Building resilience and well‐being in the Margins within the City: Changing perceptions, making connections, realising potential, plugging resources leaks

ArticleinCity 15(2):181-203 · April 2011with 26 Reads
Cite this publication
Regeneration policy in the UK has failed to deliver real gains for many of the inner‐city neighbourhoods that it was meant to help, but particularly those on the margins of our most prosperous and affluent city centres. In Leeds in 2008 an independent group of professionals came together through a project called ‘Margins within the City’ to challenge thinking about regeneration in the city. We wanted to find new ways of understanding the neighbourhoods in the rim around the city centre, uncover the potential of these neighbourhoods for future resilience and well‐being and suggest ways forward. A year‐long programme of action research was undertaken to pilot an approach to investigating the social networks, skills and enterprise, and under‐utilised land and buildings in a case study neighbourhood. This paper shows the approach and method for the research, the cross‐cutting themes within the findings and the recommendations for future policy development. It suggests that if social and physical connections are mended, established and extended, then perceptions can be radically changed, resource and ecological leaks plugged, and under‐utilised potential more fully realised.

Do you want to read the rest of this article?

Request full-text
Request Full-text Paper PDF
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Regeneration strategies and transport improvement in a deprived area: what can be learnt from Northern France? Regional Studies. This paper reports on a case study in an ex-coal-mining area in northern France that faces different socio-economic problems along with a limited public transportation system. Over the last decades it has undergone several regeneration strategies. The study analyses transport behaviour, the impact of major potential regeneration projects and residents’ needs. The research is based on qualitative analysis and focuses on those population groups with limited transportation availability or at risk of social exclusion. The results show that many different transport policy measures are needed in order to achieve successful regeneration.
  • Article
    While commonly pitched as potential spaces for the empowerment of marginalised minority groups, self-organised projects such as community gardens are also susceptible to neoliberal discourses and governance mechanisms. While relationships between community gardening and gentrification are now well established, less is known about the grassroots strategies of garden groups in the context of such conditions and the ways in which gentrification changes the community gardening movement itself. This paper combines conceptual approaches to community gardens as shaping citizen-subjectivities and as projects positioned in networks to offer detailed insight into strategic responses of community gardeners to a gentrifying environment. The paper highlights how demographic change, neighbourhood densification and changes in the attitude of local government shape three community gardens in Sydney, Australia. The paper reveals that, more than government policy, changes that gardeners observe in the neighbourhood and their perceptions of local government’s attitude towards different community gardens in the vicinity, shape how they manage community gardens. Interactions and responses of garden groups to perceived threats, as well as changes in the projects’ social composition, can lead to the emergence of conflict and competition. As it becomes increasingly clear that inequalities in the surrounding urban environment manifest as part of the social fabric of community spaces, the paper demonstrates that communities are differently positioned to articulate strategies in response to perceived precarity and that these strategies can amplify unequal opportunities for distinct garden groups to persist into the future.
  • In the last decade, urban studies scholars have been studying a wide variety of urban regeneration strategies formulated by social movements and civic networks. These initiatives range from physical interventions to social and cultural activities that also serve to appropriate urban space, according to an alternative logic to neo-liberal redevelopment plans. The aim of this paper is to participate in this debate by focusing on urban interventions that arise from self-organised local civic networks, to which I refer to as urban regeneration ‘from the bottom up’. The term includes proposals, projects or effective actions that are not yet framed by a public policy implemented by governments. Drawing on empirical research in the Navigli area of Milan, Italy, civic network initiatives are contrasted to municipal strategies of regeneration. By focusing on two different experiences I show how civic networks’ actions respond to neo-liberalism ambiguously: they challenge it, but at the same time they are consistent with its logic. In the conclusion, it is claimed that urban regeneration ‘from the bottom up’ suggests that the urban civic substratum of contemporary cities is still thriving. However, it is urgent that the contradictions these strategies entail are critically appropriated in order to develop a stronger answer to austerity urbanism.
