ArticlePDF Available

Destruction of Atlantis by a great earthquake and tsunami? A geological analysis of the Spartel Bank hypothesis

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Numerous geographical similarities exist between Plato’s descriptions of Atlantis and a paleoisland (Spartel) in the western Straits of Gibraltar. The dialogues recount a cata- strophic event that submerged the island ca. 11.6 ka in a single day and night, due to violent earthquakes and floods. This sudden destruction is consistent with a great earth- quake (M 􏰂 8.5) and tsunami, as in the Gulf of Cadiz region in 1755 when tsunami run- up heights reached 10 m. Great earthquakes (M 8–9) and tsunamis occur in the Gulf of Cadiz with a repeat time of 1.5–2 k.y., according to the sedimentary record. An unusually thick turbidite dated as ca. 12 ka may coincide with the destructive event in Plato’s ac- count. The detailed morphology of Spartel paleoisland, as determined from recently ac- quired high-resolution bathymetric data, is reported here. The viability of human habi- tation on this paleoisland ca. 11.6 ka is discussed on the basis of a new bathymetric map.
Content may be subject to copyright.
q2005 Geological Society of America. For permission to copy, contact Copyright Permissions, GSA, or editing@geosociety.org.
Geology; August 2005; v. 33; no. 8; p. 685–688; doi: 10.1130/G21597.1; 5 figures. 685
Destruction of Atlantis by a great earthquake and tsunami? A
geological analysis of the Spartel Bank hypothesis
Marc-Andre´ Gutscher Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Institut Universitaire Europe´en de la Mer, Universite´de
Bretagne Occidentale, F-29280 Plouzane´ , France
ABSTRACT
Numerous geographical similarities exist between Plato’s descriptions of Atlantis and a
paleoisland (Spartel) in the western Straits of Gibraltar. The dialogues recount a cata-
strophic event that submerged the island ca. 11.6 ka in a single day and night, due to
violent earthquakes and floods. This sudden destruction is consistent with a great earth-
quake (M .8.5) and tsunami, as in the Gulf of Cadiz region in 1755 when tsunami run-
up heights reached 10 m. Great earthquakes (M 8–9) and tsunamis occur in the Gulf of
Cadiz with a repeat time of 1.5–2 k.y., according to the sedimentary record. Anunusually
thick turbidite dated as ca. 12 ka may coincide with the destructive event in Plato’s ac-
count. The detailed morphology of Spartel paleoisland, as determined from recently ac-
quired high-resolution bathymetric data, is reported here. The viability of human habi-
tation on this paleoisland ca. 11.6 ka is discussed on the basis of a new bathymetric map.
Keywords: earthquake, tsunami, Iberia, paleoseismology, geoarcheology.
Figure 1. A: Location map of south Iberian–Moroccan region with relief shaded (>200 m
light gray, >1000 m medium gray, >2000 m dark gray). Dimensions of coastal plain sur-
rounding Gulf of Cadiz are 450 3300 km, consistent with Plato’s description in
The
Critias
(3000 32000 stadia). Subduction fault plane (light shading) has been proposed
to be source of 1755 earthquake (Gutscher, 2004). B: Eustatic sea-level curve since 30
ka (after Labeyrie et al., 1987; Bard et al., 1996). C: Bathymetric map of western Straits
of Gibraltar showing paleoshoreline at 14.5 ka (2100 m contour). Modern shoals rising
to <100 m depth (shaded black) represent paleoislands, as pointed outby Collina-Girard
(2001, 2003, 2004), and form basis of Spartel Bank hypothesis.
INTRODUCTION
In recent years several studies have sought
to explain the origin of legends and myths
deeply rooted in ancient cultures in terms of
geological phenomena. Faulting and hydro-
carbon gas emissions were demonstrated to
have existed at the temple of Apollo in Del-
phi, Greece, and were reported in ancient doc-
uments to have influenced the oracle (Piccardi,
2000; de Boer et al., 2001). The paleogeog-
raphy of the ancient harbor of Illium (Troy)
was investigated using modern sedimentolog-
ical techniques (Kraft et al., 2003) and was
found to correspond closely to the Homeric
accounts. The recurrent deluge story (e.g., in
the Epic of Gilgamesh, Greek mythology, and
the Book of Genesis in the Old Testament) has
been interpreted in terms of the catastrophic
flooding of settlements along the Black Sea as
the Bosphorous spillway was breached ca.
5500 B.C. (Ryan and Pitman, 1998; Lerico-
lais, 2001). Several authors have attributed the
biblical accounts in Exodus (Old Testament)
to the catastrophic eruption of Santorini (The-
ra), Greece, ca. 1600 B.C., the ash falls of
which may have been the source of the
‘‘plague of darkness’’ in Egypt (Stanley and
Sheng, 1986; Bruins and van der Pflicht,
1996).
Archeological upheavals such as the decline
or disappearance of civilizations have been at-
tributed to severe natural disasters (e.g., vol-
canic eruptions and/or earthquakes). It has
been suggested that the abandoning and/or de-
struction of numerous cities in the eastern
Mediterranean ca. 1200 B.C. was partly due
to a sequence of destructive earthquakes (M
.6.5) along active plate boundaries (Nur and
Cline, 2000). The caldera and island collapse
of Thera-Santorini created tremendous ash
falls (Stanley and Sheng, 1986) and generated
a giant tsunami (McCoy and Heiken, 2000),
which has been blamed for the downfall of the
Minoan civilization. Some geologists and ar-
cheologists believe that this event may have
inspired the Atlantis legend (Galanopolous
and Bacon, 1969).
Geographical similarities between paleois-
lands in the western Straits of Gibraltar,which
existed during and shortly after the Last Gla-
cial Maximum (LGM), between 20 and 11 ka,
have been discussed (Collina-Girard, 2001). It
was proposed that their gradual inundation by
rising sea levels may have provided the basis
for the Atlantis legend (Collina-Girard, 2001),
and strong earthquakes (Lisbon, 1755) in the
region were also noted (Collina-Girard, 2003,
2004). The purpose of this paper is to examine
this Spartel Bank hypothesis in light of new
evidence on the tectonics and paleoseismolo-
gy of the Gulf of Cadiz–Straits of Gibraltar
region (Gutscher et al., 2002; Gutscher,2004).
