ArticlePDF Available

Perceived Effects of an MBA Degree on Employability and Career Advancement

Authors:

Abstract

Purpose Given this rapid expansion in business schools and MBA graduate numbers, the purpose of this paper is to assess whether and how graduate management education offered in Greece makes better managers. Design/methodology/approach To this purpose an empirical research was conducted, interviewing 68 MBA graduates from a Greek business school, to assess whether and to what extent, MBA training can influence managerial competencies, employability and career development. More specifically, the paper tests the hypotheses that gaining an MBA will: provide graduates with business‐related competencies; enhance graduates' employability; promote career advancement and lead to increased compensation. Findings Analyzing graduates' perceptions and attitudes, the findings indicate that MBA studies have a positive effect on skills, employability and compensation and a much moderate effect on career advancement. Research limitations/implications This is an exploratory study that seeks to analyze the self‐reports of a limited number of respondents. A large‐scale national survey involving graduates from numerous academic institutions across the country would result in a more comprehensive assessment of the effectiveness of MBA studies on managers in Greece. Practical implications This study has shown that an accredited MBA program seems to add value to graduates' managerial skills and employability in an ever‐changing labor market. Originality/value Given the dearth of empirical research on management education in Greece, this study contributes to debates in the wider academic community discussing the impact of MBA studies on managerial jobs.
RESEARCH NOTE
Perceived effects of an MBA
degree on employability and
career advancement
The case of Greece
Dimitrios M. Mihail and Kristina Antigoni Elefterie
University of Macedonia, Business Administration Department,
Thessaloniki, Greece
Abstract
Purpose Given this rapid expansion in business schools and MBA graduate numbers, the purpose
of this paper is to assess whether and how graduate management education offered in Greece makes
better managers.
Design/methodology/approach To this purpose an empirical research was conducted,
interviewing 68 MBA graduates from a Greek business school, to assess whether and to what
extent MBA training can influence managerial competencies, employability and career development.
More specifically, the paper tests the hypotheses that gaining an MBA will: provide graduates with
business-related competencies; enhance graduates’ employability; promote career advancement and
lead to increased compensation.
Findings Analyzing graduates’ perceptions and attitudes, the findings indicate that MBA studies
have a positive effect on skills, employability and compensation and a much moderate effect on career
advancement.
Research limitations/implications This is an exploratory study that seeks to analyze the
self-reports of a limited number of respondents. A large-scale national survey involving graduates
from numerous academic institutions across the country would result in a more comprehensive
assessment of the effectiveness of MBA studies on managers in Greece.
Practical implications This study has shown that an accredited MBA program seems to add
value to graduates’ managerial skills and employability in an ever-changing labor market.
Originality/value Given the dearth of empirical research on management education in Greece, this
study contributes to debates in the wider academic community discussing the impact of MBA studies
on managerial jobs.
Keywords Greece, Business studies, Master of business administration, Competences,
Career development
Paper type Research paper
Introduction
Greece is an example of an advancing economy in transition. Having made remarkable
progress towards macroeconomic convergence throughout the 1990s, Greece was
allowed to join the advanced European countries in shaping the European Monetary
Union (EMU). Thus Greece sets the example for other advancing European Union
countries like Slovenia, Hungary, the Czech Republic, and Poland that are aiming at
entering the Eurozone in the near future. For Greek firms, particularly the small and
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at
www.emeraldinsight.com/1362-0436.htm
CDI
11,4
352
Received October 2005
Revised January 2006
Accepted January 2006
Career Development International
Vol. 11 No. 4, 2006
pp. 352-361
qEmerald Group Publishing Limited
1362-0436
DOI 10.1108/13620430610672559
medium sized ones (SMEs) that constitute the cornerstone of the country’s economy,
the formidable challenge is to cope with ever increasing competitive pressures
emanating from the EMU, and in global markets more generally.
Greek firms are characterized by a dualism: on one side there is a class of
professionally managed firms, including the subsidiaries of multinationals, and on the
other side there are numerous SMEs, mostly family-owned, that have been
traditionally managed by their founders or by small proprietors (Makridakis et al.,
1997). Competing in the integrated European market has put a lot of pressure on small
company owners to reform organizational structures, placing emphasis on standard
rules and procedures for organizing business activities. In fact, in a recent empirical
study it was reported that Greek SMEs are characterized by a tendency towards
shaping formal managerial layers staffed with professional managers. It is evident, the
study concludes, that SMEs have abandoned the paternalistic management style and
they appear to “move towards a more professional management style by enhancing the
size and quality of managerial teams with the recruitment of well-educated
professionals” (Spanos et al., 2001, p. 644).
