ArticlePDF Available

Post-Harvest Fungal Ecology: Impact of Fungal Growth and Mycotoxin Accumulation in Stored Grain

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Grain quality after harvest is influenced by a wide variety of abiotic and biotic factors and has been studied as a stored grain ecosystem. Important factors include grain and contaminant mould respiration, insects and mites, and the key environmental factors of water availability and temperature. Interactions between these factors influence the dominance of fungi, particularly mycotoxigenic species. Studies have shown that growth, mycotoxin production, competitiveness and niche occupation by mycotoxigenic species are influenced by the presence of other contaminant moulds and environmental factors. This has been demonstrated for both Fusarium culmorum and deoxynivalenol production, Aspergillus ochraceus/Penicillium verruscosum and ochratoxin production and Fusarium section Liseola and fumonisin production. Interactions between mycotoxigenic spoilage fungi and insects do occur but have not been studied thoroughly. Some insects disseminate mycotoxigenic species, others are known to use spoilage moulds as a food source, while others avoid certain fungal species. Thus, a more holistic ecological view is needed when considering management approaches to long-term-safe storage of cereal grains after harvest.
Content may be subject to copyright.
European Journal of Plant Pathology 109: 723–730, 2003.
© 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
Post-harvest fungal ecology: Impact of fungal growth and
mycotoxin accumulation in stored grain
Naresh Magan, Russell Hope, Victoria Cairns and David Aldred
Applied Mycology Group, Biotechnology Centre, Cranfield University, Silsoe, Bedford MK45 5DT, UK
(Fax: +44 1525 863540; E-mail: n.magan@cranfield.ac.uk)
Key words: ecology, biotic, abiotic factors, fungal interactions, niche occupation, mycotoxins, insects
Abstract
Grain quality after harvest is influenced by a wide variety of abiotic and biotic factors and has been studied as
a stored grain ecosystem. Important factors include grain and contaminant mould respiration, insects and mites,
and the key environmental factors of water availability and temperature. Interactions between these factors influ-
ence the dominance of fungi, particularly mycotoxigenic species. Studies have shown that growth, mycotoxin
production, competitiveness and niche occupation by mycotoxigenic species are influenced by the presence of
other contaminant moulds and environmental factors. This has been demonstrated for both Fusarium culmorum
and deoxynivalenol production, Aspergillus ochraceus/Penicillium verruscosum and ochratoxin production and
Fusarium section Liseola and fumonisin production. Interactions between mycotoxigenic spoilage fungi and insects
do occur but have not been studied thoroughly. Some insects disseminate mycotoxigenic species, others are known
to use spoilage moulds as a food source, while others avoid certain fungal species. Thus, a more holistic eco-
logical view is needed when considering management approaches to long-term-safe storage of cereal grains after
harvest.
Stored grain as an ecosystem
Grain entering store carries a wide range of microor-
ganisms including bacteria, yeasts and filamentous
fungi, the population structure being dependent on field
climatic conditions and harvesting processes (Magan
and Lacey, 1986; Lacey and Magan, 1991). Poor post-
harvest management can lead to rapid deterioration in
grain quality, severely decreasing germinability and
nutritional value of stored grain. Fungal activity can
cause undesirable effects in grain including discoloura-
tion, contribute to heating and losses in nutritional
value, produce off-odours, losses in germination, dete-
rioration in baking and milling quality, and can result
in contamination with mycotoxins.
Wallace and Sinha (1981) were the first to con-
sider stored grain as a man-made ecosystem and use
multivariate statistics to examine the complex inter-
actions between abiotic and biotic factors to identify
key parameters for safe storage. They believed that
unless this more holistic and ecological approach was
adopted it was not possible to understand the processes
occurring and thus improve post-harvest management
of stored grain. Factors such as grain type and quality,
fungal population and community structure, mycotoxin
production and pest infestation were all interlinked
(Figure 1). The key environmental factors of tempera-
ture, water availability and gas composition influence
both the rate of fungal spoilage and the production of
mycotoxins.
Generally, provided grain is stored at a moisture
content equivalent to 0.70 water activity (aw) then
no spoilage will occur. However, since grain is often
traded on a wet weight basis, inefficient drying systems
can lead to fungal activity and concomitant myco-
toxin production which renders grain useless for food
or feed. During initial storage, fungal inoculum can
become redistributed in grain. Mechanical damage is
also conducive to entry of spoilage fungi in insuffi-
ciently dried grain. It must also be remembered that
724
Figure 1. Diagrammatic representation of interactions between
biotic and abiotic factors in stored grain ecosystems (adapted from
Sinha, 1995).
stored grain ecosystems offer an excellent but finite
nutritional substrate for spoilage fungi.
Ecological considerations of interactions
between spoilage fungi post-harvest
Fungi seldom occur on grains in isolation, but usu-
ally as a mixed consortium of bacteria, yeasts and
filamentous fungi. It is thus inevitable that interspe-
cific and intraspecific interactions will occur depend-
ing on the nutritional status of the grain and the
prevailing environmental conditions. Indeed, envi-
ronmental factors may exert a selective pressure
influencing community structure and dominance of
individual species, especially mycotoxigenic species.
Figure 2 shows the effect of awon respiration of sin-
gle spoilage fungi (e.g. Eurotium amstelodami and
Penicillium aurantiogriseum) when grown individually
or co-inoculated on wheat grain using an automated
electrolytic respirometer system (Willcock and Magan,
2001). Respiration of co-inoculated species was less
than additive especially at intermediate awconditions
after 7 days. After 14 days, patterns changed again
when total O2utilisation was considered (Hamer and
Magan, unpublished data). This is indicative of com-
petition between species. The situation becomes even
more complex when a mixture of species colonising
cereal substrates is considered.
From an ecophysiological point of view, it has to be
remembered that spoilage fungi colonising grain use
different primary and secondary strategies to occupy
the niche. They may have combative (C-selected),
Figure 2. Measurement of the total respiratory activity of
E. amstelodami (Ea), P. auratiogriseum (Pa) or a mixture of
the two (mixture) at 0.85 and 0.90 water activity after 7 and
14 days incubation (Magan, unpublished data). Bar indicates least
significant difference (P=0.05) between treatments.
stress (S-selected) or ruderal (R-selected) strategies or
merged secondary strategies (C–R, S–R, C–S, C–S–R;
Cooke and Whipps, 1993). Primary resource capture
of grain is influenced by the germination rate, growth
rate, enzyme production and the capacity for sporula-
tion. Subsequent interactions between spoilage fungi
result in combat, antagonism and niche overlap which
all influence secondary resource capture.
