ArticlePDF Available

Coastal sensitivity to environmental change: A view from the beach

Authors:
  • University of Glasgow, Scotland

Abstract and Figures

The coastal environment is home to a range of landforms and landscapes that include those at either end of the sensitivity scale. The soft coastal landscapes of beaches, sand dunes, and mudflats represent fast-responding and mobile geomorphic systems that are highly sensitive to environmental change. On the other hand, coastal landscapes in areas of hard rock and inherited Quaternary deposits represent relatively slow-responding systems that are, in the main, thought to be relatively insensitive to change. This paper focuses upon both groups of systems and demonstrates not only how soft coasts respond to environmental stimuli over a variety of time scales but also how this inheritance shapes subsequent development. Using mainly Scottish soft coast examples, the changes associated with sensitive coastal landscapes are assessed in terms of the past timing and magnitude of changes in both sea level and sediment economy. Declining abundance of coastal sediment has initiated a process of internal re-organisation that, because of an inherent sensitivity to sea level change and low thresholds for the forcing of change, fundamentally restricts future management options. The paper also attempts to show that hard rock coasts are also responsive to particular types of event on short time scales and examples are discussed that modify the accepted view of hard rock insensitivity to environmental change.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Ž.
Catena 42 2001 291–305 www.elsevier.comrlocatercatena
Coastal sensitivity to environmental change: a view
from the beach
J.D. Hansom)
Department of Geography and Topographic Science, UniÕersity of Glasgow, Glasgow G12 8QQ Scotland, UK
Abstract
The coastal environment is home to a range of landforms and landscapes that include those at
either end of the sensitivity scale. The soft coastal landscapes of beaches, sand dunes, and
mudflats represent fast-responding and mobile geomorphic systems that are highly sensitive to
environmental change. On the other hand, coastal landscapes in areas of hard rock and inherited
Quaternary deposits represent relatively slow-responding systems that are, in the main, thought to
be relatively insensitive to change. This paper focuses upon both groups of systems and
demonstrates not only how soft coasts respond to environmental stimuli over a variety of time
scales but also how this inheritance shapes subsequent development. Using mainly Scottish soft
coast examples, the changes associated with sensitive coastal landscapes are assessed in terms of
the past timing and magnitude of changes in both sea level and sediment economy. Declining
abundance of coastal sediment has initiated a process of internal re-organisation that, because of
an inherent sensitivity to sea level change and low thresholds for the forcing of change,
fundamentally restricts future management options. The paper also attempts to show that hard rock
coasts are also responsive to particular types of event on short time scales and examples are
discussed that modify the accepted view of hard rock insensitivity to environmental change.
q2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Soft coast inheritance; Hard coast HMLF events; Coastal sensitivity; Scotland
1. Introduction
Landscape or landform sensitivity can be defined as the ability of the landscape
or landform to undergo a recognizable change in response to changes in external
)Fax: q44-141-3304894.
Ž.
E-mail address: jhansom@geog.gla.ac.uk J.D. Hansom .
0341-8162r01r$ - see front matter q2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Ž.
PII: S0341- 8 1 6 2 00 00142-9
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305292
Ž.
controlling variables Brunsden and Thornes, 1979 . The nature of the response may
vary depending upon the amount and direction of change, the complexity of the system
Ž.Ž
and the time required for a new equilibrium to be achieved relaxation time Chorley
.
and Kennedy, 1971 . Many coastal landscapes contain elements that are viewed as being
Ž.
Fig. 1. a A well-adjusted soft coast, the gravels of Culbin Bar in the Moray Firth, Scotland extend westwards
Ž.
at a rate of 14 mryear. b The poorly adjusted hard coast. Plunging cliffs of Caithness flagstone, NE.
Scotland.
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305 293
both sensitive and insensitive to environmental change. Soft sedimentary coasts are
representative of a responsive system that rapidly adjusts in a labile fashion to changing
environmental conditions, as evidenced by the degree of adjustment to prevailing
Ž.
conditions Fig. 1a . However, this may result in underestimation of the role of
inheritance in the subsequent evolution of soft coastal systems. Conversely, hard rock
coasts are generally thought of as slow-responding systems that persist unchanged for
long time periods and require major disturbances to the system controls to provide the
impetus for change. The argument that hard rock coasts are poorly adjusted to prevailing
Ž.
environmental conditions is also persuasive Fig. 1b , but risks underestimation of the
Ž.
role of extreme high-magnitude, low-frequency HMLF events in the forcing of change.
In some situations, dramatic responses to contemporary changes can be demonstrated via
an examination of cliff processes in relation to present day HMLF events.
A good example of the role of inheritance and its far reaching effect on subsequent
system performance is the Holocene history of sea level change and its effect on coastal
sediment budget change. Much of the development of the Scottish coast can be related
to fundamental changes over the Holocene and can be demonstrated at a variety of
scales. Events over three time scales are used here on the soft coast to demonstrate the
effect of adjustments to the forcing factors of change and the importance of coastal
inheritance. These are: mid-Holocene sediment switching, late-Holocene internal re-
organisation of coastal sediments, and present day coastal sediment deficits.
