ChapterPDF Available

Neanderthals and Monkeys in the Würmian of Central Europe: The Middle Paleolithic Site of Hunas, Southern Germany

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The site of Hunas is a cave ruin, filled with bedded sediments up to the roof. About 20 m sediments from the top down were excavated and yielded Middle Paleolithic artifacts as well as numerous faunal remains, including Macaca. With a single human molar, the site is one of the rare Neanderthalian localities in Germany. New TIMS-U/Th dating of speleothems at the base of the profile indicate that the whole sequence was not deposited during the late Middle Pleistocene as previously thought, but during the last glacial. According to the new chronological results, Hunas is the only place which shows the coexistence of man and monkey in the Würmian of Central Europe. The Macaca remains are the most recent evidence of magots in Central Europe so far. Keywords Homo neanderthalensis - Macaca -Late Pleistocene-TIMS/U-Th-Enviromagnetism-Bavaria-Cave
Content may be subject to copyright.
15
N.J. Conard and J. Richter (eds.), Neanderthal Lifeways, Subsistence and Technology: One Hundred Fifty Years of Neanderthal Study,
Vertebrate Paleobiology and Paleoanthropology, DOI 10.1007/978-94-007-0415-2_3, © Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011
Abstract The site of Hunas is a cave ruin, filled with bedded
sediments up to the roof. About 20 m sediments from the top
down were excavated and yielded Middle Paleolithic arti-
facts as well as numerous faunal remains, including Macaca.
With a single human molar, the site is one of the rare
Neanderthalian localities in Germany. New TIMS-U/Th dat-
ing of speleothems at the base of the profile indicate that the
whole sequence was not deposited during the late Middle
Pleistocene as previously thought, but during the last glacial.
According to the new chronological results, Hunas is the only
place which shows the coexistence of man and monkey in the
Würmian of Central Europe. The Macaca remains are the
most recent evidence of magots in Central Europe so far.
Keywords Homo neanderthalensis Macaca Late Pleistocene
• TIMS/U-Th • Enviromagnetism • Bavaria • Cave
Introduction
The site of Hunas is located 40 km east from Nuremberg/
Bavaria (Fig. 3.1) and lies in a limestone quarry on the east-
ern slope of a hill, 520 m above sea level. The limestone is a
dolostone of Middle Kimmeridgian (Malm Delta) age. The
karstification of the Franconian Jura dates back to the
Neogene. In the limestone quarry of Hunas no other caves or
karstic fissures with archaeological or paleontological finds
are known.
The cave ruin was discovered in 1956 by Florian Heller
from Erlangen University, Institute for Paleontology and was
investigated in the following years up to 1964 (Heller 1983).
From the top of the hill, the excavation opened just the upper
part of a stratigraphic sequence which comprises altogether
20 m thick sediments and included abundant faunal remains
as well as several archeological levels. In anticipation of the
complete destruction of the site – the quarry has been reacti-
vated in 1982 new excavations have been started in 1983
(Reisch and Weissmüller 1984) and are still going on (Groiss
et al. 1998; Kaulich et al. 2006).
Stratigraphy
The cave ruin is filled with bedded sediments up to the roof.
The roof is collapsed, covering the sediment-filling and
obstructing the cave entrance. The extent of the room and the
dimensions of the entrance are unknown. The sediment
filling has been opened vertically by the blasting-front of the
quarry. About 12 m sediment from the top down were inves-
tigated (Fig. 3.2) with modern methods in the recent excava-
tion since 1983 (Ambros et al. 2005). The sequence shows
a series of sediments of various compositions (Table 3.1).
The sediments are mainly built by fine grained sand and silt,
sometimes mixed with dolostone blocks (roof falls) of different
size. The sediment colors vary between different brown, grey
and yellowish color shades.
W. Rosendahl (*)
Reiss-Engelhorn-Museen, C5 Zeughaus, 68159 Mannheim, Germany
e-mail: wilfried.rosendahl@mannheim.de
D. Ambros and B. Hilpert
Institut für Paläontologie, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität
Erlangen-Nürnberg, Loewenichstr. 28, 91054 Erlangen, Germany
e-mail: dieta.ambros@pal.uni-erlangen.de;
Brigitte.hilpert@pal.uni-erlangen.de
U. Hambach
Labor für Paläo- & Umweltmagnetik (PUM), LS Geomorphologie,
Universität Bayreuth, 95440 Bayreuth, Germany
e-mail: ulrich.hambach@uni-bayreuth.de
K.W. Alt
Institut für Anthropologie, Universität Mainz, Saarstr.
21, 55099 Mainz, Germany
e-mail: altkw@uni-mainz.de
M. Knipping
Institut für Botanik, Universität Hohenheim, Garbenstr.
30, 70593 Stuttgart, Germany
e-mail: knipping@uni-hohenheim.de
L. Reisch and B. Kaulich
Institut für Ur- und Frühgeschichte, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität
Erlangen-Nürnberg, Kochstr. 4/18, 91054 Erlangen, Germany
e-mail: lgreisch@phil.uni-erlangen.de
Chapter 3
Neanderthals and Monkeys in the Würmian of Central Europe:
The Middle Paleolithic Site of Hunas, Southern Germany
Wilfried Rosendahl, Dieta Ambros, Brigitte Hilpert, Ulrich Hambach, Kurt W. Alt, Maria Knipping,
Ludwig Reisch, and Brigitte Kaulich
Rosendahl, W., Ambros, D., Hilpert, B., Hambach, U., Alt, K.W., Knipping, M., Reisch, L. & Kaulich, B.† (2011): Neanderthals and
monkeys in the Würmian of Central Europe - The Middle Palaeolithic site of Hunas, Southern Germany.- In: Conard, N. J. & Richter, J.
(eds.), Neanderthal Lifeways, Subsistence and Technology - One Hundred Fifty Years of Neanderthal Study.- Vertebrate Paleobiology and
Paleoanthropology, Volume 19, Part 4, 15-23, DOI: 10.1007/978-94-007-0415-2-3.