  • Article
    This paper describes a four-year programme of ‘action research’ undertaken with six communities in the UK, referred to as the EVALOC (Evaluating Low Carbon Communities) project. The research combined a programme of community-facing events with phased household-level monitoring of energy and carbon reduction interventions. These interventions were funded by the United Kingdom’s (UK) Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC) prior to the onset of the study. Action Research (AR) has a long history within the social sciences. It has been applied at both the individual and collective level, to a wide range of policy-relevant research contexts. It has recently been adopted within the context of environmental behaviour change programmes in the UK, with a number of methodological challenges. The EVALOC project’s challenges included developing a collaborative research design; building reciprocity between the researchers and research participants; dealing with biases and burdens in the research process; ensuring analytical rigour in the interpretation of the primarily qualitative evidence; and dealing with the long-term and process-driven outcomes that arise from such interactions. This paper explores and discusses these issues in relation to selected research outcomes from the AR. We conclude by suggesting that the AR approach has helped to support the low carbon communities (LCCs) who participated in the research with the design and delivery of their energy and carbon reduction activities. The research has also enabled an important process of inter-organisational exchanges between the LCCs, providing rich reflections and learning about the experiences and processes of stimulating energy and carbon reductions.
  • Article
    Design culture has emerged as a broadly applied term in the past decade. Analytically, we can take it to describe the networking of the domains of design, production, and consumption within which questions of value, circulation, and practice reside. The reflexive promotion of design cultures and the enrollment of subjects and objects into its cause are taken to be of particular importance within neoliberalism. Since design cultures are networks, issues of their density and scale and the speed and strength of their interactions are of interest. Design activism has emerged as a movement, partly in response to the recent crises of neoliberalism. However, it is not necessarily independent of mainstream design culture. Instead, it picks up and runs with some of its key themes, including intensification, co-articulation, temporality, and territorialization.
  • Article
    Leeds is the third largest Metropolitan District in the United Kingdom and the administrative and employment centre of the Yorkshire and the Humber region in the north of England. From being dominated initially by textiles and clothing manufacture, it has seen the development of engineering and the rise of services, notably business and financial services, to produce what remains a relatively diverse local economy. It has been transformed from an industrial to a services dominated city but one retaining important elements of its manufacturing past. A city in a unitary state, the profile traces developments in the city’s political economy through the lens of central–local state relationships and the recent transition from urban government to evolving forms of urban governance: from the entrepreneurial municipal city of Victorian times to the current attempts by the local council to reinvigorate ‘civic enterprise’ in the aftermath of recession and the current Government’s austerity programme and localism agenda.
  • In this paper, we explore the relationship between creative practice, activism and urban place-making by considering the role they play in the construction of meaning in urban spaces. Through an analysis of two activist groups based in Stokes Croft, Bristol (UK), we argue that cultural activism provides new political prospects within the wider context of global capitalism through the cultivation of a shared aesthetics of protest. By cultivating aspects of shared history and a mutual enthusiasm for creative practice as a form of resistance, Stokes Croft has emerged as a ‘space of nurturance’ for creative sensibilities. However, we note how Stokes Croft as an autonomous space remains open-ended and multiple for activists interested in promoting different visions of social justice.
  • City Matters: Competitiveness, Cohesion and Urban Governance Localism: Unravelling the Supplicant State. London: New Economics FoundationExploring equity and sustainable development in the new carbon economy
    • M Boddy
    • M Parkinson
    • D Boyle
    Boddy, M. and Parkinson, M. (2004) City Matters: Competitiveness, Cohesion and Urban Governance. Bristol: Policy Press, University of Bristol. Boyle, D. (2009) Localism: Unravelling the Supplicant State. London: New Economics Foundation. Brown, K. and Corbera, E. (2003) 'Exploring equity and sustainable development in the new carbon economy', Climate Policy 3(S1), pp. S41–S56.