The Greek business community’s increasing demand for managers who have
acquired excellent managerial skills has led to an explosion in a demand for graduate
courses in management. After all, the conventional wisdom is that individuals with a
master’s degree in Business Administration (MBA) generally perform better in
managerial positions than those who do not hold an MBA degree (Baruch and Peiperl,
2000). Studying for an MBA appears to be a foolproof investment for a solid career in
corporate Greece, and as a result the reputation of MBA programs has soared over the
last decade. At the same time, trying to catch up with the increasing demand for
graduate management education, Greek academic institutions have been setting up
new MBA programs. While there was only one accredited MBA curriculum in the
country offered by the Athens University of Economics and Business up to the early
1990s, since then MBA programs have sprang up at an increasing rate across the
country. In the midst of these developments, fierce competition has surfaced over
market shares between public business schools the only eligible, according to law to
offer accredited MBAs in the country and the non-accredited private business
schools that built academic and economic affiliations with mostly British and
American universities in launching MBA programs.
Still the Greek case must be considered as a little piece of the whole European
picture. Such an increase in demand for management education at the graduate level
was experienced in the USA during the 1980s and in the European Union over the last
15 years (Hawksley, 1996). Of course, on the supply side, US business schools dominate
the international market with more than 600 MBA programs and 70,000 full-time
students. However, students’ enrolments in Europe have been increasing reaching
10,000 full-time and 15,000 part-time MBA students (Stern, 2002). There are more than
100 business schools in the UK, over 70 in France and 20 in Germany. In fact, if one
takes an example from Germany, they can detect a changing pattern of management
culture from one stressing the traditional specialist Diploma to one now emphasizing
the rising popularity for generalist MBA programs (Randlesome, 2000).
It is clear that today’s MBA graduates from Greek business schools enter the
country’s business community at an increasing rate. What is far less clear is whether
these newly established MBA programs have a significant impact on prospective
Perceived effects
of an MBA
degree
353
managers’ set of skills needed on graduation day. Actually, there is a remarkable
dearth of information concerning the added value of Greek MBAs to managerial
performance, employability and career advancement and this empirical study tries to
provide some insights into these issues. In the subsequent part of this contribution, the
research questions are stated. The paper continues by outlining the methodology of the
empirical research, and then presents and analyzes the main findings that are based on
perceptions and self-reports of the surveyed graduates. The main conclusions are
discussed in the last part of the study.
Theoretical background and research aims
An MBA program is explicitly aimed to add value to graduate students giving them
business-related knowledge and managerial skills. Empirical studies seem to lend
support for this contention. In the USA, Boyatzis and Renio (1989) have showed that an
MBA program had a significant positive effect on graduates’ managerial competencies
in areas of information analysis, quantitative analysis, and implementation of projects.
The program, though did not appear effective in enhancing soft skills, mainly
interpersonal skills such as building relationships with peers, managing or leading
people. Kretovics (1999) measured the learning outcomes of an MBA program. He
found that the MBA studies enhanced 12 skills related to business of its graduates
compared to entering students. The program was most effective on “hard” managerial
skills such as goal setting, information gathering, quantitative analysis, theory
application, technology application but also important for building interpersonal skills
such as help skills and ability to inspire and motivate others.
Sturges et al. (2003) assessed the impact of a Canadian MBA program on graduates’
competencies based on in-depth interviews with the students. They showed that
completing the program allowed the graduates to be more effective managers, with
knowledge of and access to a range of business techniques, but also helped improve
their self-confidence, people management and team working skills. Similar results were
found by Ishida (1997) surveying the alumni of the Graduate School of Business
Administration at Keio University that has been in the vanguard of business education
in Japan.
In the UK, Baruch and Peiperl (2000) demonstrated that gaining an MBA improved
graduates’ competencies. Some of these qualities and abilities were associated with
specific “hard” skills such as research and accounting skills whereas others were
concerned with general managerial competencies such as career management,
decision-making and working in teams. Equally interesting, this comparative study
concluded that MBA studies help graduates gain an advantage over other managers
with respect to skills needed in business. In another UK study, Baruch and Leeming
(2001) provide an assessment of the impact of an MBA of a leading UK management
school on the skills and career paths of its graduates. The results of the study support
the contention that MBA studies led to increased self-confidence, managerial skills,
employability and improved several aspects of career advancement.
Increasingly, however, both business press and academicians have raised questions
about the added value of graduate business education to graduates’ managerial skills
and competencies. Recent critiques such as those of Bennis and O’Toole (2005),
Mintzberg (2004), and Pfeffer and Fong (2002) point to the gap between theory and
practice, arguing that the knowledge and skills delivered by the MBA programs relate
CDI
11,4
354
poorly to practitioners’ needs. Some, such as Pfeffer and Fong (2002), suggest the gap is
due to irrelevant curriculum structure and teaching and along with Bennis and
O’Toole, who stress irrelevance of business school research, conclude that
management studies would benefit from emulating the most innovative law, medical
and other professional schools. The distorted structure of business curricula was
pinpointed previously in Porter and McKibbin’s (1988) study, according to which
analytical techniques received too much emphasis at the expense of leadership,
interpersonal and communication skills. Grey (2004) on the other hand, is attacking
traditional MBA studies by highlighting business school’s place in sustaining the
status quo and proposing an overtly politicized version of management education.
