Conference PaperPDF Available

Running and Walking with Compliant Legs

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

It has long been the dream to build robots which could walk and run with ease. To date, the stance phase of walking robots has been characterized by the use of either straight, rigid legs, as is the case of passive walkers, or by the use of articulated, kinematically-driven legs. In contrast, the design of most hopping or running robots is based on compliant legs which exhibit quite natural behavior during locomotion.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... Visual inspection of simulations using the spring-mass model show the vertical CoM displacement and vertical GRFs were consistently overestimated compared to experimental running data (Bullimore andBurn 2007, Lipfert et al 2012); suggesting the springmass model is not as good at modelling running as the literature might imply. Presumably, to improve the agreement between the simulations and experimental data, a number of two-segment (Rummel and Seyfarth 2008, Phan et al) and three-segment (Seyfarth et al 2001, Seyfarth et al 2006, Qiao et al 2017 lower limb models have been developed. ...
... Lim and Park (2018) also showed that the addition of an off-centred curvy foot connected to the leg by a compliant segment qualitatively improved agreement with empirical data of both walking a running compared to the original spring mass model. On the other hand, the three-segment models showed that having a small foot relative to the shank allows for large knee extensions, and a small foot relative to the thigh requires a lower ankle joint stiffness than knee joint stiffness (Seyfarth et al 2001, Seyfarth et al 2006. These results are characteristic of a human leg configuration, suggesting such a model could improve prediction of the kinematic and kinetic characteristics of running. ...
Article
Full-text available
Mathematical models have the potential to provide insight into human running. Existing models can be categorised as either simple or complex, and there appears to be a lack of natural progression in model development. By sequentially adding complexity, there is the potential to determine how different mechanical components contribute to the biomechanics of running. In this study, a series of four models, of increasing complexity were developed in OpenSim: a simple spring-mass model, a two-segment model with a torsional spring at the knee and two three-segment models, one with a sprung knee and ankle and another with a sprung knee and actuated ankle. For each model, a forward simulation was developed and model predictions compared with experimental data from 10 forefoot runners. The results showed the spring-mass model overestimated the vertical displacement of the centre of mass (percentage difference: 43.6(22.4)-67.7(21.7)%) and underestimated the vertical ground reaction force (percentage difference: 13.7(8.9)-34.4(10.9)%) compared to the experimental data. Adding a spring at the knee increased the match with the vertical centre of mass displacement (percentage difference: 4.4(25.2)-18.4(40.2)%), however, geometry restrictions meant it was only possible to model approximately 60% of stance. The passive three-segment model showed a good match with centre of mass movements across most of stance (percentage difference in the vertical centre of mass displacement: 4.3(24.5)-21.3(19.2)%), however, actuation at the ankle was required to obtain a closer match with experimental kinetics and joint trajectories (e.g. vertical ground reaction force RMSD decreased by approximately 0.4BW). This is the first study to investigate models of increasing complexity of distance running. The results show that agreement between experimental data and model simulations improves as complexity increases and this provides useful insight into the mechanics of human running.
... Recent articles on quadrupedal and bipedal walking and running (Lee et al., 2011(Lee et al., , 2013Nauwelaerts et al., 2015;O'Neill and Schmitt, 2012), along with theoretical models by Geyer et al. (2006) and Seyfarth et al. (2006), have led to the development of a more nuanced model of a SLIP and the idea that pendular periods and collisional periods are both important to consider in evaluating potential costs of locomotion (Lee et al., 2011;O'Neill and Schmitt, 2012) rather than treating those as discreet and mutually exclusive. In SLIP models, a continuum between an infinitely stiff or infinitely compliant spring element can be used to represent a full range of gaits, from inverted pendulum-like walking, through pogo-stick-like running, to the highly compliant 'stealthy' gaits. ...
Article
It is thought that the magnitude of center of mass (COM) oscillations can affect stability and locomotor costs in arboreal animals. Previous studies have suggested that minimizing collisional losses and maximizing pendular energy exchange are effective mechanisms to reduce muscular input and energy expenditure during terrestrial locomotion. However, few studies have explored whether these mechanisms are used in an arboreal context, where stability and efficiency often act as tradeoffs. This study explores three-dimensional center of mass mechanics in an arboreal primate—the squirrel monkey (Saimiri sciureus)—moving quadrupedally at various speeds on instrumented arboreal and terrestrial supports. Using kinetic data, values of energy recovery, center of mass mechanical work and power, potential and kinetic energy congruity, and collision angle and fraction were calculated for each stride. Saimiri differed from many other mammals by having lower energy recovery. Although few differences were observed in center of mass mechanics between substrates at low or moderate speeds, as speed increased, center of mass work was done at a much greater range of rates on the pole. Collision angles were higher, while collision fractions and energy recovery values were lower on the pole, indicating less moderation of collisional losses during arboreal versus terrestrial locomotion. These data support the idea that the energetic demands of arboreal and terrestrial locomotion differ, suggesting that arboreal primates likely employ different locomotor strategies compared to their terrestrial counterparts—an important factor in the evolution of arboreal locomotion.
