Article

Symbols of Organization: Informal Ways of Negotiating the Global and the Local in MNCs

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

Abstract In this article I build on the growing number of anthropological studies of businesses and explore the role that symbols play in the development of globalizing business networks. Transnational business people employ symbols not only to define boundaries between groups and develop collective solidarity but also to construct continuously changing networks between different social spaces and even, in the final analysis, between the concepts of global and local. The case study presented here focuses on the use of the symbols defining ‘German business style’ by the employees of a branch of a German bank in London as they interact with colleagues in the office, staff at their Frankfurt head office, and their clients and competitors. I conclude that, first, the use of symbols in social interaction is key to the negotiation of global and local spaces, and second, that, as the concepts of ‘global’ and ‘local’ spaces are themselves symbolic constructs, the drawing of distinctions between the two may be misleading.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... In what follows I will examine the discourse of cosmopolitanism for the corporation rather than in the corporation. In other words I will examine how popular management texts prescribe an ideal set of attitudes and characteristics, rather than the degree to which these attitudes are actually present in individual managers and organizations , an area in which some empirical research has been carried out (Monaci, Mugati and Caselli, 2003; Moore, 2004 Moore, , 2005). My analysis falls within what Beck (2004) defines as 'normative' or 'philosophical' cosmopolitanism, i.e. the philosophical analysis of the legitimacy and validity of what are deemed 'cosmopolitan' attitudes. ...
... Professional solidarity, then, is a factor for rationalizing, managing and ultimately controlling cultural difference, rather than recognizing it as a value in its own right. Similarly, an anthropological study by Moore (2004 Moore ( , 2005) of business persons in the City of London branch of a major German bank has demonstrated how professionals use national and 'cosmopolitan' identities as multivalent symbols, particularly by defining themselves and others by means of stereotypical characteristics gained from popular intercultural literature on 'business styles'. 'Cosmopolitanism', Moore finds, is not simply a question of identifying either with national culture or with a global professional group, but is a constantly shifting and ambiguous process of identification in which the professional is aware of the necessity of presenting oneself with a particular identity for a particular time and set of circumstances. ...
Article
This paper examines how the ideal of cosmopolitan identity is represented in selected popular global management texts. The paper argues that the corporate cosmopolitan ideal of a flexible identity draws interdiscursively on two main discourses. Firstly, the Enlightenment ideal of cosmopolitanism, expressed as a moral imperative towards detachment from existing cultural identities and loyalties in the name of the adoption of a universal perspective. This is reflected in the rhetoric of the necessity for managers and employees to ‘transform’ themselves from ‘locals’ into ‘cosmopolitans’. This uplifting rhetoric of ‘transformation’ is however accompanied by the more prosaic discourse of cosmopolitanism as a competence in ‘managing culture’ which can be acquired by all. Secondly, ‘corporate cosmopolitanism’ draws on a ‘postmodern’ ideal of a flexible ‘pastiche’ identity, distanced through irony from all existing cultural and other ‘hot’ loyalties. This discourse is personified in the image of the ‘hybrid’ as the ideal corporate cosmopolitan. The paper argues that corporate cosmopolitanism represents, not a utopia in which cultural difference and diversity is respected and celebrated, but a dystopia in which cultural difference is made superfluous by the establishment of a flexible transnational capitalist class with no attachment to or responsibility for place.
... not really and I've been in contacts eh as I told you before was when I quit my job in a children hospital (.) I was eh in contact with various NGOs both domestic and international and I was travelling eh not only throughout former Yugoslavia but I've been to the Netherlands or Germany or Hungary (.) eh so and (..) eh I didn't find anything strange or different s-it everything was normal there were no unnecessary complications unnecessary eh administrative eh remarks everything makes sense so it was all (.) as simple as it it could be This intersection of the global and the local (also known as glocal: Carr 2004;Moore 2004) is a constant underlying trend in our whole dataset and is reflected in the quotes cited here illustrating the views expressed by the participants. Making the local part of one's self, though, is not an automatic transition from the state of being mobile to being cosmopolitan. ...
Article
In multinational corporate companies, multilingualism is often a daily reality for employees and the negotiation of language practices for work and social purposes, a routine. Despite the role of English as a lingua franca, the linguistic ecology of modern workplaces is dynamic, rich and diverse. While English is often used for communication between a company’s headquarters and its subsidiaries, language choice is dynamically negotiated between the interactants in informal meetings and everyday interactions in the workplace. Against this backdrop, the article discusses the lived experience of the multinational workplace. We draw on interview data with 40 employees in senior and junior management posts in 12 companies situated in Croatia, Greece, Italy, Serbia, Sweden and the UK where English is the official corporate language. Special attention is paid to the employees’ perceptions of the role of languages in their daily work life. We focus here on three discourses that have emerged from the analysis of our data: multilingualism and the use of English, multilingualism and cosmpolitanism, and challenges and expectations of multilingualism. Our findings show that the employees draw on a range of linguistic resources in order to manage their work-related interactions, and dominant ideologies in relation to language use come to the fore. We close the article by focusing on the profile of the ‘global’ employee and the impact of the ‘modern’ workplace on the working realities of the participants.
