No full-text available
To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.
Epigenetic Basis for Differentiation Plasticity in Stem Cells
Abstract
Stem cells possess the remarkable property of being able to self-renew and give rise to at least one more differentiated cell
type. Embryonic stem cells have the ability to differentiate into all cell types of the body and have unlimited self-renewal
potential. Somatic stem cells are found in many adult tissues. They have an extensive but finite life-span and can differentiate
into a more restricted range of cell types. Increasing evidence suggests that the multilineage differentiation ability of
stem cells is brought about by the potential for expression of developmentally regulated transcription factors and of lineage-specification
genes. Potential for gene expression is largely controlled by epigenetic modifications of DNA (DNA methylation) and chromatin
(such as post-translational histone modifications) on regulatory regions. These modifications modulate chromatin organization
not only on specific genes but also at the level of the whole nucleus. They can also influence the timing of DNA replication.
This chapter highlights how epigenetic mechanisms that poise genes for transcription in undifferentiated stem cells are being
uncovered through, notably, genome-wide mapping of DNA methylation, histone modifications, and transcription factor binding.
Epigenetic marks on developmentally regulated and lineage-specifying genes in undifferentiated stem cells seem to define a
pluripotent state.
KeywordsChromatin–Differentiation–DNA methylation–Embryonic stem cell–Epigenetics–Mesenchymal stem cell
... DNA methylation status had been previously analysed in hESCs and it had been suggested that hESCs have a distinct epigenetic signature from somatic cells and the genes differentially methylated are those mostly related to pluripotency, such as NANOG and OCT4 (Lagarkova and Volchkov et al., 2006). It was also proposed that the methylation pattern of only a small number of developmentally controlled genes constitute an epigenetic mark that is unique to the hESCs (Collas and Timoskainen et al., 2008). However, in the current project, both immunofluorescent staining and western blotting using antibodies against 5-methylated cytosine revealed little variety in the methylation states of the genomes of hESCs, HFFs, HFFs treated with either self extracts or with hESC extracts (Figure 4.10 and 4.11). ...
... However, due to the limitation caused by poor growth and proliferation of reprogrammed cells and small sample sizes, we were unable to check the status of these cells over an extended duration. Since it was suggested that methylation modifications on DNA could occur to a small portion of genes in the whole genome (Collas and Timoskainen et al., 2008), it would be helpful to examine the methylation status of the promoter regions of specific genes, such as OCT4 and NANOG rather than explore the methylation changes at a global extent. However, for collecting DNA samples, many more cells than what we were able to achieve are needed. ...
... Interestingly, TNF was undetectable after TLR stimulation in USSC, which appeared to be a result of a methylated TNF promoter [2]. As MSC, isolated from different anatomical locations, show a different epigenetic makeup [12], we analyzed MSC obtained from BM for their epigenetic silencing of their TNF promoter. Here, we elaborate on this by demonstrating that although USSC do not produce TNF, they are sensitive to TNF stimulation, as demonstrated by NF-B translocation and subsequent cytokine production. ...
The TNF promoter is silenced in mesenchymal stem cells able to respond to LPS by NFκB translocation and cytokine production yet without TNF.
Previously, we demonstrated that several TLRs are expressed on cord blood-derived USSC. Stimulation of USSC with TLR agonists resulted in a marked increase of IL-6 and IL-8 production. Interestingly, TNF was undetectable after TLR stimulation, which appeared to be a result of an inactivated TNF promoter in USSC. Here, we elaborate this study by demonstrating that although USSC do not produce TNF, they are susceptible to TNF stimulation, resulting in NF-κB translocation and cytokine production. Additionally, we compared different stem cell sources for their ability to produce TNF. Interestingly, we found that the TNF promoter in BM-MSC is inactivated as well. Like USSC, they are able to respond to TNF stimulation, but they are not able to produce TNF, even not after LPS stimulation. This limited cytokine response in combination with the well-studied immunosuppressive properties of MSC makes these cells ideal for immune-suppressive treatment modalities such as graft-versus-host disease.
Ramalho-Santos et al . ([ 1 ][1]) and Ivanova et al. ([ 2 ][2]), comparing the same three “stem cells”— embryonic stem cells (ESCs); neural stem cells (NSCs), referred to as neural progenitor/stem cells (NPCs) in the present study; and hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs)—with their
Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) is a key technique for studying protein-DNA interactions and mapping epigenetic histone modifications on DNA. Current ChIP protocols require extensive sample handling and large cell numbers. We developed a quick and quantitative (Q2)ChIP assay suitable for histone and transcription factor immunoprecipitation from chromatin amounts equivalent to as few as 100 cells. DNA-protein cross-linking in suspension in presence of butyrate, elimination of background chromatin through a tube shift after washes, and a combination of cross-link reversal, protein digestion, increased antibody-bead to chromatin ratio, and DNA elution into a single step considerably improve ChIP efficiency and shorten the procedure. We used Q2ChIP to monitor changes in histone H3 modifications on the 5′ regulatory regions of the developmentally regulated genes OCT4, NANOG, LMNA, and PAX6 in the context of retinoic-acid-mediated human embryonal carcinoma cell differentiation. Quantitative polymerase chain reaction analysis of precipitated DNA unravels biphasic heterochromatin assembly on OCT4 and NANOG, involving H3 lysine (K)9 and K27 methylation followed by H3K9 deacetylation and additional H3K27 trimethylation. Di- and trimethylation of H3K4 remain relatively unaltered. In contrast, PAX6 displays histone modifications characteristic of repressed genes with potential for activation in undifferentiated cells. PAX6 undergoes H3K9 acetylation and enhanced H3K4 trimethylation upon transcriptional activation. Q2ChIP of the transcription factor Oct4 demonstrates its dissociation from the NANOG promoter upon differentiation. This study is, to our knowledge, the first to reveal histone modification changes on human OCT4 and NANOG regulatory sequences. The results demonstrate ordered chromatin rearrangement on developmentally regulated promoters upon differentiation.
