ArticlePDF Available

Exploring the Safety and Therapeutic Effects of Deep Pressure Stimulation Using a Weighted Blanket

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This paper presents the results of a concurrent, nested, mixed methods exploratory study on the safety and effectiveness of the use of a 30 lb weighted blanket with a convenience sample of 32 adults. Safety is investigated measuring blood pressure, pulse rate, and pulse oximetry, and effectiveness by electrodermal activity (EDA), the State Trait Anxiety Inventory-10 and an exit survey. The results reveal that the use of the 30 lb weighted blanket, in the lying down position, is safe as evidenced by the vital sign metrics. Data obtained on effectiveness reveal 33% demonstrated lowering in EDA when using the weighted blanket, 63% reported lower anxiety after use, and 78% preferred the weighted blanket as a calming modality. The results of this study will be used to form the basis for subsequent research on the therapeutic influence of the weighted blanket with adults during an acute inpatient mental health admission.
Content may be subject to copyright.
This article was downloaded by: [University of Massachusetts, Amherst],
[Sundar Krishnamurty]
On: 01 August 2014, At: 05:27
Publisher: Routledge
Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954
Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH,
UK
Occupational Therapy in Mental
Health
Publication details, including instructions for
authors and subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/womh20
Exploring the Safety and
Therapeutic Effects of Deep
Pressure Stimulation Using a
Weighted Blanket
Brian Mullen BS
a
, Tina Champagne MEd, OTR/L
b
,
Sundar Krishnamurty PhD
a
, Debra Dickson APRN, BC
b
& Robert X. Gao PhD
a
a
University of Massachusetts—Amherst, Department
of Mechanical & Industrial Engineering—ELAB
Building , 160 Governors Drive, Amherst, MA, 01003,
USA
b
Cooley Dickinson Hospital, Acute Inpatient
Behavioral Health Department , 30 Locust Street,
Northampton, MA, 01060, USA
Published online: 08 Sep 2008.
To cite this article: Brian Mullen BS , Tina Champagne MEd, OTR/L , Sundar
Krishnamurty PhD , Debra Dickson APRN, BC & Robert X. Gao PhD (2008) Exploring
the Safety and Therapeutic Effects of Deep Pressure Stimulation Using a Weighted
Blanket, Occupational Therapy in Mental Health, 24:1, 65-89, DOI: 10.1300/
J004v24n01_05
To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1300/J004v24n01_05
PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the
information (the “Content”) contained in the publications on our platform.
However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no
representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness,
or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions and views
expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and
are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the
Content should not be relied upon and should be independently verified with
primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any
losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages,
and other liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or
indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the
Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes.
Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan,
sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is
expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at
http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
Exploring the Safety and Therapeutic
Effects of Deep Pressure Stimulation
Using a Weighted Blanket
Brian Mullen, BS
Tina Champagne, MEd, OTR/L
Sundar Krishnamurty, PhD
Debra Dickson, APRN, BC
Robert X. Gao, PhD
ABSTRACT. This paper presents the results of a concurrent, nested,
mixed methods exploratory study on the safety and effectiveness of the
use of a 30 lb weighted blanket with a convenience sample of 32 adults.
Safety is investigated measuring blood pressure, pulse rate, and pulse
oximetry, and effectiveness by electrodermal activity (EDA), the State
Trait Anxiety Inventory-10 and an exit survey. The results reveal that
Brian Mullen (E-mail: Bmullen@student.umass.edu), BS, is Graduate Research
Assistant, Sundar Krishnamurty (E-mail: skrishna@ecs.umass.edu), PhD, is In
-
terim Department Head and Associate Professor, and Robert X. Gao (E-mail:
Gao@ecs.umass.edu), PhD, is Professor; all are at University of Massachusetts-
Amherst, Department of Mechanical & Industrial Engineering–ELAB Building, 160
Governors Drive, Amherst, MA 01003 .
Tina Champagne (E-mail: Tina_Champagne@cooley-dickinson.org), MEd, OTR/L,
is Occupational Therapy and Group Program Supervisor, and Debra Dickson (E-mail:
Debra_Dickson@cooley-dickinson.org), APRN, BC, is Behavioral Health Clinical
Nurse Specialist; both are at Cooley Dickinson Hospital, Acute Inpatient Behav
-
ioral Health Department, 30 Locust Street, Northampton, MA 01060.
Address correspondence to Tina Champagne at the above address.
The authors wish to acknowledge and thank the UMASS-Amherst School of Nursing
for providing use of the nursing lab and vital signs monitoring equipment for the pur
-
poses of this study and to Dr. Keli Mu for his assistance with the revisions of this paper.
Occupational Therapy in Mental Health, Vol. 24(1) 2008
Available online at http://otmh.haworthpress.com
© 2008 by The Haworth Press. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1300/J004v24n01_05 65
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
the use of the 30 lb weighted blanket, in the lying down position, is safe
as evidenced by the vital sign metrics. Data obtained on effectiveness
reveal 33% demonstrated lowering in EDA when using the weighted
blanket, 63% reported lower anxiety after use, and 78% preferred the
weighted blanket as a calming modality. The results of this study will be
used to form the basis for subsequent research on the therapeutic influ
-
ence of the weighted blanket with adults during an acute inpatient mental
health admission.
doi:10.1300/J004v24n01_05 [Article copies available for a fee
from The Haworth Document Delivery Service: 1-800-HAWORTH. E-mail ad
-
dress: <docdelivery@haworthpress.com> Website: <http://www.HaworthPress.
com> © 2008 by The Haworth Press. All rights reserved.]
KEYWORDS. Sensory modulation, weighted blanket, deep pressure
touch stimulation, skin conductance, electrodermal activity
INTRODUCTION
The weighted blanket is a therapeutic modality used within the scope
of occupational therapy practice (Nackley, 2001; Walker & McCormack,
2002). It has been increasingly employed in acute mental health care
settings for crisis intervention, preparatory purposes, and as a purposeful
activity, which appears to help the consumer nurture, soothe, and care
for himself or herself (Champagne & Stromberg, 2004). When used in
this way it is considered a sensory modulation treatment tool aiding in
the stabilization and recovery process (Champagne, 2005). While there
is no published research on the safety or effectiveness of the therapeutic
use of the weighted blanket, anecdotal accounts support that when used
in an individualized manner, the weighted blanket appears to facilitate
the ability to feel safe, comforted, and grounded in the world (Cham
-
pagne & Stromberg, 2004; Heller, 2002).
The President’s Freedom Commission (Department of Health and Hu
-
man Services, 2003) was initiated to promote a national focus on increas
-
ing options in the areas of treatment, education, employment, assistive
devices, and universally designed technology for people with mental ill
-
ness. National and state mental health organizations, such as the National
Association for State Mental Health Program Directors (NASMHPD)
and the Department of Mental Health (DMH) support this initiative and
advocate the use of more humane, person-centered, and sensory sup
-
portive options (Huckshorn, 2004; National Executive Training Institute
[NETI], 2003). Although it is well established that no one therapeutic
tool is helpful to all consumers, the use of the weighted blanket as a
66 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
prevention and/or crisis intervention tool, classifies as a primary and
secondary crisis prevention approach (NASMHPD, 1999), which may
ultimately help to decrease the need for the use of restraint and seclusion
(Champagne & Stromberg, 2004; NETI, 2003). Therefore, given the
potential of this humane and recovery supportive treatment option and
the importance of engaging in evidence-based practice, it is necessary
for occupational therapists to begin studying the safety and effective
-
ness of the use of the weighted blanket.
Further, when requesting the allocation of resources to introduce a
novel treatment modality into clinical practice it is necessary to present
empirical evidence demonstrating that its use is within one’s scope of
practice and that it is both safe and effective. This may be achieved
through the application of principles from traditional social science and
engineering data analysis. Such an analysis will not only lead to a better
understanding of the therapeutic effects of deep pressure, but also will
lay the foundation for technological advances in the remote sensing of
anxiety (Luharuka, Gao, & Krishnamurty, 2003), and the engineering
of new and improved modalities offering deep pressure stimulation. To
this end, this paper presents the details of the first clinical study exploring
both the safety and effectiveness of the use of a 30 lb weighted blanket, the
heaviest available at the time of the study, with a heterogeneous conve-
nience sample of 32 volunteer adults.