2. Soft coast: inheritance effects
2.1. Mid-Holocene sediment switching
Central to the functioning of the coastal system are the interactions between relative
Ž.
sea level RSL , which affects the stability of coastal forms and sediment abundance or
deficit, which results in either progradation sufficient to reverse transgression or erosion
Ž.Ž.
even when RSL is falling Carter et al., 1987; Roy et al., 1994 Fig. 2 . In Scotland and
Ž. Ž
elsewhere, including much of Northern Europe Orford, 1987 , North America Boyd et
.Ž .
al., 1987 and Australia Roy et al., 1994 , sediment supply over the late-Glacial and
Holocene periods was controlled by availability on the continental shelf and by the sense
and magnitude of RSL change. Over the early part of the Holocene, the rapid rise in
RSL resulted in transgression which drowned moving shorelines rather than accomplish-
Ž.
ing significant shoreface modification Hansom, 1988 . Only when the rise in RSL
Ž.Ž.
began to slow down and stabilise at about 6.5 ka BP Firth et al., 1995 Fig. 3 did
wave activity establish widespread shoreface modification in association with the arrival
Ž.
of offshore gravels and then sand Carter, 1988 . However, in a static or slowly
Ž
changing RSL, the finite offshore sediment store declines through time Davies, 1974;
.
Bird, 1996 , leading to marked fluctuations in the coastal sediment economy. In Europe
and elsewhere, the resultant switch in sediment economy from surplus to decline at
Ž.
about 6.5 ka BP Carter, 1988, 1992 led to erosional shoreline tendencies irrespective of
RSL sense. However, the timing of the switch varied. In Eastern Scotland, RSL began to
fall in the mid-Holocene at a variety of start dates and rates depending on distance from
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305294
Ž.
Fig. 2. Coastal responses to the rate and sense of RSL and the availability of sediment after Carter, 1988 .
the centre of glaci-isostatic uplift and partly offset the negative effects of an overall
decline in the coastal sediment economy. In other areas, such as the Shetland Islands, the
Ž.
rise in RSL continued at a reduced rate Fig. 3 and led to a marked switch from
sediment surplus to deficit and increased shoreface erosion. This latter situation arose
under sediment deficit and rising RSL because shoreface sediments were transferred
offshore onto the shelf in order to maintain a nearshore gradient capable of dissipating
Ž.
wave energy Pethick, 1999 .
In the Scottish context, such erosion occurred first where high energy conditions and
rising RSL served to exacerbate the trend, conditions met in the north and west of
Scotland where foreshore freshwater peat, widespread erosion and tide-gauge evidence
Ž.
shows ongoing Holocene submergence Angus and Elliot, 1992 . In 1977, only 32 of the
Ž
466 Highland and Islands beaches were progradational the proportion of beaches with
.
purely erosional edges reaches a maximum in the Western and Northern Islands
Ž.
Mather and Ritchie, 1977 . Reversal of the positive sediment economy that once fed
dune development resulted in the removal of the frontal dunes and the recycling of dune
Ž.
sediment Hansom, 1999 . As a result, few dune and machair systems in Scotland are
Ž.
now fronted by anything other than eroding sub-vertical mature dune faces Fig. 4
Ž.
Hansom and Angus, in press .
Support for such an analysis of abundance followed by declining coastal sediment
supply over the Holocene comes from archaeological sites built originally within
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305 295
Fig. 3. Modelled RSL curves from the Shetland Islands to the Firth of Forth, Scotland. Note the earlier onset
Ž.
of RSL rise in the north and the mid-Holocene RSL fall in the south after Lambeck, 1993 .
accreting coastal dunes now behind beaches that are erosional. The houses at Rosinish in
Ž.
Benbecula show an onset of sand deposition from 5.7 ka BP Ritchie, 1979 . Neolithic
houses within sand deposits at Skara Brae in Orkney were occupied around 4.7 ka BP
and then abandoned amidst environmental instability. Many other similarly aged sites
such as at Bornish and Baleshare in the Uists, and Traigh Varlish in Vatersay were also
likely abandoned due to wind blow and environmental instability. The onset of sand
arrival depended on local factors and at some sites may have been as early as 8.7 ka BP
Ž.
Ritchie, 1979; Gilbertson et al., 1996; Hansom and Angus, in press . The relatively
recent archaeological discoveries at many such sites is usually due to exhumation by the
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305296
Fig. 4. Eroding dunes, such as these in the Isle of Iona, Argyll, are commonplace except where sediment is
locally plentiful, such as in estuaries.
wave-erosion of a sand dune edge. For example, Skara Brae was first revealed by
erosion of the dune front during storms in 1850.
It seems clear that the change from accretion to erosion was directly related to
mid-Holocene adjustments in sediment economy that have affected the sensitivity of the
coastal system and its subsequent performance. The role of inheritance appears all-per-
vasive.
2.2. Late-Holocene internal re-organisation of coastal sediments
On a shorter time scale, an important repercussion of the mid-Holocene decline of
sediment supply has been the late-Holocene re-organisation of coastal sediment into
progressively smaller coastal cells and sub-cells. Under conditions of sediment abun-
dance, coastal systems may adjust via the alongshore exchange of sediments between
Ž.
sections of the coast Roy et al., 1994 and by headland by-passing. However, in
Scotland and elsewhere the decline in the sediment economy and the resultant landwards
migration of the shoreline post 6.5 ka BP, favoured the emergence of barriers such as
headlands to alongshore exchanges. As a result, smaller and more discrete coastal
Ž.
sediment cells and sub-cells subsequently began to emerge Fig. 5 that are dominated
by the internal re-organisation processes of erosion and deposition.
A useful case study of the partitioning of a large coastal sediment cell into smaller
ones is the evolution of Culbin Sands in the Moray Firth, a beach and dune system
intimately linked to the longshore supply of sand and gravel from the east, including
both the Findhorn and Spey Rivers. About 6.5 ka BP, sediment from Spey Bay was
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305 297
Ž.
Fig. 5. Coastal cells and sub-cells in Scotland as identified by Brampton et al. 1999 .
by-passing the headland of Burghead in its westwards movement into the Findhorn and
Ž.
Culbin area Comber et al., 1994 , leading to the construction of spectacular raised
gravel ridges that now underlie large areas of this coast. Based on estimates of the
amounts of sediment delivered to these beaches and their downdrift connections within
the same cell, a palaeosediment budget has been established that demonstrates former
Ž.
connectivity Comber, 1993 . However, at some time between 6.5 and 4.6 ka BP
Ž.