Disclosure of potential conflicts of interest is found at the end of this article.
The 5' region of the gene encoding human X chromosome-linked phosphoglycerate kinase 1 (PGK1) is a promoter-containing CpG island known to be methylated at 119 of 121 CpG dinucleotides in a 450-base-pair region on the inactive human X chromosome in the hamster-human cell line X8-6T2. Here we report the use of polymerase chain reaction-aided genomic sequencing to determine the complete methylation pattern of this region in clones derived from X8-6T2 cells after treatment with the methylation inhibitor 5-azacytidine. We find (i) a clone showing full expression of human phosphoglycerate kinase is fully unmethylated in this region; (ii) clones not expressing human phosphoglycerate kinase remain methylated at approximately 50% of CpG sites, with a pattern of interspersed methylated (M) and unmethylated (U) sites different for each clone; (iii) singles, defined as M-U-M or U-M-U, are common; and (iv) a few CpG sites are partially methylated. The data are interpreted according to a model of multiple, autonomous CpG sites, and estimates are made for two key parameters, maintenance efficiency (Em approximately 99.9% per site per generation) and de novo methylation efficiency (Ed approximately 5%). These parameter values and the hypothesis that several independent sites must be unmethylated for transcription can explain the stable maintenance of X chromosome inactivation. We also consider how the active region is kept free of methylation and suggest that transcription inhibits methylation by decreasing Em so that methylation cannot be maintained. Thus, multiple CpG sites, independent with respect to a dynamic methylation system, can stabilize two alternative states of methylation and transcription.
Imprinting, the differential expression of the two alleles of a gene based on their parental origin, requires that the alleles be distinguished or marked. A candidate for the differentiating mark is DNA methylation. The maternally expressed H19 gene is hypermethylated on the inactive paternal allele in somatic tissues and sperm, but to serve as the mark that designates the imprint, differential methylation must also be present in the gametes and the pre-implantation embryo. We now show that the pattern of differential methylation in the 5' portion of H19 is established in the gametes and a subset is maintained in the pre-implantation embryo. That subset is sufficient to confer monoallelic expression to the gene in blastocysts. We propose that paternal-specific methylation of the far 5' region is the mark that distinguishes the two alleles of H19.
Cytosine residues in the sequence 5'CpG (cytosine-guanine) are often postsynthetically methylated in animal genomes. CpG methylation is involved in long-term silencing of certain genes during mammalian development and in repression of viral genomes. The methyl-CpG-binding proteins MeCP1 and MeCP2 interact specifically with methylated DNA and mediate transcriptional repression. Here we study the mechanism of repression by MeCP2, an abundant nuclear protein that is essential for mouse embryogenesis. MeCP2 binds tightly to chromosomes in a methylation-dependent manner. It contains a transcriptional-repression domain (TRD) that can function at a distance in vitro and in vivo. We show that a region of MeCP2 that localizes with the TRD associates with a corepressor complex containing the transcriptional repressor mSin3A and histone deacetylases. Transcriptional repression in vivo is relieved by the deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin A, indicating that deacetylation of histones (and/or of other proteins) is an essential component of this repression mechanism. The data suggest that two global mechanisms of gene regulation, DNA methylation and histone deacetylation, can be linked by MeCP2.
Methylation of cytosine residues in CpG dinucleotides is generally associated with silencing of gene expression. DNA methylation, as a somatic event, has the potential of diversifying gene expression in individual cells of the same lineage. There is little quantitative data available concerning the extent of methylation heterogeneity in individual cells across the genome. T cells from the peripheral blood can be grown as single-cell-derived clones and can be analyzed with respect to their DNA methylation patterns by restriction landmark genomic scanning. The use of the methylation-sensitive enzyme NotI to cut and end-label DNA fragments before their separation in two dimensions provides a quantitative assessment of methylation at NotI sites that characteristically occur in CpG islands. We have undertaken quantitative analysis of two-dimensional DNA patterns to determine the extent of methylation heterogeneity at NotI sites between peripheral blood single-cell-derived T cell clones from the same individual. A total of 1,068 NotI-tagged fragments were analyzed. A subset of 156 fragments exhibited marked methylation heterogeneity at NotI sites between clones. Their average intensity among clones correlated with their intensity in uncultured, whole-blood-derived T cells, indicating that the methylation heterogeneity observed in clones was largely attributable to methylation heterogeneity between the individual cells from which the clones were derived. We have cloned one fragment that exhibited variable NotI-site methylation between clones. This fragment contained a novel CpG island for a gene that we mapped to chromosome 4. The methylation status of the NotI site of this fragment correlated with expression of the corresponding gene. Our data suggest extensive diversity in vivo in the methylation and expression profiles of individual T cells at multiple unrelated loci across the genome.
Metastatic progression of most common epithelial tumors involves a heterogeneous, transient loss of expression of the homotypic cell adhesion protein, E-cadherin, rather than the uniform loss of a functional protein resulting from coding region mutation. Indeed, whereas E-cadherin loss may promote invasion, reexpression may facilitate cell survival within metastatic deposits. The mechanisms underlying such plasticity are unclear. We now show that the heterogeneous loss of E-cadherin expression in primary human breast cancers reflects a heterogeneous pattern of promoter region methylation, which begins early prior to invasion. In cultured human tumor cells, such heterogeneous methylation is dynamic, varying from allele to allele and shifting in relation to the tumor microenvironment. Following invasion in vitro, which favors diminished E-cadherin expression, the density of promoter methylation markedly increased. When these cells were cultured as spheroids, which requires homotypic cell adhesion, promoter methylation decreased dramatically, and E-cadherin was reexpressed. These data show that the methylation associated with E-cadherin loss in human breast cancer is heterogeneous and unstable and suggest that such epigenetic plasticity may contribute to the dynamic, phenotypic heterogeneity that drives metastatic progression.