New high-resolution bathymetric data from
Spartel paleoisland are presented, and the vi-
ability of human habitation on this paleoisland
between 14 and 9 ka is examined.
PLATO AND THE GEOGRAPHY AND
CHRONOLOGY OF ATLANTIS
The earliest surviving written records de-
scribing an ancient Atlantis culture are the di-
686 GEOLOGY, August 2005
Figure 2. Regional map showing effects of great Lisbon earthquake of
1 November 1755, with isoseismals shown in color (after Martinez-
Solares et al., 1979). Historically reported tsunami run-up heights are
shown (Baptista et al., 1998). Initial seafloor displacement for east-
dipping subduction fault plane is shown (Gutscher et al., 2005). Gorringe
Bank has also been proposed as source of 1755 earthquake (Johnston,
1996). Inset shows isoseismals in Europe and Africa (Johnston, 1996).
alogues of Plato, The Timaeus and The Critias
(Plato, 360 B.C.), wherein key details are
found concerning the geography and chronol-
ogy pertinent to the Spartel Bank hypothesis
and to the sudden destruction of Atlantis. Only
the most important elements are summed here;
an extensive discussion of the Spartel Bank
hypothesis can be found in Collina-Girard
(2001, 2003, 2004).
The chronology given by Plato indicates de-
struction of Atlantis ca. 11.6 ka, 9 k.y. before
Egyptian priests in Sais recounted the tale to
Solon. (Solon lived ca. 600 B.C.; Plato lived
from 420 to 340 B.C.). A small island is de-
scribed, located in the Atlantic beyond the
Straits of Gibraltar (Fig. 1A), ‘‘This power
came forth out of the Atlantic Ocean...and
there was an island situated in front of the
straits which are by you called the Pillars of
Heracles.’’ The distance to the center of the
island is given as 50 stadia, or ;7.5 km (1
stadium 5150 m). In The Timaeus, the sud-
den destruction is described: ‘‘there occurred
violent earthquakes and floods; and in a single
day and night of misfortune all your warlike
men in a body sank into the earth, and the
island of Atlantis in like manner disappeared
in the depths of the sea. For which reason the
sea in those parts is impassable and impene-
trable, because there is a shoal of mud in the
way; and this was caused by the subsidence
of the island.’’
SEA-LEVEL CHANGES AND THE
SPARTEL BANK HYPOTHESIS
During the LGM (20–15 ka), global eustat-
ic sea level was 130–100 m lower than present
and rose to 250 m by 11 ka (Labeyrie et al.,
1987; Bard et al., 1996) (Fig. 1B). Sea level
remained fairly stationary at ;265 m from
ca. 12.5 ka until 11.5 ka (Bard et al., 1996).
These eustatic sea-level changes were due to
melting of the ice sheets at the onset of the
most recent interglacial period.
In the western Straits of Gibraltar, several
shoals rise to within 50 m of sea level and
were islands prior to 11 ka (Collina-Girard,
2001). The largest of these paleoislands was
;5–6 km in size, and may be a candidate for
a formerly inhabited sunken island (Fig. 1C).
Both the effect of lower sea levels on the pa-
leocoastline and the presence of islands in the
western Straits of Gibraltar were discussed ex-
tensively as being the possible origin of the
Atlantis legend (Collina-Girard, 2001, 2003,
2004). The possibility of oral transmission of
this inundation event over a period of 6 k.y.
(until the advent of written records) was also
discussed at length (Collina-Girard 2001,
2003, 2004). The Spartel Bank hypothesis as
outlined in these studies emphasized gradual
destruction by inundation lasting several cen-
turies (due to a sea-level rise of 4 m per cen-
tury). However, the sudden destruction de-
scribed by Plato (in a single day and night)
requires a catastrophic event.
REGIONAL TECTONICS AND
PALEOSEISMOLOGY
On 1 November 1755, the great Lisbon
earthquake (estimated Mw 58.5–9) struck
southwest Iberia and northwest Morocco
(Johnston, 1996; Gutscher, 2004)(Fig. 2). Ob-
served intensities from Cadiz (Spain) and Tan-
giers (Morocco) were I 57, suggesting sim-
ilar intensities in the western Straits of
Gibraltar (Martinez-Solares et al., 1979; Lev-
ret, 1991). The associated tsunami devastated
the Gulf of Cadiz region, with reported run-
up heights exceeding 5 m for port cities in
southwest Iberia and northwest Morocco
(Baptista et al., 1998) (Fig. 2).
Recent evidence supports the existence of
an active subduction zone beneath the Gulf of
Cadiz and Straits of Gibraltar (Gutscher et al.,
2002; Gutscher, 2004), that poses a long-term
risk of great earthquakes (Fig. 3). The poten-
tial seismogenic zone, with mean dimensions
estimated as 180 3210 km, is capable of gen-
erating earthquakes of Mw 8.6–8.8 with a pe-
riodicity of 1–2 k.y. (Gutscher et al., 2005).
Tsunami modeling of a subduction source in-
dicates a strong focusing effect in the eastern
Gulf of Cadiz–Straits of Gibraltar area, which
amplifies wave heights (Gutscher et al., 2005).
This is in agreement with historical reports of
extreme wave heights (15 m in Cadiz, 17 m
in Tangiers) observed in nearby cities (Baptis-
ta et al., 1998).
