Article

Hockey and Habitus: Sport and National Identity in Northern Ireland

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

In the official program of the 2005 European Hockey Nations' Championship held in Dublin, Lynsey McVicker, the captain of the Irish women's hockey team noted that, "When you are from Northern Ireland, sometimes you experience a confusion of identity—we're not quite the same as those from the Republic of Ireland. British or Irish? In a sense we [are] outsiders looking in."1 Her comment highlights one dimension of a more complex social phenomenon: the question of national habitus, or what the pioneering sociologist Norbert Elias called those "traits of national group identity—what we call the 'national character'—[that] are a layer of social habitus built very deeply and firmly into the personality structure of the individual."2 Questions relating to national identity have a particular resonance for people living in Northern Ireland, given the current sociopolitical situation and the highly politicized relationship between sport and politics in that region. Such questions as "What nationality am I?"; "What does this sport mean tome?"; "Am I any less Irish or British if I play for, or support the 'other' team?"; and "Where does being Northern Irish or from Ulster fit into this?" find social expression both on and off the playing field. The difficult questions of "Who am I both as a social and individual being?" lie at the very heart of this tension balance.3 Sport is thus inevitably implicated in questions of identity, and athletes from Northern Ireland who are eligible to represent the Republic of Ireland (sometimes described loosely as Ireland) or the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland experience this particular tension in differing ways. Research on sport and national identity on the island of Ireland has focused almost exclusively on male variants of such team sports as rugby union, soccer, and Gaelic football.4 The sporting experiences of female athletes on the island of Ireland have been relatively neglected. In addition, research on women in Ireland, and Northern Ireland in particular, tends to ignore those for whom sport is an important aspect of their lives.5 Though much of this existing literature has addressed the intricacies associated with the formation, expression, and reproduction of national identity, David Hassan has acknowledged that "the complexities of identity construction" need "to be more fully elucidated."6 Elsewhere, Alan Bairner has argued that some Northern Irish Unionists live relatively comfortably with their "Irishness" through their support for such team sports as soccer and rugby union. To understand fully the sorts of negotiations of loyalty and identity that such support requires it is essential that each particular sporting context be explored.7 Our opening hypothesis is that female hockey players represent a focal and vibrant link between sport and "the nation."We focused on the experiences of ten female athletes, eight of whom were Protestant and two of whom were Catholic. All were from Northern Ireland and had represented Ireland at the elite level. We examine the sport-national identity nexus within the sporting context of what is an under researched team sport, that of hockey. The province of Ulster has attained a measurable degree of success in women's interprovincial hockey competitions over the past eight years and Northern Irish players are consistently well represented on the Irish national team. This leads players like Judith to articulate some identity tensions—she states, "I really don't see myself as being Irish, however I really don't see myself as being British either"—while Laura feels that playing for Ulster in interprovincial competition is akin to "playing against the Irish."8 In her words, "I suppose when you play for Ulster you are not Irish, you are playing against the Irish." How are we to begin to describe the apparent malleability of identity and explain these tensions? Norbert Elias's notion of social habitus as it applies to the national character provides a possible theoretical and conceptual framework. Using the Eliasian conceptual apparatus, we might describe the complexities of national identity in Northern Ireland as a habitus problem par excellence. Elias concerned himself with the level of embodied social learning, and for him, it is the dynamic figurations or social networks that people form that enable...

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... The expression of this sense of 'Irishness' through Gaelic games would appear to be a significant feature of the shared cultural habituses of the teachers and GAA personnel that participated in this study. The construction of a clear 'We-' identity through Gaelic games featured prominently in the data and supports the assertion made by Liston and Moreland (2009) that 'sport is thus inevitably implicated in questions of identity' (p. 127). ...
Article
Recent studies suggest school communities accept the goods and services of external providers uncritically. Considering the pivotal role played by teachers in curriculum and policy enactment, this paper explores how and why teachers in Ireland advocate for, and engage with, the services and resources of one particular external provider, the Gaelic Athletic Association (GAA). This paper draws upon data generated from a purposive sample of teachers and external coaches who were involved in the provision of Gaelic games in primary schools. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with teachers and coaches, and policy documents were examined in order to gain a better understanding of the external provision provided by the GAA. The data were subsequently analysed thematically. Our findings suggest that teachers who promote Gaelic games within the core and extracurricular PE and sport programmes consider these games crucial to the development of children’s sporting and cultural identity.