Future cell-based therapies such as tissue engineering will benefit from a source of autologous pluripotent stem cells. For mesodermal tissue engineering, one such source of cells is the bone marrow stroma. The bone marrow compartment contains several cell populations, including mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) that are capable of differentiating into adipogenic, osteogenic, chondrogenic, and myogenic cells. However, autologous bone marrow procurement has potential limitations. An alternate source of autologous adult stem cells that is obtainable in large quantities, under local anesthesia, with minimal discomfort would be advantageous. In this study, we determined if a population of stem cells could be isolated from human adipose tissue. Human adipose tissue, obtained by suction-assisted lipectomy (i.e., liposuction), was processed to obtain a fibroblast-like population of cells or a processed lipoaspirate (PLA). These PLA cells can be maintained in vitro for extended periods with stable population doubling and low levels of senescence. Immunofluorescence and flow cytometry show that the majority of PLA cells are of mesodermal or mesenchymal origin with low levels of contaminating pericytes, endothelial cells, and smooth muscle cells. Finally, PLA cells differentiate in vitro into adipogenic, chondrogenic, myogenic, and osteogenic cells in the presence of lineage-specific induction factors. In conclusion, the data support the hypothesis that a human lipoaspirate contains multipotent cells and may represent an alternative stem cell source to bone marrow-derived MSCs.
Chromatin, the physiological template of all eukaryotic genetic information, is subject to a diverse array of posttranslational
modifications that largely impinge on histone amino termini, thereby regulating access to the underlying DNA. Distinct histone
amino-terminal modifications can generate synergistic or antagonistic interaction affinities for chromatin-associated proteins,
which in turn dictate dynamic transitions between transcriptionally active or transcriptionally silent chromatin states. The
combinatorial nature of histone amino-terminal modifications thus reveals a “histone code” that considerably extends the information
potential of the genetic code. We propose that this epigenetic marking system represents a fundamental regulatory mechanism
that has an impact on most, if not all, chromatin-templated processes, with far-reaching consequences for cell fate decisions
and both normal and pathological development.
Genes constitute only a small proportion of the total mammalian genome, and the precise control of their expression in the
presence of an overwhelming background of noncoding DNA presents a substantial problem for their regulation. Noncoding DNA,
containing introns, repetitive elements, and potentially active transposable elements, requires effective mechanisms for its
long-term silencing. Mammals appear to have taken advantage of the possibilities afforded by cytosine methylation to provide
a heritable mechanism for altering DNA-protein interactions to assist in such silencing. Genes can be transcribed from methylation-free
promoters even though adjacent transcribed and nontranscribed regions are extensively methylated. Gene promoters can be used
and regulated while keeping noncoding DNA, including transposable elements, suppressed. Methylation is also used for long-term
epigenetic silencing of X-linked and imprinted genes and can either increase or decrease the level of transcription, depending
on whether the methylation inactivates a positive or negative regulatory element.
We report here that cells co-purifying with mesenchymal stem cells--termed here multipotent adult progenitor cells or MAPCs--differentiate, at the single cell level, not only into mesenchymal cells, but also cells with visceral mesoderm, neuroectoderm and endoderm characteristics in vitro. When injected into an early blastocyst, single MAPCs contribute to most, if not all, somatic cell types. On transplantation into a non-irradiated host, MAPCs engraft and differentiate to the haematopoietic lineage, in addition to the epithelium of liver, lung and gut. Engraftment in the haematopoietic system as well as the gastrointestinal tract is increased when MAPCs are transplanted in a minimally irradiated host. As MAPCs proliferate extensively without obvious senescence or loss of differentiation potential, they may be an ideal cell source for therapy of inherited or degenerative diseases.
Polycomb group (PcG) proteins play important roles in maintaining the silent state of HOX genes. Recent studies have implicated
histone methylation in long-term gene silencing. However, a connection between PcG-mediated gene silencing and histone methylation
has not been established. Here we report the purification and characterization of an EED-EZH2 complex, the human counterpart
of theDrosophila ESC-E(Z) complex. We demonstrate that the complex specifically methylates nucleosomal histone H3 at lysine 27 (H3-K27). Using
chromatin immunoprecipitation assays, we show that H3-K27 methylation colocalizes with, and is dependent on, E(Z) binding
at an Ultrabithorax (Ubx) Polycomb response element (PRE), and that this methylation correlates withUbx repression. Methylation on H3-K27 facilitates binding of Polycomb (PC), a component of the PRC1 complex, to histone H3 amino-terminal
tail. Thus, these studies establish a link between histone methylation and PcG-mediated gene silencing.
Lysine methylation of histones in vivo occurs in three states: mono-, di- and tri-methyl. Histone H3 has been found to be di-methylated at lysine 4 (K4) in active euchromatic regions but not in silent heterochromatic sites. Here we show that the Saccharomyces cerevisiae Set1 protein can catalyse di- and tri-methylation of K4 and stimulate the activity of many genes. Using antibodies that discriminate between the di- and tri-methylated state of K4 we show that di-methylation occurs at both inactive and active euchromatic genes, whereas tri-methylation is present exclusively at active genes. It is therefore the presence of a tri-methylated K4 that defines an active state of gene expression. These findings establish the concept of methyl status as a determinant for gene activity and thus extend considerably the complexity of histone modifications.
Replication of the genome before mitotic cell division is a highly regulated process that ensures the fidelity of DNA duplication. DNA replication initiates at specific locations, termed origins of replication, and progresses in a defined temporal order during the S phase of the cell cycle. The relationship between replication timing and gene expression has been the subject of some speculation. A recent genome-wide analysis in Saccharomyces cerevisiae showed no association between replication timing and gene expression. In higher eukaryotes, the limited number of genomic loci analyzed has not permitted a firm conclusion regarding this association. To explore the relationship between DNA replication and gene expression in higher eukaryotes, we developed a strategy to measure the timing of DNA replication for thousands of genes in a single DNA array hybridization experiment. Using this approach, we generated a genome-wide map of replication timing for Drosophila melanogaster. Moreover, by surveying over 40% of all D. melanogaster genes, we found a strong correlation between DNA replication early in S phase and transcriptional activity. As this correlation does not exist in S. cerevisiae, this interplay between DNA replication and transcription may be a unique characteristic of higher eukaryotes.
