ArticlePDF Available

School Readiness: The Need for a Paradigm Shift

Taylor & Francis
School Psychology Review
Authors:
Martha P. Carlton Latorre at Southern Illinois University Edwardsville
Martha P. Carlton Latorre
Adam Winsler at George Mason University
Adam Winsler
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

School readiness is receiving increased attention from schools, parents, teachers, and policy makers. This article presents a reflective and critical review of the school readiness construct, the theoretical perspective that has guided practice in the area to date, and the effectiveness of the educational placement options currently available for children deemed to be "unready." It is argued that the construct of school readiness has suffered from a narrow, maturationist theoretical perspective, which presents the problem as residing solely within the child, with the determination of readiness being the duty of the school systems. The popular practices of delayed entry, retention, and transition classes are not supported by the empirical literature. It is argued that a new theoretical framework and a paradigm shift is needed in the area of school readiness to lead the way to reformed practices. A new perspective based upon Vygotskian sociocultural theory and contemporary developmental theory is offered that presents readiness as a bidirectional process of both the school and the child flexibly adjusting to each other to ensure success. Finally, the implications of such a perspective for school psychologists and educational practice are discussed. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Content uploaded by Adam Winsler
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Adam Winsler
Content may be subject to copyright.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
School readiness: The need for a paradigm shift
Martha P Carlton; Adam Winsler
School Psychology Review; 1999; 28, 3; Education Periodicals
pg. 338
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
... Recently, more and more importance has been placed on educational research on the study of the development of interpersonal skills. Social capability is increasingly recognized as essential to school readiness (Carlton & Winsler, 1999). It is found that socially competent pupils are more successful in schools than their less skilled peers in developing positive attitudes towards school and adjusting to school. ...
How Does Gender Relate to Interpersonal Skills? Exploring Differences in Interpersonal Skills among Primary School Pupils
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2024
The current study examined gender differences in interpersonal skills among standard four primary education pupils. Interpersonal skill is a crucial ability that contributes to positive development among primary school pupils. This quantitative research was conducted in the public primary schools of Babati Township Council, Manyara region. The study randomly involved 340 standard four primary school pupils from 17 purposely selected schools (ten boys and ten girls from each school) and their class teachers who were also purposely selected. The assessment tool for pupils was adopted from the MESSY-II (Matson Evaluation of Social Skills with Youngsters –II) to assess interpersonal skills among the selected pupils. T-test was used to test the differences between girls and boys concerning the possession of interpersonal skills. The findings show no significant statistical difference between boys and girls possessing interpersonal skills. This is reflected in both the 'means' and 'p-values'. This study concludes that interpersonal skills are vital for them to prosper academically. Having no significant difference between boys and girls, the study deviates from a body of literature that signifies the difference between the two
View
... School readiness is a holistic concept that captures various domains of development in early childhood (National Research Council, 2008, Pisani et al., 2018. Although many definitions exist (UNICEF, 2012), school readiness has been described as knowledge, skills, and abilities that children need to succeed at school (Carlton Latorre & Winsler, 1999;Lemelin et al., 2007). The domains encompassed in school readiness often entail early numeracy, language and literacy skills (Duncan et al., 2007), cognitive skills, self-regulation, social emotional skills, sustained attention skills, and motivation (Blair & Raver, 2015;Duncan et al., 2018;Lin et al., 2003;Pisani et al., 2018). ...
View
... Entrepreneurial spirit, often characterized by creativity, innovation, risk-taking, and problemsolving (Mulyani, Mansoer and Hardiyanto, 2019), is increasingly recognized as a crucial skill set for navigating the complexities of the 21st century. However, traditional educational models have been slow in adapting to this paradigm shift, often focusing on rote learning and standardized testing (Carlton and Winsler, 1999). This study posits that by engaging young children in gross motor activities combined with role-play scenarios, we can lay a foundational framework that not only enhances their physical and cognitive development but also fosters key entrepreneurial traits such as confidence, creativity, and collaboration. ...