We will consider two approaches which have been
used to understand the type of interactions which occur
between fungi under different environmental regimes
in grain to enable better prediction of not just domi-
nance by key spoilage fungi, but also the potential for
production of mycotoxins. Magan and Lacey (1984,
1985) used categories of mutual intermingling (1/1),
antagonism (2/2; 3/3) on contact or at a distance
respectively, and dominance on contact or at a dis-
tance (4/0; 5/0). By giving a higher numerical score
to fungi able to dominate in vitro rather than antago-
nism and adding the scores for each species, an Index
of Dominance (ID) was developed to assist with inter-
preting patterns of colonisation and dominance in grain
ecosystems. The IDwas found to significantly change
with awand temperature, and with grain substrate.
Of 15 species, the most competitive species in wheat
grain in the United Kingdom were P. brevicompactum,
725
P. hordei,P. roqueforti,Aspergillus fumigatus and
A. nidulans. Decreasing the awled to conditions
increased competitiveness of P. brevicompactum. Only
Fusarium culmorum could compete with storage
moulds, at >0.93–0.95 aw. Interestingly, the rate of
growth was not related to dominance. Previously,
studies by Ayerst (1969) had suggested that speed
of germination and growth were key determinants
of colonisation of nutrient-rich matrices, such as
grain.
Table 1 shows the effect of interactions between
a mycotoxigenic strain of F. culmorum and other
species in relation to water availability on wheat
grain using the IDscoring system. It is interesting to
note that F. graminearum is more competitive than
F. culmorum, regardless of temperature or water avail-
ability. F. culmorum is, however, dominant against
Table 1.F. culmorum interaction and IDdetermined after 30 day
incubation at 15 or 25 C on irradiated wheat grain adjusted to
different awlevels (Hope and Magan, unpublished data)
awSpeciesaTemperature ID
15 C25
C
0.995 F.c: F.g 0b/4c0/4 0/8
F.c: F.p 2/2 1/1 3/3
F.c: A.t 4/0 4/0 8/0
F.c: C.h 4/0 4/0 8/0
F.c: M.n 2/2 4/0 6/2
F.c: M.m 2/2 4/0 6/2
F.c: P.v 4/0 2/2 6/2
ID16/10 19/7 35/17
0.955 F.c: F.g 0/4 0/4 0/8
F.c: F.p 0/4 2/2 2/6
F.c: A.t 4/0 4/0 8/0
F.c: C.h 4/0 4/0 8/0
F.c: M.n 4/0 4/0 8/0
F.c: M.m 0/4 4/0 4/4
F.c: P.v 2/2 4/0 6/2
ID14/14 20/6 34/20
aF.c., Fusarium culmorum; F.g., Fusarium graminearum; F.p.,
Fusarium paoe; A.t., Alternaria tenuissima; C.h., Cladosporium
herbarum; M.n., Microdochium nivale; M.m; M. nivale var.
majus; P.v., Penicillium verrucosum.
bRefers to interaction score for first species only.
cRefers to interaction score for second species only.
IDrefers to total addition of scores for an individual species com-
peting with a range of other species based on the interaction scores
for each species of 1 : 1 (mutual intermingling), 2 : 2 (mutual
antagonism on contact), 3 : 3 (mutual antagonism at a distance),
4 :0 (first species dominant over the other on contact), 5 : 0 (first
species dominant at a distance over the other; from Magan and
Lacey, 1984).
other grain fungi including Microdochium nivale.
This is indicative of why F. culmorum has become such
an important pre- and post-harvest pathogen of temper-
ate cereals and also indicates that F. graminearum is
more competitive when both colonise grain. Thus inter-
actions can change with different abiotic factors and
with interacting species. Table 2 gives an example for
an ochratoxin (OTA)-producing strain of A. ochraceus
and other species, both in vitro and on maize grain at
two different temperatures. A. ochraceus is domi-
nant against A. candidus and A. flavus at 18 C, but
not against the latter at 30 Cin situ.
More recently, alternative approaches were utilised
to understand the relative competitiveness of different
species within fungal communities colonising grain.
Wilson and Lindow (1994a,b), working with bio-
control systems, suggested that the co-existence of
microorganisms particularly on plant surfaces may be
mediated by nutritional resource partitioning. Thus
in vitro carbon utilisation patterns (Niche size) could
be used to determine Niche overlap indices (NOI)
and thus the level of ecological similarity. Based on
the ratio of the number of similar C-sources utilised
and those unique to an individual isolate or species,
a value between 0 and 1 was obtained. NOI of >0.9
were indicative of co-existence between species in an
ecological niche, while scores of <0.9 represented
occupation of separate niches. This approach was mod-
ified by Marin et al. (1998a) and Lee and Magan
(1999) for a multifactorial approach by including
water availability and temperature into the system.
This demonstrated that based on utilisation of maize
C-sources, the NOIs for fumonisin-producing strains
of F. verticillioides and F. proliferatum were >0.90 at
>0.96 awat 25 and 30 C, indicative of co-existence
with other fungi such as Penicillium species, A. flavus
and A. ochraceus. However, for some species, pairing
with F. verticillioides resulted in NOI values <0.80
indicating occupation of different niches. Figure 3
shows a diagrammatic example of the impact that envi-
ronmental factors and interaction have on Niche size
and NOI for A. ochraceus against Alternaria alternata.
