ArticlePDF Available

Sedimentary features of tsunami backwash deposits as assessed by micro-beam synchrotron X-ray fluorescence (μ-SXRF) at the Siam photon laboratory

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Over the past few years, several attempts have been performed to find alternative “chemical proxies” in order to discriminate “tsunami backwash deposits” from “typical marine sediments”. A wide range of statistical tools has been selected in order to investigate the sediments and/or terrestrial soils transportation mechanism during the tsunami inundation period by using several types of chemical tracers. To relate the physical and chemical characteristics of Typical Marine Sediments (TMS), Tsunami Backwash Deposits (TBD), Onshore Tsunami Deposits (OTD) and Coastal Zone Soils (CZS) with their synchrotron radiation based micro-X-ray Fluorescence (μ-SXRF) spectra, the μ- SXRF spectra were built in the appropriate selected spectra range from 3,000 eV to 8,000 eV. Further challenges were considered by using the first-order derivative μ-SXRF spectra coupled with Probability Distribution Function (PDF), Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA) and Principal Component Analysis (PCA) in order to investigate the elemental distribution characteristics in various types of terrestrial soils and marine sediments. Dendrographic classifications and multi-dimensional plots of principal components (i.e. bi-polar and three dimensional plots) could indicate the impacts of terrestrial soils and/or marine sediments transport on onshore and/or offshore during the tsunami inundation period. Obviously, these advanced statistical analyses are quite useful and provide valuable information and thus shed new light on the study of paleotsunami.
Content may be subject to copyright.
ISSN 8755-6839
SCIENCE OF TSUNAMI HAZARDS
Journal of Tsunami Society International
Volume 32 Number 2 2013
SEDIMENTARY FEATURES OF TSUNAMI BACKWASH DEPOSITS AS ASSESSED BY
MICRO-BEAM SYNCHROTRON X-RAY FLUORESCENCE (µ-SXRF) AT THE SIAM
PHOTON LABORATORY
Siwatt Pongpiachan1, Kanjana Thumanu2, Waraporn Tanthanuch2, Danai Tipmanee3,4,
Panatda Kanchai1, Klaus Schwarzer5 and Somchai Tancharakorn2*
1NIDA Center for Research & Development of Disaster Prevention & Management, School of Social and
Environmental Development, National Institute of Development Administration (NIDA), 118 Moo-3, Sereethai
Road, Klong-Chan, Bangkapi, Bangkok 10240 THAILAND
2Synchrotron Light Research Institute (Public Organization), Ministry of Science and Technology, THAILAND
3International Postgraduate Program in Environmental Management, Graduate School, Chulalongkorn
University, Bangkok, THAILAND
4Center of Excellence for Environmental and Hazardous Waste Management (EHWM), Chulalongkorn
University, Bangkok, THAILAND
5Institute of Geosciences Sedimentology, Coastal and Continental Shelf Research, Christian Albrechts
University Kiel, Otto Hahn Platz 1, D - 24118 Kiel, GERMANY
ABSTRACT
Over the past few years, several attempts have been performed to find alternative chemical proxies
in order to discriminate “tsunami backwash deposits” from “typical marine sediments”. A wide range
of statistical tools has been selected in order to investigate the sediments and/or terrestrial soils
transportation mechanism during the tsunami inundation period by using several types of chemical
tracers. To relate the physical and chemical characteristics of Typical Marine Sediments (TMS),
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 96 (2013)
*Corresponding author landline phone: (66) 44-217040 ext 1477; mobile phone: (66) 860319900; fax: (66)
044-217047; e-mail: somchai@slri.or.th
Tsunami Backwash Deposits (TBD), Onshore Tsunami Deposits (OTD) and Coastal Zone Soils
(CZS) with their synchrotron radiation based micro-X-ray Fluorescence (µ-SXRF) spectra, the µ-
SXRF spectra were built in the appropriate selected spectra range from 3,000 eV to 8,000 eV. Further
challenges were considered by using the first-order derivative µ-SXRF spectra coupled with
Probability Distribution Function (PDF), Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA) and Principal
Component Analysis (PCA) in order to investigate the elemental distribution characteristics in various
types of terrestrial soils and marine sediments. Dendrographic classifications and multi-dimensional
plots of principal components (i.e. bi-polar and three dimensional plots) could indicate the impacts of
terrestrial soils and/or marine sediments transport on onshore and/or offshore during the tsunami
inundation period. Obviously, these advanced statistical analyses are quite useful and provide
valuable information and thus shed new light on the study of paleotsunami.
Keywords: Andaman Sea; Tsunami Backwash Deposits; Micro-beam Synchrotron X-ray
Fluorescence (
µ
-SXRF); First Order Derivative; Hierarchical Cluster Analysis; Principal Component
Analysis.
1. INTRODUCTION
The 2004 Sumatra-Andaman earthquake and tsunami was commonly considered as the worst natural
disaster to ever attack Southeast Asian countries, triggering death and injury as well as major
destruction to the transportation system, property, and environmental and economic sustainability
(Griffin et al., 2013; Matsumaru et al., 2012). The severe impact on the beach zone between the
Pakarang Cape and the Khao Lak, Phang-nga province of Thailand in turn had serious consequences
on the scoured features existed in both on the beach side and in the embayment of tidal channels
(Choowong et al., 2007, 2009; Fagherazzi and Du, 2007). In spite of various papers focusing on
geomorphological, sedimentological and geological alterations in tsunami-affected areas (Choowong
et al., 2007, 2008a, 2008b, 2009;Szczuciński et al., 2005, 2006, 2007), the knowledge of chemical
distribution is strictly limited.
As a consequence, several challenges have been made to conduct both qualitative and quantitative
analyses of various chemical species in both onshore and offshore of tsunami-affected regions (Goff
et al., 2012; Jagodziński et al., 2012; Pongpiachan et al., 2012; Pongpiachan et al., 2013; Sakuna et
al., 2012; Tipmanee et al., 2012). In order to understand the destructive behaviour of tsunami
affecting both onshore and offshore areas, numerous studies have attempted to draw the scientific
community’s attention on the feasibility of chemical tracers to characterize tsunami backwash
deposits from those of typical marine sediments (Pongpiachan et al., 2012; Pongpiachan et al., 2013;
Tipmanee et al., 2012). Since the identification of tsunami backwash deposit is the first step to gain
information on tsunami impacts, it is therefore essentially crucial to find an alternative method to
discriminate tsunami backwash deposits from those of natural background submarine sediments.
In the past few years, X-ray fluorescence (XRF) have been widely used for the determination of
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 97 (2013)
elements in sedimentological record of tsunamis on the Portuguese Shelf off Lisbon (Abrantes et al.,
2008), geoarchaeological evidence of multiple tsunamigenic imprint on the Bay of Palairos-Pogonia,
Greece (Vött et al., 2011)) and most recently sedimentary deposits left by the 2004 Indian Ocean
tsunami on the inner continental shelf offshore of Khao Lak, Andaman Sea, Thailand (Sakuna et al.,
2011). XRF has gained more popularity on studies of environmental sciences because of its relatively
low cost solution compared to other analytical instruments, non-destructive testing solution, fast
processing time, typical detection limit of around 0.01% for most elements and quantitative analysis.
Recently, the shared use of synchrotron radiation based micro-X-ray Fluorescence (µ-SXRF) permits
analysis of objects at the micron-scale owing to its high intensity and energy tenability in comparison
with those of conventional light sources such as sealed-tube or rotating-anode generators
(Tancharakorn et al., 2012). Because of micrometer sized X-ray beam, one can use µ-SXRF not only
to quantify the elemental compositions in target samples but also its distribution at the micrometer
scale (Kanngieβer & Haschke, 2006).
In this research, the author postulates that the use of µ-SXRF in cooperation with the first derivative,
probability distribution functions (PDF), hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA) and principal component
analysis (PCA) provides a better insight of sedimentary features of tsunami backwash deposits in
comparison with those of typical marine sediments and terrestrial components. Note that this is the
first time to employ µ-SXRF with assistance of synchrotron radiation in order to assess the elemental
distribution of tsunami backwash deposits in micro-scale. It is also worth mentioning that neither the
source apportionment, nor the analysis of spatial variation of chemical components in sediments is the
principal objective of this paper.