Two different types of sedimentological
data from the Gulf of Cadiz area suggest that
great earthquakes and tsunamis occur with a
periodicity of 1.5–2 k.y. Coarse-grained
tsunami-induced deposits in the lagoon near
Cadiz correlate with the 1755 earthquake, and
indicate a tsunami height .6 m in order to
wash over the barrier of the sand bar (Luque
et al., 2001). An older coarse-grained deposit
is dated as 200 B.C., thus suggesting a period
of 2 k.y. (Luque et al., 2001). Sediment cores
from the Horseshoe abyssal plain (Lebreiro et
al., 1997) indicate 8 major turbidites since 12
ka, which may be markers of great earth-
quakes in the past (Fig. 3). The most recent
turbidite (H1) is 10–25 cm thick and has been
dated as being contemporaneous with the
1755 earthquake (Thomson and Weaver,
1994). If the turbidites record the history of
great earthquakes, then a repeat time of ;1.5
k.y. is indicated (Gutscher, 2004). Turbidite
H8 has a mean thickness of 50–120 cm and a
total estimated volume of 5.8 km
3
(Lebreiro
et al., 1997) (Fig. 3). It is the thickest of the
postglacial series and has been dated as 12.05
ka (Lebreiro et al., 1997). For comparison, the
turbidite associated with the great Lisbon
earthquake of 1755 has an estimated volume
of ;1km
3
.
NEW BATHYMETRIC DATA FROM
SPARTEL PALEOISLAND
In July 2003, high-resolution bathymetric
data from Spartel paleoisland were acquired
with R/V Le Suroit (Fig. 4). At the 130 m
depth contour (lowest sea-level stand during
the most recent glacial maximum ca. 20 ka),
GEOLOGY, August 2005 687
Figure 3. Left: Map of Gulf of Cadiz region; thickness of turbidite H8 in Horseshoeabyssal
plain is indicated (after Lebreiro et al., 1997). Core locations are shown by white circles and
major faults are shown as thick lines. Estimated depth to top of subducting plate is shown
(in kilometers). Right: Schematic stratigraphy based on cores from Horseshoe abyssal plain
(after Lebreiro et al., 1997).
Figure 5. Outline of Spartel paleoisland as
function of time and rising sea levels: left—
chronology based on eustatic sea-level var-
iations only; right—chronology assuming 40
m of tectonic subsidence since 12 ka.
Figure 4. High-resolu-
tion bathymetric map (5
m grid spacing) of
Spartel paleoisland.
Data were acquired by
R/V
Le Suroit
(using
Simrad EM300 multi-
beam system) in July
2003 during TV-GIB
cruise.
an island of 6.5 km length (ENE-WSW) and
4 km width was present (Fig. 5). This is much
smaller than the 14-km-long paleoisland sug-
gested in earlier studies, on the basis of less
accurate hydrographic and navigation maps of
the area (Collina-Girard, 2001, 2004).
The western and southern portions of the
paleoisland were flattest, and today present the
aspect of a paleoterrace at ;120 m water
depth that may record a prolonged sea-level
lowstand. The backbone of the paleoisland is
an ENE-trending ridge at ;60–90 m water
depth, with a second morphologic high situ-
ated to the SE. These highs are marked by
slightly curved parallel bands, likely outcrops
of strata, possibly folded sedimentary flysch
of the outer Betic and Rif allochthonous units.
The 120 m to 100 m depth contours outline a
reduced island of ;5 km length, with a shel-
tered bay, facing east toward the Mediterra-
nean (Figs. 4 and 5). The 90 m and 80 m
contours define a scattered archipelago, no
wider than a few hundred meters, consisting
only of the rocky ridges and not likely to be
hospitable to habitation (Fig. 5). Thus, assum-
ing only eustatic sea-level variations, Spartel
paleoisland would have been reduced to wave-
swept rocky islets by 13 ka at the latest
(Fig. 5).
DISCUSSION
One of the most remarkable coincidences is
that the type of destruction described by Plato
(in a single day and night, by violent earth-
quakes and floods) is a very accurate descrip-
tion of the sudden (catastrophic) destruction
associated with a great (M .8) earthquake.
In 1755, tsunami waves persisted for as long
as ;24 h (Baptista et al., 1998) and likewise
following the 26 December 2004, tsunami in
the Indian Ocean. The occurrence of this type
of earthquake and tsunami in the geographic
region chosen by Plato for his narrative ap-
pears to be more than just fortuitous.
The Gulf of Cadiz–Straits of Gibraltar re-
gion is above an east-dipping subduction zone
(Gutscher et al., 2002), apparently marked by
a wide locked seismogenic zone and a long
repeat interval (as much as 2 k.y.) between
great earthquakes (Gutscher, 2004). Subduc-
tion zones are environments of locally strong
uplift and strong subsidence. Coseismic sub-
sidence caused by great earthquakes in the
Cascadia forearc are reported to be 0.5–2 m
(Clague, 1997), and coseismic subsidence of
1–2 m was observed for the great Alaska
earthquake of 1964 (Holdahl and Sauber,
1994). During the great Sumatra earthquake of
December 2004, coastlines were significantly
changed through the combined effects of the
tsunami-induced erosion and local earthquake-
induced subsidence. Some low-lying islands
were partially submerged. Spartel paleoisland
is located in the foreland of the Betic-Rif
mountain belt. Land studies of Pliocene–
Quaternary marine terraces exposed along the
Spanish side of the Straits of Gibraltar suggest
continuing active tectonic uplift of the Internal
Betic-Rif units at a rate of ;1 mm/yr (Zazo
et al., 1999) and subsidence in the foreland
region.
Assuming only eustatic sea-level variation,
Spartel paleoisland would have been uninhab-
688 GEOLOGY, August 2005
itable at 11.6 ka (because it would have been
reduced to small rocky islets ,500 m in size;
see Fig. 5). In order for the island to have been
inhabitable at the time described in Plato’s di-
alogues, at least 40 m of total tectonic subsi-
dence must have affected the island since then
(which represents a mean subsidence rate of
3.5 mm/yr). In such a scenario, the 100 m
depth contour line would represent the paleo-
shoreline ca. 11.6 ka (Fig. 5). Subsidence of
40 m could possibly be explained by ;5m
of coseismic tectonic subsidence during each
of the 8 great earthquakes during the past 12
k.y. (the number of earthquakes indicated by
the turbidite record). This amount of subsi-
dence is greater than that known for compa-
rable tectonic settings (Cascadia, Alaska).
