ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

In this study, three cylinder-shaped vortex finders with diameters of 80, 120 and 160 mm were designed and manufactured to find out the pressure drop of the cyclones by experimentally investigating the effects of gas inlet velocity, the vortex finder diameter and length on the cyclone performance at different gas concentration. As a result of this experimental analysis, a critical diameter of vortex finder is obtained as 120 mm. Furthermore, analyzing the experimental findings with a statistical regression method indicated that there was a linear relationship between length of vortex finder and pressure loss. Then, according to the analysis results, relevance values were obtained as 98.87, 98.37 and 97.59% for these vortex finders (with diameters of 80, 120 and 160 mm), respectively.
Content may be subject to copyright.
International Journal of the Physical Sciences Vol. 5 (6), pp. 804-813, June, 2010
Available online at http://www.academicjournals.org/IJPS
ISSN 1992 - 1950 ©2010 Academic Journals
Full Length Research Paper
The effects of vortex finder on the pressure drop in
cyclone separators
Ferit Ficici*, Vedat Ari and Murat Kapsiz
Technical Education Faculty, Sakarya University, Sakarya, Turkey.
Accepted 25 May, 2010
In this study, three cylinder-shaped vortex finders with diameters of 80, 120 and 160 mm were designed
and manufactured to find out the pressure drop of the cyclones by experimentally investigating the
effects of gas inlet velocity, the vortex finder diameter and length on the cyclone performance at
different gas concentration. As a result of this experimental analysis, a critical diameter of vortex finder
is obtained as 120 mm. Furthermore, analyzing the experimental findings with a statistical regression
method indicated that there was a linear relationship between length of vortex finder and pressure loss.
Then, according to the analysis results, relevance values were obtained as 98.87, 98.37 and 97.59% for
these vortex finders (with diameters of 80, 120 and 160 mm), respectively.
Key words: Cyclone, vortex finder, pressure drop.
INTRODUCTION
Cyclones are devices that employ a centrifugal force
generated by a spinning gas stream to separate particles
from the carrier gas (Gimbun et al., 2005). Cyclone
separators operate under the action of centrifugal forces.
Fluid mixture enters the cyclone and makes a swirl
motion and, due to centrifugal forces, the dense phase of
the mixture gains a relative motion in the radial direction
and is separated from main flow (Avci and Karagoz,
2003). In this design, particle-laden gas enters the
cyclone at the top of the cylinder and makes several
revolutions due to the shape of the entry forming a vortex
with a high tangential velocity which accelerates particles
outward to the wall for collection. Below the bottom of the
gas exit tube, the spinning gas gradually migrates inward,
to a “central core” axially along the cylinder centerline,
and from there up, finally out exit tube (Zhu and Lee,
1999). Their simple design, low capital cost and nearly
maintenance-free operation make them ideal for use as
pre-cleaners for more expensive final control devices
such as baghouses or electrostatic precipitators.
Cyclones are particularly well suited for high temperature
and pressure conditions because of their rugged design
and flexible components materials. Cyclone collection
efficiencies can reach 99 % for particles bigger than 5 µm,
*Corresponding author. E-mail: fficici@sakarya.edu.tr.
and can be operated very high dust loading. Cyclones
are used for the removal of large particles for both air
pollution control and process use (Silva et al.,2003).
Application in extreme condition includes the removing of
coal dust in power plant, and the use as a spray dryer or
gasification reactor (Gimbun, 2005).
Engineers are generally interested in two parameters in
order to carry out an assessment of the design and
performance of a cyclone. These parameters are the
collection efficiency of particle and pressure drop through
the cyclone (Dirgo and Leith, 1985). An accurate predict-
tion of cyclone pressure drop is very important because it
relates directly to operating costs. Higher inlet velocities
give higher collection efficiencies for a given cyclone, but
this also increases the pressure drop across the cyclone.
Therefore, a trade off must be made between higher
collection efficiency and low pressure drop across the
cyclone (Griffiths and Boysan, 1996).
The vortex finder size is an especially important
dimension, which significantly affects the cyclone
performance as its size plays a critical role in defining the
flow field inside the cyclone, including the pattern of the
outer and inner spiral flows. The vortex finder affected the
collection efficiency and pressure drop of cyclones, and
proposed an energy-effective cyclone design (Lim et al.,
2003).
The purpose of this study is to help in understanding of
the pressure drop of cyclones by experimentally exploring
Ficici et al. 805
Figure 1. Reverse flow cyclone.
Table 1. Dimensions of the Tests Cyclone.
Sizes (m)
Dc 0.340 h1 0.272
Dw 0.126 h2 0.374
Dp 0.068 h3 0.05
Hc 0.647 be 0.075
ht 0.0961 hi 0.550
the effects of gas inlet velocity, the vortex finder diameter
and length, at different gas concentration, on the cyclone
performance. The pressure drop of cyclones with 3
different vortex finders diameters have been evaluated
and compared. This study focused on the effects of the
vortex finder diameter on the pressure drop as little work
has been performed on cyclones in relation to this
dimension.
EXPERIMENT
Cyclone geometry
There are a number of different forms of cyclone but the reverse
flow cyclone represented in Figure 1 is the most co mmon design
used in the industry. The cyclone consists of four main parts: the
inlet, the separation chamber, the dust chamber and the vortex
finder. Tangential inlets are preferred for the separation of solid
particles from gases (Atmeyer et al., 2004). Cyclone dimension
used in this simulation are as shown in Table 1. Cyclone tests were
performed on the system as shown in Figure 2.
Definition and composition of the pressure drop
Generally, the pressure drop over a cyclone is the difference of
static pressure between the inlet and outlet, which can be written
as:
si so
P P P
∆ =
The static pressure at the inlet cross-section is uniformly distributed
because there is no swirling motion. It can be easily measured with
a pressure tapping in the wall. But the static pressure at the outlet
wall is quite different from its cross- sectional average due to the
strong swirling flow. The dynamic pressure stored in the swirling
motion can be significant. The determination of the static pressure
downstream of a cyclone, hence the pressure drop, becomes more
complicated and difficult (Chen and Shi, 2006).
The total pressure drop consists of four partial pressure drops
(Equation 1) pressure drop due to gas expansion at the separators
entrance; (Equation 2) pressure drop due to wall friction within the
separator; (Equation 3) pressure drop due to swirling motion of the
gas (Equation 4); pressure drop due to gas flow through the outlet
pipe (Zhao,2004).
806 Int. J. Phys. Sci.
Figure 2. Schematic diagram of experimental set-up.
Pressure drop due to gas expansion at the separator entrance
Pressure drop due to gas expansion at the separator inlet was
determined as follows:
1
( )
2
in in g in
ξ ρ
∆ = (1)
This pressure drop was calculated for the case of uniform flow from
the right pipe to the limited space, and was expressed as:
1
( )
Rw
ev
w e re
v v dr
R r
θ θ
=
2
1( )
in
w e
ab
R r H
ξ
 