This shows how interactions may change with environ-
ment. Table 3 shows results for interactions between an
OTA-producing P. verrucosum strain and a Eurotioum
species at 15 and 25 C. These results suggest that
Niche overlap is in a state of flux and significantly
influenced by both temperature and water availabil-
ity. Nutrient status is very important. Lee and Magan
(1999) demonstrated that comparison of C-sources in a
standard BIOLOG test plate (95 carbon sources) with
726
Table 2.In vitro and in situ interaction scores and IDbetween A. ochraceus and other
species in relation to environmental factors (adapted from Lee and Magan, 2000a,b)
awSpeciesaIn vitro In situ
18 C30
C18
C30
C
0.95 A. ochraceus :A. candidus 4b/0c5/0 4/0 4/0
A. ochraceus :A. flavus 4/0 4/0 4/0 0/4
A. ochraceus :A. niger 4/0 0/4 0/4 0/4
A. ochraceus :E. amstelodami 2/2 2/2 0/4 0/4
Index of Dominanced14/2 11/6 8/8 4/12
aInteracting fungal species.
bRefers to interaction score for A. ochraceus only.
cRefers to interaction score for interacting species only.
dRefers to total addition of scores for an individual species competing with a range of
other species based on the interaction scores for each species of 1 :1 (mutual intermin-
gling), 2 : 2 (mutual antagonism on contact), 3 : 3 (mutual antagonism at a distance),
4 :0 (first species dominant over the other on contact), 5 : 0 (first species dominant at a
distance over the other; from Magan and Lacey, 1984).
Figure 3. Diagrammatic representation of the Niche size and
NOI for A. ochraceus when interacting with A. alternata at
different temperatures and water activity levels (adapted from
Lee and Magan, 1999). aNumber of C-sources utilised out
of 95; NOIoch, number of C-sources in common divided by
total number utilised by A. ochraceus; NOIstr, number of C-
sources utilised in common divided by the number utilised by
A. alternata.
those only relevant to maize grain (18 carbon sources)
gave very different results in terms of Niche size and
NOI under different environmental conditions. This
approach confirms that interactions and dominance are
dynamic, not static, and emphasises the importance
of taking account of such fluxes in any integrated
approach to understanding and controlling the activity
of mycotoxigenic spoilage moulds in the stored grain
ecosystem.
Table 3. Example of impact of environmental factors on Niche
size and NOI between P. verrucosum and other spoilage fungi
(Cairns and Magan, unpublished data)
Water activity 0.995 0.93
Niche NOIPv/ Niche NOIPv/
sizeaNOISp size NOISp
15 C
P. verrucosum 92 74
A. ochraceus 71 0.71/0.92 52 0.50/0.74
F. culmorum 90 0.88/0.92 63 0.58/0.74
P. aurantiogriseum 90 0.78/0.92 75 0.69/0.74
25 C
P. verrucosum 85 69
A. ochraceus 88 0.84/0.85 63 0.55/0.69
F. culmorum 89 0.82/0.85 51 0.45/0.69
P. aurantiogriseum 74 0.84/0.85 64 0.59/0.60
aNiche size, the total number of carbon sources utilised by a
species based on Biolog GN plate of 95 Carbon sources.
NOIpv, total number of carbon sources utilised in common divided
by the total number utilised by P. verrucosum only, under each
set of conditions.
NOIsp, total number of carbon sources utilised in common,
divided by the total utilised by the competitor, under each set of
conditions.
Effect of interactions on growth and
mycotoxin production
Figure 4 shows effects of fungal interactions and awon
growth of F. culmorum on layers of irradiated wheat
grain at two different awlevels. The results show that
when interacting with some species, e.g. M. nivale or
727
Figure 4. Effect of environmental factors on relative growth (diametric extension±SE) of F. culmorum when paired with other interacting
fungi on wheat grain at 0.995 and 0.955 water activities and 25 C. Growth rates are means of five replicates per treatment. Key to fungi:
F.c., Fusarium culmorum; F.g., Fusarium graminearum; F.p., Fusarium paoe; A.t., Alternaria tenuissima; C.h., Cladosporium herbarum;
M.n., Microdochium nivale; M.m.; M. nivale var. majus; P.v., Penicillium verrucosum (Hope and Magan, unpublished data).
P. verrucosum, growth of F. culmorum is significantly
faster than when growing alone on grain. Similar effects
on growth and on OTA production were observed for
A. ochraceus on maize grain (Lee and Magan, 2000b).
The question arises whether such effects on growth
also influence mycotoxin production in poorly stored
grain. In vitro and in situ studies have previously
suggested that interaction between some species can
result in a significant accumulation of mycotoxins,
while in other cases an inhibition of mycotoxin pro-
duction is observed. For example, interactions between
section Liseola Fusarium species with A. niger resulted
in a tenfold increase in fumonisin production espe-
cially at 0.98 aw, although under drier conditions no
increase in fumonsin occurred on maize grain (Marin
et al., 1998b). Also in maize, A. flavus,A. niger and
E. amsteladami all significantly inhibited OTA produc-
tion by A. ochraceus (Figure 5; Lee and Magan, 2000b).
Recent studies with F. culmorum show that interaction
with M. nivale stimulated DON production on wheat
grain with freely available water (=0.995 aw),
while under drier conditions (0.955 aw) interaction
with A. tenuissima,Cladosporium herbarum and
P. verrucosum reduced DON production (Table 4, Hope
and Magan, unpublished data). OTA production by
P. verrucosum was also influenced by competition with
other spoilage fungi on wheat grain (Table 5).
Relationship between insects and mycotoxin
producing fungi in stored grain
It is important to remember that insect pests are a
common problem in stored grain ecosystems. They
grow and multiply at water availabilities much drier
than those allowing fungal growth. Insects can produce
728
Figure 5. Effect of temperature and water activity on relative ochratoxin production by A. ochraceus when interacting with other fungi on
maize grain at 18 and 30 C when compared to A. ochraceus colonisation alone. Key to fungi: Ao, Aspergillus ochraceus; Ac, Aspergillus
candidus; An, Aspergillus niger;Aa, Alternaria alternata; Ea, Eurotium amstelodami (adapted from Lee and Magan, 2000b). Indicates
significant differences from the control (P=0.05).
Table 4. Effect of interactions between F. culmorum and
other species on deoxynivalenol and nivalenol (ng g1
grain) production on irradiated wheat grain at two water
activity levels at 25C (Hope and Magan, unpublished
data)
Mycotoxin
Deoxynivalenol Nivalenol
Water activity 0.995 0.955 0.995 0.955
F. culmorum 7669 447 289 298
F. culmorum +C. herbarum 634 0 316 412
F. culmorum +A. tenuissima 459 444 0 288
F. culmorum +M. nivale 451 600 868 0
F. culmorum +M. majus 0 440 292 0
F. culmorum +P. verrucosum 3264 450 0 0
LSD (P=0.05): DON =180.5: NIV =123.2.