Early Childhood Role Models and Gross Motor Activities Could Assist to Build a Sense of Enterprise in Kids
Article
  • Dec 2023
This study explores the impact of gross motor activities and role-play centers on cultivating entrepreneurial spirit in early childhood. Employing both qualitative and quantitative methods, the research involved 50 children aged 4-6 years from various kindergartens. Gross motor activities such as running and jumping were integrated with role-playing games that included simulations of small business activities. The study found that a combination of physical activities and social role-playing significantly enhanced the children’s cognitive, social, and emotional skills, which are crucial components of an entrepreneurial mindset. Results showed improvements in self-confidence, creativity, and collaborative abilities in children, in addition to strengthening their understanding of basic business and economic concepts. These findings highlight the importance of incorporating entrepreneurial education in early childhood curriculums, laying the foundation for the development of entrepreneurial skills and attitudes for the future.
View
... Given the profound impact of school readiness, it has consistently attracted the PARENTAL INVOLVEMENT AND SCHOOL READINESS 4 attention of researchers and policy makers during past decades. Currently, the focus of school readiness policies goes through a dramatic paradigm shift from 'getting children ready for school' to 'making school ready for children' (National Association for the Education of Young Children [NAEYC], 1995;Carlton & Winsler, 1999; Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development [OECD], 2017). Based on the developmental theories, school readiness refers to children's necessary skills and competencies for being ready to learn at school, encompassing multiple domains such as their cognitive skills, language development, social-emotional competence, approaches to learning, physical well-being and motor development, etc (Kagan, 1992;Janus & Offord, 2007). ...
Relationship between parental involvement and school readiness: a meta-analysis
Preprint
Full-text available
  • Aug 2024
School readiness is foundational for children's later achievement. Despite a surge in studies examining the relationship between parental involvement and school readiness in recent decades, to the best of our knowledge, no systematic reviews have comprehensively addressed this link. This meta-analysis mapped the evidence on the relationship between facets of parental involvement and school readiness, and examined potential moderators across 73 studies (859 effect sizes, N = 109,931). We found a small, significant overall effect of parental involvement on school readiness, r = .12, 95% CI [.10, .14], with similar publication bias-adjusted estimates. This effect size remained relatively stable across the levels of studied moderators. Notably, our results suggest that socioeconomic status acts as a suppressor for the association between parental involvement and school readiness. The findings suggest that addressing socioeconomic challenges may attenuate constraints on the causal link from parental involvement to school readiness.
View
... School readiness is another often studied topic in school psychology journals (e.g., Carlton & Winsler, 1999;Hojnoski & Missall, 2006;Parker et al., 1999). Although Silberzahn et al. (2018) discussed the "many analysts, one dataset, " crowdsourcing approach to replication, a Type III replication can be thought of as a "one model, many datasets" approach where a general regression model is applied to multiple datasets with similar variables. ...
Replication Studies Using Secondary or Nonexperimental Datasets
Article
  • Apr 2024
Replication studies have been promoted as a means to investigate the fragility or robustness of findings from prior studies. However, less well known is that replication studies can be done with nonexperimental or secondary datasets and are not just for experimental studies. We present a framework of different types of replication studies with nonexperimental or secondary data and provide examples in the context of school psychology. We show that replication studies can be used as robustness checks, as a means of testing the generalizability of existing theories, and as a way of extending findings of prior studies. We advocate for the thoughtful use of replication studies and highlight some of the benefits of replications.
View
... Home-school relationships are significant predictors of children's academic attainment (Rimm-Kaufman et al., 2000;Kingston et al., 2013) as well as a smooth transition into school (Carlton and Winsler, 1999) regardless of child age or ethnic origin (Wilder, 2014). Engaging families in the learning process from the very beginning maximizes children's developmental outcomes (Bridgemohan et al., 2005). ...
School-based delivery of a dialogic book sharing intervention: a feasibility study of Books Together
Article
Full-text available
  • Feb 2024
Introduction Growing numbers of children enter mainstream education without the skills needed to prosper in the school environment. Without additional support, these children face poor long-term outcomes in terms of academic attainment, mental health difficulties and social problems. The aim of this study was to investigate the feasibility and acceptability of school-based delivery of the Books Together dialogic book sharing program to groups of parents, and to explore whether it impacts parent and child outcomes in order to facilitate school readiness. Methods Parents of children aged 3–5 years old (n = 16) were recruited from four North Wales primary schools. Video observations of parent/child interactions, a gaming format measure of expressive child language ability, parent-report measures of children’s behavior, and social-emotional ability and of their parental competence were collected pre- and post-intervention. Thematic analysis of interviews with parents and the school-based staff who delivered the program explored feasibility and acceptability of the program. Results Significant post-intervention increases in observed positive parenting and child expressive language skills and significant reductions in observed negative parenting were found. Parents reported significantly higher rates of child prosocial behavior and social/emotional ability as well as improved parenting competency at follow-up. Thematic analysis showed that staff and parents were satisfied with the program and that it was feasible to deliver in a school environment. Discussion The Books Together program is a low-cost intervention that, when delivered by school-based staff, shows promise for increasing the use of parenting strategies that build children’s language and social/emotional skills associated with school readiness.