However, the presence of an additional crustal
fault may account for the remainder. Rapidly
subsiding and tectonically active regions like
the Gulf of Corinth, Greece (Armijo et al.,
1996), can exhibit modern-day subsidence at
rates .5 mm/yr.
If the earthquake ca. 11.6 ka was excep-
tionally large, as suggested by the great thick-
ness of turbidite H8 found in the Horseshoe
abyssal plain (Fig. 3), then perhaps as much
as 10 m of coseismic subsidence may have
occurred. If one then considers the added im-
pact of a 10-m-high tsunami wave (Fig. 2),
then everything within 20 m of the previous
sea level would have been obliterated. The re-
maining rocky islets, after the sudden and ir-
reversible 10 m immersion into the sea, would
bear little resemblance to the formerly 5-km-
long island with its east-facing bay (Fig. 5).
The combined effects of the continuing rise in
sea level and additional subsidence due to
earthquakes would completely submerge the
remnants within a few thousand years.
CONCLUSIONS
The high-resolution bathymetric data ac-
quired on Spartel Bank indicate a significantly
smaller island at the 130 m contour (6.5 km
34 km) than the 15-km-long island reported
in previous studies (Collina-Girard, 2001,
2003, 2004). Furthermore, assuming only eu-
static sea-level variation, Spartel paleoisland
would have been uninhabitable at 11.6 ka (two
small rocky islets ,500 m in size). Thus,
these new bathymetric data, taken alone, do
not confirm the Spartel Bank hypothesis; rath-
er, they render it highly unlikely. However,
taking into account strong tectonic subsidence
due to great earthquakes, and the sudden de-
struction by a great tsunami, the Spartel Bank
hypothesis may be viable. Although the cata-
strophic destruction described by Plato is con-
sistent with the geological and tectonic history
of the Straits of Gibraltar, this does not imply
that Atlantis ever existed. It simply means the
account is geologically plausible. The ques-
tion remains, was the paleoisland of Spartel
inhabited nearly 12 k.y. ago? In order to ob-
tain an answer, it will be necessary to conduct
a detailed survey of the seafloor in this area
and search for signs of construction or
artifacts.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I thank the Captain and crew of the R/V Le Su-
roit for their fine work during the cruise TV-GIB
and Graeme Cairns, Stephane Dominguez, and oth-
ers for their inspiration and direct participation. I
also thank David Fastovsky and Renee Hethering-
ton for constructive suggestions that helped clarify
the focus of this paper. This is contribution 948 of
the Institut Universitaire Europe´en de la Mer.
REFERENCES CITED
Armijo, R., Meyer, B., King, G.C.P., Rigo, A., and
Papanastassiou, D., 1996, Quaternary evolu-
tion of the Corinth Rift and implications for
the late Cenozoic evolution of the Aegean:
Geophysical Journal International, v. 126,
p. 11–53.
Baptista, M.A., Heitor, S., Miranda, J.M., Miranda,
P.M.A., and Mendes Victor, L., 1998, The
1755 Lisbon earthquake; evaluation of the tsu-
nami parameters: Journal of Geodynamics,
v. 25, p. 143–157.
Bard, E., Hamelin, B., Arnold, M., Montaggioni, L.,
Cabioch, G., Faure, G., and Rougerie, F.,
1996, Deglacial sea-level record from Tahiti
corals and the timing of global meltwater dis-
charge: Nature, v. 382, p. 241–244.
Bruins, H.J., and van der Pflicht, J., 1996, The Ex-
odus enigma: Nature, v. 382, p. 213–214.
Clague, J.J., 1997, Evidence for large earthquakes
at the Cascadia subduction zone: Reviews in
Geophysics, v. 35, p. 439–460.
Collina-Girard, J., 2001, Atlantis off the Gibraltar
Strait? Myth and geology: Paris, Acade´mie des
Sciences Comptes Rendus, v. 333, p. 233–240.
Collina-Girard, J., 2003, La transgression finiglaci-
aire, l’arche´ologie et les texts (exemple de la
grotte de Cosquer et du mythe de l’Atlantide):
CIESM Workshop Monographs, v. 24,
p. 63–70, www.ciesm.org/publications/
Santorini04.pdf.
Collina-Girard, J., 2004, Du vestige ge´ologique au
vestige litteraire, Gibraltar et l’Atlantide:
LUKHNOS Connaissances Helenniques,
v. 100, p. 9–21.
de Boer, J.Z., Hale, J.R., and Chanton, J., 2001,
New evidence for the geological origins of the
ancient Delphic oracle (Greece): Geology,
v. 29, p. 707–710.
Galanopolous, A.G., and Bacon, E., 1969, Atlantis:
The truth behind the legend: New York,
Bobbs-Merill, 216 p.
Gutscher, M.-A., 2004, What caused the Great
Lisbon earthquake?: Science, v. 305,
p. 1247–1248.
Gutscher, M.-A., Malod, J., Rehault, J.-P., Contruc-
ci, I., Klingelhoefer, F., Mendes-Victor, L., and
Spakman, W., 2002, Evidence for active sub-
duction beneath Gibraltar: Geology, v. 30,
p. 1071–1074.
Gutscher, M.-A., Baptista, M.A., and Miranda, J.M.,
2005, The Gibraltar Arc seismogenic zone
(part 2): Constraints on a shallow east-dipping
fault plane source for the 1755 Lisbon earth-
quake provided by tsunami modeling and seis-
mic intensity: Tectonophysics (in press).
Holdahl, S.R., and Sauber, J., 1994, Co-seismic slip
in the 1964 Prince William Sound earthquake:
A new geodetic inversion: Pure and Applied
Geophysics, v. 142, p. 55–81.
Johnston, A., 1996, Seismic moment assessment of
earthquakes in stable continental regions—III.
New Madrid, 1811–1812, Charleston 1886
and Lisbon 1755: Geophysical Journal Inter-
national, v. 126, p. 314–344.