... However, in wearable robotics, the required torques are rarely perfectly linear with respect to the output angle over the entire operating range of motion. The joint stiffness profiles required for walking, for example, exhibit low stiffness at low joint flexion and high stiffness at high joint flexion (Seyfarth et al., 2006). A closer match between the spring characteristic and the required torque can be achieved by means of nonlinear transmissions. ...
Article
Full-text available
The science and technology of wearable robots are steadily advancing, and the use of such robots in our everyday life appears to be within reach. Nevertheless, widespread adoption of wearable robots should not be taken for granted, especially since many recent attempts to bring them to real-life applications resulted in mixed outcomes. The aim of this article is to address the current challenges that are limiting the application and wider adoption of wearable robots that are typically worn over the human body. We categorized the challenges into mechanical layout, actuation, sensing, body interface, control, human-robot interfacing and coadaptation, and benchmarking. For each category, we discuss specific challenges and the rationale for why solving them is important, followed by an overview of relevant recent works. We conclude with an opinion that summarizes possible solutions that could contribute to the wider adoption of wearable robots.
... Legged robots have been developed with varying abilities to perform human-like locomotion (Collins et al., 2005;Torricelli et al., 2016;Kim and Wensing, 2017). For example, robots have been developed with comparable efficiency to human walking (Collins et al., 2005;McGeer, 1990) and an ability to generate a variety of movement tasks, such as walking and running (Seyfarth et al., 2006;Kwon and Park, 2003;Jones and Hurst, 2012). ...
Article
Robotic limb design struggles to combine energy efficiency with human-like levels of movement versatility. High efficiency and a range of angles and torques are characteristics of human hopping at different frequencies. Humans use muscles in combination with tendons to achieve the required joint actuation. Therefore, we consider whether appropriately tuned series elastic actuators (SEAs) placed at the leg joints can be used to reduce the functional gap between robots and humans. Human hip, knee, and ankle biomechanics were recorded over a range of hopping frequencies to extract joint angles and torques, which were used as an input to a mechanical simulation SEA model. This model was used to optimize the SEA stiffness of each joint to either minimize peak power or energy requirements. This work investigated the relationship between hopping frequency and SEA stiffness, the utility of using SEAs at each joint, and the reasons behind humans’ preferred hopping frequency. Although the constant stiffness values across different hopping frequencies are suitable for the knee and the ankle, a variable serial elastic actuator stiffness could still further reduce energy requirements. Optimal SEA stiffness was found to reduce peak power requirements by up to 73 % at the ankle and up to 66 % at the knee, with greatest benefits found around the preferred frequency. However, no SEA benefits were found for the hip and above the preferred hopping frequency for the knee. These insights could be used to aid in the design of robotic and assistive devices to achieve versatile and energy efficient human-like movements.
... In the context of locomotion, robotic systems used biarticular structures with compliant properties of muscles or tendons [124,[130][131][132][133][134][135]. Such designs are inspired by biological bodies [136,137]. Both of these qualities, biarticular arrangement and inherent compliant properties, can be considered tools for control embodiment. ...
Article
Full-text available
Leg morphology is an important outcome of evolution. A remarkable morphological leg feature is the existence of biarticular muscles that span adjacent joints. Diverse studies from different fields of research suggest a less coherent understanding of the muscles' functionality in cyclic, sagittal plane locomotion. We structured this review of biarticular muscle function by reflecting biomechanical template models, human experiments and robotic system designs. Within these approaches, we surveyed the contribution of biarticular muscles to the locomotor subfunctions (stance, balance and swing). While mono- and biarticular muscles do not show physiological differences, the reviewed studies provide evidence for complementary and locomotor subfunction-specific contributions of mono- and biarticular muscles. In stance, biarticular muscles coordinate joint movements, improve economy (e.g. by transferring energy) and secure the zig-zag configuration of the leg against joint overextension. These commonly known functions are extended by an explicit role of biarticular muscles in controlling the angular momentum for balance and swing. Human-like leg arrangement and intrinsic (compliant) properties of biarticular structures improve the controllability and energy efficiency of legged robots and assistive devices. Future interdisciplinary research on biarticular muscles should address their role for sensing and control as well as non-cyclic and/or non-sagittal motions, and non-static moment arms.