 
 
= − (2)
Pressure drop due to wall friction within the separator
Pressure drop due to wall friction within the separator can be
described under static equilibrium in the cyclone separators:
2 2
1
1
( ) ( )
4eev
fr
P D d c DL
θ
π τ π
 
 
 
 
 
− = (3)
1
c
is a swirling flow correction factor related to the uniform flow at
the wall in the cyclone separator. According to Stepherd and
Lapple’s method:
1
D
c
a
π
= (4)
ev
θ
τ
is the mean shear stress of the gas in the external vortex, and
can be calculated in terms of Fanning’s equation as:
1
( ).
2
g
ev ev
f v DL
θ θ
τ ρ π
= (5)
where
0.0055
f
=
.
w
v
θ
is the mean tangential velocity in the external vortex, and can
be obtained from:
1
( )
Rw
ev
w e re
v v dr
R r
θ θ
=
(6)
Combining the above equations gives:
2
2
2 2
( / )( ) 1 1
( )
1/4 ( ) ( ) 2
Rw
g in
fr
e w e in re
D a DL f
P v dr v
D d R r v
θ
π π ρ
π
 
 
 
 
∆ = (7)
Pressure drop due to swirling motion of the gas
From the Navier-Stokes equation in cylindrical coordinates, the
relationship between pressure and 3D velocity can be simplified by
neglecting the axial effects:
2
g
v
dp
dr r
θ
ρ
= (8)
According to Mothes and Loffler (1988) the circumferential flow
pattern or velocity profile including the wall roughness is expressed
as follows:
( / ) 1 (1 / )
w
w w
v
vr R P r R
θ
θ
 
 
=+ − (9)
1 1
( . )
4 2
.
d w
w
d
vv
v h v
h
θ
θ
ξ
ξ
= +
(10)
2
0.204( / ) 0.889
w
wd
w
R
v v ab b R
θ
π
 
 
= + (11)
2
d
w
Q
v
R
π
= (12)
2
2 arccos( / 1)
2
w
w w
b R
a h
h
R R
π
π
 
 
 
− −
= + (13)
( )
sin
w
d
v
Pv
θ
ζ
ζ
ε
= + (14)
( )
in
Q ab v
=
(15)
Where
0.0065 0.0075
ζ
= −
Although the expression for
v
θ
looks complicated, the result
agrees very well with the typical velocity profile based on the power-
law correlation of Alexander (1949). The advantage of this
expression is that it presents a quantitative value of the tangential
velocity at the edge of the core,
w
v
θ
, which has sometimes been
assumed equal to the inlet velocity.
Combining and transforming the above equations gives:
2 2
2
2 2
2( / ) ( / ) 1
( )
( / ) (1 / ) 2
Rw
w
wd
g in
Pvf
w r w
re
v v ab R
dr v
r r R P P R
θ
πρ
 
 
 
 
∆ = + −
(16)
Pressure drop due to gas flow through the outlet pipe
This pressure drop includes the local pressure drop and the friction
Ficici et al. 807
pressure drop within outlet pipe.
out
ol of
p p p
= ∆ + ∆
(17)
The local pressure drop was handled as gas flow contraction loss
from the cyclone body to the outlet pipe:
2 2 2
2
1 1
( ) 1 ( ) ( )
2 2
e
g in
ol
e
r
ab
v
r Rw
ξ ρ
π
 
 
 
= − (18)
Because of the strong swirling flow in the outlet pipe, this pressure
drop was calculated in an analogous way to the pressure drop due
to wall frictions within the separator:
2
2
1
( ) . ( )
4
e e
iv
ol
p d c d s s
θ
π τ π
 
