Lay recommendations on how to treat mental disorders. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol

ArticleinSocial Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 36(11):553-556 · October 2001with18 Reads
Impact Factor: 2.54 · DOI: 10.1007/s001270170006


    Background Beliefs about the helpfulness of interventions are influencing the individual help-seeking behavior in case of mental illnesses.
    It is important to identify these beliefs as professional helpers are asked to consider them in their treatment recommendations.
    Objective Assessing lay proposals for an appropriate treatment of mental illnesses. Methods We conducted a representative opinion survey in Switzerland. Eighteen treatment proposals were presented with respect to
    a vignette either depicting schizophrenia or depression. Respondents were asked to indicate the proposals considered to be
    helpful for treatment and those considered to be harmful, respectively. Results‘Psychologist,’‘general practitioner,’‘fresh air,’ and ‘psychiatrist’ were mostly proposed as being helpful. Among several
    psychiatric treatment approaches ‘psychotherapy’ was favored, while psychopharmacological treatment and electroconvulsive
    therapy were only proposed by less than one-fourth of the interviewees. Especially psychotropic drugs were considered to be
    harmful. Treatment by a psychiatrist was regarded as being more helpful for schizophrenic individuals than for depressive
    persons. For a person experiencing a life crisis, treatment by a psychiatrist and psychological treatment were viewed as being
    harmful, and non-medical interventions were preferred. However, for persons thought to be mentally ill, psychiatric and psychopharmacological
    treatments were recommended. Conclusion Mental health professionals are regarded as being helpful although their treatment methods are seen as being less helpful.
    A clear distinction is made between lay proposals for depression and schizophrenia. However, the perception of whether a condition
    is considered to be an illness or a life crisis has significantly more influence on lay treatment proposals than the cited
    diagnosis in the vignette.