... Some may wonder to what extent our orientation extends beyond traditional notions of public relations (Grunig, 1992;Moriarty, 1994), corporate self-presentation (Moore, 2004;Pollach, 2005;Roberts, 2003), image management (Cheney & Christensen, 2001;Christensen & Askegaard, 2001;Rowland & Jerome, 2004) or even management by walking around (Bass & Avolio, 1994;Waldman & Yammarino, 1999). In some respects our view parallels what other authors have been saying on these various topics and we certainly do not want to claim that our perspective substitutes this rich body of work. ...
Article
Full-text available
In this article, we develop an analytical perspective to examine how an organization's mode of being is constituted and experienced through ongoing processes of communication. To show the use and implications of this perspective, we analyze how members and partners of Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF, a.k.a.`Doctors Without Borders'), a renowned humanitarian organization, coproduce and problematize the presence of their organization in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Africa.
... The essentialist correlation of cultural characteristics with economic success in 'business culture' literature and its corollary, the identification of certain 'cultural predispositions' as incompatible with it, as exemplified here, can be seen to have two main implications. Firstly, this establishes an essential link between national stereotypes and economic performance which, due to the popularity and widespread nature of such literature, have become familiar through use in business education and transnational business (Dahlen 1997; Moore 2004 Moore , 2005). Secondly, this link forms the foundation for a discourse surrounding the relationship between the success of certain national 'models of capitalism' and their export to other cultures whose development I will examine in the next section. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article examines changing conceptions of culture and nation in business literature from the early 1990s to the present. In the early 1990s the growth of literature concerned with depicting the cultural differences between national varieties of capitalism and business systems seemingly betokened an interest in diversity in the business world. This seeming interest in cultural diversity, however, concealed an implicit neo-liberal teleology which implies a convergence hypothesis and change in the cultural role of the nation state to that of a ‘location manager’, whose role is merely to guarantee favourable conditions for business with the minimum of state intervention. This reconceptualisation of the nation leads to the ultimate stage in this teleology, the discourse of the ‘brand state’, in which ‘culture’ is seen as just equivalent to those aspects of a country’s ‘brand equity’ which meet the requirements of instant recognisability to the outside world.
Article
Introduction While a number of companies have adopted the philosophy that, once they reach a certain degree of globalisation, they can, and should, divorce themselves from their national origins and become ‘international’ instead, sociological and anthropological research on social identity questions whether any company should - or, indeed, can - become completely ‘global’ in this fashion. Through applying a system, society and dominance approach to case studies of the British operations of two German multinationals, one a bank (‘ZwoBank’) and one a car company (‘AutoWorks’), I examine how they took different approaches to the process of being seen as ‘international’, study the impact of this process upon the management culture of the organisation and conclude with a look at more general implications for cross-cultural management and international human resource management. ‘Made in Germany’ or ‘Made by Siemens’: the problem outlined The dominance effect, hyperglobalisers and convergence Although it may seem counter-intuitive in light of the evidence to the contrary, the ‘hyperglobaliser’ and ‘convergence’ philosophies continue to exist, and to contribute to the idea that companies can become truly international. In this section I challenge this idea using SSD theory. David Held, Anthony McGrew, David Goldblatt and Jonathan Perraton (1999) identify hyperglobalisers as follows: that they assume that the processes of globalisation are bringing about a new era in which nation states are decreasing in importance and old divisions are being eroded in favour of a new, more egalitarian economic system (3-5; see also Ohmae, 1990).
Article
Despite the fact that international business (IB) studies frequently has to deal with ambivalent social phenomena, such as the construction of international strategic alliances, expatriate adjustment, and the globalisation of the service industries, ambivalence-tolerant methodologies such as ethnography largely remain on the margins. In this paper, I review selected ethnographic literature in IB studies, employing Smelser's concept of ambivalence as a means of understanding why ethnography has been marginalised, and what a greater focus on ethnography could contribute to IB. I conclude by arguing that the establishment of a more formalised and focused anthropology of international organisations could enable IB scholars to better explore and understand the ambivalent phenomena that pervade its subject matter.