 
= + ∆
(19)
'
2
e
e
d
c
d
π
= (20)
2
1
( )
2
g
iv iv
f v
θ θ
τ ρ
= (21)
Where
iv
θ
τ
is the mean shear stress of gas in the internal vortex,
and
iv
v
θ
is the mean tangential velocity in the internal vortex, and
can be obtained by assuming it to be equal to the tangential velocity
at
e
r r
=
:
( / )(1 Pr / )
w
iv
e w e w
v
v
r R P R
θ
θ
=+ − (22)
Combining and transforming the above equations yields:
2
2
2
/
( )
1/4 ( / )(1 Pr / )
wd
of
e e w e w w
v v
S S f ab
d r R P R R
θ
π
ξπ π
 
 
 
+∆
=+ − (23)
Total pressure drop
Su mming up, the equation for total pressure drop can be
expressed as:
in out
fr vf
p p p p p
= ∆ + ∆ + ∆ + ∆
(24)
The pressure drop across a cyclone is co mmonly expressed as the
number of gas inlet velocity heads
ξ
, named the pressure drop
coefficient (PDC), which is just a function of the cyclone geometrical
dimensions. It is accordingly defined as:
2
1/ 2 g
in
p
v
ξρ
= (25)
808 Int. J. Phys. Sci.
Figure 3. Cyclone vortex finder adjusting mechanism
Test procedure
In the experiment (Figure 2), chimney gas of 1100°C is produced
with a diesel oil burner (1). Cyclone inlet flow is measured with a
pitot tube. The necessary gas flow is adapted by tuning the cycle
number of the exiting ventilator. Desired amount of far is supplied
into the system by a loading unit (2) before the entrance of the
testing cyclone (6) and after regime is established, the measures
are recorded. These measuring results recorded as analog signals
are evaluated at Data collecting and Controlling System which is
conducted by a PC. In the experiment, the temperature is
measured at seven different places beginning from the entrance up
to the existence as TG, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, C with the help of a
thermocouple. Moreover, pressures at the entrance and existence
of cyclones are measured and their difference is calculated as
pressure drop (Ari, 2000).
In the experiments, pressure decrease, change at vent depth of
cyclone vortex finder, cyclone entrance velocity, entrance
temperature and entrance concentration are chosen as varying
parameters and pressure drop are investigating according to these
parameters.
The mechanism designed for investigation of the powder
suppression efficiency and pressure drop according to cyclone
vortex finder insert depth are shown in Figure3. The depth of vortex
finder insert depth, here is denoted as h4 and varies from 10 up to
220 mm in length. Experimental program consists of 3 main groups.
First, cyclone, vortex finder diameter of which is changed, is
adapted to experiment set-up. For finding the pressure drop and
powder suppression efficiencies according to change in depth of
vent of the vortex finder, ventilator cycle is stabilized as the flow
velocity would be 12.44 m/s for each vent length and regime of the
system is waited for. Then, 0.566 kg/ m3 farin is loaded to system.
After loading, the decrease of the system entrance temperature to a
constant value is waited for. After that process, other test data,
cyclone entrance temperature, flow measure temperature, cyclone
temperature of conic section, cyclone temperature of cylindrical
section, storing temperature of farin, cyclone entrance and existing
temperatures are recorded by taking the correct values from Control
Unit. Stopping the test, farin, which is and preheated raw material of
cement (limestone kalker+clay) and taken from cyclone powder
reservoir, is carefully collected and weighed out.
At second group of tests, cyclone characteristics for changing
velocities are measured which is increased from 9.5 m/s up to
10.18 m/s. Here, the powder concentration is fixed.
At third and final group of tests, tests are repeated for increasing
behavior of particle concentration.
At each experiments with particles and without particles,
measured values are recorded (Ficici, 2006).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Dependencies at pressure drop according to length of
vortex finder, inlet velocity and concentration for three
different types of vortex finders with different vortex finder
diameters are investigated at the experiments. These
diameters are taken as 80,120 and 160 mm.
Effects of length of vortex finder
The cyclone pressure drops for the different vortex finder
are compared at different length of vortex finder in
Figure4 and Fig5. Figure 5 shows that pressure drop
increases as vortex finder length increases. This situation
is observed for all cyclones. Under these conditions there
is, however, poor separation of coarse particles. The
main reason is that large quantities of coarse particles
bypass the separation process via the short circuit flow
under the top cover and report to the overflow. Extension
of the vortex finder, however, shortens the natural vortex
in the cyclone body and reduces the opportunity of the
fine particles to separate from the vortex. This has been
confirmed for cyclones (Fuping et al., 2006; Martinez et
al., 2008).
In these experiments, pressure drop measured betw-
een entrance and exit points of cyclone are displayed
graphically. According to these results, an increase at
pressure drops is determined depending on the dia-
meters of vortex finder. When we increase the diameter
of vortex finder to 120 mm in the test cyclone with a
diameter of 80 mm, this pressure drop is increased while
a further decrease in diameter to 160 mm causes the
pressure drop to approach to the measured values of the
case with 80 mm diameter. This situation tells us that up
to a critical diameter of vortex finder, pressure drop shows
Ficici et al. 809
y = 7.726x + 11.60
R² = 0.988 y = 7.571x + 0.678
R² = 0.983
y = 6.595x - 3.678
R² = 0.975
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
10 50 90 96 130 170 210 220
Pressure Drop (Pa)
Length of Vortex Finder (mm)
80 mm
120 mm
160 mm
Figure 4. The effect of length of vortex finder on pressure drop.
Figure 5. Effect of length of vortex finder on pressure drop.
shows a climbing behavior and for further increasing
diameters after that absolute diameter value (120 mm), a
