ArticlePDF Available

Contract-Intensive Money: Contract Enforcement, Property Rights, and Economic Performance

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

We introduce a new, easily accessed and objective measure of the enforceability of contracts and the security of property rights. This measure, called contract-intensive money or CIM, is based on citizens decisions regarding the form in which they choose to hold their financial assets. Country case studies show that CIM varies over time in response to political events in ways predicted by our arguments. We also show that CIM is positively related to investment and growth rates, and to the relative size of contract-dependent sectors of the economy.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... Although there is still an ongoing debate around the precise meaning of institution, the author defines it as constraints that structure political, economic, and social interaction, consisting of formal rules and informal constraints. Therefore, to gauge the institutional conditions in a country, researchers have been using these three types of institutions, namely: (i) political institutions, such as corruption (e.g., Mauro, 1995;Iqbal and Daly, 2014), political instability (e.g., Campos et al., 2012;, and democracy (e.g., Acemoglu et al., 2001; Mathonnat and Minea, 2019); (ii) economic institutions, such as property rights (e.g., Pereira and Luiz, 2020), and contract-intensive money (e.g., Clague et al., 1999); and, (iii) social institutions, such as culture, customs, and religion (e.g., Bernardelli and Michellon, 2018). ...
... For instance, democratic stability can have positive growth effects, constraining distorted public policies (Mathonnat and Minea, 2019). Clague et al. (1999) argue that in societies with inferior economic institutions, there is less protection of property rights and enforcement of contracts, translating into fewer incentives to invest and adopt more efficient technologies. At last, social institutions tend to affect society through the power to mold individuals through communal aspects. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper assesses Brazil's real convergence (1822–2019) through unit root tests and Markov Regime-Switching (MS) models in three different scenarios: towards (i) other six Latin American countries (LA6); (ii) Portugal; and (iii) the technological frontier country, the US. The extended unit root test results favour Brazil's very long-run real convergence towards LA6 and Portugal, but not the US. The estimated MS models, involving two different regimes, real convergence and real non-convergence/divergence, capture institutional quality's positive effect in promoting Brazil's real convergence.
... We identify and include in our analysis two variables plausibly related to both the demand for insurance and the independence of the judiciary. The first of these is the level of economic development, argued a determinant of independence because of increased need for property rights protection (Clague et al. 1999), and to be closely related to the competitiveness of the political arena (Frye 2010). To account for this, we include the log of per capita GDP in international dollars at 2000 prices. ...
Article
Full-text available
Popular insurance models of judicial independence contend that electoral competition induces executives to establish or maintain independence as insurance against the risks associated with losing office. Existing accounts, however, focus only on variation in the likelihood of losing office, treating risks associated with losing as constant. This inattention to the model’s causal logic limits theoretical development and empirical conclusions. We model the demand for insurance rather than simply the likelihood of losing office, with empirical implications tested via instrumental variables. This paper offers a major development of the insurance account, with important implications for the study of judicial independence.
... It is the combination of trust, civic standards, and networks that enable collective action and improve market performance by lowering transaction costs (Rasak, 2019). Macro-level social capital refers to the governmental institutions that inuence people's ability to cooperate for mutual benet, such as the rule of law, contract enforcement, and the absence of corruption, transparency in decision-making, an efcient administrative system, and a reliable legal system (Clague, Keefer & Knack, 1999). ...
Article
Full-text available
In many developing countries, the approach for lifting the poor out of poverty has focused on how to build physical and human capital, while social capital, which is critical for the effectiveness of all other types of capital, has been largely ignored. The effects of social capital investment on sectoral productivity in Nigeria was investigated in this study. Annual time series data from 2005 to 2017 sourced from the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Statistical Bulletin and the World Bank Development Indicator were utilized in the study. Granger causality technique was used in the analysis of data. The ndings revealed a bi-causation link, with institutions found to granger cause agricultural and non-agricultural sector productivity, but no causality was found between agricultural and non-agricultural sector productivity and social network as well as trust level. The implication of the result is that, social capital, specically the level of trust required to create personal relationships in business and other institutions, does not stimulate productivity growth. It was suggested that families and educational institutions should through policy instil in students the importance of being trustworthy, honest, and law abiding in their interpersonal connections and contractual agreements with others in society. Word Count: 196
Chapter
