The Taxonomic Significance of Species That Have Only Been Observed Once: The Genus Gymnodinium (Dinoflagellata) as an Example

Université Paris Sud, France
PLoS ONE (Impact Factor: 3.23). 08/2012; 7(8):e44015. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0044015
Source: PubMed


Taxonomists have been tasked with cataloguing and quantifying the Earth's biodiversity. Their progress is measured in code-compliant species descriptions that include text, images, type material and molecular sequences. It is from this material that other researchers are to identify individuals of the same species in future observations. It has been estimated that 13% to 22% (depending on taxonomic group) of described species have only ever been observed once. Species that have only been observed at the time and place of their original description are referred to as oncers. Oncers are important to our current understanding of biodiversity. They may be validly described species that are members of a rare biosphere, or they may indicate endemism, or that these species are limited to very constrained niches. Alternatively, they may reflect that taxonomic practices are too poor to allow the organism to be re-identified or that the descriptions are unknown to other researchers. If the latter are true, our current tally of species will not be an accurate indication of what we know. In order to investigate this phenomenon and its potential causes, we examined the microbial eukaryote genus Gymnodinium. This genus contains 268 extant species, 103 (38%) of which have not been observed since their original description. We report traits of the original descriptions and interpret them in respect to the status of the species. We conclude that the majority of oncers were poorly described and their identity is ambiguous. As a result, we argue that the genus Gymnodinium contains only 234 identifiable species. Species that have been observed multiple times tend to have longer descriptions, written in English. The styles of individual authors have a major effect, with a few authors describing a disproportionate number of oncers. The information about the taxonomy of Gymnodinium that is available via the internet is incomplete, and reliance on it will not give access to all necessary knowledge. Six new names are presented - Gymnodinium campbelli for the homonymous name Gymnodinium translucens Campbell 1973, Gymnodinium antarcticum for the homonymous name Gymnodinium frigidum Balech 1965, Gymnodinium manchuriensis for the homonymous name Gymnodinium autumnale Skvortzov 1968, Gymnodinium christenum for the homonymous name Gymnodinium irregulare Christen 1959, Gymnodinium conkufferi for the homonymous name Gymnodinium irregulare Conrad & Kufferath 1954 and Gymnodinium chinensis for the homonymous name Gymnodinium frigidum Skvortzov 1968.

Download full-text


Available from: Anne Thessen
  • Source
    • "How common are synonyms? For the well studied dino flagellate genus Gymnodinium, an autotroph common in coastal waters, of the 268 described species 103 have never been observed since their description, so called oncers, and a large portion are likely synonyms (Thessen et al., 2012). A very similar level of synonymy or dubious species was found for another genus of dinoflagellates, the relative ly rare Histioneis, heterotrophic dinoflagellates found in open waters. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The view that current species inventories (lists of binomial species) of planktonic protists significantly underestimate true diversity is widespread. However, the existence of synonyms in species lists, due to repeated descriptions of the same form, and polymorphism in which different “forms” or life-history stages are but one species, are generally underappreciated. Recent studies have shown that synonyms are probably common, significantly inflating species lists, and taxa previously thought to be distinct species based on morphology have been revealed to be simple variants of single species. Given here are examples from among tintinnid ciliates, dinoflagellates and foraminifera. The commonality of synonyms and the phenomena of both polymorphism and crypticism underscore a need for taxonomic reviews as well as species-focused studies involving molecular biologists, taxonomists and ecologists.
    Full-text · Article · Sep 2015 · Journal of Plankton Research
  • Source
    • "Some museums have amassed material from across the globe with the intention of documenting the existence of all unique forms of life. As a consequence, collections frequently house many poorly known, rare, endangered, and extinct taxa, some of which may not have been seen again subsequent to their initial collection (Sinha, 1973; Novotny & Basset, 2000; Thessen, Patterson & Murray, 2012). Aside from the importance of museum collections for research and education, they may also represent *Corresponding author. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Museums hold most of the world's most valuable biological specimens and tissues collected, including type material that is often decades or even centuries old. Unfortunately, traditional museum collection and storage methods were not designed to preserve the nucleic acids held within the material, often reducing its potential viability and value for many genetic applications. High-throughput sequencing technologies and associated applications offer new opportunities for obtaining sequence data from museum samples. In particular, target sequence capture offers a promising approach for recovering large numbers of orthologous loci from relatively small amounts of starting material. In the present study, we test the utility of target sequence capture for obtaining data from museum-held material from a speciose mammalian genus: the horseshoe bats (Rhinolophidae: Chiroptera). We designed a ‘bait’ for capturing > 3600 genes and applied this to 10 species of horseshoe bat that had been collected between 93 and 7 years ago and preserved using a range of methods. We found that the mean recovery rate per species was approximately 89% of target genes with partial sequence coverage, ranging from 3024 to 3186 genes recovered. On average, we recovered 1206 genes with ≥ 90% sequence coverage, per species. Our findings provide good support for the application of large-scale bait capture across congeneric species spanning approximately 15 Myr of evolution. On the other hand, we observed no clear association between the success of capture and the phylogenetic distance from the bait model, although sample sizes precluded a formal test.
    Full-text · Article · Aug 2015 · Biological Journal of the Linnean Society
  • Source
    • "Unfortunately, at present it is often tedious, even with the help of new technologies, to obtain information on a taxonomic name, either to track its origins and subsequent use, or to verify that it has been correctly used. Taxonomists have to consult primary literature because they consider that online resources are incomplete (Thessen et al. 2012, Franz et al. 2008). Nowadays, species identification errors come from diverse causes: the variation in data quality and cross-linkages between databases, an inadequate updating of information and the lack of a single authoritative world taxonomic resource for the definition of the taxa cause. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This paper introduces a new method of automatically extracting, integrating and presenting information regarding species from the most relevant online taxonomic resources. First, the information is extracted and joined using data wrappers and integration solutions. Then, an analytical tool is used to provide a visual representation of the data. The information is then integrated into a user friendly content management system. The proposal has been implemented using data from the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF), the Catalogue of Life (CoL), the World Register of Marine Species (WoRMS), the Integrated Taxonomic Information System (ITIS) and the Global Names Index (GNI). The approach improves data quality, avoiding taxonomic and nomenclature errors whilst increasing the availability and accessibility of the information.
    Full-text · Article · Dec 2014 · ZooKeys
Show more