Content uploaded by Odd V. Höglund
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Odd V. Höglund on Sep 10, 2018
Content may be subject to copyright.
Breed Variations in the Incidence of Pyometra and Mammary Tumours in Swedish
Dogs
S Jitpean, R Hagman, B Stro
¨m Holst, OV Ho
¨glund, A Pettersson and A Egenvall
Department of Clinical Sciences, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden
Contents
Dogs enrolled in a Swedish insurance company (during 1995–
2006) were studied for development of pyometra and mam-
mary tumours (MTs), with special attention to breed and age.
There were over 260 000 female dogs with over 1 000 000
dog-years at risk (DYAR) in the database, using data on
bitches up to 10 years of age and 110 breeds with over 1000
DYAR. In total, 20 423 bitches were diagnosed with pyometra
and 11 758 with MTs and 30 131 with either or both of the
two diseases. The incidence rate (IR) for pyometra was 199
(95% CI 196–202), for MTs 112 (95% CI 110–114) and for
either or both of the two diseases 297 (95% CI 294–301) dogs
per 10 000 DYAR. The mean age of diagnosis pyometra was
7.0 years (SD ±2.2), MTs 8.0 years (SD ±1.6). In all breeds,
the overall proportion of the bitches that developed disease by
10 years of age was for pyometra 19%, MTs 13%, and either
or both of two diseases 30%. The top 10 breeds diagnosed
with either or both of the two diseases were the Leonberger
(73%), Irish Wolfhound (69%), Bernese Mountain Dog
(69%), Great Dane (68%), Staffordshire Bull Terrier (66%),
Rottweiler (65%), Bullterrier (62%), Doberman (62%), Bou-
vier des Flandres (60%), Airdaleterrier (60%). These data
provide information of the combined disease incidence in a
large number of different breeds. Breed variations in incidence
rate suggests genetic components in disease development. Our
study may be valuable in the search for genetic risk-factors or
protective factors.
Introduction
Pyometra and mammary tumours (MTs) constitute the
main reimbursement claims for veterinary costs in
female dogs in Sweden (Egenvall et al. 1999, 2000).
There are breed- and age-related differences in incidence
of both diseases, but the combined risk has not yet been
studied by breed (Egenvall et al. 2001, 2005). The Agria
Insurance database (Stockholm, Sweden) has been used
to investigate breed- and age-related risks for developing
disease (Egenvall et al. 2000). The objective of the study
was to evaluate the incidence of pyometra and MTs in
this insured dog-population, up to 10 years of age, in
relation to breed and age.
Materials and Methods
The insurance process, benefits and limitations of using
insurance data in veterinary research has earlier been
described in detail (Egenvall et al. 2000, 2009). The
Agria Insurance database contains data from over
260 000 female dogs ( 10 years). In the present study,
female dogs enrolled for both veterinary care and life
insurance during 1995–2006 were included. Each year a
dog was insured contributed to one dog-year at risk
(DYAR). All insured bitches were considered at
potential risk for developing pyometra. Variables used
were: gender, breed, date of birth, dates when dogs
entered or left the insurance program, information on
the type of insurance for which dogs were enrolled, and
whether claims were reimbursed. Breeds were classified
according to the Swedish Kennel Club breed classifica-
tion system. If dogs had reimbursed claims for pyom-
etra, they were considered as pyometra-cases and
likewise for MTs. The crude- and breed-specific
proportions (percentages) of dogs that had insurance
claims for pyometra or MTs up to certain ages (6, 8, and
10 years) were calculated using the base-line survival
statement from Cox regression (without independent
variables). Incidence rates, crude and breed-specific
mean ages were calculated for development of pyometra
and MTs and either or both of the two diseases.
Results
The database contained data from over 260 000 female
dogs, resulting in just over 1 000 000 DYAR calculated
for dogs up to 10 years of age. There were 110 breeds with
over 1000 DYAR in the database, constituting the basis
for the analyses. In total, data from 20 423 bitches
diagnosed with pyometra, 11 758 with MTs, and 30 131
with either or both of the two diseases were obtained from
the database. The incidence rate (IR) for pyometra was
199 (95% CI 196–202) dogs per 10 000 DYAR, for MTs
112 (95% CI 110–114) dogs per 10 000 DYAR and for
either or both of the two diseases 297 (95% CI 294–301)
dogs per 10 000 DYAR. The mean age of diagnosis
pyometra was 7.0 years (SD ±2.2), for MTs 8.0 years
(SD ±1.6) and for either or both of the diseases 7.4 years
(SD ±2.1). The proportion of bitches diagnosed with
either or both of the two diseases ranged from 9 to 73% in
different breeds. The proportion of the bitches that
developed these diseases at 10 years of age was for
pyometra 19%, MTs 13%, and either or both pyometra
or MTs 30%. There were 20 breeds with a proportion of
at least 50% affected by either or both of the two diseases
at 10 years of age (Table 1). In the supplementary tables
(S1–S3), all breeds are ranked according to the propor-
tion that developed either of or both the diseases
(pyometra and MT) by the age of 10 years.