  • Urban Regeneration in the UK. London: Sage
    • P Jones
    • J Evans
    Jones, P. and Evans, J. (2008) Urban Regeneration in the UK. London: Sage.
  • Prosperity without Growth? The Transition to a Sustainable Economy Sustainable Development Commission Available at: publicationsThe roofs over our heads: housing supply and demand
    • T Jackson
    • H Jones
    • J Kettle
    • R Unsworth
    Jackson, T. (2009) Prosperity without Growth? The Transition to a Sustainable Economy. London: Sustainable Development Commission. Available at: publications.php?id=914 Jones, H., Kettle, J. and Unsworth, R. (2004) 'The roofs over our heads: housing supply and demand', in R. Unsworth and J. Stillwell (eds) Twenty-First Century Leeds: Geographies of a Regional City, pp. 75–102.
  • The Party's Over: Oil, War and the Fate of Industrial Societies Leitch Review: Prosperity for all in the Global Economy—World Class Skills
    • R Heinberg
    Heinberg, R. (2005) The Party's Over: Oil, War and the Fate of Industrial Societies. Forest Row, East Sussex: Clairview. HM Treasury (2006) Leitch Review: Prosperity for all in the Global Economy—World Class Skills. Norwich: TSO.
  • Permaculture: Principles and Pathways Beyond Sustainability
    • D Holmgren
    Holmgren, D. (2002) Permaculture: Principles and Pathways Beyond Sustainability. Hepburn, Vic.: Holmgren Design Services.
  • Social capital as social networks: a new framework for measurement and an empirical analysis of its determinants and consequences
    • London
    London: Earthscan. Sabatini, F. (2008) 'Social capital as social networks: a new framework for measurement and an empirical analysis of its determinants and consequences', The Journal of Socio-Economics, doi:10.1016/ j.socec.2008.06.001
  • Tools for Conviviality. London: Fontana/ Collins. Imagine Chicago Available at: http:// Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (2007) Fourth Assessment Report: Climate Change
    • I Illich
    Illich, I. (1973) Tools for Conviviality. London: Fontana/ Collins. Imagine Chicago. Available at: http:// Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (2007) Fourth Assessment Report: Climate Change 2007 (AR4). Geneva: IPCC.
  • Two-Track Cities: The Challenge of Sustaining Growth and Building Opportunity. London: Institute for Public Policy Research. Downloaded by [Columbia University] at 14:34 08
    • G Athey
    • P Lucci
    • C Webber
    Athey, G., Lucci, P. and Webber, C. (2007) Two-Track Cities: The Challenge of Sustaining Growth and Building Opportunity. London: Institute for Public Policy Research. Downloaded by [Columbia University] at 14:34 08 December 2014 UNSWORTH ET AL.: BUILDING RESILIENCE AND WELL-BEING IN THE MARGINS WITHIN THE CITY 201
  • Red Tory: How Left and Right have Broken Britain and How we can Fix It
    • P Blond
    Blond, P. (2010) Red Tory: How Left and Right have Broken Britain and How we can Fix It. London: Faber & Faber.
  • Attachment to Place: Social Networks, Mobility and Prospects of Young People
    • A E Green
    • R J White
    Green, A.E. and White, R.J. (2007) Attachment to Place: Social Networks, Mobility and Prospects of Young People. York: JRF.
  • Can we deliver better public services for less money?', Design Council Magazine 4
    • M Bichard
    Bichard, M. (2008) 'Can we deliver better public services for less money?', Design Council Magazine 4, pp. 16–21.
  • Co-creation: New Pathways to Value: An Overview
    • London
    London: Earthscan. Promise/LSE Enterprise (2009) Co-creation: New Pathways to Value: An Overview. London: Promise.