Much of the work conducted on adult stem cells has focused on mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) found within the bone marrow stroma. Adipose tissue, like bone marrow, is derived from the embryonic mesenchyme and contains a stroma that is easily isolated. Preliminary studies have recently identified a putative stem cell population within the adipose stromal compartment. This cell population, termed processed lipoaspirate (PLA) cells, can be isolated from human lipoaspirates and, like MSCs, differentiate toward the osteogenic, adipogenic, myogenic, and chondrogenic lineages. To confirm whether adipose tissue contains stem cells, the PLA population and multiple clonal isolates were analyzed using several molecular and biochemical approaches. PLA cells expressed multiple CD marker antigens similar to those observed on MSCs. Mesodermal lineage induction of PLA cells and clones resulted in the expression of multiple lineage-specific genes and proteins. Furthermore, biochemical analysis also confirmed lineage-specific activity. In addition to mesodermal capacity, PLA cells and clones differentiated into putative neurogenic cells, exhibiting a neuronal-like morphology and expressing several proteins consistent with the neuronal phenotype. Finally, PLA cells exhibited unique characteristics distinct from those seen in MSCs, including differences in CD marker profile and gene expression.
Cells of a multicellular organism are genetically homogeneous but structurally and functionally heterogeneous owing to the differential expression of genes. Many of these differences in gene expression arise during development and are subsequently retained through mitosis. Stable alterations of this kind are said to be 'epigenetic', because they are heritable in the short term but do not involve mutations of the DNA itself. Research over the past few years has focused on two molecular mechanisms that mediate epigenetic phenomena: DNA methylation and histone modifications. Here, we review advances in the understanding of the mechanism and role of DNA methylation in biological processes. Epigenetic effects by means of DNA methylation have an important role in development but can also arise stochastically as animals age. Identification of proteins that mediate these effects has provided insight into this complex process and diseases that occur when it is perturbed. External influences on epigenetic processes are seen in the effects of diet on long-term diseases such as cancer. Thus, epigenetic mechanisms seem to allow an organism to respond to the environment through changes in gene expression. The extent to which environmental effects can provoke epigenetic responses represents an exciting area of future research.
While CpG methylation can be readily analyzed at the DNA sequence level in wild-type and mutant cells, the actual DNA (cytosine-5) methyltransferases (DNMTs) responsible for in vivo methylation on genomic DNA are less tractable. We used an antibody-based method to identify specific endogenous DNMTs (DNMT1, DNMT1b, DNMT2, DNMT3a, and DNMT3b) that stably and selectively bind to genomic DNA containing 5-aza-2'-deoxycytidine (aza-dC) in vivo. Selective binding to aza-dC-containing DNA suggests that the engaged DNMT is catalytically active in the cell. DNMT1b is a splice variant of the predominant maintenance activity DNMT1, while DNMT2 is a well-conserved protein with homologs in plants, yeast, Drosophila, humans, and mice. Despite the presence of motifs essential for transmethylation activity, catalytic activity of DNMT2 has never been reported. The data here suggest that DNMT2 is active in vivo when the endogenous genome is the target, both in human and mouse cell lines. We quantified relative global genomic activity of DNMT1, -2, -3a, and -3b in a mouse teratocarcinoma cell line. DNMT1 and -3b displayed the greatest in vivo binding avidity for aza-dC-containing genomic DNA in these cells. This study demonstrates that individual DNMTs can be tracked and that their binding to genomic DNA can be quantified in mammalian cells in vivo. The different DNMTs display a wide spectrum of genomic DNA-directed activity. The use of an antibody-based tracking method will allow specific DNMTs and their DNA targets to be recovered and analyzed in a physiological setting in chromatin.
The human Dnmt2 protein is one member of a protein family conserved from Schizosaccharomyces pombe and Drosophila melanogaster to Mus musculus and Homo sapiens. It contains all of the amino acid motifs characteristic for DNA-(Cytosine-C5) methyltransferases, and its structure is very similar to prokaryotic DNA methyltransferases. Nevertheless, so far all attempts to detect catalytic activity of this protein have failed. We show here by two independent assay systems that the purified Dnmt2 protein has weak DNA methyltransferase activity. Methylation was observed at CG sites in a loose ttnCGga(g/a) consensus sequence, suggesting that Dnmt2 has a more specialized role than other mammalian DNA methyltransferases.
DNMT2 is a subgroup of the eukaryotic cytosine-5 DNA methyltransferase gene family. Unlike the other family members, proteins encoded by DNMT2 genes were not known before to possess DNA methyltransferase activities. Most recently, we have shown that the genome of Drosophila S2 cells stably expressing an exogenous Drosophila dDNMT2 cDNA became anomalously methylated at the 5'-positions of cytosines (Reddy, M. N., Tang, L. Y., Lee, T. L., and Shen, C.-K. J. (2003) Oncogene, in press). We present evidence here that the genomes of transgenic flies overexpressing the dDnmt2 protein also became hypermethylated at specific regions. Furthermore, transient transfection studies in combination with sodium bisulfite sequencing demonstrated that dDnmt2 as well as its mouse ortholog, mDnmt2, are capable of methylating a cotransfected plasmid DNA. These data provide solid evidence that the fly and mouse DNMT2 gene products are genuine cytosine-5 DNA methyltransferases.