Kraft, J.C., Rapp, G., Kayan, I., and Luce, J.V.,
2003, Harbor areas at ancient Troy: Sedimen-
tology and geomorphology complement Ho-
mer’s Illiad: Geology, v. 31, p. 163–166.
Labeyrie, L.D., Duplessey, J.C., and Blanc, P.L.,
1987, Variations in the mode of formation and
temperature of oceanic deep waters over
the past 125,000 years: Nature, v. 327,
p. 477–482.
Lebreiro, S.M., McCave, I.N., and Weaver, P., 1997,
Late Quaternary turbidite emplacement on the
Horseshoe abyssal plain (Iberian margin):
Journal of Sedimentary Research, v. 67,
p. 856–870.
Lericolais, G., 2001, La catastrophe du Bosphore:
Pour la Science, v. 284, p. 30–37.
Levret, A., 1991, The effects of the November 1,
1755 ‘‘Lisbon’’ earthquake in Morocco: Tec-
tonophysics, v. 193, p. 83–94.
Luque, L., Lario, J., Zazo, C., Goy, J.L., Dabrio,
C.J., and Silva, P.G., 2001, Tsunami deposits
as paleoseismic indicators: Examples from the
Spanish coast: Acta Geologica Hispanica,
v. 36, p. 197–211.
Martinez-Solares, J.M., Lopez, A., and Mezcua, J.,
1979, Isoseismal map of the 1755 Lisbon
earthquake obtained from Spanish data: Tec-
tonophysics, v. 53, p. 301–313.
McCoy, F.W., and Heiken, G., 2000, Tsunami gen-
erated by the late Bronze Age eruption of The-
ra (Santorini), Greece, in Keating, B.H., et al.,
eds., Landslides and tsunamis: Pure and Ap-
plied Geophysics, 157, p. 1227–1256.
Nur, A., and Cline, E.H., 2000, Poseidon’s horses:
Plate tectonics and earthquake storms in the
late Bronze Age Aegean and Eastern Mediter-
ranean: Journal of Archaeological Science,
v. 27, p. 43–63.
Piccardi, L., 2000, Active faulting at Delphi,
Greece: Seismotectonic remarks and a hypoth-
esis for the geologic environment of a myth:
Geology, v. 28, p. 651–654.
Ryan, W., and Pitman, W., 1998, Noah’s flood: The
new scientific discoveries about the event that
changed history: New York, Simon and
Schuster, 319 p.
Stanley, D.J., and Sheng, H., 1986, Volcanic shards
from Santorini (Upper Minoan ash) in the Nile
Delta, Egypt: Nature, v. 360, p. 733–734.
Thomson, J., and Weaver, P., 1994, An AMS radio-
carbon method to determine the emplacement
time of recent deep-sea turbidites: Sedimen-
tary Geology, v. 89, p. 1–7.
Zazo, C., Silva, P.G., Roy, J.L., Hillaire-Marcel, C.,
Ghaleb, B., Lario, J., Bardaji, T., and Gonza-
lez, A., 1999, Coastal uplift in continental col-
lision plate boundaries: Data from the last in-
terglacial marine terraces of the Gibraltar
Strait area (south Spain): Tectonophysics,
v. 301, p. 95–109.
Manuscript received 21 February 2005
Revised manuscript received 4 April 2005
Manuscript accepted 18 April 2005
Printed in USA
... Ces platesformes, sculptées dans des bancs de grès à facies numidien, correspondent à des niveaux de stationnements marins du Pléistocène et de l'Holocène (35-40 m ; 15-20 m ; 10-12 m et 2-4 m). La préservation de rasas aux altitudes de 35-40 m et 15-20 m est liée, sans doute, au soulèvement continu qu'a connu le secteur du cap Spartel au cours du Quaternaire (Alouane 2001).Cette néotectonique est considérée, par les adeptes de la véracité de l'Atlantide, comme un argument de sa localisation au niveau de Gibraltar, plus précisément au large du cap Spartel(Collina-Girard 2001, 2002, Gutscher 2005. De l'avis de certains auteurs, les hauts-fonds des cartes bathymétriques à l'ouest du détroit de Gibraltar formaient des îlots durant le Pléistocène terminal. ...
Article
Full-text available
Cape Spartel is known by the oldest lighthouse in Morocco. It was known since prehistoric times, as evidenced by the sites of Cape Achakar 4 km to the south
... Paleogeographic reconstmctions indicate that the minimum width of the strait in the Pleistocene would have been 8-10 km (Shackleton et aI. 1984;Collina-G irard 2001 ;Gutscher 2005 ;Gracia et aI. 2008). ...
Article
Full-text available
New finds of bones of the Egyptian Mongoose (Herpestes ichneumon), one from Portugal and one from Spain, were directly ¹⁴C dated to the first century AD. While the Portuguese specimen was found without connection to the Chalcolithic occupation of the Pedra Furada cave where it was recovered, the Spanish find, collected in the city of Mérida, comes from a ritual pit that also contained three human and 40 dog burials. The finds reported here show that the Egyptian mongoose, contrary to the traditional and predominant view, did not first arrive in the Iberian Peninsula during the Muslim occupation of Iberia. Instead, our findings are consistent with the hypothesis that the species was first introduced by the Romans, or at least sometime during the Roman occupation of Hispania. Therefore, radiocarbon dating of new archaeological finds of bones of the Egyptian Mongoose (Herpestes ichneumon) in the Iberian Peninsula push back the confirmed presence of the species in the region by approximately eight centuries, as the previously oldest dated record is from the ninth century. With these new dates, there are now a total of four ¹⁴C dated specimens of Egyptian mongooses from the Iberian Peninsula, and all of these dates fall within the last 2000 years. This offers support for the hypothesis that the presence of the species in Iberia is due to historical introductions and is at odds with a scenario of natural sweepstake dispersal across the Straits of Gibraltar in the Late Pleistocene (126,000–11,700 years ago), recently proposed based on genetic data.