Key to fungi: F, Fusarium; A, Alternaria;M,Microdochium;
M. majus,M. nivale var. majus;P,Penicillium verrucosum.
metabolic heat which generates water via condensa-
tion on surfaces due to temperature differentials and
develop classic hot spots which can quickly result
in heating and complete spoilage. Pre-harvest insect
infection can lead to increased post-harvest production
of aflatoxin in maize (Sauer et al., 1984).
Some storage insects are disseminators of storage
fungi, while others are exterminators (Sinha, 1971).
Some storage fungi attract insects as food sources
and promote population increases. Some fungi pro-
duce metabolites which repel insects. Indeed, loss in
calorific value is due to the combined effects of spoilage
fungi and insects. These interactions have often been
neglected, although they are important. Physiological
and biochemical similarities between fungi and
early developmental stages of insects mean that
potential exists for combined insecticidal/fungicidal
control.
729
Table 5. Effect of interactions between P. verrucosum and two other mycotoxigenic Fusarium species
(F. culmorum,F. poae) on ochratoxin production (ng g1±SE) on wheat-based medium under different
water activity and temperature conditions after 56 days incubation
Water activity Temperature (C)
15 25
0.99 0.95 0.99 0.95
P. verrucosum alone 3000 ±327 1800 ±645 150 ±36 3600 ±409
P. verrucosum +F. culmorum 010±70 0
P. verrucosum +F. poae 60 200 ±18 0 0
There are no recent studies of interactions between
insects and mycotoxigenic fungi. Dix (1984) found
that Penicillium spp. and A. flavus were associated
with Sitophilus zeamais. As adults they carried a
high density of spores without succumbing to afla-
toxicoses. Earlier Eugenio et al. (1970) showed that
the lesser mealworm and the confused flour beetle
retained zearelenone (ZEA) through metamorphoses
from larvae to adult. Wright (1973) found that neither
ZEA or T-2 toxin produced by F. graminearum and
F. tricinctum, respectively, caused any mortality in the
life-cycle of Tribolium confusum. Since this insect also
feeds on these fungi, it may be a non-propagative vector
or disperser of these fungal metabolites.
Dunkel (1988) carried out elegant studies to exam-
ine the efficacy of different concentrations of OTA,
citrinin, rubratoxin B and patulin on larval weights
and development time of three different insect species
at between 0 and 1000 ppm concentrations. Larval
weight of T. confusum was only significantly affected
by citrinin, rubratoxin B and patulin at 1000 ppm con-
centration, with little effect on adult emergence. Of the
three insect pests examined, only Attagenus megatoma
was significantly affected at 100–1000 ppm of the
mycotoxins. Surprisingly, no studies have been con-
ducted with regard to fumonsins, DON or nivalenol.
Such studies are necessary to evaluate the interactions
which might occur between insect pests and spoilage
moulds in stored grain ecosystems.
Conclusions
The activity of mycotoxigenic fungi in stored
grain must be examined in the context of the
ecosystem as a whole in order to understand the
dominance of certain species under certain environ-
mental conditions. Interactions between these fungi
and other contaminants are complex and are signifi-
cantly affected by the prevailing and changing envi-
ronmental factors. Niche overlap and dominance of
mycotoxigenic species have been shown to fluctuate
with environmental factors. Studies in vitro and in situ
suggest that interactions between toxigenic species and
other spoilage fungi markedly influence mycotoxin
production, with some species stimulating and others
inhibiting production. The role of insect pests should
not be neglected as they may be integrally involved in
the dominance of mycotoxigenic species by helping
in dispersal and acting as vectors and carriers of the
toxin through grain. Overall, conditions in stored grain
are not in a steady state and thus the dynamics of the
system will vary over time. This needs to be taken into
account in determining safe storage times for cereals
without risks of spoilage and mycotoxin contamina-
tion. Any decision support system must take all these
factors into account for the effective development of
good management systems post-harvest.
Acknowledgements
Parts of this research were funded by the European
Commission, Quality of Life and Management of
Living Resources Programme (QOL), Key Action 1 on
Food, Nutrition and Health, Contract Nos. QLK1-CT-
1999-00433 and QLK1-CT-1999-00996.
References
Ayerst G (1969) The effects of moisture and temperature on
growth and spore germination in some fungi. Journal of Stored
Product Research 5: 127–141
Cooke R and Whipps J (1993) Ecophysiology of Fungi.
Blackwell, Oxford
Dix DE (1984) Interactive binomics of the maize weevil,
Sitophilus zeamais Motchulsky, and Aspergillus flavus Link.
Ph.D. Thesis, University of Georgia, Athens, GA, USA,
129 pp
Dunkel F (1988) The relationship of insects to deteriora-
tion of stored grain by fungi. International Journal of Food
Microbiology 7: 227–244
730
Eugenio C, Delas Casas E, Harein PK and Mirocha CJ (1970)
Detection of the mycotoxins F-2 in the confused flour beetle
and the lesser mealworm. Journal of Economic Entomology
63: 412–415
Lacey J and Magan N (1991) Fungi colonising cereal grain:
Their occurrence and water and temperature relationships.
In: Chelkowski J (ed) Cereal Grain – Mycotoxins, Fungi
and Quality in Storage, Chapter 5 (pp 77–118) Elsevier,
Amsterdam
Lee HB and Magan N (1999) Environmental factors and nutri-
tional utlization patterns affect niche overlap indices between
Aspergillus ochraceus and other spoilage fungi. Letters in
Applied Microbiology 28: 300–304
Lee HB and Magan N (2000a) Environmental influences on in
vitro interspecific interactions between A. ochraceus and other
maize spoilage fungi on growth and ochratoxin production.