Uncontrolled expansion of adipose tissue leads to obesity, a public health epidemic affecting >30% of adult Americans. Adipose mass increases in part through the recruitment and differentiation of an existing pool of preadipocytes (PA) into adipocytes (AD). Most studies investigating adipogenesis used primarily murine cell lines; much less is known about the relevant processes that occur in humans. Therefore, characterization of genes associated with adipocyte development is key to understanding the pathogenesis of obesity and developing treatments for this disorder. To address this issue, we performed large-scale analyses of human adipose gene expression using microarray technology. Differential gene expression between PA and AD was analyzed in 6 female patients using human cDNA microarray slides and data analyzed using the Stanford Microarray Database. Statistical analysis for the gene expression was performed using the SAS mixed models. Compared with PA, several genes involved in lipid metabolism were overexpressed in AD, including fatty acid binding protein, adipose differentiation-related protein, lipoprotein lipase, perilipin, and adipose most abundant transcript 1. Novel genes expressed in adipocytes included E2F5 transcriptional factor and SMARC (SWI/SNF-related, matrix associated, actin-dependent regulator of chromatin). PA predominantly expressed genes encoding extracellular matrix components such as fibronectin, matrix metalloprotein, and novel proteins such as lysyl oxidase. Despite the high differential expression of some of these genes, many did not differ significantly likely due to high variability and limited statistical power. A comprehensive list of differential gene expression is presented according to cellular function. In conclusion, these studies offer an overview of the gene expression profiles in PA and AD and identify new genes with potentially important functions in adipose tissue development and obesity that merit further investigation.
The covalent modification of nucleosomal histones has emerged as a major determinant of chromatin structure and gene activity. To understand the interplay between various histone modifications, including acetylation and methylation, we performed a genome-wide chromatin structure analysis in a higher eukaryote. We found a binary pattern of histone modifications among euchromatic genes, with active genes being hyperacetylated for H3 and H4 and hypermethylated at Lys 4 and Lys 79 of H3, and inactive genes being hypomethylated and deacetylated at the same residues. Furthermore, the degree of modification correlates with the level of transcription, and modifications are largely restricted to transcribed regions, suggesting that their regulation is tightly linked to polymerase activity.
Following hybridization with embryonic stem (ES) cells, somatic genomes are epigenetically reprogrammed and acquire pluripotency.
This results in the transcription of somatic genome-derived tissue-specific genes upon differentiation. During nuclear reprogramming,
it is expected that DNA and chromatin modifications, believed to function in cell-type-specific epigenotype memory, should
be significantly modified. Indeed, current evidence indicates that acetylation and methylation of histone H3 and H4 amino
termini play a major role in the regulation of gene activity through the modulation of chromatin conformation. Here, we show
that the reprogrammed somatic genome of ES hybrid cells becomes hyperacetylated at H3 and H4, while lysine 4 (K4) of H3 becomes
globally hyper-di- and -tri-methylated. In the Oct4 promoter region, histones H3 and H4 are acetylated and H3-K4 is highly tri-methylated on both the ES and reprogrammed somatic
genomes, which correlates with gene activation and DNA demethylation. However, H3-K4 is also di- and tri-methylated in the
promoter regions of Neurofilament-M (Nfm), Nfl, and Thy-1, which are all silent in both ES and hybrid cells. Thus, H3-K4 di- and tri-methylation of reprogrammed somatic genomes is
independent of gene activity and represents one of the major events that occurs during somatic genome reprogramming towards
a transcriptional activation-permissive state.
SUZ12 is a recently identified Polycomb group (PcG) protein, which together with EZH2 and EED forms different Polycomb repressive complexes (PRC2/3). These complexes contain histone H3 lysine (K) 27/9 and histone H1 K26 methyltransferase activity specified by the EZH2 SET domain. Here we show that mice lacking Suz12, like Ezh2 and Eed mutant mice, are not viable and die during early postimplantation stages displaying severe developmental and proliferative defects. Consistent with this, we demonstrate that SUZ12 is required for proliferation of cells in tissue culture. Furthermore, we demonstrate that SUZ12 is essential for the activity and stability of the PRC2/3 complexes in mouse embryos, in tissue culture cells and in vitro. Strikingly, Suz12-deficient embryos show a specific loss of di- and trimethylated H3K27, demonstrating that Suz12 is indeed essential for EZH2 activity in vivo. In conclusion, our data demonstrate an essential role of SUZ12 in regulating the activity of the PRC2/3 complexes, which are required for regulating proliferation and embryogenesis.
It has been reported that DNA methyltransferase 1-deficient (Dnmt1−/−) embryonic stem (ES) cells are hypomethylated (20% CpG methylation) and die through apoptosis when induced to differentiate.
Here, we show that Dnmt[3a−/−,3b−/−] ES cells with just 0.6% of their CpG dinucleotides behave differently: the majority of cells within the culture are partially
or completely blocked in their ability to initiate differentiation, remaining viable while retaining the stem cell characteristics
of alkaline phosphatase and Oct4 expression. Restoration of DNA methylation levels rescues these defects. Severely hypomethylated
Dnmt[3a−/−,3b−/−] ES cells have increased histone acetylation levels, and those cells that can differentiate aberrantly express extraembryonic
markers of differentiation. Dnmt[3a−/−,3b−/−] ES cells with >10% CpG methylation are able to terminally differentiate, whereas Dnmt1−/− ES cells with 20% of the CpG methylated cannot differentiate. This demonstrates that successful terminal differentiation
is not dependent simply on adequate methylation levels. There is an absolute requirement that the methylation be delivered
by the maintenance enzyme Dnmt1.
Human NT2 cells, which differentiate into neurons and astrocytes, initially express and then permanently down-regulate Nanog and Oct-4 (POU5F1). We investigated the relationship between the expression of these genes and the methylation state of their 5'-flanking regions. Gene expression and DNA methylation were assayed with quantitative polymerase chain reaction and bisulfite genomic sequencing, respectively. Retinoic acid-induced differentiation of NT2 cells to neurons is accompanied by a sequential decrease in the expression of both genes, paralleled by sequential epigenetic modification of their upstream regions. This is the first report demonstrating changes in DNA methylation in the promoter regions of Nanog and Oct-4 in a human cell line.