Discussion
It is common practise to insure dogs in Sweden and
approximately 40% of all dogs are covered by Agria
Insurance. Approximately 90% (all ages) of the Swedish
dog population is intact, hence most dogs are suscep-
tible to reproductive organ disease (Egenvall et al.
©2012 Blackwell Verlag GmbH
Reprod Dom Anim 47 (Suppl. 6), 347–350 (2012); doi: 10.1111/rda.12103
ISSN 0936–6768
Table 1. Breed, proportion (derived from Cox proportional hazards
regression without independent variables) of bitches that developed
disease, rank, and numbers of cases in different breeds that by the age
of 10 years had developed pyometra (P), mammary tumours (MTs),
and either or both of pyometra or MTs
Breed
Pyometra
%
rank
(n)
MTs
%
rank
(n)
P/MTs
%
rank
(n)
Total
female
dogs
Afghan 16
79
(21) 26
17
(34) 34
55
(49) 475
Airedale Terrier 49
11
(141) 28
12
(75) 60
10
(184) 599
Alaskan Malamute 40
21
(34) 20
32
(15) 49
22
(43) 383
American Cocker
Spaniel
36
23
(127) 35
6
(111) 56
12
(211) 1331
Basenji 11
99
(7) 5
101
(3) 16
104
(10) 265
Basset Artesien
Normand
28
38
(28) 6
99
(6) 31
66
(32) 450
Basset hound 44
14
(75) 25
22
(38) 56
13
(99) 517
Beagle 20
67
(125) 15
47
(94) 30
67
(200) 2035
Bearded Collie 17
75
(147) 6
100
(53) 22
91
(198) 2128
Bedlington Terrier 17
77
(13) 33
8
(26) 42
32
(34) 220
Belgian Shepherd Dog 33
27
(185) 10
77
(51) 39
35
(225) 1484
Bernese Mountain
Dog
66
1
(363) 14
57
(44) 69
3
(393) 2332
Bichon Frise
´16
82
(131) 20
34
(159) 32
64
(275) 2328
Border Collie 13
93
(213) 8
88
(125) 19
99
(324) 5300
Border Terrier 22
59
(172) 13
60
(92) 32
65
(252) 2458
Borzoi 24
50
(21) 16
43
(14) 35
51
(33) 441
Bouvier des Flandres 50
9
(103) 23
25
(40) 60
9
(130) 459
Boxer 28
36
(183) 35
7
(236) 51
20
(387) 2198
Briard 17
73
(48) 11
66
(30) 26
80
(73) 911
Bull Terrier 52
8
(36) 23
26
(14) 62
7
(47) 323
Cairn Terrier 22
57
(280) 16
45
(190) 34
58
(431) 2863
Cavalier King Charles
Spaniel
48
12
(891) 15
52
(218) 54
15
(1025) 5527
Chihuahua (long-
haired)
23
53
(37) 6
98
(9) 27
78
(44) 867
Chihuahua (smooth-
haired)
26
44
(22) 11
73
(9) 33
59
(30) 819
Collie 44
15
(664) 2
109
(20) 45
27
(679) 3755
Coton de Tulear 5
108
(1) 20
31
(5) 24
87
(6) 286
Dachshund (long-
haired)
15
43
(64) 16
44
(65) 28
75
(121) 857
Dalmatian 16
80
(96) 11
72
(62) 25
86
(150) 1699
Danish/Swedish
Farmdog
16
84
(25) 14
55
(22) 25
84
(43) 909
Dobermann 43
17
(152) 42
2
(135) 62
8
(259) 1744
Drever 30
33
(596) 11
68
(187) 37
44
(718) 6235
East Siberian Laika 8
105
(4) 2
107
(1) 10
109
(5) 398
Elkhound 25
45
(284) 13
62
(132) 35
54
(405) 3924
English Springer
Spaniel
32
30
(637) 36
5
(729) 55
14
(1221) 5521
English Cocker
Spaniel
32
29
(469) 26
16
(367) 48
24
(750) 4637
English Pointer 18
71
(28) 15
48
(22) 30
69
(48) 588
English Setter 21
62
(83) 21
30
(88) 36
45
(157) 1111
Finnish Lapphund 12
97
(10) 3
105
(2) 15
105
(12) 552
Finnish Spitz 3
110
(14) 6
94
(27) 9
110
(40) 1649
Finnish Hound 20
66
(104) 7
91
(35) 25
85
(134) 2227
Flat Coated Retriever 28
37
(297) 16
46
(157) 38
42
(426) 3669
German Jagde Terrier 18
70
(20) 12
64
(13) 27
79
(31) 689
German Longhaired
Pointer
13
92
(34) 14
53
(37) 26
81
(69) 546
