Dairy heifer growth and live weight at first calving are regarded as important management variables affecting profitability and animal welfare. However, the appropriateness of heifer growth rate targets for different farming systems is not clear. Retrospective assessments of the association between heifer live weight and subsequent productivity indicate significant benefits in milk production and, even, reproduction from increasing live weight at breeding and first calving. Prospective interventionist experiments do not concur, however, with very variable effects of live weight at breeding on milk production and only limited evidence of a positive effect of first calving live weight on first lactation milk yield. In addition, any benefit in the first lactation is not evident in subsequent lactations in the limited number of long-term studies reported. Pre-weaning nutrition and average daily weight gain are areas of increasing interest, with lifelong increases in milk production resulting from accelerated growth rates during the first eight weeks of life indicating possible significant return from a short-term investment. This could be one reason for the inconsistent effects of heifer live weight at breeding and first lactation on milk production. Although the effect of pre-weaning average daily gain on heifer live weight is short-lived, a recent meta-analysis indicates that pre-weaning average daily gain explains 22% of the variation in first lactation milk production. The validity of these results in grazing systems requires investigation. Despite considerable extension efforts over successive decades, current evidence indicates that failure to provide the new-born calf with sufficient high quality colostrum is common. To understand the reasons for suboptimal colostrum feeding requires social research, with appropriate extension strategies developed to elicit practice change. Although there can be little doubt regarding the importance of heifer rearing to the profitability and sustainability of the farming business, the collective literature points to a failure of retrospective analyses in determining the cause of poor heifer performance. In reality, it is likely to be a combination of factors. The most likely nutritional factors are discussed in this review. BACKGROUND Dairy heifer growth rate and live weight (Lwt) at first calving are regarded as important benchmarks in farm management (Sejrsen and Purup, 1997) because lower Lwt heifers are at a greater risk of dystocia at first calving (Mee et al. 2008), produce less milk, and have a shorter lifespan in the herd (Archbold et al. 2012, McNaughton and Lopdell 2013). Also, greater heifer growth rates can theoretically lead to an earlier breeding event and reduce the time that the heifer spends in a non-productive state (Capuco et al. 1995, Sejrsen and Purup 1997). However, there is evidence that excessive growth rates at key periods of development are associated with impaired mammary development and reduced milk production (Harrison et al. 1983, Sejrsen et al. 1983, Sejrsen and Purup 1997). Therefore, the rate of growth must be planned to ensure that heifers become productive early, without undermining lifetime productivity. To complicate matters, recommendations on optimum first-calving Lwt vary widely. In high concentrate intensive feeding systems, Holstein-Friesian cows achieve 550 to 650 kg of Lwt before first calving (Keown and Everett, 1986; Heinrichs, 1993; Hoffman, 1997), while a more modest first-calving Lwt is accepted in pasture-based systems for the same breed (450 to 550 kg; McLean and Freeman 1996, Holmes et al. 2002). Troccon (1993) recommended that a heifer's Lwt at first calving should be 90% of her mature Lwt. However, how should mature Lwt be determined? The average of the herd does not account for the heifer's individual genetics and is heavily influenced by the environment in which the herd is managed. In addition, (Archbold et al. 2012) reported that low Lwt heifers at 15 months remained low Lwt heifers at first calving and as cows up to at least their third lactation. In fact, in their dataset, all heifers were 85% of their five year old Lwt at first calving, irrespective of the quartile of 15 month Lwt they belonged to; herd mature Lwt could, therefore, be a function of historical heifer growth trajectory and projecting heifer growth on data from cows that were poorly grown as heifers