Yet there is little empirical research published to date on the relationship between
the knowledge acquired in MBA programs around the world, particularly from
non-elite schools, and managers’ competencies and career prospects. Hence, drawing
on Baruch and Peiperl (2000) and Baruch and Leeming (2001), the present study tries to
explore the extent to which graduates of accredited Greek MBA programs enhance
their business-related skills and gain career benefits in terms of management status,
promotions, pay, employability and career change. In light of this discussion, the
research questions for this study included the following:
RQ1. Would one enhance his/her managerial competencies completing an MBA
program offered by accredited Greek business schools?
RQ2. Would one improve his/her employability and job content completing an
MBA program offered by accredited Greek business schools?
RQ3. Would one promote his/her career advancement, including better
compensation completing an MBA program offered by accredited Greek
business schools?
Method
The surveyed MBA program
To examine the above mentioned three research questions a survey was designed
based on the perceptions and attitudes of graduates of a full-time MBA program
offered by the University of Macedonia, located in Thessaloniki, northern Greece. This
program started in 1994 and it is the second oldest in the country, after that offered by
Athens University of Economics and Business. These two MBA programs, combined
with that offered by the University of Piraeus, are the most widely known MBA
programs in the country that are accredited by the Greek Ministry of Education. It
must be noted that over the last decade, the MBA program offered by the University of
Macedonia was the only accredited one available in the entire region of northern
Greece, covering actually one-third of the Greek population. This MBA program
consists of two parts: a core, offering basic knowledge of management, technical skills
and quantitative methods that covers the first two semesters; and a second part,
consisting of four areas of concentration: finance, marketing, human resource
management and generic MBA, that covers the third semester and a Master’s thesis.
Subjects
The subjects of the survey were alumni of the MBA program, offered by the University
of Macedonia, who graduated from 1996 to 2002. The names, phone numbers, and
Perceived effects
of an MBA
degree
355
e-mail addresses were drawn from a list provided by the MBA’s Records Office. The
sample consisted of all graduates who attended the MBA program from its beginning
(1994) up to those who were enrolled in 2000 and graduated in 2002. Hence, the last
graduates have at least three years of working experience after graduation to assess
the MBA’s impact on skills, employability and career advancement. Over the last three
years, in many cases phone numbers and e-mails have changed so we were able to
establish contact with only 94 graduates from a population of 230 individuals. Hence, a
total of 94 questionnaires were e-mailed. A second mailing was sent two weeks later to
all non-respondents. A total of 68 questionnaires were returned for a total response rate
of 72 percent. This sample might appear small at first glance. Nevertheless, it must be
stressed that it includes about 30 percent of all graduates of the surveyed MBA
program from its beginning to 2002. The sample included 44 men and 24 women. More
than 70 percent of the respondents were between 26 and 34 years old.
Research tool
The use of a questionnaire as a research tool in the behavioral sciences, including
business and public administration disciplines, is widely acknowledged. This survey
that was based on a structured questionnaire, reports on former graduates’
self-perceptions on main aspects of the MBA studies working life nexus. In the
first part of the questionnaire through completion-type questions, graduates provided
information of demographic characteristics. In the second part, through a Likert-type
of scale (1: not at all to 5: completely), respondents were asked to evaluate their MBA’s
contribution to improving a list of managerial skills (Baruch and Leeming, 2001), in
enhancing their employability and improving career prospects including
compensation. Thus respondents’ self-reporting allowed us to analyze graduates’
attitudes and perceptions and examine closely the three research questions on added
value of an accredited MBA program.
Findings
Assessing the impact on competencies
So what makes for an effective MBA program in terms of skill enhancement? In
response to this question our participants were presented with a list of business-related
skills. Then they were asked to assess the need for those skills in their present job, and
the extent to which the MBA program had enhanced their competence in these skills.
However, we avoided asking graduates to evaluate their own competence in
business-related skills, considering such a question highly subjective, involving
serious personal bias. All responses were on a scale of 1-5 and Table I shows the mean
of the graduates’ evaluations.
The perceived skills needed in managerial careers are demonstrated by the data in
the second column. Correspondingly, in the third column the impact of the MBA on
these skills is shown. The graduates’ responses indicate that there is not a considerable
gap between the evaluation of skills needed in their present job and the evaluation of
the contribution attributed to the specific MBA program. Instead, both the perceived
need for the listed skills and the impact of MBA studies on managerial competencies
are relatively high, with values ranging in most cases between three and four, well
above the middle point three of the Likert scale.
CDI
11,4
356
Table I presents the needed skills in descending order. Time management, stress
management, interpersonal skills, self-confidence and written presentations are the five
top-rated categories of skills perceived as vital in a manager’s working environment.