... Our results show that the presented VSA can span from a rigid configuration, up to 5 Nm/deg, to values very close to zero, resulting in a passive behavior of the joint useful when the limb should move freely under inertial or gravitational effects, e.g., during the swing phase. Besides, the actuator presents a stiffening effect with respect to the deviation angle, which has been found beneficial for locomotion (Seyfarth et al., 2006;Vanderborght et al., 2011). Finally, in a previous study the authors demonstrated the ability of the proposed VSA to reduce it's electrical energy consumption online during the execution of repetitive tasks (Jimenez-Fabian et al., 2018). ...
Article
Full-text available
Achieving human-like locomotion with humanoid platforms often requires the use of variable stiffness actuators (VSAs) in multi-degree-of-freedom robotic joints. VSAs possess 2 motors for the control of both stiffness and equilibrium position. Hence, they add mass and mechanical complexity to the design of humanoids. Mass distribution of the legs is an important design parameter, because it can have detrimental effects on the cost of transport. This work presents a novel VSA module, designed to be implemented in a bio-inspired humanoid robot, Binocchio, that houses all components on the same side of the actuated joint. This feature allowed to place the actuator's mass to more proximal locations with respect to the actuated joint instead of concentrating it at the joint level, creating a more favorable mass distribution in the humanoid. Besides, it also facilitated it's usage in joints with centralized multi-degree of freedom (DoF) joints instead of cascading single DoF modules. The design of the VSA module is presented, including it's integration in the multi-DoFs joints of Binocchio. Experiments validated the static characteristics of the VSA module to accurately estimate the output torque and stiffness. The dynamic responses of the driving and stiffening mechanisms are shown. Finally, experiments show the ability of the actuation system to replicate the envisioned human-like kinematic, torque and stiffness profiles for Binocchio.
... The greater stability of hexapods becomes an advantage because it eases control. 16 The robotic vehicle presented in this article has a kind of legs that has been described in three previous articles. The first one, presented by Nuñez-Altamirano et al., 2 explains the skills by means of which the PL-based leg reconfigures itself according to the spatial descriptions of three points found on the route where the robotic machine walks. ...
Article
Full-text available
This article describes the way in which six nontraditional legs collaborate to provide locomotion to a walking machine when it moves along a path. Such legs are based on the one-degree-of-freedom Peaucellier–Lipkin mechanism, which was modified by the addition of four degrees of freedom. Such five-degree-of-freedom legs have the ability to adapt their postures according to the center of rotation around of which the machine walks. The attributes and abilities of the hexapod are expressed by means of a mathematical framework, which grants the spatial description and required joint variables, according to a specific task, resulting in the configuration of its legs for a particular path planning. Additionally, the article presents an illustrative example describing a detailed procedure concerning the configurations and collaboration of their legs according to an imposed center of rotation around of which the six-legged robot walks.
... For this reason, several researchers have implemented springs in hopping robots [194,129,93,16]. Based on the notion that the knee joint needs to stiffen as it is flexed more in order to ensure stable hopping [201,186], the stiffness of the knee actuator is often nonlinear in compliant designs [220]. The ability to vary stiffness is also an important feature, because the stiffness of the leg determines the hopping frequency [65] and varying stiffness allows us to adapt to the surface stiffness [69]. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
In this dissertation, we present and evaluate simple methods and models for the optimization of energy-efficient actuators. Furthermore, we discuss two energy-efficient actuation paradigms: compliance and redundancy. The first part of this work discusses how modeling affects the energy-efficient design of actuators. Unlike many other works, where the models are limited to the mechanical domain, our analysis addresses friction, nonlinear gearbox efficiency, speed- and load-dependent motor losses and losses in the drive circuitry. These aspects are shown to have a considerable effect on the actuator's power and energy consumption. In the second part of this work, two basic elastic actuator configurations are compared: Series Elastic Actuation (SEA) and Parallel Elastic Actuation (PEA). An interesting conclusion of this work was the strong impact of motor and gearbox losses on the optimal spring stiffness. Motor limitations also have a strong influence on the selection of the optimal spring configuration, as demonstrated in a case study on the design of an active ankle prosthesis. Another energy-efficient actuation paradigm studied in this work is redundancy. In a redundant actuator, the required output power can be distributed over the two motors, so that the overall efficiency of the actuator can be increased. From the different types of redundancy, kinematic redundancy emerged as a promising option for robotics. Kinematically redundant actuators offer the possibility of lowering the reflected inertia, allowing them to achieve high accelerations, even if a high torque is required. Finally, we study whether series elasticity and redundancy can be combined in a single actuator. We demonstrate that a series elastic dual-motor actuator concept can be applied to a hopping robot by implementing and validating a general control framework that generates repetitive hopping, while effectively managing the actuator's redundant degree of freedom.