Mycopathologia 146: 43–47
Lee HB and Magan N (2000b) Impact of environment and inter-
specific interactions between spoilage fungi and Aspergillus
ochraceus and ochratoxin production on maize. International
Journal of Food Microbiology 61: 11–16
Magan N and Lacey J (1984) The effect of water activity, temper-
ature and substrate on interactions between field and storage
fungi. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 82:
83–93
Magan N and Lacey J (1985) Interactions between field and
storage fungi on wheat grain. Transactions of the British
Mycological Society 85: 29–37
Magan N and Lacey J (1986) The phylloplane microbial popula-
tions of wheat and effect of late fungicide applications. Annals
of Applied Biology 109: 117–128
Marin S, Sanchis V, Ramos AG and Magan N (1998a)
Environmental factors, interspecific interactions, and niche
overlap between Fusarium moniliforme and F. proliferatum
and Fusarium graminearum,Aspergillus and Penicillium spp.
isolated from maize Mycological Research 102: 831–837
Marin S, Sanchis V, Rull F, Ramos AJ and Magan N
(1998b) Colonisation of maize grain by F. moniliforme and
F. proliferatum in the presence of competing fungi and their
impact on fumonisin production. Journal of Food Protection
61: 1489–1496
Sauer DB, Storey CL and Walker DE (1984) Fungal populations
in US farming-stored grain and their relationship to moisture,
storage time, regions and insect infestation. Phytopathology
74: 1050–1053
Sinha RN (1971) Fungus as food for some stored product insects.
Journal of Economic Entomology 64: 3–6
Sinha, RN (1995) The stored-grain ecosystem. In: Jayas DS,
White NDG and Muir WE (eds) Stored Grain Ecosystems.
Marcell Dekker, New York, USA
Wallace HAH and Sinha RN (1981) Causal factors oper-
ative in distributional patterns and abundance of fungi:
A multivariate study; In: Wicklow DT and Carroll GC
(eds) The Fungal Community– Its Organisation and
Role in Ecosystems (pp 233–247) Marcell Dekker Inc.,
New York, USA
Willcock J and Magan N (2001) Impact of environmental fac-
tors on fungal respiration and dry matter losses in wheat straw.
Journal of Stored Product Research 37: 35–45
Wilson M and Lindow S (1994a) Coexistence among epiphytic
bacterial populations mediated through nutritional resource
partitioning. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 60:
4468–4477
Wilson M and Lindow S (1994b) Ecological similarity and
co-existence of epiphytic ice-nucleating (Ice+)Pseudomonas
syringae strains and a non-ice nucleating (Ice) biological
control agent. Applied and Environmental Microbiology 60:
3128–3137
Wright (1973) A model to study the effects of mycotoxins on
insects utilizing Tribolium confusum DuVal and metabolites
of Fusarium species. M.Sc. Thesis, University of Minnesota,
Minneapolis, MN, USA, 70 pp
... In contrast, A. terreus (47) and A. tubingensis (40) demonstrated smaller proportions at 13.12% and 11.17% of the total isolates, respectively. Aspergillus and Penicillium are the main storage fungi that commonly infect walnuts stored in unfavorable conditions, including elevated temperatures and moisture levels [33]. Based on these findings, we proposed that A. flavus is the dominant pathogenic fungus in walnuts stored in Shanxi, China. ...
Article
Full-text available
Walnuts are prone to contamination by rotting fungi. However, the microflora present in walnuts across various regions of China has not been thoroughly investigated. Cinnamon essential oil (CEO) is commonly used in food preservation because of its natural safety and strong antimicrobial properties. Additionally, studies on the antifungal potential of CEO to prevent walnut spoilage are limited. Therefore, we investigated Aspergillus spp. contamination in moldy walnuts stored across different locations in Shanxi, China. A total of 100 moldy walnut samples underwent traditional mycological analysis to isolate Aspergillus spp. The antibacterial properties and the mechanisms by which CEO targets Aspergillus spp. were thoroughly investigated. Five representative morphospecies were subsequently classified to the species level using Internal Transcribed Spacer sequence analysis. The dominant species were Aspergillus flavus and Aspergillus fumigatus, with frequencies of 100% and 93%, respectively, followed by Aspergillus nigers, Aspergillus terreus, and Aspergillus tubingensis, with frequencies of 78%, 47%, and 40%, respectively. Overall, 358 fungal species belonging to the Aspergillus genus were recovered. The MIC of CEO against A. flavus in vitro was 0.78 g/L. Furthermore, CEO compromised the permeability and integrity of the cell membrane, causing the leakage of intracellular components and promoting the accumulation of malondialdehyde compounds and a decrease in superoxide dismutase activity. Overall, we isolated and identified Aspergillus spp. in moldy walnuts and confirmed the feasibility of using CEO as a green anti-Aspergillus spp. agent for the preservation of walnuts.
... Fungal activity can cause undesirable effects in grain, including discolouration, and contribute to heating and losses in nutritional value. It can also produce off-odours and lead to losses in the germination and deterioration of baking and milling quality, ultimately resulting in mycotoxin contamination [23]. Fungal contamination of maize and wheat determined in this study is presented in Table 3. Maize samples were more severely contaminated than the wheat ones; the determined cfu/mL was 7.31 × 10 5 ± 2.16 × 10 6 and 1.06 × 10 4 ± 1.4 × 10 4 , respectively, although statistically significant difference failed to be observed (p > 0.05). ...
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this study was to establish the differences in fungi and mycotoxin contamination and mycobiota biodiversity between wheat and maize after harvesting. Determination of fungal contamination of wheat and maize is crucial, given that these grains are extensively used in food and feed production. Some moulds can produce toxic secondary metabolites, such as mycotoxins, which can cause serious health problems in humans and animals. Due to the metabolic activities of moulds, undesirable changes in food and feed colour, taste, and smell can occur. In this study, samples of wheat and maize, harvested during 2021 in the Northern Croatia, were analysed for mycological and mycotoxin contamination before storage. Also, potentially mycotoxigenic mould genera were identified at the species level in order to uncover the presence of toxigenic species. The presence of the following mycotoxins was examined: zearalenone, deoxynivalenol, ochratoxin, aflatoxin B1, T-2, and HT-2 toxin. The results indicate that both wheat and maize samples were contaminated with yeasts, with maize exhibiting a higher level of contamination as compared to wheat (1.5 × 10⁴ to 1.8 × 10⁶ vs 1.7 × 10³ to 9.0 × 10⁵). In wheat, the predominant mycotoxigenic mould species was Alternaria, as opposed to maize in which the Penicillium genus was the most represented. Mycotoxin analysis revealed that both maize and wheat were contaminated with Fusarium mycotoxins. Aflatoxin B1 and ochratoxin were not determined in any of the tested samples. The results point out that grains carry a different risk of contamination with Fusarium mycotoxins and that maize is more susceptible to fungus spoilage.
