ArticlePublisher preview available

Ecology of the Family As A Context for Human-Development - Research Perspectives

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

Reviews research on the influence of external environments on the functioning of families as contexts of human development. Investigations of the interaction of genetics and environment in family processes; transitions and linkages between the family and other major settings influencing development, such as hospitals, daycare, peer groups, school, social networks, the world of work (both for parents and children), and neighborhoods and communities; and public policies affecting families and children are included. A 2nd major focus is on the patterning of environmental events and transitions over the life course as these affect and are affected by intrafamilial processes. External systems affecting the family are categorized as meso-, exo-, and chronosystem models. Identified as areas for future research are ecological variations in the expression of genotypes, relations between the family and other child settings, relations between family processes and parental participation in other settings of adult life, and families in broader social contexts. (4 p ref) (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Developmental Psychology
1986,
Vol. 22, No.
6,723-742
Copyright 1986
by
the American Psychological Association,
Inc.
0012-1649/86/S00.75
Ecology of the Family as
a
Context
for
Human Development:
Research Perspectives
Urie Bronfenbrenner
Cornell University
This review collates and examines critically a theoretically convergent but widely dispersed body of
research
on the
influence
of
external environments
on the
functioning
of
families
as
contexts
of
human
development.
Investigations falling within this expanding domain include studies of the inter-
action of genetics and environment in family processes; transitions and linkages between the family
and other major settings influencing development, such as hospitals, day care, peer groups, school,
social networks, the world of work (both for parents and
children),
and neighborhoods and commu-
nities;
and public policies affecting families and children. A second major focus
is
on the patterning
of environmental events and transitions over the life course
as
these affect and are affected by intra-
familial
processes.
Special emphasis
is given
to critical research gaps in knowledge and priorities for
future investigation.
The purpose
of
this article
is to
document
and
delineate
promising
lines
of research on external influences that affect the
capacity
of
families
to
foster the healthy development
of
their
children. The focus differs from that of most studies of the fam-
ily
as a
context
of
human development, because
the
majority
have concentrated
on
intrafamilial processes
of
parent-child
interaction,
a
fact that
is
reflected
in
Maccoby
and
Martin's
(1983) recent authoritative review
of
research
on
family influ-
ences
on
development.
By
contrast,
the
focus
of
the present
analysis
can be
described
as
"once removed."
The
research
question becomes: How are intrafamilial processes affected
by
extrafamilial conditions?
Paradigm Parameters
In tracing the evolution of research models in developmental
science, Bronfenbrenner and Crouter
(1983)
distinguished
a
se-
ries of progressively more sophisticated scientific paradigms for
investigating the impact of environment on development. These
paradigms provide
a
useful framework for ordering and analyz-
ing studies bearing on the topic of this review. At the most gen-
eral level,
the
research models vary simultaneously along
two
dimensions. As applied to the subject
at
hand, the first pertains
This review
is
based
on a
longer background paper prepared
at the
request
of
the
Human Learning and Behavior Branch
of
the
National
Institute of Child Health and Human Development in connection with
the development of their
Five
Year Plan for Research.
I am indebted t6 the following colleagues
for
their constructive criti-
cism of the original document: Josephine
Arastah,
Mavis
Hetherington,
Richard Lerner, Jeylan
T.
Mortimer, Joseph H. Pleck, Lea Pulkinnen,
Michael Rutter, Klaus Schneewind, and Diana Slaughter. Appreciation
is also expressed to Gerri Jones for typing innumerable revisions of the
manuscript.
Correspondence concerning this article should be sent to Urie Bron-
fenbrenner, Department
of
Human Development
and
Family Studies,
Cornell University, Ithaca,
New
York 14853.
to
the
structure
of
the external systems that affect
the
family
and the manner in which they exert their influence. The second
dimension relates
to
the degree
of
explicitness
and
differentia-
tion accorded
to
intrafamilial processes that are influenced
by
the external environment.
External Systems
Affecting
the Family
Research paradigms
can be
distinguished
in
terms
of
three
different environmental systems that can serve as sources of ex-
ternal influence on the family.
Mesosystem models. Although
the
family
is the
principal
context
in
which human development takes place,
it
is but one
of several settings
in
which developmental process can
and do
occur. Moreover, the processes operating in different settings are
not independent
of
each other.
To
cite
a
common example,
events
at
home
can
affect
the
child's progress
in
school,
and
vice versa. Despite the obviousness of this fact,
it
was
not
until
relatively recently that students
of
development began
to em-
ploy research designs that could identify the influences operat-
ing,
in
both directions, between the principal settings
in
which
human development occurs.
The
term mesosystem
has
been
use
to
characterize analytic models
of
this
kind (Bronfenbren-
ner, 1979). The results
of
studies employing this type
of
para-
digm
in
relation
to the
family
are
summarized below,
in the
section "Mesosystem Models."