2. MATERIALS & METHODS
2.1 Sampling sites & sampling procedure
2.1.1 Surface marine sediment
The research area is governed by two seasonal monsoons: the northeast monsoon from mid October
until March and the southwest monsoon from May to September. This study was carried out offshore
along the west coast of Phang Nga province, in the southwest region of Thailand, which was heavily
affected by the 2004 tsunami. The research area covers approximately 1,000 km2 between Thap Lamu
and Pakarang Cape, up to a water depth of 70 meters. Our research was carried out on research cruises
taken from one year apart, from November-December 2007 with RV CHAKRATONG TONGYAI
and November-December 2008 with RV BOONLERT PASOOK, covering approximately 1500
nautical miles of hydroacoustic profiles (side scan sonar, multibeam echo sounder and shallow
reflection seismic with a boomer system) were recorded at Pakarang Cape. Twenty of sediment
samples were collected during 18-20 July 2009 (Fig. 1)). The sampling stations were selected on the
basis of the basic data acquired from hydroacoustic mapping using equipment, which consisted of
Multi-beam, Side Scan Sonar and Boomer system to investigate the sedimentary deposition on near-
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 98 (2013)
shore seabed (Feldens et al., 2009; Feldens et al., 2012). These supporting data provided the
geophysical structure of seabed, which was promising evidence of terrestrial deposits in the study
area. Van-veen Grab Sampler was used to collect the 20 surface sediment samples. Sediment samples
were wrapped in clean aluminum foil, placed in a glass bottle, and kept frozen at – 20 ºC.
Fig. 1: Sampling site description at tsunami affected area at Khao Lak, Phang-nga province of
Thailand.
2.1.2 Terrestrial soils
Ten of terrestrial soil samples were collected during 18-20 July 2009. Soil sampling stations were
selected by considering the areas, which were affected by the 2004 Tsunami (Szczucinski et al.,
2005). In addition, the locations of soil sampling stations were also in the transect line of the surface
sediment sampling stations (Fig.1-2). They were collected during 18-20 July 2009. The surface layer
was collected by using a clean shovel. About half kilogram of composite samples from 2 m2 area of
each station was taken (Badin et al., 2008). They were wrapped in clean aluminum foil, placed in a
glass bottle, and kept frozen at - 20ºC
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 99 (2013)
Fig. 2: Tsunami and Post-tsunami deposition layer at Khao Lak, Phang-nga province of Thailand.
2.2 Sample preparation for
µ
-SXRF
Due to the heterogeneity of sediment, all samples for XRF measurement were prepared in
homogenous and flat discs using grinding and pelletizing processes. In the grinding process, 100 g of
powder was weighted and put into a 10 ml ZrO2 grinding bowl with two ZrO2 balls (Ø 10 mm) and
seven SiO2 balls (Ø 5 mm) and shaken at 1,800 oscillations/min for 30 minutes (Fig. 3). Then, in the
pelletizing process, 50 g of homogenous powder was put into a steel mould and pressurized at 4 tons
for 1 minute to form a 13 mm in diameter disc.
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 100 (2013)
Fig. 3: sediment powder with grinding balls in a ZrO2 bowl before (a) and after (b) grinding process,
and after (c) pelletizing process.
2.3
µ
-SXRF Experiment
Synchrotron X-ray fluorescence experiments were carried out at the µ-SXRF end-station
(Tancharakorn et al., 2012) attached to beamline 2.2 of the Siam Photon Laboratory to utilize
monochromatic X-ray beam. In this beamline, X-rays can be generated by the 1.2 GeV storage ring
travelling 21 m through an evacuated pipe to the sample. The beamline consists of a double multilayer
monochromator (DMM) (at 8.8 m downstream) to select desired energy between 6 keV to 9 keV,
focusing mirror (FM) (at 11.0 m downstream) to increase photon flux and beryllium window of 200
µm thickness (at 21 m downstream) to separate high vacuum region and atmospheric pressure. Details
of the beam line 2.2 can be found in previous literature (Soontaranon et al., 2012). In the experiment,
samples were mounted on a motorized sample stage in air. An energy-dispersive Si-PIN detector from
AMPTEK, USA, with energy resolution of 160 eV at the Mn Kα emission line was used to collect
XRF signals. Six spots were randomly chosen to be exposed with 9 keV X-rays for 100 seconds for
each spot. XRF signals were collected in the detector and then sent to MCA8000A multichannel
analyzer (AMPTEK, USA) where each signal is stored in each channel corresponding to the certain
energy. Therefore, the detector must be first calibrated to find a relationship between channel and
photon energy. Here commercial XRF metal standards (titanium, vanadium and iron foils) were used.
The energy-dispersive data were finally created in a single-column file, which can be analyzed using
the pyMCA. In this code, a Guassian function is used to characterized position, width and height or
area of each peak. The position of each peak is used to identify element, while its area is directly
related to its concentration. The code also deals with the background signal. The algorithm of the
pyMCA can be found in (Sole et.al., 2007).
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 101 (2013)
2.4 Statistical analysis
The derivative spectrophotometric method is based on transformation of zero-order spectra of
sediment and soil samples into the first-order derivative (ΔPhoton Energy (eV)/ΔIntensity (counts)).
In this study, the value of first derivative was performed by using the Software OPUS Version 7.0. In
addition, first derivatives of the spectral data from each sampling location were treated through
hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA) and principal component analysis (PCA) with the orthogonal
Varimax solution using Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) Version 13.0.
3. RESULTS & DISCUSSION
3.1.Characteristics of the first-order derivative
µ
-SXRF spectra
Although several attempts have been made by several researchers to quantify chemical contents in
sediments in order to elucidate tsunami backwash mechanism (Pongpiachan et al., 2012; Pongpiachan
et al., 2013; Sakuna et al., 2012; Tipmanee et al., 2012;), some alternative proxies are always required
to enhance the reliability of data interpretation. In this study, the assessment of µ-SXRF spectra as an
alternative “fingerprint” to discriminate tsunami backwash deposit from typical marine sediments was
performed by using the concept of first derivative. All samples were classified into four groups
namely “Typical Marine Sediments (TMS)”, “Tsunami Backwash Deposits (TBD)”, “Onshore
Tsunami Deposits (OTD)” and “Coastal Zone Terrestrial Soils (CTS)” as clearly described in Table 1.
Table 1. Sample information of marine sediments and terrestrial soils.
Sampling code
Sampling date
Sampling description
Coastal Zone Soils (CZS)
Tub1
July-18-2009
Canal bank
PK 3
July-19-2009
Shrimp pond
BN 2
July-20-2009
Canal bank
BP 3
July-20-2009
Mangrove
Onshore Tsunami Deposits (OTD)
BK 1 Post Tsu, BK1 Tsu
July-19-2009
Tsunami deposit layer
BK 5 Tsu
July-19-2009
Tsunami deposit layer
BM 1 Tsu
July-20-2009
Tsunami deposit layer
BM 2 Post Tsu, BM2 Tsu
July-20-2009
Pond
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 102 (2013)
Typical Marine Sediments (TMS)
10, 17
December-1-2007
Pakarang cape sediment
3-2 ,3-6, 3-16, 4-2, 4-6, 5-20, 5-25
March-4-5- 2010
Pakarang cape sediment
53, 62 December-7-2007 Thup Lamu Sediment
Tsunami Backwash Deposits (TBD)
23, 27, 31, 39, 72, 78
December-3-2007
Tsunami affected sediment
5-17, 5-21, 5-23
March-5- 2010
Tsunami affected sediment
The average µ-SXRF spectra of four sample groups are compared and carefully investigated (See Fig.
4). Generally, all sample groups display similar spectral characteristics. There are four prominent
features, which are common to all µ-SXRF spectra: a) main element which can be found in all
samples is calcium (K
α
at 3.69 keV, K
β
at 4.01 keV); b) all samples have a relatively small amount of
titanium (K
α
at 4.51 keV, K
β
at 4.93 keV) and manganese (K
α
at 5.90 keV, K
β
at 6.49 keV); c) another
main element contained in all samples is iron(K
α
at 6.40 keV, K
β
at 7.06 keV); and d) low
concentration of three elements which are potassium ((K
α
at 3.31 keV, K
β
at 3.59 keV), titanium and
manganese were detected in OTD samples. Based on these results, one can deduce that all elemental
species in samples share comparable distribution patterns.
