ArticlePDF Available

Victims of the Long Term Effects of Chemical Weapons on Health in Kurdistan of Iraq

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Extensive exposure to chemical weapons such as mustard gas, nerve gas and cyanide causes high mortality, morbidity, injuries, and chronic side effects in vital organs, especially the respiratory tract. Globally, chemical weapons have been documented as having been used since 429 BC, when they were used by the Spartans in the Peloponnesian War. In the First World War (WW1) the use of chemical agents caused an estimated 1,300,000 casualties, including 90,000 deaths. Chemical weapons were heavily used by Iraq against Iranian soldiers between1984-1986, then, against the Iraqi Kurds in Sheikh Wasan and Balisan valley, during April 1987 and in Halabja on 18th March 1988. Reports suggested that as many as 2.9% of the Kurdish population have been exposed to chemical weapons at some level. This case report describes a Kurdish lady who was exposed to mustard gas during a chemical attack in Sheikh Wasan in Iraq. A forty eight years old woman wearing black clothes presented to our center at 1999 complaining from shortness of breath (SOB). Her condition started 12 years ago when the Iraqi Government attacked her village Sheikh Wasan by Chemical weapons which included Mustard gas and nerve gases such as Sarin, Tabun and VX in April 1987. She described how the gas smelled like rotten apples as it spread over the village. During the attack she suffered from sever SOB, cough, skin burn and eye irritation and lacrimation. After several days of being without medical care, she received some medical attention by local medical staff in the area because the Iraqi authorities at that time refused and prohibited them from management at the major hospitals. When she returned to her home she found that several members of her family had died during the exposure to chemical gases. Among the dead people were her parents, two brothers, husband and son, in addition to other second and third degree relatives. Since that time she has suffered from repeated attacks of cough and SOB and wheezing that were increased by exertion and cold exposure. The attacks were more severe with time and the SOB has interfered with her daily activity and eventually she was suffering from SOB at rest and during sleep that made her unable to sleep lying down. Moreover she was suffering from severe depression since that time for which she consulted several doctors but without improvement. In the end of 2001, she suffered from severe cough and Hemoptysis associated with anorexia and loss of weight. She consulted our center for this purpose and we asked for a medical care for her. Available haematological and radiological investigations were done for her showing a preliminary diagnosis of non-small cell lung cancer. . She was sent for further investigations and treatment, but since then she has been disappeared and no more information was recorded about her situation. This is one example of many of those who suffered from the effect of chemical weapons in Kurdistan of Iraq.
Content may be subject to copyright.
M ID DL E EA ST J OU R NA L OF I NT ER NA L ME DI CI NE • V OL UM E 2, I SS UE 3 27
MIDDLE EAST JOURN AL OF IN TERNA L MEDICINE VOLUME 5, ISSUE 4
M OD EL S AN D SY ST EM S OF C AR E
Case Report: Victims of the Long Term Effects of Chemical
Weapons on Health in Kurdistan of Iraq
ABSTRACT
Extensive exposure to chemical weapons such as mustard gas, nerve gas and
cyanide causes high mortality, morbidity, injuries, and chronic side effects in
vital organs, especially the respiratory tract.
Globally, chemical weapons have been documented as having been used since
429 BC, when they were used by the Spartans in the Peloponnesian War. In
the First World War (WW1) the use of chemical agents caused an estimated
1,300,000 casualties, including 90,000 deaths. Chemical weapons were heavily
used by Iraq against Iranian soldiers between1984-1986, then, against the
Iraqi Kurds in Sheikh Wasan and Balisan valley, during April 1987 and in
Halabja on 18th March 1988.
Reports suggested that as many as 2.9% of the Kurdish population have been
exposed to chemical weapons at some level.
This case report describes a Kurdish lady who was exposed to mustard gas
during a chemical attack in Sheikh Wasan in Iraq.
A forty eight years old woman wearing black clothes presented to our center
at 1999 complaining from shortness of breath (SOB). Her condition started 12
years ago when the Iraqi Government attacked her village Sheikh Wasan by
Chemical weapons which included Mustard gas and nerve gases such as Sarin,
Tabun and VX in April 1987. She described how the gas smelled like rotten
apples as it spread over the village. During the attack she suffered from sever
SOB, cough, skin burn and eye irritation and lacrimation. After several days
of being without medical care, she received some medical attention by local
medical staff in the area because the Iraqi authorities at that time refused and
prohibited them from management at the major hospitals. When she returned
to her home she found that several members of her family had died during
the exposure to chemical gases. Among the dead people were her parents,
two brothers, husband and son, in addition to other second and third degree
relatives. Since that time she has suffered from repeated attacks of cough
and SOB and wheezing that were increased by exertion and cold exposure.
The attacks were more severe with time and the SOB has interfered with her
daily activity and eventually she was suffering from SOB at rest and during
sleep that made her unable to sleep lying down. Moreover she was suffering
from severe depression since that time for which she consulted several doctors
but without improvement. In the end of 2001, she suffered from severe cough
and Hemoptysis associated with anorexia and loss of weight. She consulted
our center for this purpose and we asked for a medical care for her. Available
haematological and radiological investigations were done for her showing a
preliminary diagnosis of non-small cell lung cancer. . She was sent for further
investigations and treatment, but since then she has been disappeared and no
more information was recorded about her situation.
This is one example of many of those who suffered from the effect of chemical
weapons in Kurdistan of Iraq.
Key words: Chemical weapon, Mustard gas, shortness of breath, Cancer.