Exosystem
models.
The psychological development
of
chil-
dren
in
the family
is
affected
not
only
by
what happens
in the
other environments in which children spend their time but also
by what occurs
in
the other settings
in
which their parents live
their
lives,
especially in a place that children seldom enter—the
parents' world of work. Another domain to which children tend
to have limited access
is the
parents' circle
of
friends
and ac-
quaintances—their social network. Such environments "exter-
nal"
to
the developing person are referred
to as
"exosystems."
The
findings
of investigations employing exosystem designs are
reviewed
below,
in the section "Exosystem Models."
723
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
... The Ecological Systems Theory (EST) by Bronfenbrenner (1986) can serve as a framework by which the health behavior outcomes of immigrant youth can be understood. The EST is an integrated framework that highlights how the behavior and attitudes of individuals are formed by the transactions that happens within the various contexts they find themselves in, such as family, peer group, school, and community (Hong et al., 2016). ...
... While each of these subsystems helps in the better understanding of the behavior and attitudes of immigrant youth, the microsystem, mesosystem and exosystem are more closely related to their unique life circumstances (Paat, 2013). This is because the microsystem represents the relationship between immigrant youth and their immediate environment while the mesosystem consists of a network of microsystems, and the exosystem is conceptualized as the remote social settings that may have indirect effects on immigrant youth (Bronfenbrenner, 1986). The macrosystem represents the broad range of cultural values, beliefs, ideas, laws and customs that immigrant youth are exposed to while the chronosystem is the historical period and time in which immigrant youth grow and mature (Bronfenbrenner, 1986). ...
... This is because the microsystem represents the relationship between immigrant youth and their immediate environment while the mesosystem consists of a network of microsystems, and the exosystem is conceptualized as the remote social settings that may have indirect effects on immigrant youth (Bronfenbrenner, 1986). The macrosystem represents the broad range of cultural values, beliefs, ideas, laws and customs that immigrant youth are exposed to while the chronosystem is the historical period and time in which immigrant youth grow and mature (Bronfenbrenner, 1986). In essence, the EST is an important framework for evaluating the complex mechanisms that could influence the behavior and attitude of immigrant youth toward AOD use within multiple contexts (DeJonckheere et al., 2017). ...
... Research indicates that relationships are also central to children's learning and development (Birch & Ladd, 1997;Bronfenbrenner, 1986;Hamre & Pianta, 2001;Li & Julian, 2012). For instance, there is broad evidence as to how individuals (across age groups) use more mental state language when talking about, or with, members of their own group or familiar people, and this has implications for how parents might use mental state talk with their own child as opposed to an unfamiliar child. ...
Article
Full-text available
Parent mental state talk (MST) is an important contributor for children’s theory-of-mind development, with cognitive MST for Western children being more advanced, often being used with older children relative to talk about desires or emotions. We investigated the contexts in which cognitive MST is most prevalent, as well as the conditions that prompted mothers to provide scaffolding of MST with toddlers. We tested 89 mother–toddler dyads, examining mothers’ MST and non-MST with familiar and unfamiliar children during a Picture Describing Task. Of particular interest was whether the age of the toddler, the toddler’s preestablished mental state (MS) or non-MS vocabulary, spontaneous conversation dynamics, or the familiarity of the child influenced the mothers’ MST. We found that mothers used significantly more cognitive talk in interactions with their own child than with an unfamiliar child. These findings persisted even after covarying out the child’s age and MT vocabulary, as well as the mother’s MST and non-MST during the picture task. We argue that mothers possessed a better understanding of their own child’s MS vocabulary because of their rich relationship history, which resulted in greater use of more advanced cognitive MS discourse with the child. Further, our cross-lagged correlational analysis examining the first half and second half of the Picture Describing Task demonstrated that more child MS talk cued mothers to use more advanced cognitive talk. Overall, the findings of the present study underscore the importance of a relationship history between adults and children for the sensitive scaffolding of children’s MT understanding.