Interestingly enough, it is found that these crucial categories of skills for managerial
careers are enhanced considerably by MBA studies, with pertinent evaluations ranging
from 3.4 to 3.8. As might be expected, the perceived impact of MBA studies is more
important in enhancing research skills (3.52), oral (3.72) and written presentation skills
(3.51), the ability to work in teams (3.77), along with boosting self-confidence (3.79)
(Sturges et al., 2003). On the other hand, the educational program apparently lags behind
and has a moderate impact on negotiating skills (2.83) and competency to manage other
people (2.87). Therefore, when it comes to comparing the perception of the added value of
an MBA, and the needed skills, there is not a perfect match. Still, what truly matters is a
whole array of skills necessary in managerial jobs, which have been found upgraded by
MBA studies offered in the country (Ishida, 1997; Kretovics, 1999).
Improving employability and job content
Our analysis of the impact of MBA studies on manager’s employability draws on
Kanter’s view of employability as an employee’s “increased value of internal and
external labor markets” (Kanter, 1989, p. 92). In modern dynamic corporate
environments, post-corporate career paths (Peiperl and Baruch, 1997) are conditioned
by a new more entrepreneurial employment relationship, which assumes that
managers are responsible for their own career and for increasing skills highly
transferable between companies or industries (O’Reilly and Chatman, 1994). On the
other hand, employing companies that replace gradually employment security with
employability need to match individual’s knowledge and competencies with job
opportunities that encompass rewarding and stimulating working conditions in order
to retain their best people (Ghoshal et al., 2001). Hence, in this part of the survey, we
attempt to gauge the main dimensions of employability and job content, including,
among other things, whether or not the MBA degree contributed to finding
employment with better working conditions, freedom of taking initiatives and
Skills
Perceived need for skills
in business
Perceived contribution
of MBA studies
Time management 4.23 3.41
Stress management 4.23 3.48
Interpersonal skills 4.11 3.44
Self-confidence 4.1 3.79
Written presentations 4.06 3.51
Decision making 3.84 3.47
Working in teams 3.83 3.77
Oral presentations 3.7 3.72
Negotiating skills 3.66 2.83
Financial skills 3.47 3.4
Research skills 3.39 3.52
Managing others 3.35 2.87
Career management 3.34 3.1
Average and standard deviation 3.78 (1.1) 3.4 (0.98)
Table I.
Enhancing competencies
in managerial skills
Perceived effects
of an MBA
degree
357
responsibilities, and job assignments with high recognition within the company.
Table II summarizes the findings with respect to the impact of the MBA program on
graduates’ employability and job content.
According to the participants in this study, an overwhelming 74 percent believe that
the MBA degree has contributed decisively to finding a new job with better
employment conditions after graduation. Improved employability is also discerned by
the relatively high evaluation (3.82) of the contribution of MBA studies on graduates’
ability to find a job after graduation (Cheng, 2000). Taking into account that most of
the respondents graduated a few years ago, the responses that indicate that one out of
three graduates have already found at least two new jobs point to enhanced
employability. In addition, only a negligible portion of participants (2.9 percent) who
tried to find a new employing firm after graduation have failed to do so.
A review of the data presented in the third column of Table II makes it evident that
graduates are able not only to find a new job but to successfully negotiate with new
employers more promising jobs. Indeed, young managers perceive that holding an
MBA was a relatively important factor in engaging in new work environments with
more responsibilities (3.79), more initiatives (3.44) and challenging project assignments
(3.85). These perceptions were expected though. Reasonably employing firms are
willing to trust and “empower” MBA graduates with a great deal of freedom and
responsibilities in order to keep individual managers aligned with the company’s quest
for quality and competitiveness.
Contributing to rewarding careers
Pay and promotion are widely accepted as being among the most important
mechanisms for motivating managerial employees. Data presented in Table III sheds
Number of different employers after graduation Percent
Perceived contribution of
MBA (means of scale 15)
0 2.9
1 47.1
2 32.9
3 12.9
4þ4.2
Finding jobs after graduation 3.82 (1.07)
Jobs requiring more responsibilities 3.79 (1.09)
Jobs allowing more initiatives 3.44 (1.19)
Job assignments with higher recognition 3.85 (0.82)
Table II.
Improving employability
and job content
Contribution to promotion pace Percent Contribution to pay raise Percent
None 20.5 Slight 16.3
Slow 10.3 Moderate 32.6
Moderate 28.2 Important 32.6
Fast 38.5 Very important 18.6
Very fast 2.6
Contribution on a scale 1-5 2.92 (1.2) Contribution on a scale 1-5 3.53 (0.98)
Table III.
The MBA contribution to
promotions and pay
CDI
11,4
358
light on the issue of the MBA studies’ contribution to tangible career rewards, such as
promotions and pay raises after graduation.
All the data presented in the first two columns of Table III point to a moderate
impact of MBA studies on promotion after graduation. About 20 percent of the
graduates have experienced a stagnant situation concerning promotion, while about 40
percent of them perceive slow or moderate chances of being promoted. The same
picture emerges when respondents evaluate the impact of their MBA studies on
promotions with a value that does not exceed the middle value of three on a scale 1-5.