Kawa Dizaye
Correspondence:
Dr. Kawa Dizaye
Professor of Pharmacology
Hawler Medical University,
Erbil,
Iraq
Tel: 009647504452392
Email: dr_kawadizaye@yahoo.com
M ID DL E EA ST J OU R NA L OF I NT ER NA L ME DI CI NE • VO LU ME 2 , IS SU E 3
28 MIDD LE EAST JOURNAL OF IN TERNAL MEDICINE VOLUME 5, ISSUE 4
M OD EL S AN D SY ST EM S OF C AR E
Introduction
The use of chemical warfare agents dates back to 429 BC and various agents have been developed and used against populations
since that time. (Table 1 - below)
The NATO denition of a chemical agent is: A chemical substance which is intended for use in military operations to kill,
seriously injure or incapacitate people because of its physiological effects. (1).
• 429 B.C. - Spartans ignite pitch and sulphur to create toxic fumes in the Peloponnesian War (CW)
• 424 B.C. - Toxic fumes used in siege of Delium dur ing the Peloponnesian War (CW)
• 960-1279 A.D. - A rsenical smoke used in battle during China’s Sung Dynasty (CW)
• 1346-1347 - Mongols catapult corpses contaminated with plague over the walls into Kaffa (in Cr imea), forcing besieged Genoans to ee
(BW)
• 1456 - City of Belgrade defeats invading Turks by igniting rags dipped in poison to create a toxic cloud (CW)
• 1710 - Russian troops allegedly use plag ue-infected cor pses against Swedes (BW)
• 1767 - During the French and Indian Wars, the British give blankets used to wrap British smallpox victims to hostile Indian tribes (BW)
• April 24, 1863 - The U.S. War Department issues General Order 100, proclaiming “The use of poison in any manner, be it to poison
wells, or foods, or arms, is wholly excluded from modern warfare”
• July 29, 1899 - “Hague Convention (II) with Respect to the Laws and Customs of War on Land” is signed. The Convention declares “it is
especially prohibited… To employ poison or poisoned arms”
• 1914 - French begin using tear gas in grenades and Germans ret aliate with tear gas in artillery shells (CW)
April 22, 1915 - Germans attack the French with chlorine gas at Ypres, France. This was the rst signicant use of chemical warfare in
WWI (CW)
September 25, 1915 - First British chemical weapons at tack; chlor ine gas is used against Germans at the Bat tle of Loos (CW)
1916-1918 - German agents use anth rax and the equine disease glanders to infect livestock and feed for export to Allied forces. Incidents
include the infection of Romanian sheep with anthrax and glanders for export to Russia, Argentinian mules with anthrax for expor t to
Allied troops, and American horses and feed with glanders for export to France (BW)
February 26, 1918 - Germans launch the rst projectile attack against U.S. troops with phosgene and chloropicrin shells. The  rst major
use of gas against American forces (CW)
June 1918 - First U.S. use of gas in warfare (CW)
June 28, 1918 - The United States begins its formal chemical weapons program with the est ablish ment of the Chemical Warfare Service
(CW)
1919 - British use Adamsite against the Bolsheviks during the Russian Civil War (CW)
1922-1927 - T he Spanish use chemical weapons against the Rif rebels in Spanish Morocco (CW)
June 17, 1925 - “Geneva Protocol for the Prohibition of the Use in War of Asphyxiating, Poisonous or Other Gases, and of
Bacteriological Methods of Warfare” is signed - not ratied by U.S. and not signed by Japan
1936 - Italy uses mustard gas against Ethiopians during its invasion of Abyssinia (CW)
1937 - Japan begins its offensive biological weapons program. Unit 731, the biological weapons research and development unit, is located
in Harbin, Manchuria. Over the course of the program, at least 10,000 prisoners are killed in Japanese experiments (BW)
1939 - Nomonhan Incident - Japanese poison Soviet water supply with intestinal typhoid bacteria at former Mongolian border. First use
of biological weapons by Japanese (BW)
1940 - The Japanese drop rice and wheat mixed with plague-carrying eas over China and Manchur ia (BW)
1942 - U.S. begins its offensive biological weapons program and chooses Camp Det rick, Frederick, Maryland as its research and
development site (BW)
1942 - Nazis begin using Zyklon B (hydrocyanic acid) in gas chambers for the mass murder of concentration camp prisoners (CW)
December 1943 - A U.S. ship loaded with mustard bombs is attacked in the port of Bari, Italy by Germans; 83 U.S. t roops die in
poisoned waters (CW)
April 1945 - Germans manufacture and stockpile large amounts of tabun and sarin ner ve gases but do not use them (CW)
May, 1945 - Only known tactical use of biological weapons by Ger many. A large reservoir in Bohemia is poisoned with sewage (BW)
September, 1950-February, 1951 - In a test of biological weapons dispersal methods, biological simulants are sprayed over San
Francisco (BW)
1962-1970 - U.S. uses tear gas and four types of defoliant, including Agent Orange, in Vietnam (CW)
Table 1: Chronology of biological and chemical weapons use and control, 429 B.C.–1998 (continued top of next page)
Source: (http://www.libraryindex.com/pages/1888/Proliferation-Weapons-Mass-Destruction-WMD-HISTORY-USAGE-
PROLIFERATION.html”)
M ID DL E EA ST J OU R NA L OF I NT ER NA L ME DI CI NE • V OL UM E 2, I SS UE 3 29
1963-1967 - Egypt uses chemical weapons (phosgene, mustard) against Yemen (CW)
June, 1966 - The United States conducts a test of vulnerability to cover t biological weapons attack by releasing a har mless biological
simulant into the New York City subway system (BW)
November 25, 1969 - President Nixon announces unilateral dismantlement of the U.S. offensive biological weapons program (BW)
February 14, 1970 - President Nixon extends the dismantlement efforts to toxins, closing a loophole which might have allowed for their
production (BW)
April 10, 1972 - “Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production and Stockpiling of Bacteriological (Biological) and
Toxin Weapons and on Their Destruction” (BWC) is opened for signat ure
1975 - U.S. raties Geneva Protocol (1925) and BWC