Fig. 4: µ-SXRF spectra of typical marine sediments (TMS), tsunami backwash deposits (TBD), on-
shore tsunami deposits (OTD) and coastal zone soils (CZS).
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 103 (2013)
Although all sample groups show comparatively similar µ-SXRF spectra features in the photon
energy range from 3000 to 8000 eV, some subtle relative changes can be enhanced by computing the
first-order derivative of raw spectra (Balsam and Deaton, 1991). The computation of the first-order
derivative generates curves that have peaks where the rate of change of the raw µ-SXRF spectral
curves is at maximum and are flat where spectral curves display no change in slope. TMS is
characterized by its four positive major peaks in the first derivative situated at 5104 eV, 5165 eV,
5735 eV and 7754 eV, followed by three negative main peaks located at 3110 eV, 5091 eV and 5661
eV respectively. On the contrary, the disappearances of two main peaks at 3110 eV and 7754 eV were
detected at TBD, OTD and CZS samples, highlighting the absence of some typical marine elements in
non-marine samples. It is well known that marl and calcareous clay, glauconite, kalolinite, organic
matter, phosphorite, hematite and goethite show relatively high contribution in marine sediments as
previously mentioned in several publications (Balsam and Beeson, 2003). Recent studies also reveal
the significance of Ca, Fe, K, Sr, and Ti in selected sediment sections from a continental margin
sediment core by using Micro-XRF analyzer (Micro-XRF) with a 100-µm resolution and an XRF
whole-core scanner (XRF-S) with a 5-mm resolution (Böning et al., 2007). Hence, the discrepancy of
µ-SXRF spectra features between marine and non-marine samples can be ascribed to the differences
in elemental compositions.
Fig. 5: First derivative plot of typical marine sediments (TMS), tsunami backwash deposits (TBD),
on-shore tsunami deposits (OTD) and coastal zone soils (CZS).
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 104 (2013)
3.2 Probability distribution function (PDF)
In probability theory, a probability density function (PDF) is a function that defines the comparative
possibility for this random variable to take on a certain value. The probability for the random variable
to fall within a particular region is given by the integral of this variable’s density over the region. The
probability density function is nonnegative everywhere, and its integral over the entire space is equal
to one. PDF was employed to all µ-SXRF spectra in the intensity range from 0 to 400 counts as
clearly displayed in Fig. 6. Generally, the probability density of standard normal distribution can be
described as follows:
(1)
where e, x and
π
represent for exponential constant (i.e. 2.718), intensity (counts) and pi value (i.e.
3.142) respectively. If a random variable X is provided and its distribution possesses a probability
density function f, then the estimated value of X can be computed as
(2)
A distribution has a density function if and only if its cumulative distribution function F(x) is
absolutely continuous. In this case: F is almost everywhere differentiable, and its derivative can be
used as probability density:
(3)
PDF is a function that describes the relative likelihood for this random variable to take on a given
value. The probability for the random variable to fall within a particular region is given by the
Gaussian distribution, which can be described as follows:
(4)
where y,
σ
,
σ
2,
µ
and x represent for probability distribution function (PDF), standard deviation of µ-
SXRF spectra intensity, variance of µ-SXRF spectra intensity, average of µ-SXRF spectra intensity
and µ-SXRF spectra intensity of all samples respectively.
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 105 (2013)
Fig. 6: Probability distribution of µ-SXRF of typical marine sediments (TMS), tsunami backwash
deposits (TBD), on-shore tsunami deposits (OTD) and coastal zone soils (CZS).
As noticeably displayed in Fig. 6, some prominent curve features can be obtained directly from these
unique plots. It is worth mentioning that skewnessis a degree of the asymmetry of the curve plots
between µ-SXRF spectra intensity and PDF of a real-valued random variable (i.e. µ-SXRF spectra
intensity). Basically, there are three types of skewness values, which can be termed as positive
skew, negative skew and undefined. A positive skew designates that the tail on the right side is longer
than the left side, whilst a negative skew implies that the tail on the left side is longer than the right
side. It is also important to stress that the bulk of the PDF values (including the median) of positive
skew and negative skew situate at the left and right of the mean respectively. Qualitatively, a zero
value implies that the PDF values are comparatively consistently dispersed on both sides of the mean,
characteristically indicating a symmetric distribution.
Firstly, the relatively symmetrical bell-shape curves were detected in the curve plots between
averaged µ-SXRF spectra intensity and PDF of TMS, TBD and CZS with moderately longer tails in
the right side with most of the data still concentrated on the left indicating the positive skewness
type of normal distribution. Since the majority of the PDF curve peaks are more focused in the
intensity range of 50 ± 5 counts, it seems rational to assume that this phenomenon is a consequence
of comparatively homogeneous spatial elemental distribution in typical marine sediments, tsunami
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 106 (2013)
backwash deposits and coastal zone soils. Interestingly, both TMS and CZS have considerably similar
curve plots in spite of its different sampling backgrounds. This can be explained by the invariability of
elemental compositions (i.e. Cl, K, Ca, Ti, Cr, Mn, Fe, V) observed in both marine sediments and
terrestrial soils. Secondly, the irrelevant curve feature of OTD was detected with positive skewness
type of bell shape distribution with exceedingly broad peaks coupled with flat tops at the interval
range of 50 to 300 counts in comparison with those of TMS, TBD and CZS. This reflects highly
deviated elemental distributions involved in onshore tsunami deposits as a result of more complex
chemical mixtures derived from both terrestrial components and marine deposits.
3.3 Hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA)
Cluster analysis (CA), also called segmentation analysis or taxonomy analysis, seeks to identify
homogeneous subgroups of cases in a population. That is, cluster analysis seeks to identify a set of
groups, which both minimize within-group variation and maximize between-group variation. In this
study, CA was conducted using SPSS 13.0 for Windows. CA techniques may be hierarchical (i.e. the
resultant classification has an increasing number of nested classes) or non-hierarchical (i.e. k-means
clustering). Hierarchical clustering allows users to select a definition of distance, then select a linking
method of forming clusters, then determine how many clusters best suit the data. Hierarchical
clustering methods do not require pre-set knowledge of the number of groups.
Two general methods of hierarchical clustering methods are available: divisive and agglomerative.
The divisive technique starts by assuming a single group, partitioning that group into subgroups,
partitioning these subgroups further into subgroups and so on until each object forms its own
subgroup. The agglomerative techniques start with each object describing a subgroup, and then
combine like subgroups into more inclusive subgroups until only one group remains. In either case,
the results of the application of the clustering technique are best described using a dendrogram or
binary tree. The objects are represented as nodes in the dendrogram and the branches illustrate when
the cluster method joins subgroups containing that object. The length of the branch indicates the
distance between the subgroups when they are joined.
In this study, Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA) was applied to test the hypothesis that µ-SXRF
spectra can be used as an alternative fingerprint” in order to distinguish “tsunami backwash
deposits” from those of “typical marine sediments”. Two types of datasets, namely raw and first
derivative µ-SXRF spectra of all samples, were employed to HCA as clearly illustrated in Fig. 7-8.
The HCA of raw µ-SXRF spectra showed the existence of two major clusters with four different sub-
clusters. The first main cluster constitutes[consists of?] of all sample types with the average
percentage contribution of 37 %, 21 %, 26 % and 16% for TMS, TBD, OTD and CZS respectively.
This cluster can be divided into two sub-clusters; the first sub-cluster constitutes of TMS (30 %), TBD
(20 %), OTD (40 %), CZS (10 %) and the second sub-cluster is composed of TMS (44 %), TBD (22
%), OTD (11 %), CZS (22 %). According to dendrogram, the second major cluster [is constructed
of?]constructs of all groups with the average percentage contribution of 35 %, 48 %, 8 % and 8% for
TMS, TBD, OTD and CZS respectively. The second major cluster can be separated into two sub-
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 107 (2013)
clusters; the third sub-cluster [is comprised of?]comprises of TMS (20 %), TBD (80 %), OTD (0 %),
CZS (0 %) and the fourth sub-cluster is composed of TMS (35 %), TBD (48 %), OTD (8 %), CZS (8
%). The second major cluster can be considered as a mixture of “typical marine sediments” and
“tsunami backwash deposits”, which has been highly characterized in the third sub-cluster (See Fig.