Comber et al., 1994 , widespread decline in the sediment economy contributed to the
emergence of headland barriers and the cessation of sediment supply from the Spey to
Culbin. Lack of sediment from the west and ongoing westwards tracking waves led to
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305298
up-drift erosion of existing beaches, sediment transfer westwards, and down-drift
Ž
deposition in spits which deflected the exit of the River Findhorn west spits 1, 2 and 3,
.
Fig. 6 . Radiocarbon dating of peat shows the abandonment of spit 3 to have occurred
between 4.6 and 3.3 ka BP as the River Findhorn breached the eroding proximal end
Ž.
Comber et al., 1994 . This internal re-organisation of sediment within the cell continued
y1Ž
through a series of spits, the present one extending west at a rate of 16 m a Comber
.
et al, 1994 . Similar re-organisation occurred throughout Scottish coasts and led to the
establishment of the series of small and well-organised sediment cells observed today
Ž.Ž .
Fig. 5 Brampton et al., 1999 .
Further north in the Dornoch Firth, sediment re-organisation led to shifts in the wave
climate of the firth that fundamentally affected the subsequent performance of the
system. In the inner Dornoch Firth, a series of raised spits developed as a result of
Ž
changing relative sediment influx amounts from offshore and alongshore sources Fig.
.Ž .
7a Firth et al., 1995 . At the mid-Holocene high sea level before about 6.5 ka BP, the
waters of the inner Dornoch Firth were open to storm waves from the north east and
prominent westwards-trending raised gravel spits up to c10m OD developed at Meikle
Ž.
Ferry and Ness of Portnaculter Fig. 7b . At about the same time large sand spits began
to develop in the outer firth at Dornoch Point and, at 6.8 ka BP, at the Morrich More
Ž.Ž .
Fig. 7a Hansom and Leafe, 1990 . The development of the outer spits resulted in the
progressive isolation of the inner spits from wave energies sufficient to move their
constituent gravels and in a change to the relative importance of wave directions within
the firth. On the Scottish east coast, westerly waves are usually insignificant relative to
easterly waves, but the growth of Morrich More and Dornoch Point in the mid-Holocene
limited the ingress of easterly waves and led to a switch to favour westerly waves in the
central firth. As a result eastwards-trending, spits composed of small gravels were
constructed in the lower energy wave climate at c4m OD at Ard na Cailc and
particularly at Ardjachie Point. The inherited product that resulted from this energy shift
and now affects modern beaches, is erosion of the east side of the Morrich More due to
an enhanced easterly transfer of sediment.
Both of the above examples are the direct result of the creation of the smaller and
more isolated coastal sediment cells inherited from post 6.5 ka BP decline in the
sediment economy. Landwards translation of the shoreline, together with internal
re-organisation of its sediment store, has created a highly sensitive, and sensitised,
coastal system.
2.3. Present day coastal sediment deficits
The decline in the relative importance of offshore sediment sources has direct
implications for the short-term sensitivity of the present coast in the face of changing
Ž.
conditions, not only in Scotland but worldwide Bird, 1993 . As noted above, ongoing
erosion of up-drift sites serves to fuel down-drift accretion in those places affected by
the internal re-organisation of coastal sediment cells. To the east of Culbin at Spey Bay
Ž.
Fig. 6 , the declining importance of offshore sand and gravel sources and the switch to
a negative sediment economy has led to enhancement of the importance of gravels
sourced from the Spey River which now contributes about 6400 m3ay1of gravel to the
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305 299
Ž. Ž.
Fig. 6. Culbin Sands Fig. 1 has developed via internal re-organisation of sediments from updrift to fuel downdrift distal extension after Comber, 1995.
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305300
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305 301
Ž.
Fig. 8. Modern sediment supply to Spey Bay comes largely from the River Spey Profile 1 . Sediments eroded
Ž.
from here are redistributed alongshore e.g. to Profile 2 etc. and provide temporary volumetric additions to the
beach.
Ž.
coast in addition to sediment eroded from the shoreface Gemmell et al., 1997 .
Sediment is no longer added areally from offshore sources to the entire length of the
Spey Bay beaches. Instead, reduced volumes of sediment are now added as point
Ž.
sources at the Spey-mouth delta and at erosional sites Fig. 8 . Sediments from both
sources are periodically redistributed alongshore as discrete plugs of gravel by storm
events and can be identified as longshore-moving areas of sediment accreted to beach
Ž.
profiles Fig. 8 . Those profiles affected by the transit of a sediment plug undergo
temporary changes reflected in a seawards shift in the shoreline resulting from foreshore
accretion, but inter-plug areas are characterised by a landwards shift in the shoreline and
overtopping of the main beach ridge. Protection to particular profiles is afforded only for
the residence time of the sediment plug. Similarly, during the intervening periods of
local sediment deficit, the beach volume reduces to levels that threaten the integrity of
the main beach ridge and by implication, the land behind. This condition of locally
reduced sediment volumes now renders sections of the main beach ridge at Spey Bay
Ž.
Fig. 7. a In the early Holocene, the wide entrance of the Dornoch Firth allowed unrestricted access of high
Ž.
energy waves into the inner firth. b Early Holocene development of high energy gravel spits in the central
Dornoch Firth was curtailed by the growth of Dornoch Point and Morrich More and resulted in the
development of an eastwards drift of sediment.
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305302
progressively more susceptible to storm events of lesser magnitude than would previ-
Ž.
ously have been the case under a regime of plentiful sediment Gemmell et al., 1997 .