German Spaniel 23
52
(92) 26
15
(103) 43
28
(183) 1906
German Shepherd
Dog
31
32
(1658) 26
18
(1348) 47
25
(2779) 20520
Greyhound 11
100
(17) 7
94
(10) 16
103
(26) 1195
Golden Retriever 36
24
(1971) 10
78
(518) 42
30
(2353) 13626
Gordon Setter 8
106
(12) 14
56
(20) 20
98
(31) 484
Great Dane 62
2
(104) 27
13
(31) 68
4
(127) 1154
Groenendaeler 27
39
(75) 7
93
(16) 32
63
(89) 728
Table 1. (continued)
Breed
Pyometra
%
rank
(n)
MTs
%
rank
(n)
P/MTs
%
rank
(n)
Total
female
dogs
Hamilton/Swedish
Hound
17
74
(206) 8
89
(89) 23
89
(285) 3907
Havanese 16
81
(19) 9
84
(9) 23
90
(27) 637
Hovawart 21
60
(41) 28
11
(55) 42
33
(90) 745
Irish Setter 22
56
(124) 20
33
(110) 37
43
(218) 1563
Irish Wolfhound 58
5
(38) 41
3
(19) 69
2
(54) 496
Icelandic Sheepdog 15
87
(17) 7
95
(8) 19
100
(23) 373
Irish Soft Coated
Wheaten Terrier
13
95
(82) 28
10
(185) 36
46
(252) 2201
Jack Russel Terrier 12
96
(108) 17
39
(144) 27
77
(245) 4191
Japanese Spitz 30
34
(97) 9
82
(26) 36
47
(114) 828
Karelian Bear Dog 13
91
(14) 10
73
(8) 22
96
(21) 384
Keeshond 52
7
(102) 10
75
(16) 57
11
(115) 462
Kelpie 25
48
(68) 10
74
(27) 33
65
(92) 796
Chinese Crested Dog
Powder Puff
33
25
(17) 15
51
(7) 42
31
(23) 310
Labrador Retriever 28
35
(1116) 11
71
(462) 35
49
(1512) 12525
Lancashire Heeler 10
102
(7) 2
108
(1) 12
107
(8) 263
Large Poodle 33
28
(257) 15
50
(108) 42
29
(346) 2319
Leonberger 61
3
(159) 46
1
(99) 73
1
(233) 1287
Lhasa Apso 26
42
(40) 12
65
(17) 35
52
(56) 512
Maltese 8
107
(10) 17
38
(23) 22
93
(30) 388
Miniature Pinscher 17
78
(11) 13
60
(9) 28
73
(20) 343
Mixed breed 24
51
(1288) 16
41
(849) 35
50
(1982) 22846
Munsterlander 25
46
(121) 15
49
(69) 35
48
(176) 1153
Newfoundland 50
9
(243) 8
85
(27) 54
17
(263) 1486
Norrbotten Spitz 4
109
(9) 11
67
(23) 14
106
(31) 639
Norfolk Terrier 22
58
(31) 16
42
(22) 35
53
(51) 468
Norwegian Buhund 19
69
(36) 4
104
(7) 22
94
(42) 442
Norwich Terrier 11
101
(13) 1
110
(1) 11
108
(14) 290
Nova Scotia Duck
Tolling Retriever
26
41
(118) 19
35
(83) 39
38
(185) 1533
Old English
Sheepdog
42
18
(76) 29
9
(48) 54
18
(107) 475
Papillon 15
85
(121) 21
29
(164) 33
60
(268) 2626
Papillon Drop Ear 14
90
(8) 25
23
(16) 30
68
(20) 363
Pomeranian 19
68
(31) 4
103
(7) 21
97
(36) 694
Petit Basset Griffon
Vendeen
21
63
(75) 17
40
(59) 33
61
(125) 1526
Pug 48
13
(77) 3
106
(3) 49
21
(80) 614
Pyrenean Mountain
Dog
43
16
(58) 22
27
(24) 53
19
(76) 524
Rhodesian
Ridgeback
20
65
(45) 26
20
(57) 39
40
(95) 1109
Rottweiler 58
4
(712) 22
28
(206) 65
6
(850) 5048
Saluki 10
104
(10) 26
19
(31) 34
57
(41) 376
Samoyed 31
31
(152) 14
54
(64) 39
37
(200) 1544
Schiller Hound 18
72
(52) 10
79
(29) 26
83
(79) 921
Schipperke 25
47
(34) 8
90
(10) 29
72
(41) 447
Swiss Hound/Lucerne 33
26
(38) 8
86
(8) 38
41
(45) 333
Shetland Sheepdog 23
54
(251) 7
92
(71) 28
74
(313) 3372
Shiba 17
76
(11) 6
96
(4) 22
92
(15) 234
Shih Tzu 16
83
(91) 13
63
(70) 26
82
(152) 1655
Siberian Husky 14
89
(33) 5
102
(12) 18
101
(44) 951
Scottish Terrier 41
19
(61) 13
58
(17) 47
26
(73) 409
Sma
˚land Hound 13
94
(22) 13
59
(23) 24
88
(43) 539
Staffordshire Bull
Terrier
54
6
(50) 25
21
(19) 66
5
(64) 550
Swedish Elkhound 40
