Noise considerations of three-point water-fat separation imaging methods

Department of Physics, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305, USA.
Medical Physics (Impact Factor: 2.64). 09/2008; 35(8):3597-606. DOI: 10.1118/1.2952644
Source: PubMed


Separation of water from fat tissues in magnetic resonance imaging is important for many applications because signals from fat tissues often interfere with diagnoses that are usually based on water signal characteristics. Water and fat can be separated with images acquired at different echo time shifts. The three-point method solves for the unknown off-resonance frequency together with the water and fat densities. Noise performance of the method, quantified by the effective number of signals averaged (NSA), is an important metric of the water and fat images. The authors use error propagation theory and Monte Carlo simulation to investigate two common reconstructive approaches: an analytic-solution based estimation and a least-squares estimation. Two water-fat chemical shift (CS) encoding strategies, the symmetric (-theta, 0, theta) and the shifted (0, theta, 2theta) schemes are studied and compared. Results show that NSAs of water and fat can be different and they are dependent on the ratio of intensities of the two species and each of the echo time shifts. The NSA is particularly poor for the symmetric (-theta, 0, theta) CS encoding when the water and fat signals are comparable. This anomaly with equal amounts of water and fat is analyzed in a more intuitive geometric illustration. Theoretical prediction of NSA matches well with simulation results at high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), while deviation arises at low SNR, which suggests that Monte Carlo simulation may be more appropriate to accurately predict noise performance of the algorithm when SNR is low.

Download full-text


Available from: Angel R Pineda, Aug 06, 2014
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Fat-water separation is a classical problem for in vivo magnetic resonance imaging, with multiple applications both in cases where the aim is the removal of fat signal, as well as in cases where the fat signal itself is of diagnostic interest. Although many methods have been proposed, robust fat-water separation remains a challenge. The problem presents two key difficulties: (a) the presence of B0 field inhomogeneities, which makes the problem non-linear and ill-posed; and (b) the difficulty of accurately modeling the acquired signal, which can lead to bias in quantitative fat-water separation applications. The research in this thesis has developed joint estimation methods to address the ill-posedness of the problem by simultaneously estimating the complete fat-water images and field inhomogeneity map. The joint estimation formulation developed in this work is able to overcome the complications of voxel-by-voxel separation, and it allows characterization of the resolution properties of its estimates, but results in a challenging optimization problem. To address this complication, optimization algorithms based on graph cuts have been developed and studied. Additionally, this work addresses the modeling issues of fat-water separation by comparing a set of recently proposed models, demonstrating that accurate spectral modeling of the acquired signal is critical for quantitative applications. Simulation, phantom and in vivo results are included to highlight the properties of the proposed methods and compare them to previous approaches. This thesis also contains example applications of the proposed methods, with an emphasis on the characterization of intramyocardial fat.
    Preview · Article ·
  • Source

    Preview · Article · Jan 2011
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Diffusion-weighted (DW) MRI has emerged as a key tool for assessing the microstructure of tissues in healthy and diseased states. Because of its rapid acquisition speed and insensitivity to motion, single-shot echo-planar imaging is the most common DW imaging technique. However, the presence of fat signal can severely affect DW-echo planar imaging acquisitions because of the chemical shift artifact. Fat suppression is usually achieved through some form of chemical shift-based fat saturation. Such methods effectively suppress the signal originating from aliphatic fat protons, but fail to suppress the signal from olefinic protons. Olefinic fat signal may result in significant distortions in the DW images, which bias the subsequently estimated diffusion parameters. This article introduces a method for removing olefinic fat signal from DW images, based on an echo time-shifted acquisition. The method is developed and analyzed specifically in the context of single-shot DW-echo-planar imaging, where image phase is generally unreliable. The proposed method is tested with phantom and in vivo datasets, and compared with a standard acquisition to demonstrate its performance.
    Full-text · Article · Mar 2011 · Magnetic Resonance in Medicine
Show more