sinking behavior is observed. This finding is verified in
other studies of literature (lim et al., 2003; Cullivan et al.,
2004).
In addition, experimental results were also analyzed
with statistical regression method. As a result of
analyzing the experimental results with such a statistical
method, it was observed that there was a linear
relationship between length of vortex finder and pressure
loss. According to the analysis results, relevance values
were obtained as 98.87, 98.37 and 97.59% for lengths of
vortex finder considered as 80, 120 and 160 mm,
respectively. Table 2 shows the using regression
equations.
Effects of inlet velocity
Measurement of the cyclone pressure drop was carried
out for average inlet velocity ranging from 4.62 to 14.16
m/s by Bohnet (Bohnet, 1995) and from 5.1 to 25 m/s by
Griffiths and Boysan (1996). In this study, measurement
of the cyclone pressure drop was carried out for inlet
velocity ranging from 9.56 to 10.18 m/s. The cyclone
pressure drops for the different vortex finder are compar-
810 Int. J. Phys. Sci.
Table 2. Static analysis of length of vortex finder
Regression R2 F Sigf
0
1
80 mm 0.9887 1184.11 0.00 7.7262 11.607
120 mm 0.9837 1124.90 0.00 7.5714 0.6786
160 mm 0.9759 1555.20 0.00 6.5952 3.6786
y = 16.65x + 19.53
R² = 0.948
y = 16.31x + 36.4
R² = 0.959
y = 16.65x + 56.53
R² = 0.948
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
9.56 9.73 9.81 9.98 10.02 10.18
Pressure Drop (Pa)
Average of Inlet Velocity (m/s)
80 mm
120 mm
160 mm
Figure 6. Pressure drops of the cyclone separator with different vortex finder diameter.
Figure 7. Effect of average inlet velocity on pressure drop.
ed at different inlet velocities in Figures 6 and 7. These
Figures show that the cyclone pressure drop is increased
with the all vortex finder diameter. At a low inlet velocity,
the pressure drop increases slowly, and at a higher inlet
velocity, the pressure drop increases greatly (Gimbun et
al., 2005).
Additionally, in this experiment when the velocity of gas
with particles is increased, pressure drops at each
cyclone with three vortex finder diameters differ from
each other. With this fact, it is observed that the diffe-
rence of this pressure drop is decreasing when diameter
of vortex finder value is changed from 80 to 120 mm. A
Ficici et al. 811
Table 3. Static analysis of inlet velocity
Regression R2 F Sigf
0
1
80 mm 0.9482 74.44 0.01 16.657 56.533
120 mm 0.9593 54.80 0.02 16.314 36.400
160 mm 0.9482 54.80 0.02 16.657 19.533
y = 22.5x + 12
R² = 0.810
y = 15.7x +
59
R² = 0.
983
y = 24.7x + 60.5
R² = 0.975
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
0.23
0.38
0
.
52
0
.
67
Pressure Drop (Pa)
Figure 8. The effect of inlet farin concentration on pressure drop.
Table 4. Static analysis of inlet farin concentration
Regression R
2
F Sigf
0
1
80 mm 0.8106 74.44 0,096 16.657 56.533
120 mm 0.9838 54.80 0,007 16.314 36.400
160 mm 0.975 54.80 0,011 16.657 19.533
further increase up to 160 mm, again these differences of
losses become lower. The increase of entrance velocity
is very much related with cycle number of swirl. Since the
swirl cycle number will be much for smaller diameters of
vortex finder, pressure drop is higher than losses at
greater diameters. The conclusion presented in this study
is consistent with the literature (Fuping and Yanpeng,
2009). In addition, According to the regression analysis
results, relevance values were obtained as 94.82, 95.93
and 94.82 % for length of vortex finder considered as 80,
120 and 160 mm, respectively. Table 3 shows the using
regression equations.
Effects of inlet farin concentration
The cyclone pressure drops for the different vortex finder
are compared at different inlet farin concentration in
Figures 8 and 9. In this study, experiments are carried on
with cyclone concentrations are varied between 0.19
kg/m3–0.55 kg/m3. As the farin concentration is increas-
ed, the pressure drop, as expected, also increases. This
finding has been observed by many researchers (Kim
and Lee, 1990; Saltzman and Hochstrasser, 1983; Dirgo
and Leith, 1985; Dirgo and Leith, 1985; Moore and
Mcfarland, 1993).
Furthermore, Pressure loss is highest at cyclone with
160 mm diameter. The reason is that, number of swirls is
less at this diameter. Thus, higher pressure loss is seen
at 160 mm. Table 4 shows that relevant values were
obtained as 81.06, 98.38, and 97.5% for length of vortex
finder considered as 80, 120 and 160 mm, respectively.
Conclusions
As a result of this experimental research and data from it,
a critical diameter of vortex finder is obtained. This is
812 Int. J. Phys. Sci.
Figure 9. Effect of inlet farin concentration on pressure drop.
determined as 120 mm. A desired result has not been
obtained according to cyclone collection efficiency
despite the fact that further increase in diameter lowered
the pressure drops. That means that pressure drop can
be lowered with increasing diameter, however efficiency
of collection is lost then. In this research, the theoretical
argument of critical vortex finder is experimentally
proved.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The authors would like to thank the Nuh Cement A.S for
financial and technical supports.
NOMENCLATURE
a [m] inlet height
b [m] inlet width
B [m] particle outlet diameter
c [-] swirling flow correction factor
D [m] cyclone body diameter
de [m] gas outlet diameter
h [m] cyclone cylinder height
H [m] cyclone height
L [m] natural length of cyclone
p [Pa] pressure
P [-] parameter of momentum
exchange between gas at the
wall
Q [m3/s] volumetric gas flow rate
r [m] radial dimension
Rw [m] cyclone body radius
re [m] vortex finder radius
S [m] gas outlet duct deep length
S [m] gas outlet duct extend length
Greek symbols
e [rad] the cone slope
g [kg/m3] gas density
t [Pa] shear stress
[m/s] gas velocity
[-] the pressure drop coefficient
[-] the wall friction coefficient
Subscripts
d cyclone body
g gas
e near the exit or vortex finder
fr friction
in cyclone inlet
iv internal vortex
ol outlet local loss
of outlet friction loss
out cyclone outlet
vf vortex flow
