Brain Training Game Boosts Executive Functions, Working Memory and Processing Speed in the Young Adults: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Smart Ageing International Research Centre, Institute of Development, Aging and Cancer, Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan
PLoS ONE (Impact Factor: 3.23). 02/2013; 8(2):e55518. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0055518
Source: PubMed


Do brain training games work? The beneficial effects of brain training games are expected to transfer to other cognitive functions. Yet in all honesty, beneficial transfer effects of the commercial brain training games in young adults have little scientific basis. Here we investigated the impact of the brain training game (Brain Age) on a wide range of cognitive functions in young adults.
We conducted a double-blind (de facto masking) randomized controlled trial using a popular brain training game (Brain Age) and a popular puzzle game (Tetris). Thirty-two volunteers were recruited through an advertisement in the local newspaper and randomly assigned to either of two game groups (Brain Age, Tetris). Participants in both the Brain Age and the Tetris groups played their game for about 15 minutes per day, at least 5 days per week, for 4 weeks. Measures of the cognitive functions were conducted before and after training. Measures of the cognitive functions fell into eight categories (fluid intelligence, executive function, working memory, short-term memory, attention, processing speed, visual ability, and reading ability).
Our results showed that commercial brain training game improves executive functions, working memory, and processing speed in young adults. Moreover, the popular puzzle game can engender improvement attention and visuo-spatial ability compared to playing the brain training game. The present study showed the scientific evidence which the brain training game had the beneficial effects on cognitive functions (executive functions, working memory and processing speed) in the healthy young adults.
Our results do not indicate that everyone should play brain training games. However, the commercial brain training game might be a simple and convenient means to improve some cognitive functions. We believe that our findings are highly relevant to applications in educational and clinical fields.
UMIN Clinical Trial Registry 000005618.