7).
Fig. 7: Dendrographic classification with raw data of typical marine sediments (TMS), tsunami
backwash deposits (TBD), on-shore tsunami deposits (OTD) and coastal zone soils (CZS). The
Euclidean distance after vector normalization spectra and the Ward linkage method were employed.
For details about cluster group composition see data in Table 1.
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 108 (2013)
Further efforts to underline the importance of µ-SXRF spectra as an alternative fingerprinthave
been conducted by using the first derivative data. It can be seen in Fig. 8 that the OTD samples are
highly deviated from CZS samples, which emphasizes the strong discrepancy in elemental distribution
between onshore tsunami deposits and coastal zone soils. Interestingly, TMS samples have a high
degree of similarity with those of OTD samples. This particular phenomenon can be ascribed as
heavily influenced by advancement of large-scale tsunami inundation, which is responsible for
extensive sediment transport from the offshore and subsequently deposited over the coastal areas.
Similarly, TBD samples share a high level of affinity with those of CZS samples. This unique
occurrence can be attributed to rapid tsunami backwash, which carried terrestrial debris from the
onshore to the offshore.
Fig. 8: Dendrographic classification with the first-order derivative data of typical marine sediments
(TMS), tsunami backwash deposits (TBD), on-shore tsunami deposits (OTD) and coastal zone soils
(CZS). The Euclidean distance after vector normalization spectra and the Ward linkage method were
employed. For details about cluster group composition see data in Table 1.
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 109 (2013)
3.4 Principal component analysis (PCA)
In PCA, all variables are expressed in standardized form with a mean of 0 and a standard deviation of
1. The total variance therefore equals the total number of variables, and the variance of each factor
expressed as a fraction of the total variance is referred to as the eigenvalue. If a factor has a low
eigenvalue, then it is contributing little to the explanation of variances in the variables and may be
ignored. PCA is generally used when the research purpose is data reduction (i.e. to reduce the
information in many measured variables into a smaller set of components). PCA seeks a linear
combination of variables such that the maximum variance is extracted from the variables. It then
removes this variance and seeks a second linear combination that explains the maximum proportion of
the remaining variance, and so on. This is called the principal axis method and results in orthogonal
(uncorrelated) factors. Thus, the largest combination, accounting for most of the variance, becomes
principal component 1 (PC1), the second largest accounts for the next largest amount of variances and
becomes principal component 2 (PC2), and so on. In general, the first component (P1) for observed
variables X1, X2, ………, Xp can be expressed as:
(5)
where the are the weights chosen to maximise the ratio of the variance of P1 to
the total variation, subject to the constraint that
(6)
The second principal component (P2) is the combination of the observed variables, which is
uncorrelated with the first linear combination and which accounts for the maximum amount of the
remaining total variance not already accounted for by P1. Assume that the data set has n samples for p
variables. The basic ( ) data matrix can be written as:
(7)
where Xij is the value of variable j obtained for sample i. When the matrix X is used, P can be
rewritten as:
(8)
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 110 (2013)
where M is the mean matrix given by:
(9)
where Equation 9 is the mean for variable j.
(10)
The matrix of standardised loadings, A, is a ( ) matrix such that . The scores matrix, P,
is a ( ) matrix such that is a diagonal matrix. Equation 7 becomes
(11)
In this study, Varimax rotation was selected to maximize the sum of the variances of the squared
loadings and thus enable us to seek the similarity of chemical components in sediment and soil
samples. µ-SXRF spectra of the samples listed in Table 1 were analysed by PCA. The principal
component patterns for Varimax rotated components of 30 samples composed of two PC, which
account for 82.9 % and 17.0 % for the total of variances of PC1 and PC2 respectively. The
contribution of PC1 and PC2 explains 99.9 % of total variance, and moreover PC1 is 4.87 times
higher than PC2.
Multi dimensional (MD) plots of PC1, PC2 and PC3 have been frequently employed as diagnostic
tools of chemical sources in environmental samples (Marcosa et al., 2010; Pongpiachan, 2006;
Pongpiachan et al., 2012; Pongpiachan et al., 2013; Tipmanee et al., 2012). MD distribution patterns
of PCs can be used as a characteristic diagnostic parameter to identify their elemental distribution
characteristics in soil and sediment samples. However, these MD plots, as well as HCA and PDF,
should be used with great caution as physiochemical processes can alter elemental distribution pattern
during their transport from the emission source to the receptor site. Apart from using only raw data of
µ-SXRF spectra, a second approach was also pioneered by using the first-order derivative dataset for
three-dimensional (3D) plots of PCs in order to minimize the above-mentioned uncertainties.
In bi-polar plots of PC1 versus PC2 (see Figure 9), the vast majority of data points were clustered
along the positive values of PC2 (y-axis) adjacent to 1.0 and subsequently decrease exponentially to
positive side of PC1 (x-axis). The clearest features in MD plots (see Fig. 9-10) are: (i) 2D plots of
samples No.23, No.31, No.39, No.72, No.78, No.5-21 and No.5-23, which were clustered close to
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 111 (2013)
each other. It seems rational to interpret this cluster as evidence of tsunami backwash deposit samples.
(ii) 2D plots of CZS samples (i.e. No.Tub1, No.PK3, No.BN2, No.BP3) with the mixture of TMS
samples (i.e. No.17, No.53, No.62) and OTD samples (i.e. No. BM1-Tsu, No.BM2-Tsu, No.BP3,
No.BK5-Tsu, No.BM2-Post-Tsu). It appears reasonable to ascribe this cluster as a mixture of
terrestrial components and marine deposits. This can be deduced as a consequence of inferior mixing
process between tsunami backwash deposits and typical marine sediments after tsunami inundation;
(iii) OTD samples are highly deviated from TMS and TBD samples but possess similar distribution
pattern with those of CZS samples as noticeably illustrated in 3D plots of first-order derivative PCs
(see Fig. 10). This can be explained by the high degree of similarity in elemental distribution between
onshore tsunami deposits and coastal zone soils.
Fig. 9: Three-dimensional plots of principal components (PC) with raw data of typical marine
sediments (TMS), tsunami backwash deposits (TBD), on-shore tsunami deposits (OTD) and coastal
zone soils (CZS).
4. SYNTHESIS AND CONCLUSIONS
The above statistical analysis of collected data reveals that µ-SXRF spectra can yield authentic and
valuable insight upon the terrestrial soils and/or marine sediments transportation processes affecting
elemental distribution in the tsunami affected area. Subsequently, the authors support interpreting µ-
SXRF spectra on the basis of various types of advanced statistical analyses rather than the simple use
of raw spectra, which seems to be difficult for drawing any conclusions.
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 112 (2013)
Terrestrial)Soils)
Tsunami)Backwash)Deposits)
Tsunami)Backwash)Deposits)
The major conclusions that occur from this data interpretation are described as follows:
(a) The prominent µ-SXRF spectra features of Typical Marine Sediments (TMS), Tsunami
Backwash Deposits (TBD), Onshore Tsunami Deposits (OTD) and Cluster Zone Soils (CZS)
can be achieved only through the employment of first order derivative data.
(b) The analysis of Probability Distribution Function (PDF) for different sample categories shows
a clear influence of terrestrial soils and/or marine sediments transportation on elemental
distribution.
(c) The Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA) analysis of both raw and first order derivative data
successfully discriminate terrestrial components from typical marine sediments with the
assistance of dendrographic classification.
(d) The multi-dimensional plots of principal components (PCs) by using both raw and first order
derivative data highlights the characteristic features of onshore tsunami deposits and coastal
zone soils as clearly demonstrated in Fig.9-10.
Fig. 10: Three-dimensional plots of principal components (PC) with the first-order derivative data of
typical marine sediments (TMS), tsunami backwash deposits (TBD), on-shore tsunami deposits
(OTD) and coastal zone soils (CZS).