Such heightened sensitivity of the modern soft coastal system appears to be driven
largely by sediment deficits inherited from earlier in the Holocene. The human response
to such sensitivity is usually to stabilise the shoreline position using structures, a
response which may exacerbate the original condition by reducing the local supply of
Ž.
eroded sediment Bird, 1993, 1996; Viles and Spencer, 1995 . As a result, many
AstabilisedBsections of soft coast are now rendered increasingly insensitive to all but the
most dramatic of environmental change. In this light, to acknowledge the role of
inheritance and supply the beach with sediments to restore sensitivity seems a logical
management strategy.
3. Hard coast: sensitivity to HMLF events?
3.1. Present day HMLF eÕents and cliff processes
In marked contrast to the soft systems described above, the hard systems of rocky and
cliff coasts are seemingly insensitive to all but the most dramatic of changes and are
Ž.
generally understood to adjust at much slower rates Trenhaile, 1997 . For example,
plunging cliffs have altered little over long time periods and some are interglacial in age.
In such situations only large-scale disturbances in system controls, such as significant
Ž
sea level changes, or infrequent HMLF events may stimulate change Bryant et al.,
.
1992; Bryant and Young, 1996 . However, in some locations there is evidence to
suggest that the amount of change produced by HMLF events may be greater than
supposed and produces landforms that show a substantial amount of sensitivity to
environmental extremes.
For example, in exposed sites in the north and west of Scotland, cliffs that plunge
Ž
vertically into y20 to y30 m water depths are not unusual May and Hansom, in
.
press . As a result, these cliff coasts are subject to relatively unattenuated deepwater
waves, the dimensions of which are impressive. For example, analysis of wave records
to the west of Shetland show that waves exceeding 25 m in amplitude can be expected
Ž.
in major storms Hall et al., in preparation . Where plunging cliffs occur, such waves
may undergo only limited attenuation and access of breaking waves seems likely at
Ž.
heights of about 15–25 m above sea level asl . Consequently, in such situations
wave-wash stripping of vegetation is known to result in significant modification of the
Ž
cliff edge to considerable altitudes and distances inland Hall et al., in preparation; May
.
and Hansom, in press . Similar effects have been noted from Australia as a result of
Ž.
catastrophic wave or tsunami impact Bryant et al., 1992; Young et al., 1996 . Where
the coastal slope is more gentle, then wave attenuation is greater and the run-up altitude
of waves may be reduced. However, although they occur at several sites in Scotland, the
development of wave-placed accumulations of large boulders at heights of 15–25 m asl
Ž.
on top of such cliffs is less well known Steers, 1973; May and Hansom, in press .
At several sites in the Northern and Western Islands, cliff-top deposits composed of
boulders of c2.1m a-axis, 1m b-axis and 0.3m c-axis are arranged in prominent ridges.
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305 303
The boulders are arranged in ordered imbricate clusters that show almost perfect
Ž.
relationships with the intricacies of cliff-edge morphology Fig. 9 . For example, at
Eshaness, in the Shetland Islands, large slabs of ignimbrite have been quarried from the
adjacent cliff-top edge, and transported 50 m landwards to be deposited at 15 m asl in
Ž.
one of three cliff-top boulder ridges, the largest of which reaches 3.5 m Fig. 9 . The
boulders that comprise the ridges are fresh, with sharp and serated edges that can be
Ž
matched perfectly to fresh scars on the cliff edge quite unlike the adjacent rounded,
.
lichen-encrusted surfaces . It is likely that these boulders have been recently quarried
and moved to their present locations by HMLF events. Even higher, but less distinct,
deposits exist in Shetland up to 35 m asl. In Australia, similar wave-tossed boulder
masses and wave erosion of rock surfaces have been related to tsunami wave impact up
Ž.
to 32 m asl Bryant et al., 1992; Bryant and Young, 1996; Nott, 1997 .
Key questions remain as to whether the waves are storm- or tsunami-related, whether
the wave heights and forces generated at altitude are sufficient to quarry and move large
boulders, the date of emplacement of individual boulders and thus, the frequency of the
events that moved them. Mathematical and hardware modelling is under way to address
the first two issues and to establish the sensitivity of cliff edges to wave impact. A
variety of dating techniques are also being employed to secure dates for the emplace-
ment of the boulders. Nevertheless, field evidence in Shetland indicates that a series of
relatively recent events have deposited, or at least re-organised the fresh cliff-top
boulder ridges. In the absence of recent tsunamis in the North Atlantic, it seems
probable that the quarrying and movement of the fresh boulders may be the result of
Ž.
storms in the 1980s and 1990s Hall et al., in preparation .
Fig. 9. A wave-placed boulder ridge atop a 50-m-wide rock platform quarried into a 15 m asl cliff in northern
Shetland. The boulders of the 3.5-m-high ridge have been freshly quarried from the adjacent cliff edge.
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305304
Such processes of modification of cliffs and cliff-top deposits are by no means
commonplace, but their occurrence and degree of development strongly indicates that
the processes and periodicity of HMLF events may either be greatly underestimated or
the concept of low frequency needs to be process-qualified and quantified. The
environmental significance of extreme waves has relevance not only for coastal sensitiv-
ity in a variety of settings from Australia to the North Atlantic, but also for the safety of
offshore installations in such environments.
4. Conclusion
In many respects, the endless adjustments of the coastline should represent a perfect
example of the concept of sensitivity and adjustment to the present morphogenetic
environment, yet within the labile soft coast the role of inheritance is a central control on
subsequent system performance. On the other hand, hard rocky coasts should represent
lack of adjustment to present processes and classic slow responses, yet in some places a
surprising degree of sensitivity to HMLF events can be demonstrated. It follows that in
order for the sensitivity concept to fulfill its promise in contributing to the improved
understanding of coastlines and their management, the effects and timing of both
inheritance and process extremes on both soft and hard coastal landforms and develop-
ment need to be more fully understood.