16 W. Rosendahl et al.
Paleontology and Environment
About 140 different taxa have been found in Hunas (Ambros
et al. 2005). More than 50% are mammals, nearly 30% birds,
10% mollusks and 5% reptiles and amphibians. The majority
belongs to living species. The macrofauna is dominated by
the family of the bears (Hilpert 2006). The most important
paleontological finds belong to primates. The macrofauna
known up to now is listed in Table 3.2.
Most of the mammals are micromammals, including
Chiroptera, Insectivora, Lagomorpha, as well as the
rodent families Sciuridae, Castoridae, Dipodidae, Muridae,
Criceti-dae and Microtidae, the most abundant family with
18 species (Heller 1983; Carls et al. 1988). Due to the distri-
bution of each species, multiple changes of climate are
reflected in the Hunas stratigraphy. It begins, from bottom to
top, with a phase showing temperate to warm climate and
vegetation in the layers P-L with Muscardinus avellanarius,
Apodemus maastrichtensis, Clethrionomys glareolus,
Pitymys subterraneus and other forms of mixed deciduous
woodland. The lack of these forms indicates a significant
colder climate in the following layer (K
unt
) but their reappear-
ance in the next layers (K
mitte
H) testifies again favorable
moderate humid and warmer climatic conditions. In the lay-
ers G2 and G1 – G3 is represented very poorly in the excava-
tion since 1983 a clear and rapid change to colder and dryer
conditions turns up, indicated by Lemmus lemmus,
Dicrostonyx gulielmi, Microtus gregalis or Microtus oecono-
mus. G1 with coarse, sharp-bordered rock debris portrays the
coldest climatic phase within the whole stratigraphy. The
covering layers only small remains of Hellers layer F and
nothing of layers A – D are left – indicate an improvement of
the climate.
Altogether we are facing a gradual development from an
ending warm phase to a significant cold climate.
Investigations in pollen and charcoal confirm this opinion.
Less pollen are conservated in the detrital layers of Hunas.
A small series from layer F with spruce (Picea abies), pine
(Pinus silvestris) and birch (Betula sp.) represents open
woodland vegetation with many herbs showing a cold to
cool climate. Charcoal out of layer L results from a piece of
yew (Taxus baccata) which was often used for spears or
other weapons in prehistory. Pollen from layer P, a spele-
othem, indicates a warm and wet climate with mixed decid-
uous forests.
Paleoanthropology
As mentioned above, the most important paleontological
finds belong to primates, i.e. Macaca and Homo neander-
thalensis. Five remains of Macaca sylvanus ssp., the
Pleistocene subspecies of Recent magot (Macaca sylvanus),
were found in the cave ruin Hunas till the end of the excava-
tion campaign 2006 (Groiss 1986; Ambros 2003; Ambros
et al. 2005). The first evidence of Macaca in Hunas, a right
M3, was found in 1985 in layer H (Groiss 1986). The sec-
ond find, made in 1987 in layer H, was a left M3 (Fig. 3.3),
probably of the same individual. Other nds from a much
lower stratigraphic level (layer K) are a fragment of a M2
(in 2000) and a dp3 (in 2001). Checking undetermined
material of layer H from the excavation of Heller (1956–
1964) in winter 2000/2001, a fragmentary right third meta-
tarsal could be determined as a Macaca remain. These five
remains belong to at least two, probably three individuals.
Three of the teeth and the metatarsal represent adults; only
one tooth is from a very young individual. This deciduous
premolar was not broken through the maxillary bone and
therefore belongs to an animal younger than 3 months
(Starck 1990).
Magots or Barbary Macaques (Macaca sylvanus) belong
to the genus Macaca (macaques). The genus includes nearly
20 species with numerous subspecies, e.g. Macaca mulatta
(Rhesus Macaque) and Macaca fuscata (Japanese Macaque).
All members of the genus live in Asia with exception for
Macaca sylvanus. These species today has a patch-like dis-
tribution in Northwestern Africa; in the Atlas range of
Morocco and Algeria. In modern Europe there are some
semi-domesticated populations of the magot, e.g. the colony
at the rock of Gibraltar.
The oldest known macaques belong to the species Macaca
libyca living in the Miocene of Egypt. Macaques have existed
in Europe since the Late Miocene (Rook et al. 2001). In the
Fig. 3.1 Geographical position of the Hunas site (Graphic by
W. Rosendahl)
Fig. 3.2 Compiled stratigraphy of the Hunas site (state 2005). The lowermost level shown is P, the dated speleothem layer (Graphic by