  • The Long Emergency: Surviving the End of Oil, Climate Change, and Other Converging Catastrophes of the Twenty-First Century Climate Change Strategy. Leeds: Leeds City Council Vision for Leeds
    • J H Kunstler
    Kunstler, J.H. (2005) The Long Emergency: Surviving the End of Oil, Climate Change, and Other Converging Catastrophes of the Twenty-First Century. Washington, DC: Atlantic Monthly Press. Leeds City Council (2009) Climate Change Strategy. Leeds: Leeds City Council. Available at: http:// Sustainability/Climate_Change_Strategy.aspx Leeds Initiative (2004) Vision for Leeds. Leeds: Leeds Initiative.
  • Local communities and organised action Community Organization: Studies in Resource Mobilization and Exchange
    • A Hunter
    • S Staggenborg
    Hunter, A. and Staggenborg, S. (1988) 'Local communities and organised action', in C. Milofsky (ed.) Community Organization: Studies in Resource Mobilization and Exchange. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • Survival Skills: Using Life Skills to Tackle Social Exclusion
    • H Lownsbrough
    • G Thomas
    • S Gillinson
    Lownsbrough, H., Thomas, G. and Gillinson, S. (2004) Survival Skills: Using Life Skills to Tackle Social Exclusion. London: DEMOS.
  • Total Place: Bradford. Gateway to integrated services
    • T Reeves
    Reeves, T. (2010) 'Total Place: Bradford. Gateway to integrated services', Yorkshire and Humber Regional Review 20(1), pp. 39–40.
  • Book
    Jobs and enterprise are critical to creating viable neighbourhoods. Yet much recent policy activity aimed at the regeneration of deprived neighbourhoods has had only a marginal impact on the economic challenges presented by areas of concentrated disadvantage. This book directly addresses the economic development issues central to neighbourhood renewal, drawing on the authors' original research and wide-ranging analysis of recent academic theory and policy practice. Their critical examination of the economic problems of deprived areas, and the range of employment and enterprise-related policy initiatives and governance arrangements that have attempted to address them, offers informed insights into what does and what does not work. Through its topical focus on issues of work and enterprise in deprived neighbourhoods, “Renewing neighbourhoods” goes to the heart of much current policy practice that seeks to combine concerns of economic competitiveness with those of social exclusion. It will be essential reading for academics, practitioners and policy makers working in the fields of urban regeneration, neighbourhood renewal and local and regional economic development. It will also be a key text for students of urban studies, planning, social policy, human geography and related disciplines.
  • Book
    As our great economic machine grinds relentlessly forward into a future of declining fossil fuel supplies, climate change and ecosystem failure, governments are at long last beginning to question the very structure of the global economy. In this fresh, politically charged analysis, Jonathon Porritt wades in on the most pressing question of the 21st century: can capitalism, as the only real economic game in town, be retooled to deliver a sustainable future? Porritt argues that indeed it can, and it must, as he lays out the framework for a new 'sustainable capitalism' that cuts across the political divide and promises a prosperous future of wealth, equity and ecosystem integrity.
  • Article
    Climate change is one of the most challenging issues of our time. As key sites in the production and management of emissions of greenhouse gases, cities will be crucial for the implementation of international agreements and national policies on climate change. This book provides a critical analysis of the role of cities in addressing climate change and the prospects for urban sustainability. Cities and Climate Change is the first in-depth analysis of the role of cities in addressing climate change. The book argues that key challenges concerning the resources and powers of local government, as well as conflicts between local goals for economic development and climate change mitigation, have restricted the level of local action on climate change. These findings have significant implications for the prospects of mitigating climate change and achieving urban sustainability. This book provides a valuable interdisciplinary analysis of these issues, and will appeal to students and researchers interested in sustainability at local and global scales. © 2003 Harriet Bulkeley and Michele M. Betsill. All rights reserved.
  • Five Reasons why you should Care about Social NetworksSustainable construction and design in UK planning
    • Rotterdam Skillcity
    Rotterdam Skillcity. Available at: http:// Rowson, J. (2009) Five Reasons why you should Care about Social Networks. London: Royal Society of Arts. Connected Communities Blog, 4 November 2009. Available at: http:// jonathan/ Rydin, Y. (2009) 'Sustainable construction and design in UK planning', in S. Davoudi, J. Crawford and A.