Background Information
Deep Pressure Stimulation (DPS)
One of the qualities offered by the weighted blanket is DPS, which is
generally referred to as a form of touch pressure applied to the body
providing the feeling of a firm hug, holding, swaddling, or massage
(Grandin, 1992). Although there is no published research regarding the
use of the weighted blanket, there is a growing body of research sup
-
porting the use of DPS for varied therapeutic purposes. Interestingly,
when using Grandin’s Hug Machine, the use of DPS had a calming in
-
fluence for adults and children with anxiety, autism, and attention dif
-
ficulties (Edelson, Edelson, Kerr, & Grandin, 1999; Grandin, 1992).
Additionally, DPS applied through the use of the weighted vest, for chil
-
dren with pervasive developmental and attention disorders, influenced an
increased ability to focus on fine motor tasks (Fertel-Daly, Bedell, &
Hinojosa, 2001; Olson & Moulton, 2004a, 2004b; VandenBerg, 2001),
and a decrease in self-stimulatory behaviors (Fertel-Daly et al., 2001).
Mullen et al. 67
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
Foam-padded splints to the arms applying firm pressure appeared to help
reduce self-stimulatory and self-injurious behaviors in a child with au
-
tism (McClure & Holtz-Yotz, 1991). Wrist weights providing DPS influ
-
enced a reduction in self-injurious behaviors by 92% in a child with
intellectual disabilities (Hanley, Piazza, Keeney, Blakeley-Smith, &
Worsdell, 1998). These studies provide support for the use of DPS mo
-
dalities for a variety of treatment purposes, such as the facilitation of
attention, self-control, and a decrease in anxiety. While providing some
evidence of the effectiveness of the use of DPS modalities these studies
do not specifically explore the use of the weighted blanket or whether the
modalities used are safe.
Measuring Safety and Establishing Guidelines
Safety guidelines established for the use of backpacks have been gen-
eralized to the use of the weighted vests and weighted blankets (Olson &
Moulton, 2004a; Walker & McCormack, 2002). This includes recom-
mendations according to body weight ratios (5-10%), the distribution of
the weight, and wearing schedules. Weighted vests are typically used
while in ambulatory and/or seated positions, whereas the weighted blan-
ket is not meant for use while ambulating. Rather, the weighted blanket is
used while in a lying down or seated position. Therefore, applying the
same backpack safety guidelines to the use of the weighted blanket is
unsubstantiated. Further, clinical experience of the authors suggests
that for some consumers the use of a weighted blanket that is more than
10% of the person’s body weight may be preferred. Hence, there is a
need to explore whether the use of the 30 lb weighted blanket has a neg
-
ative influence on physiological safety and whether there are patterns or
preferences according to body weight. Vital signs provide information re
-
garding a person’s general health status and are used in this study to begin
to assess whether the deep pressure provided from a 30 lb weighted blan
-
ket influences adverse changes in the vital signs of the test participants.
Measuring Effectiveness
Mixed research methodology, the use of a combination of quantitative
and qualitative approaches, is considered a reliable way to measure the
effectiveness of therapeutic interventions (Creswell, 2003). Edelson et al.
(1999) used a mixed methods approach to explore the influence of DPS
provided by Grandin’s Hug Machine on the anxiety levels of children
with autism using the Connors Parent Rating Scale and electrodermal
activity (EDA). Skin conductance (SC), a measure of EDA, provides a
68 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
direct measure of sympathetic activity and has been one of the most
widely used quantitative metrics in psychophysiology research (Boucsein,
1992; Cacioppo, Tassinary, & Bernston, 2000). Although only a mar
-
ginal reduction in anxiety was revealed using SC, a significant decrease
in tension (a behavioral measure of anxiety) occurred, and researchers
concluded, “deep pressure appears beneficial for children with high lev
-
els of anxiety or arousal, and there may be a threshold of anxiety or
arousal required for deep pressure to be beneficial” (Edelson et al., 1999,
p. 151). Krauss (1987) examined the influence of DPS among college
students using a self-controlled mechanical device to self-administer
DPS with a pulley system, using qualitative surveys and body tempera
-
ture to monitor anxiety. Temperature is also a measure of sympathetic
arousal (Boucsein,1992). Although the results from Krauss’ study were
found to be inconclusive, these studies demonstrate the value of the
use of mixed methodology, including psychophysiological metrics in
addition to subjective self-report, when studying the influence of DPS.
Evidence demonstrates that sympathetic arousal is directly linked to
emotional and other cognitive processes such as attention, decision-mak-
ing, and memory (Damasio, Tranel, & Damasio, 1991; Damasio, 1994;
Bechara, Tranel, Damasio, & Damasio, 1996; Bechera, Damasio,
Tranel, & Damasio, 1997; Cahill, 1997). Further, chronic high levels
of sympathetic arousal are hallmarks of anxiety disorders and stress,
which are conditions associated with high levels of psychological and
physical morbidity (Russek, King, Russek, & Russek, 1990; Steptoe,
Cropley, & Joekes, 1999). It has also been demonstrated that treatments
influencing the reduction of autonomic arousal often reduce anxiety and
distress (Critchley, Melmed, Featherstone, Mathias, & Dolan, 2001).
Thus, it is hypothesized that the weighted blanket assists in helping con
-
sumers decrease anxiety and levels of distress. Since SC is a direct mea
-
sure of sympathetic nervous system activity, which is influenced by
anxiety, SC is a quantitative measure used to explore effectiveness. The
State Trait Anxiety Inventory-10 (STAI-10) and an exit survey are self
-
rating metrics, also used to explore effectiveness.
METHOD
Experimental Design
A concurrent, nested, mixed methods design was used to gather quan
-
titative and qualitative data. The qualitative data gathering process was
Mullen et al. 69
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
embedded within the quantitative procedures. Figure 1 shows the ex
-
perimental design.
Sample
A convenience sample of 34 people including 20 males and 14 fe
-
males participated in the study. Testing was interrupted for two partici
-
pants; therefore, the data for these two participants were not included in
the statistical analysis or results. Consequently, the final sample size of
the study was n = 32. The age range was 18-58, with a mean of 31 and a
standard deviation of 11.7. The population was skewed toward younger
people because a large number of the volunteers were undergraduate
and graduate students. The lowest body weight of the participants was
112 lb and the maximum was 234 lb with a mean of 165 lb and a standard
deviation of 27.8 lb. Inclusion criteria required consenting, non-hospi-
talized, volunteer adults with no apparent medical conditions or physical
70 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
FIGURE 1. Experimental design overview.
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
injuries between the ages of 18 and 64. Because this was an exploratory
study, a diverse group of people participated. It is understood however,
that age, sex, weight, and race may have varying influences on psycho
-
physiological processes and responses.
Using random assignment and a cross over design the participants
were divided into two groups, each person receiving an even or odd
code and number designation. All persons participated in two-test ses
-
sions, one session with the treatment (the 30 lb weighted blanket) and
one session without the treatment. The code the person was assigned de
-
termined whether the treatment was given during the first or second
testing session. An even code required the use of the treatment (30 lb
weighted blanket) during the first testing session, an odd code required
use of the treatment during the second testing session. Before any testing
or data collection occurred age, sex, and weight were recorded and all
participants signed an informed consent document. The informed consent
document explained potential risks or harm that could arise from being
a participant in the experiment, provided a general summary of the in-
struments to be used, and also the procedures that would take place
throughout the course of the experiment. Before starting the experiment,
the participants were each individually introduced to the test environ-
ment, room, and equipment, and the procedures of the experiment were
thoroughly explained. Questions were encouraged and answered before
the volunteers were asked to sign the consent form. Being fully informed
helps to reduce uncertainty regarding the testing procedures; otherwise,
the novelty of the experience may influence the test responses.
Setting
The study was conducted at the nursing resource room at Skinner
Hall at the University of Massachusetts-Amherst (UMASS). Two nurs
-
ing resource rooms were set up to replicate a hospital-like setting, which
was determined to best afford a relatively controlled environment, al
-
lowing for comparisons to be made in future studies conducted in an
acute mental health care hospital setting. Hospital beds with pull cur
-
tains were used to seclude participants from the monitoring equipment
and most of the stimulation of the rest of the room. During the experi
-
ment, the resource room door was locked, a sign was placed on the door
to inform the public that an experiment was taking place, and only the
participant and data collector were allowed in the room. Before the data
collection phase of the test session, the curtain was closed around the
bed; the data and all the equipment connected to the sensors were behind
Mullen et al. 71
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
the curtain and out of view of the participant. The room temperatures
ranged between 72 and 75 Fahrenheit.
Procedures
Grandin (1992) reported the need to use 5 minutes of sustained DPS
to produce a calming influence with children. Anecdotally, the authors
have noticed that the influence is often observable within minutes of use
with adolescent-, adult-, and geriatric-populations in acute care mental
health settings. For the purposes of this initial exploratory study, 5-min
-
ute time frames with and without the treatment were used. The partici
-
pants were given a 5-minute break between testing sessions where they
were required to complete a STAI-10 survey and leave the testing area.