tangential coordinate directions
r radial coordinate directions
w near the wall
REFERENCES
Alexander RM (1949). Fundamentals of cyclone design and operation,
Proc. Aust. Inst. Min. Met. 152: 203.
Altmeyer S, Mathieu V, Jullemier S, Contal P, Midoux N, Rode S,
Leclerc JP (2004). Comparison of different models of cyclone
prediction performance for various operating conditions using a
general software. Chem. Eng. Process., 43: 511-522.
Ari V (2000). An Experimental investigation on the pre-heater cyclone
reactors utilizing in cement industry. Ph.D Thesis, Sakarya
University.
Avci A, Karagoz I (2003). Effects of flow and geometrical parameters on
the collection efficiency in cyclone separators. J. Aerosol Sci. 34:
937-955.
Bohnet M (1995). Influence of the gas temperature on the separation
efficiency of aerocyclones., Chem. Eng. Process, 34: 151–156.
Chen J, Shi M (2006). A Universal Model to Calculate Cyclone Pressure
Drop., Powder Technol. 171: 184-191.
Cullivan JC, Williams RA, Dyakowski T, Cross CR (2004). New
understanding of a hydrocyclone flow field and separation mecha-
nism from computational fluid dynamics. Minerals Eng. 17: 651-660.
Dirgo J, Leith D (1985). Performance of theoretically optimized
cyclones, Filtration & Separation. pp. 119.
Dirgo J, Leith D (1985). Performance of theoretically optimized
cyclones”, Aerosol Sci. Technol. 12: 673-685.
Dirgo J, Leith D (1985). Cyclone collection efficiency: Comparison of
experimental results with theoretical predictions., Aerosol Sci.
Technol. 4: 401-411.
Ficici F (2006). An experimental investigation on the effect of vortex
finder diameter change in cyclones to the flow parameters.,Ms.C
Thesis, Sakarya University.
Fuping Q, Yanpeng W (2009). Effects of the inlet section angle on the
separation performance of a cyclone. Chem. Eng. Res. Design, 87:
1567-1572.
FupingQ, Jiguang Z, Mingyao Z (2006). Effects of the prolonged vertical
tube on the separation performance of a cyclone. J. Hazard. Mater.
B, 136: 822-829.
Gimbun J, Chuah TG, Choong TSY, Fakhr’ul-Razi A (2005). Prediction
of the effects of cone tip diameter on the cyclone performance. J.
Aerosol Sci. 36: 1056-1065.
Gimbun J, Chuah TG, Fakhr’ul-Razi A, Choong TSY (2005). The
influence of temperature and inlet velocity on cyclone pressure drop:
a CFD study” Chem. Eng. Process. 44: 7-12.
Ficici et al. 813
Griffiths WD, Boysan F (1996). Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and
empirical modelling of the performance of a number of cyclone
samplers. J. Aerosol Sci. 27: 281-304.
Kim JC, Lee KW (1990). Experimental-study of particle collection by
small cyclones, Aerosol Sci. Technol., 12: 1003-1015.
Lim KS, Kwon SB, Lee KW (2003). Characteristics of the collection
efficiency for a double inlet cyclone with clean air, J. Aerosol Sci. 34:
1085-1095.
Martinez LF, Lavin AG, Mahamud MM, Bueno JL (2008). Vortex finder
optimum length in hydrocyclone separation., Chem. Eng. Process.
47: 192–199.
Moore ME, Mcfarland AR (1993). Performance modeling single-inlet
aerosol sampling cyclone.” Environ. Sci. Technol. 27: 1842-1848.
Mothes H, Löffler F (1988). Int. Chem. Eng. 28:231.
Saltzman BE, Hochstrasser JM (1983). Design and performance of
miniature cyclone for respirable aerosol sampling, Environ. Sci.
Technol. 17: 418-424.
Silva PD, Briens C, Bernis A (2003). Development of a new rapid
method to measure erosion rates in laboratory and pilot plant
cyclones. Powder Technol. 131: 111-119.
Zhao B (2004). A Theoretical Approach to Pressure Drop across
Cyclone Separators, Chem. Eng. Technol. 27: 10.
Zhu Y, Lee KW (1999). Experimental Study On Small Cyclones
Operating at High Flowrates” J. Aerosol Sci. 30: 1303-1315.
... The maximum cyclone performance is obtainable by modifying the cyclone geometry, such as the vortex finder [8], [26][27][28][29][30][31][32][33]. A vortex finder is one part of the cyclone which affect vortex flow and control the flow out of the cyclone. ...
... From the results of their research, increasing the diameter of the vortex finder causes an increase in cyclone performance in both pressure drop and collection efficiency. In the experiment conducted by Ficici et al. [28] with eight variations in length, a cylindrical vortex finder is used to determine the effect on pressure drop. The experimental results show that increasing the length of the vortex finder causes an increase in pressure drop. ...
... The static pressure reaches its maximum value in the wall area and decreases radially towards the centre of the geometry. This is in line with the research conducted by Ficici et al. [28], Raoufi et al. [30], and Fu et al. [45]. The effect of the cooling model gives significant results. ...
Article
This paper studies numerical analysis about the effect of the vortex finder (Tapered in-Cylinder out) geometric innovation in a cyclone separator. Four variations of the length of the vortex finder 0.5 Dc, 0.75 Dc, Dc, and 1.25 Dc will be simulated under cooling and without cooling conditions on the velocity flow field, cyclone performance, temperature distribution, and heat transfer. The RSM turbulence model is used to simulate fluid flow. The Eulerian-Lagrangian approach was chosen to predict the phase movement of the particles. The trajectories of particles in the flow are tracked individually using the DPM method. The cooling model is applied assuming a constant temperature on the surface of the cyclone body. The simulation results show similar trends both with experimental studies and numerical simulations. The application of additional cooling to the cyclone, reduced the pressure drop up to 13%. The cyclone collection efficiency showed a non-significant increase but most of the particles collected were drier due to the increasing heat transfer 15–25% in any cases of variation.
... The results of their research showed that increasing the diameter of the vortex finder led to an increase in cyclone performance, both in terms of pressure drop and collection efficiency. Ficici et al. 2010 conducted experiments with 8 variations in the length of a cylindrical vortex finder to determine the effect on pressure drop [16]. The experimental results show that increasing the length of the vortex finder causes an increase in pressure drop. ...