Article
This article examines media discourse surrounding two UK-German intercultural business controversies: the takeover of the German company Mannesmann by the British company Vodafone in 1999, and the disposal of its British subsidiary Rover by its German parent company BMW in 2000. These controversies were framed in the media of both countries as part of a ‘clash of cultures of capitalism’, with the ‘Anglo- Saxon model’ on one side and the ‘German social model’ on the other, and can be seen as ‘legitimacy crises’ of the two models of capitalism involved. The article examines how cultural, economic and political discourses relating to globalization were used strategically by actors to deal with these crises, in order to legitimize a neoliberal transformation of the German model in the first case, and to legitimize a ‘rebranding’ of the UK model in line with a move from a concentration on manufacturing to a service economy in the second.
Article
Full-text available
The most common social phenomenon of Western societies is the organization, yet those involved in real-world managing are not always willing to reveal the intricacies of their everyday muddles. Barbara Czarniawska argues that in order to understand these uncharted territories, we need to gather local and concrete stories about organizational life and subject them to abstract and metaphorical interpretation. Using a narrative approach unique to organizational studies, Czarniawska employs literary devices to uncover the hidden workings of organizations. She applies cultural metaphors to public administration in Sweden to demonstrate, for example, how the dynamics of a screenplay can illuminate the budget disputes of an organization. She shows how the interpretive description of organizational worlds works as a distinct genre of social analysis, and her investigations ultimately disclose the paradoxical nature of organizational life: we follow routines in order to change, and decentralize in order to control. By confronting such paradoxes, we bring crisis to existing institutions and enable them to change.
Article
This book explores the dynamics that have accompanied the implementation of large-scale Urban Development Projects (UDPs) in nine European cities within the European Union (EU). It contributes to the analysis of the relationship between urban restructuring and social exclusion/integration in the context of the emergence of the European-wide ‘new’ regimes of urban governance. These regimes reflect the reawakening of neo-liberal policy and the rise of a New Urban Policy favouring private investments and deregulation of property and labour markets. The selected UDPs further reflect global pressures and changing systems of local, regional, and/or national regulation and governance. These projects, while being decidedly local, capture global trends and new national and local policies as they are expressed in particular institutional forms and strategic practices. The large scale urban interventions were deliberately chosen as reflections of a particular hegemonic and dominant expression of urban policy, as pursued during the 1990s. The book provides a panoramic view of urban change in some of Europe’s greatest cities. The nine case-studies include: The Europeanization of Brussels, The Guggenheim museum in Bilbao, the new financial district in Dublin, the science-university-technology complex ‘Adlershof’ in Berlin, the 1998 World Expo in Lisbon, Athens’s bid to stage the Olympic Games, Vienna’s Donau City, Copenhagen’s Oresund project, and Naples’ new business district. These case-studies testify to the unshakable belief the city elites hold in the healing effects that the production of new urban mega-projects and -events has on their city’s vitality and development potential. The book also analyses the down side of this development in terms of social exclusion, the formation of new urban elites, and the consolidation of less democratic forms of urban governance. The principal aim is to show how the production of these new urban spaces is actually also part of the production of a new polity, a new economy, and new forms of living urban life that are not very promising for a socially harmonious and just future for metropolitan urban Europe.
Chapter
The preceding chapters illustrated in their rich diversity a number of common themes and features that characterize the urban development process in the European Union. Not with standing the profound reorganizations of the urban fabric that the political-economic elites of these cities have pursued in their attempts to insert their urban economies within a neo-liberal and globalizing world order, the concrete transformations exhibit a number of contradictions that stand in sharp contrast with the professed objectives.
Chapter
This book is structured around the view that large-scale Urban Development Projects (UDPs) are the embodiment of processes that operate in and over a variety of scales, from the local to the global. These urban interventions are as it were ‘grains of sand’, albeit of a particularly rough-edged variety, that hold the world’s complex socio-spatial and political-economic configuration in their crystalline structure. They are part of a process of profound restructuring that over the past few decades has transformed the urban landscape in unexpected, perplexing, and often disturbing ways.
Book
Edmund Leach's book investigates the writings of 'structuralists,' and their different theories: the general incest theory and of animal sacrifice. This book is designed for the use of teaching undergraduates in anthropology, linguistics, literary studies, philosophy and related disciplines faced with structuralist argument. It provides the prolegomena necessary to understand the final chapter of Levi-Strauss's massive four-volume Mythologiques. Some prior knowledge of anthropological literature is useful but not essential. The principal ethnographic source is the Book of Leviticus; this guide should help anyone who is trying to grasp the essentials of 'seminology' - the general theory of how signs and symbols come to convey meaning. The author's core thesis is that: 'the indices in non-verbal communication systems, like the sound elements in spoken language, do not have meaning as isolates, but only as members of set'; the book's special merit is that it makes this kind of jargon comprehensible in terms of our everyday experience.