The research examines the role of institutional factors in the development of the information economy and its impact on economic growth. The central practical thesis of the study posits that institutional factors, including public expenditures on national endeavors, the efficacy of the judiciary, law enforcement, and security services, the efficiency of public administration and regulatory frameworks, the protection of property rights, the prevalence of corruption, and the overall business climate play a pivotal role in the development of the information economy and exert a significant influence on economic growth, in addition to the conventional drivers of economic growth, such as advancements in the number of Internet users, e-government and scientific innovation. Based on the combination of different institutional indicators, the Aggregate Index of Institutional Development of the Republic of Belarus for 2002–2021 is created and its impact on the country’s information economy is assessed. The author’s methodological contribution lies in developing a multiple regression model to identify the institutional factors that most strongly influence economic growth in the context of the information economy. The study’s findings can contribute to macroeconomic policymaking by providing a systematic and comprehensive approach to understanding the complex interactions between institutions and economic outcomes.
Article
The short answer is: probably not. We infer the priorities of national governments from observed outcomes, constructing a statistical proxy for long‐term benevolence. Using data between 1960 and 2019 for more than 100 countries, we show that, on average, democracies score more highly on our measure. We then investigate whether variation in long‐term benevolence can explain the ‘autocratic gamble’—the well‐known tendency for growth rates to vary more widely across autocracies than across democracies. We show that the distribution of long‐term benevolence under democracy first‐order stochastically dominates its distribution under autocracy. Put differently, although there is an autocratic gamble in growth rates, there is no autocratic gamble in wider development outcomes. The rapid growth seen in some autocracies probably originates in regime self‐interest rather than unusually benevolent leadership.
Chapter
The chapter reconsiders the economic aspects of the Italian history since Unification and strives to provide answers to a number of unresolved questions. Among them: why was it that the institutional reform effort during the years following Unification—unprecedented in its intensity—did not translate into sustained rates of growth? And why has the same phenomenon seemed to have occurred in the last three decades?
Preprint
Full-text available
This study aims to clarify, reaffirm, and extend empirical bases for the long-established claims of the relationship between Weberian bureaucracy and growth. Using the same dataset while taking issue with the core assumptions and methodologies of the seminal paper by Evans and Rauch (1999), this paper takes more seriously the multiple micro-level causal paths and the logically prior conditions of state-society relationship that activate the positive relationship between Weberian bureaucratic traits and national-level growth. Most of the test results confirm that (1) meritocratic recruitment system based on formal exam and higher educational credentials, (2) long-term career ladder based on internal promotions and length tenure, and (3) competitive salary relative to private sectors had robust positive effect on economic growth. However, the bureaucratic level of autonomy with regards to policy formulation had the moderation effect, serving as a precondition for such effects to exist in the first place.
Article
Why do firms demand antidumping protectionism? Contemporary literature highlights a plethora of causal mechanisms within the data-generating process, including retaliatory motives, exchange rate appreciations, business cycles, and deindustrialization. I argue that countries that are economically integrated into global markets should be associated with less demand for antidumping trade remedies. In particular, countries with higher levels of trade and financial flows should receive fewer petitions for antidumping trade remedies from firms overall, ceteris paribus. I test this theoretical argument with a series of de facto globalization indicators collected from thirty-three countries between 1978 and 2022, finding support for these arguments.
Article
Full-text available
This paper analyzes the role of wealth distribution in macroeconomics through investment in human capital. It is shown that in the presence of credit markets' imperfections and indivisibilities in investment in human capital, the initial distribution of wealth affects aggregate output and investment both in the short and in the long run, as there are multiple steady states. This paper therefore provides an additional explanation for the persistent differences in per-capita output across countries. Furthermore, the paper shows that cross-country differences in macroeconomic adjustment to aggregate shocks can be attributed, among other factors, to differences in wealth and income distribution across countries.
Article
Full-text available
The effectiveness with which a country's financial system functions to c hannel savings into productive activities has an important effect on economic growth. The way savings get directed into productive activities depends crucially on a country's financial institutions and their effectiveness. The last two decades have been ones of tremendous change in Mexico's financial structure with a deep impact on economic activity and growth. The aim of this paper is twofold: first, to describe the developments that have transpired in Mexico's financial structure over the last two decades. And second, to analyze how the increase in credit to the private sector brought about by these macroeconomic and financial developments affected output and investment in different sectors and therefore, growth in the Mexican economy. We use the Vector Error Correction methodology to show that an increase in the availability of credit has a relatively larger effect on the output of those sectors that are a priori considered to be more liquidity constrained, such as manufactures, durables, construction, and investment in the construction sector.