Article

Two Centuries of Progress in Technical Communication

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

A common aphorism in the halls of education is that the writing skills of Americans decline over time. Compared to the "golden age of letters," so the argument goes, each subsequent generation of writers is worse than the last. Although contemporary readers and educators commiserate over encounters with bad writing, a fair comparison of 18th century American exemplars to modern American exemplars reveals a significant advance in clarity, an advance that technical communicators can be proud of. To demonstrate the advances in expository writing over the past two centuries, the author compares what the authors of the U.S. Constitution did with their limited resources to what modern professional communicators do with their abundance of resources. Many of the communication problems that were pervasive when the U.S. Constitution was created have since been remedied by insights emerging from the fields of linguistics, human factors, and cognitive psychology, among others.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Article
There is ample evidence of a longstanding and pervasive discourse positioning students, and engineering students in particular, as “bad writers.” This is a discourse perpetuated within the academy, the workplace, and society at large. But what are the effects of this discourse? Are students aware faculty harbor the belief students can’t write? Is student writing or confidence in their writing influenced by the negative tone of the discourse? This dissertation attempts to demonstrate that a discourse disparaging student writing exists among faculty, across disciplines, but particularly within the engineering disciplines, as well as to identify the reach of that discourse through the deployment of two attitudinal surveys—one for students, across disciplines, at Michigan Technological University and one for faculty, across disciplines at universities and colleges both within the United States and internationally. This project seeks to contribute to a more accurate and productive discourse about engineering students, and more broadly, all students, as writers—one that focuses on competencies rather than incompetence, one that encourages faculty to find new ways to characterize students as writers, and encourages faculty to recognize the limits of the utility of practitioner lore.
Article
This article combines an adaptation of the Toulmin model of argument with a framework designed to analyze assertions of technology-related expertise in order to examine how expert witnesses fulfill the legal requirements for explaining the methodology underlying their testimony within the combative and sometimes prejudicial conditions of the courtroom environment. Its findings support previous claims about contributions technical communication scholars can make to the legal field.
Article
Purpose This paper aims to examine and critique the accounting literature's dominant readability formula, the Flesch formula. Furthermore, the paper sets out to propose refinement and augmentation to the formula with a view to expanding its applicability and relevance to researchers' attempts at better understanding and critiquing the effectiveness of accounting communications. This aim extends to setting a more robust foundation for informing policymakers' and practitioners' interest in implementing more effective communications with their target stakeholders. Design/methodology/approach The paper offers an historically informed methodological critique of the current articulation and application of the Flesch formula, both generally and in accounting research. This critique forms the basis for developing proposed revisions and supplementary measures to augment Flesch's coverage. These are presented with sample empirics. Findings Illustrative examples suggest that it is feasible and desirable to apply a revised formula that reduces Flesch's misplaced emphasis on word length by respecifying its sentence length variable, a probable cause of low readability. A reader attribute score further enhances the formula by integrating the considerable impact of readers' attributes on readability and accounting communication effectiveness. Supplementary measures, comprising non‐narrative communications dimensions, are introduced as a foundation for further research. Originality/value The paper provides not only critique but also refinement and augmentation of the much used Flesch readability formula for accounting communications research. It offers a first stage approach to encompassing potentially important communication elements such as readers' attributes, tables, graphs and headings, to date critiqued as potentially important but left unattended by accounting researchers. This offers the prospect of extending Flesch's application to contemporary accounting communications issues and questions.
Article
Full-text available
The recommendation that regulatory language should be consistent is common in guides or manuals for drafting as well as in several studies. Yet a review from the angle of practice demonstrates the desirability of a more functional recommendation. This study offers some ideas in this regard. It analyses which might be the optimal definition for consistency and its types, and it asks whether the recommendation should be applied in all cases. That discussion then serves as the basis for a new formulation of the recommendation.
Article
This article analyzes the effects of a transparency view of language that is implicit in some technical discourses. Using a legal concept, the excited utterance exception to hearsay, as an exemplary discourse, I show that this view of language is predicated on social norms rather than empirical standards. Indeed, I argue, the measurement of accuracy using an empirical standard creates a situation in which the speaker's rhetorical concerns and the context can be ignored.
Article
Full-text available