... A study conducted on structural family factors and bullying at school among adolescents in China showed that being from a rural residence was associated with bullying at school [67]. Furthermore, the influence of rural residence is supported by Bronfenbrenner's ecological model, suggesting that broader social systems indirectly influence an individual's development, such as the community and neighborhood in which they live [68]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Violence is a major public health concern with a significant impact on the health and well-being of individuals, families, and communities. Living in a new environment without parental control and experimenting with new lifestyles may increase the risk of violence among university students. Therefore, this study aimed to assess exposure to violence and its associated factors among university students in Ethiopia. Method A cross-sectional study was conducted among 2988 university students from six randomly selected universities in Ethiopia. A two-stage stratified sampling method was used to recruit the study participants. A self-administered questionnaire was utilized to collect information regarding exposure to emotional, physical, and sexual violence. Bivariable and multivariable logistic regression analyses were used to identify factors associated with violence exposure in the last 12 months. Results The prevalence of exposure to any type of violence in the last 12 months was 17.6% (n = 525) (17.9% among males, 16.5% among females). The adjusted odds ratio (AOR) of violence was 2.9 times higher (95% CI 1.6-5.0) among students older than 25 years than those aged 18-20 years. Those students who were in a relationship had 1.4 times higher odds of violence (95% CI 1.0-2.0) than those who were not in a relationship. In addition, those students who were from rural residences before coming to the university had 1.4 times higher odds of violence (95% CI 1.1-1.8) than those from urban residences. The odds of violence among those who consumed alcohol once a week or more in the past month were 2.2 times higher (95% CI 1.3-3.6) than those who did not consume alcohol. Furthermore, the likelihood of violence was 1.6 times higher (95% CI 1.0-2.4) among those who chewed khat and 2 times higher (95% CI 1.3-3.1) among those who used other drugs in the last 12 months. Conclusion Exposure to violence is a challenge for both male and female university students in Ethiopia. Several socio-demographic and behavioral factors were significantly associated with exposure to violence. Therefore, it is crucial for universities and stakeholders to raise awareness about contributing factors to minimize violence, regardless of gender.
... Furthermore, perceived social support has been shown to significantly influence learners' engagement t (Huang et al., 2024). Similarly, drawing from the ecological system theory (Bronfenbrenner, 1986), learning engagement is considered to be influenced by the interaction of individual and situational factors within an ecosystem (Liu et al., 2018;Roffeei et al., 2015). Social support, specifically academic and emotional support provided by teachers and peers, has been identified as a significant influencing factor for learning engagement (Luan et al., 2023). ...
Article
Full-text available
Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in early 2020, online learning has gained widespread adoption as a learning mode in both K-12 and higher education. Learning engagement serves as a crucial indicator of learning quality and is highly correlated with students’ persistence, satisfaction, and academic performance. Numerous researchers have conducted investigations into the factors that influence online learning engagement. This study employs a systematic literature review methodology to synthesize 55 empirical studies published between January 2020 and July 2023. The research findings reveal the following: (1) Community of Inquiry Theory, Self-determination Theory, Social Cognition Theory, Transaction Distance Theory, and Technology Acceptance Model are the most frequently utilized theories employed by researchers to analyze the influencing factors of online learning engagement. (2) Factors that influence online learning engagement from the learners’ perspective include Motivation, Digital Experience and Literacy, Emotions and Regulatory Strategies, Psychology, Self-Perception, Self-efficacy, and Self-Directed Learning. Additionally, factors from the environment encompass Instrument, Task characteristics, Digital Platforms and Equipment, Physical Environment, Collaboration, and Interaction. (3) Effective strategies to enhance online learning engagement comprise setting clear learning goals for learners, improving their information and social media literacy, strengthening their self-directed learning ability, providing robust instructor support, and creating an optimal learning environment. Through this comprehensive review, researchers interested in this topic will gain a broader understanding, while also obtaining evidence-based insights and valuable recommendations for future research.
With the rapid advancement of technology, internet addiction among children has become a growing concern, particularly in China. This study examines the impact of different parenting styles on internet addiction and the role of parental mediation on the relationship among Chinese children. A survey of 600 Chinese families with children aged 6 to 17 was conducted in 2024. Using structural equation modeling (SEM), the results reveal that authoritative parenting is linked to lower levels of internet addiction, while authoritarian and permissive parenting are associated with higher levels. Parental mediation partly mediates this relationship, with authoritative parents who are actively involved with their children’s internet activities showing a reduced risk of addiction. The findings highlight that both parenting style and parental intervention are key factors in addressing internet addiction among Chinese children. Encouraging authoritative parenting alongside active mediation may help children mitigate internet addiction.
Article
Communication within the parent-child relationship plays a key role in children’s well-being, particularly children’s disordered eating behaviors and body image. Given the critical role of parental communication and beliefs in children’s socialization, the current study tested a model in which parental weight talk may facilitate children’s diet culture-related beliefs, which may further affect children’s disordered eating and positive body image. Surveys were completed by 199 parent-child dyads, and structural equation modeling was employed to test the hypothesized model. Results provide support for diet culture socialization within the parent-child relationship via parental weight talk, with disordered eating as a key outcome. However, children’s diet culture beliefs were not found to be directly associated with positive body image. Implications for future research on the parent-child relationship and children’s well-being are discussed.