C. Gropp)
18
W. Rosendahl et al.
Table 3.1 Detailed sediment description of the actual profile (state 8/2004)
Layer Sediment description
Cave roof Partly strongly corroded
E Coarse-medium scree, to some extent heavily weathered, with light reddish-brown, silty, fine sand
Distinct boundary Abrupt change of sediment
F2 Medium-fine, heavily abraded and weathered scree with reddish-brown, loamy, fine sand and Mn and Fe incrustations
Distinct boundary Abrupt change of sediment
G1 Coarse-medium angular scree with small amounts of light brown to yellow fine sand
Mainly angular, coarse scree with light reddish-brown to red fine sand (earthy dolomite), comprising several large
blocks and a layer of slab-shaped stones at the base
Distinct boundary
G2 Coarse-medium, slightly abraded scree comprising horizontally-bedded stones with large amounts of pale
greyish-brown, silty fine sand
Medium-fine, heavily abraded scree with light brown fine sand
Medium-fine, abraded scree with reddish-brown fine sand
Coarse-medium, heavily abraded scree with bright reddish-brown fine sand
Distinct boundary
H Intermediate layer, only preserved in places: medium-fine scree in varying stages of abrasion with pale reddish-brown,
slightly silty, fine sand
Medium-fine scree in varying stages of abrasion comprising large amounts of grey fine sand; numerous remains of
charcoal on the surface
Medium-fine, abraded and partly heavily weathered scree with isolated large blocks and pale grayish-brown, silty,
fine sand, becoming reddish-brown towards the base
Medium-fine scree in varying stages of abrasion with slightly silty reddish-brown fine sand, numerous
particles of charcoal
Distinct boundary
J Medium-fine scree with yellowish-grey, slightly silty, medium-fine sand
Distinct boundary
K
ob
Medium-fine, heavily abraded and weathered scree with dark-grey fine sand
K
mitte
Large block of rock respectively scree deposit
K
unt
Loosely bedded, mainly weakly abraded, coarse-medium scree with light greyish yellow, slightly silty, medium-ne sand
Loosely bedded, mainly weakly abraded medium-sized coarse scree with light ochre, slightly silty, medium-ne sand
Distinct boundary
L Thin zone with heavily weathered, medium-sized scree comprising isolated pieces of coarse scree and a high
proportion of brownish-grey, weakly silty, medium-fine sand
Mainly heavily weathered, medium-sized scree with isolated, larger scree pieces and a large proportion of grey,
partly yellowish-light brown, slightly silty, fine-medium sand, numerous charcoal remains
Heavily weathered, coarse-medium scree with many voids and some light grey, silty, medium-fine sand and tiny
pieces of charcoal
Irregular boundary
M Medium-fine scree with isolated larger components and yellowish-grey, slightly silty, medium-fine sand, compact
sediment without voids, Manganese flecks
More heavily abraded, medium-fine scree with large amounts of ochre colored, slightly silty, medium-fine sand,
increasing percent of detritus towards the base, isolated larger stones covered with thick manganese deposits,
isolated weakly-developed sinter incrustation
Partly heavily abraded, medium-fine scree with ochre coloured, slightly silty, medium-fine sand with some voids
Distinct boundary
N Thick, chaotically deposited coarse scree deposit, in places breccia-like, high proportion of medium-fine sand in the
upper part, on the upper and lower surfaces multiple sinter incrustations, already displaying weathering, deposits of
grey to ochre coloured, silty, medium-fine sand stratified above larger blocks, abundant traces of manganese,
increasingly larger blocks (up to more than 1 m in size) towards the bottom of the layer, which form locally a
massive, thick and hard breccia at the base
Distinct boundary
O Thin deposit of distinctly ochre-colored, slightly silty, medium-fine sand, not visible throughout
Sharp boundary
P Extensive, in places more than 15 cm thick, speleothem with thick stalagmites on top forms, in places, a hard
breccia together with sediment from the upper part of the deposits currently forms the base of the excavated
sequence, exposed only in one part of the site
19
3 Neanderthals and Monkeys in the Würmian of Central Europe
Table 3.2 Macrofauna of Hunas (state 2004); (Compiled by B. Hilpert)
Carnivora
D E F G1 G2 G3 H I Kob Km Ku L M N Höh So
Canis lupus
Vulpes sp.
Alopex sp.
Ursus spelaeus
Ursus arctos
Mustela aff. praenivalis
Mustela aff. palerminea
Putorius cf. stromeri
Martes sp./Martes martes
Meles sp.
Lutra lutra groissii
Gulo gulo
Crocuta crocuta spelaea
Panthera leo fossilis/P. spelaea
Perissodactyla D E F G1 G2 G3 H I Kob Km Ku L M N Höh So
Dicerorhinus kirchbergensis
Equus aff. mosbachensis
Artiodactyla D E F G1 G2 G3 H I Kob Km Ku L M N Höh So
Sus scrofa
Alces sp.
Megaloceros sp.
Cervus elaphus
Rangifer sp.
Capreolus capreolus
Bison priscus
Bos primigenius
Lagomorpha, Rodentia D E F G1 G2 G3 H I Kob Km Ku L M N Höh So
Lepus sp.
Ochotona pusilla
Ochotona sp.
Sciurus sp.
Marmota marmota primigenia
Castor fiber
Primates D E F G1 G2 G3 H I Kob Km Ku L M N Höh So
Macaca sylvanus pliocena
Homo neanderthalensis
Coarsely shaded: From new excavation, not directly correlated to layers of the Heller excavation (Höh.: cave). Heller 1983 mentioned 3 “caves”.
These are small cavities among big blocks, an assignment to layers is impossible. So: without assignment to a layer (from detritus)
Early Pliocene, Macaca sylvanus prisca appeared. It resem-
bled the modern magots except for its smaller size, so it was
described as subspecies of Macaca sylvanus. M. sylvanus
prisca is known from numerous Pliocene sites in Southern,
Western and Central Europe. In the Latest Pliocene and Early
Pleistocene, Macaca sylvanus florentina lived in Southern,
South-eastern, Western and Central Europe. It was nearly
like the modern magot in size and morphology.
During the Early and Late Pleistocene, Macaca sylvanus
(pliocena) subsp. showed a wide geographical distribution
(Szalay and Delson 1979). It colonized large parts of Europe,
the Caucasus and Israel. In comparison to the modern magot
the fossil subspecies had slightly broader and more
powerful teeth. In the past it was believed that magots became
extinct in Central Europe at the end of the Middle Pleistocene.
Only a single premolar from the Kugelsteinhöhle in Austria
was discussed as a Late Pleistocene (MIS 5e) nd (Fladerer
1991). According to new speleothem dates (Rosendahl et al.
2006) the Macaca remains from Hunas provide the most
recent evidence of magots in Central Europe so far (Fig. 3.4).
20
W. Rosendahl et al.
During the excavation campaign of 1986, the author
B. K. found an isolated human tooth in situ by cleaning
the sediment profile at the base of layer F2. The tooth
could be identified as a right, possibly third, mandibular
molar (Figs. 3.5 and 3.6). Characteristic parameters such
as crown and root morphology, fissure pattern, enamel
thickness, occlusal and interproximal wear, dental dimen-
sions and indices indicate that the Hunas molar represents
the tooth of a Neanderthal (Alt et al. 2006). This is cor-
roborated by the archeological findings (Mousterian) of
layer F2.