The data collection equipment was set to have no alarms or noises and
remained quiet throughout the monitoring phases. All participants were
tested in the lying down position. Blood pressure was monitored on
the right upper extremity and all pulse oximetry, pulse rate, and SC data
were collected from the right hand. To ensure the consistency of proce-
dures and data collection throughout the experiment for all participants,
data collectors used a standardized data-recording protocol document and
practice sessions.
Instruments
The Treatment: The Weighted Blanket
One 30 lb weighted blanket was located at each of the two experiment
stations. The weighted blankets used in this study were 56 inches 76
inches in size and each blanket weighed 5 lb in itself (with all of the
weights removed). The blankets were each set up to contain five addi
-
tional (removable) 5 lb sleeves of nylon material filled with popcorn
seed, each running the length of the blanket and securely buttoned into
place. Velcro secured each of the openings around the edge of the blan
-
ket. The additional five weighted sleeves served to provide an addi
-
tional 25 lb of weight in an evenly distributed manner throughout the
blanket. Thus, each blanket weighed a total of 30 lb. The blankets used
in this study were purchased from Weighted Wearables and ordered spe
-
cifically to be consistent in make/style, materials used, and weight. This
was carefully specified and subsequently verified by the researchers.
72 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
Quantitative Measure of Safety: Vital Signs
For the purposes of this initial study exploring safety, the following vi
-
tal sign metrics were used: pulse oximetry, pulse rate, and blood pressure.
Each participant’s vital signs, data with the blanket and without the
blanket, were compared for each vital sign measured in order to deter
-
mine if the blanket influenced a change in vital signs. Table 1 shows the
safe ranges of the vital signs for adult populations, when in an upright
position (Barkauskas, Baumann, & Darling-Fisher, 2002). There are no
standardized vital sign parameters available for the lying down position;
thus, the information in Table 1 was used as a general guideline. It is well
established however that blood pressure and pulse rate decreases when
someone is lying down (Barkauskas et al., 2002).
Vital signs were obtained using a GE 4000 vital signs machine
(Model # DSH04490805GA). Pulse oximetry (SpO
2
) is a measure of
the amount of oxygen concentration in the blood. It is measured by plac-
ing a probe onto a person’s finger. The SpO
2
reading is also known as
the oxygen saturation level and is recorded as a percentage. The normal
SpO
2
range is from 90 to 100% in adult populations (Barkauskas et al.,
2002). Pulse rate indicates the number of times the heart beats per minute.
The anatomy and physiology of the blood pressure “is the interaction of
the cardiac output and peripheral resistance and is dependent on the ve-
locity of the arterial blood, intravascular volume, and the elasticity of the
arterial walls” (Barkauskas et al., 2002, p. 175). There are normal varia-
tions that can occur with a person’s blood pressure. Typically the first
reading is higher than others and at least one to three minutes should be
left between readings for accuracy. An average of readings over time
affords the best indication of an individual’s baseline blood pressure
(Barkauskas et al., 2002).
Mullen et al. 73
TABLE 1. Vital Signs Parameters
Age Temperature Pulse
per/min
Respirations
per/min
Oximetry
Spo
2
BP Systolic
(mm Hg)
BP Diastolic
(mm Hg)
Adult 98.6 / 1 60 to 100
(Mean 75)
12 to 20 90 to 100% 100 to 130 60 to 85
Adapted from: Harkreader, H. and Hogan, M. A. (2004), and Barkauskas, Baumann, and Darling-Fisher
(2002).
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
Quantitative Measure of Effectiveness:
Electrodermal Activity (EDA)
The effectiveness of the 30 lb weighted blanket is measured using
EDA, the STAI-10, and an exit survey. EDA continuously changes over
time and influences the increased or decreased activity of the eccrine sweat
glands, and is measured through the collection of SC (Stern, Ray, &
Quigley, 2001). Hence, for the purposes of this study, SC is used as the
quantitative indicator of anxiety. Skin Conductance (SC) is obtained us
-
ing the ProComp SC sensor from Thought Technology, using a con
-
stant-voltage sampling of SC at a rate of 32 hz with an accuracy of 5%.
Silver chloride cup electrodes were used to minimize the development of
bias potentials and polarization. The electrodes were secured to the volar
surfaces of the first and second distal phalanges of the right hand of each
participant, using Velcro fasteners. Since the results will be compared,
10% accuracy is used as the significance level, because, when comparing
the control group to the treatment group, it is possible that one of the read-
ings may have an error of 5% and the other by 5%.
RESULTS
Vital Signs Analysis and Interpretation
For the purposes of this study, a negative influence in vital sign mea-
sures concludes that the use of the 30 lb weighted blanket is unsafe for the
participant. When the vital sign measures remain within the participant’s
normal range it is concluded that the treatment is generally safe. Not
taken into consideration during this initial exploration of the safety of
the use of the 30 lb weighted blanket include additional safety factors
related to medical conditions not experienced by the participants (e.g.,
fractured bones, open wounds, circulatory disorders, pregnancy).
The safety results, as evidenced by the three vital signs metrics used,
are shown in the following sections. The ending values are analyzed
closely because the end of the 5-minute test sessions shows the accumu
-
lated influence of the blanket use. The recorded values of the vital signs
data during the sessions without the blanket were used as a baseline. The
baseline data were compared to the data collected when the blanket
was used to determine if the blanket is the cause of the participant be
-
ing within an unsafe range. A baseline is necessary since some of the
74 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
participants may naturally be outside of the safe ranges at their baseline
or because of some other unknown contributing variable.
Pulse Oximetry (SPO
2
)
Only 20 of the 32 participants were included in the pulse oximetry
analysis because of sensor attachment problems during data collection.
Table 2 shows the initial and final SPO
2
measurements for 20 participants
with complete sets of data collected, both with and without the blanket.
None of the participants shown in Table 2 have a final oxygen level be
-
low 90%. Thus, there is no evidence to show that the weighted blanket
causes any adverse affects to the amount of oxygen in the blood.
Pulse Rate
As shown in Figure 2, none of the participants have a final pulse rate
greater than 100 beats per minute with or without the blanket. There are
seven participants whose pulse rates are under 60 beats per minute, with
and/or without the blanket. Of the participants with a pulse rate below
Mullen et al. 75
TABLE 2. Pulse Oximetry Results
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
60 beats per minute, only one person’s pulse rate with the blanket is
below his/her control value without the blanket. This suggests that those
participants may normally have a pulse rate outside the general safe range
and that the weighted blanket was not the cause of the pulse rate being out
of the safe range.
Blood Pressure (BP)
The volunteer’s initial and final BP is averaged to account for the
variation in BP as discussed in the introduction. On average, all partici
-
pants are found to be at the low end of the safe range. Only one participant
has an average BP, in either of the 5-minute test sessions, in the high end
of the safe range. Participant #2 has a high BP average. Upon further ex
-
amination of this participant’s data, however, 3 of the 4 readings were
on the low end of the safe range. Only the first BP reading was high and
out of the safe range. Participant #2 had the blanket applied during the
first test session; the BP right before the blanket application was 150/89.
BP dropped to 121/76 by the end of the test session and was 124/77 and
125/72 for the beginning and end of the second test session, respectively.
Since the blanket was applied during the first session and the BP was high
before the blanket was applied, the high BP could have been a result of
76 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
FIGURE 2. Pulse rate results: Each participant’s pulse rate after 5 minutes
of testing with the weighted blanket (squares) and without the blanket (dia
-
monds).
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
anxiety caused by participating in the experiment. Thus, the conclusion
should not be made that the blanket caused participant #2 to have an av
-
erage BP out of the safe BP range over the test session.
Figure 3 shows the average systolic and diastolic BP for each person
with and without the blanket. The bold horizontal lines denote the safe
range over the course of the study. This figure shows that all but partici
-
pant #2 were inside the safe range for the BP guidelines for systolic blood
pressure. The majority of the participants were toward the lower end of
the safe range for the average diastolic BP.
In sum, it can be concluded that the data from the three different vital
sign measures collected show that the use of the 30 lb weighted blanket
did not cause the participants to move into an unsafe physiological range.
All 20 participants stayed above 90% for SPO
2
, all 32 participant’s pulse
rates stayed below 100 beats per minute and only one participant’s pulse
rate with the blanket was below his/her control value without the blanket.
Only one person was out of the safe range for systolic BP, which could
be attributed to anxiety from participating in the experiment, and not to
the blanket. No participant was outside of the safe range for diastolic BP.
