ArticlePDF Available

Abstract and Figures

There is a vast body of literature on school size but comparatively few high quality empirical studies comparing outcomes in schools of different sizes. This systematic review synthesizes the results of the published research from 31 studies on the effects of secondary school size from OECD countries since 1990. Overall the directions and patterns of effect vary for different outcomes. For pupil attainment measured by exam results, and for attendance, larger schools appear to do better up to some optimal school size but estimates of this point or range are insufficiently precise to be useful. The implications of different school sizes on student behaviours are equivocal, but teachers and pupils at smaller schools are more likely to have a positive perception of their ‘school environment’. Costs per pupil appear to decrease as school size increases. The results of the review suggest that there is little empirical evidence to justify policies that aim to ‘change’ or mandate particular school sizes. However, given the evidence that there do appear to be optimal sizes for some outcomes, stakeholders should be made aware that dramatic changes in a school's size may change the characteristics of a school's learning environment.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... El ejercicio del liderazgo escolar varía según el contexto y una característica que da forma al contexto es el tamaño del establecimiento (Southworth, 2002;Leithwood & Riehl, 2003;Leithwood et al., 2019). El tamaño del colegio tiene un efecto directo en resultados tales como desempeño académico, bienestar escolar, sentido de pertenencia, cohesión social, seguridad, participación, ausentismo escolar, deserción escolar y actitudes sobre uno mismo y la escuela (Andrews, Duncombe & Yinger, 2002;Newman et al., 2006;Leithwood & Jantzi, 2009;Scheerens, Hendriks & Luyten, 2014). Esta es una característica que puede afectar en el ASE de los estudiantes en un establecimiento. ...
... En otras evaluaciones del impacto de programas de ASE se controla la variable de tamaño del colegio para la comparación entre establecimientos (Hagelskamp et al., 2013;Schonfeld et al., 2015). Otro resultado relevante es que la percepción sobre el clima escolar parece ser más positiva en colegios pequeños (Newman et al., 2006). ...
Article
Full-text available
En los últimos años ha surgido una amplia evidencia del impacto de programas de aprendizaje socioemocional (ASE) universales y basados en evidencia, que se implementan en educación parvularia, básica y media. El proceso de implementación es uno de los factores más importantes en el impacto de los programas y los líderes educativos ejercen un rol clave en apoyar la puesta en práctica del programa en sus contextos. Este artículo presenta un estudio de casos múltiple de dos escuelas de distinto tamaño que implementan el programa de ASE Trabün. A través de entrevistas individuales y grupales se buscó establecer las principales diferencias en los factores que afectan la implementación y las estrategias que realizan directores y encargados del programa para apoyar la puesta en práctica del programa en sus escuelas. Los resultados señalan que existen diferencias en el compromiso y motivación de directores, disposición y apertura de docentes, comunicación entre actores, clima laboral y estrategias de apoyo y monitoreo a la implementación del programa. Las conclusiones sugieren importantes implicancias a las escuelas y organizaciones que proveen programas educativos en la gestión de la comunicación y diversificación de estrategias de apoyo y monitoreo a la implementación del programa en escuelas con distinto tamaño.
... However, it also has to be considered that our secondary outcomes (job strain and school climate) might be influenced by several school characteristics, even more than by the implementation fidelity of the OBPP. For example, school climate appears to be more positive in smaller schools, with more personalized relationships between teachers and pupils and a bigger feeling of safety (Cotton, 2001;Newman et al., 2006). Teachers in smaller schools tended to have more positive perceptions of their abilities to influence school norms, and to control their classrooms (Garrett et al., 2004), which might contribute to less job strain. ...