The surface of nucleosomes is studded with a multiplicity of modifications. At least eight different classes have been characterized to date and many different sites have been identified for each class. Operationally, modifications function either by disrupting chromatin contacts or by affecting the recruitment of nonhistone proteins to chromatin. Their presence on histones can dictate the higher-order chromatin structure in which DNA is packaged and can orchestrate the ordered recruitment of enzyme complexes to manipulate DNA. In this way, histone modifications have the potential to influence many fundamental biological processes, some of which may be epigenetically inherited.
Genomic imprinting is an epigenetic system of gene regulation in mammals. It determines the parent-of-origin-dependent expression of a small number of imprinted genes during development, i.e., the maternal allele is inactive while the paternal is active, or vice versa. Imprinting is imparted in the germ line and involves differential DNA methylation such that particular DNA regions become methylated in one sex of germ line but not in the other. Inheritance of these differential egg and sperm methylation states is then transmitted to somatic cells, where they lead to differential maternal and paternal allelic activity, or monoallelic expression. Increasing evidence indicates that the inherited and stable differential allelic methylation regulates monoallelic expression by influencing the activity of gene regulatory elements—for one allele the element is switched off by methylation, while for the other the element is left potentially active by the lack of methylation. An interesting feature of the germ line is that, despite the presence of genomic imprinting, either as imprints inherited from the zygote or as new imprints imparted according to germ cell sex, imprinted genes are biallelically expressed as if imprints were not present. One explanation for this observation is that imprints have no influence over the germ cell's transcriptional machinery, i.e., imprinting may be neutralized in the germ cell lineage. This phenomenon may have a common basis with other unique features of the germ line, such as totipotency, perhaps in some unique aspect of chromatin structure.
A number of transgenes in the mouse show variation in methylation and expression phenotypes dependent on parental transmission. It appears that there exist at least two types of transgene imprinting; one is retained on an essentially homozygous background, while the other requires heterozygosity at some modifying loci in the genome and is observed as differences in phenotype in reciprocal crosses. For this type of imprinting to occur, the parental origin of the modifier locus itself is important, and parental asymmetry may involve specific interactions between egg cytoplasm and the chromosomes. Based on the identification of 'methylation polymorphism' in the mouse genome, we also show that endogenous gene sequences can undergo imprinting by DNA methylation.
Data derived from both pronuclear transplantation experiments and classical genetic experiments indicate that the maternal and paternal genetic contributions to the mammalian zygote nucleus do not function equivalently during subsequent development. These observations have been interpreted as resulting from differential 'genome imprinting' during male and female gametogenesis. The molecular mechanism responsible for genome imprinting is unknown, but data gathered to date require that the mechanism fulfill at least four criteria: (1) the imprint must be physically linked to the pronucleus; (2) the imprint must persist through DNA replication and cell division; (3) the mechanism must be capable of affecting gene expression; and (4) the mechanism must be capable of switching the identity of the imprint from one sex to the other in successive generations. One molecular mechanism which could satisfy the first three criteria is differential DNA methylation during gametogenesis itself, or before formation of the zygote nucleus during embryogenesis. We present data indicating that the methylation patterns of exogenous DNA sequences in transgenic mice can be changed by switching their gamete of origin in successive generations. These data suggest that DNA methylation can also satisfy the fourth criterion for an imprinting mechanism.
Mouse embryogenesis relies on the presence of both the maternal and the paternal genome for development to term. It has been proposed that specific modifications are imprinted onto the chromosomes during gametogenesis; these modifications are stably propagated, and their expression results in distinct and complementary contributions of the two parental genomes to the development of the embryo and the extraembryonic membranes. Genetic data further suggest that a substantial proportion of the genome could be subject to chromosomal imprinting, the molecular nature of which is unknown. We used random DNA insertions in transgenic mice to probe the genome for modified regions. The DNA methylation patterns of transgenic alleles were compared after transmission from mother or father in seven mouse strains carrying autosomal insertions of the same transgenic marker. One of these loci showed a clear difference in DNA methylation specific for its parental origin, with the paternally inherited copy being relatively undermethylated. This difference was observed in embryos on day 10 of gestation, but not in their extraembryonic membranes. Moreover, the methylation pattern was faithfully reversed upon each germline transmission to the opposite sex. Our findings provide evidence for heritable molecular differences between maternally and paternally derived alleles on mouse chromosomes.
Although vertebrate DNA is generally depleted in the dinucleotide CpG, it has recently been shown that some vertebrate genes contain CpG islands, regions of DNA with a high G + C content and a high frequency of CpG dinucleotides relative to the bulk genome. In this study, a large number of sequences of vertebrate genes were screened for the presence of CpG islands. Each CpG island was then analysed in terms of length, nucleotide composition, frequency of CpG dinucleotides, and location relative to the transcription unit of the associated gene. CpG islands were associated with the 5′ ends of all housekeeping genes and many tissue-specific genes, and with the 3′ ends of some tissue-specific genes. A few genes contained both 5′ and 3′ CpG islands, separated by several thousand base-pairs of CpG-depleted DNA. The 5′ CpG islands extended through 5′-flanking DNA, exons and introns, whereas most of the 3′ CpG islands appeared to be associated with exons. CpG islands were generally found in the same position relative to the transcription unit of equivalent genes in different species, with some notable exceptions.
Current models suggest that de novo methylases add methyl groups to mammalian DNA early in development, establishing cell-specific patterns of methylation, and that these patterns are maintained by maintenance methylases that copy them onto newly replicated DNA strands. To test the prediction that clonal populations of histologically homogeneous cells should, therefore, have homogeneous methylation patterns, we studied methylation in leiomyomas. Despite the clonality and histological homogeneity of these solid tumors, we found that cells were heterogeneously methylated at a number of genomic sites. The heterogeneity was not caused by random methylation events within the leiomyomas because methylation patterns were similar in the core and periphery of a given tumor, and similar also among samples of independent leiomyomas and surrounding myometrial tissues extracted from a single uterus. Our results also showed that methylation of a site in the YNZ22 locus--in leiomyomas and in smooth muscle--was determined independently from the methylation of a neighboring site. Similar results were obtained for the IGH locus in colon and in several tumor tissues. These data indicate that methylation patterns are not identical in progeny cells, as current models suggest. Instead, it seems likely that methylation of a specific site reflects an equilibrium frequency defined by a continual loss and gain of methyl groups. Hence, the specificity found for the methylation of mammalian tissues is not achieved by strictly determining the methylation fate of individual cells, but by determining the overall methylation frequencies for individual sites.