The data give no evidence to indicate that the use of the 30 lb weighted
blanket is unsafe.
Mullen et al. 77
FIGURE 3. Average diastolic and systolic blood pressure for each participant
with the blanket (squares) and without (diamonds) the blanket.
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
EDA Data Analysis and Interpretation
Data interpretation is a critical step in the scientific study of the time
series data gathered using SC. It requires a standardization procedure that
ensures the integrity of information contained in the raw data in a consis
-
tent and uniform manner. Accordingly, this study introduces one such
procedure to address the lag time effects related to sensor amplification,
the uncertainty associated with the response starting and ending times,
and the influence of external factors such as the curtain is closing and
opening affecting the responses. Specifically, to overcome the inherent
drawbacks by using the raw data, the SC recordings were extended in
this study to both before and after the actual test duration of 5 minutes.
Additionally, the actual start time was identified as the time at which
there was a noticeable drop in the SC reading caused by movement be
-
fore the person was considered to be settled into the rest position, and
the corresponding SC reading at this start time was taken as the average
of the data up to that time. Figure 4 shows a sample time-series data and
the identification of the resulting 5-minute actual test session for further
data analysis.
Skin Conductance (SC) Results
Two of the 32 participants were dropped from the anxiety data analysis
because of problems with the SC sensor during their test sessions. Table 3
shows the mean values for the whole sample, the blanket first sample,
and the blanket second sample, as well as the standard deviation. The per-
cent change in the SC data is examined to study if there is a difference be
-
tween using the blanket and not using the blanket. This percent change
acts as the indicator of how much change occurs over the 5 minute pe
-
riod, taking into account different starting values by normalizing the
data. The average percent changes in Table 3 show that regardless of
blanket order or test session, SC values decrease significantly over time
indicating that the lying down position influences a reduction in anxi
-
ety. When examining each person’s response, 27 of the 30 participants
have a decrease in SC over both of the 5 minute test sessions.
Table 4 shows the comparison of percent change in SC between
participants over a period of 5 minutes. To compare the participants’
responses, the percent change with the blanket is subtracted from the
percent change without the blanket for each person. If the resulting
number is negative then the person had a larger percent change in SC
without the blanket than with the blanket. Ten of the 30 participants
78 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
demonstrated a significantly larger drop in SC when using the blanket
than when not using the blanket. Four of the 30 participants showed an
increase in SC with the blanket compared to when not using the blanket
and 16 participants had no significant difference between the two test ses
-
sions.
Table 5 shows the results from performing a Student’s T-test assuming
unequal variance comparing “with the blanket” to “without the blanket”
sample populations. T-tests were also used to compare the blanket ap
-
plied to the first group to the blanket being applied to the second group.
The results from the statistical analysis show that there is no significant
difference between using the blanket and not using the blanket, and there
-
fore, no difference between the orders in which the blanket was applied,
with an alpha of 0.05.
A z-test is also conducted for the entire sample because of the neces
-
sary assumption of having more than 30 participants to assume normal
-
ity. The results shown in Table 6 reveal a statistically significant result
Mullen et al. 79
FIGURE 4. Example of the GSR level data with the landmarks of participants’
adjustment period and curtain close time, and the 5-minute time span of testing
window.
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
when comparing “with the blanket” and “without the blanket,” having
an alpha of 0.05. This verifies that there is no difference due to ordering.
STAI-10 Analysis and Interpretation
The STAI-10, a subscale of the State Trait Anxiety Inventory, is a stan
-
dardized quantitative (closed-ended) 10 question survey used to measure
anxiety (Speilberger, Gorsuch, & Luchene, 1970). Data collected from
the STAI-10 were analyzed to show each participant’s self-rated per
-
ception of anxiety with and without the treatment. The results were also
used in comparison with SC data for further SC validation. Since the
STAI-10 data was to be directly compared to the SC data, the two par
-
ticipants who did not have SC results were not included in the analysis.
Using the STAI-10 results and comparing the scores obtained, after using
and not using the blanket, shows whether the use of the 30 lb weighted
blanket influences a larger decrease in self-perceived anxiety ratings.
STAI-10 scores and exit survey responses help to determine whether
80 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
TABLE 3. Average and Standard Deviation of the SC Data for the Whole Popu
-
lation
With Blanket Treatment
All Participants Blanket Applied
1
st
Sample
Blanket Applied
2
nd
Sample
Mean Standard
Deviation
Mean Standard
Deviation
Mean Standard
Deviation
Initial 4.33 5.22 4.38 3.89 4.65 6.62
Final 2.65 4.21 2.47 2.46 3.07 5.70
Percent Change 38.73 20.00 43.59 18.90 33.94 21.65
No Blanket Treatment
All Participants Blanket Applied
1
st
Sample
Blanket Applied
2
nd
Sample
Mean Standard
Deviation
Mean Standard
Deviation
Mean Standard
Deviation
Initial 4.36 4.53 4.25 3.57 4.76 5.63
Final 2.79 3.53 2.54 1.95 3.31 3.28
Percent Change 35.88 22.20 41.45 23.70 30.86 21.24
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
Mullen et al. 81
TABLE 4. Each Participant’s Percentage SC Change with and Without the
Blanket
Participant #
WB Percentage
Change
NB Percentage
Change
Difference
(WB-2NB)
3
36.67 28.71 7.96
5
20.68 23.02 2.34
7
66.67 64.02 2.65
9
24.06 33.33 9.28
11 55.33 46.70 8.63
15
48.35 44.19 4.17
17
44.32 1.10 45.42
19
66.40 48.05 18.35
21
14.66 13.92 0.75
23
59.62 85.31 25.68
25
49.22 25.02 24.21
27
64.33 33.72 30.61
29
30.77 25.00 5.77
31
29.65 45.31 15.66
33
7.89 17.24 25.14
2
28.47 7.06 21.41
4
48.54 33.33 15.21
6
67.57 11.68 55.89
8
22.01 30.13 8.12
10
50.00 42.07 7.93
12
12.31 44.99 32.68
14
50.49 25.17 75.66
16
27.71 22.92 4.79
18
6.67 5.26 1.40
20
42.52 39.06 3.46
22
56.17 45.46 10.63
24
59.17 43.43 15.74
28
66.05 61.85 4.20
30
43.37 47.98 4.61
34
55.46 63.34 7.88
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
EDA alone is a metric that correlates with the subjective ratings of the
blanket’s influence. Table 7 shows the average STAI-10 scores for the
participants. Higher scores correspond to higher anxiety ratings. On av
-
erage the participants scored lower after using the blanket than without
the blanket. For the participants having the blanket applied first, the
mean STAI-10 score was 12.5 compared to a mean score of 15.7 without
the blanket in the second session. For the sample population having the
blanket applied second, the mean score was, 13.2 with the blanket and
15.3 without the blanket.
These results show that at least 33% of the sample using the blanket
had a significantly greater drop in SC or anxiety than without using
82 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
TABLE 5. Statistical Results from the Student’s T-test Comparison
All Participants Blanket 1
st
Sample
Compared to
Blanket 2
nd
Sample
With
Blanket
No
Blanket
t Stat 1.426 z Stat 1.401 0.302 0.479
P(T t) one-tail 0.080 P(Z z) one-tail 0.081 0.383 0.318
t Critical one-tail 1.672 z Critical one-tail 1.645 1.701 1.701
P(T t) two-tail 0.159 P(Z z) two-tail 0.161 0.765 0.636
t Critical two-tail 2.002 z Critical two-tail 1.960 2.048 2.048
TABLE 6. Statistical Comparison of All Participants with the Blanket and With
-
out the Blanket
All Participants Blanket 1
st
Sample
Compared to
Blanket 2
nd
Sample
With
Blanket
No
Blanket
t Stat 3.102 z Stat 2.721 0.474 0.329
P(T t) one-tail 0.002 P(Z z) one-tail 0.003 0.320 0.372
t Critical one-tail 1.699 z Critical one-tail 1.645 1.725 1.701
P(T t) two-tail 0.004 P(Z z) two-tail 0.007 0.641 0.744
t Critical two-tail 2.045 z Critical two-tail 1.960 2.086 2.048
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
the blanket, and 53% of the sample experienced no difference when
comparing the blanket condition and the no-blanket condition. It was hy
-
pothesized that only a portion of the tested participants would respond to
the blanket with a reduction in anxiety, particularly given that it was a
low anxiety population as evidenced by the initial STAI-10 question-
naire results. Grandin (1992) specifically indicated that there might need
to be a threshold anxiety before DPS will be effective. Also, given that
the population is non-acute and, by lying down for 5 minutes anxiety lev-
els dropped greatly, it may be possible that participants reached their
steady (minimum anxiety) dynamic state or baseline SC so that the
blanket could not reduce SC levels much further.