1975-1983 - Alleged use of Yellow Rain (trichothecene mycotoxins) by Soviet-backed forces in Laos and Kampuchea. There is evidence
to suggest use of T-2 toxin, but an alter native hypothesis suggests that the yellow spots labeled Yellow Rain were caused by swarms of
defecati ng bees (CW)
1978 - In a case of Soviet state-sponsored assassination, Bulgarian exile Georgi Markov, living in London, is stabbed with an umbrella
that injects him with a tiny pellet containing rici n (BW)
1979 - The U.S. government alleges Soviets use of chemical weapons in Afghanistan, including Yellow Rain (CW)
April 2, 1979 - Outbreak of pulmonary anthrax in Sverdlovsk, Soviet Union. In 1992, Russian president Boris Yeltsin ack nowledges that
the outbreak was caused by an accidental release of anthrax spores from a Soviet militar y microbiological facility (BW)
August, 1983 - I raq begins using chemical weapons (mustard gas), in Iran-Iraq War (CW)
1984 - First ever use of ner ve agent tabun on the battleeld, by Iraq du ring Iran-Iraq War (CW)
1985-1991 - Iraq develops an offensive biological weapons capability including anth rax, botulium toxin, and aatoxin (BW)
1987-1988 - Iraq uses chemical weapons (hydrogen cyanide, mustard gas) in its Anfal Campaign against the Kurds, most notably in the
Halabja Massacre of 1988 (CW)
September 3, 1992 - “Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on
their Destruction” (CWC) approved by United Nations
April 29, 1997 - Ent ry into force of CWC
1998 - Iraq is suspected of maintaining an active CBW program in violation of the ceasere agreement it signed with the UN Security
Council. Baghdad ref uses to allow UNSCOM inspectors to visit undeclared sites (CW/BW)
Table 1: Chronology of biological and chemical weapons use and control, 429 B.C.–1998
Figure 1: Classication of chemical weapon according to their mechanism of action
M OD EL S AN D SY ST EM S OF C AR E
M ID DL E EA ST J OU R NA L OF I NT ER NA L ME DI CI NE • VO LU ME 2 , IS SU E 3
30 MIDD LE EAST JOURNAL OF INTERN AL MED ICINE VOLUME 5, ISSUE 4
M OD EL S AN D SY ST EM S OF C AR E
About 70 different chemicals have been used or stockpiled
as chemical warfare agents during the 20th century and the
21st century. These agents may be in liquid, gas or solid form.
Liquid agents are generally designed to evaporate quickly;
such liquids are said to be volatile or have a high vapor
pressure. Many chemical agents are made volatile so they can
be dispersed over a large region quickly These agents were
designed specically to harm people by any route of exposure
and to be effective at low doses (2).
Chemical Weapons can be divided into lethal and
incapacitating categories (Figure 1).
A substance is classied as incapacitating if less than 1/100 of
the lethal dose causes incapacitation, e.g., through nausea or
visual problems. The limit between lethal and incapacitating
substances is not absolute but refers to a statistical average.
In comparison, it may be mentioned that the ratio for the
nerve agents between the incapacitating and lethal dose is
approximately 1/10. Chemical warfare agents are generally
also classied according to their effect on the organism. The
two major threat classes of chemical weapons are mustard
gas and the nerve agents, and this has not changed in over 50
years. Both types are commonly called gases, but they are
actually liquids that are not remarkably volatile. (3, 4).
It must also be remembered that possible new agents are
constantly being discovered, and also, that some chemical
agents may be used together as a mixture. From the medical
standpoint, toxins could pose similar problems to those
produced by chemical agents. (1)
Chemical agents in the modem sense were rst used in World
War I when chlorine gas was released, from large cylinders,
in a favorable wind.
The French were the rst to use chemical weapons during
the First World War, using tear gas. The German’s rst use of
chemical weapons were shells containing xylyl bromide that
were red at the Russians near the town of Bolimów, Poland
in January 1915 (5). Ofcial gures declare about 1,176,500
non-fatal casualties and 85,000 fatalities directly caused by
chemical warfare agents during the course of the war (6).
Later in the War they used mustard gas. Soon both sides were
using chemical warfare extensively leading to the introduction
of gas masks. The fear of the detrimental effects of chemical
warfare caused many countries to abstain from using it
and except for the use of poison gas by the Italians in the
war against Ethiopia (1935-36) and by the Japanese against
Chinese guerrillas (1937-42), chemical warfare was not
employed after World War I. This is not to say however, that
the militar y powers of the world did not continue to develop
new gases (7).
Chemical weapons were heavily used by Iraq against Iranian
soldiers between1984-1986, then, against the Iraqi Kurd Table
(2). In 1987-88 Iraqi forces launched chemical attacks against
approximately 40 Kurdish villages and thousands of innocent
civilians (8).
Initial scientic studies conducted by local doctors and
international specialists indicate that as many as 2.9% of the
population of almost four million people in northern Iraq have
been exposed to chemical weapon at some level between April
1987 and August 1988. In April of 1987, the regime attacked
the villages of Sheik Wasan and Balisan, using chemical
weapons for the rst time, killing more than a hundred people
Figure (2), mostly women and children. The worst of these
attacks devastated the city of Halabja on March 16, 1988. (9)
The attack on Halabja, a town of 80,000 to 90,000 people, is
the largest chemical attack against civilians in histor y (10).
The Halabja attack involved multiple chemical agents
including mustard gas, and the nerve agents SARIN, TABUN
and VX. Some sources report that cyanide was also used.
It may be that an impure form of TABUN, which has a
cyanide residue, released the cyanide compound. Most
attempts directed to developing strategies against chemical or
biological weapons have been directed towards a single threat.