Archeology
Artifacts (mainly flakes, backed bifaces and sidescrapers)
were discovered in all layers except A, B and G1 of the
Heller excavation and layer O and P of the recent excavation.
Small series from the levels G2 and G3 have been considered
to belong to a Charentien of Proto-Quina type (Freund 1983).
New finds from layers H to N cannot be assigned to an indus-
try because of their scarcity.
Fig. 3.3 Occlusal view of the upper right M3 of Macaca sylvanus ssp.
from layer H, scale bar = 9 mm (Photo Institut für Paläontologie,
Erlangen)
Fig. 3.4 Pliocene and Pleistocene macaques’ sites in Central Europe
(graphic by W. Rosendahl). Pliocene (°), Pliocene or Early Pleistocene (^),
Early Pleistocene (+), Early or Middle Pleistocene (#), Middle Pleistocene
(*), Late Pleistocene (). 1 Tegelen/Netherlands, 2 Mosbach/Germany,
3 Bilzingsleben/Germany, 4 Voigtstedt/Germany, 5 Untermaßfeld/Germany,
6 Gundersheim/Germany, 7 Hohensülzen/Germany, 8 Hunas/Germany,
9 Heppenloch/Germany, 10 Zlatý Kůň/Czech Republic, 11 Kugelsteinhöhle/
Austria, 12 Deutsch-Altenburg/Austria, 13 Gombasek/Slovak Republic,
14 Včeláre/Slovak Republic, 15 Vertesszölös/Hungary, 16 Somssich-hegy/
Hungary, 17 Csarnóta/Hungary, 18 Beremend/Hungary, 19 Betfia/Romania
21
3 Neanderthals and Monkeys in the Würmian of Central Europe
Chronology
Due to the fact that true index fossils are missing, it was quite
difficult to determine the age of the cave filling. The stage of
evolution shown by certain species led Heller to place the
deposits of Hunas into the final part of the Riss glaciation
(Heller 1983). A first dating of a speleothem was carried out
in 1979 by (Hennig 1979). The sample originated from a
layer below Heller’s excavations, but detailed sample docu-
mentation does not exist. The age of 260 +60/−40 ka was
used as one important argument for a Middle Pleistocene
chronostratigraphical position (Brunnacker 1983).
In 2002, a flowstone layer has been discovered at the base
(layer P) of the section in the recent excavation. This layer
gave the opportunity to date the sediment filling of Hunas
with a modern method. The layer is in direct contact with the
partly cemented sediment series above without showing an
obvious hiatus. A 30 cm high stalagmite from this layer was
dated by TIMS-U/Th-method at Stanford University. The
stalagmite base yielded an age of 79 ± 8 ka and the top an age
of 76 ± 9 ka (Rosendahl et al. 2006). This early Würmian
age was additionally confirmed by dating a second stalag-
mite from the same flowstone layer. These new data indicate
a maximum age of around 85 ka for the base of the Hunas
section. The minimum age of the site is constrained by the
presence of typical Middle Paleolithic artifacts within the top
layer of the section (Freund 1983). Therefore the whole sedi-
ment stack was deposited within a maximum time span of
around 45 kyr (OIS 5b till OIS 3). An explanation for the
first, Middle Pleistocene numeric age could also be found.
The sample, taken in the 1970s, is from an older speleothem
generation, only partly covered by the younger generation.
Where both generations are present, they are only separated
by a 2 mm layer of reddish silt. This could be demonstrated
by dating the speleothem layer under the small reddish silt
(Rosendahl et al. 2006).
Additionally, enviromagnetic investigations (Evans and
Heller 2003; Ellwood et al. 2004) were undertaken on the
cave sediments. The results of magnetic measurements were
plotted as a function of stratigraphy and correlated to the
isotope record from Greenland ice cores (North GRIP
Members 2004: Fig. 3.7).
The magnetic volume susceptibility as a simple
concentration dependent parameter shows strong variations
and enhancement of magnetic compounds in stratigraphic
units G2 to J. This fits quite well to the sedimentological
results from these units but contrasts the observation of strong
weathering in units M and N where no enhancement is
observed. The so called S-ratio, however, which provides
information about the relative amounts of magnetite and
hematite in the sediment, reveals the predominance of magne-
tite in units G2 to J as well as in units M and N. This finding
is interpreted as an indication for intense weathering during
the formation of these units. The climate during formation of
units G2 to J was probably more humid but not warmer than
during formation of units M and N. The higher humidity
resulted in higher absolute concentration of ferromagnetic
minerals but gave similar ratios of magnetite to hematite.
Fig. 3.5 Occlusal view of a lower right (possibly third) Neanderthal
molar from layer F2 Hunas, scale bar = 1 cm (Photo by I. Hirsmüller)
Fig. 3.6 The lower right Neanderthal molar from Hunas in lingual
view, scale bar = 1 cm (Photo by I. Hirsmüller)
22
W. Rosendahl et al.
Based on these results and on the TIMS-U/Th-age of the
basal flowstones (layer P), we propose the following
correlation to the North-Grip isotopic record: Units M and N
correspond probably to Greenland Interstadials 20 and 19 and
thus to the end of MIS 5. Consequently, units G2 to J may
correspond to Greenland Interstadials 12 to 14 which repre-
sent the warmest phases in MIS 3. Unit G1 is presumably
older than Greenland Interstadial 8. However, the use of only
magnetic volume susceptibility as a simple concentration
dependent parameter may lead to wrong conclusions. The
complexity of the formation of cave sediments requires a
magnetic multi-proxy approach as applied here and as recently
demonstrated in the Moravian Karst (Sroubek et al. 2001).
Conclusion
According to the new chronological results, the Macaca
remains from Hunas are the most recent evidences of magots
in Central Europe so far. It seems that in this region, Macaca
did not disappear with the end of the Eemian (Fladerer 1991),
but probably at the middle Würmian (OIS 4). Further, Hunas
is the only place which shows the coexistence of man and
monkey in the Würmian of Central Europe.