Turning to pay raises, the relevant findings shown in Table III are slightly more
encouraging for young managers compared to promotion pace. Just over 50 percent of
the graduates believe that completing an MBA programme contributed significantly
(32.6 percent) or quite significantly (18.6) to pay raises after graduation. A similar
picture is depicted when graduates are asked to evaluate on a scale 1-5 the MBA
contribution to the pay raises that they received after graduation. The value 3.53 might
be above the middle value but it is not indicative by any means of a robust effect.
Conclusions
The main aim of this paper was to investigate graduates’ perceptions of relatively
newly established accredited MBA programs in Greece. Given the dearth of empirical
research on the impact of a Greek MBA on graduate careers, the aim of this paper was
to contribute to debates in the wider academic community on the issue of the added
value of MBA studies to young managers. It reports on an empirical study that
provides an assessment of the contribution of an accredited Greek MBA program to the
skills, employability and career development of its graduates.
The first research issue of this study was to test if the accredited MBA program of
the University of Macedonia provides graduates with stronger managerial skills.
Contrasting needed skills in managerial job positions with skills that have been
enhanced through the specific MBA programme, the conclusion that can be drawn is
that graduates reaped benefits from their studies.
The second research issue of this paper was to offer insights as to the bargaining
power of students after graduation in the labor market. Based both on the number of
different employers after graduation and on the respondents’ self-report on the MBA
contribution to find a new job, the findings suggest added value for MBA studies in
terms of graduates’ employability. Further, our results are indicative of enhanced
bargaining power in terms of job content, given that MBA studies allowed graduates to
negotiate successfully for more challenging jobs after their graduation.
The final research issue of this study was to test if challenging assignments and
augmented job responsibilities are balanced with increasing job rewards, in terms of
promotions and pay for our sample of MBA graduates. From our empirical account of
this matter, it seems evident that there is some match between higher job
responsibilities and pay raises. Still, the pace of promotions and graduates’ perceptions
on this job dimension indicates a moderate rather than robust career progress.
While the overall conclusion is that an accredited MBA program in Greece seems to
help graduates in pursuing their managerial careers, care should be taken when
extrapolating the results to the whole country. It is important for future research to
incorporate a wider range of graduates and academic institutions to enable
generalizations to be made for the impact of MBA programs throughout Greece.
Perceived effects
of an MBA
degree
359
Any further conclusions drawn from this research must be considered tentative as it
was based on a relatively small sample of respondents taken solely from a business
degree program. The subjects in this study were strictly graduates and the survey’s
findings were based on their perceptions on added value of an accredited MBA
program. To remedy this weakness further research should include more information
on the other side of the employment relationship, namely employing companies.
Furthermore, another limitation of the present study was that it did not survey a
“control” sample of individuals who did not complete an MBA program. Examining
attitudes of such a comparison group would definitely enhance the validity of this
exploratory study. These additional insights seem crucial if academic institutions and
government are to adjust the current accredited MBA programs to better meet the
business community’s increasing needs for talented, well-trained young managers.
References
Baruch, Y. and Leeming, A. (2001), “The added value of MBA studies-graduates’ perceptions”,
Personnel Review, Vol. 30 No. 5, pp. 589-601.
Baruch, Y. and Peiperl, M. (2000), “The impact of an MBA on graduate careers”, Human
Resource Management Journal, Vol. 10 No. 2, pp. 69-90.
Bennis, W. and O’Toole, J. (2005), “How business schools lost their way”, Harvard Business
Review, Vol. 83 No. 5, pp. 96-104.
Boyatzis, R. and Renio, A. (1989), “Research article: the impact of an MBA programme on
managerial abilities”, Journal of Management Development, Vol. 8 No. 5, pp. 66-77.
Cheng, E. (2000), “Test of the MBA knowledge and skills transfer”, The International Journal of
Human Resource Management, Vol. 11 No. 4, pp. 837-52.
Ghoshal, S., Moran, P. and Bartlett, C.A. (2001), “Employment security, employability and
sustainable competitive advantage”, in Gual, J. and Ricart, J. (Eds), Strategy, Organization
and the Changing Nature of Work, Edward Elgar, Northampton, MA.
Grey, C. (2004), “Reinventing business schools: the contribution of critical management
education”, Academy of Management Learning and Education, Vol. 3 No. 2, pp. 178-86.
Hawksley, F. (1996), “In the right place at the right time”, Accountancy, May, pp. 40-2.
Ishida, H. (1997), “MBA education in Japan: the experience of management education at the
Graduate School of Business Administration, Keio University, Japan”, Journal of
Management Development, Vol. 16 No. 3, pp. 185-96.
Kanter, R.M. (1989), “The new managerial work”, Harvard Business Review, Vol. 67 No. 6,
pp. 85-92.
Kretovics, M. (1999), “Assessing the MBA: what do our students learn?”, The Journal of
Management Development, Vol. 18 No. 2, pp. 125-36.
Makridakis, S., Caloghirou, Y., Papagiannakis, L. and Trivellas, P. (1997), “The dualism of Greek
firms and management: present state and future implications”, European Management
Journal, Vol. 15 No. 4, pp. 381-402.