The attack on Halabja illustrates the importance of careful
tactical planning directed towards more than one agent, and
specic knowledge about the effects of each of the agents.
More than 5000 people were killed during the attack on
Halabja, and more than 20,000 were injured (11).
Table 2: Documented Iraqi Use of Chemical Weapons on the Kurds
M ID DL E EA ST J OU R NA L OF I NT ER NA L ME DI CI NE • V OL UM E 2, I SS UE 3 31
MIDDLE EAST JOURN AL OF IN TERNA L MEDICINE VOLUME 5, ISSUE 4
CO MM U NI TY C AR E
Figure 2: Samples of chemical weapon used in Balisan Vali in 1987.
Today at Balisan and Sheik h Wassan, 23 commemorative graves are representing 233 lost in the attack. The remains of the
dead were too difcult to separate and identify Figure (3).
Figure 3: Today at Balisan and Sheikh Wassan, 23 commemorative graves are representing 233 lost in the attack
M ID DL E EA ST J OU R NA L OF I NT ER NA L ME DI CI NE • VO LU ME 2 , IS SU E 3
32 MIDDLE EAST J OURNAL OF INT ERNAL MEDI CINE VO LUME 5, I SSUE 4
Unlike Halabja, the Balisan valley is far from the Iran border Figure 4. Injured survivors seeking treatment at hospitals in
government-controlled Arbil were taken away by the security forces -- and many were never seen again.
Residents of the villages recall that planes appeared, dropping canisters that spewed yellow dust. The dust was mustard gas,
but most civilians did not recognize the danger until symptoms appeared hours later. Many who did not die in the attacks were
permanently blinded; children and the elderly were particularly affected.
Extensive exposure to chemical weapons such as mustard gas, nerve gas and cyanide caused high mortality, morbidity, injuries,
and chronic side effects in vital organs, especially the respiratory tract (12).
Mustard a poisonous chemical agent is a cell poison that causes disruption and impairment of a variety of cellular activities.
Mustard is an alkylating agent, and once absorbed, its toxic effects result from chemical reactions with cellular constituents.
These biochemical reactions cause inhibition of mitosis, nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD) depletion, decreased tissue
respiration, and ultimately, cell death (13, 14,15).
Figure 4: Location of Balisan Vali and Halabja in northern Iraq
Mustard agent was produced for the rst time in 1822 but its harmful effects were not discovered until 1860. Mustard agent was
rst used as a CW agent during the latter part of the First World War and caused lung and eye injuries to a very large number of
soldiers. Many of them still suffered pain 30-40 years after they had been exposed, mainly as a result of injuries to the eyes and
chronic respiratory disorders (16)
Mustard agents are usually classied as “blistering agents” owing to the similarity of the wounds caused by these substances
resembling burns and blisters. It produces blisters and damage to skin, eyes, respiratory and gastrointestinal tracts. There is
usually erythema; vesication; bur ns and lung damage. Mustard gas also affects many other systems including haematopoietic
and immune systems. Haematological effects include leucopenia, thrombocytopenia, decrease in RBCs and sepsis. Secondary
infections of damaged tissue can occur easily. The most serious of the long term effects arise because mustard gas is
carcinogenic and mutagenic. In the respiratory system there are increased risks of chronic lung disease, asthma, bronchitis.
Permanent impairment of vision may occur and eye damage may be severe, leading to blindness. Skin lesions and bur ns may
be severe with persistent changes and hypersensitivity to mechanical injury. Carcinogenic and mutagenic effects can result in
cancers, Carcinogenic and mutagenic effects can result in cancers, congenital malformations and infertility. Long term effects
(mutagenesis, carcinogenesis, eye, skin, lung, fertility) etc are dose and route dependent (17, 18, 19).
M OD EL S AN D SY ST EM S OF C AR E
M ID DL E EA ST J OU R NA L OF I NT ER NA L ME DI CI NE • V OL UM E 2, I SS UE 3 33
M OD EL S AN D SY ST EM S OF C AR E
MIDDLE EAST JOURN AL OF IN TERNA L MEDICINE VOLUME 5, ISSUE 4
Case report
This case report describes a Kurdish lady who was exposed to mustard gas and
nerve agent during a chemical attack in Sheikh Wasan and Balisan vale in Iraq.
Figure 5: Badriya Saed Khidir
A forty eight year old woman wearing black clothes presented to our center at
1999 complaining from shortness of breath (SOB). Her condition started 12 years
ago when the Iraqi Government attacked her village Sheikh Wasan by Chemical
weapons which included Mustard gas and nerve gases such as Sarin, Tabun and
VX in April 1987. She described how the gas smelled like rotten apples as it spread
over the village.
During the attack she suffered from severe SOB, cough, skin burn and eyes
irritation and lacrimation. After several days of being without medical care, she
received some medical attention by local medical staff in the area because the Iraqi
authorities at that time refused and prohibited them from management at the major
hospitals. When she returned back to her home she found that several members
of her family have died during the exposure to chemical gases. Among the dead
people were her parents, two brothers, husband and son, in addition to other second
and third degree relatives. Since that time she has suffered from repeated attacks
of cough and SOB and wheezing that were increased by exer tion and exposure to
cold. The attacks were more severe with time and the SOB has interfered with her
daily activity and more recently she was suffering from SOB at rest and during
sleep that made her unable to sleep lying down. Moreover she was suffering from
severe depression since that time for which
she consulted several doctors but without
improvement.
In the end of 2001, she suffered from
sever cough and Hemoptysis associated
with anorexia and loss of weight. She
consulted our center for this purpose
and we asked for medical care for her.
Available haematological and radiological
investigations were done for her showing
a preliminary diagnosis of non-small
cell lung cancer. She was sent for further
investigations and treatment, but since
then she had disappeared and no more
information was recorded about her
situation.