Download full-text


Available from: Atsushi Sekiguchi
  • Source
    • "We posit that these effects might be enhanced in Airmen if the physical exercises being performed better replicated AF operational demands. This speculation is based on a theoretical extension of research supporting the efficacy of 'brain' training exercises for improving specific cognitive functions (e.g., executive function [4]), accompanied with research indicating that specific types of exercise, specifically those that require heightened concentration and/or the performance of complex motor skills such as Tai Chi [2] and agility drills [3], tend to be more effective for eliciting short-and long-term improvements in cognitive function. In particular, these latter findings hint that PT exercise requiring an explicit focus on mind-body interactions and/or the juggling of multiple performance goals (e.g., maintaining balance while building speed and explosive power in an agility ladder exercise), are more effective for eliciting improved cognitive function. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In today's high-intensity Air Force (AF) operations, Airmen are often required to perform demanding cognitive and physical tasks simultaneously, or in close concert (e.g., AF Explosive Ordinance Disposal) [1]. However, most AF physical training programs [e.g., squadron physical training (PT)] do not account for these operational requirements, and thus may not optimally instill the combined skills that are required of Airmen to perform their jobs efficiently and effectively. To address this issue, we have initiated a research and development program that seeks to create and validate specific exercises, routines, and comprehensive workout programs that integrate cognitive ('brain') training with contemporary PT exercises (e.g., performing body squats while concurrently tracking incoming information to improve lower body strength and working memory capacity). This initiative is inspired by, 1) findings indicating a positive relationship between specific modes of physical exercise (e.g., agility drills and Tai Chi) and cognitive performance (e.g., attention and working memory) [2, 3], 2) growing research interest in the effects and application of " brain training " [4], and 3) the AF's stated goal of developing personalized health and human performance technologies [5]. To accomplish this, we are currently developing training exercises and routines based on knowledge of operator physical and cognitive requirements obtained from quantitative and qualitative reports, surveys and interviews. These requirements are then distilled and paired in creative and practical ways to generate exercises and workout routines that can be instantiated effectively and efficiently into daily PT sessions performed in garrison at base fitness centers, at home, or down-range. Here, we share some of the exercises and routines we have developed, describe the philosophy and theoretical framework of our initiative, and provide a glimpse into future research in this area.
    Full-text · Conference Paper · Dec 2015
    • "For instance, if the child is in the avatar selection screen and sees the arrows, she " guesses " that by clicking on an arrow the screen will show the next (or the previous) possible avatar. Regarding mood, we would like to note that we measured it by observing positive mood signals such as smiling or laughing, children' verbal expressions of happiness, their weekly level of excitement or energy, their interest in the content being taught, etc. Table 5 includes a definition of all behavioral parameters used in this study, which have been also used in related research works (Boot, Kramer, Simons, Fabiani, & Gratton, 2008; Campigotto, McEwen, & Demmans Epp, 2013; Dobrowolski, Hanusz, Sobczyk, Skorko, & Wiatrow, 2015; Fern andez-L opez, Rodríguez-F ortiz, Rodríguez-Almendros, & Martínez-Segura, 2013; Helms & Sawtelle, 2007; Karal, Kokoç, & Ayyildiz, 2010; Martinovic, Burgess, Pomerleau, & Marin, 2015; Nouchi et al., 2013). Perceptual and cognitive observations, i.e., attention, memory, reasoning, easiness to handle the program, and intuition were included because engagement with music plays a major role in developing perceptual processing systems that facilitate the encoding and identification of speech sounds and patterns (Azizinezhad, Hashemi, & Darvishi, 2013), thus being used in other works from the related literature as mentioned above. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The use of Information and Communication Technologies (ICT) for students with special learning needs is being particularly studied by the research community. Likewise, music has gained recognition through the years in the field of learning disabilities, playing lately a key role in providing a better quality of life to people with special needs. However, there is still a gap on the combination of ICT and music teaching tools. In this work, we present the results of a case study where students with disabilities took a 3-month introductory music course using the multimedia tool called PLAIME (PLAtform for the Integration of handicapped children in Music Education) developed by the same authors. The aims of this work are three-fold: i) to explore the capability of disabled students to acquire musical knowledge using PLAIME, ii) to measure the improvement in their ICT skills, and iii) to observe their behavior along the study. At the end of the program, students showed an advance in their music knowledge and a positive improvement in behavioral development, being able to perfectly manage the computer platform.
    No preview · Article · Sep 2015 · Computers & Education
  • Source
    • "Dahlin et al., 2009 -0.19 [-1.09, 0.71] Salminen et al., 2012 -0.14 [-0.79, 0.51] Redick et al., 2012 -0.10 [-0.59, 0.39] Von Bastian et al., 2013b -0.02 [-0.45, 0.41] Sprenger et al., 2013 1 0.04 [-0.33, 0.41] Sprenger et al., 2013 2 0.05 [-0.32, 0.42] Jolles et al., 2010 0.08 [-0.65, 0.81] Schweizer et al., 2011 0.17 [-0.44, 0.78] Richmond et al., 2014 0.18 [-0.47, 0.83] Von Bastian et al., 2013a 0.20 [-0.29, 0.69] Chooi et al., 2012 0.22 [-0.25, 0.69] Takeuchi et al., 2011 0.39 [-0.20, 0.98] Brehmer et al., 2012 0.62 [0.07, 1.17] Heinzel et al., 2014 0.67 [-0.07, 1.41] Owens et al., 2013 0.71 [-0.15, 1.57] Nouchi et al., 2013 0.74 [0.01, 1.47] mean ES 0.06 [-0.14, 0.26] Zimmermann et al., 2014 -0.38 [-2.05, 1.29] Von Bastian et al., 2013a -0.07 [-0.60, 0.46] Theill et al., 2013 0.11 [-0.52, 0.74] Brehmer et al., 2012 0.17 [-0.42, 0.76] Borella et al., 2014 2 0.25 [-0.38, 0.88] Zinke et al., 2014 0.29 [-0.14, 0.72] Borella et al., 2014 1 0.31 [-0.32, 0.94] Nouchi et al., 2012 0.43 [-0.31, 1.17] Heinzel et al., 2014 0.45 [-0.28, 1.18] Borella et al., 2013 0.45 [-0.22, 1.12] Brehmer et al., 2011 0.52 [-0.32, 1.36] Zinke et al., 2011 0.60 [-0.07, 1.27] Stepankova et al., 2013 0.65 [0.14, 1.16] Borella et al., 2010 1.77 [1.03, 2.51] "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Deficits in working memory (WM) are commonly observed after brain injuries and cause severe impairments in patients' everyday life. It is still under debate if training can enhance or rehabilitate WM in case of malfunction. The current meta-analysis investigates this issue from a clinical point of view. It addresses under which conditions and for which target group WM training may be justifiable. Relevant WM training studies were identified by searching electronic literature databases with a comprehensive search term. In total, 103 studies, which added up to 112 independent group comparisons (N = 6,113 participants), were included in the analysis. Overall, WM training caused a moderate and long-lasting improvement in untrained WM tasks. Moreover, improvement of WM functioning led to sustainable better evaluation of everyday life functioning, however, effect sizes were small. Concerning transfer effects on other cognitive domains, long-lasting improvements with small effect sizes were observed in cognitive control and reasoning/intelligence. In contrast, small immediate, but no long-term effects were found for attention and long-term memory. Studies with brain injured patients demonstrated long-lasting improvements in WM functions with moderate to large effect sizes. A main moderator variable of intervention efficacy is the number of training sessions applied. WM training produces long-lasting beneficial effects which are strongly pronounced in patients with acquired brain injuries. This finding supports the application of WM training in clinical settings. To determine optimal training conditions, future studies must systematically investigate the characteristics of interventions as they are at present inevitably confounded. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2015 APA, all rights reserved).
    Full-text · Article · Aug 2015 · Neuropsychology
Show more