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 113 (2013)
5. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work was performed with the approval of Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, Grant
SCHW/ 11-1) and National Research Council of Thailand (NRCT). The authors acknowledge Phuket
Marine Biological Center (PMBC) for their support with ship time of RV Chakratong Tongyai and
RV Boonlert Pasook, as well as other contributions and facilities during field measurements. We are
greatful to Mrs. D. Sakuna for support during all cruises. The authors would also like to express
special gratitude to Synchrotron Light Research Institute (Public Organization), Ministry of Science
and Technology, Thailand for their contribution of µ-SXRF measurements.
REFERENCES
ABRANTES, F., ALT-EPPING, U., LEBREIRO, S., VOELKER, A. & SCHNEIDER, R. (2008). Mar. Geol. 249
(3–4), 283-293.
BADIN, A. L., FAURE, P., BEDELL, J. P. & DELOLME, C. (2008). Sci. Total. Environ. 403, 178-187.
BALSAM, W. L. & DEATON, B. C. (1991). Rev. Aquat. Sci. 4, 411-447.
BALSAM, W. L. & BEESON, J. P. (2003). Deep. Sea. Res. Pat. I. 50, 1421-1444.
BÖNING, P., BARD, E. & ROSE, J. (2007). Geochem. Geophy. Geosy. 8 (5),
DOI: 10.1029/2006GC001480.
CHOOWONG, M., MURAKOSHI, N., HISADA, K., CHARUSIRI, P., DAORERK, V., CHAROENTITIRAT, T.,
CHUTAKOSITKANON, V., JANKAEW, K. & KANJANAPAYONT, P. (2007). J. Coastal. Res. 23(5),
1270–1276.
CHOOWONG, M., MURAKOSHI, N., HISADA, K., CHARUSIRI, P., CHAROENTITIRAT, T.,
CHUTAKOSITKANON, V., JANKAEW, K., KANJANAPAYONT, P. & PHANTUWONGRAJ, S. (2008a)
Mar. Geol. 248 (3–4), 179–192.
CHOOWONG, M., MURAKOSHI, N., HISADA, K., CHAROENTITIRAT, T., CHARUSIRI, P.,
PHANTUWONGRAJ, S., WONGKOK, P., CHOOWONG, A., SUBSAYJUN,R., CHUTAKOSITKANON, V.,
JANKAEW, K. & KANJANAPAYONT, P. (2008b). Terra. Nova. 20, 141–149.
CHOOWONG, M., PHANTUWONGRAJ, S., CHAROENTITIRAT, T., CHUTAKOSITKANON, V., YUMUANG, S. &
CHARUSIRI, P. (2009). Geomorphology. 104, 134–142.
FAGHERAZZI, S. & DU, X. (2007). Geomorphology. 99, 120-129.
FELDENS, P., SCHWARZER, K., SZCZUCIŃSKI, W., STATTEGGER, K., SAKUNA, D. &
SOMGPONGCHAIYKUL, P. (2009). Polish. J. Enivron. 18, 63-68.
FELDENS, P., SCHWARZER, K., SAKUNA, D., SZCZUCIŃSKI, W. & SOMPONGCHAIYAKUL, P. (2013).
Earth. Planets. Space. 64(10), 875-887.
GOFF, C. C., ANDREW, A., SZCZUCIŃSKI, W., GOFF, J. & NISHIMURA, Y. (2012). Sediment. Geol. 282,
65-77.
GRIFFIN, C., ELLIS, D., BEAVIS, S. & NANTES, Z.D. (2013). Ocean. Coast. Manage. 71, 176-186.
JAGODZIŃSKI, R., STERNAL, B., SZCZUCIŃSKI, W., GOFF, C. C. & SUGAWARA, D. (2012). Sediment.
Geol. 282, 57-64.
KANNGIEβER, B. & HASCHKE, M. (2006). Handbook of Practical X-ray Fluorescence Analysis, edited
by B. Beckhoff, B. Kanngieber, N. Langhoff, R. Wedell and H. Wolff, pp. 442-462. Berlin,
Spinger-Verlag.
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 114 (2013)
MARCOSA, M. M., HARRISON, M. R., SCHUHMACHER, M., DOMINGO, L. J. & PONGPIACHAN, S. (2010).
Sci. Total. Environ. 408, 2387-2393.
MATSUMARU, R., NAGAMI, K. & TAKEYA, K. (2012). IATSS. Res. 36 (1), 11-19.
PONGPIAJUN, S. (2006). Atmospheric Chemistry of Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds in Urban and
Rural Air, University of Birmingham.
PONGPIACHAN, S., THUMANU, K., KOSITANONT, C., SCHWARZER, K., PRIETZEL, J., HIRUNYATRAKUL, P.
& KITTIKOON, I. (2012). J. Anal. Methods. Chem. Article ID 659858, doi:
10.1155/2012/659858.
PONGPIACHAN, S., THUMANU, K., NA PHATTHALUNG, W., TIPMANEE, D., KANCHAI, P., FELDENS, P &
SCHWARZER, K. (2013). Sci. Tsu. Haz. (ISSN 8775-6839), 32 (1), 39-57.
SAKUNA, D., SZCZUCIŃSKI, W., FELDENS, P., SCHWARZER, K. & KHOKIATTIWONG, S. (2012). Earth.
Planets. Space. 64, 931-943.
SOLE, V. A., PAPILLON, E., COTTE, M., WALTER, PH., & SUSINI, J. (2007). Spectrochim. Acta B, 62, 63-
68.
SOONTARANON, S. & RUGMAI, S. (2012). Small angle X-ray scattering at Siam photon laboratory,
Chinese. J. Phys. 50 (2), 204–210, 2012.
SZCZUCIŃSKI, W., NIEDZIELSKI, P., RACHLEWICZ, G., SOBCZYŃSKI, T., ZIOŁA, A., KOWALSKI, A.,
LORENC, S. & SIEPAK, J. (2005). Environ. Geol. 49 (2), 321-331.
SZCZUCIŃSKI, W., CHAIMANEE, N., NIEDZIELSKI, P., RACHLEWICZ, G., SAISUTTICHAI, D., TEPSUWAN,
T., LORENC, S. & SIEPAK, J. (2006). Pol. J. Environ. Stud. 15 (5), 793–810.
SZCZUCIŃSKI, W., NIEDZIELSKI, P., KOZAK, L., FRANKOWSKI, M., ZIOŁA, A. & LORENC, S. (2007).
Environ. Geol. 53 (2), 253-264.
SZCZUCIŃSKI, W. (2012). Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci. 60,115–133.
TANCHARAKORN, S., TANTHANUCH, W., KAMONSUTTHIPAIJIT, N., WONGPRACHANUKUL, N., SOPHON,
M., CHAICHUAY, S., UTHAISAR, C. & YIMNIRUN, R. (2012). J. Synchrotron. Rad. 19, 536-540.
TIPMANEE, D., DEELAMAN, W., PONGPIACHAN, S., SCHWARZER, K. & SOMPONGCHAIYAKUL, P. (2012).
Nat. Hazards Earth Syst. Sci. 12, 1441–1451.
VÖTT, A., LANG, F., BRÜCKNER, H., PAPANASTASSIOU, G. K., MAROUKIAN, H., PAPANASTASSIOU, D.,
GIANNIKOS, A., HADLER, H., HANDL, M., NTAGERETZIS, K., WILLERSHÄUSER, T. & ZANDER, A.
(2011). Quatern. Int. 242(1), 213-239.
Vol. 32, No. 2, page 115 (2013)
... This was interpreted as an alternation between marine and terrestrial sources, probably influenced by successive up-rush and backwash phases. Pongpiachan et al. (2013a) analyzed the first-order derivative of micro XRF spectra (µ-SXRF) from marine tsunami backwash deposits and compared it to onshore tsunami deposits, typical marine sediment and coastal zone soils. They noticed that, unlike onshore tsunami deposits, which show similar signature as typical marine sediment, marine backwash deposits show similar geochemical signature as coastal zone soils, as reported in previous studies. ...