... Many historians discount Plato's statements as a mere instructional tale whilst a few geoscientists have opted, for sound reasons, for Atlantis' possible existence thousands of years ago at a site within the greater Gibraltar Strait: during the late-Ice Age, about 21,000 to 19,000 years ago, the western part of Gibraltar Strait actually had a 70 square kilometer island ("Spartel Island") which was later submerged about 11,000 years ago by rising sea-level. Two prominent modern geoscientists have outlined on bathymetric charts the location for a now lost Atlantis landscape, Spartel Bank, and postulated that rising sea-level and a spate of tremendous tsunamis may have plagued the human inhabitants of Spartel Island to sudden extinction (Collina-Girard, 2001;Gutscher, 2005). Tsunamis are well-known occurrences within the Basin. ...
... But then how can we account Atlantis' catastrophe? The answer came at the Melos International Symposium as thunder when Gutscher (2005) a C.N.R.S geologist pointed very clearly that the mechanism of Atlantis', which Plato described, can be fully explained in terms of geology and seismotectonics at the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean in the region west of Gibraltar. In his opinion the seismogenous fault called Gorringe Bank, situated about 6 degrees west of Gibraltar, produces earthquakes with a frequency of about 1.200-1.500 ...
Article
Full-text available
Plato described the end of Atlantis very vividly in a single day and night due to earthquakes and floods and nobody believed him because all experts imagined the impossibility of the giant island’s continental size in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean to vanish in 24 hours. They did not care to understand that Plato meant three different geographic and geological entities all called by him Atlantis which were the giant island, the horseshow basin and the concentric rater. Following Plato’s text that giant island was identified as the peninsula of Portugal-Spain and its northern extend. They did not even care to interpret correctly a genuine myth’s kernel which belonged in the end of the Bronze Age considering the island’s change of meaning versus time from prehistory to history both for the Egyptian and the Greek language up to Solon’s visit in Egypt in the 6th century B.C. This, mentioned above negligence, produced delay in understanding a complex problem which required a very good geological background besides other trans-scientific knowledge in archaeology, philology, mythology and mathematics in order to be faced properly. The loss of a nature made multi-ringed crater, which Plato also called Atlantis, in Andalusia’s palaecoast in the end of the Bronze Age due to earthquakes, a tsunami and land slide constitutes the end of Atlantis.
... Yalciner et al. [64] and Leroy et al. [65] have documented and discussed tsunami events in the Marmara Sea since the late Holocene. A similar study was also published for the central Atlantic region offshore of Gibraltar (Gutscher [66]). ...
Article
Full-text available
Mehrotra et al. [1] reported the presence of reworked Carboniferous terrestrial palynomorphs ( spores and pollen) in the Panna Formation (Paleocene-Early Eocene) of the Mumbai Offshore Basin. This was a puzzling discovery because Carboniferous sediments are not known to occur in peninsular India. Although Carboniferous sediments are present in the Himalayas, they are predominantly of marine origin. The Himalayan sediments have yielded extremely poor palynomorphs and have little in common with the reworked assemblage of Carboniferous palynomorphs from the Panna Formation. Mehrotra et al. [1] offered two possibilities for this occurrence. Firstly, they speculated on the existence of Carboniferous sediments under the widespread flood basalts of central India known as the Deccan Traps, and hypothesized their erosion and re-deposition in the Panna Formation. Secondly, they speculated that the reworked palynomorphs might have been derived from Carboniferous sediments of the Africa-Arabia regions by waves. However, to date there is no proof of the presence of Carboniferous sediments under the Deccan Traps. Furthermore, the authors did not propose any explanation regarding the kind of wave action that might have been responsible for transporting Carboniferous palynomorphs from the vast regions of Africa-Arabia to the Mumbai Offshore Basin. This paper offers a hypothesis that may explain the presence of reworked Carboniferous palynomorphs in the Panna Formation of the Mumbai Offshore Basin, India. About 65 Ma ago, at a time roughly coincident with the Cretaceous-Tertiary (K-T) boundary, a bolide approximately 40 km in diameter struck the western shelf of India a few hundred kilometers off the coast of present day Mumbai, India. The impact created a giant and complex multiring crater with several roughly concentric highs and lows, known today as the Shiva Crater (Chatterjee et al. [2]). This catastrophic event likely generated mega-tsunamis that traveled in all directions and severely impacted the coastlines of western India and eastern Africa, as well as the southern and eastern coasts of the Arabian Peninsula. The northwestward moving mega-tsunami waves impacted the Arabian continental shelf and coastal regions. These giant waves traveled across the lowlands of the Arabian Peninsula until they encountered the eastern and southern margins of the Arabian Shield. The mega-tsunami waves then reflected and refracted back in the northeastern, eastern, and southeastern directions after impacting the Arabian Shield. These waves severely scoured and eroded the exposed Carboniferous strata of the Arabian Peninsula. All these Carboniferous stratigraphic units are known to contain rich terrestrial palynomorph assemblages. In addition, all reworked Carboniferous palynomorphs found in the Panna Formation occur also in the Carboniferous sediments of the Arabian Peninsula. It is suggested that the mega-tsunami triggered turbidity currents, which carried with them eroded Carboniferous fine sediments and associated palynomorphs from the Arabian Peninsula and deposited them in the sediments that formed the Panna Formation upon reaching the Mumbai Offshore Basin. It is also possible that turbidity currents may have continued to transport these Arabian palynomorphs into the Shiva marine low for centuries following the bolide event, explaining the occurrence of Carboniferous palynomorphs at multiple levels in the Panna Formation.
... The connection of earthquakes, tsunamis and turbidites also includes literature on turbidites (triggered by land failures) triggered by earthquakes, sometimes known as "seismoturbidites" (Mutti et al., 1984). In addition to the Grand Banks case (Piper et al., 1988), such deposits have been described by Adams (1990) from cores in the Cascadia deep-sea channel off the Washington and Oregon coastline and interpreted as evidence for up to 13 prehistoric earthquakes since ~7000 B.P. Nakajima and Kanai (2000) described submarine land failures triggered by the 1983 Japan Sea earthquake as well as prehistoric cases where turbidites are inferred to be proxies for earthquakes (see also Doig, 1990;Inouchi et al., 1996;Goldfinger et al., 2003;Gutscher, 2005;McHugh et al., 2006). All the historic cases considered were also tsunamigenic, and submarine landslides produce tsunamis, but a direct genitive link between tsunamis and turbidity currents is difficult to document. ...
