Temporary Agency Work and Firm Competitiveness: Evidence from German Manufacturing Firms

Industrial Relations A Journal of Economy and Society (Impact Factor: 1.48). 06/2011; 53(3). DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.1898546


This paper addresses the relationship between the utilization of temporary agency workers by firms and their competitiveness measured by unit labor costs, using a rich, newly built, data set of German manufacturing enterprises. The analysis is conducted by applying different panel data models while taking the inherent selection problem into account. Making use of dynamic panel data models allows us to control for firm specific fixed effects as well as for potential endogeneity of explanatory variables. The results indicate a U-shaped relationship between the extent that temporary agency workers are used and the competitiveness of firms.

Download full-text


Available from: Alexander Schiersch
  • Source
    • "This is in agreement, in a sense, with Atkinson's view as he argues that the new structure emerging among MNCs is that managers are tending towards breaking up the workforce into peripheral or numerical flexible groups of workers clustered around a stable core group that would conduct the organisation's specific activities. Workers at the core are those who win their employment security at the cost of accepting functional flexibility both in the short term (involving cross-trade working, reducing demarcation, and multi-discipline project teams) as well as in the longer term (changing career and re- training)[48]. "

    Preview · Article · Jan 2015 · Open Access Library Journal
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Using nationally representative workplace data we find the use of temporary agency workers (TAW) is positively associated with financial performance in the British private sector and weakly associated with higher sales per employee. However TAW is not associated with value added per employee. Employees in workplaces with TAW receive higher wages than observationally equivalent employees in non-TAW workplaces. But the presence of TAW in the employee’s occupation is associated with lower wages for employees in that occupation. Furthermore, conditioning on wages, the presence of TAW at the workplace is associated with lower job satisfaction and higher job anxiety among employees. These findings are consistent with TAW having an adverse effect on employees’ experiences at work, perhaps due a more labour intensive regime, one which is only partly compensated for with higher wages.
    No preview · Article · Apr 2012 · Journal of Productivity Analysis
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: This study investigates the effect of temporary agency work on the user firm’s productivity. We hypothesise that using temporary agency work to enhance numerical flexibility and to screen job candidates may increase productivity, whereas temporary workers’ lower firm‐specific human capital and spillover effects on the user’s permanent employees may adversely affect productivity. Other than the sparse existing literature on this issue, we exploit a large panel data set and control for time‐invariant and time‐varying unobserved heterogeneity by using the system GMM estimator. We find a robust hump‐shaped effect of the extent of temporary agency work on the user firm’s productivity.
    No preview · Article · Aug 2012 · The Economic Journal
Show more