... Climatic factors, such as temperature, precipitation, and atmospheric CO 2 concentration, influence fungal colonization and mycotoxin production [69]. Therefore, fluctuations in these factors may lead to an increase/decrease in the relative risk of mycotoxin contamination during both field and postharvest cultivation. ...
Article
Full-text available
Currently, one of the main challenges is the mitigation of the effects of climate change on the agricultural sector. Conventional agriculture, with the intensive use of herbicides and pesticides to control weeds and pests, and the improper use of mineral fertilizers, contributes to climate change by causing increased greenhouse gases and groundwater pollution. Therefore, more innovative technologies must be used to overcome these problems. One possible solution is nanotechnology, which has the potential to revolutionize the conventional agricultural system. Active nanoparticles can be used both as a direct source of micronutrients and as a delivery platform for bioactive agrochemicals to improve crop growth, yield, and quality. The use of nanoparticle formulations, including nano-pesticides, nano-herbicides, nano-fertilizers, and nano-emulsions, has been extensively studied to improve crop health and shelf-life of agricultural products. Comprehensive knowledge of the interactions between plants and nanoparticles opens up new opportunities to improve cropping practices through the enhancement of properties such as disease resistance, crop yield, and nutrient use. The main objective of this review is to analyze the main effects of climate change on conventional agricultural practices, such as the use of pesticides, herbicides, and fertilizers. It also focuses on how the introduction of nanoparticles into conventional practices can improve the efficiency of chemical pest control and crop nutrition. Finally, this review examines in depth the last 10 years (2014–2024) of scientific literature regarding the use of nanoparticles in agriculture to mitigate the effects of climate change.
... As can be seen from the table, the amount of ergosterol was 42% higher when the maize weevil was present in treatments with fungi (but no sulcatone). These results are in agreement with previous studies that stated that the presence of insects may favor fungal infection of stored maize, either by damaging grains and making it more vulnerable to fungal attack, or by acting as fungal vectors [5,28,[51][52][53]. For example, Ferreira-Castro et al. [51] reported the ability of weevils to disseminate fungal spores from contaminated maize grains to uncontaminated grains, with the subsequent production of mycotoxins. ...
Article
Full-text available
Stored maize is frequently attacked by different pests, such as insects and microorganisms. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the bioactivities of sulcatone (6-methyl-5-hepten-2-one) against the maize weevil Sitophilus zeamais and the phytopathogenic fungi Fusarium verticillioides, Aspergillus flavus, and A. parasiticus. Sulcatone showed a strong repellent effect with a maximum value of −92.1 ± 3.2% at 40 µM in two-choice olfactometer bioassays and an LC95 value of 17.2 µL/L air (95% 16.5–18.1) in a fumigant toxicity experiment. The antifungal effect of sulcatone was evaluated through the fumigant method, reporting MIC values of 3.5, 3.8, and 3.9 mM for F. verticillioides, A. parasiticus, and A. flavus, respectively. Additionally, a silo-bag experiment containing all pests was conducted to evaluate the potential use of sulcatone in a real storage system. Sulcatone caused 71.69 ± 1.57% weevil mortality in silo-bags and proved to be effective as a fungicidal and antimycotoxigenic agent since both ergosterol and fumonisin B1 content were significantly reduced by 60% in silo-bags containing sulcatone. This study demonstrated that sulcatone has the potential to be used for the control of both insects and fungi of stored maize, without affecting the germination of grains.
... Some of these secondary pests are also known to be mold or fungal feeders, contaminating grains through their presence and metabolic wastes [21]. This contamination can lead to moistureladen conditions, including excretion and condensed heat, fostering mold development [22]. ...
Article
Approximately 10% to 30% of the stored agricultural produce is damaged out of which 26% is due to insect-pest infestation thus seriously impacting the food security. The infestation also leads to loss of quality and thereby affecting the overall profitability. In absence of enough storage space, usually farmers dispose-off their produce immediately after harvest and thus do not get remunerative prices. For those opting for storage, physical and chemical methods are in vogue to manage the storage insect-pests. Fumigation with chemical pesticides such as methyl bromide and aluminium phosphide is a common method, though it has its own health and environmental risks. Inhalation of phosphine gas released when aluminium phosphide is used could seriously affect human animal health, sometimes leading to deaths. Thus for using these fumigants, strict supervision of government recognized experts is required. Due to their wide usage, some insect-pests have developed resistance against these molecules. Nanotechnology has created numerous new opportunities in agriculture and allied sectors. Insecticide formulations based on nanotechnology could be a viable alternative to toxic chemicals like aluminium phosphide to manage storage insect-pests. In recent years, a variety of formulations including solid nanopesticides, controlled-release formulations, nano-emulsions, and nano-suspensions have been developed possessing different modes of actions and applications. Their small size is a significant advantage because it provides higher insect-body surface area coverage and thus enhanced efficacy as compared to traditional pesticides. Aside from their small size, they are reported to be safe for non-target beneficial organisms. Nano-pesticides can thus prove as effective and eco-friendly alternatives for insect pest control in storage. However, there is a need to establish their safety on the human and animal ecosystems to rule out their ecological hazards over time. In absence of such information, nanopesticides will not be widely accepted despite their other beneficial effects. In this article, an effort is made to review the current status of nano-formulations for the management of storage-insect-pests, the research and extension gaps and ways to bridge the gaps to ensure safe use of the technology for efficient management of postharvest storage losses.