20
(313) 26
14
(188) 54
16
(473) 4944
Swedish Lapphund 37
22
(85) 11
67
(22) 42
34
(98) 628
Swedish Vallhund 15
88
(49) 9
81
(30) 22
95
(74) 896
Tibetan Spaniel 11
98
(51) 8
87
(34) 18
102
(81) 1338
Tibetan Terrier 10
103
(21) 19
36
(42) 27
76
(62) 575
Toy Poodle 26
43
(21) 11
69
(8) 34
56
(29) 304
Welsh Terrier 20
64
(20) 37
4
(33) 48
23
(47) 245
Welsh Springer
Spaniel
27
40
(63) 18
37
(41) 39
39
(96) 895
348 S Jitpean, R Hagman, B Stro
¨m Holst, OV Ho
¨glund, A Pettersson and A Egenvall
©2012 Blackwell Verlag GmbH
1999). The Agria database thus offers unique possibil-
ities for studies concerning such diseases. The incidences
of pyometra and MTs have been shown to vary between
different breeds, suggesting a genetic background
(Egenvall et al. 2001; Rivera et al. 2009). The overall
proportion of dogs that had developed pyometra in this
study was slightly lower (19%) than previously reported
(23–24%) which possibly reflects that more low-risk
breeds were included in the present study (Egenvall
et al. 2001). Although based on different study periods,
the overall proportion of dogs developing MTs in the
present study was 13%, which is the same as in a
previous report (Egenvall et al. 2005). In some breeds
(i.e. the Leonberger and the Great Dane), the risk for
both diseases was high, indicating that predisposing
factors may be similar. In contrast, other breeds had a
relatively high risk for MTs (i.e. the English Springer
Spaniel and the American Cocker Spaniel, ranked 5 and
6, respectively), but were only ranked as number 30 and
23 for pyometra. The Bernese mountain dog (highest
rank for pyometra) was ranked as 57 for MTs. These
findings suggest that there is breed variation in risk-
factors or protective factors. Though complex diseases
with probable multifactorial aetiology, the data
reported here may be useful for the selection of breeds
in future studies for identification of factors that may be
protective or increase the risk for the development of
pyometra and/or MTs.
Elective spaying is commonly performed in many
countries, and will prevent development of pyometra,
and depending on at which age the surgery is performed,
also have a protective effect for MTs (Schneider et al.
1969). However, recently the protective effects by
spaying on MT development have been questioned
(Beauvais et al. 2012). In the present study, high
incidences (up to 73%) of pyometra and MTs were
demonstrated in some giant and large breeds of which
are commonly affected by post spaying urinary incon-
tinence (Thrusfield et al. 1998). Since the pros and cons
of elective spaying will vary by breed, knowledge of
breed-variations will be clinically useful in the decision
process for each dog.
Due to insurance age limitations, only data from dogs
up to 10 years of age are included in the database, which
is a study limitation. The true mean ages of diagnosis
and incidences are likely to be higher and larger,
respectively, and especially in breeds with long life
expectancy.
Conclusion
In the present study the incidence of pyometra and MTs
in Swedish female dogs up to 10 years of age is reported.