... The results of their research showed that increasing the diameter of the vortex finder led to an increase in cyclone performance, both in terms of pressure drop and collection efficiency. Ficici et al. 2010 conducted experiments with 8 variations in the length of a cylindrical vortex finder to determine the effect on pressure drop [16]. The experimental results show that increasing the length of the vortex finder causes an increase in pressure drop. ...
... Over the past few decades, a tremendous number of experimental and numerical work has been done on single cyclone separator varying the gas temperature, velocity, and particle diameter for measuring the pressure drop and separation efficiency [5][6][7]. Ithape et al. [8], investigated the effect of geometric parameters and Ficici et al. [9] reported the effect of vortex finder on the performance of a cyclone separator. In general, cyclone separator is characterized by highest efficiency at lower pressure drop, which is mostly desired. ...
Article
In this present study, the effect of inlet velocity, gas temperature on pressure drop and the effect of particle size on the collection efficiency under different operating conditions are demonstrated for a double cyclone separator, which mainly consists of a 2D2D and 1D3D cyclone in series arrangement. The experiment of pressure drop measurement for different inlet gas velocities in the range of 11-23 m/sec are conducted and it is observed that the pressure drop increase with an increase in gas velocity, which is also validated with CFD results using RSM model and well-established theoretical models. The numerical simulation is also performed for different gas temperature in the range of 300-1100K. The prediction shows that the pressure drop decrease gradually with increasing the gas temperature, which also gives a better agreement with empirical correlations. The collection efficiency has been estimated for different particle size in the range of 1-10μm at u=23 m/sec, by CFD approach. It is noted that the efficiency of single cyclone is very poor for fine particles (<5μm) but adding a 1D3D cyclone in series with a 2D2D cyclone separator, the pressure drop is reduced more and the overall separation efficiency is improved in a comprehensive way.
... The change is more obvious for a longer vortex finder length, and this may be due to the strengthening tangential velocity and increased pressure drop [18]. However, extending the vortex finder shortens the natural vortex in the cyclone body, reducing the chance of small particles separating from the vortex [19]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Hydrocyclones are devices used in numerous chemicals, food, and mineral-related industrial sectors for the separation of fine particles. A d50 mm hydrocyclone was modelled with the use of the Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation, ANSYS® Fluent 2021 R1. The vortex finder depth was varied from 20 mm, 30 mm, and 35 mm to observe the effects of pressure drop and separation efficiency from a varied vortex finder depth and characteristics of the air core. The numerical methods validated the results observed from different parameters such as volume fraction characteristics based on CFD simulations. The tangential and axial velocities increased as the vortex finder length increased. It was found that as the depth of the vortex finder is increased, particle re-entrainment time in the underflow stream increases, and separation efficiency improved.
... This equipment is used in many industries because it has relatively low installation and maintenance costs, high separation efficiency for small particles, and be able to operate it at high temperatures. Inside the cyclone, inlet of particles and gases go through the tangential direction into the top of the cyclone [1,2]. Therefore, evaluation of preduster efficiency is needed. ...
Article
Full-text available
p>The rotary kiln in cement industries used hot air (temperature 1450<sup>0</sup>C) for doing a reaction to form a clinker. The outlet hot air from the combustion reaction in the kiln is reused to decrease the water content of coal in the coal mill. However, the hot air that contained ash will affect the drying process in the coal mills will not reach the maximum point. Therefore, the hot air needs treatment to separate the hot air and particle. The hot air is carried out to the cyclone. The goal of this study is to investigate the efficiency work of cyclones in cement industries using the CFD method. Besides, the other goal of this research will convey the expense that is reduced in decreasing the ash content in hot air. In general, the good cyclone has the low-pressure drop, the turbulence model using Reynold Average Navier Stokes (RANS) simulation,k-ε standard, with the Lagrangian model to solve the problem in particle lane. The result of this study is showing the pattern of the ash in cyclones, the pressure in cyclones, and the efficiency of cyclones. The number of efficiencies will affect the reduction of expense in this section.</p
... Ultimately, the reduction in the tangential velocity leads to the degradation of collection efficiency. Experimental studies have shown that increasing the inlet velocity will affect the flow pattern and results in a higher pressure drop [9]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Gravity-driven separators are broadly used in various engineering applications to remove particulate matters from gaseous fluids to meet legislation demands. This study represents a detailed numerical investigation of a two-phase cyclone separator using the Eulerian–Lagrangian gas flow method. The turbulence is modelled using the Reynolds stress model (RSM). The technique has successfully predicted the typical trends and variations seen in such gas separators with an average error of approximately 5.5%. Also, the computed results show a realistic agreement with the experimental measurements.