On the 17th of March 2009 I visited the
area which were exposed to chemical
weapon in 1987. In Balisan I asked about
a woman called Badriya Saed Khidir and
they showed me her grave saying she had
passed away several weeks before. She
died while her eyes were lled with tears
crying for the fate of her son, her parents,
her two brothers and her lovely husband.
Another victim was a baby girl. Her
family named her Chemia (Chemist)
because she was borne on 16th April 1987
on the day of the attack in Sheikhwasan.
She died after three months from the
exposure to chemical attack.
These are two examples of the many
who suffered from the effect of chemical
weapons in Kurdistan of Iraq.
References
1-NATO. Handbook on medical aspects of
NBC defensive operations (1996)
2-Blodgett Brian, Germany’s Use of
Chemical Warfare in World War 1
(1999)Available:http://members.tripod.
com/Brian._Blod. gett / Chemical.htm
3-http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_
warfare
3- Sharon Reutter: Research Review.
Hazards of Chemical Weapons Release
during War: New Perspectives:
Environmental Health Perspectives
Volume 107, Number 12, December 1999
4- Gordon M. Burck and Charles C.
Flowerree; International Handbook on
Chemical Weapons Proliferation 1991
5-The First World War” (a Channel 4
documentary based on the book by Hew
Strachan).
M ID DL E EA ST J OU R NA L OF I NT ER NA L ME DI CI NE • VO LU ME 2 , IS SU E 3
34
MIDDLE EAST JOURN AL OF IN TERNA L MEDICINE VOLUME 5 I SSUE 4
Figure 6: Grave of Badriya Saed Khidir
Figure 7: The author visiting the grave of Badriya Saed Khidir
M OD EL S AN D SY ST EM S OF C AR E
M ID DL E EA ST J OU R NA L OF I NT ER NA L ME DI CI NE • V OL UM E 2, I SS UE 3 35
M OD EL S AN D SY ST EM S OF C AR E
MIDDLE EAST JOURN AL OF IN TERNA L MEDICINE VOLUME 5, ISSUE 4
Figure 8: A family escaping from area exposed to chemical weapon in Balisan Vale
6-Heller, Charles E. (September 1984), Chemical Warfare in
World War I: The American Experience, 1917-1918, US Army
Command and General Staff College,
http://www-cgsc.army.mil/carl/resources/csi/Heller/HELLER.
asp
7- Robinson Julian Perry and Goldblat Jozef, Chemical
warfare in the Iraq-Iran war, Sipri fact sheet, Stockholm
International Peace Research Institute (1984)
8-http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/iraq _wmd/Iraq _Oct_
2002.htm
9- Kawa Dizaye, Hamanejm Jaff. Pattern of morbidity and
mortality in Kurdistan / Iraq with an emphasis on exposure
to chemical weapon. Fourth World Congress on Chemical,
Biological and Radiological Terrorism. Croatia, 14 - 20 April
2007
10-Chemical and biological weapons non-proliferation project
Henry L. Stimson Center 11 Dupont Circle, NW, 9th Floor
Washington, DC 20036 tel: 202.223.5956 www.stimson.org
11-Christine M. Gosden Super Terrorism: Biological,
Chemical, and Nuclear, by Yonah Alexander and Milton
Hoenig, Editors. Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2001
12-Bijani Kh, Moghadamnia AA: Long-term effects of
chemical weapons on respiratory tract in Iraq-Iran war
victims living in Babol (North of Iran). Ecotoxicol Environ
Saf. 2002 Nov;53(3):422-4.
13. Somani SM, Babu SR. Toxicodynamics of sulfur mustard.
Int J Clin Pharmacol 27:419-435 (1989).
14. Papirmeister B, Feister AJ, Robinson SI, Ford RD.
Medical Defense against Mustard Gas. Boca Raton. FL:CRC
Press, 1991.
15-Dacre JC, Goldman M: Toxicology and pharmacology of
the chemical warfare agent sulfur mustard. Pharmacol Rev
1996;48:289-326
16-Marrs TC, Maynard RL, Sidell FR. Chemical Warfare
Agents, Toxicology and Treatment. Chichester, UK:John
Wiley and Sons, 1996.
17-Bijani Kh. ; Moghadamnia A. A. Long-ter m effects of
chemical weapons on respiratory tract in Iraq-Iran war
victims living in Babol (North of Iran). Ecotoxicology
and environmental safety 2002 ISSN 0147-6513 CODEN
EESADV
18-Emad A, Rezaian GR. The diversity of the effects of sulfur
mustard gas inhalation on respiratory system 10 years after a
single, heavy exposure. Chest 1997; 112: 734-738.
19- Sohrabpour H, Masjedi MR, Bahadori M. Late
complications of sulfur mustard in respiratory system.
Medical Journal of the Islamic Republic of Iran. 1988; 2/3.
... The Iraqi Kurdistan region was subjected to chemical bombings during the 1980s Iran-Iraq war. In 1987 and 1988, the Saddam regime targeted several cities and villages and used various types of chemical warfare against innocent people, such as Sheikh Wasan and the Balisan Valley in April 1987, and in Halabja on 16 March 1988, it was estimated that up to 2.9% of the Kurdish population was exposed to chemical weapons at a different level (Dizaye, 2012). ...
Article
Full-text available
Genocide attempts are among the most severe traumatic events that are transmitted across generations. However, it may also prove the strength and survivability as well as the vulnerability of the targeted group. Anfal and chemical attacks on Halabja on Iraqi Kurds that targeted their annihilation had a devastating impact. Many survivors and their generations are still dealing with their effects on psychological disorders such as posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression. To address the psychological effects of these tragic events on survivors and their generations and propose the actions to be taken, this article explores the psychological trauma and problems caused by attempted genocide and chemical attacks in the case of Anfal campaign. These effects require more research to fully understand the long-term effects of these tragedies, as well as support and provision of comprehensive psychological and mental health interventions to their survivors and generations.