References
Angus, S., Elliot, M.M., 1992. Erosion in Scottish Machair with particular reference to the outer Hebrides. In:
Ž.
Carter, R.W.G., Curtis, T.G.F., Sheehy-Skeffington, M.J. Eds. , Coastal Dunes. Balkema, pp. 93–117.
Bird, E.C.F., 1993. Submerging Coasts: The Effects of a Rising Sea-level on Coastal Environments. Wiley,
Chichester, 184 pp.
Bird, E.C.F., 1996. Beach Management. Wiley, Chichester, 281 pp.
Boyd, R., Bowen, A.J., Hall, R.K., 1987. An evolutionary model for transgressive sedimentation on the
Ž.
Eastern Shore of Nova Scotia. In: Fitzgerald, D.M., Rosen, P.S Eds. , Glaciated Coasts. Academic Press,
San Diego, pp. 88–114.
Brampton, A., Lees, G., Ramsey, D.L., 1999. The coastal cells of Scotland and their application. In: Baxter, J.,
Ž.
Duncan, K., Atkins, S., Lees, G. Eds. , Scotland’s Living Coastline. HMSO, pp. 69–78.
Bryant, E.A., Young, R.W., 1996. Bedrock sculpting by tsunami, south coast New South Wales, Australia.
Journal of Geology 104, 565–582.
Bryant, E.A., Young, R.W., Price, D.M., 1992. Evidence of tsunami sedimentation on the southeastern coast
of Australia. Journal of Geology 100, 753–765.
Brunsden, D., Thornes, J.B., 1979. Landscape sensitivity and change. Transactions of the Institute of British
Geographers, NS 4, 463–484.
Carter, R.W.G., 1988. Coastal Environments. Academic Press, London, 617 pp.
Carter, R.W.G., 1992. How the British coast works: inherited and acquired controls. In: Stevens, C., Gordon,
Ž.
J.E., Green, C.P., Macklin, M.G. Eds. , Conserving Our Landscape, Proceedings of the Conference
Conserving Our Landscape: Evolving Landforms and Ice-age Inheritance. English Nature, Peterborough,
pp. 63–68.
Carter, R.W.G., Johnston, T.W., McKenna, J., Orford, J.D., 1987. Sea-level, sediment supply and coastal
changes: examples form the coast of Ireland. Progress in Oceanography 18, 79–101.
()
J.D. HansomrCatena 42 2001 291–305 305
Chorley, R.J., Kennedy, B.A., 1971. Physical Geography: A Systems Approach. Prentice-Hall, London, 370
pp.
Comber, D.P.M., 1993. Shoreline response to relative sea level change: Culbin Sands, Northeast Scotland.
Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Glasgow.
Ž.
Comber, D.P.M., 1995. Culbin sands and the bar. Scottish Geographical Magazine 111 1 , 54–57.
Comber, D.P.M., Hansom, J.D., Fahy, F.M., 1994. Culbin sands, Culbin forest and Findhorn Bay, SSSI:
documentation and management prescription. Scottish Natural Heritage Research Survey and Monitoring
Report No. 14. Scottish Natural Heritage, Edinburgh, 98 pp.
Davies, J.L., 1974. The coastal sediment compartment. Australian Geographical Studies 12, 139–151.
Firth, C.R., Smith, D.E., Hansom, J.D., Pearson, S.G., 1995. Holocene spit development on a regressive
shoreline, Dornoch Firth, Scotland. Marine Geology 124, 203–214.
Gemmell, S.L.G., Hansom, J.D., Hoey, T.B., 1997. The geomorphology, conservation and management of the
River Spey and Spey Bay SSSI’s, Moray. Research, Survey and Monitoring Report: Scottish Natural
Heritage. Scottish Natural Heritage, Edinburgh, 230 pp.
Gilbertson, D., Grattan, J., Pyatt, B., Schwenninger, J.-L., 1996. The Quaternary geology of the coasts of the
Ž.
islands of the southern Outer Hebrides. In: Gilbertson, D., Kent, M., Grattan, J. Eds. , The Outer
Hebrides, the Last 14,000 Years. Sheffield Academic Press, Sheffield, pp. 59–102.
Hall, A.M., Hansom, J.D. and Jarvis, J. Cliff-top storm deposits from extreme events in the Shetland Islands,
Ž.
Scotland in preparation .
Hansom, J.D., 1988. Coasts. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 96 pp.
Hansom, J.D., 1999. The coastal geomorphology of Scotland: understanding sediment budgets for effective
Ž.
coastal management. In: Baxter, J., Duncan, K., Atkins, S., Lees, G. Eds. , Scotland’s Living Coastline.
HMSO, Norwich, pp. 34–44.
Ž.
Hansom, J.D., Angus, S. Tir a Mhachair Land of Machair : sediment supply and climate change scenarios for
`Ž.
the future of the outer Helsides machair. In: Gordon, T.E., Ed. , Earth science and the Natural Heritage of
Ž.
Scotland. HMSO, Norwich in press .
Hansom, J.D., Leafe, R.N., 1990. The geomorphology of Morrich More: development of a scientific database
and management prescription. Nature Conservancy Council Commissioned Report Series, Peterborough.
174 pp.
Lambeck, K., 1993. Glacial rebound of the British isles-1: preliminary model results. Geophysical Journal
International 115, 941–959.
Mather, A.S., Ritchie, W., 1977. The Beaches of the Highlands and Islands of Scotland. Countryside
Commission for Scotland, Battleby, Perth, p. 201.
May, V. and Hansom, J.D. Coastal geomorphology of Great Britain. Geological Conservation Review. Joint
Ž.
