Article

Is there utility in the transtheoretical model?

Department of Psychology, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK.
British Journal of Health Psychology (Impact Factor: 2.7). 11/2008; 14(Pt 2):195-210. DOI: 10.1348/135910708X368991
Source: PubMed

ABSTRACT

The transtheoretical model is arguably the dominant model of health behaviour change, having received unprecedented research attention, yet it has simultaneously attracted exceptional criticism. However, the criticisms have been directed almost exclusively at the stages of change, just one of fourteen components of the transtheoretical model, which may have diverted attention away from more fruitful avenues of research based on the model.
Narrative review.
The evidence would suggest some flaws in the concept of stages of change as currently articulated in the transtheoretical model. On a conceptual level, even studies incorporating the five stages of change point to a model that better fits Gollwitzer (1993) and Heckhausen's (1991) idea of a motivational phase followed by a volitional phase. Potentially the processes of change components of the transtheoretical model may actually prove the most useful, yet have been under-researched, at least experimentally. Three studies that successfully utilise the processes of change to reduce alcohol consumption, encourage smoking cessation and increase physical activity are described.
Elements of the transtheoretical model offer promise in developing effective health behaviour change interventions, but the question arises as to whether extracting these elements undermines completely the idea of a transtheoretical model.

10 Followers
 · 
72 Reads
  • Source
    • "The first stage would be a combination of precontemplation , contemplation and preparation and the second action and maintenance. The first one has been described as the motivational phase and the second the volitional phase (for a review, see Armitage, 2009). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Introduction Le nombre de déplacements en voiture, qui est en augmentation, engendre des effets négatifs sur notre environnement et sur notre propre qualité de vie. Il est important de comprendre le processus de décision sous-jacent aux comportements de déplacements pour atteindre un changement dans une direction davantage pro-environnementale. Objectif Le but de cette étude est d’explorer les facteurs importants qui déterminent la volonté de se déplacer à vélo en se référant à deux théories bien établies à savoir : la théorie du comportement planifié (TCP) et le modèle transthéorique de changement (MTC). Des études ont montré que les habitudes aident à comprendre le choix du mode de déplacement, un autre objectif a donc été d’examiner la relation entre habitude et MTC. Méthode Cette étude comprenait un échantillon de 414 individus issus d’une population générale qui a répondu à un questionnaire portant sur un trajet qu’ils ont fait le plus souvent au cours d’une semaine. Résultats Les résultats confirment que les construits, tels que mesurés par la TCP, permettent uniquement de faire une distinction entre la précontemplation et la contemplation et entre la préparation et l’action. L’introduction de l’habitude a révélé que c’était principalement les gens à la première et la dernière étapes lesquels le comportement pouvait être considéré comme automatique. Les résultats ont également montré que la relation entre la TCP et le MTC est principalement linéaire, mais aussi quadratique. Cette étude a exploré les croyances comportementales des répondants pour lesquelles l’analyse factorielle a permis d’extraire trois composantes. En général les gens sont d’accord pour dire que le vélo est bon pour leur santé et l’environnement. Ils se différencient sur les aspects liés aux avantages et aux inconvénients du vélo, aux conséquences perçues qui sont devenues plus positives et moins négatives avec la progression des étapes. Conclusion Cette étude suggère que la combinaison de la TPB et du MTC est utile quand on essaie de comprendre le choix modal. Cependant, l’étude soutient que c’est la nature multidimensionnelle des construits qui est intéressante plutôt que de considérer chacun d’eux séparément. Elle suggère également que même si les avantages à court terme sont fortement liés au processus de changement, les effets négatifs doivent être documentés et être sérieusement pris en compte si nous voulons que les gens persistent dans leur nouveau comportement. Les implications des conclusions de l’étude concernant la description des gens aux différents stades sont discutées.
    Full-text · Article · May 2014 · Revue Européenne de Psychologie Appliquée
  • Source
    • "The process of initiating and maintaining healthy lifestyle behaviours is complex, includes a number of distinct phases and is not static [1]. Theoretical models of behaviour change consider psychological constructs such as intention and self efficacy but do not clearly consider the role of psychological or emotional distress [2-4]. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The process of initiating and maintaining healthy lifestyle behaviours is complex, includes a number of distinct phases and is not static. Theoretical models of behaviour change consider psychological constructs such as intention and self efficacy but do not clearly consider the role of stress or psychological distress. General practice based interventions addressing lifestyle behaviours have been demonstrated to be feasible and effective however it is not clear whether general practitioners (GPs) take psychological health into consideration when discussing lifestyle behaviours. This qualitative study explores GPs' and patients' perspectives about the relationship between external stressors, psychological distress and maintaining healthy lifestyle behaviours. Semi-structured telephone interviews were conducted with 16 patients and 5 GPs. Transcripts from the interviews were thematically analysed and a conceptual model developed to explain the relationship between external stressors, psychological distress and healthly lifestyle behaviours. Participants were motivated to maintain a healthy lifestyle however they described a range of external factors that impacted on behaviour in both positive and negative ways, either directly or via their impact on psychological distress. The impact of external factors was moderated by coping strategies, beliefs, habits and social support. In some cases the process of changing or maintaining healthy behaviour also caused distress. The concept of a threshold level of distress was evident in the data with patients and GPs describing a certain level of distress required before it negatively influenced behaviour. Maintaining healthy lifestyle behaviours is complex and constantly under challenge from external stressors. Practitioners can assist patients with maintaining healthy behaviour by providing targeted support to moderate the impact of external stressors.
    Full-text · Article · Nov 2013 · BMC Family Practice
    • "Support for the other hypotheses was more equivocal: Self-generated implementation intentions were not differentially effective in reducing alcohol consumption compared with the VHS, nor was asking people to form simultaneous multiple implementation intentions differentially effective as compared to requesting a single implementation intention using the VHS. Consistent with a large body of research on the impact of implementation intention-based interventions on health behavior change (Armitage 2009b), the present study showed that implementation intentions were effective in reducing alcohol consumption in a sample broadly representative of the general population in a field setting without potentially costly tailoring or targeting. Importantly, simply being asked to plan does not account for the effects: Explicitly linking critical situation and appropriate response is necessary to exert the observed effects. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Volitional help sheets (VHS) have been shown to be effective in changing health behavior, but not yet alcohol consumption in a general population. The aim of the present research was to test the ability of VHS to reduce alcohol consumption against an active control condition, a "standard" self-generated implementation intention condition, and forming a single implementation intention using the VHS. Sixty-nine participants were randomly allocated to one of four conditions: active control, VHS: single implementation intention, VHS: multiple implementation intentions and self-generated implementation intention. The main outcome measure was alcohol intake, assessed using a version of the timeline follow-back technique. Subsequent alcohol consumption decreased by more than 0.5 standard units (8 grams) per day in each of the experimental conditions (ps < 0.05), but increased marginally (0.05 units/day) in the active control condition. There were no significant differences in cognition or behavior between the three experimental conditions. The findings support the efficacy of a new VHS to reduce alcohol consumption. Further research is needed to identify alternative means by which people may form implementation intentions.
    No preview · Article · Sep 2012 · Prevention Science
Show more