Article
To improve the performance of the enhanced cyclone with shunt device (ECSD), the vortex finder lengths optimization for the ECSD is carried out by numerical investigation. Reynolds stress model and discrete phase model are adopted. The results show that the separation ability of the ECSD can be improved by longer vortex finder, which is contrary to the generally accepted conclusion that the vortex finder length of the traditional cyclone should not be longer than cylindrical section length. When the ratio of vortex finder length to cylindrical section length reaches 1.5 (225mm vortex finder), the total separation efficiency, reduced separation efficiency and comprehensive separation efficiency are 90.7%, 89.7%, and 80.6%, respectively, which are the highest. The tangential velocity distribution is one of the most important reasons that the separation efficiency increases with the increase of the vortex finder length in general. The tangential velocity in the conical section of the ECSD increased with the increase of vortex finder length. When the length of vortex finder is the same as that of cylindrical section, the overall energy consumption and split ratio of the ECSD are the largest of 1.88 kPa and 12.4%, respectively, which is detrimental to the overall performance of ECSD.
Article
Cyclone separators have been widely used for gas–particle separation in chemical engineering. However, their enhancement in separation performances usually increases the pressure drop, which inevitably leads to an increase in operating energy consumption. One of the challenging issues is how to reduce the cyclone pressure drop while improving separation performances. To gain insight into the pathways and impacts of cyclone pressure drop reduction, this work reviews the state-of-the-art technical principles, performances and effects, focusing on the processes, mechanisms, and characteristics of pressure drop reduction by inlet/outlet variations, additional auxiliary devices, local cyclone dimension improvement, and global optimization based on intelligent algorithms. The cyclone performances are assessed using a proposed index that combines the Euler number and the square-root particle cut-off Stokes number. It is suggested that the pressure drop and separation capability usually have a dynamic compromise. Considering the comprehensive performances, the technology using helical roof inlet, cross cone, increasing cylindrical height with h / D = 4.3 ( H / D = 6.35), and globally optimized design by Sun et al. (2017) are respectively considered to the others. Particularly, the last one is recommended to be more representative in practice. Finally, the key issues to be considered in further research were also prospected.
Article
The waxy component in natural gas may bring about some challenges in the treatment and transportation processes, especially in the cryogenic separation process. An axial flow cyclone separator was applied to separate wax from natural gas. An Eulerian–Lagrangian approach combined with the Reynolds stress model (RSM) was adopted to investigate the flow of gas and wax droplets in the separator. The distributions of static pressure as well as tangential, axial, and radial velocity were presented to describe the flow field in the cyclone separator. The results suggested that the established model could be used to simulate the separation process in the cyclone efficiently. Most importantly, the simulation was conducted under various inlet velocities and mass content of waxy component to study the effects of the operation parameters on separation efficiency. It was indicated that the inlet velocity has a great impact on the separation efficiency when it is greater than 15 m/s. The effect of mass content of waxy component is significant when it is smaller than 172.4 kg/m³, especially for small sized wax droplets. It is believed that the separation efficiency in the proposed axial flow cyclone is as high as 95% with suitable operational conditions.
Article
Preliminary experiments were conducted on a standard design, the Stairmand high-efficiency cyclone. Results were used to select two efficiency theories and two pressure drop theories that best fit the data. A computer program was developed to use these theories to predict dimensional changes that would improve cyclone efficiency without increasing pressure drop. Four new cyclones were designed with the program; they were tested under experimental conditions identical to those used to evaluate the standard design. The new cyclones did not perform as efficiently as predicted and only one of the cyclones performed better than the standard design. Results indicate that although cyclone theories may work for some designs under some operating conditions, they are not developed to a sufficient extent to allow design optimization.
Article
A new application-oriented mathematical model of particle removal in cyclone separators has been developed, using the results of recent experimental and theoretical investigations of the flow of the gas and the motion and separation of particles. The article motion is treated as a process consisting of the superposition of a random motion, caused by turbulence in the gas, on a deterministic mean motion. Calculation of particle flows inside the cyclone body, which has been divided into four characteristic regions, is performed with the help of a simplified flow model of the fluid motion. The new mathematical model takes into account all the important parameters of design while requiring only a modest amount of calculation.
Article