Mintzberg, H. (2004), Managers not MBAs: A Hard Look at the Soft Practice of Managing and
Management Development, Berrett-Koehler Publications, San Francisco, CA.
O’Reilly, C.A. and Chatman, J.A. (1994), “Working smarter and harder: a longitudinal study of
managerial success”, Administrative Management Quarterly, Vol. 39 No. 4, pp. 603-27.
Peiperl, M. and Baruch, Y. (1997), “Back to square zero: the post-corporate career”,
Organizational Dynamics, Vol. 25 No. 4, pp. 7-22.
CDI
11,4
360
Pfeffer, J. and Fong, C. (2002), “The end of business schools? Less success than meets the eye”,
Academy of Management Learning and Education, Vol. 1 No. 1, pp. 78-95.
Porter, L. and McKibbin, L. (1988), Management Education and Development: Drift of Thrust into
the 21st Century?, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, NY.
Randlesome, C. (2000), “Changes in management culture and competencies: the German
experience”, Journal of Management Development, Vol. 19 No. 7, pp. 629-42.
Spanos, Y., Prastacos, G. and Papadakis, V. (2001), “Greek firms and EMU: contrasting SMEs
and large-sized enterprises”, European Management Journal, Vol. 19 No. 6, pp. 638-48.
Stern, S. (2002), “What did business school do for them?”, Management Today, February, pp. 40-5.
Sturges, J., Simpson, R. and Altman, Y. (2003), “Capitalising on learning: an exploration of the
MBA as a vehicle for developing career competencies”, International Journal of Training
and Development, Vol. 7 No. 1, pp. 53-66.
About the authors
Dimitrios M. Mihail is an Associate Professor at the University of Macedonia, Greece. He holds a
PhD in Economics. Department of Economics, The Graduate Faculty, New School University,
New York, USA. PhD dissertation: “Power, profits and industrial capital accumulation in
postwar Greece”. He teaches European industrial relations, and Greek industrial relations both in
the undergraduate and post-graduate programs of the Business Administration Department. His
research fields are industrial relations, labour economics, and European economic institutions.
His current research focuses on labour market flexibility, student employment and career
development issues. Dimitrios M. Mihail is the corresponding author and can be contacted at:
mihail@uom.gr
Kristina Elefterie holds an MBA. She is a PhD candidate at the University of Macedonia. Her
dissertation focuses on modeling the impact of management education, prior work experience
and social networking on managerial career. She is working under the supervision of Dr D. Mihail.
Perceived effects
of an MBA
degree
361
To purchase reprints of this article please e-mail: reprints@emeraldinsight.com
Or visit our web site for further details: www.emeraldinsight.com/reprints
... The influence of MBA GPA, pre-MBA work experiences, and ethnic backgrounds are absent in career development of the MBA graduates' [28]. The effect of MBA studies is positive on skills, employability and compensation, where a much moderate effect is observed on career advancement [29]. Besides increasing business knowledge and skills, an MBA education can have a positive effect on employeeemployer integration levels [30]. ...
... The corporate sector become interest to hire MBA graduates for their attributes to think analytically and strategically, complemented by leadership skills, quantitative skills and communication skills [4]. Many firms are willing to trust and "empower" MBA graduates with a great deal of freedom and responsibilities in order to keep individual managers aligned with the company's quest for quality and competitiveness [29]. Over the years, public and private organizations have sent their senior management to university executive programs, one of the primary sources of executive education with the aim of turning functional specialists into general managers [37]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Success of any organization mostly depends on the competent workforce of the organization. Competency refers to the qualities, skills and abilities which generally obtained by the individuals through participating in different formal training and education programs. Professionals are now more interested in enhancing their capabilities through gaining new knowledge and skills in meeting their job demand and career development. The professionals look for MBA, an advanced academic degree in management under business education seems essential qualification for becoming a successful manager. Professionals hope their betterment in job and career by admitting such educational programs. The objective of this paper is to review the literature for understanding the significance of MBA program on professionals' knowledge, skills and career development. Opportunities of MBA education on a part time basis considered as blessing for the job holders in developing their managerial knowledge, skills and career. The professionals aim in obtaining managerial knowledge and skills besides availing career development opportunities being a graduate of an MBA program. Therefore, the MBA graduates frequently claim that they have better managerial efficiencies than their non-MBA colleagues. Thus, the projected outcomes of the MBA degree attract most of the professionals to admit in this type of education programs.
... Individual motives for undertaking management education may emphasise career progression, learning and personal development (expanding individual human capital), building professional networks (expansion of social capital) or a combination. In the twentieth century, possession of an MBA qualification was seen as the passport to a lucrative career and rapid promotion (Baruch and Leeming, 2001;Mihail and Elefterie, 2006). More recent research (Byrne et al., 2017;GMAC, 2024) has found that MBA graduates can continue to expect significant salary increases and career progression after completing their degree, with many progressing into more senior leadership roles within their organisations. ...