Remark Recent studies of the mandibular molar root
morphology in Neanderthals and Late Pleistocene and recent
Homo sapiens strongly suggest that the Hunas molar, which
was assigned to a molar of a Neanderthal, is that of a recent
Homo sapiens (Kupczik & Hublin 2010). This result changes
nothing to the general statement of this article.
References
Alt, K. W., Kaulich, B., Reisch, L., Vogel, H., & Rosendahl, W. (2006).
The Neanderthalian molar from Hunas, Germany. HOMO – Journal
of Comparative Human Biology, 57, 187–200. Stuttgart: Theiss
Verlag.
Ambros, D. (2003). New finds from the Middle Pleistocene cave ruin
Hunas, county Pommelsbrunn, Bavaria, Germany. Atti del museo
civico di storia naturale di Trieste, 49, 9–14.
Ambros, D., Hilpert, B., Kaulich, B., Reisch, L., & Rosendahl, W. (2005).
Steinberg Höhlenruine bei Hunas (HFA A 236). Abhandlungen der
Naturhistorischen Gesellschaft Nürnberg, 45, 325–336.
Fig. 3.7 Magnetic volume susceptibility and the S-ratio (proxy for
magnetite/hematite) are plotted as a function of stratigraphy and
correlated to the isotope record from Greenland ice cores (North
GRIP Members 2004). The enhancement of magnetic minerals in
the cave sediments causes higher values in magnetic susceptibility
and an increase of relative magnetite concentration, reflecting
warmer and more humid climatic conditions (Graphic by U.
Hambach)
23
3 Neanderthals and Monkeys in the Würmian of Central Europe
Brunnacker, K. (1983). Die Sedimente in der Höhlenruine von Hunas.
In F. Heller (Ed.), Die Höhlenruine Hunas bei Hartmannshof
(Landkreis Nürnberger Land). Eine paläontologische und urge-
schichtliche Fundstelle aus dem Spät-Riß. Quartär-Bibliothek 4
(pp. 53–89). Bonn: Röhrscheid Verlag.
Carls, N., Groiss, J. T., Kaulich, B., & Reisch, L. (1988). Neue
Beobachtungen in der mittelpleistozänen Fundstelle von Hunas, Ldkr.
Nürnberger Land, Vorbericht zu den Grabungskampagnen 1983–
1986. Archäologisches Korrespondenzblatt, 18, 109–119.
Ellwood, B. B., Harrold, F. B., Benoist, S. L., Thacker, P., Otte, M.,
Bonjean, D., Long, G. J., Shahin, A. M., Hermann, R. P., &
Grandjean, F. (2004). Magnetic susceptibility applied as an age-depth-
climate relative dating technique using sediments from Scladina cave,
a Late Pleistocene cave site in Belgium. Journal of Archaeological
Science, 31, 283–293.
Evans, M. E., & Heller, F. (2003). Environmental magnetism: Principles
and applications of enviromagnetics. San Diego: Academic.
Fladerer, F. A. (1991). Der erste Fund von Macaca (Cercopithecidae,
Primates) im Jungpleistozän von Mitteleuropa. Zeitschrift für
Säugetierkunde, 56, 272–283.
Freund, G. (1983). Die paläolithischen Kulturreste aus der Höhlenruine
von Hunas in der Nördlichen Frankenalb. In F. Heller (Ed.), Die
Höhlenruine Hunas bei Hartmannshof (Landkreis Nürnberger
Land). Eine paläontologische und urgeschichtliche Fundstelle aus
dem Spät-Riß. Quartär-Bibliothek 4 (pp. 323–349). Bonn:
Röhrscheid Verlag.
Groiss, J. T. (1986). Erste Funde von Primaten in der Höhlenruine von
Landschaft, 35, 193–197.
Groiss, J. Th., Kaulich, B., & Reisch, L. (1998). Zum Stand der
Ausgrabungen in der mittelpleistozänen Höhlenruine von Hunas.
Das Archäologische Jahr in Bayern 1997 (pp. 25–28). Stuttgart:
Theiss Verlag.
Heller, F. (Ed.) (1983). Die Höhlenruine Hunas bei Hartmannshof
(Landkreis Nürnberger Land). Eine paläontologische und urge-
schichtliche Fundstelle aus dem Spät-Riß. Quartär-Bibliothek 4.
Bonn: Röhrscheid Verlag.
Hennig, G. J. (1979). Beiträge zur Th-239/U-234-Alterbestimmung von
Höhlensintern sowie ein Vergleich der erzielten Ergebnisse mit den
anderer Absolutdatierungsmethoden. Ph.D. dissertation, University
of Cologne, Cologne.
Hilpert, B. (2006). Die Ursiden aus Hunas - Revision und Neubearbei-
tung der Bärenfunde aus der Steinberg-Höhlenruine bei Hunas
(Gde. Pommelsbrunn, Mittelfranken, Bayern). Ph.D. dissertation,
University of Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen-Nürnberg.
Kaulich, B., Reisch, L., & Rosendahl, W. (2006). Neanderthaler und
der Zahn der Zeit Neues zur Fundstelle Hunas. Das Archäologische
Jahr in Bayern 2005 (pp. 11–13). Stuttgart: Theiss Verlag.
Kupczik, K., & Hublin, J.-J. (2010). Mandibular molar root morphol-
ogy in Neanderthals and Late Pleistocene and recent Homo sapiens.
Journal of Human Evolution, 59, 525–541.
North GRIP Members. (2004). High-resolution record of Northern
hemisphere climate extending into the last interglacial period.
Nature, 431, 147–151.
Reisch, L., & Weissmüller, W. (1984). Eine Schichtenfolge aus der
vorletzten Eiszeit in der Höhlenruine von Hunas. Das Archäologische
Jahr in Bayern 1983 (pp. 23–26). Stuttgart: Theiss Verlag.
Rook, L., Mottura, A., & Gentili, S. (2001). Fossil Macaca remains
from RDB quarry (Villafranca d’Asti, Italy): New data and overview.
Journal of Human Evolution, 40, 187–202.