  • Book
    Since the publication of the first edition of “The well-connected community” there has been a growing recognition in practice and policy of how networks contribute to the vitality of community life and civil society. Government policy has increasingly emphasised the need to involve communities in decision making, while social capital is increasingly associated with health, low levels of crime, educational achievement and a strong ‘sense of community’. “The well-connected community” aims to strengthen and extend informal networks, support partnership working across boundaries and promote social cohesion. It explores the concept of ‘community’ in relation to patterns of interaction, social identity and mutual influence, advocating a new model of community development that promotes networking as a skilled and strategic intervention and providing recommendations for good networking practice. This fully updated second edition includes new ideas drawn from recent research on social capital and the policy context for community practice, reflecting the increasing emphasis on community engagement and empowerment. Recent case studies and examples have been added throughout. “The well-connected community” is aimed at practitioners, trainers, policy makers and managers working with communities or responsible for community participation strategies, both in the UK and internationally. Academics will also find it a useful source for teaching and research.
  • Article
    The Spirit Level: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better is a landmark reference on the health of populations. This new book by Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett catalogues the accumulated research on income inequality. The premise of The Spirit Level is that well-being is patterned on something other than individual wealth. Rather, physical and social health is spread among particular groups according to a recurring pattern—that of income inequality. Where there are bigger differences in the distribution of wealth, undesirable health and social outcomes are more prevalent. Wilkinson and Pickett characterize income inequality in two ways. In analyses comparing “rich countries,” income inequality is the ratio between the average household income of the richest 20 percent and that of the poorest 20 percent; in the comparisons of US states, income inequality is measured using the Gini coefficient. The authors illustrate their argument regarding the importance of income inequality using ten different indicators of health and social well-being. According to this model, addressing a common determinant addresses the roots of multiple forms of disadvantage; by reducing income inequality, a society can reduce the incidence and prevalence of various social problems. In the book, the US and the UK are the most common examples as they are among the most unequal of unequal societies. Albeit to a lesser extent than in these other countries, income inequality is a growing concern in Canada; recent research has shown that income inequality in Canada increased between 1990 and 2000 (Picot and Myles 2005, 9). The implication is that income inequality is affecting individual and community well-being—the spirit level—in our society too. Because of the breadth of the topic and the diverse nature of the intended audience, the authors have necessarily abridged the research. The result is an accessible reader on what is known about income inequality. This accessibility is necessary for the stated goal of The Spirit Level. Wilkinson and Pickett have assumed the task of raising awareness about this body of evidence. They are convinced that raising awareness is a key stage in a process of change—that the evidence exists to be shared, and that informed actors are empowered actors. In describing their purpose, Wilkinson and Pickett engage the discourse of political action; they name the political nature of their goal and, in so doing, reinforce the strength of their contribution. In the face of all the evidence about problems that reduce quality of life, the narrative reflects a spirited can-do, even must-do, attitude toward reducing inequality: “Far from being inevitable and unstoppable, the sense of deterioration in social wellbeing and the quality of social relations in society is reversible. Understanding the effects of inequality means that we suddenly have a policy handle on the wellbeing of whole societies” (p. 33). Yet, without disparaging either the inspiring tone or the important connection to official policy action, the references to action are ambiguous and somewhat superficial. Based on the accumulated evidence, income inequality is, indeed, a focus for policy at multiple levels and by myriad actors. To “suddenly” have a “handle” on this issue, however, would require substantial additional information about successful interventions. And while it is useful to know that the level of trust is low where inequality is high, perhaps the more actionable analysis would be to examine where the level of trust is high and then ask why and how. Admittedly, these details are beyond the scope of an overview text like The Spirit Level. In the preface to their text, Wilkinson and Pickett propose Evidence-Based Politics as an alternate title. “At this stage,” they explain, “creating the political will to make society more equal is more important than pinning our colours to a particular set of policies to reduce inequality. Political will is dependent on the development of a vision of a better society which is both achievable and inspiring” (p. 264). The idea is that people will respond to the evidence with political action—be it partisan “Political” action or a civic “political” movement. Undoubtedly, political will is necessary to begin a process of change. Capacity and will to act are not uncomplicated, however. The authors acknowledge the...
