ArticlePDF Available

Communist Party Membership and Regime Dynamics in China

Authors:

Abstract

This article uses event history analyses to examine how the criteria of political screening and educational credentials evolve in the attainment of Chinese Communist Party membership during the period between 1949 and 1993 and how party membership, in turn, influences individual mobility into elite political and managerial positions. We argue that political screening is a persistent feature and a survival strategy of all Communist parties and that the mechanisms of ensuring political screening are affected by the regime's agendas in different historical periods. Using data from surveys conducted in Shanghai and Tianjin in 1993, we found that measures of political screening were persistently significant predictors of party membership attainment in all post–1949 periods and that party membership is positively associated with mobility into positions of political and managerial authority during the post–1978 reform era. Education emerged to be a significant predictor of Communist party membership in the post–1978 period. These findings indicate that China has made historical shifts to recruit among the educated to create a technocratic elite that is both occupationally competent and politically screened.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... Respondents to Jang and Kim (2018) study perceived greater influence of fake news on members of different parties than on members of their own parties. In China, CCP membership is a symbol of integrity and competence besides political conviction, loyalty, and obedience (Bian et al., 2001;Rosen, 1990;Zhao, 2004). Journalists are encouraged to join CCP, which is in line with the traditional "mouthpiece" role of the media (Chan et al., 2004;Hassid, 2011). ...
... Party members reported weaker TPP regarding attitude than non-members. This is consistent with earlier reports that, at grassroots of the Chinese society, political identity is more a symbol of model citizenship than a badge of political power or ideological conviction (Bian et al., 2001;Rosen, 1990;Zhao, 2004). The Party has a long history of demanding its members to practice "mass line" (qun-zhong-lu-xian), the Chinese version of the imperative "of the people, for the people." ...
Article
Full-text available
This study assessed the third-person perceptions (TPP) regarding attitude and knowledge among journalists in China and explored factors that may affect such perceptions. Based on a stratified sample of media professionals in two different regions, it was found that TPP regarding attitude was present and stronger than TPP regarding knowledge. The results also revealed that the media environment affected TPP regarding knowledge, while political identity and perceived news quality (PNQ) affected TPP regarding attitude. In addition, the study found that key personal factors interacted with each other in affecting TPP through the mediation of two components, the perceived effect on others (PEO) and the perceived effect on self (PES). The theoretical and methodological implications are discussed.
... This means that a talented person can become a party member earlier than a normal person. Second, party membership has a signi cant effect on mobility into elite positions with political and managerial authority (Bian, Shu and Logan, 2001). Third, a party member can take the opportunity to join party activities that promote human capital and social network formation. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
What are the consequences of having a female leader for economic and political outcomes? This study investigates the impact of female leadership on policy outcomes at the local government level in China. Based on institutional theory and role theory, we investigate the impacts of women’s service as Chinese Communist Party (CCP) secretaries or government mayors on local economic growth and social policies. Based on municipal economic performance, government financial expenditures, and demographic data from the period between 1995 and 2015 in China, the results suggest that the influence of gender roles is eliminated when women are involved in leading local economic development, which receives strong institutional pressure. In contrast, female leadership is more conducive to social development, which is more likely to be subject to a leader’s discretion. Female leaders may not ensure better economic growth than male leaders, as indexed by GDP growth rates, but they usually produce more balanced and welfare-oriented development, as measured by higher expenditureson social security and employment.
... It acts as a lens to focus on the nuanced yet potentially significant influence of political affiliation to against subtle biases that might otherwise color the data. This approach is particularly critical given the unique political landscape of China [52]. By acknowledging the influence of CPC membership, the study ensures that the conclusions drawn are comprehensive and reflective of the intricate socio-political fabric of the Chinese context, thereby maintaining the integrity and depth of the findings. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose Despite rich data on neighborhood safety perception’s role in shaping depressive symptoms, a comprehensive view of this dynamic interplay remains a frontier. This study seeks to unravel the intricate interplay of neighborhood safety perception and depressive symptoms, utilizing the lens of social safety theory. Methods Employing the 2016 and 2020 waves of the China Family Panel Studies (CFPS), this study utilized ordered logistic regression (ologit) for statistical analysis. The approach encompassed descriptive analysis of variables, Spearman’s correlation analyses to explore associations between variables, and a moderated mediation analysis. Sensitivity analyses were also conducted to affirm the robustness of findings against model assumptions and data processing techniques. Results The study uncovered a significant negative correlation between neighborhood safety perception and depressive symptoms (Direct effect = − 0.338, Z = − 2.564, p = 0.010). A key finding was the steeper slope of the relationship between neighborhood safety perception and neighborhood relation perception among individuals with a higher perception of neighborhood environment quality. As neighborhood environment quality perception increases, the strength of the mediated negative impact on depressive symptoms intensifies (− 0.102 > − 0.132 > − 0.162). Conclusion This study offers a comprehensive moderated mediation model that establishes a novel connection between neighborhood safety perception and depressive symptoms. It integrates the complexities of social safety theory and social information processes, revealing key strategies such as enhancing perceived neighborhood environment quality and neighborhood relationship quality.