Article
Full-text available
Although teachers are key figures of a program’s effectiveness, most intervention studies to date have not explored how anti-bullying programs are associated with changes at teacher level. Moreover, teacher data also informs about aspects of program implementation, which are essential in program evaluations. Therefore, the aim of this study was to gain insight into the perspectives of teachers working with the Olweus Bullying Prevention Program (OBPP). A scientific evaluation of the OBPP was carried out in 21 German schools. In addition to annual student surveys, regular teacher surveys were conducted. Ordered logistic regressions and linear regressions were used to estimate the variables. As we expected a dosage-response effect, we divided the schools by level of implementation (non-completer, completer, and certified Olweus schools). At baseline, 615 teachers took part in the assessment (68.26%), and 388 teachers at postline 2 years later (47.32%). A positive change in teachers’ intention to intervene in bullying could be found across all schools (p < .001), which was only significant for completer (p < .001) and certified schools (p = .004) when differentiated by implementation level. Teachers’ level of job strain did not change at all (non-significant model fit), while an improvement in school climate only emerged for certified schools (p = .003). The moderating effect of the implementation level turned out to be independent of different school characteristics. The self-reported changes at the teacher level depended on the level of program implementation. Therefore, it is essential to record data about the intensity of program activities when evaluating a program. Trial registration number: DRKS00008202 (date of registration: 08/04/2015).
... We leveraged a school-based longitudinal cohort called the Project Tal 24 We cre- ...
Article
Full-text available
We leveraged a unique school-based longitudinal cohort-the Project Talent Aging Study-to examine whether attending higher quality schools is associated with cognitive performance among older adults in the United States (mean age = 74.8). Participants (n = 2,289) completed telephone neurocognitive testing. Six indicators of high school quality, reported by principals at the time of schooling, were predictors of respondents' cognitive function 58 years later. To account for school-clustering, multilevel linear and logistic models were applied. We found that attending schools with a higher number of teachers with graduate training was the clearest predictor of later-life cognition, and school quality mattered especially for language abilities. Importantly, Black respondents (n = 239; 10.5 percentage) were disproportionately exposed to low quality high schools. Therefore, increased investment in schools, especially those that serve Black children, could be a powerful strategy to improve later life cognitive health among older adults in the United States.
... 3 Decisions about which information to record will be made by the review team based on the review question and conceptual framework. For example, a systematic review about the relationship between school size and student outcomes collected data from the primary studies about each schools funding, students, teachers and school organisational structure as well as about the research methods used in the study (Newman et al. 2006). The information coded about the methods used in the research will vary depending on the type of research included and the approach that will be used to assess the quality and relevance of the studies (see the next section for further discussion of this point). ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
... For example, Driscoll et al., (2003) investigating the impact of school size in students' performance in California indicated a negative correlation. In contrast, Kantabutra and Tang, (2006) focusing on rural-urban characteristic indicated that in both areas school size had positive effect in students' performance while Newman et al., (2006) in a cross-country study revealed the complexity of school size effects, suggesting the pursuit of the optimal school size. In the same direction, Bloom et al. (2010) analyzing educational reform in New York City after 2002, Schwartz et al., (2013 that examined the same reform concluded that new small schools increased students' educational outcomes and Humlum and Smith (2015) indicated a positive effect on students' performance and graduation rate. ...
Article
Full-text available
Advocates for education reforms frequently call for policies to increase school efficiency performance. The Greek educational system has undergone several reforms while the recent financial crisis alters significantly. Using a unique dataset this study attempts to shed light on 643 Greek secondary education schools’ efficiency performance, over the period 2000–2017, and to perform an investigation of the efficiency determinants in a multilevel framework. Results reveal that there is substantial room for improvements especially for specific Greek NUTS2 regions while the adopted reforms seem to have a very low effect. Our findings also denote a favourable effect for physics, science laboratories, and class size and a significant negative effect for the variable of student per class. In addition, at a second level the gross domestic product per capita of the NUTS2 region that each school belongs positively affects its efficiency performance.
... We included school size because a vast body of literature has found that it might be related to student achievement, although the direction of the relationship is not entirely clear and may depend on various factors (e.g., Newman et al. 2006;Ready, Lee, and Welner 2004). Meanwhile, single-sex schools in Poland, because they are rare and nonmainstream, tend to be smaller than the coed ones. ...