For the first time data on contracting either or both of
the two diseases was studied in a comparatively large
population of 110 breeds. Substantial between-breed
variation in the incidence of pyometra and MTs was
demonstrated. These differences indicate that genetic
factors may predispose and/or protect for disease
development. These results may be valuable for future
genetic studies or breeding programs aimed to decrease
the prevalence in high-risk breeds.
Acknowledgements
Agria Pet Insurance kindly allowed us to use their database. Financial
support was provided by Thure F. and Karin Forsbergs Research
Foundation, M. Forsgrens Research Foundation and Agria Insurance
and The Swedish Kennel Club Research Foundation.
Conflicts of interest
None of the authors have any conflicts of interest to declare.
Author contributions
All authors were involved in the study design, performance and
manuscript preparation. AE performed statistical analyses and SJ
drafted the manuscript.
Supporting Information
Additional Supporting Information may be found in the online version
of this article:
Table S1. Rank, breed, proportion (%) of bitches in different breeds
that had developed pyometra by the age of ten years. The 110 breeds
are listed in ranking order.
Table S2. Rank, breed, proportion (%) of bitches in different breeds
that had developed mammary tumours by the age of ten years. The 110
breeds are listed in ranking order.
Table S3. Rank, breed, proportion (%) of bitches in different breeds
that had developed either pyometra or mammary tumours or both of
the two diseases by the age of ten years. The 110 breeds are listed in
ranking order.
References
Beauvais W, Cardwell JM, Brodbelt DC,
2012: The effect of neutering on the risk
of mammary tumours in dogs: A system-
atic review. J Small Anim Pract 53,
314–322.
Egenvall A, Hedhammar A, Bonnett BN,
Olson P, 1999: Survey of the Swedish dog
population- Age, gender, breed, location
and enrolment in animal insurance. Acta
Vet Scand 40, 231–240.
Egenvall A, Bonnett BN, Olson P, Hedham-
mar A, 2000: Gender, age and breed
pattern of diagnoses for veterinary care
in insured dogs in Sweden during 1996.
Vet Rec 146, 551–557.
Egenvall A, Hagman R, Bonnett BN, Hed-
hammar A, Olson P, Lagerstedt AS, 2001:
Breed risk of pyometra in insured dogs in
Sweden. J Vet Intern Med 15, 530–538.
Table 1. (continued)
Breed
Pyometra
%
rank
(n)
MTs
%
rank
(n)
P/MTs
%
rank
(n)
Total
female
dogs
West Highland White
Terrier
24
49
(205) 8
84
(64) 30
71
(255) 2067
Whippet 23
55
(82) 10
80
(35) 30
70
(112) 1173
Yorkshire Terrier 21
61
(157) 25
24
(176) 39
36
(301) 1959
The 110 breeds are listed in alphabetical order. The breeds are ranked according
to the proportion of disease(s) within each breed (rank 1 =highest proportion).
Total female dogs column describes the number of dogs in each breed that
contributed to the number of dog-years at risk included in the analysis.
Pyometra and Mammary Tumours in Swedish Dogs 349
©2012 Blackwell Verlag GmbH
Egenvall A, Bonnett BN, Ohagen P, Olson
P, Hedhammar A, von Euler H, 2005:
Incidence of and survival after mam-
mary tumors in a population of over
80,000 insured female dogs in Sweden
from 1995 to 2002. Prev Vet Med 69,
109–127.
Egenvall A, Nodtvedt A, Penell J, Gunnars-
son L, Bonnett BN, 2009: Insurance data
for research in companion animals:
benefits and limitations. Acta Vet Scand
51,4.
Rivera P, Melin M, Biagi T, Fall T, Hagg-
strom J, Lindblad-Toh K, von Euler H,
2009: Mammary tumor development in
dogs is associated with BRCA1 and
BRCA2. Cancer Res 69, 8770–8774.
Schneider R, Dorn CR, Taylor DO, 1969:
Factors influencing canine mammary can-
cer development and postsurgical sur-
vival. J Natl Cancer Inst 43, 1249–1261.
Thrusfield MV, Holt PE, Muirhead RH,
1998: Acquired urinary incontinence in
bitches: its incidences and relationship to
neutering practices. J Small Anim Pract
39, 559–566.
Submitted: 29 May 2012; Accepted: 24 Jul
2012
Author’s address (for correspondence): S
Jitpean, Department of Clinical Sciences,
Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences,
Box 7054, 75007 Uppsala, Sweden.
E-mail: supranee.jitpean@slu.se
350 S Jitpean, R Hagman, B Stro
¨m Holst, OV Ho
¨glund, A Pettersson and A Egenvall
©2012 Blackwell Verlag GmbH