... Fungi produce mycotoxins under stress conditions, primarily temperature stress, or to combat external agents, such as fungicides. Magan et al. (2003) reported that the ideal conditions for deoxynivalenol production occurred at an average temperature of 25 ℃ and that it was significantly greater at this temperature than at 15 ℃, which may have contributed to the low mycotoxin levels in this study, as the average temperature of all treatments during the experimental period was 15.9 ℃. Noteworthy, the higher initial temperature measured on the WBG on day 0 might have been influenced by its temperature at arrival, because WBG were delivered from the brewing industry at high temperature. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study investigated the occurrence of mycotoxins in wet brewers’ grains (WBG) treated with salt (sodium chloride) and the intake, nutrient digestibility, and nitrogen use efficiency in lamb diets. Two experiments were conducted: first, WBG was distributed in plastic boxes and treated with no additive (control), sodium formate (3 g/kg of WBG), or three levels of salt—25, 30, and 35 g/kg of WBG. The WBG were stored at room temperature (17.7±4.6 ℃) for 27 days. In the second experiment, eight six-month-old male lambs were allotted to one of four total mixed ration (TMR) diets in a 4 × 4 double Latin square: 0, 10, 20, and 30% of WBG replacing corn silage and soybean meal. In the first experiment, the concentration of mycotoxins throughout the experiment was lower than the tolerance levels accepted by the European Community and Food and Drug Administration for animal feedstuffs. However, the control and sodium formate groups showed visual fungal development on the WBG surface from the sixth day and presented an unpleasant smell from day 12. In the salt treatments, fungal growth was observed on top of the WBG from day 12 and an unpleasant smell from day 15. Salt-treated WBG showed a lower pH than the control and sodium formate groups and decreased dry matter deterioration. In the second experiment, including up to 30% WBG in the TMR did not affect dry matter, organic matter, neutral detergent fiber, and acid detergent fiber intake or digestibility in lambs. However, the N digestibility and N use efficiency increased with WBG inclusion. These results suggest that salt can be used to increase the storage time of WBG up to 15 days and the inclusion of up to 30% WBG in TMR for lambs can improve N use efficiency without negatively affecting nutrient intake and digestibility. agroindustrial waste; digestibility; intake; mycotoxin
Chapter
In India, approximately 10–30% of the stored agricultural produce is damaged out of which 26% is due to insect-pest infestation thus seriously impacting the food security. The infestation also leads to loss of quality and thereby affecting the overall profitability. In absence of enough storage space, usually farmers dispose-off their produce immediately after harvest and thus do not get remunerative prices. For those opting for storage, physical and chemical methods are in vogue to manage the storage insect-pests. Fumigation with chemical pesticides such as methyl bromide and aluminium phosphide is a common method, though it has its own health and environmental risks. Inhalation of phosphine gas released when aluminium phosphide is used could seriously affect human animal health, sometimes leading to deaths. Thus for using these fumigants, strict supervision of government recognized experts is required. Due to their wide usage, some insect-pests have developed resistance against these molecules. Nanotechnology has created numerous new opportunities in agriculture and allied sectors. Insecticide formulations based on nanotechnology could be a viable alternative to toxic chemicals like aluminium phosphide to manage storage insect-pests. In recent years, a variety of formulations including solid nanopesticides, controlled-release formulations, nano-emulsions, and nano-suspensions have been created possessing various ways of actions and applications. Their small size is a significant advantage because it provides higher insect-body surface area coverage and thus enhanced efficacy as compared to traditional pesticides. Aside from their small size, they are reported to be safe for non-target beneficial organisms. Nano-pesticides can thus prove as effective and eco-friendly alternatives for insect pest control in storage. However, there is a need to establish their safety on the human and animal ecosystems to rule out their ecological hazards over time. In absence of such information, nanopesticides will not be widely accepted despite their other beneficial effects. In this book chapter, an effort is made to review the current status of nano-formulations for the control of pest insects in storage, the research and extension gaps and ways to bridge the gaps to ensure safe use of the technology for efficient management of postharvest storage losses.
Article
Full-text available
Mycotoxins are a major threat to animal and human health, as well as to the global feed supply chain. Among them, aflatoxins, fumonisins, zearalenone, T-2 toxins, deoxynivalenol, and Alternaria toxins are the most common mycotoxins found in animal feed, with genotoxic, cytotoxic, carcinogenic, and mutagenic effects that concern the animal industry. The chronic negative effects of mycotoxins on animal health and production and the negative economic impact on the livestock industry make it crucial to develop and implement solutions to mitigate mycotoxins. In this review, we summarize the current knowledge of the mycotoxicosis effect in livestock animals as a result of their contaminated diet. In addition, we discuss the potential of five promising phytogenics (curcumin, silymarin, grape pomace, olive pomace, and orange peel extracts) with demonstrated positive effects on animal performance and health, to present them as potential anti-mycotoxin solutions. We describe the composition and the main promising characteristics of these bioactive compounds that can exert beneficial effects on animal health and performance, and how these phytogenic feed additives can help to alleviate mycotoxins’ deleterious effects.
Article
The mycotoxin, F-2, produced by the fungus Fusarium roseum var. graminearum Snyder & Hansen was ingested and retained by the confused flour beetle, Tribolium confusum Jacquelin du Val, and the lesser mealworm, Alphitobius diaperinus (Panzer). F-2 persisted in the insects through metamorphosis and was detected after starvation and death. The amount of F-2 recovered from the insects increased with increasing 1-2 concentrations in the insect culture media.
Article
Nine species of stored-product insects representing 8 genera in 6 families of Coleoptera and I genus of Psocoptera were exposed to 23 species of seed-borne fungi and I actinomycete cultures on potato-sugar agar in the laboratory. Some feeding by all 9 species was observed on Cladosporium cladosporioides (Fresenius) de Vries, Nigrospora sphaerica (Saccardo) Mason, and Alternaria alternate (Fries) Keissler. Most insects rejected Streptomyces gri- seus (Krainsky) Waksman and Henrici, Cochliobolus sativus (Ito and Kurib.) Drechsler ex Dastur, and Asper gilles spp. The granary weevil, Sitophilus granarius (L.); and the lesser grain borer, Rhyzopertha dominica (F.), fed lightly on a few but failed to reproduce on any microorganism. The psocid Lepinotus reticulates (Enderlein) and the beetles Lathridius minutus (L.) and Microgramma arga (Reitter) were the most successful fungivores.