... This is also confirmed by the lower 210 Pbxs activity found in layers EL1 to EL4, which reveals the presence of older reworked sediment, or originating from a shallower source, in the layers. Based on the terrigenous signature, the geodynamic context of Tutuila island and similar event layers encountered in a previous study in Pago Pago Bay attributed to recent tsunami backwash deposits following the 2009 SPT and the 1960 GCET (Riou et al., submitted), event layers EL1 to EL4 can be either interpreted as tsunami backwash deposits or cyclone-related flash-flood deposits (Srinivasalu et al., 2010;Sakuna et al., 2012;Pongpiachan et al., 2013a;Veerasingam et al., 2014;Sakuna-Schwartz et al., 2015). However, the grain size distribution of the cores display poor to very poor sorting in both cores and a bimodal trend in core K16. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
Following recent destructive tsunamis, especially the 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami and the 2011 Tohoku-Oki Tsunami, and their worldwide coverage, there has been a growing interest in tsunami research amongst the scientific community. However, most of the studies dealing with geological evidence of past tsunamis focus on onshore deposits, leaving aside marine deposits despite their potential for recording of the backwash phase. Moreover, the few studies on tsunami marine deposits were carried out in open and dynamic shallow marine environments, which are not favorable for long-time preservation. In this study, we focus on sheltered bays of Tutuila (American Samoa) frequently impacted by tsunamis, supposed to offer ideal preservation potential, to gain knowledge on tsunami backwash deposits. The sediment-fill of Pago Pago Bay was first examined. The internal architecture and sediment facies show that the bay infilling was emplaced during the last 12 000 years through the last sea-level rise and highstand. The upper bay-fill consists of alternations between low-energy and high-energy sediment units, interpreted as stacked tsunami backwash deposits, emplaced during the last millenaries. Within the uppermost meter-thick silty unit, backwash deposits emplaced following the 2009 South Pacific Tsunami and the 1960 Great Chilean Earthquake Tsunami were identified based on geochemical, mineralogical and micro-structural signatures. Basal microstructural features give evidence that those tsunami backflows behave as hyperpycnal currents. Finally, backwash deposits of four recent tsunamis were identified in bays located along the north shore of Tutuila, including the 2009 South Pacific Tsunami, the 1960 Great Chilean Earthquake Tsunami or the 1957 Aleutian Islands Tsunami, the 1917 Tonga Trench Tsunami and an older tsunami never reported in American Samoa, most likely the 1868 South American Tsunami. Backwash deposits emplaced by the 1868 South American Tsunami would represent the first marine geological evidence of this tsunami. As a whole, this study shows the great potential of sheltered shallow marine environments for tsunami backwash archiving, with at least four tsunami backwash deposits identified for the last 150 years in the bays of Tutuila. In addition, this work provides new identification criteria for tsunami backwash deposits, particularly in comparison with flash-flood deposits.
... In the case of the distinctly displayed GDF, the area under the curve will reveal the probability of occurrence of a continuous random parameter. Previous studies have applied the GDF to evaluate the symmetricity of a bell-shaped curve of data in environmental sciences (Pongpiachan et al., 2013a(Pongpiachan et al., , 2013b(Pongpiachan et al., , 2015Pongpiachan & Iijima, 2016), astrophysics (McDonald et al., 2000), psychology (Link & Heath, 1975), risk analysis (Clemen & Winkler, 1999), and social studies (Newman & Park, 2003;Pongpiachan, 2018aPongpiachan, , 2018b. As noticeably illustrated in Figure 6, numerous prominent components of the GDF can be principally extracted from the original graphs. ...
... Based on the terrigenous signature (higher Ti/Ca related to volcanic minerals, Riou et al.,2020b), the ages, known tsunami waves and cyclones that hit Tutuila Island (Table 1) and similar event layers encountered in a previous study in Pago Pago Bay attributed to recent tsunami backwash deposits following the 2009 South Pacific tsunami and the 1960 Valdivia tsunami (Riou et al., 2020a(Riou et al., , 2020b, event layers AL1 to AL5 can be either interpreted as tsunami backwash deposits or cyclone-related flash-flood deposits (Srinivasalu et al., 2010;Sakuna et al., 2012;Pongpiachan et al., 2013;Veerasingam et al., 2014;Sakuna-Schwartz et al., 2015). As pointed out by Tamura et al. (2015), there are still no proxy kits allowing to distinguish tsunami backwash deposits from flash flood deposits and the attribution of a deposit to one or the other origin (tsunami vs flashflood) often relies on the chronological control. ...
... Based on these results, we found that all elemental species in the PM10 samples shared comparable spectral features. Although all PM10 samples showed relatively similar SXRF spectral distribution patterns in the photon energy range of 2-12 keV, noticeable comparative alterations can be magnified by calculating the first and second-order derivative of the raw spectra (Bhagavathy et al., 1991;Hong et al., 2019;Li et al., 2020;Pongpiachan et al., 2013). The calculation of the first-order derivative provides curves with peaks indicating the maximum alteration rate of the original spectral curves, while horizontal lines indicate no fluctuation in the slope of the spectral curves. ...
... Hikkaduwa district Jayawardana et al. (2012) 2004 IOT ---Major and trace elements, S, TOC Andaman Islands (Fig. 2d) AN-1 Andaman Islands Raja et al. (2009) 2004 IOT √ --Water-leachable ions Nayak et al. (2010) 2004 IOT √ --Exchangeable ions, forms of Fe Ilayaraja et al. (2012) 2004 IOT √ --Water-leachable ions, heavy metals, carbonates, TOC Velmurugan et al. (2015) 2004 IOT √ --Water-leachable ions Szczuciński et al. (2005Szczuciński et al. ( , 2007 2004 IOT √ --Water-leachable ions, acid-leachable metals, exchangeable As, total Hg Boszke et al. (2006) 2004 IOT √ --Hg fractionation Astel et al. (2008) 2004 IOT √ --Water-leachable ions, acid-leachable metals, forms of Hg, exchangeable metalloids Kozak et al. (2008) 2004 IOT √ --As speciation 2004 IOT √ --Acid-leachable trace elements Kozak et al. (2015) 2004 IOT √ --Acid-leachable metals, metalloids Kozak and Niedzielski (2013) 2004 Pongpiachan et al. (2013b) 2004 IOT --√ μ-SXRF spectra of elements Pongpiachan et al. (2013c) 2004 IOT √ -√ PAHs Pongpiachan (2014) 2004 IOT --√ PAHs Sakuna-Schwartz et al. (2015) 2004 IOT --√ Elemental counts TH-5 Patong Bay region, Szczuciński et al. (2005Szczuciński et al. ( , 2007 2004 IOT √ --Water-leachable ions, acid-leachable metals Phuket Island Exchangeable As, Hg Boszke et al. (2006) 2004 IOT √ --Hg fractionation Astel et al. (2008) 2004 IOT √ --Water-leachable ions, acid-leachable metals, forms of Hg, exchangeable metalloids Kozak et al. (2008) 2004 IOT √ --As speciation 2004 IOT √ --Acid-leachable trace elements Kozak et al. (2015) 2004 IOT √ --Acid-leachable metals, metalloids Zioła-Frankowska et al. (2009) 2004 IOT √ --Labile Al Kozak and Niedzielski (2013) 2004 metalloids, total organic carbon (TOC), nutrients, total nitrogen (TN), total phosphorus (TP), C/N, stable isotopes of C (δ 13 C), N (δ 15 N) and S (δ 34 S), biomarkers and other organic compounds, carbonates and recently palaeoDNA. Furthermore, 210 Pb and 137 Cs, which are generally used in radiometric dating, were applied as markers of a deposit in association with 134 Cs, and thus they are reported as chemical proxies here, mainly in the context of the 2011 FDNPP accident. ...
Article
Much progress has been made since the first published studies of tsunami deposits nearly 30 years ago. Geochemistry is now a much more widely used proxy in tsunami research, mainly due to its increasingly recognised value in the identification of historical and/or prehistorical deposits, at times even providing the conclusive proof when other proxies are missing or equivocal, but also its significance in environmental impact assessments following recent tsunamis. The rapid advance in analytical techniques has also made it a more approachable and popular method, as it is now most often faster and cheaper. Here we provide a review of the applications of geochemistry, including the techniques used, as well as a database of studies that used chemical proxies in their investigation of recent and old events, including onshore and offshore tsunami deposits. Chemical signatures are often used as markers of marine inundation, either as salinity indicators, where they can also allow the identification of the limit of tsunami inundation, or tracers of the incorporation of marine-sourced carbonates. Their applications as indicators of source material are nevertheless expanding, thereby potentially providing additional information on the hydrodynamic processes associated with tsunami inundation, although they are largely site-specific. The effects of post-depositional processes in different climatic regimes are examined, with a particular emphasis on water-leachable components and implications for post-event recovery of coastal ecosystems. We demonstrate the usefulness of chemical proxies in studies of the geological record of tsunamis extending back thousands of years, suggest new approaches and discuss limitations and existing knowledge gaps.