(This partially reprinted article originally appeared in Psychological Review, 1956, Vol 63, 81–97. The following abstract of the original article appeared in PA, Vol 31:2914.) A variety of researches are examined from the standpoint of information theory. It is shown that the unaided observer is severely limited in terms of the amount of information he can receive, process, and remember. However, it is shown that by the use of various techniques, e.g., use of several stimulus dimensions, recoding, and various mnemonic devices, this informational bottleneck can be broken. 20 references. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
Full-text available
A variety of researches are examined from the standpoint of information theory. It is shown that the unaided observer is severely limited in terms of the amount of information he can receive, process, and remember. However, it is shown that by the use of various techniques, e.g., use of several stimulus dimensions, recoding, and various mnemonic devices, this informational bottleneck can be broken. 20 references. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2006 APA, all rights reserved).
Article
When people read silently, they unconsciously translate what they read into a speech-like code that facilitates word identification and the creation of meaning, especially when they read scientific and technical texts. Many studies have explored how this "silent speech" affects the reading process. As a follow-up to a previous article about applying a phonological reading model to technical communication, this article proposes that educators and practitioners of technical communication would benefit greatly from a thorough understanding of the speech instinct. Therefore, the author explores the speech instinct, how humans developed it, and how it has been and still is fostered by reading behavior and pedagogy.
Article
When people read silently, they unconsciously translate what they read into a speech-like code that facilitates word identification and the creation of meaning. This article examines that phenomenon - known as silent speech - based upon the published research of cognitive psychologists and psycho-linguists. The author develops a phonological model of reading based upon published results of experimental investigators to determine the relationship between cognition and silent speech. The author then applies the model to technical communication. The applications include the use of punctuation, pronouns, and abbreviations, as well as introducing new words, writing to satisfy the speech instinct, cultivating a human voice, and revising technical documents.
Article
Some reading researchers and technical communicators assume the efficacy of readability formulas. Reading researchers use such formulas to equalize the reading difficulty of texts used in experiments. Results of an informal Intemet survey indicate that some professional writers and editors use readability formulas that are integrated into word-processing software. This article proposes that readability formulas fail to predict text difficulty. The results of an experiment demonstrate that text difficulty' is a perception of the reader and therefore cannot be objectively calculated by counting syllables, word length, sentence length, and other text characteristics.
Article
Ongoing attempts to define technical writing are inevitably confounded by problems caused by an excessively broad focus, which obscures the basis and usefulness of the definition, or by an excessively narrow focus, which arbitrarily-and sometimes oddly-relegates samples of writing as in or out of the realm of technical writing. Technical writers have been doing their jobs for far too long without a definition to be satisfied with a one- or two-sentence catch-all definition, and such a definition may result in dividing technical writing into two (or more) cultures.
Article
Technical writers and editors are beset with rules. As authoritative as they are, published style guides such as The Chicago manual of style, MLA, APA, and Gregg do not address reading theory but hang their prescriptions on the flimsy mantle of tradition. This article challenges some putative rules of grammar and mechanics in an effort to improve technical texts for the people who read them.
A Grammatical Institute of the English Language: Part II, Facsimile, Delmar, Scholars' Facsimiles & Reprints
  • N Webster
N. Webster, A Grammatical Institute of the English Language: Part II, Facsimile, Delmar, Scholars' Facsimiles & Reprints, New York, New York [1800], 1980. TWO CENTURIES OF PROGRESS IN TECHNICAL COMMUNICATION / 147
The Influence of Text Factors on Readers
  • J H Spyridakis
  • C S Isakson
J. H. Spyridakis and C. S. Isakson, The Influence of Text Factors on Readers, Proceedings of the 45th Annual Conference of the Society for Technical Communication, 1998.
Photography Basics for Technical Communicators: Part 2: Taking Technical Photographs
  • B R Connatser
Connatser, B. R. Photography Basics for Technical Communicators: Part 2: Taking Technical Photographs, Intercom, May 1996.
Self-Reliance, in Essays: First and Second Series, Vintage Books
  • R W Emerson
R. W. Emerson, Self-Reliance, in Essays: First and Second Series, Vintage Books, New York, New York, 1990.
Photography Basics for Technical Communicators: Part 1: Equipping a Communication Department
  • B R Connatser
Connatser, B. R. Photography Basics for Technical Communicators: Part 1: Equipping a Communication Department, Intercom, April 1996.
Transforming Tribal Knowledge into Written Instructions, Intercom
  • B R Connatser
Connatser, B. R. Transforming Tribal Knowledge into Written Instructions, Intercom, April 2006.
Coping with Wordslaughter and the ‘Good Enough’ Syndrome, Intercom
  • B R Connatser
Connatser, B. R. Coping with Wordslaughter and the 'Good Enough' Syndrome, Intercom, January 2004.
The Great Pyramid War in Writing a Professional Life: Stories of Technical Communicators On and Off the Job
  • B R Connatser
Connatser, B. R. The Great Pyramid War in Writing a Professional Life: Stories of Technical Communicators On and Off the Job, Allyn and Bacon, Boston, 2000.
Techniques for Technical Communicators
  • C M Barnum
  • S Carliner
C. M. Barnum and S. Carliner, Techniques for Technical Communicators, Allyn and Bacon, Needham Heights, Massachusetts, 1993.
Reading to Learn to Do, The Technical Writing Teacher
  • J Redish
J. Redish, Reading to Learn to Do, The Technical Writing Teacher, 15, pp. 223-233, 1988. Other Articles On Communication By This Author
The Things Our Readers Do, Intercom
  • B R Connatser