Book
The report examines changing relations between London and Frankfurt with the introduction of a single European currency and the decision to locate the European Central Bank in Frankfurt. Based on interviews with key personnel in global financial and business service firms and institutions in both cities, the findings support a network model of inter-city relations, which, the authors contend, is more appropriate than the simplistic competition model that dominates public discussion. | Free download at https://hdl.handle.net/2134/9572
Book
Article
Skilled international migration is as an important process of both contemporary globalization and the global city. The establishment of a transnational elite of expatriate labour in international finance plays a vital part in the accumulation of capital within international financial centres (IFCs). Expatriate labour has become a major determinant of the IFC, creating financial capital through complex social relations, knowledge networks, practices and discourses. The principal argument being made in this paper is that expatriates are major agents in the accumulation and transfer of financial knowledge in the IFC, and that such processes are undertaken through expatriate global–local knowledge networks and other social practices. The paper is divided into three major parts. Following a discussion of transnational elites as expatriates in global cities, which also conceptualises their contribution to the spatialization of financial knowledge networks, the empirical study investigates the working, social and cultural knowledge networks and practices of British expatriates in Singapore. Finally, the paper revisits the conceptual work on transnational elites and suggests that expatriates were deeply embedded in global–local relations in the workplace and the business/social sphere through interaction with local `western educated/experienced' Singaporeans, but were disembedded from the local in the home and other household social spaces due to the invisibility of the local population in their interactions. Both the theoretical and empirical analyses suggests that expatriates are flow in the Castellian spatial logic of the network society.
Article
A multinational corporation consists of a group of geographically dispersed and goal-disparate organizations that include its headquarters and the different national subsidiaries. Such an entity can be conceptualized as an interorganizational network that is embedded in an external network consisting of all other organizations such as customers, suppliers, regulators, and so on, with which the different units of the multinational must interact. Based on such a conceptualization, the present authors draw on interorganization theory to develop a model of the multinational corporation as an internally differentiated interorganizational network. They propose hypotheses that relate certain attributes of the multinational, such as resource configuration and internal distribution of power, to certain structural properties of its external network.
Book
From the Publisher: This ambitious book is an account of the economic and social dynamics of the new age of information. Based on research in the USA, Asia, Latin America, and Europe, it aims to formulate a systematic theory of the information society which takes account of the fundamental effects of information technology on the contemporary world. The global economy is now characterized by the almost instantaneous flow and exchange of information, capital and cultural communication. These flows order and condition both consumption and production. The networks themselves reflect and create distinctive cultures. Both they and the traffic they carry are largely outside national regulation. Our dependence on the new modes of informational flow gives enormous power to those in a position to control them to control us. The main political arena is now the media, and the media are not politically answerable. Manuel Castells describes the accelerating pace of innovation and application. He examines the processes of globalization that have marginalized and now threaten to make redundant whole countries and peoples excluded from informational networks. He investigates the culture, institutions and organizations of the network enterprise and the concomitant transformation of work and employment. He points out that in the advanced economies production is now concentrated on an educated section of the population aged between 25 and 40: many economies can do without a third or more of their people. He suggests that the effect of this accelerating trend may be less mass unemployment than the extreme flexibilization of work and individualization of labor, and, in consequence, a highly segmented socialstructure. The author concludes by examining the effects and implications of technological change on mass media culture ("the culture of real virtuality"), on urban life, global politics, and the nature of time and history. Written by one of the worlds leading social thinkers and researchers The Rise of the Network Society is the first of three linked investigations of contemporary global, economic, political and social change. It is a work of outstanding penetration, originality, and importance.
Article
Supervisor: Dr Steven Vertovec. Thesis (D. Phil.)--University of Oxford, 2002. Includes bibliographical references (leaves 335-367).
Article
The recent spread of 'structuralist' writing has been hailed as the dawn of a new age and condemned as an intellectual disaster but, like all fashionable diseases, it is more talked about than understood. Edmund Leach's new book is designed for the use if teaching undergraduates in anthropology, linguistics, literary studies, philosophy and related disciplines faced for the first time with structuralist argument; it provides the prolegomena necessary to understand the final chapter of Levi-Strauss's massive four-volume Mythologiques. The objective is complex, the manner simple. Some prior knowledge of anthropological literature is useful but not essential; the principal ethnographic source is the Book of Leviticus; this guide should help anyone who is trying to grasp the essentials of 'seminology' - the general theory of how signs and symbols come to convey meaning.Although, in essence, a textbook, substantial portions of the argument are here presented for the first time; thus Section 16 contains an innovating contribution to general incest theory, and the analysis of the logic of animal sacrifice presented in Section 18 is an advance on anything previous published on this theme. The author's core thesis is that: 'the indices in non-verbal communication systems, like the sound elements in spoken language, do not have meaning as isolates, but only as members of set'; the book's special merit is that it makes this kind of jargon comprehensible in terms of our everyday experience.