From the STAI-10 survey data collected, there were 19 participants
whose anxiety decreased more with the blanket, 8 participants experi-
enced no change, and 3 had higher anxiety with the blanket than with-
out. Comparing the STAI-10 data to the SC data in Table 8, it seems that
SC accurately indicated the participant’s perceived change in anxiety
when the use of the blanket resulted in higher anxiety than without the
blanket. This raises the question as to why the SC data did not match the
STAI-10 survey data. Since the SC measurements indicated when the
anxiety of the participant was higher with the blanket and not for when
the anxiety was lower with the blanket suggests that by lying down for
5 minutes the participants reach their baseline SC even though anxiety
continues to decrease. For some participants using the blanket, the blan
-
ket influences an activating response and raises the SC above baseline
so the effects could be seen.
Exit Survey Analysis and Interpretation
In addition to STAI-10 data, the exit survey questions were analyzed
to explore each participant’s responses regarding the use of the weighted
Mullen et al. 83
TABLE 7. Average STAI-10 Data for All Participants with the Blanket and With
-
out the Blanket
STAI-10 All Participants Blanket 1
st
Sample Blanket 2
nd
Sample
Mean
Blanket Applied 12.87 12.53 13.20
No Blanket Applied 15.50 15.73 15.27
NB-WB 2.63 3.20 2.07
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
blanket, personal preferences, and whether the self-reports matched the
STAI-10 and SC results. When asked, “when did you feel more relaxed,
when using the blanket or when not using the blanket?” 25 of the 32 par-
ticipants (78%) reported that they felt more relaxed with the blanket than
without the blanket.
The exit survey included the question, “how did the amount of weight
feel?” with three choices to choose from: too much, not enough (I would
like it heavier), and good. Table 9 explores if there is a relationship be-
tween body weight and preference for a 30 lb weighted blanket. Only
one person reported that the 30 lb weighted blanket was “too much,”
and, given the variability of body weight among the participants, body
weight did not appear to significantly influence the person’s preference
regarding the 30 lb weighted blanket.
Additionally, the participants were asked to rank their preferences ac
-
cording to four of the qualities afforded by the weighted blanket using a
Likert scale [ranking very effective (1) through very ineffective (5)].
These qualities include: the warmth of the blanket (temperature), the
weight of the blanket (30 lb/deep pressure), the feel of the fabric (tactile),
and that it was voluntarily used (not forced upon the participant). Table 10
shows the varied responses.
Finally, to the question “any other comments about the SC or weighted
blanket?” Ten participants commented on the use of the blanket, and all
were positive comments. When comparing the SC data for these ten
particular participants, four had a larger percent change in SC with the
blanket, four had a larger percent change in SC without the blanket, and
two had no change.
84 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
TABLE 8. Statistical Comparison of the Group with the Blanket and Without the
Blanket
STAI-10 Skin Conductance
Greater Change
With Blanket
Greater Change
Without Blanket
No
Change
Total
Greater change with blanket 7 3 9 19
Greater change w/o blanket 1 1 1 3
No change 2 68
Total
10 4 16 30
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
DISCUSSION
Limitations
There are several limitations in this study. One limitation is that only
a 5-minute time frame was used in each of the test sessions; therefore,
results cannot be generalized to the use of the 30 lb weighted blanket for
longer time periods. Second, since one of the primary purposes of the
study was to research safety, participants were all required to use the
full 30 lb. When using the weighted blanket in clinical practice it is part
of the protocol to individualize the amount of weight used and the pre
-
ferred weight placement. Hence, different results may be obtained with
the individualization of the amount of weight used. Third, the pulse
oximetry and SC sensors did not stay in place for all of the participants;
therefore, not all participants’ pulse oximetry, pulse rate, and SC data
were obtained. Fourth, there may be a difference in the results if the group
without the blanket used a thin sheet rather than no sheet or blanket at
all. Fifth, there is an absence of well-established mathematical models
to characterize SC data without the use of other physiological measures
such as respiration, though general guidelines have been put forward
Mullen et al. 85
TABLE 9. Deep Pressure Stimulation (DPS) Self-Report
DPS of the 30 lb. Weighted Blanket Number of Responses Body Weight Ranges
“Not enough” 5 112 -234 lbs.
“Good” 26 114 -206 lbs.
“Too much” 1 174 lbs.
TABLE 10. Weighted Blanket Qualities: Participants Self-Ratings
Weighted Blanket Qualities
Participant’s Rankings
Very
Effective (1)
(2) (3) (4) Very
Ineffective (5)
Warmth (Temperature) 12 15 3 1 1
Weight (Deep pressure) 13 15 2 2 0
Feeling of the fabric (Tactile) 11 11 7 2 1
Voluntarily used (Not forced
upon you)
10 13 7 1 1
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
using parameters such as number of SC peaks and their corresponding
values (Boucsein, 1992). Thus, it is possible that the development and
subsequent use of empirical models, through additional dynamic and
statistical analysis of data, may provide more insight into the influence
of the use of the weighted blanket. A final limitation includes the use
of a low-to-no anxiety population, while according to Edelson et al.
(1999), a threshold of arousal or anxiety may be necessary to influence
SC changes when using modalities providing DPS. The low anxiety
contributed to the physiological signal to seemingly reach a floor during
the 5-minute test sessions.
Implications and Recommendations
This paper presents the results of a first exploratory study on the
safety and effectiveness of the use of a 30 lb weighted blanket among
a heterogeneous, non-hospitalized volunteer sample. A general proto-
col using quantitative and qualitative metrics was piloted to determine
whether it would be useful in future studies on the safety and effective-
ness of the weighted blanket. This research group will conduct these
studies with both an adult population during an acute inpatient mental
health hospitalization and a non-acute, volunteer adult population sub-
jected to a high anxiety task.
The results of this study demonstrate that the use of a 30 lb weighted
blanket did not adversely influence pulse oximetry, pulse rate, or blood
pressure. Further, using SC as an anxiety metric, 33% of the participants
were found to exhibit a greater reduction in anxiety with the weighted
blanket than without the blanket. Observations however, reveal that there
appear to be differences in the results. The corresponding STAI-10 sur
-
vey responses showed that 63% of the participants rated their anxiety
lower with the use of the weighted blanket. Furthermore, according to
the exit survey, 78% reported a lower anxiety after using the blanket
than when not using the blanket. Thus, the results indicate that the use
of the 30 lb weighted blanket has a calming influence for some adults.
For many participants, the perceived sense of relaxation is greater
than indicated by SC measures. This may be a result of some of the partic
-
ipants’ reaching a SC floor as a sole result of lying down for 5 minutes.
Further research comparing additional psychophysiological metrics
more sensitive to changes in anxiety, in conjunction with SC, may en
-
hance the ability to more accurately measure anxiety through the use
of quantitative measures. Future studies looking at correlations among
SC, DPS, age, sex, race, sensory tendencies, consumer preferences, and
86 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
diagnostic factors is recommended to continue exploring the safety and
effectiveness of the therapeutic use of the weighted blanket. Re
-
search is needed to explore other aspects of safety, such as the use of the
weighted blanket with people with different medical conditions. Addi
-
tionally, future research may afford the ability to gain knowledge of how
to engineer new technologies in the remote sensing of anxiety, and new
DPS devices specific to people’s unique needs and preferences.
REFERENCES
Barkauskas, V. H., Baumann, L. C., & Darling-Fisher, C. S. (2002). Health and physical
assessment (3rd Ed.). St. Louis: Mosby.
Bechara, A. Tranel, D. Damasio, H. & Damasio, A. R. (1996). Failure to respond au
-
tonomically to anticipated future outcomes following damage to prefrontal cortex.
Cerebral Cortex, 6, 215-225.
Bechara, A., Damasio, H., Tranel, D., & Damasio, A. R. (1997). Deciding advanta-
geously before knowing the advantageous strategy. Science, 275, 1293-1295.
Boucsein, W. (1992). Electrodermal activity. New York: Plenum Press.
Cacioppo, J. T., Tassinary, L. G., & Bernston, G. G. (2000). Handbook of psycho-
physiology (2nd Ed.). New York: Cambridge University Press.
Cahill, L. (1997). The neurobiology of emotionally influenced memory: Implications
for understanding traumatic memory. Annals of New York Academy of Science, 821,
238-246.
Champagne, T. (2005). Expanding the role of sensory approaches in acute psychiatric
settings. Mental Health Special Interest Section Quarterly, 28(1), 1-4.