Several lines of evidence strongly suggest that DNA methylation is involved in embryo development. Perhaps the most direct evidence comes from experiments with methyltransferase deficient mice. Embryos that express low levels of the maintenance methyltransferase do not develop to term and die at the 5 to 20 somite stage corresponding to the level of the enzyme. In the mouse, dramatic methylation changes have been observed during the early steps of embryo development. Most genes are subject to a process of active demethylation starting promptly after fertilization. Except for a small number of methylated CpG sites in imprinted genes the vast majority of the sites are unmethylated by the stage of cavitation (16 cell). Such genome-wide demethylation may signify an erasure of epigenetic information originating in the highly differentiated gametes. This erasure may be essential for the establishment of a pluripotent state, before specific cell lineages can be determined. The process of laying down a new developmental program involves, initially, global de novo methylation at the stage of pregastrulation followed by gene specific demethylations associated with the onset of activity of these genes. CpG islands characteristic of housekeeping genes, appear to be protected from the global de novo methylation. An exception to this rule is the hypermethylation of CpG islands in X-linked housekeeping genes on the inactive X chromosome and of specific differentially methylated CpG sites in imprinted genes. Primordial germ cells escape the global de novo methylation which takes place at the pregastrula stage and undergo a very similar de novo methylation process in the differentiated gonads (15.5-18.5 days post coitum), forming the methylation patterns which are specific to the gametes. Specific demethylations then form a terminal methylation pattern which is then clonaly inherited in the soma and erased after fertilization.
The Polycomb and trithorax group genes encode trans-regulators of homeotic gene function in Drosophila. The Polycomb group genes encode transcriptional repressors, while the trithorax group proteins are positive factors required for homeotic gene function. Among the Polycomb group proteins, the POLYCOMB protein has been most extensively characterized. The POLYCOMB protein contains a chromodomain, a conserved domain found in a Drosophila protein with effects on position-effect variegation. Among the trithorax group proteins characterized, the BRAHMA protein appears to be a subunit of a protein complex conserved from yeast to man (the SNF/SWI complex) that modifies chromatin to facilitate the transcriptional activation by gene-specific DNA-binding proteins. The ZESTE protein may help to activate transcription by bringing distant cis-regulatory elements closer to promoter-bound proteins.
Human blastocyst-derived, pluripotent cell lines are described that have normal karyotypes, express high levels of telomerase
activity, and express cell surface markers that characterize primate embryonic stem cells but do not characterize other early
lineages. After undifferentiated proliferation in vitro for 4 to 5 months, these cells still maintained the developmental
potential to form trophoblast and derivatives of all three embryonic germ layers, including gut epithelium (endoderm); cartilage,
bone, smooth muscle, and striated muscle (mesoderm); and neural epithelium, embryonic ganglia, and stratified squamous epithelium
(ectoderm). These cell lines should be useful in human developmental biology, drug discovery, and transplantation medicine.
It has become widely accepted that modification of nucleosome structure is an important regulatory mecha- nism. The hypothesis that the acetylation of histones is involved in regulation was first formed over thirty years ago by Allfrey and colleagues (Allfrey et al. 1964). Sub- sequent genetic studies suggested that complexes that utilize ATP hydrolysis to alter chromatin structure might also play a regulatory role. In the past 5 years, numerous ATP-dependent remodeling complexes, acet- yltransferases, and acetyltransferase complexes have been isolated and characterized. With the identification of these complexes, it is now possible to examine how these complexes modulate gene expression, and how the
Distinct modifications of histone amino termini, such as acetylation, phosphorylation and methylation, have been proposed to underlie a chromatin-based regulatory mechanism that modulates the accessibility of genetic information. In addition to histone modifications that facilitate gene activity, it is of similar importance to restrict inappropriate gene expression if cellular and developmental programmes are to proceed unperturbed. Here we show that mammalian methyltransferases that selectively methylate histone H3 on lysine 9 (Suv39h HMTases) generate a binding site for HP1 proteins--a family of heterochromatic adaptor molecules implicated in both gene silencing and supra-nucleosomal chromatin structure. High-affinity in vitro recognition of a methylated histone H3 peptide by HP1 requires a functional chromo domain; thus, the HP1 chromo domain is a specific interaction motif for the methyl epitope on lysine9 of histone H3. In vivo, heterochromatin association of HP1 proteins is lost in Suv39h double-null primary mouse fibroblasts but is restored after the re-introduction of a catalytically active SWUV39H1 HMTase. Our data define a molecular mechanism through which the SUV39H-HP1 methylation system can contribute to the propagation of heterochromatic subdomains in native chromatin.
The stem cells that maintain human colon crypts are poorly characterized. To better determine stem cell numbers and how they divide, epigenetic patterns were used as cell fate markers. Methylation exhibits somatic inheritance and random changes that potentially record lifelong stem cell division histories as binary strings or tags in adjacent CpG sites. Methylation tag contents of individual crypts were sampled with bisulfite sequencing at three presumably neutral loci. Methylation increased with aging but varied between crypts and was mosaic within single crypts. Some crypts appeared to be quasi-clonal as they contained more unique tags than expected if crypts were maintained by single immortal stem cells. The complex epigenetic patterns were more consistent with a crypt niche model wherein multiple stem cells were present and replaced through periodic symmetric divisions. Methylation tags provide evidence that normal human crypts are long-lived, accumulate random methylation errors, and contain multiple stem cells that go through "bottlenecks" during life.