The flow field of a 2 in. hydrocyclone is shown to be significantly asymmetric without precession, through both computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and experimental observation. Hence the application of full three-dimensional modelling is demonstrated to be essential. Further, CFD predicts that the axial pressure is not below atmospheric prior to development of the air core and that such development is not pressure driven. In fact, initial insight into a cause of instability of the air-core is identified from the CFD and supported through experimental observation. The predictions use the second-order differential-stress turbulence model which has previously been identified to represent a minimum model. Lastly, the inclusion of full three-dimensional modelling and high-order turbulence modelling leads to a new understanding of particle-separation classification within the hydrocyclone, including a significant stochastic component.
Article
This paper describes the results of tests conducted on a Stairmand high-efficiency cyclone. The cyclone was pilot-plant scale with a design air flow of 0.139 m/s (300 cfm). Collection efficiency and pressure drop were measured over a range of air flows at ambient temperature and pressure. An oil mist was used as a test aerosol because it consisted of spherical drops of uniform density unlikely to bounce or reentrain after striking the cyclone wall. At each air flow, a fractional efficiency curve (collection efficiency versus particle diameter) was determined. Experimental curves were compared with fractional efficiency curves generated by several cyclone efficiency theories. Over the range of particle sizes measured (1 to 7 μm), the predictions of a modified version of Barth's theory and the Leith-Licht theory were closest to experimental results.
Article
The improvement of the inlet geometry of the cyclone is conducted in this study based on the previous works, i.e., the cyclone inlet has a certain inlet section angle. The gas flow fields in cyclones for the different inlet section angles were calculated by means of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) technology, and the inner flow field geometry of these cyclones were compared. Additionally, the pressure drops and separation efficiencies of these cyclones were studied by experiments. The results indicate that the inlet section angle can make the flow filed in the cyclone be propitious for particle separation, and improve the separation performance effectively. At the same inlet velocity, with increasing the inlet section angle, both total separation efficiencies and grade efficiencies increase, and the pressure drops reduce greatly. Combining the change tendency of the pressure drop and the separation efficiency, a conclusion can be obtained, i.e., the optimal angle should be 45° for the range of the inlet section angle in this study.
Article
The design of aerocyclones operating at high temperatures is still a difficult problem since practical experience shows that the separation efficiency really obtained is mostly smaller than that calculated. For this reason, the pressure drop and the grade efficiency has been measured over the temperature range 293–1123 K. Both quantities show a remarkable influence on the gas temperature. A new model into which a wall friction coefficient depending on the temperature is introduced and consideration taken of the re-entrainment of already separated particles together with the boundary layer flow at the cyclone cover plate, the cyclone wall and along the outside of the vortex finder leads to measured pressure drops and grade efficiency curves for high temperatures of a high accuracy.
Article
Two single inlet cyclones and a double inlet cyclone were designed and fabricated to evaluate, and compare, their collection efficiencies. Two single inlet cyclones had different inlet sizes and vortex finder diameters. The double inlet cyclone had two inlet parts that divided the cyclone inlet in two. Clean air was introduced to the inlet near the cyclone wall, and particle-laden air was introduced to the inlet away from the cyclone wall. This double inlet made the clean air swirl in the region near the vortex finder, and the particle-laden air swirl in the region close to cyclone wall. The performance of the double inlet cyclone was evaluated at various clean air flow rates, keeping the particle-laden air flow rate constant.The collection efficiency of the double inlet cyclone was found to be 5–15% greater than that of the single inlet cyclone with the same inlet size and vortex finder diameter. As the flow rate of clean air was increased, the collection efficiency increased. This result indicates the possibility of achieving higher collection efficiencies with a double inlet cyclone.
Article
The definition and composition of the pressure drop over a tangential inlet, reverse flow cyclone have been analyzed. It is assumed that two factors mainly contribute to the pressure drop, i.e., the local loss and the loss along the distance. The former includes the expansion loss at the cyclone inlet and the contraction loss at the entrance of the outlet tube (or vortex finder). The latter consists of the swirling loss resulting from friction at the cyclone walls and the dissipation of gas dynamic energy in the outlet tube. By use of the measured results of the flow field in cyclones, the calculation methods for each loss have been developed. And a universal model to predict the cyclone pressure drop is thus obtained simply by summing each loss. A detailed comparison between the calculated and experimental results shows that this accurate model is suitable either for pure or for dust laden gases at normal or high temperatures and can meet the requirement of most cyclone designs.
Article
Erosion limits the collection efficiency of cyclones and affects their reliability. A new method uses triboelectric probes to measure relative wall erosion rates in cyclones. Reliable measurements can be performed in about 1 min. The erosion rate generally increases with both gas and solid flow rates. However, at high flow rates, a dense protective layer of slowly moving solids forms at the wall, and the erosion rate decreases slightly with further increase in flow rate. The erosion maps indicated that particles rebound on the cyclone wall. Erosion is most severe at the locations where particles rebound.