Rosendahl, W., Wiegand, B., Kaulich, B., & Reisch, L. (2006). Zur
Altersstellung der mittelpaolithischen Höhlenfundstelle Hunas/Ldkr.
Nürnberger Land. Ergebnisse und Interpretationen alter und neuer
Sinteruntersuchungen. Germania, 84, 1–18. Stuttgart: Theiss Verlag.
Sroubek, P., Diehl, J. F., Kadlec, J., & Valoch, K. (2001). A Late
Pleistocene paleoclimate record based on mineral magnetic proper-
ties of the entrance facies sediments of Kulna cave, Czech Republic.
Geophysical Journal International, 147, 247–262.
Starck, D. (1990). Ordnung Primates - Herrentiere. In J. Niethammer &
F. Krapp (Eds.), Handbuch der Säugetiere Europas (pp. 485–508).
Band 3/I. Wiesbaden: Aula Verlag.
Szalay, F., & Delson, E. (1979). Evolutionary history of the primates.
New York: Academic.
... However, most of the taxonomic attributions are based on the chronology of the specimens, with only subtle differences recognized between M. sylvanus subspecies (Szalay and Delson, 1979;Delson, 1980;Alba et al., 2019). Indeed, fossil remains of M. s. florentina are considered larger than those of M. s. prisca, but close to extant specimens of M. s. sylvanus (Rook et al., 2001); whereas specimens of M. s. pliocena are nearly identical to those of M. s. florentina, except for slightly wider cheek teeth in the latter (Delson, 1980). Given the lack of adequate diagnostic features, several attributions do not go beyond the species level (Montoya et al., 1999;Zapfe, 2001). ...
... Most of the Italian fossil primates were described from the 1870s to the beginning of the 1900s (Gervais, 1859;Cocchi, 1872;Forsyth Major, 1872a, b, 1875, 1914Ottolenghi, 1898;Seguenza, 1902Seguenza, , 1907Merciai, 1907;Portis, 1917). Nevertheless, this mammalian group was almost forgotten by Italian paleontologists during the last century, and as recently as in the last decades, only a few studies have been published (Belli et al., 1991;Rook et al., 2001;Mazza et al., 2005;Rook & O'Higgins, 2005;Rook, 2009;Zoboli et al., 2016;Bona et al., 2016). ...
... Except for M. majori, the Italian Plio-Pleistocene record of macaques has been poorly investigated (Gentili et al., 1998;Rook, 2009). The Pliocene macaque from Villafranca d'Asti has been tentatively assigned to M. s. prisca (Rook et al., 2001), whereas the fossil remains from the Early Pleistocene are generally ascribed to M. s. florentina, from Italian sites including Barberino del Mugello, Monte Peglia, Pietrafitta, and Valdarno Superiore (Rook, 1997;Gentili et al., 1998;SOM Table S1). Many fossils recorded from the Middle Pleistocene sites of the Italian Peninsula are commonly referred to Macaca sylvanus ssp., but seldom described in detail (SOM Table S1). ...
... Fossil/climate modelling suggest there was an excellent chance of finding macaques across mainland Europe during the Last Glacial Maximum (Elton and O'Regan 2014), which is within the timeframe for obtaining human European paleogenomes (Fu et al. 2016). However, the youngest fossils actually found to date are~70-50 kyo from southern Europe and Germany (Mazza et al. 2005;Castaños et al. 2011;Rosendahl et al. 2011), which may make any aDNA extraction difficult using existing material. The cause of the extinction has been primarily attributed to climatic effects on vegetation, but unlike Asian species of macaques, Barbary macaques are negatively impacted by human occupation (Ménard 2003), so the impact of some kind of resident Homo species such as Neanderthals may have also played some role (Rosendahl et al. 2011) (AMH likely did not enter Europe before Barbary macaques went extinct in the region). ...
... However, the youngest fossils actually found to date are~70-50 kyo from southern Europe and Germany (Mazza et al. 2005;Castaños et al. 2011;Rosendahl et al. 2011), which may make any aDNA extraction difficult using existing material. The cause of the extinction has been primarily attributed to climatic effects on vegetation, but unlike Asian species of macaques, Barbary macaques are negatively impacted by human occupation (Ménard 2003), so the impact of some kind of resident Homo species such as Neanderthals may have also played some role (Rosendahl et al. 2011) (AMH likely did not enter Europe before Barbary macaques went extinct in the region). As the only known recent primate in Europe, obtaining aDNA from some of these ancient European macaques would be of interest for examining their long-term population dynamics and how they may have interacted with archaic humans, as well as help advise conservation efforts for extant Barbary macaques in North Africa that are currently in serious decline (IUCN lists them as endangered). ...
Chapter
The field of paleogenomics is revolutionizing our understanding of a variety of species, including humans, dogs, horses, and even extinct mammoths. Yet, despite sequencing over 1,000 anatomically modern and archaic human ancient genomes, there has yet to be a single paleogenome for any nonhuman primate. In this review I outline the problems facing the application of paleogenomics to nonhuman primates. The major issue is that primates are predominantly found in regions of the world that are hot and humid and have acidic soil conditions, such as tropical rainforests, where DNA preservation is poor. I then identify multiple possible directions for future research that focus on questions that could be addressed based on the existing paleontological record from the Late Pleistocene and Holocene. One of these, the study of extinct lemurs, has already produced results using ancient mitogenomes that have challenged existing ideas of the lemur phylogeny based on morphology. A similar process of anthropogenic-mediated extinction could potentially be studied in the case of monkeys that once resided in Caribbean. In addition, there are also possibilities to learn more about the past history and subsequent local extinction of macaques in Europe and apes on mainland Asia during the Late Pleistocene.
... An OIS stage 7 age for the Ehringsdorf sample is commensurate with all of the age indicators, including chronometric dating of the travertines to ≥ 200 ka (Street et al., 2006). Rosendahl et al., 2006Rosendahl et al., , 2011 Klausenhöhle-Klausennische di 1 † ...