Article
Free copies available here: https://www.tandfonline.com/eprint/8EDBAW3PQDPQED8FWVRZ/full?target=10.1080/02671522.2021.1886318 . This study inquired into the effect of single-sex schooling on achievement of female adolescents. It used national examination data of 4,787 Polish female students (10 cohorts) attending single-sex and co-educational Catholic schools. We tested two sets of partially contradictory predictions derived from two different theoretical models explaining how and why achievement of female students in the two types of school may differ. The results of cross-classified random-effects regression models showed that after controlling for initial student and school differences female adolescents attending all-girls schools scored higher on the lower-secondary school exam in science and the humanities in comparison to those who attended co-educational schools. However, the difference was statistically significant only for science. The results were fully consistent with neither of the two adopted theoretical models, although provided more support for the one drawing upon peer effects. Although the effect of 17% of the exam scores standard deviation could be considered small, it appeared in the results of a high-stakes exam. Since the examination results were the main criterion for admission to the next-stage school, attending an all-girls school might significantly affect future educational career and job opportunities of young women. Free full text: https://www.tandfonline.com/eprint/8EDBAW3PQDPQED8FWVRZ/full?target=10.1080/02671522.2021.1886318
... Studies (Leithwood, Jantzi, 2009;Bellibas et al., 2016) have shown that in smaller schools there is a greater sense of community between teachers and that smaller schools provide more interaction and participation opportunities for teachers (Newman et al., 2006). ...
Article
Full-text available
Romanian educational system is in a constant search for reform, due to one of the highest rates of students` underachievement in basic skills and lack of qualified teachers among EU member states. It is well established that professional learning communities (PLCs) can be a solution for both problems, aiming to enhance students` results by teacher collaboration in learning and professional development. This study aims to determine the specificity of Romanian PLCs in relation with some contextual factors - school size, school environment (urban or rural), type of school (general or special school), professional development procedures at school level, and the individual factors that can impact the PLC, represented by teachers` personality structure. To answer the research question, reflecting on what contextual and individual factors determine the specificity of PLCs, two online questionnaires and a demographic survey were distributed to teachers across Romania. First, the School Professional Staff as Learning Community Questionnaire (SPSLCQ) was validated on the 253 participants, the original five-factor structure of SPSLCQ adequately fit the sample and proved to be a reliable instrument in the Romanian population. The results showed the Romanian PLCs` do not significantly differ from other countries: the most representative PLC dimension is shared vision, the organizational factor which explains best the PLC is the existence of strong at-school-level professional development procedures. School size best describes the differences between PLCs, but they do not differ in terms of the school environment and school type. The personality factor that correlates the most with PLC is conscientiousness, but the correlation is non-significant. These results suggest that for functionally stronger PLCs, the school should implement professional development procedures at the school level, based on collaboration and mutual learning in small groups of teachers.
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of the present study was to understand students’ school readiness as a function of student and teacher behaviors but also school size and class size using both linear and non-linear analytical approaches. Data came from 21,903 schools distributed across 80 countries as per the 2018 cohort of the PISA database. Results pointed to a preference for the Cusp model in that the relationship between school and class sizes with achievement proved to be best described by the non-linearity of the Cusp catastrophe model. The critical benchmarks were a school size of 801 students and a class size of 27 students for which increases beyond those thresholds were linked to nonlinearity and unpredictability in school readiness. For this reason, we suggest using the cusp catastrophe model from Nonlinear Dynamical Systems Theory (NDST) to understand more fully such complex phenomena.