... What are usually termed environmental factors by bio-scientists and social factors by social scientists play an equally important role in 3 This is notwithstanding the concerns raised byListon and Moreland (2009) about the important role of selfreflection, on the part of current (and indeed former) athletes, in generating a clear comprehension by them about the social phenomena in which they are/were enmeshed. 4Lewontin (2000) uses the metaphor of the "empty bucket" to describe the contribution of genes and the environment in development. ...
Article
Full-text available
This research examined the experiences of eight Portuguese (former) elite athletes from a social scientific perspective. In so doing it attempted to move away from the tentacles of achievement sport and, in particular, the performance efficiency model that dominates elite sport. Rather, it focused on the subjective and qualitative experiences of sportspeople themselves and gave them a forum to reflect upon the primary socializing agents that played a key role in their sporting success, and on the peaks and troughs on their journeys to sporting success, nationally and internationally. The research design included semi-structured interviews with athletes that excelled in athletics, handball, gymnastics, korfball and swimming. All eight had achieved outstanding results nationally and internationally. A qualitative approach was adopted for data collection and analysis. Giving voice to the former athletes themselves revealed much about: the primary socializing agents for sport in their lives, as young, teenage and adult athletes; those role models and mentors that influenced their initial and ongoing involvement and specialization in sport, these being the family (usually parents), physical education teachers and peers; and, finally, the peaks and troughs in their careers which usually hinged around sporting success or defeat, failure to achieve expected results, and the onset and impact of injury. Taken together, these findings reverberate with those of other researchers beyond the Lusophone world. They also indicate the emergence and development of a sports ethic in Portugal despite the comparatively late entry of that country into the global sporting arms race.
Chapter
In this chapter, I show how the antithetical relationship between civilisation and terrorism continued in the form of established-outsider relations between British elites and rebellious Irish groups that were seeking emancipatory change.
Article
This article responds to calls in this journal for increased attention to identity, culture, power and sport. It explores, for the first time, the lived realities of identity politics in a divided society, through interviews with 12 self-declared Irish nationalists and republicans that represented Northern Ireland. Important insights are revealed into national eligibility decisions for either Irish team, motivated mainly by ‘shop window’ visibility and being seen as the best of a peer group. Political and sporting nationalisms were not necessarily analogous. A significant original finding is that the lived experiences of being closer to ‘the other’ resulted in an overall reinforcement rather than dissolution of difference. Visual and oral ‘national’ symbols such as flag, and especially anthem, delineated such difference, being symbolic walls of the mind. ‘Our wee country’ was thus a polarised and polarising fantasy shield. The article concludes by reconsidering the role of sport as a lens through which to examine identity and its’ place as part of the ‘problem’ and ‘solution’.
Article
This article marks an important watershed in the investigation of elite sport development in the 'Atlantic Isles'. It outlines some features of the emergence and development of international elite sports policy and its idiosyncratic diffusion to Northern Ireland (NI) specifically. Drawing on the SPLISS framework and the need for empirical work within Pillar 7 (coaching provision and coaching development), there is also an examination of elite coaches' perceptions of the policy factors influencing international sporting success. This goes some way towards redressing the dearth of knowledge about the complex social and political realities in which elite coaches ply their trade. A 'mixed methods' approach was employed, which incorporated secondary analysis of government and sports policy documents, the historical charting of the elite sports policy field in NI, the completion of an internationally validated survey and also semi-structured interviews with eight high-performance coaches (seven males and one female) who ranged in age from 38 to 59 years. The study demonstrates some of the unique challenges for the dual positioning of NI within Irish and British sports governance arenas. There, the resultant fractured elite sports policy landscape has constrained coaches' attempts to deliver upon performance targets. There was also less than convincing evidence of a 'high-performance' oriented sport culture. The article concludes by bridging the gap between sports policy and social policy in NI and, in so doing, offers some possibilities for developing a more integrated research agenda.