Champagne, T. & Stromberg, N. (2004). Sensory approaches in inpatient psychiatric
settings: Innovative alternatives to seclusion and restraint. Journal of Psychosocial
Nursing, 42(9), 35-44.
Creswell, J. (2003). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods ap
-
proaches (2nd Ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications, Inc.
Critchley, H. D., Melmed, R. N., Featherstone, E., Mathias, C. J., & Dolan, R. J. (2001).
Brain activity during biofeedback relaxation: A functional neuroimaging investiga
-
tion. Brain, 124, 1003-1012.
Damasio, A. R. (1994). Descartes’ error: Emotion, reason, and the human brain. New
York: Putnam.
Damasio, A. R., Tranel, D., & Damasio, H. C. (1991). Somatic markers and the guid
-
ance of behavior: Theory and preliminary testing. In H. S. Levin, H. M. Eisenberg,
& A. L. Benton (Eds.), Frontal lobe function and dysfunction (pp. 217-229). New
York: Oxford University Press.
Department of Health and Human Services (2003). Achieving the promise: Transform
-
ing mental health care in America. Final Report. New Freedom Commission on Men
-
tal Health, DHHS Publication Number SMA-03-3832 ed. Rockville, Md.
Edelson, S., Edelson, M., Kerr, D., & Grandin, T. (1999). Behavioral and physiologi
-
cal effects of deep pressure on children with autism: A pilot study evaluating the
Mullen et al. 87
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
efficacy of Grandin’s hug machine. American Journal of Occupational Therapy,
53, 145-152.
Fertel-Daly, D., Bedell, G., & Hinojosa, J. (2001). The effects of the weighted vest on
attention to task and self-stimulatory behaviors in preschool children with pervasive
developmental disorders. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 55, 629-640.
Grandin, T. (1992). Calming effects of deep pressure in patients with autistic disorder,
college students, and animals. Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychopharmacology,
2, 63-72.
Hanley, G. P., Piazza, C. C., Keeney, K. M., Blakeley-Smith, A. B., & Worsdell, A. S.
(1998). Effects of wrist weights on self-injurious behaviors and adaptive behaviors.
Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 3, 307-310.
Harkreader, H. and Hogan, M. A. (2004). Fundamentals of Nursing: Caring and Clinical
Judgment (2nd Ed). St. Louis: W.B. Saunders
Heller, S. (2002). Too loud, too bright, too fast, too tight. What to do if you are sensory
defensive in an overstimulating world. New York: Harper Collins Publishers, Inc.
Huckshorn, K. A. (2004, September). Reducing seclusion and restraint use in mental
health settings. Journal of Psychosocial Nursing, 42, 22-33.
Krauss, K. (1987). The effects of deep pressure touch on anxiety. American Journal of
Occupational Therapy, 41, 366-373.
Luharuka, R., Gao, R., & Krishnamurty, S. (2003). Design and realization of a portable
data logger for physiological sensing. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and
Measurement, 52, 1289-1295.
McClure, M. K., & Holtz-Yotz, M. (1991). Case Report: The effects of sensory
stimulatory treatment on an autistic child. American Journal of Occupational Therapy,
45, 1138-1142.
Nackley, V. (2001). Sensory diet applications and environmental modifications: A win-
ning combination. Sensory Integration Special Interest Section Quarterly, 24(1), 1-4.
National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors, Medical Directors
Council. (1999). Reducing the use of seclusion and restraint. Alexandria, VA: Na
-
tional Association of State Mental Health Program Directors.
National Executive Training Institute (2003). Training curriculum for the reduction of
seclusion and restraint. Alexandria, VA: National Association of State Mental
Health Program Directors.
Olson, L. J., & Moulton, H. J. (2004a). Occupational therapists’ reported experiences
using weighted vests with children with specific developmental disorders. Occupa
-
tional Therapy International, 11, 52-66.
Olson, L. J., & Moulton, H. J. (2004b). Use of weighted vests in pediatric occupational
therapy practice. Physical and Occupational Therapy in Pediatrics, 24, 45-60.
Russek, L. G., King, S. H., Russek, S. J., & Russek, H. I. (1990). The Harvard mastery
of stress study 35-year follow-up: Prognostic significance of patterns of psychophys
-
iological arousal and adaptation. Psychosomatic Medicine, 52, 271-285.
Speilberger, C. D., Gorsuch, R. L., & Luchene, R. E. (1970). State-trait anxiety inven
-
tory. Palo Alto, CA. Consulting Psychology Press.
Steptoe, A., Cropley, M., & Joekes, K. (1999). Job strain, blood pressure and response
to uncontrollable stress. Journal of Hypertension, 17, 193-200.
88 OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY IN MENTAL HEALTH
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
Stern, R., Ray, W., & Quigley, K. (2001). Psychophysiological recording (2nd Ed.).
New York: Oxford University Press.
VandenBerg, N. L. (2001). The use of a weighted vest to increase on-task behavior in
children with attention difficulties. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 55,
621-628.
Walker, D. & McCormack, K. (2002). The weighted blanket an essential nutrient in a
sensory diet. Everett, MA: Village Therapy.
doi:10.1300/J004v24n01_05
RECEIVED: 05/03/06
REVISED: 11/02/06
ACCEPTED: 12/08/06
Mullen et al. 89
Downloaded by [University of Massachusetts, Amherst], [Sundar Krishnamurty] at 05:27 01 August 2014
... The use of WBs is believed to be safe, with no known side effects in the adult population [21][22][23]. However, the scientific evidence of the effect of WBs on the treatment of sleep difficulties is debateable [21]. ...
... The use of WBs is believed to be safe, with no known side effects in the adult population [21][22][23]. However, the scientific evidence of the effect of WBs on the treatment of sleep difficulties is debateable [21]. The clinical experience from prescribing a WB has been a positive effect on patient well-being [24,25]. ...
... The patients with heavier blankets generally reported greater improvements in sleep, as well as possible better daytime functioning. Furthermore, there were no indications of adverse events [21]. Baric et al. [28] found positive effects on both sleep quality and daily routines for a group of people with psychiatric diagnoses using the WB every night [28]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background: Weighted blankets (WBs) have been suggested as a treatment option for insomnia and are commonly prescribed despite lack of evidence of efficacy. Aim: To investigate prescription pattern, return rate and cost of WBs. Material and methods: This observational cohort register-based study in western Sweden included every individual who, in a 2.5-year period, was prescribed and received at least one WB (n = 4092). A cost evaluation was made by mapping prescription processes for WBs and sleep medication. Results: Individuals diagnosed with dementia, anxiety, autism or intellectual disability (ID) retained the WB longer than others. Individuals younger than six and older than 65 years had shorter use time. The cost evaluation showed that the prescription process for WBs was longer and resulted in a higher cost than for sleep medication. Conclusions: Some individuals had longer use time, indicating a possible benefit from using a WB. Due to low risk of harm but high economic cost, a revision of the WBs prescription process could be recommended to identify those who might benefit from WB. Significance: Our result points towards a need for revision of the prescription process, to implement standardized sleep assessments, and create a more efficient prescription process to lower the cost.
... Edelson et al. [29] evaluated Grandin's squeeze machine on 12 children with autism randomly assigned to two groups (experimental and placebo groups) and then reported that administering deep pressure had a calming effect or benefit for children with autism with high levels of anxiety or arousal. The administration of deep pressure treatment with a 30-pound weighted blanket displayed no adverse effects on the user's vital signs (blood pressure, pulse rate, and pulse oximetry) targeting adult mental health consumers [30,31]. Research related to the effect of using a pressure vest has been conducted. ...
... Heart rate is one vital sign that is commonly used to measure the physiological effect of deep pressure devices [30,31,38]. Heart rate was measured using Elitech ® FOX-1 pulse oximetry (Surabaya, Indonesia) by recording blood oxygenation pulsations. ...