Nature Conservancy Council, HMSO, Norwich in press .
Ž.
Orford, J., 1987. Coastal processes: the coastal response to sea-level variation. In: Devoy, R.J.N. Ed. , Sea
Surface Studies: A Global View. Croom Helm, London, pp. 415–463.
Nott, J., 1997. Extremely high-energy wave deposits inside the Great Barrier Reef, Australia: determining the
causes — tsunami or tropical cyclone. Marine Geology 1414, 193–207.
Pethick, J., 1999. Future sea-level changes in Scotland: options for coastal management. In: Baxter, J.,
Ž.
Duncan, K., Atkins, S., Lees, G. Eds. , Scotland’s Living Coastline. HMSO, Norwich, pp. 45–62.
Roy, P.S., Cowell, P.J., Ferland, M.A., Thom, B.G., 1994. Wave-dominated coasts. In: Carter, R.W.G.,
Ž.
Woodroffe, C.D. Eds. , Coastal Evolution. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, pp. 121–186.
Ritchie, W., 1979. Machair development and chronology in the Uists and adjacent islands. Proceedings of the
Royal Society of Edinburgh 77B, 107–122.
Steers, J.A., 1973. The Coastline of Scotland. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge.
Trenhaile, S.A., 1997. Coastal Dynamics and Landforms. Clarendon Press, Oxford, 366 pp.
Viles, H., Spencer, T., 1995. Coastal Problems: Geomorphology, Ecology and Society at the Coast. Edward
Arnold, London, 350 pp.
Ž.
Young, R.W., Bryant, E.A., Price, D.M., 1996. Catastrophic wave tsunami? transport of boulders in southern
Ž.
New South Wales, Australia. Zeitschrift fuer Geomorphologie 40 2 , 191–207.
... It is worth noting that the palaeogeography of the Dornoch estuary at the time of the tsunami would have been different because the beach ridges and dunes at Morrich More at the eastern end of the estuary would not have been present because they are younger deposits [63,64]. This would have left a wider entrance to the Dornoch Firth, enabling the tsunami wave to extend into the estuary. ...
... Instead of a pair of spits across the mouth of the embayment, the GPR does not show evidence for a spit on the southern side; instead, there appear to be channel scours in this area (Figure 7). Furthermore, a spit attached to the northern margin is consistent with a westerly longshore drift when the entrance to Dornoch Firth was open to northeasterly waves [63]. When tsunami waves enter an embayment, they will commonly wash over beach ridges and dunes, but the inflow has to be followed by an outflow as the water returns to the sea. ...
... The spit at Dornoch Point and beach ridges at Morrich More currently restrict the width of the entrance to the Dornoch Firth to less than 2.5 km (Figure 1). At the time of the tsunami, the entrance to the Dornoch Firth would have been much wider, close to 9 km, allowing waves to penetrate further into the estuary [63,64]. In addition, spits within the firth at Ardjachie were also interpreted to have formed after the tsunami [42] and thus would not have obstructed tsunami flow within the firth. ...
Article
Full-text available
A submarine landslide on the edge of the Norwegian shelf that occurred around 8150 ± 30 cal. years BP triggered a major ocean-wide tsunami, the deposits of which are recorded around the North Atlantic, including Scotland. Ground-penetrating radar (GPR) was used here to investigate tsunami sediments within estuaries on the coast of northeastern Scotland where the tsunami waves were funnelled inland. Around the Dornoch Firth, the tsunami deposits are up to 1.6 m thickness, which is exceptionally thick for tsunami deposits and about twice the thickness of the 2004 IOT or 2011 Tohoku-oki tsunami deposits. The exceptional thickness is attributed to a high sediment supply within the Dornoch Firth. At Ardmore, the tsunami appears to have overtopped a beach ridge with a thick sand layer deposited inland at Dounie and partly infilled a valley. Later, fluvial activity eroded the tsunami sediments locally, removing the sand layer. At Creich, on the north side of the Dornoch Firth, the sand layer varies in thickness; mapping of the sand layer with GPR shows lateral thickness changes of over 1 m attributed to a combination of infilling an underlying topography, differential compaction, and later reworking by tidal inlets. Interpretation of the GPR profiles at Wick suggests that there has been a miscorrelation of Holocene stratigraphy based on boreholes. Changes in the stratigraphy of spits at Ardmore are attributed to the balance between sediment supply and sea-level change with washovers dominating a spit formed during the early Holocene transgression, while spits formed during the subsequent mid-Holocene high-stand are dominated by progradation.
... Coastal sand dunes form naturally above the tidal limits of a beach as a result of sediment transport processes controlled by tides, waves, wind, and vegetation (Sloss et al., 2012a). Such landforms represent a complex and dynamic ecosystem resulting from hydrodynamic and sedimentary processes, as well as feedback and interactions with other geomorphic features of the fluvial and marine environment (Hansom, 2001;Sloss et al., 2012b). Dunes play a dual role as sediment sinks or sources to maintain the long-term resilience of a coastal system as long as natural environmental functioning is not restricted by human activities (Sabatier et al., 2009). ...
... As the demographic, economic and social core of the region moved to the coast, more pressure was placed on the area (Deur, 2016). Urbanization, coastal and river engineering, dredging and resource development altered the balanced functioning of coastal ecosystems by reducing their resilience (Hansom, 2001). The last decades of the century were marked by a new understanding of beaches and dunes throughout the world, as the development of scientific knowledge on coastal systems clarified their role and importance in the natural dynamic processes. ...