  • In line with a general foreboding emerging from the analysis of the future of our cities - and indeed concerning our civilisations as such - that has made its appearance in the pages of CITY, this paper investigates in detail how civilisations collapse. It looks at the systemic forces that produce the general self-consciousness of civilisations that leads to their relinquishing responsibility for their own future. In the case of our civilisation we can see a number of ingredients that include an early adoption of individualistic thinking that tends to the belief that looking after one's self is better for society than trying to look after society as such (to précis Adam Smith). The postmodern condition and the unalloyed pursuit of consumption in our age is, however, altogether more extravagant than any past civilisation and this paper goes into considerable detail on the way in which our passion for the automobile has come to possess our culture and is screening out any realistic sense of responsibility for what is now looking like a catastrophic collapse ahead. This paper is the centrepiece of a trilogy appearing in the pages of CITY. The first paper appeared in the last issue and pointed both to the failure of the debate on sustainable development (and sustainable cities) and our dependence of vast throughputs of energy that in a few short years will start to dry up. In the next issue, I will be presenting the most likely scenario of collapse that will be unfolding over the coming decades, finishing with a discussion of how we need to conceptualise this and do what we can to survive the consequences.
  • Article
    This article explores different conceptions of ‘enterprise’ and seeks to indicate the extent to which they are non-reducible. Its main focus is on one particular conception of enterprise that has underpinned a powerful critique of public sector organizations and which has been translated into a variety of specific organizational strategies for restructuring or modernizing the public services. This conception, it is argued, is very different from that informing much of the prescriptive and descriptive literature on entrepreneurship within management studies, for instance. The article also attempts to question the opposition between ‘bureaucracy’ and ‘enterprise’ that frames this self-styled ‘entrepreneurial’ approach to organizational reform. This epochal ‘bureaucracy/enterprise’ dualism, it is argued, is best viewed as a rhetorical move in a political polemic, but one with real effects.
  • One facet of City over the years has been a rather dark foreboding that the trajectory of urbanisation around the world is accumulating problems that refuse to be solved and that in the foreseeable future we will see some kind of apocalyptic collapse. In New Orleans we saw one version of this, in other cities there may be others yet to reveal themselves. This paper is one of a trilogy that focus on the 'sustainable development' of cities and that, by the end, spells out a rather specific scenario of collapse as a consequence of energy starvation that we will, in all likelihood, be seeing unfold over the coming decades. Here we take a distanced view of the whole 'sustainable development' and 'sustainable cities' discourse, concluding that it has become diffused and lost in a welter of fragmented analyses, hopes and small projects that, prima facie, is failing to address deteriorating environmental conditions. The point, however, is that the real source of unsustainability of our civilisation lies in its extreme and increasing reliance on fossil fuels which, in the coming decades will be declining in availability. This paper makes a preliminary assessment of the relationship between 'development' and its demand for energy, noting the consistent avoidance of any meaningful assessment of this or what should be done in an effective way to avoid an emerging crisis. This will surely reveal itself with the progressive difficulty, and thence impossibility, of satisfying our energy demands in a situation where the widely held belief in the imminent rapid growth of alternative sources of energy proves to be without foundation. The next paper in the trilogy looks at the reasons why our society is so blind to the tragedy ahead and the third sketches the probable trajectory of the collapse of our civilisation and the consequence of this for the future of cities both in the north and the south.
  • Article
    The abstract for this document is available on CSA Illumina.To view the Abstract, click the Abstract button above the document title.