Article
This book is an overview of the state-of-the art developments in sedimentology of tsunami-induced and tsunami-affected deposits, namely tsunamiites. It also points out any problems that need additional investigation, as well as providing insight into the direction of future tsunamiite researches. Important characteristics of tsunami wave and tsunami currents are explained. There are reports on the sediments generated by recent tsunami including the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami presented. Tsunamiites induced by other seismic activities, a submarine slump and a volcanic eruption are investigated as well. Several contributions in this book present new ideas concerning the characteristic sedimentary records of tsunamis and provide the criteria for recognizing features of various tsunamiites. The importance of studies of bedforms of tsunamiites from various environments is emphasized. New information is provided on tsunami-derived boulder deposits. The significance of studies on tsunamiites in the archeological and geological past is also illustrated in this book. For example, the Mediterranean homogenites, and the K/T boundary meteorite impact-induced tsunamiites have been investigated from new aspects. * Provides a comprehensive overview of developments in tsunamiites * Investigates future trends and development needs * Cutting edge research articles from leading experts aimed at researchers and scientists.
Chapter
It is demonstrated that ancient sources, prior to Plato, mentioned a sacredcircular entity somewhere West of Gibraltar. Homer in the 8th, Hesiod in the 7th BC, Pindar and Hellanicus in the 5th centuries respectively also wrote about it. We do not expect to read the name Atlantisin their texts, since it was invented by Plato as he clearly declares. We know that in the Euro-African region, west of Gibraltar, both in North West Africa and South West Iberia there are several submerged craters which are products of diapyrism. Some of them in Cadiz's bay are large. At least a small one is visible in Andalusia. We explore the case of ancient Erytheia mentioned in early ancient Greek texts as a vanished red island. We propose that in Andalusia's palaeocoast of 1200 BC, a nature-made circularityexisted. In the past, it served once as a religious, cultural site for the nearby maritime prehistoric populations. It was associated with Ibero-Mauretian and Tartessian culture. It was understood, due to its circular shape, by the visiting prehistoric Greeks, as Poseidon's work. It vanished together with Achaeans and Atlantesafter earthquakes and floods. Atlantis' giant islandis Germano-Celto-Iberia, since the concept of the island in prehistory in either Greek or Egyptian was not that of the 5th century BC, because Herodotus added the word peninsulafor the first time. The mythological part of Iberia reflects Heracles' activities. In other words, it reflects the collective unconscious of the prehistoric and historic Greeks in that region of the world. We note the first archaeological finding of an Achaean shard close to Guadalquivir's estuary. Plato's Atlantesis a remote strange and deformed incomplete echo of Sea Peoples' second assault against East Mediterranean countries. The giant continent West of Gibraltar was known to the Egyptians prior to 6th century BC, because of the trade of unique products existing only in South America. In other words, Plato's story about Atlantisbegins to be comprehensible and gradually proved.
Article
Full-text available
An archipelago, facing Gibraltar Strait was submerged 9′000 years BC. This history fits exactly with the egyptian tradition, basis of the history of Atlantis in the text of Plato: "Timaeus". During late glacial period prehistoric hunter-gatherers were constraint to adapt rapidly to a main reduction of their territories, to an important global warming and to compose with the redistribution of hunted animal species. Ethnography, Prehistory, and classical texts prooves that verbal traditions could keep in memory such exceptional events during a long period of time. Plato myth of "Atlantis" seems builded on a local prehistoric tradition of flooding transmitted during 5000 years to the first egyptian scribes around 3′000-4′000 BC.
Article
Full-text available
LETTERS TO NATURE example, ~50-40 mmyr1 is roughly equivalent to discharge rates of 16,000 km3 yr~&apos; for MWP-1 A). A third meltwater pulse, smaller than the two other, was identified at ~7,600cal. yr bp in a compilation of Caribbean corals together with the Barbados curve . ...
Article
Full-text available
The tsunami generated by the 1755.01.11 earthquake affected mainly the coasts of the Iberian Peninsula and Northwest Morocco and was observed all over the North Atlantic coasts. The catastrophic dimensions of that phenomenon had a tremendous impact on the city of Lisbon and on several villages along the south coast of Portugal. The earthquake was felt all over Europe and the seismic intensity was estimated as X–XI (Mercalli Intensity Scale) at Lisbon and Southwest Portugal (Cape S. Vicente). The most destructive waves were observed along the coast of Portugal, specially in Lisbon, in the area of the S. Vicente Cape, along the Gulf of Cadiz and Northwest Morocco.
Article
Full-text available
The Gibraltar region features the arcuate Betic - Rif mountain belt with outward di- rected thrusting, surrounding a zone of strong Neogene subsidence and crustal thin- ning in the Western Alboran Sea. Until now its geodynamic interpretation has re- mained controversial. The Gibraltar Arc is located at the eastern end of the Azores- Gibraltar transform, a diffuse transpressional plate boundary between the Iberian and African Plates. Attention has recently been focussed on this plate boundary, while seeking the likely source of the destructive Lisbon great earthquake (M 8.5 - 9) and tsunami of 1755. The SISMAR marine seismic survey conducted in April 2001 ac- quired over 3000 km of 360-channel seismic data with a 4.5 km long streamer and 1000 km of wide-angle data recorded by ocean bottom seismometers (OBS), com- pletely spanning the actively deforming region between the margins of Portugal and northwest Morocco. Results from this seismic survey reveal a thick chaotic sedimen- tary mass west of Gibraltar to be an actively deforming accretionary wedge, with east dipping thrust faults disrupting the seafloor and soleing out to an east dipping decolle- ment. New travel-time tomographic results image a continuous east dipping body with high seismic velocities (i.e. a cold slab of oceanic lithosphere) descending from the Atlantic domain of the Gulf of Cadiz, passing through intermediate depth (60 - 120 km) seismicity beneath the Gibraltar Arc and Western Alboran Sea, and merging with a region of deep focus earthquakes 600 - 660 km below Granada Spain. Together these provide compelling evidence for an active east dipping subduction zone. Slab rollback towards the west provides a plausible mechanism for extension and subsidence in the Alboran Sea, while the associated westward advance of the Gibraltar Arc drives com- pressional deformation in the accretionary wedge where active mud volcanoes have recently been discovered.