Article
Flag leaves and ears of spring wheat cv. Timmo (in 1980) and winter wheat cv. Maris Huntsman in 1981 and 1982 were colonised by a variety of micro-organisms whose numbers increased rapidly between anthesis and harvest. The predominant mycoflora were yeasts, yeast-like fungi and filamentous fungi which included Cladosporium spp., Verticillium lecanii, Alternaria alternata, Fusarium spp. and Epicoccum nigrum. Although similar species were isolated, their relative abundance on flag leaves and ears differed. The fungicide captafol was most effective as a protectant and significantly decreased populations of fungi on flag leaves and ears for 6 and 4 wk respectively, compared to untreated controls. Benomyl and Delsene M (carbendazim + maneb) were the most effective of the systemic sprays and formulations. In general, fungicides affected populations of yeasts, yeast-like fungi and Cladosporium spp. most while Alternaria was tolerant of all treatments. Yields of winter wheat were increased in two seasons by an average 0–2 t ha-1 (2–4%) following a single late fungicide treatment at G.S. 50 or 60 and 0–41 t ha-1 (5-1%) when this was combined with an early spray against foliar diseases (G.S. 38–40). Individual treatments increased yield by up to 12% with little difference between applications at G.S. 50 or 60. The yield benefit came mainly from increased 1000-grain weights. Germination of the treated grain was increased only slightly.
Article
Field and storage fungi demonstrated a wide range of interactions on malt and wheat extract agars. A numerical Index of Dominance ({itI{ind}}) was derived for individual fungi. This was found to vary with water activity ({itaw}), temperature and substrate. Epicoccum nigrum and Fusarium culmorum were the only field fungi that competed successfully against other fungi on both substrates while Alternaria alternata, Cladosporium species and Verticilliutn lecanii were all uncompetitive, intermingling freely with many Aspergillus and Penicillium spp. Of the Penicillium spp., P. brevicompactum and P. hordei were most dominant although P. verrucosum var. cyclopium and P. roquefortii were favoured by malt and wheat extract, respectively. P. piceum competed well against both field and storage fungi but only at 30 °C. A. candidus and A. nidulans were the most competitive of the Aspergillus spp. but only at 25 and 30° while A. fumigatus was competitive at 30° only. A. repens and A. versicolor were uncompetitive regardless of {itaw}.Variations in temperatures between 15 and 30° were accompanied by changes in {itI{ind}} scores. Total {itI{ind}} scores of the most dominant fungi were usually lower on wheat extract than on the richer malt agar.Detailed microscopic examination of the interaction zones revealed granulation and vacuolation of hyphal cells and increased branching but no changes in permeability of the affected cells, loss of metabolic activity or cell death.
Article
The effects of different water activities (aw) and temperatures on interaction between groups of field fungi, Aspergillus and Penicillium spp. on wheat grain were measured using direct and dilution plating. Numbers of individual species isolated and the percentage of grain contaminated changed considerably during a four week incubation period. At the end of this period, the relative abundance of each species did not correspond well with that predicted using a numerical Index of Dominance (ID) derived from studies in vitro.When wheat grains were inoculated with different field fungi and incubated for four weeks, Fusarium culmorum became dominant and contaminated most grains at all temperatures (15–30 °C) and 0 · 99 and 0 · 95 aws although the in vitro ID was large only at 15°. Epicoccum nigrum, which had a high in vitro ID at all temperatures, did not compete well on wheat grain at any temperature, while Alternaria alternata which had a low ID, contaminated up to 50% grain after four weeks storage. Of the Aspergillus spp., A. versicolor was dominant at all temperatures and aws tested (0 · 95 and 0 · 90) although it competed poorly in culture. A. repens and A. candidus were also present at 15° and A. nidulans at 25–30† and 0 · 95–0 · 90 aw. The dominance of Penicillium hordei on wheat grain corresponded well with its ID at 15–25° and 0 · 95 aw but less well at 0 · 90 aw. P. piceum was seldom isolated at 15° but was most numerous at 30°. P. verrucosum var. cyclopium (P. aurantiogriseum) and P. brevicompactum competed well at 15–25° and 0 · 95–0 · 90 aw. When groups of Aspergillus and Penicillium spp. were inoculated together on wheat grain, A. versicolor and P. hordei became dominant at 15–25° and 0 · 95 and 0 · 90 aw, while at 30° A. nidulans and A. repens were also numerous.
Article
The effects of temperature and water availability on growth and interactions between fumonisin-producing isolates of Fusarium moniliforme and F. proliferatum and seven other fungi from maize grain were determined in vitro. The type of interaction and index dominance (Id) between species were markedly influenced by temperature and aw. Generally, F. moniliforme and F. proliferatum were very competitive and dominant against the Penicillium spp. and A. flavus. They were in turn dominated by A. niger, but mutually antagonistic when paired with F. graminearum and A. ochraceus. Under slightly drier conditions (<0.98aw) A. ochraceus became more competitive and dominant over the fumonisin-producing species. A. flavus was dominant only at 30°C and <0.96aw. F. moniliforme and F. proliferatum demonstrated dominance against all species over a range of temperatures and 0.994 to 0.96aw. At lower aw levels they were less competitive. The growth rate of the two fumonisin-producing species was significantly reduced by F. graminearum, regardless of aw. F. moniliforme and F. proliferatum reduced growth of Penicillium and Aspergillus spp., especially at > 0.96 aw. At < 0.96 aw, growth of these species was unaffected. Using Biolog plates the effect of aw and temperature on utilization patterns of carbon sources in maize were evaluated for the first time. The niche overlap indices relative to F. moniliforme and F. proliferatum were determined and compared with that of each interacting species. NOIs for F. moniliforme and F. proliferatum were > 0.90 at > 0.96aw and 25 and 30°, indicative of co-existence with other species. Most of species had NOIs > 0.90, except in some cases when paired with F. moniliforme, where NOIs < 0.80 suggested the occupation of different niches. Although there was no significant correlation between the Id and NOI methods both suggested that the niche overlap between species was in a state of flux and significantly influenced by both temperature and water availability. This suggests that interpretation of Id NOIs carried out under one set of environmental conditions may be misleading when considering interactions between species and also where screening for biocontrol potential is being considered.
Article
The delays in germination and subsequent growth rates of thirty isolates from twelve species of Aspergillus, three species of Penicillium and Stachybotrys atra were measured throughout the ranges of water activity and temperature which permitted growth. There were marked differences between species in their temperature and water activity optima and limits but the differences between isolates of individual species were small. All the isolates were most tolerant of low water activity at temperatures close to the optimum but in some species the optimum and maximum temperatures were higher at reduced water activity.