View
Okula Hazırbulunuşluk: Tüm Yönleri ile Okula Geçiş
Book
  • Dec 2024
Okula Hazırbulunuşluk ve Okul Sisteminin Tarihi Ebru DERETARLA GÜL İnanç ETİ Okula Hazırbulunuşluk ve Çocuğun Gelişimsel Özellikleri Filiz YURTAL Okula Hazırbulunuşluk: Bakış Açıları, Kuramlarve Teoriler Gülsüm HOŞ Ülkelerin Okula Hazırbulunuşluk Politikaları Yasemin AKKAYA ALICI Okula Hazır Bulunuşluğun Değerlendirilmesi Pınar POLAT Okula Hazırbulunuşlukta Çocuk ve Öğretmenın Rolü Serap ÖZBEK Okula Hazırbulunuşlukta Aile ve Toplumun Rolü Sedef ÇAĞLAR KABACIK Risk Altındaki Çocukların Okula Hazırbulunuşluğu Habibe ÖZER YANARKAYA Ayperi DİKİCİ SIĞIRTMAÇ
View
Young children's perceptions and experiences of school readiness during the transition from preschool to primary school in China
Article
  • Oct 2024
School readiness has a profound educational value for children's positive adjustment to primary school and holistic development. However, little research sufficiently addresses how young children view multifaceted components of learning, such as cognitive, affective and behavioural experiences on school readiness. A timely understanding of children's perceptions and experiences is crucial to shed light on how to promote transition and improve children's school readiness. This study investigated the perceptions and experiences of 41 children in China (5–6 years of age, 23 girls) regarding their school readiness based on Mosaic approach methods. The results indicated that young children have their own unique perceptions, emotional and behavioural experiences of school readiness. The perceptions of school readiness include four aspects of material supplies, subjects knowledge, interests and specialties and behavioural habits, which has similarities to that of adults in aspects of academic knowledge and social rules. Nevertheless, findings revealed young children view interests and strengths as important part of school readiness, reflecting their personal preferences and abilities. The emotional experiences could be considered positive or negative, with positive emotional experiences expressing children's curiosity and expectation, fulfilment and pleasure, and negative emotional experiences expressing academic burden, rules pressure and social worries, which need to be addressed. Young children's behavioural experiences with school readiness present two patterns of passive acceptance and active participation, they are eager to participate in activities and have a strong desire to explore and learn. Our findings extend beyond existing conception of school readiness, and give greater weight to children's interests and strengths, positive experiences and active participation. It is important to focus on children's intrinsic interests and strengths, accept children's ideas and choices, care for their emotional state and provide positive support.
View
View
THE INFLUENCE OF PARENTING STYLES ON ADOLESCENTS MENTAL HEALTH: A COMPREHENSIVE STUDY ON INTERMITTENT EXPLOSIVE DISORDER, SUICIDALITY, AND SELF-ESTEEM
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2023
Adolescence is a critical time marked by a variety of changes in the body, mind, and emotions, which makes it a susceptible phase for the emergence of mental health problems. The objective of the current study was to investigate how adolescents' development of intermittent explosive disorder (IED), suicidality, and self-esteem is influenced by perceived parenting styles. Participants were recruited using a purposive sample technique and a correlational research design. Two hundred teenagers from public and private educational institutions (colleges and schools) in Multan, Pakistan, were included in the sample. The Zakia (2020) Perceived Parenting Scale was utilised to gauge parents' perceptions of their parenting styles. Bano (2021) created the Intermittent Explosive Disorder scale to gauge the severity and prevalence of the condition. Bano (2018) developed the Suicidality Scale to quantify suicidal ideation, intention, and attempts. The translated Urdu version of the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (Rosenberg, 1965) was utilised; Rizwan (2017) translated the scale. The hypotheses of the studies were tested using independent sample t-tests, multiple linear regression, and Pearson correlation analysis. This theory is supported by the present study's data, which show a strong positive link between positive parenting styles and self-esteem. Negative parenting styles were found to be negatively connected with self-esteem.