Chapter
The study area, El Palmar de Vejer, located in the Gulf of Cadiz in southwestern Spain, was severely struck by the AD 1755 Lisbon tsunami. El Palmar de Vejer was chosen as the study area due to the topographical setting, characterized by the flat alluvial floodplain, which has good preconditions as a sedimentary archive for tsunami deposits in order to gain a better understanding of the effects of the Lisbon tsunami based on previous studies and historical descriptions. The sedimentological and geochemical features indicate the processes of successive tsunami wash-overs and subsequent backwash and ponding conditions. An analysis of the major elements revealed a distinction between marine and terrestrial depositional environments. Using organic geochemistry, several different natural compounds were detected (e.g., n-alkanes and n-aldehydes), as well as some anthropogenic compounds (polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons). The results suggest a differentiation between the AD 1755 tsunami deposit and the lagoonal background sediments, thus making it possible to identify tsunami processes. The results of this study analyzing the sedimentary archive provide strong evidence that a multi-proxy approach, with the inclusion of geochemical applications, can confidently detect tsunami deposits, distinguish them from the surrounding background sediments and subsequently characterize their internal structure and composition.KeywordsAD 1755 Lisbon tsunamiGulf of CadizGeochemical signaturesEl Palmar de VejerTsunami wave cycleMulti-proxy analysis
Article
Full-text available
Previous studies highlighted the importance of soft indicators (e.g., quantitative sociological survey) influencing citizen satisfaction towards municipal service quality. Citizen satisfaction assessments have raised concerns over numerous independent parameters such as gender, age, and education on satisfaction levels toward administrative performance. It is also crucial to underline that the application of sociological survey for improving service quality is not well understood by municipal officers or scholars. To obtain substantial combined multiple indicators of service quality, it seems rationale to reconnoitre numerous parameters of citizen satisfaction and quantitatively investigate impacts of independent variables (e.g., gender, age, education) on corresponding satisfaction levels by using some advanced statistical tools. In this sociological assessment, a targeted population was constructed of Bangkok Metropolitan administration (BMA) stakeholders (n = 38,500), which are as follows: - Bangkok residents in 50 districts under the governance of BMA - Board committee, executive directors and general staff of 27 BMA offices This multiple dimensional analysis sociological survey data indicates that gender, age, and education play some important roles in governing municipal citizen satisfaction levels. Overall, the knowledge of relationship between citizen satisfaction levels and independent parameters can enhance the service quality of municipal administration.
Article
Full-text available
This manuscript provides some comprehensive technical insights regarding the application of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) characterized by using Gas-Chromatography Mass Spectrometry. Although numerous chemical species such as water soluble ionic species (e.g. Na þ , K þ , Cl À , Ca 2þ , Mg 2þ) and acid leachable heavy metal fractions (e.g. Fe, Cd, Al, Mo, Sb, As, Cu, Zn, Pb, and Mn) can be used to characterize tsunami deposits, the knowledge of PAH congeners as alternative chemical species for identifying tsunami backwash deposits is strictly limited. This manuscript is exclusive because it aims to find some alternative chemical proxies in order to distinguish tsunami backwash deposits from typical marine sediments. A wide range of diagnostic binary ratios of PAH congeners have been selected in order to characterize Typical Marine Sediments (TMS), Tsunami backwash deposits (TBD), Onshore Tsunami Deposits (OTD) and Coastal Zone Soils (CZS). The state of the art and future perspectives coupled with both advantages and disadvantages of above mentioned chemical tracers will be critically reviewed and further discussed.
Article
Reduction-oxidation (redox) reaction conditions, which are of great importance for the soil chemistry of coastal marshes, can be temporally dynamic. We present a transect of cores from northwest Florida wherein radical post-depositional changes in the redox regime has created atypical geochemical profiles at the bottom of the sedimentary column. The stratigraphy is consistent across the transect, consisting of, bottom upward, carbonate bedrock, a gray clay, an organic mud section, a dense clay layer, and an upper organic mud unit representing the current saltwater marsh. However, the geochemical signature of the lower organic mud unit suggests pervasive redox reactions, although the interval has been identified as representing a freshwater marsh, an unlikely environment for such conditions. Analyses indicate that this discrepancy results from post-depositional diagenesis driven by millennial-scale environmental parameters. Rising sea level that led to the deposition of the capping clay layer, created in anaerobic conditions in the freshwater swamp interval, and isolating it hydrologically from the rest of the sediment column. The subsequent infiltration of marine water into this organic material led to sulfate reduction, the buildup of H2S and FeS, and, first anoxic, and then euxinic conditions, marked by the precipitation of Fe, S and Mo, the hallmark of euxinic conditions. Because this chemical transformation occurred long after the original deposition the geochemical signature does not reflect soil chemistry at the time of deposition and cannot be used to infer syn-depositional environmental conditions, emphasizing the importance of recognizing diagenetic processes in paleoenvironmental studies.
Article
Full-text available
Tsunamis symbolize one of the most harmful natural disasters for low-lying coastal zones and their residents, due to both its destructive power and irregularity. The 2004 Boxing Day tsunami, which attack the Andaman Sea coast of Thailand, resulted 5,395 of deaths and inestimable casualties, interrupted economies and social well-being in numerous coastal villages and caused in extreme alterations of both onshore and offshore coastal morphology. The Great Indian Ocean tsunami also highlighted that there are many missing jigsaw puzzle pieces in scientific knowledge, starting from the generating of tsunamis offshore to the countless influences to the marine ecosystems on the continental shelf, coastal areas and on land and to the economic and social systems consequences. As with all deposits that do not have a direct physical link to their causative sources, marine tsunami deposits must be distinguished from other deposits through regional correlation, dating and criteria for recognition within the deposits themselves. This study aims to provide comprehensive reviews on using Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) as a chemical proxy to discriminate tsunami related Vol. 32, No. 4, page 236 (2013) deposits from typical marine sediments. The advantages and disadvantages of this chemical tracer will be critically reviewed and further discussed.
Article
Full-text available
A Small Angle X-ray Scattering (SAXS) beamline has been constructed at the Siam Pho-ton Laboratory (SPL) of the Synchrotron Light Research Institute (SLRI). The SAXS beam-line is dedicated for nano structural characterization of materials. The synchrotron light originated from a bending magnet is monochromatized using a Double Multilayer Monochro-mater (DMM) to provide x-ray in the energy range of 6–9 keV. A toroidal mirror is used to focus x-ray to the sample position. The experimental station is equipped with a CCD detector, in which the sample-detector distance can be extended to up to 4 m. The beamline has been commissioned and opened for users in March 2011. The commissioning result of the beamline, including SAXS measurement of nano particles, is presented.
Article
Full-text available
Tsunamis symbolize one of the most harmful natural disasters for low-lying coastal zones and their residents, due to both its destructive power and irregularity. The 2004 Boxing Day tsunami, which attack the Andaman Sea coast of Thailand, resulted 5,395 of deaths and inestimable casualties, interrupted economies and social well-being in numerous coastal villages and caused in extreme alterations of both onshore and offshore coastal morphology. The Great Indian Ocean tsunami also highlighted that there are many missing jigsaw puzzle pieces in scientific knowledge, starting from the generating of tsunamis offshore to the countless influences to the marine ecosystems on the continental shelf, coastal areas and on land and to the economic and social systems consequences. As with all deposits that do not have a direct physical link to their causative sources, marine tsunami deposits must be distinguished from other deposits through regional correlation, dating and criteria for recognition within the deposits themselves. This study aims to provide comprehensive reviews on using Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) as a chemical proxy to discriminate tsunami related Vol. 32, No. 4, page 236 (2013) deposits from typical marine sediments. The advantages and disadvantages of this chemical tracer will be critically reviewed and further discussed.
