. Avian
Diseases 1996; 40: 296-305.
5. Bailey TA, Naldo J, Samour JH, Sleigh IM, and Howlett JC. Bustard pediatric diseases: a review of clinical and
pathologic findings. Journal of Avian Medicine and Surgery 1997; 11(3): 166-174.
6. Bailey TA, Nicholls PK, Wernery U, Samour JH, Cooper JE, Path C, and O´Leary MT. Avian paramixovirus type 1
infection in Houbara bustards (Chlamydotis undulata macqueenii): clinical and pathological findings. Journal of
Zoo and Wildlife Medicine 1997; 28 (3): 325-330.
7. Bailey TA, Silvanose CD, Naldo J, and Howlett JH. Pseudomonas aeroginosa infections in Kori bustards
(Ardeotis kori). Avian Pathology 2000; 29: 41-44.
8. Cooper J.E. 1989. Disease and Threatened Birds. ICBP Thecnical Publications.
9. Dáloia MA, Bailey TA, Samour JH, Naldo J, and Howlett JC. Bacterial flora of captive houbara (Chlamydotis
undulata), Kori (Ardeotis kori) and rufous-crested (Eupodotis ruficrista) bustards. Avian Pathology 1996; 25: 459-
468.
10. Illescas-Gómez MP, and Gómez MP. First citation in Spain of Schistometra conoides (Bloch 1782) Skrjabin 1914,
parasitizing Otis tarda L. Proceedings of the third European Multicolloquium of Parasitology, 1980, Cambridge,
U.K.
11. Illescas-Gómez MP, and Gomez MP. Idiogenes otidis, intestinal parasite of Otis tarda. Revista Ibérica de
Parasitología 1981; 41 (4): 475-484.
12. Jones A, Bailey TA, Nicholls PK, Samour JH, and Naldo J. Cestode and acanthocephalan infections in captive
bustards: New host and location records, with data on pathology, control, and preventive medicine. Journal of
Zoo and Wildlife Medicine 1996; 27 (2): 201-208.
13. Körmendy B, Illes J, Glavits R, and Sztojkov V. An outbreak of Yersinia pseudotuberculosis infection in a bustard
(Otis tarda) flock. Acta Veterinaria Hungarica 1988; 36 (3-4): 173-176.
14. Körmendy P, Sztojkov V, Ivanics E, Illes J, and Csatori G. Pseudotuberculosis in a Great bustard population and
comparison with the changes after an experimental tuberculosis infection. Verh. ber. Erkr. Zootiere 1982; 24: 299-
302.
15. Kozakiewicz, B. Infection with endoparasites of bustards (Otis tarda) under breeding conditions. Wiadomosci-
Parazytologiczne 1984; 30 (4): 489-492.
16. Reina D, Habela M, Serrano F, Nieto CG, Brena M, Pérez E, Navarrete I, Hernandez-Rodriguez S. Contribución
al conocimiento de la parasitofauna de los animales silvestres y de vida libre en la provincia de Cáceres
(España). In Memoriam al Prof. Dr. Francisco de Paula Martínez Gómez 1992. Universidad de Córdoba, 407-
428.
17. Sleigh I and Samour JH. Bird care manual: Management techniques for a collection of bustards. NARC, 1996.
18. Traverso JM. Agricultura y tendidos afectan a las avutardas del este de Madrid. Quercus 2001; diciembre: 62-63.