Unternehmenskulture: die Entwicklung eines UK-Models und der Berücksichtigung ethnologischer Erkentnisse und dessen Anwerkung auf die Innovations-Thematik
  • A B Schnyder
Schnyder, A. B. (1989) Unternehmenskulture: die Entwicklung eines UK-Models und der Berücksichtigung ethnologischer Erkentnisse und dessen Anwerkung auf die Innovations-Thematik, Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang Verlag.
British management versus German management: a comparison of organizational effectiveness in West German and UK factories
  • J Millar
Millar, J. (1979) British management versus German management: a comparison of organizational effectiveness in West German and UK factories, London: Saxon House.
Industry and society in Europe
  • C Lane
Lane, C. (1995) Industry and society in Europe, London: Edward Elgar.
A cauliflower will cost you 56 centimes – in Rothsham', Financial Times
  • S Jones
Jones, S. (1998) 'A cauliflower will cost you 56 centimes – in Rothsham', Financial Times, 11
Less than a universe of difference: evaluating the reality of German finance Dimensions of German unification: economic, social and legal analyses
  • A Posen
Posen, A. (1993) 'Less than a universe of difference: evaluating the reality of German finance' in A. B. Shingleton, M. J. Gibbon and A. K. S. Mack (eds) Dimensions of German unification: economic, social and legal analyses, Oxford: Westview Press, 43–56.
Introduction' in S. Vertovec and A. Rogers (eds) Muslim European youth: reproducing religion
  • S Vertovec
Vertovec, S. and A. Rogers (1998) 'Introduction' in S. Vertovec and A. Rogers (eds) Muslim European youth: reproducing religion, ethnicity, culture, Aldershot: Ashgate, 1–33.
The conceptualization of place A place in the world
  • D Massey
Massey, D. (1995) 'The conceptualization of place' in D. Massey and P. Jess (eds) A place in the world? Oxford: Oxford University Press, 45–86.
The EEC as an expanded home market for the United Kingdom and the Federal Republic of Germany Business and industrial anthropology: an overviewAnthropology of work in the Fortune 1000: a critical retrospective
  • Arthur D Little
  • Ltd
Arthur D. Little Ltd. (1979) The EEC as an expanded home market for the United Kingdom and the Federal Republic of Germany, London: Anglo–German Foundation. Baba, M. L. (1986) Business and industrial anthropology: an overview, NAPA Bulletin No. 2, Washington: NAPA. Baba, M. L. (1998) 'Anthropology of work in the Fortune 1000: a critical retrospective', Anthropology of Work Review, 18, 17–28.
Management worldwide: the impact of societal culture on organizations around the globe
  • D J Hickson
  • D S Pugh
Hickson, D. J. and D. S. Pugh (2001) Management worldwide: the impact of societal culture on organizations around the globe (2nd edition), London: Penguin.
Nations and nationalism in a global era Uneven development Rethinking symbolism The social practice of symbolization: an anthropological analysis The world in a grain of sand " : large-scale urban development projects and the dynamics of
  • A D N Smith
Smith, A. D. (1995) Nations and nationalism in a global era, Cambridge: Polity Press. Smith, N. (1984) Uneven development, Oxford: Basil Blackwell. Sperber, D. (1974) Rethinking symbolism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Strecker, I. (1988) The social practice of symbolization: an anthropological analysis, London: Athlone Press. Swyngedouw, E., F. Moulaert and A. Rodriguez (2003a) ' " The world in a grain of sand " : large-scale urban development projects and the dynamics of " glocal " transformations' in F.
Narrating the organization: dramas of institutional identity Anglo– German business collaboration: pitfalls and potentials The Nuer
  • B Czarniawska
Czarniawska, B. (1997) Narrating the organization: dramas of institutional identity, London: University of Chicago Press. Ebster-Grosz, D. and D. Pugh (1996) Anglo– German business collaboration: pitfalls and potentials, London: Macmillan Press. Evans-Pritchard, E. E. (1940) The Nuer, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • Ebster-Grosz D.
  • Leach E.
A cauliflower will cost you 56 centimes ‐ in Rothsham
  • Jones S.