Article
Full-text available
Aceh, located in the northernmost area of Sumatra Island, is one of the regions that suffered the most damage from the Indian Ocean tsunami in 2004. The process of reconstruction after a large-scale disaster is considered an opportunity to create a safer society, especially for developing countries, however the accumulation of knowledge about how to improve reconstruction is insufficient. The affected areas have diverse social and economic characteristics and unprecedented restoration efforts have been made. The Indian Ocean tsunami disaster, therefore, provides numerous research opportunities, and many surveys and other researches have been conducted to better understand what happened and how the reconstruction process could be improved. However, the majority of such research has focused on housing reconstruction, rebuilding livelihoods and community rehabilitation and there has been only limited research on transportation-related issues. Thus, there is significance in evaluating the reconstruction of Aceh from a transportation perspective, a dimension that has yet to be examined systematically. As a first step in the effort to evaluate various aspects of the reconstruction of Aceh from a transportation perspective, this research aims to present three transportation-related issues within the reconstruction process—1) the road network in the Banda Aceh coastal area, 2) mobility in relocation sites, and 3) reconstruction of the Banda Aceh–Meulaboh road—and to conduct a preliminary analysis of these issues by adding the viewpoint of disaster management and reconstruction, the authors' area of specialization. For conducting a preliminary analysis, existing information such as research papers, articles and reports and data collected through interviews and field reconnaissance conducted by the authors were utilized as much as possible, and such “qualitative data” was analyzed by applying the “interpretive approach”, considered an appropriate analytical framework for qualitative data.
Article
Full-text available
Here we describe a chemical analysis technique for Ca, Fe, K, Sr, Ti, and S using a recently developed Micro-XRF analyzer (Micro-XRF) with a 100-μm resolution and an XRF whole-core scanner (XRF-S) with a 5-mm resolution for selected sediment sections from a continental margin sediment core. The Micro-XRF produces highly resolved element maps of individual sections, and the calculation of individual continuous element profiles is based on overlap measurements of successive sections. By means of discrete subsamples analyzed by ICP-OES, the two XRF data sets are successfully calibrated to provide quantitative profiles of Ca, Fe, K, Sr, and Ti. We discuss the advantages and limitations of both XRF techniques. A comparison of the two independent XRF data sets demonstrates the overall high consistency and accuracy of both techniques. The resulting element profiles and detailed XRF maps clearly show that the Micro-XRF is a powerful tool for studying at high resolution the chemical transitions linked to paleoenvironmental changes. For example, the discrimination between provenance changes and diagenetical effects on the Fe profile can be achieved by the combined inspection of the Fe/Ti profile and S maps. This highlights the usefulness of the XRF maps for clarification of profile ambiguities and clearly distinguishes the Micro-XRF from other technical devices producing elemental profiles only.
Article
Full-text available
The devastating December 26, 2004, tsunami produced abundant geologic effects along the Andaman coast of Thailand. The tsunami inundated the numerous sandy beaches and flowed over the adjacent aeolian dunes. On some of the dunes, the tsunami scoured circular holes 10-30 cm in diameter, and in its waning phases, it coated the holes with mud. The tsunami locally deposited a sand sheet that ranged from 0-30 cm in thickness, with an average thickness of approximately 10 cm. Sedimentary structures within the sand sheet include ripples from inflow and outflow, graded bedding, parallel lamination, and double-layered deposits. Erosion, locally severe, affected sand beaches and tidal inlets. We use these erosional and depositional features to infer the main processes that acted during inundation from the tsunami.
Article
Full-text available
Our paper presents selected short- and long-term environmental and geological impacts of the 26 December 2004 tsunami on the Andaman Sea coast of Thailand. The tsunami inundated the coastal zone more than 1.5 km inland and above 10 m a.s.l., causing coastal erosion mainly in the nearshore zone, beaches, river mouths and peninsulas. The tsunami runup was significantly influenced by nearshore bathymetry. Almost the entire inundation zone was covered with up to 0.5 m tsunami-laid sand and silty sand layer burying former soil. The layer has not eroded during subsequent rainy seasons and probably will be preserved in the geological record. The inland waters were salinated and the tsunami deposits were enriched in salts and bioavailable heavy metals and arsenic. Most of them were mobilized during rainy season. Sandy beaches - the most tsunami damaged coastal habitat, recovered quickly after the tsunami event. Also, most of the land vegetation recovered within one year after the tsunami.
Article
The 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami drastically altered the coastal zone of Aceh, Indonesia. Tsunami induced erosion of the coast, including aquaculture farms (tambak) and mangrove forests, destroyed livelihood opportunities and access to coastal resources. The following paper discusses impacts of the tsunami on coastal resources and the associated coastal and disaster management implications. Data is drawn from a time series of digitised mean high water marks (MHWM's) sourced from Google Earth imagery, along with areal measurements of tambak, mangrove and casuarina cover and qualitative interviews with local residents. Two sites, namely, the Banda Aceh west coast and Lhok Nga Bay were studied. The results reveal that within these study sites 68% of mangroves and 92% of tambak ponds have not recovered since the tsunami resulting in the loss of between 241 and 725 tambak livelihoods and mangrove supplied resources including food, wood and shelter. Unique coastal environments respond to, and recover from, tsunami differently depending on factors such as tsunami characteristics, wave climate, sediment supply, vegetation, morphology and level of pre-disturbance human modification. While the study supports recent findings that mangrove and casuarina forests do not substantially mitigate the impact of large tsunamis, it strongly encourages their conservation for the environmental and economic sustainability of coastal communities. The study recommends that better integrated management of coastal resources such as mangroves and tambak, considering disaster management, environmental and economic concerns, will strengthen the resiliency of vulnerable coastal communities such as those in Aceh to future disaster.
Article
This paper presents evidence of multiple tsunami impact on the Bay of Palairos-Pogonia, NW Greece, during the Holocene based on detailed geo-scientific studies. Altogether, 41 vibracores were drilled to detect high-energy influence in the stratigraphical record. Layers of coarse-grained allochthonous marine deposits were found intersecting autochthonous fine-grained back beach sediments in the Palairos coastal plain, on top of beach or marly bedrock units at Pogonia beach and along the Pogonia cliff section. High-energy deposits are associated with specific sedimentary structures such as fining upward sequences, rip up-clasts, basal erosional contact, bi- to multimodal grain size distribution, lamination, and co-existence of both well rounded and angular, sharply edged components, all of them typical of tsunami impact. Macro- and microfaunal analyses revealed tsunami-related input of numerous ex situ marine species and mostly angular shell debris into quiescent fresh- to brackish water environments by high-energy and long-distance transport. Geophysical methods helped to find subsurface structures and to seize the lateral extent of tsunami layers. Ca–Fe ratios derived from XRF measurements were used to trace tsunami influence inland. Most important is the widespread spatial distribution of the tsunamites with a lateral extent between 70 m at the Pogonia cliff section, 200 m at Pogonia beach, and 1 km in the central Palairos plain, and overall tendencies of fining and thinning towards inland. Highest elevations of tsunamites were found around Pogonia village at ca. 7.5 m a.s.l. Vibracore data give evidence that the overall coastal evolution has been strongly affected, locally even controlled by multiple high-energy impact.
Article
At Bangtao Beach, Phuket, the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami produced a repeated sequence in which rapid inflow of turbulent water was followed by ponding and then by gradual outflow. Photographs and eyewitness accounts show an initial withdrawal followed by series of inflows. The tsunami left behind a sand sheet as much as 25 cm thick that contains parallel, inclined, landward and seaward lamina in addition to the normal grading commonly reported from tsunami deposits. The sheet contains evidence for two times of vigorous inflow. Each of these is marked by mud rip-ups, medium to coarse sand that grades upward to fine, landward-inclined laminae, and a sharp basal contact. The top of the sand sheet, when observed in the first days after the tsunami, abounded in current dune and ripple bedforms of mostly landward orientation. The tsunami's first positive wave left no onshore sedimentary record in this pitting area. The second wave deposited sand that is much less extensive and slightly finer than that of the third wave. The deposit of both these waves contains multiple fining-upward sequences possibly due to multiple surges in one wave train. The depth-averaged flow velocity estimated from thickness and grain size are in the range 7–21 m/s, whereas, a near bottom threshold velocity calculated from bedforms reveals the order of magnitude difference from 1.74 to 1.03 m/s.