Coevolution Trumps Pleiotropy: Carbon Assimilation Traits Are Independent of Metabolic Network Structure in Budding Yeast

Department of Ecology and Evolution, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, New York, United States of America.
PLoS ONE (Impact Factor: 3.23). 01/2013; 8(1):e54403. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0054403
Source: PubMed


Phenotypic traits may be gained and lost together because of pleiotropy, the involvement of common genes and networks, or because of simultaneous selection for multiple traits across environments (multiple-trait coevolution). However, the extent to which network pleiotropy versus environmental coevolution shapes shared responses has not been addressed. To test these alternatives, we took advantage of the fact that the genus Saccharomyces has variation in habitat usage and diversity in the carbon sources that a given strain can metabolize. We examined patterns of gain and loss in carbon utilization traits across 488 strains of Saccharomyces to investigate whether the structure of metabolic pathways or selection pressure from common environments may have caused carbon utilization traits to be gained and lost together. While most carbon sources were gained and lost independently of each other, we found four clusters that exhibit non-random patterns of gain and loss across strains. Contrary to the network pleiotropy hypothesis, we did not find that these patterns are explained by the structure of metabolic pathways or shared enzymes. Consistent with the hypothesis that common environments shape suites of phenotypes, we found that the environment a strain was isolated from partially predicts the carbon sources it can assimilate.

Download full-text


Available from: Joshua S Rest
  • Source
    • "Opulente et al. (2013) compared patterns of sugar consumption and structure of metabolic pathways in 488 different Saccharomyces strains. Based on this, the authors were able to 'partially predict' the substrate specificity of a strain based on the environment from which it was isolated (Opulente et al. 2013). Because S. cerevisiae has the metabolic capacity for sucrose consumption (Grossmann and Zimmermann 1979), one of the main questions that arise is: Where, in nature, does S. cerevisiae feed on sucrose? "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Sucrose is an abundant, readily available and inexpensive substrate for industrial biotechnology processes and its use is demonstrated with much success in the production of fuel ethanol in Brazil. Saccharomyces cerevisiae, which naturally evolved to efficiently consume sugars such as sucrose, is one of the most important cell factories due to its robustness, stress tolerance, genetic accessibility, simple nutrient requirements and long history as an industrial workhorse. This mini-review is focused on sucrose metabolism in S. cerevisiae, a rather unexplored subject in the scientific literature. An analysis of sucrose availability in nature and yeast sugar metabolism was performed, in order to understand the molecular background that makes S. cerevisiae consume this sugar efficiently. A historical overview on the use of sucrose and S. cerevisiae by humans is also presented considering sugarcane and sugarbeet as the main sources of this carbohydrate. Physiological aspects of sucrose consumption are compared with those concerning other economically relevant sugars. Also, metabolic engineering efforts to alter sucrose catabolism are presented in a chronological manner. In spite of its extensive use in yeast-based industries, a lot of basic and applied research on sucrose metabolism is imperative, mainly in fields such as genetics, physiology and metabolic engineering.
    Full-text · Article · Dec 2015 · FEMS Yeast Research
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: In this paper, using generating functions and combinatorial techniques, we extend Agoh and Dilcher’s quadratic recurrence formula for Bernoulli numbers in (Agoh and Dilcher in J. Number Theory 124:105-122, 2007) to Apostol-Bernoulli and Apostol-Euler polynomials and numbers. MSC: 11B68, 05A19.
    Preview · Article · Dec 2012 · Advances in Difference Equations
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Radical shifts to new natural and human made niches can make some functions unneeded and thus exposed to genetic degeneration. Here we ask not about highly specialized and rarely used functions but those relating to major life-history traits, rate of growth, and resistance to prolonged starvation. We found that in yeast each of the two traits was visibly impaired by at least several hundred individual gene deletions. There were relatively few deletions affecting negatively both traits and likely none harming one but improving the other. Functional profiles of gene deletions affecting either growth or survival were strikingly different: the first related chiefly to synthesis of macromolecules whereas the second to maintenance and recycling of cellular structures. The observed pattern of gene indispensability corresponds to that of gene induction, providing a rather rare example of agreement between the results of deletion and expression studies. We conclude that transitions to new environments in which the ability to grow at possibly fastest rate or survive under very long starvation become practically unnecessary can result in rapid erosion of these vital functions because they are coded by many genes constituting large mutational targets and because restricted pleiotropy is unlikely to constrain this process.
    No preview · Article · Nov 2013 · Evolution
Show more