... The results showed that during the administration of a stressful film, the heart rate indicator did not show a significant difference, while the skin conductance showed a significant difference compared to a non-stressful film [45]. Similar results were also found in a study related to deep pressure application with a short period of application using a weighted blanket [30,31]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Traveling with children with autism can be very challenging for parents due to their reactions to sensory stimuli resulting in behavioral problems, which lead to self-injury and danger for themselves and others. Deep pressure was reported to have a calming effect on people with autism. This study was designed to investigate the physiological effect of deep pressure, which is an autism hug machine portable seat (AHMPS) in children with autism spectrum disorders (ASD) in public transportation settings. The study was conducted with 20 children with ASD (16 boys and 4 girls) at the Semarang Public Special School with an age ranging from 4 to 13 years (mean 10.9 ± 2.26 years), who were randomly assigned into two groups. The experiment consisted of group I who used the AHMPS inflatable wraps model and group II who used the AHMPS manual pull model. Heart rate (HR) and skin conductance (SC) were analyzed to measure the physiological calming effect using pulse oximeter oximetry and a galvanic skin response (GSR) sensor. Heart rate was significantly decreased during the treatment compared to the baseline (pre-test) session in group I (inflating wrap model) with p = 0.019, while no change of heart rate variability (HRV) was found in group II (manual pull model) with p = 0.111. There was no remaining effect of deep pressure using the HRV indicator after the treatment in both groups (group I with p = 0.159 and group II with p = 0.566). GSR captured the significant decrease in skin conductance during the treatment with p < 0.0001 in group I, but no significant decrease was recorded in group II with p = 0.062. A skin conductance indicator captured the remaining effect of deep pressure (after the treatment); it was better in group I (p = 0.003) than in group II (p = 0.773). In conclusion, the deep pressure of the AHMPS inflating wrap decreases physiological arousal in children with ASD during traveling.
... Research demonstrates that broad, deep pressure touch stimulation increases the arousal of the parasympathetic nervous system, while also reducing sympathetic arousal (Chen et al., 2016;Reynolds et al., 2015). The increase in parasympathetic arousal is hypothesized to have a calming effect, while the decrease in sympathetic arousal is associated with changes in physiological processes that dampen the body's physiologic stress response (Chen et al., 2016;Mullen et al., 2008;Reynolds et al., 2015). Daily use of weighted blankets has shown reductions in stress-related psychologic and physiologic symptoms among non-cognitively impaired older adults with mental health conditions (Champagne et al., 2015;Mullen et al., 2008). ...
... The increase in parasympathetic arousal is hypothesized to have a calming effect, while the decrease in sympathetic arousal is associated with changes in physiological processes that dampen the body's physiologic stress response (Chen et al., 2016;Mullen et al., 2008;Reynolds et al., 2015). Daily use of weighted blankets has shown reductions in stress-related psychologic and physiologic symptoms among non-cognitively impaired older adults with mental health conditions (Champagne et al., 2015;Mullen et al., 2008). ...
... Research demonstrates that deep pressure tactile stimulation may increase the arousal of the parasympathetic nervous system, while also reducing sympathetic arousal (Chen et al., 2016;Reynolds, Lane, & Mullen, 2015). The increase in parasympathetic arousal is hypothesized to have a calming effect, while the decrease in sympathetic arousal is associated with changes in emotional and cognitive processes (Chen et al., 2016;Mullen et al., 2008;Reynolds et al., 2015). ...
Thesis
People living with dementia (PLWD) often experience behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD) which are burdensome to those diagnosed, their families, and society. Many non-pharmacologic interventions have demonstrated efficacy in reducing BPSD in research but have had limited uptake in the community, possibly due to lack of feasibility and limited acceptance by PLWD and their family caregivers. Acutherapy and weighted blankets are non-pharmacologic interventions that have improved outcomes among older adults, but few studies have focused on PLWD and BPSD. The purpose of this research was to explore the potential of acutherapy and weighted blankets as non-pharmacologic interventions to reduce BPSD in PLWD. The research presented in this 3-paper dissertation was guided by 6 specific aims: 1. Identify, examine, and synthesize the state of the science relating to the effects of acutherapy on BPSD. (Paper 1) 2. Explore perspectives of family caregivers of community dwelling older adults with Alzheimer’s disease or related dementias (ADRD) regarding BPSD and use of non-pharmacologic interventions for BPSD management. (Paper 2) 3. Explore perspectives of family caregivers of community dwelling older adult family members with ADRD regarding changes in their caregiving experiences, BPSD displayed by their relatives with ADRD and BPSD management strategies used during the COVID-19 pandemic. (Paper 2) 4. Explore initial perceptions of family caregivers regarding weighted blankets as an in-home care strategy for community dwelling PLWD following a brief description and visual presentation of weighted blankets. (Paper 3) 5. Examine feasibility and acceptability of a virtually delivered, in-home weighted blanket intervention for older adults with ADRD living in the community as perceived by the family caregiver and the person with ADRD. (Paper 3) 6. Examine feasibility of collecting outcome measures of BPSD, cognitive function, and quality of life of care recipients with ADRD, and well-being and self-reported health status of family caregivers. (Paper 3) Aims were addressed using: a scoping review methodology (Aim 1); a qualitative approach using semi-structured interviews with 21 family caregivers living with community dwelling PLWD (Aims 2, 3, and 4); a prospective, within subjects, pre-post design study with 21 community dwelling PLWD and their family caregivers (Aims 5 and 6). This dissertation research had 6 key findings: 1) Acutherapy is a safe non-pharmacologic care strategy for PLWD and a potential treatment for BPSD, but additional research is needed to determine efficacy; 2) The caregiving experience of family caregivers of community dwelling PLWD was described as an interdependent partnership between the caregiver and the PLWD; 3) Family caregivers and PLWD experienced challenges to in-home care prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, many of which were compounded by it; 4) The virtually delivered, in-home weighted blanket intervention was feasible and acceptable to PLWD and their family caregivers; 5) Collecting outcome measures of care recipient cognitive function, caregiver well-being and caregiver self-reported health was feasible; 6) Collecting outcome measures of care recipient BPSD and quality of life was feasible through measures completed by caregiver report, but not by care recipient self-report. The efficacy of feasible and acceptable care strategies for community dwelling PLWD must be determined to promote broader uptake by clinicians, support service providers, and families. As BPSD are overwhelming for PLWD, their families, and society, we are in dire need of evidence-based non-pharmacological interventions to reduce the burden and improve the quality of life of PLWD and their families.
... Sensory approaches are a safe and empowering means for consumers to self-manage distress and agitation (Hedlund Lindberg et al. 2019), and include a range of techniques that target sight, touch, taste, hearing, smell, and/or proprioception to assist regulation of emotional and physiological arousal (Scanlan & Novak, 2015). Weighted modalities (WMs) are a sensory approach providing deep pressure stimulation to reduce arousal and promote a sense of calm (Eron et al. 2020;Mullen et al. 2008). ...
... WMs reduce arousal through distraction, safe containment, and grounding, and have been found effective and safe for use with adults during inpatient mental health admissions (Champagne et al. 2015;Mullen et al. 2008;Sutton & Nicholson, 2011), although higher quality evidence and guidelines for use are needed (Eron et al. 2020). While most studies on sensory approaches, including use of WMs, have explored changes in consumers' self-rated distress and seclusion and/or restraint rates (Eron et al. 2020;Scanlan & Novak, 2015), few have explored whether the use of sensory approaches is associated with reduced use of PRN. ...
Article
Implementing psychosocial approaches into mental health inpatient settings continues to be challenging. This is despite mental health policies prioritizing trauma-informed and recovery-orientated care approaches. This study reports on an interdisciplinary project that implemented and examined the uptake of weighted modalities in a psychiatric inpatient rehabilitation setting. While over-reliance on pro re nata (PRN) medication in these settings has been reported, weighted modalities are a sensory approach that can be self-initiated by consumers as an alternative to use of PRN to manage distress and agitation. A mixed-methods realist approach was used to determine what works, for whom, and in what circumstances weighted modalities were offered by clinicians and used by consumers. Additionally, we were interested in determining whether there was an associated change in PRN use during the trial. Data included in-depth interviews with consumers (n = 12) and clinicians (n = 11), and extraction of PRN medication use preceding, throughout, and following implementation. Statistical analysis revealed a significant increase in PRN rates in the first 3 months of implementation (mean difference from baseline = 29.5, P = 0.047) but a significant decrease in the second three-month period following implementation (mean difference from baseline = −30.7, P = 0.036). Qualitative findings highlighted the key components of successful implementation as being environmental restructuring (availability/accessibility and visibility of weighted modalities) and social influences. Strategies to enhance these components are discussed.
... Therefore, the experiences of nursing staff are essential in assessing and understanding the influence on health expression that the non-pharmacological implementation as a weighted blanket may have on residents (Ancoli-Israel, 2009;MacLeod et al., 2018;Slettebø et al., 2017;Webster et al., 2020). The non-pharmacological intervention of a weighted blanket creates deep pressure on the body and dampens the sympathetic response associated with, for example, anxiety and sleep problems (Mullen et al., 2008;Reynolds et al., 2015). ...
