Abstract
Different aspects of the biology and ecology of Hellula undalis F. were studied in the
lowlands of Central Luzon, Philippines, in the province of Nueva Ecija. Special emphasis was
put on E,E-11,13-Hexadecadienal, the identified sex pheromone of H. undalis. H. undalis is a
major insect pest on cultivated crops of the plant family Brassicaceae (Cruciferae). Field trials
were conducted to determine possible practical use of the synthetic pheromone in integrated
pest management (IPM) with the overall goal to reduce insecticide overuse. These trials were
divided in: (i) handling of the pheromone, i.e. determinations of the best trap height, trap
design, intertrap distance, pheromone dosage, active substance longevity in the field with new
prepared and freezer stored lures, (ii) biology and ecology of H. undalis, with determination
of natural host plants with analysis of secondary plant metabolites, comparison between E,E-
11,13-Hexadecadienal and the virgin female emitted pheromone, influence of virgin females
next to synthetic pheromone sources, female sexual maturity, calling time of virgin females
and flight activity of males in the field and in the laboratory, (iii) studies regarding the
usefulness of the synthetic pheromone in pest control were conducted by comparing E,E-
11,13-Hexadecadienal with added Z-11-Hexadecenal in different concentrations, the possible
use of E,E-11,13-Hexadecadienal for monitoring and attempts to confuse male H. undalis to
find females.
The population fluctuations were recorded in different areas of Nueva Ecija partially from
October 2001 to November 2003.
The used compound E,E-11,13-Hexadecadienal was specific and attractive for male H.
undalis. The trap height is best 0.5m above ground, with wing traps and an intertrap distance
more than 15 m, when traps are placed crosswind and between 20-30m apart when placed in
lines with the wind direction. The best cost/benefit of the pheromone dosage resulted in the
use of 10μg impregnated red rubber septa. Lures with 10μg remain highly attractive for two
weeks, although males were caught for six weeks in areas with high H. undalis density. Lures
attracted equal numbers of males when stored for almost a year in a freezer (-7°C) compared
to newer prepared ones.
Cleome species are natural host plants. The species Cleome viscosa and Cleome rutidosperma
reached infestations up to 60%. Both species are widespread and play a possible key role as
food plant for the larvae at times Brassicaceae are not or only little cultivated. Glucosinolates
(GSL) are metabolites of both Cleome species with glucocapparin (methylglucosinolate) as
the predominant GSL compound (>90%). Glucocleomin was found in both species as well as
traces of Indolyl-GSL such as 4-OH (4-hydroxyglucobrassicin) and glucobrassicin (GBC).
The total GSL content of the aliphatic compounds was much higher in C. viscosa than in
C. rutidosperma. Glucosinolates are known to be host plant attractants for H. undalis.
The sex pheromone emitted by virgin females lured up to 25 times more males than E,E-
11,13-Hexadecadienal. It is assumed that the sex pheromone might be a blend of chemicals,
not only a single compound, or local differences occur in the biochemistry in pheromone
production by females of Japan and the Philippines and that might be true for male
perception.
The catch rate is not influenced when virgin female baited traps were placed in direct vicinity
to traps with the synthetic pheromone. The ratios of catches between both types of baits were
in a constant range, which makes E,E-11,13-Hexadecadienal useful as monitoring tool.
Females are sexual mature right after eclosion, i.e. when they emerge from the pupa. No
significant differences in the number of males caught were detected between 1 to 5 day old
virgin females. The time females start to call and lure males was determined in the field
between four and eight o’clock in the morning with most males recorded at six o’clock. This
time span could be verified in the laboratory. Males are active in the same phase of the night
and do not react when synthetic pheromone is offered outside this period. Already calling
females probably influence other females to start calling.
Results of pheromone research in Japan suggested that added Z-11-Hexadecenal to E,E-
11,13-Hexadecadienal enhanced the number of males caught. This was not confirmed for the
Philippines. Reasons to explain this discrepancy may be in differences in the composition of
the pheromone for Japanese and Philippine H. undalis strains.
Despite the lesser attractiveness of the synthetic pheromone compared to the natural
pheromone emitted by female H. undalis seems monitoring feasible. Good correlations
existed between trap catches and subsequent larval infestation by monitoring the presence of
adult H. undalis and larval counts. It was also found that rainfall has no effect on males
caught in traps, whereas a significant negative correlation existed between rainfall and larval
infestation.
A first attempt was made for the use of the synthetic pheromone to confuse males to locate
their mating partners. Although mating was not possible due to the set up of the trial, it was
clear that males were able to locate females in the area covered with lures containing 1 μg of
the synthetic pheromone and therefore mating was likely to happen. However, an effect might
be possible regarding the great differences of males caught in- and outside the treated area. It
seems worthwhile to continue the research with this method.
Monitoring the population fluctuations over periods up to 2 years proved H. undalis a major
pest in crucifer cropping systems throughout the year in Nueva Ecija. Population peaks were
found mainly in the dry season with infestation rates higher than 70%. The older the crop
grew the higher were the infestation and the damage.