Diverse post-translational modifications of histone amino termini represent an important epigenetic mechanism for the organisation of chromatin structure and the regulation of gene activity. Within the past two years, great progress has been made in understanding the functional implications of histone methylation; in particular through the characterisation of histone methyltransferases that direct the site-specific methylation of, for example, lysine 9 and lysine 4 positions in the histone H3 amino terminus. All known histone methyltransferases of this type contain the evolutionarily conserved SET domain and appear to be able to stimulate either gene repression or gene activation. Methylation of H3 Lys9 and Lys4 has been visualised in native chromatin, indicating opposite roles in structuring repressive or accessible chromatin domains. For example, at the mating-type loci in Schizosaccharomyces pombe, at pericentric heterochromatin and at the inactive X chromosome in mammals, striking differences between these distinct marks have been observed. H3 Lys9 methylation is also important to direct additional epigenetic signals such as DNA methylation--for example, in Neurospora crassa and in Arabidopsis thaliana. Together, the available data strongly establish histone lysine methylation as a central modification for the epigenetic organisation of eukaryotic genomes.
Cloning by nuclear transfer from adult somatic cells is a remarkable demonstration of developmental plasticity. When a nucleus is placed in oocyte cytoplasm, the changes in chromatin structure that govern differentiation can be reversed, and the nucleus can be made to control development to term.
The temporal firing of replication origins throughout S phase in yeast depends on unknown determinants within the adjacent chromosomal environment. We demonstrate here that the state of histone acetylation of surrounding chromatin is an important regulator of temporal firing. Deletion of RPD3 histone deacetylase causes earlier origin firing and concurrent binding of the replication factor Cdc45p to origins. In addition, increased acetylation of histones in the vicinity of the late origin ARS1412 by recruitment of the histone acetyltransferase Gcn5p causes ARS1412 alone to fire earlier. These data indicate that histone acetylation is a direct determinant of the timing of origin firing.
It is suggested that hematopoietic stem cells (HSC) could be found in several tissues of mesodermic origin. Among these, adipose tissue can expand throughout adult life and its expansion is not only due to mature adipocyte hypertrophy but also to the presence of precursor cells in stroma-vascular fraction (SVF). Here we report that transplantation of cells isolated from mice adipose tissue can efficiently rescue lethally irradiated mice and results in a reconstitution of major hematopoietic lineages. Donor cells can be detected in blood and in hematopoietic tissues of recipient mice. Adipose tissue contains a significant percentage of CD34, CD45 positive cells, and SVF cells were able to give rise to hematopoietic colonies in methylcellulose. We demonstrate the presence of hematopoietic progenitors in adipose tissue by phenotypic and functional characteristics. Thus adipose tissue could be considered as an important and convenient source of cells able to support hematopoiesis.
Genomic imprinting in mammals marks the two parental alleles resulting in differential gene expression. Imprinted loci are characterized by distinct epigenetic modifications such as differential DNA methylation and asynchronous replication timing. To determine the role of DNA methylation in replication timing of imprinted loci, we analyzed replication timing in Dnmt1- and Dnmt3L-deficient embryonic stem (ES) cells, which lack differential DNA methylation and imprinted gene expression. Asynchronous replication is maintained in these ES cells, indicating that asynchronous replication is parent-specific without the requirement for differential DNA methylation. Imprinting centers are required for regional control of imprinted gene expression. Analysis of replication fork movement and three-dimensional RNA and DNA fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis of the Igf2-H19 locus in various cell types indicate that the Igf2-H19 imprinting center differentially regulates replication timing of nearby replicons and subnuclear localization. Based on these observations, we suggest a model in which cis elements containing nonmethylation imprints are responsible for the movement of parental imprinted loci to distinct nuclear compartments with different replication characteristics resulting in asynchronous replication timing.
Polycomb group (PcG) proteins play important roles in maintaining the repressed transcriptional state of genes. PcG proteins operate as part of Polycomb repressive complexes (PRCs). 'Core' PRCs have been purified that contain only a limited number of PcG proteins. In addition, many gene regulatory proteins have been identified to interact with PcG proteins. However, it remains subject to discussion whether these interactions are transient or whether the regulatory proteins are real components of PRCs. It has also become clear that the compositions of 'core' PRCs differ amongst cell types and that extensive changes in compositions occur during the embryonic development of cells. Because of these dynamic changes, we argue that speaking of a definitive core PRC can be misleading.
Polycomb group (PcG) proteins are important for maintaining the silenced state of homeotic genes. Biochemical and genetic studies in Drosophila and mammalian cells indicate that PcG proteins function in at least two distinct protein complexes: the ESC-E(Z) or EED-EZH2 complex, and the PRC1 complex. Recent work has shown that at least part of the silencing function of the ESC-E(Z) complex is mediated by its intrinsic activity for methylating histone H3 on lysine 27. In addition to being involved in Hox gene silencing, the complex and its associated histone methyltransferase activity are important in other biological processes including X-inactivation, germline development, stem cell pluripotency and cancer metastasis.
In mammals, active demethylation of cytosine methylation in the sperm genome prior to forming a functional zygotic nucleus is thought to be a function of the oocyte cytoplasm important for subsequent normal development. Furthermore, a stepwise passive loss of DNA methylation in the embryonic nucleus has been observed as DNA replicates between two-cell and morula stages, with somatic cell levels of methylation being re-established by, or after the blastocyst stage when differentiated lineages are formed. The ability of oocyte cytoplasm to also reprogram the genome of a somatic cell by nuclear transfer (SCNT) has raised the possibility of directing reprogramming of a somatic nucleus ex ovo by mimicking the epigenetic events normally induced by maternal factors from the oocyte. Whilst examining DNA methylation changes in normal sheep fertilization, we were surprised to observe no demethylation of the sheep male pronucleus at any point in the first cell cycle. Furthermore, using quantitative image analysis, we observed limited demethylation of the sheep embryonic genome only between the two- and eight-cell stages and no evidence of remethylation by the blastocyst stage. We suggest that the dramatic differences in DNA methylation between the sheep and other mammalian species examined call in to question the requirement and role of DNA methylation in early mammalian embryonic development.