... Various health complaints were found among survivors who were exposed to chemical gases, such as respiratory, eye, dermatological, and immunologic complaints [2]. Using chemical weapons extensively by Iraqi army against Kurdish villages and cities such as Sheikh Wasan and Balisan valley, during April 1987 and in Halabjah on 16 th March 1988, suggested that as many as 2.9% of the Kurdish population has been exposed to chemical weapons at a different level [3]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Article info Abstract Original: Revised: Accepted: Published online: The current study was carried out to determine the percentage rates of anti-hepatitis A and E (HAV and HEV) IgG and IgM seropositivity and RNA among chemical bombarded survivors in different regions in Iraqi Kurdistan. Blood samples were collected randomly from 92 chemical bombed exposures and 45 non-exposures-controls-from July to November 2013. ELISA and conventional, nested PCR techniques were followed to detect anti-hepatitis A and E IgG, IgM and RNA respectively. Lymphocyte counting also was done for all tested exposures and controls. It was observed that the percentage rates of hepatitis A seropositivity were higher than hepatitis E. All tested exposures (100%) were seropositive for anti-HAV IgG, whereas 61.79% were positive for anti-HEV IgG. Similarly, anti-HAV IgM seropositivity was higher (8.9%) than that of anti-HEV (1.089%). Current results revealed that there were significant differences between exposures and controls regarding anti-HAV and anti-HEV IgG (p= 0.0001 and 0.0002), whereas no significant differences were observed between the two tested groups concerning anti-HAV and anti-HEV IgM seropositivity (p= 0.621 and 0.56). Moreover, significant differences were found among anti-HAV IgG and IgM as well as anti-HEV IgG and IgM seropositivity among exposures themselves (p= 0.000 and 0.0055) respectively. The percentage rate of hepatitis A RNA positivity was 15.68%, whereas no positive results were seen for HEV. Geographical distribution of exposures was appeared to be significantly effective on all obtained results (seropositivity and RNA detection) (p ‹ 0.05). It was noticed that lymphocytes were significantly different between HAV-seropositive and seronegative exposures (p ‹ 0.05). A high percentage rate of exposures with positive results for anti-HAV, anti-HEV, and PCR positive results, were suffering from lymphopenia. The highest lymphocyte abnormalities were among exposures with anti-HAV IgM followed by anti-HAV IgG then anti-HEV IgG seropositive exposures.
Article
Full-text available
Introducción: A partir del atentado de Tokio en 1995 y de la crisis de los sobres en 2001, se observa un cambio en la percepción del riesgo NBQ entre los profesionales sanitarios. Un objetivo secundario del estudio era estudiar el nivel de percepción del riesgo NBQ entre los médicos y enfermeros militares. Material y Métodos: Se realizó un estudio exploratorio descriptivo transversal basado en un cuestionario autoadministrado dirigido a la población de médicos y enfermeros militares (348 oficiales del Cuerpo Militar de Sanidad - 50,6% médicos y 49,4% enfermeros). Resultados: El 74,7% de los participantes consideraban como probable que se produjera un incidente NBQ en los próximos cinco años. El 78,7% consideraba que se vería implicado. El 42,7% consideraban que el entorno sería militar, mientras que el 24,5% consideraban que lo sería en entorno civil. En torno al 30% de los pertenecientes al Órgano Central y la Armada consideraban como más probable el escenario biológico. Discusión: Se observa una elevada percepción del riesgo NBQ entre el personal sanitario militar, fundamentalmente entre los menores de 30 años, siendo más marcada esta percepción en los hombres que en las mujeres. En relación al empleo militar, el personal con empleos de teniente y coronel son los que referían una mayor percepción del riesgo. Mientras que los tenientes coroneles, fundamentalmente médicos y destinados en el Órgano Central, consideraban que no se verían implicados profesionalmente en un incidente NBQ. Conclusiones: Existe una elevada percepción del riesgo NBQ entre el personal sanitario militar, fundamentalmente entre los tenientes y menores de 30 años. Hecho que se ve corroborado con la idea de la implicación profesional en incidentes NBQ en un futuro.
Article
Full-text available
Introducción: El personal sanitario debe estar preparado para poder intervenir con eficacia en un incidente NBQ. El objetivo principal de este estudio exploratorio era conocer el nivel de preparación del personal sanitario que trabajaba en el ámbito militar ante incidentes NBQ en general, y químico en particular. Material y métodos: Se realizó un estudio descriptivo transversal mediante un cuestionario autoadministrado en una muestra de 348 oficiales del Cuerpo Militar de Sanidad (50,6% médicos y 49,4% enfermeros) de los que el 71,8% eran mujeres. Resultados: El 68,4% habían recibido formación específica de Defensa NBQ durante su periodo de formación militar técnica, y el 23% la habían recibido fuera del ámbito militar. El 95,4% consideraban necesario recibir formación en defensa NBQ y el 89,3% no se consideran preparados para intervenir en un incidente NBQ. Dentro de los empleos de la muestra estudiada son los tenientes y capitanes los que muestran más interés en recibir formación. Discusión: A la vista de los resultados obtenidos parece que las actividades formativas no son suficientes para alcanzar la capacidad de intervención en incidentes NBQ. Conclusiones: Los empleos de teniente y capitán son los que refieren una mejor preparación para intervenir con eficacia frente a un incidente NBQ. Se deduce una necesidad en la preparación del personal sanitario por lo que se debe de establecer un sistema de capacitación sanitaria de defensa NBQ.