... In southeastern Bavaria, the site of Hunas has produced an isolated lower right molar, possibly an M 3, from layer F2 and in direct association with Pleistocene fauna and Middle Paleolithic artifacts (Alt et al., 2006). 7 A speleotherm at the base of the deposits is dated to 76-79 ka by TIMS-U/Th (Alt et al., 2006;Rosendahl et al., 2011). The tooth is younger than this date range, but it is not possible to specify how much younger. ...
... The biggest part of this collection is from the Zoolithenhöhle near Burggaillenreuth (Fig. 19.1). Another big part of the vertebrate collections derives from Hunas, near Pommelsbrunn (Rosendahl et al. 2011). The Hunas excavation commenced in 1956 and continued with interruptions until 2016. ...
Chapter
Palaeontological collections at Friedrich-Alexander University Erlangen comprise more than 50,000 specimens mostly of Jurassic marine invertebrates and Pleistocene mammals. Ten percent of the collection material is digitized and available through the institute’s mySQL database and the Global Biodiversity Information Facility. Invertebrate collections are mostly used for teaching whereas there is active research on the palaeoecology of vertebrates.
... Currently, the species is confined to the westernmost part of North Africa. Its phylogenetic position , basal to all the other macaques (Morales and Melnick 1998), and the fossil presence of macaques throughout northern Africa and Europe during the Last Glacial Maximum— with last occurrence dates of ~25k b.p. and ~80 b.p. for sites in Germany and Spain, respectively (Alba et al. 2011; Rosendahl et al. 2011) clearly confirms its status as a " relict species. " It is also one of a small group of primates that has populations living in areas where, for significant part of the year, the temperatures drop into single digits, and snowfall occurs regularly. ...
Article
Full-text available
Archaeoprimatology explores how humans and nonhuman primates coexisted in the past. This discipline has profound roots in texts of early scholars. Archaeoprimatological research examines the liminality between humans, apes, monkeys, and prosimians deep in time before the rise of the Anthropocene. By exploring the beginning of the relationship between modern Homo sapiens and primates, which possibly dates to approximately 100,000 BCE, I survey the evidence, ranging from portable objects and 2D surfaces with primatomorphic depictions to primate remains at archaeological sites worldwide. For example, an overview of ancient frescoes and mosaics with primate representations reveals that the vast majority of them were rendered in locations where primates were not part of the local fauna. An extensive review of primates in the zooarchaeological record shows as a global pattern that traded primates were usually young individuals and frugivorous/omnivorous species. Local primates yielded at sites of regions they naturally inhabited were mostly hunted. Thus, examining past patterns of the human–nonhuman primate interface provides insight into major questions about human niche construction and primate conservation today.
Preprint
Full-text available
Hominin living sites in the chalk landscapes of the cooler, drier (and presumably sunnier) climates of the Middle Palaeolithic (MIS stages 5, 4 and 3) are rare, despite the existence of a large number of 'open-air' sites with scattered flint artefacts. An examination of a sample of known cave or cliff shelter sites confirms that thermal considerations including the perennial flow of spring water in karst valleys on south-facing sites with higher solar insolation would have been attractive for humans. Experiments on soot coated limestone show that there is a substantial thermal energy benefit to be gained from having multiple fireplaces at rock shelters, which again is consistent with the archaeological record. The need for fuel is examined, indicating that coexistence with beavers could have played an important role in reducing the high-energy and time consuming procurement of firewood. It is shown that the technique of charcoal analysis of Palaeolithic hearths may be biased in favour of pinewoods. Other forms of fuel are discussed, such as peat, mammoth dung (in the convenient form of pellets) and bone. The question of candoluminescence of calcium oxide and calcium sulphate is discussed in relation to the use of wood and bone fires (bonfires) and the apparent under-representation of mega-fauna limb bones in the fossil record. Experiments on the illumination in fires using fresh bone mixed with seasoned firewood and all-wood measure the advantages of using bone as a complementary fuel, light source and production of calcium oxide. The erosion of Upper Cretaceous Chalk and its influence on the landscape is reviewed, and the effect of 'Frost Creep' is analysed in relation to 'open-air sites' proposing that it is probable that this mechanism transported artefacts from original sites on steep scarp slopes to the 'open air' finds. The advantages of having higher living sites are examined in relation to the enhanced visual acuity of Middle Palaeolithic hominins. A survey of Middle Palaeolithic (MP) burial and flint extraction sites shows that manual excavation was common in soils and rock and it is suggested that living sites could have been enhanced through basic excavation on south-facing scarps in order to maximize the use of solar energy. Although the systematic excavation of cave sites in harder limestones has been undertaken for well over a hundred years, practically all 'open air' sites have been discovered during engineering works and the systematic examination of scarp slopes in areas of known Middle Palaeolithic habitation has yet to be undertaken. Field studies in the chalk landscapes of Southern England and the Vanne valley of France were carried out in order to identify possible Palaeolithic scarp sites, the results indicating that, despite erosion, a pattern of 'stepped' level areas just above steep slopes, close to water sources and immediately up-slope from 'open-air' sites can be seen. Lithics were found associated with these zones uncovered by animal burrows or tree roots. The excavation of test pits is recommended to assess the potential of these and other scarp areas. Thus instead of waiting for road/rail/quarry or wind farm engineers to uncover MP sites it is possible to use thermal criteria as a checklist or algorithm to pinpoint probable sites in chalk landscapes.