Article
Full-text available
The Drivers-Pressures-State-Impact-Response (DPSIR) framework was employed to understand the land use policies developed to manage coastal sand dunes and their consequences in Oregon, United States of America, during two contrasting periods: from the 19th to the late 20th century and from there to the early 21st century. A combination of historical data and scientific literature was used for this study. Dune destabilization became a socio-economic issue as Euro-Americans settled in Oregon in the 19th century. Ammophila arenaria and Ammophila breviligulata were widely used for stabilization. This led to a paradigm shift regarding dunes, at a time when their management was becoming more complex due to socio-natural factors. As non-native beachgrasses turned invasive causing the loss of biodiversity and habitats, their removal became the focus to restore the active dunes to support the natural processes of the ecosystem. However, the removal of these beachgrasses, particu�larly, Ammophila arenaria, results in low dune heights, increasing the risk of coastal flooding by reducing their effectiveness as a natural defense against sea-level rise and extreme storm surges. The reason for the contrasting dune management policies in Oregon since the 1930 s is that the management response to environmental impacts due to human drivers creates new drivers, pressures, and corresponding impacts, as shown in the DPSIR analysis. Thus, land use policies for managing coastal dunes in Oregon and other places must balance efforts to restore the native biodiversity while minimizing coastal flooding in a context of accelerating and continuous sea-level rise in the 21st century.
... The inherent sensitivity of soft sedimentary coasts, particularly beaches, to environmental changes is highlighted by their rapid and dynamic adjustment to prevailing conditions, such as sea level fluctuations and variations in sediment supply. Historical events, such as mid-Holocene sediment switching, highlight the complex interplay between relative sea level changes and sediment availability, directly influencing beach width and coastal erosion patterns 83 . These factors make beach width a critical parameter for understanding and mitigating coastal vulnerability. ...
Article
Full-text available
The escalating threat of climate change has placed global coastal communities at risk, with rising sea levels and intensified storm events presenting unprecedented challenges. Coastal vulnerability assessments, conducted every 3–5 years, are crucial. This empirical study assesses the Coastal Vulnerability Index (CVI) for the distinct coastal contexts of Dawlish, Happisburgh (England), and Aberystwyth (Wales). The CVI method consists of the Physical Coastal Vulnerability Index (PCVI) and the Economic Coastal Vulnerability Index (ECVI), which provide a multidimensional assessment of vulnerability for coastal zones. This integrated index allows for a nuanced evaluation of vulnerability, distinguishing between sites based on various factors. Additionally, this study conducted a correlation analysis to understand the associations between the parameters. The findings demonstrate that physical features like beach and dune widths significantly impact a location’s natural defences, and economic factors such as property values and population density are equally crucial in determining societal risks and potential financial repercussions. The Combined Coastal Vulnerability Index (CCVI) results confirm the effectiveness of incorporating a diverse range of variables. Despite its substantial economic value, it reveals that Dawlish requires targeted protective measures, whereas Happisburgh needs an increased focus on its most vulnerable sectors. Aberystwyth emerges as the area with the highest overall vulnerability, underscoring the need for comprehensive coastal management practices. The study’s conclusions emphasize the essential role of adaptive, integrated management strategies in enhancing coastal resilience against the complex threats posed by climate dynamics. Moving forward, the indices established herein advocate for their use in strategic planning and policymaking to strengthen coastal regions in the face of sea-level rise and climatic variability. This investigation lays the groundwork for future research, aimed at refining and expanding these methodologies, aspiring to develop a detailed national coastal vulnerability atlas, a critical tool for informed decision-making and safeguarding at-risk communities.
... It is well known that rock coast evolution and cliff erosion with subsequent deposition of large blocks is driven by large storms (Hansom 2001;Hall et al. 2008). In the Gerra Beach the turbidite and claystone lithostratigraphic units are hit by the waves during storm events that overlap with the high tide, but the ordinary action of the sea reworks and reshapes sediments and beach landforms throughout the year. ...
Article
Full-text available
Gerra is small beach located at the foot of a cliff on the Western coast of Cantabria (North of Iberian Peninsula). It has a sandy distal part and a proximal part at the foot of the cliff made up of boulders, supported by rockfalls and landslides from the cliff. Claystones, limestones and marls of the Triassic and Cretaceous ages form the cliff. To study geomorphological processes, a geomorphological map was drawn up; analysis of the beach deposits as texture, granulometry and Atterberg limits; analysis of photogrammetric flights between 1957 and 2017; drone flights between 2017 and 2020; and geomatic monitoring of the cliff and the beach by means of a terrestrial laser scanner (TLS) between 2012 and 2019. The processes involved in the coastal dynamic and retreat of the cliff and beach have been established, as well as the rates of erosion and retreat, which coincide with other beaches on the Cantabrian Coast. The current dynamics are characterized by the moderate regression of the coastline and greater regression and dynamism at the cliff-top, which implies the gradual degradation of the cliff due to loss of verticality. Among the factors involved in the cliff degradation, the main changes in the present and future evolution of the sea cliff can only be ascribed to sea level rise.
... Tamura, 2012;Kelsey, 2015;Oliver et al., 2017), it is agreed that ridge formation is mainly influenced by changes in sea level, local wave/tide conditions, storminess, gradient, and the degree of sediment supply. Commonly, it is expected that relative sea level (RSL) rise will erode and move beach ridges towards a more landward equilibrium position, whereas beach ridge plains prograde seaward during sea-level fall (Hansom, 2001;Plater and Kirby, 2011). However, the exact controlling factors, mechanisms, and timing remain poorly understood (e.g., Tamura, 2012). ...