Article
Full-text available
Large, historically unprecedented earthquakes at the Cascadia subduction zone in western North America have left signs of sudden land level change, tsunamis, and strong shaking in coastal sediments. The coastal geological evidence suggests that many of the earthquakes occurred at the boundary between the overriding North American plate and the subducting Juan de Fuca plate. This hypothesis is consistent with geodetic measurements and the results of geophysical modeling, which indicate that part of the plate boundary is locked and accumulating elastic strain that will be released during a future large earthquake. Arguments based on potential amounts of seismic slip and likely rupture areas suggest that most or all of the plate boundary earthquakes were magnitude 8 or larger events. The last earthquake or series of earthquakes, about 300 years ago, ruptured the entire 1000-km length of the subduction zone; if it was a single quake, it probably exceeded magnitude 9. Other earthquakes may have ruptured one or more segments of the subduction zone or may have occurred on faults in the North American plate. Recurrence intervals are uncertain because of difficulties in identifying and dating earthquakes. In southwestern Washington state, intervals for the seven most recent earthquakes average about 500 years but range from less than 200 years to 700–1300 years. Future research on Cascadian plate boundary earthquakes will probably focus on (1) the relation between plate boundary and crustal earthquakes, (2) earthquake magnitude, (3) the areal extent and severity of seismic ground motions, (4) ages and number of past plate boundary earthquakes, and (5) land level changes preceding earthquakes.
Article
Full-text available
For at least two thousand years scholars have debated the location of Troy and the events and geographic features described in Homer's Iliad. Geologic evidence is used to present a series of maps of the Trojan plain that show the geomorphic changes over the past six millennia. The geologic evidence correlates very well with the relevant Homeric geography.
Article
Full-text available
Historical data are fundamental to the understanding of the seismic history of an area. At the same time, knowledge of the active tectonic processes allows us to understand how earthquakes have been perceived by past cultures. Delphi is one of the principal archaeological sites of Greece, the main oracle of Apollo. It was by far the most venerated oracle of the Greek ancient world. According to tradition, the mantic proprieties of the oracle were obtained from an open chasm in the earth. Delphi is directly above one of the main antithetic active faults of the Gulf of Corinth Rift, which bounds Mount Parnassus to the south. The geometry of the fault and slip-parallel lineations on the main fault plane indicate normal movement, with minor right-lateral slip component. Combining tectonic data, archaeological evidence, historical sources, and a reexamination of myths, it appears that the Helice earthquake of 373 B.C. ruptured not only the master fault of the Gulf of Corinth Rift at Helice, but also the antithetic fault at Delphi, similarly to the Corinth earthquake of 1981. Moreover, the presence of an active fault directly below the temples of the oldest sanctuary suggests that the mythological oracular chasm might well have been an ancient tectonic surface rupture.
Article
The bathymetric maps from the western part of the Gibraltar Strait indicate the occurrence of a shoal between -56 and -200 m depth. During the Late Glacial Maximum (21-19 kyr BP), this shoal was the main island of an archipelago lying between Europe and Africa. The island (14 km × 5 km) was set in the middle of a narrow pass in the western part of the present strait, opening westward into an inner sea. This island was submerged around 11 kyr BP. This location, the palaeolandscapes for the Late Glacial period, and the time of submergence exactly fit the Atlantis description given by Plato in the 'Timaeus'. The 'mighty power which unprovoked made an expedition against the whole of Europe and Asia' could be the irrupting culture of northern Europe pushed to the south by the rough climates of the Late Glacial Maximum.
Article
This Part I study, in conjunction with Part II, develops a method to determine, within specified uncertainly bounds, the seismic moment, and thus moment magnitude, of all earthquakes of stable continental regions (SCR) for which instrumental or intensity data exist. Its basis is polynomial regression analysis using a database of SCR earthquakes with direct seismic moment determination. The independent variables include modern teleseismic magnitudes and regional magnitudes (Part I), and isoseismal areas or number of recording stations (Part II). Part III is an application of the methodology of Parts I and II to several major historical earthquakes. All data used in the regressions are assigned individual uncertainties estimated from the literature or from experience; formal confidence limits (68 per cent or 95 per cent) on both the regression formulas and the predicted seismic moment values are then possible via error propagation analysis. The most complete development is for the teleseismic magnitudes Ms and mb. For both, the final regression for log(Mo) is a quadratic formula that closely emulates the relationship between amplitude magnitudes and Mo expected from dislocation theory and source-scaling arguments. Regressions are also derived for the regional magnitudes mLg and ML, because there are many SCR events, mainly pre-1964, that have no teleseismic magnitudes. Prediction uncertainties from teleseismic magnitudes in moment magnitude units are in the ± 0.18. 0.28 range, and from regional magnitudes in the ±0.23–0.38 range over a wide magnitude band. Finally, the methodology developed here is generic, even though the database is specific. Application to plate-boundary, oceanic intraplate, or active continental intraplate regions should be straightforward.
Article
Ancient tradition linked the Delphic oracle in Greece to specific geological phenomena, including a fissure in the bedrock, intoxicating gaseous emissions, and a spring. Despite testimony by ancient authors, many modern scholars have dismissed these traditional accounts as mistaken or fraudulent. This paper presents the results of an interdisciplinary study that has succeeded in locating young faults at the oracle site and has also identified the prophetic vapor as an emission of light hydrocarbon gases generated in the underlying strata of bituminous limestone.