Article
Full-text available
The German Middle Paleolithic is marked by two stages with abundant archaeological sites: The Eemian Interglacial (MIS 5e) and the Weichselian Interpleniglacial (MIS 3). On the other hand, several stages were seemingly void of any human population (the second half of MIS 6 and MIS 4) and two long periods (MIS 8-6 and MIS 5d-5a) delivered very few archaeological sites, so far. The majority of all assemblages seem to belong to the latest part of the Middle Paleolithic, during the first half of MIS 3. Concerning this period, the layer G stratigraphic complex (“G-Komplex”) of Sesselfelsgrotte yielded the longest cultural sequence of late Middle Paleolithic unifacial-plus-bifacial industries (Keilmessergruppen, Micoquian in the sense of a “Mousterian with a Micoquian option”, MMO) in Central Europe. Information from this sequence permitted a reconsideration of the internal structure and the dating of the MMO. Evidence is presented for an earlier MMO stage with almost no Levallois technology (MMO-A) and a later stage (MMO-B) with Levallois technology, both occurring at the very end of the European Middle Paleolithic, between 60,000 and 43,000 (cal.) B.P. The vast majority of all Middle Paleolithic sites in Germany belong to the MMO-B which was, in Southern Germany, rapidly followed by the Upper Paleolithic Aurignacian from 42 ka (cal.) B.P. onwards without any Proto-Aurignacian interlude.
Article
The genus Macaca (Primates: Cercopithecidae) originated in Africa, dispersed into Europe in the Late Miocene and resided there until the Late Pleistocene. In this contribution, we provide an overview of the evolutionary history of Macaca in Europe, putting it into context with the wider late Miocene, Pliocene and Pleistocene European monkey fossil record (also comprising Mesopithecus, Paradolichopithecus, Dolichopithecus and Theropithecus). The Pliocene and Pleistocene European Macaca fossil material is largely regarded as Macaca sylvanus, the same species as the extant Barbary macaque in North Africa. The M. sylvanus specimens found at West Runton in Norfolk (53°N) during the Middle Pleistocene are among the most northerly euprimates ever discovered. Our simple time-budget model indicates that short winter day lengths would have imposed a significant constraint on activity at such relatively high latitudes, so macaque populations in Britain may have been at the limit of their ecological tolerance. Two basic models using climatic and topographic data for the Last Interglacial and the Last Glacial Maximum alongside Middle and Late Pleistocene fossil distributions indicate that much of Europe may have been suitable habitat for macaques. The models also indicate that areas of southern Europe in the present day have a climate that could support macaque populations. However, M. sylvanus became locally extinct in the Late Pleistocene, possibly at a similar time as the straight-tusked elephant, Palaeoloxodon antiquus, and narrow-nosed rhinoceros, Stephanorhinus hemitoechus. Its extinction may be related to vegetation change or increased predation from Homo, although other factors (such as stochastic factors occurring as a result of small population sizes) cannot be ruled out. Notwithstanding the cause of extinction, the European macaque may thus be a previously overlooked member of the Late Pleistocene faunal turnover.
Article
Full-text available
The first find of Macaca (Cercopithecidae, Primates) in the Late Pleistocene of Central Europe. Described the left lower first premolar of a male Macaca sp., sylvanus group, associated with a Würmian thanatocoenosis from the Kugelsteinhöhle II in the Eastern Alps near Graz, Austria. It is the first evidence of a primate in the Late Pleistocene of Central Europe except for Homo. As a comparison to the find, the variability of the tooth in the recent Barbary Ape M. sylvanus is outlined. The peculiar morphology including the shape of the fossil could not be observed in 14 recent individuals.
Article
Full-text available
Here we demonstrate that magnetic susceptibility (MS) data from Scladina Cave, Belgium, provide a time–depth–climate relationship that is correlated to the marine oxygen isotopic record and thus yields a high-resolution relative dating method for sediments recovered from many archaeological sites. This methodology will help resolve one of the major problems facing archaeologists, namely the difficulty of acquiring absolute dates with reasonable precision for the period from 40,000 to 400,000 years or so. The problem is that dating techniques applicable to most materials within this age range are subject to significant errors. Relative dating techniques, such as magnetic secular variation or stable isotope methods, offer the potential to improve this precision, but both methods suffer from problems that make broad application to many sites impossible. However, for most archaeological cave sites, MS measurements of cave sediments offers the potential for intra-site correlation and paleoclimate estimation. This is possible in protected cave environments because the MS of cave sediments results from climate processes active outside caves, which cause variations in magnetic properties of the sediments that ultimately accumulate inside caves. Once deposited, these materials are often preserved and their stratigraphy provides a time–depth–climate signal that can be identified. Therefore MS data can be used as an independent methodology, alongside conventional methods such as sedimentology and palynology, for relative age dates, and correlation within and between sites by tracing evidence of paleoclimatic change. This correlation has been used to infer an age of 90,000±7000 years for Neanderthal skeletal remains recovered from Scladina Cave, an important Middle Paleolithic archaeological site in Belgium.
Thesis
Die Bären aus Hunas wurden biologisch, metrisch und morphologisch untersucht. Die Höhle wurde von den Bären überwiegend als Winterquartier benutzt. Die morphologischen Merkmale des Skeletts stimmen weitgehend mit denen von Ursus spelaeus überein. Lediglich die Kaufläche der Zähne ist einfacher als bei den meisten Bären aus vergleichbar alten österreichischen Fundstellen strukturiert, gleicht aber den Bären aus würmzeitlichen Fundstellen der Frankenalb. Es handelt sich eindeutig um Ursus spelaeus, der allerdings eine für die Nördliche und Mittlere Frankenalb spezifische Merkmalskombination aufweist. Diese Charakteristika werden auf die speziellen Ökotope der Frankenalb zurückgeführt.
Article
Kulna Cave is located in the Moravian Karst, a well-developed karstic region formed in Devonian limestones in the eastern part of the Czech Republic. The entrance facies sediments in the cave consist of interbedded layers of silts (loess) and clay-rich silts (loam) that were either directly blown into the cave entrance or redeposited in the cave by slope processes during the Last Glacial Stage. The layers of loess and loam overlie fluvial sands and gravels deposited during the Last Interglacial. Previous research at Kulna concentrated on the archaeology, palaeontology and dendrology of these entrance facies sediments. From these data, palaeoenvironmental conditions in the vicinity of the cave were reconstructed. Our results suggest that susceptibility variations and in particular variations in pedogenic susceptibility yield a more detailed record of the palaeoenvironmental conditions at the cave during the Last Glacial Stage.