Article
Full-text available
Beach ridges are depositional features that allow reconstruction of past sea-level variations, sediment dynamics, and storm activity. However, there are still very few systematic studies focusing on beach ridges available from the Gulf of Thailand. Along the east coast, satellite images provide evidence of beach ridges in the Chanthaburi Province, extending as far as 6 km inland, oriented parallel to the current coastline. These can be divided into a set of landward ridges (5.3–6.0 km inland) and seaward ridges (0.4–1.8 km inland) that are separated by an arm of the Chanthaburi estuary. Optically stimulated luminescence dating of 26 sand samples from 12 pits of ridge profiles suggests that thelandward set of beach ridges formed ca. 3500 yr ago, while the seaward set of ridges formed between ca. 2100–1200 years ago, which also includes the modern active beach. It appears that the landward set of beach ridges developed during a period of relatively stable sea level followed by a rapid regression presently occupied by the arm of the Chanthaburi estuary. The seaward set of beach ridges apparently reflects a millennium of slowly retreating coastline until the modern beach ridge formed.
... Due to the vulnerability of coastal areas to rapid environmental changes (Hansom, 2001), the condition of the community structure living in coastal habitats after the mucilage became important. Coastal and estuarine areas are mostly used by small-sized adult or juvenile fish (Guidetti, 2000) and decapod crustaceans (Pallas et al., 2006). ...
Chapter
Abstract The term ‘wave-dominated coast’ is applied to coasts with an abundance of sediment (primarily sand but including gravel and cobbles) and where contemporary coastal evolution is shaped through erosion, transport, and deposition of sediment by waves and wave-generated currents. These coasts are also influenced by tides and tidal currents, but they play a subordinate role compared to waves. Waves reaching the coast may be generated locally by strong winds associated with storm events and the resulting sea is characterized by relatively high, short-period waves. Coasts exposed to the open ocean may also be characterized by the arrival of relatively low, long-period swell waves generated far out to sea. Sediment in the nearshore and on the beach may be set in motion by the orbital motion associated with the passage of an individual wave and net transport occurs as a result of the presence of unidirectional currents generated by waves, wind, or tides. Waves may break directly on the beach or, with gently sloping beaches and large waves, they may break some distance offshore forming a surf zone between the breaker line and the beach. The average form of the beach and nearshore is controlled by both the sediment size and the characteristics of the wave climate. Generally, the profile slope decreases exponentially offshore and the profile may be either smooth or one or more bars and trough systems may be present.Changes to the profile occur in response to changing wave conditions on a timescale of hours to months with the scale of the changes decreasing into deeper water. In addition to sand or gravel beaches formed along mainland coasts, longshore transport of sediment is often responsible for the formation of a wide range of depositional barrier forms such as baymouth barriers, spits, and barrier islands. These barriers are separated from the mainland by a lagoon, bay, or marsh, with the lagoon or bay being connected to the open sea by a tidal inlet or inlets cutting through the barrier. Barriers are often subject to rapid changes during storms when storm surge accompanying large waves results in erosion of dunes and overwash of the barriers. The stability of all mainland beach and barrier coasts is also influenced by sea-level change. Sea-level rise over the next century is likely to lead to an increase in the proportion of wave-dominated coasts being subject to erosion and to landward transgression.
Article
Full-text available
Lacustrine beach ridges are often used to reconstruct past lake levels. However, the sedimentary architecture involved in their sedimentary evolution remains unclear, particularly for embayed beaches. To better understand the sedimentary processes, the sedimentary architecture and geomorphology of an embayed beach on the southern of Qinghai Lake were investigated using ground penetrating radar (GPR), trenches, and modern beach observation. The embayed beach's deposits are composed of three major sedimentary facies: washover deposition, fair-weather swash deposition, and lagoonal deposition. According to the variations in sedimentary facies, the formation of the embayed beach can be divided into two stages: lake-level highstand and lake-level lowstand. During lake-level highstand stage, geomorphic changes primarily occur in the cross-shore direction. A single beach ridge with washover lobes and sheets developed along the entire embayed beach. During lake-level lowstand stage, the sediments are mainly transported alongshore within the embayed beach. The northern end shows progradational complex deposits including beach ridge, lagoon and beach system, while only a beach ridge is present at the southern end. Hydrodynamic changes in two stages lead to the heterogeneity of sediment distribution, reflected in the morphology and the sedimentary architecture. The interaction of topography and hydrodynamics controls the formation and evolution of the embayed beach. This study improves the understanding of the sedimentary processes involved in embayed beaches.
Chapter
Full-text available
Investigations into the coastal response to sea-level changes have long been a salient feature of Pleistocene geomorphological/geological research. However, of late a renewed interest has been generated by contemporary coastal problems, particularly of flooding and erosion related to sea-level changes on a worldwide scale.
Book
This is a comprehensive reference text for senior undergraduates, graduate students, and instructors and working professionals in the coastal field. It provides a thorough survey of a present state of geomorphological knowledge across a very broad spectrum of coastal types, including topics, such as the form and processes operating on cold coasts, deltas, cohesive cold coasts, and coral reefs, that have rarely been included in general coastal texts. There is also a detailed discussion on the nature, origin, and transport of beach sediment, and the possible effects of future sea-level changes on coastal environments. Anthropological influences and managerial implications are discussed in several of the chapters. All the material draws upon up-to-date research and scientific findings.
Book
This review, prepared for the United Nations Environment Programme, deals with evidence of changing sea levels, sea level rise and coastline changes, and human responses to a rising sea level. Coastal submergence has occurred as the result of coastal land subsidence, and/or rising sea levels, and is becoming more extensive as sea levels rise in reponse to global warming.
Article
Scottish machair is now regarded as having international importance both for nature conservation and for its physiographic, botantical and ornithological interest. Dune and machair systems are by their very nature dynamic and therefore erosion and deposition may occur naturally. The high average and extreme wind speeds which have contributed to the formation of the habitat also threaten it via its inherent instability. Case histories are presented which show that properly planned and managed reinstatement schemes can succeed but some well-intentioned, yet ill-advised, schemes can magnify problems. -from Authors