Article
Full-text available
Leg properties have been involved in the broad study of human walking from mechanical energy to motion prediction of robotics. However, the variable leg elasticities and their functions during gait have not been fully explored. This study presented that the fundamental leg properties during human walking comprise axial stiffness, rest leg length, tangential stiffness and force-free leg angles. We measured the axial force-leg length and tangential force-leg angle data in eight participants (mean ± s.d. age 24.6 ± 3.0 years, mass 68.2 ± 6.8 kg, height 177.5 ± 5.2 cm) at three self-selected walking speeds (slow: 1.25 ± 0.22, normal: 1.48 ± 0.28, fast: 1.75 ± 0.32 m/s) on two different contact conditions (fixed and moving). After obtaining these gait measurements, we extracted the linear and nonlinear leg elasticities during human walking by using a minimum root-mean-square fitting. We found that the axial stiffness of nonlinear elasticity (fixed condition: 7.1−8.0, moving condition: 21.3−22.6) is higher than that of the linear elasticity (fixed condition: 5.0−5.7, moving condition: 15.2−16.5). The tangential stiffness behaves different during four stance phases of gait, with the highest (linear: 2.52−3.72, nonlinear: 1.71−2.01, in moving condition) occurred at early stance and second highest at late stance, followed by two stiffnesses in mid-stance. For both linearity and nonlinearity, the axial stiffness and rest length are independent of walking speeds in both contact conditions, while the tangential stiffness and contact angles are independent of walking speeds only in moving condition. Regardless of walking speed, elasticity and contact condition, the force-free contact angle at mid-stance is maintained at average of 82.2°. This paper first demonstrates the mechanical walking leg property from both axial and tangential aspects. The findings provide insight into the fundamental properties including linearity and nonlinearity of human leg during locomotion for stability analysis and precise motion prediction of robotics and rehabilitation exoskeletons.
Article
Hareketli robotlarda eklem tahriki için dişli kutusuna sahip elektrik motorları yaygın olarak kullanılmaktadır. Dişli kutusu çıkışında yüksek empedans görülmektedir. Robotlarda eklem hızlarına, hareket türüne ve dışarıdan gelecek darbelere karşı eklem empedansının sürekli olarak değiştirilmesi gereklidir. Bu soruna çözüm oluşturulması için dişli kutusunun çıkışına seri olarak yay ve benzeri elastik elemanlar kullanılmış ve bunların yay katsayıları değişik yöntemlerle değiştirilmeye çalışılmıştır. Kısıtlı hareket alanlarında başarı da elde edilmiştir. Bu çalışmada daha pratik mekanik uygulamaya ve daha geniş yay katsayısı aralığına sahip eleman geliştirilmesi hedeflenmiştir. Bu amaçla hava yayı geliştirilmiş ve bu elemanın değişik yük ve basınç aralıklarında karakteristiği çıkarılmıştır. İlk deneysel bulgularda, farklı basınçlar altında seri elastik elemanın deformasyon ve yük eğrileri elde edilmiş, bu elamanların geniş kuvvet aralıklarında etkin kullanılabileceğini görülmüştür.
Article
Full-text available
In running, the spring-like axial behavior of stance limbs is a well-known and remarkably general feature. Here we consider how the rotational behavior of limbs affects running stability. It is commonly observed that running animals retract their limbs just prior to ground contact, moving each foot rearward towards the ground. In this study, we employ a conservative spring-mass model to test the effects of swing-leg retraction on running stability. A feed-forward control scheme is applied where the swing-leg is retracted at constant angular velocity throughout the second half of the swing phase. The control scheme allows the spring-mass system to automatically adapt the angle of attack in response to disturbances in forward speed and stance-limb stiffness. Using a return map to investigate system stability, we propose an optimal swing-leg retraction model for the stabilization of flight phase apex height. The results of this study indicate that swing-leg retraction significantly improves the stability of spring-mass running, suggesting that swing-phase limb dynamics may play an important role in the stabilization of running animals.