Chapter
This chapter measures technical efficiency scores (TE) of government and government-aided schools for secondary education in Kolkata using primary survey data, collected through multistage stratified random sampling procedure, employing data envelopment analysis and obtains the determinants of such TE. It is evident that about 52% of the sample schools are not perfectly efficient, implying that these schools can produce more output with existing resources, and the magnitude of TE varies among the schools. It is observed that a huge percentage of students undertake private tuition which may affect TE. Thus, to find out the determinants of TE, the paper considers the effect of (i) percentage number of students taking private tuition, (ii) the role of the headmaster/mistress (HM), (iii) the characteristics of the HM, (iv) the characteristics of the teachers, (v) school infrastructure and administration related variables, (vi) school characteristics and student composition-related variables, (vii) policy-related variables, (viii) socio-economic background of the students, (ix) quality of school attributes based on student’s perceptions. The results support that the TE is positively related to the percentage number of students taking private tuition and the part of the variation of TE which is not explained by the percentage number of students taking private tuition is low; it ranges from 1.5 to 23.8%, with mean value 8.28%. Further, TE is negatively and significantly related to service experience of headmaster/mistress (HM) and full time teachers, meaning that schools with relatively junior HM and junior teachers will have higher TE. TE is positively related to (a) the role of the HM in school management, i.e., while taking any policy decision whether HM interacts with students and teachers, and also the interaction between this variable with the variable specifying the frequency of interaction of HM with State Education Department; the existence of interaction term implies, given the value of one variable, TE will in turn depend on the value of the other, showing the importance of the both, (b) school infrastructure variables, i.e., whether Librarian of the school is on duty, (c) policy variable like (i) the proportion of students getting Kanyashree (an initiative taken by the government of West Bengal to improve the life and status of girls by helping economically backward families with cash transfer so that they do not arrange for the marriage of the girls before eighteen years), where nonlinear inverted U-shaped relationship between the proportion of students getting Kanyashree and TE is obtained, with positive marginal effect for the present sample, implying that an increase in Kanyashree will boost up TE and (ii) on the availability of government fund to the schools, (d) the school characteristics, student composition, and students characteristics-related variables like the class size as represented by the number of sections in the class, the proportion of reserved category students, and the proportion of students having text book at their home.KeywordsEfficiency analysis of secondary educationGovernment and government-aided schoolsData envelopment analysisPrimary survey dataKolkataIndia
Article
A study context related to social communications in restructured school environments frames this investigation of social communications skills of principals. Responses of 709 public school principals to the Social Skills Inventory (SSI) constitute the data source. The instrument, a self-report inventory demonstrating positive relationships with several measures of social effectiveness, yields a global indicator of social skills defined as social competence. Results suggested generally marginal social skills among these principals. Positive associations were found between social competence and gender (female), higher levels of education, larger school size, urban school locus, and administrative decisional autonomy. Older, more experienced respondents with more extended positional longevity and tenure as administrators revealed significantly lower social communications skills as measured by the SSI. Findings are discussed in terms of the stewardship role of the principal, and the need for social skills training for work in open systems with multiple stakeholders.
Article
The effects of school size on 945 middle school students' perceptions of school satisfaction, teacher support, and school safety were examined using data from a national probability sample of middle and high school students. Students in schools with enrollments of 800 or more scored lower than students in smaller schools on the three school environment variables. The findings suggest that the negative relationship between school size and student outcomes documented in the literature may be the result of the detrimental effect of high enrollments on the school environment. Implications for school social work interventions are discussed.
Article
Recent debate has centered on the role ofmiddle schools in rural areas. While some policymakers have focused on the organizational aspects of middle schools, especially those characteristics that have defined middle schools in cities and suburbs, others have focused on creating optimal learning environments with attention to curriculum, instruction, and assessment. In this article, community-based and consolidated school organizations are analyzed and suggestions made about he most appropriate setting for young adolescents in rural communities.
Article
To investigate school size effects for secondary schools, 18 school outcomes, including the average scores on state-developed tests, student retention, suspensions, postschool employment, and college attendance for 293 public secondary schools in New Jersey were regressed on 23 school characteristics, including district socioeconomic status and percentages of students from low-income families; school size and number of schools within each district; and teacher characteristics encompassing salaries, degree status, and years of experience. District socioeconomic status and the percentage of students from low-income families in the school were the most influential and consistent factors related to schooling outcomes. School size was the next most consistent and was negatively related to outcomes. This finding corroborates previous research conducted primarily on public elementary school and suggests that smaller school districts and smaller schools, regardless of socioeconomic status and grade level, may be more efficient at enhancing educational outcomes.
Article
The study examined the relationship of enrollment size (200-1500) to teachers' and students' attitudes toward school and the self concepts of students in selected middle schools and junior high schools in the States of Idaho, Utah and Wyoming. Middle school teachers were found to favor small schools, and junior high tearchers large schools. Student attitude toward school and self concept were not found to correlate with size.