  • Book
    What exactly is 'small change'? Build a bus stop in an urban slum and a vibrant community sprouts and grows around it - that is the power of small changes that have huge positive effects. This book is an argument for the wisdom of the street, the ingenuity of the improvisers and the long-term, large-scale effectiveness of immediate, small-scale actions. Written by Nabeel Hamdi, the guru of urban participatory development and the master of the art, Small Change brings over three decades of experience and knowledge to bear on the question 'what is practice'?. Through an easy-to-read narrative style, and using examples from the North and South, the author sheds light on this question and the issues that stem from it - issues relating to political context, the lessons of the 'informal city', and the pursuit of learning that challenges convention. The result is a comprehensive, yet imaginative, guide to the forms of knowledge, competencies and ways of thinking that are fundamental to skilful practice in urban development. This is powerful, informed, critical and inspiring reading for practitioners in the field, students and teachers of urban development, those who manage international aid and everyone looking to build their community.
  • In this third and last instalment of ‘Cities after Oil’, I envision the stages through which ‘modern’ civilisation will collapse over the coming decades. The first essay analysed the discourse on sustainability and how this has abjectly failed to deflect what has become a fatal global development trajectory. The essay focused on the coming decline in available energy and the inability of our civilisation to function without vast and increasing energy supplies. The second essay looked at the general parameters of ‘the collapse of civilisations’ and then in detail at two key aspects of our civilisation that are driving it over the edge, namely, suburban living and the obsession with the automobile. It is not at all clear how fast and through what stages the collapse will unfold because there are many variables which will interact differentially and depend crucially on political decisions taken—and possibly major conflicts—along the way; however, we can be sure that in general the decline will be inexorable. By the latter decades of this century, a radically altered world will have emerged, with a greatly reduced population living surrounded by the defunct debris of modernity, comprised of fragmented and largely self‐reliant political entities. Our complex, ‘globalised’ world of megastates and technological hubris will be but a fading memory. The impacts of global warming and other environmental legacies of our age will reduce the options for reconstruction, possibly fatally. The essay ends by surveying the attempts in the shadows of our current civilisation to envisage and even live ‘alternatives’ that might be seeds of the reconstruction of a civilisation viable within the resource and environmental constraints that can be expected to prevail.
  • Article
    Ambitious claims have been made about the development benefits of market-based policy instruments for climate mitigation. We examine the implications of forest carbon projects for different aspects of equity and sustainable development. We apply a stakeholder multi-criteria assessment to explore the range of stakeholders, their roles, interests and perspectives, to a case study in Mexico. Two elements of equity, access to markets and forests, and legitimacy in decision-making and institutions, are discussed. Robust cross-scale institutional frameworks are necessary to ensure that objectives for equity and sustainable development are met and that already marginalised sectors of society are not excluded. These institutions are still developing and their establishment brings together many different stakeholders from government, private sector and civil society. However, the ability of the “new carbon economy” to provide real benefits for sustainable development may ultimately be constrained by the nature of the market itself.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    This paper explores the tension between two opposite views on how networks create social capital. Network closure (Coleman 1988) stresses the role of cohesive ties in fostering a normative environment that facilitate cooperation. Structural hole theory (Burt 1992) sees cohesive ties as a source of rigidity that hinders the coordination of complex organizational tasks. The two theories lead to opposite predictions on how the structure of an actor's network may affect his ability to adapt that network to a significant change in task environment. Using data from a newly created special unit within the Italian subsidiary of a multinational computer manufacturer, we show that managers with cohesive communication networks were less likely to adapt these networks to the change in coordination requirements prompted by their new assignments, which in turn jeopardized their role as facilitators of horizontal cooperation within a newly created business unit structure. We conclude with a discussion of the trade-off between the "safety" of cooperation within cohesive networks and the "flexibility" provided by networks rich in structural holes.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    The management of carbon emissions holds some prospect for challenging sustainable development as the organising principle of socio-environmental regulation. This paper explores the rise of a distinctive low-carbon polity as an ideological state project, and examines its potential ramifications for the regulation of economy–environment relations at the urban and regional scale. Carbon control would seem to introduce a new set of values into state regulation and this might open up possibilities for challenging mainstream modes of urban and regional development in a manner not possible under sustainable development. But low-carbon restructuring also portends intensified uneven development, new forms of state control and a socially uneven reworking of state–society relations. In order to explore these issues we start by setting out a framework for conceptualising environmental regulation based around the idea of eco-state restructuring. This idea is introduced to capture the conflicts, power struggles and strategic selectivities involved as governments seek to reconcile environmental protection with multiple other pressures and demands. Overall the paper seeks to make a distinctive contribution to theoretical work on state environmental regulation and the emerging spatial dimensions of climate policy.