... The program helps in providing industry-ready individuals to the corporates, driving the talent requirements of the corporates. Management education across the world has been designed to upgrade the skills of students by enriching them with the much-required business knowledge and managerial skills (Mihail and Elefterie, 2006). Besides MBA being a robust program, it is unable to serve the purpose for which it has been designed i.e preparing industry-ready individuals. ...
Article
Employability has been and is likely to be a primary concern for developing nations. The study has a twofold objective, to understand the concept of employability with antecedents of employability, secondly to explore the skills required to enhance the employability of B-school graduates in developing nations. A literature review has been undertaken to find out the factors impacting employability. Exploratory Factor Analysis has been utilized to explore the skills required by B-School graduates to be employable in developing nations with reference to Delhi/NCR, India. The paper will aid three stakeholders of employability, the academicians, the students, and the industry practitioners.
... It is evident that there is a higher number of male and female students aged 35 and below; the majority are full-time students pursuing postgraduate study, suggesting these students may see an MBA as a vital credential to gain more job opportunities upon graduation (Simpson,et al. [266]) and stay competitive in the job market (Edington, et al. [267][268][269]). There are more part-time students over 35 years pursuing an MBA who may consider career switching (Mark, et al. [270,271]) or obtain career advancement from their current employers (Baruch, et al. [272][273][274][275][276][277]). Descriptive Statistics and Significance Table 3 summarises the mean score and standard deviation for each of the 30 items in the AFEQ for undergraduates and postgraduates. ...
... Many firms offer a great deal of freedom and responsibilities to make the MBA graduates empowered (Mihail & Elefterie, 2006). Some of the respondents mentioned the need of power behind pursuing an MBA (Dailey, 2006). ...
... Literature has shown how it adds value as a profession (Baruch, 2009;Baruch & Peiperl, 2000;Kelan & Jones, 2009;Mihail & Kloutsiniotis, 2014). It has shown to improve career development prospects (Baruch & Leeming, 2001) and help in career advancement due augments in skills and employability (Mihail & Elefterie, 2006). Within the Indian context, it was shown that MBAs performed better in decision-making, strategic and systems skills, while possessing better business knowledge of managerial functions than non-MBAs (Saxena & Bendale, 2014). ...
Article
The B-school scenario in India is vast; with institutions in thousands, and hundreds of thousands in annual intake. Despite availability of ranking metrics, these portray only a partial picture of the top institutes alone, leaving the majority of Indian B-schools unmapped. The competitive arena for institutes is asymmetric, creating a problem with existing indexes as they do not aid aspirants or major stakeholders to make accurate estimates of institutional performance. Using secondary data from a statutory body (AICTE), the paper studies how this asymmetry is played out in aspects of graduate outcome performance- namely outturn and placement, as well as institutional financial performances within the context of a single state. Publicly available information from media and other intelligence reports have been further leveraged to augment facts. The study clusters institutes based on graduate outturn and placements into a vulnerability-risk grid, allowing accurate assessments of how B-schools are performing across a selected time-period. Financial risk assessment also helps in identifying the problem hotspots which require direct intervention. The paper is unique in its contribution to classifying risks among management institutes using a method which is scalable and adaptable. It identifies key imperatives to establish academic parity, by clustering deficit aspects based on the level of the b-schools performance.
... However, challenges such as language barriers, cultural assimilation, and variations in pedagogical approaches and academic benchmarks across regions and countries are among the obstacles that arise in the process of globalizing MBA education. Advancements in MBA education are propelled by the evolving characteristics of labor and the prospective landscape of employment (Mihail et al., 2006). In addition to more conventional management skills, business institutions are placing a greater emphasis on imparting competencies such as adaptability, resilience, and lifelong learning as automation, AI, and the gig economy proliferate. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article discusses Pakistan's MBA program development and impact. The report examines Pakistan's MBA education from its beginnings to its widespread adoption. Through academic sources, institution data, and industry interviews, this is achieved. MBA programs are driven by globalization, the company's need for managerial skills, and government efforts to boost higher education. The essay also covers Pakistani business schools' MBA programs, instructional methods, and accreditation systems. This study examines how MBA education affects students, employers, and society. The study uses qualitative and quantitative approaches to examine how Master of Business Administration degrees affect employment opportunities, managerial abilities, and socioeconomic situations. This paper analyzes Pakistani MBA schools' quality assurance, instructor shortage, and industry alignment issues. The study also examines how digitization, sustainability, and entrepreneurship may affect MBA education. This article discusses the impact of MBA programs on Pakistan's corporate environment and the purpose of increasing human capital. Research, collaboration, and creativity are essential to keeping MBA education relevant and effective in changing socioeconomic conditions, according to the statement.
... Additionally, Puhakka et al. (2010) conducted a large longitudinal study among 1294 recent graduates from various majors and revealed teamwork skills as few of the requisite skills needed in relation with their current work. Mihail and Elefterie (2006) investigated perception among management education graduates on the impact of undertaking an MBA course in assisting their current line of work. The findings revealed the course taken to have a positive impact on boosting their ability to work in a group. ...