Article
Full-text available
The spring-loaded inverted pendulum (SLIP), or monopedal hopper, is an archetypal model for running in numerous animal species. Although locomotion is generally considered a complex task requiring sophisticated control strategies to account for coordination and stability, we show that stable gaits can be found in the SLIP with both linear and "air" springs, controlled by a simple fixed-leg reset policy. We first derive touchdown-to-touchdown Poincaré maps under the common assumption of negligible gravitational effects during the stance phase. We subsequently include and assess these effects and briefly consider coupling to pitching motions. We investigate the domains of attraction of symmetric periodic gaits and bifurcations from the branches of stable gaits in terms of nondimensional parameters.
Article
Full-text available
The approach of cheap design has been providing a number of implications by viewing behavior as the result of a system-environment interaction. It states that adaptive behavior cannot be reduced into the problem of control architectures, but the coupling between the system and the environment is essential. Case studies in the past have demonstrated not only the efficient behaviors but also the underlying mechanisms in the perception and the learning processes. This paper explores additional insights of the cheap design approach by introducing two recent case studies of the locomo-tion robots, which involve a few potentially important research directions for our further understanding of adaptive behavior. The first case study investigates the complex leg operation during bipedal walking. A newly developed biped robot will demonstrate the relatively complex human locomotion as a self-organized behavior of the compliant passive legs without the necessity of sensory feedback. In the second case study, we will discuss how the body dynamics influences the cognitive processes; It will be shown that, by exploiting the intrinsic body dynamics, the sensor information can be meaningfully structured for the purpose of situated perception of the environment.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Conventional models of bipedal walking generally assume rigid body structures, while elastic material properties seem to play an essential role in nature. On the basis of a novel theoretical model of bipedal walking, this paper investigate a simple model for biped robots which makes use of minimum control and elastic passive joints inspired from the structures of biological systems. The model is eval- uated in simulation and a physical robotic platform with respect to the kinemat- ics and the ground reaction force. The experimental results show that the behavior of this simple locomotion model shows a considerable similarity to that of human walking.
Article
Full-text available
The work done during each step to lift and to reaccelerate (in the forward direction) and center of mass has been measured during locomotion in bipeds (rhea and turkey), quadrupeds (dogs, stump-tailed macaques, and ram), and hoppers (kangaroo and springhare). Walking, in all animals (as in man), involves an alternate transfer between gravitational-potential energy and kinetic energy within each stride (as takes place in a pendulum). This transfer is greatest at intermediate walking speeds and can account for up to 70% of the total energy changes taking place within a stride, leaving only 30% to be supplied by muscles. No kinetic-gravitational energy transfer takes place during running, hopping, and trotting, but energy is conserved by another mechanism: an elastic "bounce" of the body. Galloping animals utilize a combination of these two energy-conserving mechanisms. During running, trotting, hopping, and galloping, 1) the power per unit weight required to maintain the forward speed of the center of mass is almost the same in all the species studied; 2) the power per unit weight required to lift the center of mass is almost independent of speed; and 3) the sum of these two powers is almost a linear function of speed.
Article
A simple spring-mass model consisting of a massless spring attached to a point mass describes the interdependency of mechanical parameters characterizing running and hopping of humans as a function of speed. The bouncing mechanism itself results in a confinement of the free parameter space where solutions can be found. In particular, bouncing frequency and vertical displacement are closely related. Only a few parameters, such as the vector of the specific landing velocity and the specific leg length, are sufficient to determine the point of operation of the system. There are more physiological constraints than independent parameters. As constraints limit the parameter space where hopping is possible, they must be tuned to each other in order to allow for hopping at all. Within the range of physiologically possible hopping frequencies, a human hopper selects a frequency where the largest amount of energy can be delivered and still be stored elastically. During running and hopping animals use flat angles of the landing velocity resulting in maximum contact length. In this situation ground reaction force is proportional to specific contact time and total displacement is proportional to the square of the step duration. Contact time and hopping frequency are not simply determined by the natural frequency of the spring-mass system, but are influenced largely by the vector of the landing velocity. Differences in the aerial phase or in the angle of the landing velocity result in the different kinematic and dynamic patterns observed during running and hopping. Despite these differences, the model predicts the mass specific energy fluctuations of the center of mass per distance to be similar for runners and hoppers and similar to empirical data obtained for animals of various size.