Article
This study, part of a collaborative project with the women’s prison in City A, China, aims to understand the experience of regaining employment among 21 white-collar ex-prisoners. Findings include shame and internalized stigmatization, labor market marginalization, and the political background check as a central part of the Chinese motherhood penalty. This paper demonstrates how the consequences of the women’s conviction and incarceration interact with individual, familial, and structural factors, leading some to return to domestic gender roles and pushing most into a state of precariousness. The study aims to contribute to the emerging field of feminist desistance research.
Article
This research delves into the dynamics of officials’ attitudes toward the Communist Party of China (CPC), examining the joint impact of parental political identity and political norms. A novel experimental survey conducted in provincial CPC schools is the foundation of our analysis. Employing statistical methodologies, including the Difference-in-Differences and Propensity Score Matching models, we establish compelling empirical insights: having parents who are CPC members exerts a distinct and significant adverse influence on officials’ political attitudes, underscoring the significance of familial affiliations. The proportion of parental Party membership reveals a nuanced U-shaped trajectory in shaping officials’ political attitudes concerning their years of service. However, political pressure emerges as a potent force that significantly shapes officials’ responses to sensitive inquiries, aligning them more closely with CPC values and diminishing the impact of parents with CPC membership on officials’ political attitudes. Meanwhile, the impact of fathers’ CPC membership on officials’ political attitudes is greater than that of the mothers.” This investigation contributes significantly to understanding the connections between parental political affiliations, political pressure, and officials’ political attitudes within the CPC organizational context. Our findings provide valuable insights into the mechanisms underlying political attitude dynamics and reveal differences in responses to sensitive questions across social surveys.
Article
Full-text available
Many scholars have used local Chinese county gazetteers for historical and socioeconomic analyses, yet little research has examined the completeness of coverage or the biases in reporting that characterize the compilation of these gazetteers. In this paper, we provide a novel source for studying Chinese political movements and local history under the communist regime after 1949: the internal-discussion drafts of county gazetteers ( xianzhi pingyigao ). Our findings constitute the first study to use internal review drafts to examine the authenticity and credibility of county gazetteers. Prior to their publication, gazetteer drafts are compiled by a team of editors and typically receive at least three rounds of rigorous internal review. These internal-discussion drafts are subject to a prolonged and strict process of self and external censorship. Our analysis engages in a close comparison of text samples extracted from two versions of local gazetteers collected from four counties in Guangxi province. Compared to the draft versions, we find evidence of serious data manipulation and a tendency to underreport historical events in the published editions. Our research evidently demonstrates the process of historiography editing and reveals how local history is presented through the lens of government public documents in China.
Article
Full-text available
This paper presents a causal model of membership recruitment into the Hungarian Socialist Workers' Party, using unit record data from non-Party sources. The findings qualify both the official view and new class theory by showing two roads to Party membership. The first runs through the occupational structure, where workers, professionals, and technocrats are advantaged over individuals outside socialized production. The second runs through educational institutions, providing an educated few with extra opportunities to enter the Party. Results corroborate earlier conclusions that patriarchal allocation of political privileges continues in Hungary. Despite formal guarantees to the contrary, women are significantly underrepresented in the Party. Intercohort changes in membership recruitment show that older cohorts monopolize key Party positions, suggesting that a gerontocracy has emerged in Hungarian political life. Overall, results lend further evidence to the contention that some crystallization in inequalities has taken place in Hungary in the "second stage" of socialist development.
Article
The articles published in this issue of the Journal help advance the debate on market reform in former socialist states. In our comment, besides dealing with data analysis issues, we suggest several ways to improve the level of debate about substantive issues. These suggestions include more attention to politics, including path dependence, and more attention to middle-level generalizations from other developing market societies.
Article
This article reviews the sociological literature on the transition from socialism to capitalism. It distinguishes between the erosion and transition phases and between traditional and corporate segments in the emerging private sector. Panel survey data from Hungary show that during the transition ex-communist cadres maintain their advantageous position and do especially well in the more dynamic corporate segment. They are successful because human capital is important in both capitalism and socialism and because the cadres are able to convert past political power to economic advantage. Contrary to the findings of studies based only on agriculture, the transition increases income inequalities.