... Generally, students are most commonly offered formal professional work placement opportunities in the penultimate year of their undergraduate study, when students are more knowledgeable about practice and their discipline (Case & Jawitz, 2004; Joshua & Fleming, 2002; Reddy & Moores, 2006; Rees, Collett, Crowther, & Mylrea, 1998; Rees, Collett, Mylrea, & Crowther, 1996; Wilson, Jesson, Langley, Clarke, & Hatfiel, 2005). There are a number of studies reporting the benefits of these experiential learning experiences (e.g. Brown et al., 2005; Joshua & Fleming, 2002; McDermott, Caiola, Kuhn, Stritter, & Beza, 1995; Smith, & Hall, 2008; Wilson et al., 2005), but negative features of experiential learning in higher education have rarely been discussed (Auburn, 2007). Also, little is known about the benefits and shortcomings of such experiential learning in the early stages of undergraduate education and training. ...