  • Conference Paper
    Video-based media spaces are designed to support casual interaction between intimate collaborators. Yet transmitting video is fraught with privacy concerns. Some researchers suggest that the video stream be filtered to mask out potentially sensitive ...
  • Article
    Full-text available
    A changing climate seriously challenges our sociopolitical and economic systems. Elaborating on one possible element of a successful human response, this paper looks at how participatory governance is treated in the literatures on social justice and climate change. This paper applies the works of Habermas and Foucault, as well as recent work from the fields of urban and environmental planning, to clarify how the balance between structure, power, and agency influences attempts to address social inequality and climate change. Applying this general framework to a case study of Durban, South Africa, the paper then discusses the effectiveness of participatory structures in practice. This case study provides a productive space to study the intersection of social and environmental concerns. It also allows us to explore how interactions between formal and informal participation expose the limits both of confrontational (Foucauldian) and of consensus-based (Habermassian) approaches to governance. These limitations are instructive as we attempt to create cities that are both socially just and environmentally sustainable.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    There is a vast empirical literature on the allocation of corporate PAC contributions in Congressional elections and the influence that these contributions have on the policy-making process. The attention given to PAC contributions is far in excess of their actual importance. Corporate PAC contributions account for about 10% of Congressional campaign spending and major corporations allocate far more money to lobbying or philanthropy than their affiliated PACs make in contributions.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    In the UK climate change and energy have converged on the policy agenda. We discuss the implications for theories of policy change based on well-defined networks located within single, discrete, policy domains. We suggest that such approaches struggle to account for the dynamics of change in conditions of policy convergence. The issue of climate change has opened up and destabilised the UK energy policy sector, but this process has been surprisingly free of conflict, despite radical policy shifts. To date, convergence of the energy and climate change sectors has largely occurred at a discursive level, and we focus our attention on a number of different, but largely complementary, storylines about solutions to climate change. We draw on ideas about sociotechnical regime transitions, first, to explore why the storylines are not in obvious conflict, and, second, to identify small-scale niches where tensions in storylines do emerge as discourse is translated into material reality.
  • Article
    Three approaches to innovation in the public sector in the post war period are identified and analysed for their implications for policy-makers, managers and citizens. Various relationships are identified between innovation and improvement in public services. The traditional bias of the literature that innovation is necessarily functional is undermined. Important lessons for policy, practice and research include the need to develop an understanding of innovation which is not over-reliant on the private sector manufacturing literature but reflects the distinctive contexts and purposes of the public sector.
  • Article
    This article evaluates the current attempt to develop local "compacts" between local government and the voluntary and community sector, as a way of structuring the evolving relationships between these sectors. It is based on documentary analysis and semi-structured interviews with key national and local informants. The first part of the article charts local government-voluntary sector relationships in England from 1979 to 2000. The second part introduces the concept of the "voluntary sector compact", and argues that this is central to the Government's approach to these relationships. The third part explores the implementation of the Voluntary Sector Compact in England at both the national and local level. Finally, the authors draw out key lessons for the future of relationships between local government and the voluntary sector in England.