... Information on how the weighted blanket test was to be performed was also provided in writing to all nursing staff. The weighted blanket used in the study was made of chains and weighed about 10% of each participant's body weight A weighted blanket with about 10% of a person's weight has been shown to have a calming effect (Mullen et al., 2008). In this study, the weighted blanket varied between 4 and 8 kg, depending on the weight of the resident. ...
Article
Purpose The most common treatment for resident’s health problems is pharmacological. Little research has been done on how an intervention with a non-pharmacological method, such as a weighted blanket, Through the nursing staff view, we can learn how weighted blankets influence resident’s health in nursing homes. The aim of this study was to explore nursing staff’s experiences of how an intervention with weighted blankets influenced resident’s expressions of health. Methods The study had a descriptive qualitative design with semi-structured interviews with 20 nursing staff working in nursing homes, and an inductive content analysis was applied. Results The nursing staff expressed that the weighted blanket positively influenced resident’s health in the areas of sleep, physical activity, and psychological behaviour. The weighted blanket made them fall asleep faster, sleep was uninterrupted andthey felt more rested in the morning. The nursing staff observed an increased level of activity as the resident became more energetic . The nursing staff also experienced reduced negative psychological behaviours like anxiety and worrying.
... Therefore, the experiences of nursing staff are essential in assessing and understanding the influence on health expression that the non-pharmacological implementation as a weighted blanket may have on residents (Ancoli-Israel, 2009;MacLeod et al., 2018;Slettebø et al., 2017;Webster et al., 2020). The non-pharmacological intervention of a weighted blanket creates deep pressure on the body and dampens the sympathetic response associated with, for example, anxiety and sleep problems (Mullen et al., 2008;Reynolds et al., 2015). ...
... Information on how the weighted blanket test was to be performed was also provided in writing to all nursing staff. The weighted blanket used in the study was made of chains and weighed about 10% of each participant's body weight A weighted blanket with about 10% of a person's weight has been shown to have a calming effect (Mullen et al., 2008). In this study, the weighted blanket varied between 4 and 8 kg, depending on the weight of the resident. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose The most common treatment for resident’s health problems is pharmacological. Little research has been done on how an intervention with a non-pharmacological method, such as a weighted blanket, Through the nursing staff view, we can learn how weighted blankets influence resident’s health in nursing homes. The aim of this study was to explore nursing staff’s experiences of how an intervention with weighted blankets influenced resident’s expressions of health. Methods The study had a descriptive qualitative design with semi-structured interviews with 20 nursing staff working in nursing homes, and an inductive content analysis was applied. Results The nursing staff expressed that the weighted blanket positively influenced resident’s health in the areas of sleep, physical activity, and psychological behaviour. The weighted blanket made them fall asleep faster, sleep was uninterrupted andthey felt more rested in the morning. The nursing staff observed an increased level of activity as the resident became more energetic . The nursing staff also experienced reduced negative psychological behaviours like anxiety and worrying. Conclusion This study indicated that the weighted blanket changed the health expression of resident in several crucial areas. Deep pressure treatment indicates an alternative health-improved treatment for resident in nursing homes.
... Such interventions are successfully used by occupational therapists working in other fields of practice, such as mental health, to improve self-regulation and occupational participation. Sensory modulation interventions have been reported as effective in regulating behaviors and have little to no adverse effects (Mullen et al., 2008). People living with ABI present similarly to those with mental illness in regard to behavioral disturbance and, therefore, this approach has potential to be transferred across settings. ...
Article
Full-text available
Abstract Background: Behavioral disturbance impacts almost 50% of people living with acquired brain injury (ABI) and severely impedes occupational participation. Occupational therapists are appropriately qualified and well placed to address behavioral disturbance. This scoping review analyzes the literature to ascertain approaches used by occupational therapists to treat behavioral disturbance. Method: A literature search of three databases revealed 379 papers for consideration, five of which met inclusion criteria. The Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) checklists were used for the analysis. This paper employs the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA) framework. Results: Sensory modulation interventions, community-based interventions, behavior therapy, and neurofunctional activity of daily living (ADL) retraining were identified as approaches that could be used by occupational therapists to promote participation for people living with behavioral disturbance after an ABI. Conclusion: According to current occupational therapy literature, evidenced-based behavioral interventions to enable participation for almost half of people living with an ABI are lacking. To promote the occupational therapy role in this area of rehabilitation, further empirical research is needed.
Chapter
Durch zwischenmenschliche Berührungen u. a. in Form von Massagen können verschiedenste physiologische Prozesse in Gang gesetzt werden. Zum Beispiel können Entspannungsmassagen Depression, Angst und Fatigue reduzieren, Schlaf verbessern, Stress abbauen, Blutzucker und Blutdruck senken und das Immunsystem regulieren. Die Befunde sind im Einklang mit Erkenntnissen der Psychoneuroimmunologie und Psychoneuroendokrinologie. Aus diesen Fachgebieten ist bekannt, dass Psyche und Nervensystem sowohl mit dem Immunsystem als auch dem Hormonsystem in Wechselwirkung stehen. Kurz gesagt bedeutet das, dass Veränderungen in einem der Systeme, Veränderungen in allen anderen Systemen nach sich ziehen. Daraus ergeben sich vielfältige Einsatzmöglichkeiten von zwischenmenschlichen Berührungen und Massagen als unterstützende Therapiemethode im Krankheitsfall. Außerdem in diesem Kapitel: Gewichtsdecken/ Sandwesten; Kontraindikationen und Nebenwirkungen von Massagen
Article
Introduction: Current research evidence suggests that people with schizophrenia have sensory processing difficulties. Sensory modulation has growing evidence for use in this population. This study aimed to evaluate the extent to which health, social, cognitive, and occupational functioning outcomes were impacted by sensory modulation interventions for people with schizophrenia. Methods: A prospective observational cohort study using a waitlist control design was used in two large hospital and health services in Queensland, Australia. The study recruited patients who used sensory modulation (n = 30) across the two hospitals and those who did not use sensory modulation interventions as a control (n = 11). Results were analysed using a series of planned comparisons including independent and paired t-tests, and mixed ANOVA was used whenever statistically indicated. The analysed measures were pre- and post-intervention scores. Results: This study found no statically significant differences between the control and intervention groups at both pre- and post-intervention. However, analysis of results from within the intervention group showed statistically significant improvements between pre- and post-test scores on distress, occupational functioning, and health and social functioning but not on sensory processing and global cognitive processing. Further analysis of results from this study, compared with those from an earlier study on the general population showed significant differences in Low Registration and Sensation Avoiding, as measured by the Adult/Adolescent Sensory Profile, between participants with schizophrenia and those without schizophrenia. Conclusion: This study provides evidence to suggest that sensory modulation interventions can be complementary to standard care when utilised appropriately in clinical settings. Findings also suggest that the sensory profile of people with schizophrenia is different to that of the general population and this may have clinical implications. Further longitudinal research is needed with larger and randomised samples, using more targeted measures to better explore effectiveness of sensory modulation interventions.
Article
Background Emergence delirium (ED) is a significant problem in the post anesthesia care unit (PACU), resulting in dislodgement of medical devices, patient and staff injury, prolonged recovery, and parent dissatisfaction. Parental requests for the use of weighted blankets in the hospital setting have increased. However, while weighted blankets have shown potential as treatment for anxiety in adults and children, no studies have demonstrated their safe use with children in the hospital setting. Purpose To explore the safety of weighted blanket use with children in the PACU as an intervention for ED, a feasibility study was conducted. Design and Methodology: A convenience sample of 93 participants, aged three to 10 years were recruited. Watcha scores, vital signs, length of wear time, and reason for blanket removal were recorded for all patients. Results Eighty-five patients completed the study. Four participants experienced vital signs outside the defined safety parameters, with only one experiencing an adverse event (1.2%). This was consistent with the historic adverse event rate of 1% for the study site. Staff did not report issues with the use or cleaning of the blankets. Of interest, there was significant correlation between ED and suspected pain. Conclusion The study demonstrated weighted blanket use is safe and feasible with children in the hospital setting, Additional studies are needed to determine the effectiveness of weighted blankets as an intervention for ED and the impact pain may have on the severity and prevalence of ED.
Article
Substantial evidence from animal and human subject studies converges on the view that memory for emotionally arousing events is modulated by an endogenous memory-modulating system consisting, at minimum, of stress hormones and the amygdaloid complex. Within the normal range of emotions experienced, this system is viewed as an evolutionarily adaptive method of creating memory strength that is, in general, proportional to memory importance. In conditions of extreme emotional stress, the operation of this normally adaptive system may underly the formation of strong, "intrusive" memories characteristic of PTSD. An improved understanding of the neurobiology of memory modulation should lead to an improved ability to treat or prevent traumatic memories. Language: en