Article
Full-text available
The construct of graduate employability (GE) has received a considerable attention from researchers and policy makers because of its importance in attaining the national economic agenda. Human resource management researchers have identified and examined several antecedents of employability. To date, some of the factors that have been considered include soft skills, communication skills and problem-solving skills, among others. Despite this research efforts, only few studies have attempted to consider the influence of psychological capital (PsyCap) on GE. Even if any, they have reported conflicting findings. Therefore, a moderating variable is suggested. This paper proposes grit as potential moderator on the relationship between PsyCap and graduate employability.
... After graduate studies, there were no graduates whose income is below 10,000, and there were additional five graduates whose income improved to 71,000 and above. According to Mihail and Elefterie (2006), MBA programs positively impact job performance, compensation, employability, and skills. According to Harvard's Business Review, it is no secret that those with graduate degrees earn significantly more money than those without. ...
Article
Full-text available
The success of any degree program being delivered by higher education institutions is measured using the employment performance of its graduates as they navigate the dynamic labor market after completion of their studies. The tool used to gauge this metric is known as a graduate tracer study. Thus, this explanatory sequential mixed methods study may provide the graduate school the baseline employment information, the extent of practice of program competencies and demonstration of graduate attributes of business management major graduates spanning the years 2017-2021 and their level of satisfaction with the graduate programs. The results revealed that outcomes were achieved by the graduates as the graduate degree contributes to their development of competencies and these graduates were extremely satisfied with the delivery and implementation of the programs. They also demonstrated the attributes in their workplace. The results of the study are consistent with the emerging framework of the quality delivery of business graduate programs. It upholds that the satisfaction of the graduates in the delivery, and instruction of the programs, will result in the development of competencies, unlocking of knowledge, skills, and abilities and improve the social and economic status of the graduates.
Chapter
Art is the lens through which we appreciate the world, and it can change how we experience it. Art has a vital role to play in building perspectives and relationships with various entities, groups, and individuals around us. Introducing art-based learning as a pedagogy in business school is a novel way of collaborating and discovering solutions for students. The current chapter presents different art-based pedagogical practices adopted to gradually sensitize students in their thoughts, behaviors, and relationships on various complex social issues, which would otherwise have been difficult using conventional lecture methods. This chapter is based on the application of art-based pedagogical experiences shared by faculty members at the Goa Institute of Management (GIM), India.
Article
Full-text available
We measure the effects of motivation and ability on the early career success of a sample of Master's of Business Administration (MBA) graduates in the early years of their careers. We argue that performance is a joint effect of two important individual characteristics: general cognitive ability and motivation. General cognitive ability, which is representative of the general population, refers to individual differences in tasks or pursuits that demand mental effort, such as abstraction, rule inference, generalization, and manipulating or transforming problems. Motivation is conceptualized as a stable mental state that energizes human behavior. Results show that the combination of high general cognitive ability and motivation is significantly associated with more early career success. MBAs who were both smarter and worked harder were more successful in their job search upon graduation, were earning higher salaries, had more rapid pay increases, and received more promotions in their early careers. These findings add to the mounting evidence that studying enduring individual characteristics is critical to predicting behavior.
Article
Integrating human genetics and brain coexpression patterns provides insight into autism pathogenesis.
Article
This article proposes a solution to the problems facing management education. The solution proposed is a body of thought called critical management education (CME). CME is that body of educational practice arising from a research tradition known as critical management studies (CMS). One barrier to the consideration of CME is that CME has mostly arisen and been most widely discussed and practiced not in the United States but in Europe, possibly because that is where a large number of new business schools have been founded in recent decades. Yet it is in the U.S. that the bulk of business schools, and the bulk of prestigious schools as well, are to be found. CME does require that one accepts the core claim of CMS of the unavoidable presence of values. It does not require that we all agree with CMS on what those values are. In view of implications for management education, they suggest that management needs always be taught in ways that explicitly acknowledge the political, ethical, and philosophical nature of its practice.
Article
The primary aim of this study is to contrast and identify differences in the ways by which SMEs and large firms have attempted to change their management practices in order to cope with the formidable challenges associated with competing in the EMU. Using survey data collected from leading Greek firms shortly before Greece's recent accession to the EMU, the study is an attempt to begin empirical work in this area by focusing on changes in competitive strategy, structure and management processes. The results indicate that both SMEs and large firms have initiated changes in all three dimensions. It seems, however, that the degree and direction of these responses depends on size; SMEs appear less able and/or less willing to implement change, perhaps because of size-related disadvantages.
Article
The goal of Master Business Administration (MBA) programmes is to add value to its graduates and make them better managers. Reports on a study which provides a comprehensive evaluation for the impact of an MBA programme of a leading UK business school on the competencies, skills, self-perception and careers of its graduates. The results demonstrate the value that these MBA studies generate for individuals and their employers. Based on responses of 344 graduates, now working managers, the output of the study clearly indicates the value they have gained from their MBA. This is seen in increased managerial skills, self-confidence and several aspects of career development.