Article
Full-text available
This study was performed randomly on 40 individuals selected within a specific period, between January 2014 to October 2014 in order to a certain whether or not a sample of chemical weapons used on Shekh Wasan & Balisan valley in 16 April 1987, have incurred genetic damage. The following results were obtained: The chromosomal aberration is a very sensitive and widely applied assay used as a bio indicator of genetic damage induced by an environmental agent or clastogen. In current study a group of (40) chemical bombardment survivors there were (15) individuals have different types of chromosome aberrations, including (ring chromosome %52.5, dicentric chromosome %30, chromosome break with fragment %57.5, chromatid interchange (quadriradial) %27.5, chromatid interchange (triradial) %27.5.
Article
Full-text available
In the Iraq-Iran war (1981-1989), extensive use of chemical weapons such as mustard gas caused high mortality, morbidity, injuries, and chronic side effects in vital organs, especially the respiratory tract. This study was performed to evaluate the long-term effects on respiratory tract of victims. Two hundred and twenty victims were referred from the Mostazafan and Janbazan Foundation of Babol from 1994 to 1998. Complete histories, physical examinations, chest X-rays, and PFTs were performed. Nearly all the victims complained of cough, dyspnea, and suffocation. Hemoptysis was found in 6 victims. In 4 patients, respiratory distress with use of accessory muscles was observed. Two-thirds of the subjects had wheezing and coarse rale. For the other third, physical examination revealed no abnormal finding. Radiographic findings were mostly normal. Spirometry revealed an obstructive pattern in all patients and PFT revealed mostly normal and restrictive patterns. The shortlist time from exposure to study was 7 years and the longest was 13 years. Most patients reported mustard gas exposure and a few of them did not know what type of gas exposure they had. The clinical evaluations, radiography, and PFTs revealed that the most prevalent effects of chemical weapons on respiratory tract were chronic obstructive lung disease, presenting as many types of obstructive involvement.
Book
Chemical Warfare Agents, Second Edition has been totally revised since the successful first edition and expanded to about three times the length, with many new chapters and much more in-depth consideration of all the topics. The chapters have been written by distinguished international experts in various aspects of chemical warfare agents and edited by an experienced team to produce a clear review of the field. The book now contains a wealth of material on the mechanisms of action of the major chemical warfare agents, including the nerve agent cyclosarin, formally considered to be of secondary importance, as well as ricin and abrin. Chemical Warfare Agents, Second Edition discusses the physico-chemical properties of chemical warfare agents, their dispersion and fate in the environment, their toxicology and management of their effects on humans, decontamination and protective equipment. New chapters cover the experience gained after the use of sarin to attack travellers on the Tokyo subway and how to deal with the outcome of the deployment of riot control agents such as CS gas. This book provides a comprehensive review of chemical warfare agents, assessing all available evidence regarding the medical, technical and legal aspects of their use. It is an invaluable reference work for physicians, public health planners, regulators and any other professionals involved in this field. Review of the First Edition: "What more appropriate time for a title of this scope than in the post 9/11 era? ...a timely, scholarly, and well-written volume which offers much information of immense current and...future benefit." -VETERINARY AND HUMAN TOXICOLOGY.
Conference Paper
A cross-sectional survey was carried out in kurdistan –Iraq during the period 2000-2001 to determine patterns of morbidity and mortality among kurdistan population with special emphasis on those exposed to bombs and shell injuries and chemical weapons. Kurdistan was divided in to 300 sectors; from each sector, one household was selected randomly. The total study samples were 6805 including number of the household who have died since 1935. They have a male: female ratio of 1.03:1. An interview was carried out using a special questionnaire form. The mean age of the sample was 51.5 ± 0.6 years (51.1 ± 0.75 for males and 52.9 ± 0.97 for females ) 1.5% and 2.8% of surveyed population have been exposed to non – chemical weapons (bomb and shells ) or chemical weapons , respectively; 0.23% of the alive population had cancer at the time of the study. 12.6% in the study sample were complaining from respiratory disease and 6.5 had a history of miscarriage and stillbirth. Both complaints might be attributed to expose to chemical weapons. 869 (12.5 %) of the study have died since 1935, 68.4% of them have died during the period 1980 – 1999. 3 % of all deaths were due to exposure to shells or chemical weapons; 7.9 % were lost in Al – anfal campaign in 1980s of the last century. 8.5 % of all death were due to cancer probably due to exposure to chemical weapons. Key Words : Chemical weapon, Cancer, miscarriage, stillbirth, Kurdistan
Article
Mustards have become an important topic of global discussion in recent years. The latest extensive reports and conference of 145 nations in Paris (January 13, 1989) reveal that several countries have stockpiled large quantities of mustard gas. This situation creates an imminent danger to accidental or intentional exposure of this gas to civil populations throughout the world. In view of the sparse literature on the toxic nature of mustard gas, we have tried to present an integrated panorama of this compound and its derivatives. In this article, efforts were made to review mustard gas--its chemical nature, mode of action, methods available for its analysis in biological fluids and target organs, absorption, distribution, metabolism and excretion and its toxicity to various organs. The effects of mustard poisoning may be local, systemic, or both, depending on environmental conditions, exposed organs, and the extent and duration of exposure. The toxic effects of mustard include inhibition of mitosis, NAD depletion, decreased tissue respiration and finally cell death. Most of the toxic effects are related to alkylation of DNA. Mustards are also selective in their accumulation in fat tissue. The immediate organs affected after mustard exposure are skin, eyes, and lungs. Sulfur mustard has also been reported to be a potent carcinogen. Burns caused by mustard are severe and require long healing periods. Depending on the type and time of exposure, mustard renders persons disabled temporarily or permanently. Various antidotes such as sodium thiosulfate, dexamethasone, promethazine, heparin, vitamin E and atropine have been recommended for combating mustard poisoning. Protective clothing can substantially reduce the toxic effects of mustard exposure. The best possible way of eliminating mustard hazard is to ban its use completely.