View
On the Nature of Human Plasticity
Book
  • Aug 1984
To what extent are human beings capable of changing their physical characteristics and behavioural patterns over the course of their lives? This question has engaged scientists for decades: the fundamental issue is plasticity. In this wide-ranging book, Richard Lerner explores the relevant theory and empirical evidence in a variety of disciplines: molecular genetics, neuroanatomy, neurochemistry, evolutionary biology, anthropology, comparative and developmental psychology, and sociology. The processes studied by each of these disciplines show evidence of plasticity. Conclusions about plasticity have important implications for interventions aimed at enhancing human life, as well as for future research agendas. On the Nature of Human Plasticity will be a valuable resource for all those scientists concerned with human development at biological and social levels and for their students.
View
Including Children with Special Needs in Regular Early Childhood Settings
Article
  • Dec 1995
Children with special needs are attending early childhood programs more and more frequently as the philosophy of inclusion influences the development of services. Many professionals working with children feel nervous when asked to include a child with special needs, however, the skills necessary to work effectively with children with special needs are the same as those used everyday working with all children. This article discusses an activity-based approach to working with children and shows how planning for children with special needs fits easily within this approach.
View
The effects of early grade retention on the academic achievement of fourth‐grade students
Article
  • Oct 1990
This study investigated the academic effects of early (kindergarten or first‐grade) retention on a group of fourth‐grade students who had been retained at the K‐1 level (n = 20). Two comparison groups were used: (a) fourth‐grade students who had been recommended for retention at the K‐1 level but who were not actually retained (n = 17), and (b) fourth‐grade students who had made normal progress through the grades (n = 20). No significant differences in academic achievement level were found between the retained and recommended‐for‐retention‐but‐not‐retained groups, but both of these groups of students were significantly lower on several academic achievement measures than were their normal comparison peers. The results of this study indicate that grade retention as an academic intervention was ineffective. The continued use of grade retention is discussed in relationship to the use of social promotion and other intervention alternatives.
View
Kindergarten retention and transition classrooms: Their relationship to achievement
Article
  • Jan 1994
This study examined the relationship between extra‐year programs and later school achievement. Ninety‐five children were identified as being either retained in kindergarten, placed in a transition classroom, recommended for an extra‐year program but went into first grade, or as being in a control group of children who went from kindergarten to first grade without reservation. Results indicated that children retained in kindergarten performed significantly lower on a standardized achievement test than did children in the other three groups. Despite an extra year of schooling, children placed in transition classrooms did not differ significantly in their performance from children who were recommended for an extra year but went onto first grade and children in the control group.
View
A comparison of students who delay kindergarten entry and those who are retained in grades K−5
Article
  • Jul 1995
Retention has been one way that school personnel have dealt with the problem of school failure. Some authors have proposed delayed school entry as an alternative to retention, especially since there are concerns about the effects of retention on students' self‐esteem. It is unclear from the literature whether retention and delayed entry have differential outcomes on measures of school success. This study explored whether there were differences in IQ and achievement (at grades 2, 5, and 7) between students who delayed school entry and those who were retained in later elementary grades, as well as any interactions with gender. There was a significant 6‐point difference in IQ, favoring the delayed‐entry group. Furthermore, when the achievement test scores were analyzed using an ANCOVA with IQ as a covariate, no significant differences were identified for either group or gender. Implications for school practices are provided.
View
View
View
View
Beginning school age and academic achievement
Article
  • Jan 1985
One hundred and seventeen students who began kindergarten in 1978?79 were studied to determine effects of beginning school age and gender on later school achievement and retention in grade. No significant differences among the three age groups were found at kindergarten, 2nd, or 4th grade. Differences in achievement between boys and girls were noted. Results are similar to those of other recent studies and suggest that parents and teachers may be unduly cautious when delaying the entry of children to school on the basis of chronological age considerations. Local district studies are recommended.
View
Transition classes: A viable alternative for the at‐risk child?
Article
  • Oct 1984
Increased interest in the child ?not ready? for reading has led to the use of a number of instructional options, of which the transition class is one. Efficacy of transition room programs is reviewed and importance of teacher attitudes is discussed. Educators will need to examine current educational practices in order to reduce the school failure rate.
View