Article
In the context of persistent violence affecting Colombian youth, this paper investigates the role of football-oriented Sport for Development (SfD) organizations in mitigating adolescent violence. Through in-depth interviews, 10 non-governmental organizations’ (NGOs) leaders that are part of the Gol y Paz network presented their perspectives on factors exposing plural adolescents to violence, the strategies they implement to prevent violence, and the challenges they face running their organizations across these contexts. Results showed that adolescent vulnerability to violence in Colombia is influenced by various factors, including entrenched gender norms and inadequate institutional and familial support systems and the prevalence of drug trafficking in their communities. Football-oriented SfD NGOs operate as protective buffers for youth, fostering socio-emotional resilience through the creation of safe spaces and connecting young people to institutional services. The paper reinforces football’s potential to serve as a peacebuilding tool by allowing NGOs to implement programs even in regions where violence is prevalent. Collaboration among NGOs, while faced with challenges, is presented as a pivotal component of a comprehensive violence prevention strategy. In conclusion, this paper identifies SfD NGOs as essential contributors to preventing youth violence in Colombia. They play a pivotal role not only by establishing free of violence spaces but also by fostering integral healthy development in youth. Additionally, these NGOs enhance collaboration to drive sustainable change.
Article
Full-text available
Esta pesquisa tem por objetivo apresentar a interface da trajetória familiar e educacional, e seus desdobramentos no desenvolvimento profissional de pessoas com diferença funcional. A literatura nacional e internacional identifica alguns elementos que articulam estes aspectos, o que ancorou o desenvolvimento das perguntas de entrevistas semiestruturadas realizadas de forma online com 22 pessoas com diferença funcional com ensino superior completo e que trabalham em suas áreas de formação, de todas as regiões do Brasil. Os resultados evidenciam comportamentos de enfrentamento dos pais, relativos à: atenção e clareza na identificação das necessidades dos filhos, obtenção de recursos que correspondessem às suas necessidades e adaptações dos processos educativos, os quais atuaram como estimuladores e contribuíram para o desenvolvimento das crianças. Foi salientada uma inadequação nos processos de aprendizagem nas escolas especiais e também dificuldades tanto no acesso quanto na permanência em escolas regulares. Os respondentes demonstram que a relação atual estabelecida com o trabalho é, para além de uma ocupação, uma forma de crescimento pessoal e profissional. O repertório de competências profissionais citadas pelos entrevistados como importantes condiz com as requeridas e valorizadas no mercado de trabalho atual. No entanto, a despeito do investimento no processo de desenvolvimento profissional, a inclusão laboral ainda apresenta barreiras relacionadas ao capacitismo.
Article
In recent years, global forced migration due to conflict, violence, and persecution has increased dramatically, affecting numerous countries, with Türkiye being particularly impacted. Despite global trends showing a significant decline in positive attitudes toward refugees, the limited existing literature on racism in nursing education primarily focuses on themes related to white supremacy. This focus inadequately addresses the issue of personally mediated racism toward various ethnic groups, especially within the context of nursing education and research. Considering the ongoing migration influx, it is crucial to examine personally mediated racism and its underlying causes among nursing students in countries most affected by this issue. This study examined personally mediated racism among nursing students toward refugees in Türkiye by creating an environment conducive to productive discussions, utilizing a participant‐driven photo‐elicitation method. The study identifies two key themes to address gaps in the literature: “The Road to Personally Mediated Racism” and “Uncontrollable Exclusivism,” emphasizing the existence of personally mediated racism among nursing students. This study's findings underscore the essential need to integrate antiracist education and promote open discussions about current societal developments and dynamics within nursing education.
Article
Full-text available
Social ties can be stressful as well as supportive. Are these opposing effects linked, and can they help explain subgroup differences in the efficacy of social support? These questions were applied to data on social support in response to stressful life events. The subjects were 314 women randomly chosen from the registration list of a neighborhood health center in Boston. The data were from the initial interviews of a larger study. The findings include the following: (a) The mobilization of social support was associated with better psychological well-being for women with greater personal resources, but not for those with lower levels of personal resources. (b) Women with lower levels of personal resources were more distressed by life events in the lives of their significant others, especially as the number of these events increased. (c) The subgroup effects of interpersonal support and stress on psychological well-being were independent, separate effects. In sum, women with greater material and psychological resources derived more beneficial support and suffered less stress from their social ties.
Chapter
Parent-child interaction therapy (PCIT), a program for young children and their families, is a strong evidence-based treatment that repeatedly receives the highest rankings possible in reviews of such treatments (e.g., California Evidence-Based Clearinghouse for Child Welfare, 2015; nrepp.samhsa. gov). PCIT was originally developed for use with young children (2–7 years of age) with disruptive behavior problems (McNeil and Hembree-Kigin 2010; Zisser and Eyberg 2010). As PCIT continued to show significant positive outcomes including improved child behaviors, reduced parenting stress, and improved parent-child relationships (Brinkmeyer and Eyberg 2003; Eyberg and Robinson 1982), the application of PCIT to children at risk or exposed to trauma seemed a logical step.