Article
There have been reports of chemical attacks in which sulfur mustard might have been used (a) on Iranian soldiers and civilians during the Gulf War in 1984 and 1985 and (b) in an Iraqi chemical attack on the Iranian-occupied village of Halbja in 1988, resulting in many civilian casualties. Heavy use of chemical warfare in Afghanistan by the Soviet military is a recent innovation in military tactics that has been highly successful and may ensure further use of chemical agents in future military conflicts and terrorist attacks as a profitable adjunct to conventional military arms. Mustard is a poisonous chemical agent that exerts a local action on the eyes, skin, and respiratory tissue, with subsequent systemic action on the nervous, cardiac, and digestive systems in humans and laboratory animals, causing lacrimation, malaise, anorexia, salivation, respiratory distress, vomiting, hyperexcitability, and cardiac distress. Under extreme circumstances, dependent upon the dose and length of exposure to the agent, necrosis of the skin and mucous membranes of the respiratory system, bronchitis, bronchopneumonia, intestinal lesions, hemoconcentration, leucopenia, convulsions with systemic distress, and death occur. Severe mustard poisoning in humans is associated with systemic injury, which is manifested as headache, epigastric distresses, anorexia, diarrhea, and cachexia and is usually observed at mustard doses of 1000 mg/min/m3 with damage to hematopoietic tissues and progressive leucopenia. Sulfur mustard is a cell poison that causes disruption and impairment of a variety of cellular activities that are dependent upon a very specific integral relationship. These cytotoxic effects are manifested in widespread metabolic disturbances whose variable characteristics are observed in enzymatic deficiencies, vesicant action, abnormal mitotic activity and cell division, bone marrow disruption, disturbances in hematopoietic activity, and systemic poisoning. Indeed, mustard gas readily combines with various components of the cell such as amino acids, amines, and proteins. Although evidence of an association between lung cancer and mustard gas encountered on the battlefields of World War I is at best suggestive if not problematical (Case and Lea, 1955; Beebe, 1960; Norman, 1975), the epidemiological data accumulated from the poison gas factories in Japan (Yamada et al., 1953; Wada et al., 1968; Inada et al., 1978; Shigenobu, 1980; Nishimoto et al., 1983; Hirono et al., 1984; Takuoka et al., 1986), in Germany (Weiss, 1958; Hellmann, 1970a; Weiss and Weiss, 1975; Klehr, 1984) and in England (Manning et al., 1981; Easton et al., 1988) are substantial (International Agency for Research on Cancer, 1975). Unfortunately, attempts to seek confirmatory and substantial evidence in laboratory animals such as mice (Boyland and Horning, 1949; Heston, 1950; Heston, 1953a; McNamara et al., 1975) and rats (Griffin et al., 1951; McNamara et al., 1975; Sasser et al., 1996) have not been consistent. Sulfur mustard has been shown to be mutagenic in a variety of different species using many different laboratory techniques from fruit flies, microorganisms and mammalian cell cultures (Fox and Scott, 1980). Evidence is slowly accumulating from human data (Hellmann, 1970a; Lohs, 1975; Wulf et al., 1985). Evidence for the teratogenicity of mustard has been negative in assessment of fetotoxicity and adverse effects of mustard on the reproductive potential of both human and animal studies. Indeed, investigations of women adversely affected by mustard are minimal because most of the studies have been performed on former men employees of poison gas factories and have been negative or questionable. We have recently emphasized the need to assess the affect of a suspected teratogen on maternal toxicity in laboratory animals before any conclusions can be made.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED)
tel: 202.223.5956 www.stimson.org 11-Christine M. Gosden Super Terrorism: Biological, Chemical, and Nuclear
  • L Henry
Henry L. Stimson Center 11 Dupont Circle, NW, 9th Floor Washington, DC 20036 tel: 202.223.5956 www.stimson.org 11-Christine M. Gosden Super Terrorism: Biological, Chemical, and Nuclear, by Yonah Alexander and Milton Hoenig, Editors. Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2001
  • Blodgett Brian
  • Germany's Use
  • Of
Blodgett Brian, Germany's Use of Chemical Warfare in World War 1 (1999)Available:http://members.tripod. com/Brian._Blod. gett / Chemical.htm 3-http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemical_ warfare 3-Sharon Reutter: Research Review. Hazards of Chemical Weapons Release during War: New Perspectives: Environmental Health Perspectives Volume 107, Number 12, December 1999
Pattern of morbidity and mortality in Kurdistan / Iraq with an emphasis on exposure to chemical weapon
  • Hamanejm Kawa Dizaye
  • Jaff
Kawa Dizaye, Hamanejm Jaff. Pattern of morbidity and mortality in Kurdistan / Iraq with an emphasis on exposure to chemical weapon. Fourth World Congress on Chemical, Biological and Radiological Terrorism. Croatia, 14-20 April 2007
12-Bijani Kh, Moghadamnia AA: Long-term effects of chemical weapons on respiratory tract in Iraq-Iran war victims living in Babol (North of Iran)
  • L Stimson Henry
  • Center
Henry L. Stimson Center 11 Dupont Circle, NW, 9th Floor Washington, DC 20036 tel: 202.223.5956 www.stimson.org 11-Christine M. Gosden Super Terrorism: Biological, Chemical, and Nuclear, by Yonah Alexander and Milton Hoenig, Editors. Transnational Publishers, Inc., 2001 12-Bijani Kh, Moghadamnia AA: Long-term effects of chemical weapons on respiratory tract in Iraq-Iran war victims living in Babol (North of Iran). Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 2002 Nov;53(3):422-4.