Article
On the basis of narrative structure, this exploratory work aims to distinguish the lived experience of a Portuguese sports hero and noted mountain climber, João Garcia. Using phenomenological analyses of biographical interviews lasting over 15 hr in total, the narrative of João Garcia, the Portuguese alpinist who summitted the world’s 14 mountains above 8,000 m, is constructed. The analysis also includes the books written by Garcia himself in which he presents his “public” or “hero” self. This article focuses on João Garcia’s narrative of his life with an emphasis on his body–self experiences and his personal progression as a climber. Through the use of metaphors, the themes of the “one man show,” the transition to an alpine leader or captain and the body–self relationship are explored here, with a particular focus on Garcia’s desire to maximize his psychological and physical capacities in extreme and life-threatening conditions. The article concludes with some preliminary comments on the use of the narrative structure as a methodological tool.
Background: Extra-curricular sport is an important aspect of life in Irish primary schools. Team invasion games hold a dominant position and, within this category, Gaelic games are extremely popular. Teachers have, historically, played a significant role in the promotion of Gaelic games through the organization of inter-school competitions. The Irish primary physical education curriculum document recommends a ‘balanced approach to competition’ where extra-curricular activities are organized in accordance with the ‘aims and objectives’ of the curriculum. This approach appears to be shared by the Gaelic Athletic Association (GAA), the national governing body for Gaelic games, through its promotion of school games that advocate maximum participation. Purpose: This study focused on the following research questions: (1) to what extent does current school practice align with national education and youth sport policy, as articulated by the DES and GAA, respectively; (2) how do teachers’ biographies influence the ethos of extra-curricular programmes; and (3) how do these teachers resolve the apparent tensions between the competitive and participatory models of extra-curricular games activities. Participants and setting: Seven primary teachers, six of whom were school principals, participated in this study. Each of them had shown a strong commitment to the promotion of Gaelic games as part of school sport programmes. Research design: The conceptual framework for this study was based on the main tenets of figurational sociology. The research was qualitative in nature and a purposive sample of teachers was developed. Data collection and analysis: Individual semi-structured interviews were conducted with each participant. Policy documents were reviewed. The initial coding of the data was carried out inductively. The subsequent development of categories and themes was guided by the research questions and was subject to constant comparison. Findings: Teachers’ childhood experiences were important in the shaping of their attitudes towards school sport. Other teachers and members of the wider school community were very influential during their early teaching careers. The participants in this study identified the school principal as someone who had a key role in shaping a school sport ethos. School sport was seen as an important means of maintaining discipline and social cohesion. It also provided children with opportunities for personal development. The promotion of Gaelic games helped to develop community links and to express cultural identity. Competitive inter-school competitions were still prominent, but other models of school sport, based on maximizing participation, are becoming more popular. Conclusions: The selection and organization of particular forms of school sport is influenced by teachers’ personal background. The teachers who participated in this study are part of complex networks of relationships and have a significant impact on how extra-curricular sport activities are promoted. Teachers play a key role in determining how national policy is delivered at a local level. While participatory games models are becoming increasingly popular, there still exists a strong commitment to competitive games for the more able students. This has implications for policy-makers seeking to promote more inclusive forms of extra-curricular sport.
Article
This essay examines two issues which for some time have dominated discussions on soccer in Northern Ireland. One is the long‐standing reticence of northern nationalists, Irish nationalists living in Northern Ireland, to attend home international matches. For a range of political, social and ideological reasons large numbers of this community have stayed away from these games for more than three decades. The other is the recent decision by the British government to build a new multi‐sports stadium on the outskirts of the capital city, Belfast. Viewed together, these developments give rise to a broader argument, as the present essay points to, which suggests that notwithstanding the well‐founded opposition northern nationalists have had towards symbols of unionist hegemony in Northern Ireland, including the Irish Football Association (IFA), it is now time to move on. In so doing it offers an ideal opportunity for all concerned to contribute to the birth of a new political and social context in this most divided of western societies.
Article
This paper explores the main contributions of the figurational sociological tradition to the sociology of sport. It also charts the development of this work since the pioneering text, Quest for Excitement, by Norbert Elias and Eric Dunning, as well as offering a brief overview of some of the debates and disagreements that have arisen within the area.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.