ArticlePDF Available

Towards the use of ecological heterogeneity to design reserve networks: A case study from Dadia National Park, Greece

DOI: 10.1007/s10531-010-9788-y
Authors:
Vassiliki I Kati at University of Ioannina
Vassiliki I Kati
Kostas Poirazidis at Ionian University
Kostas Poirazidis
Marc Dufrene at University of Liège
Marc Dufrene
John M. Halley at University of Ioannina
John M. Halley
Show all 7 authorsHide
Download full-text PDFDownload full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract and Figures

In this paper, we present a novel approach for using ecological heterogeneity in reserve design. We measured five ecological heterogeneity indices (EHI) and we used a database of six biological groups (woody plants, orchids, orthopterans, aquatic and terrestrial herpetofauna and passerine birds) across 30 sites in a Mediterranean reserve (Greece). We found that all the five EHI were significantly related to the overall species richness and to the species richness of woody plants and birds. Two indices, measuring vertical vegetation complexity (1/D) and horizontal heterogeneity of landcover types (SIDI) in terms of Simpson's index, predicted well overall species richness and had significantly higher values inside the complementary reserve networks designed after five of the six biological groups. We compared five methods of forming reserve networks. The method of ecological heterogeneity (selecting those sites with the greatest 1/D and then SIDI) was less efficient (non-significantly) than the species-based methods (scoring and complementary networks) but significantly more efficient than the random method (randomly selected network). We also found that the method of complementary ecological heterogeneity (selecting those sites where each EHI had its maximum value) was not that efficient, as it did not differ significantly from the random method. These results underline the potential of the ecological heterogeneity method as an alternative tool in reserve design.
Figures - uploaded by Vassiliki I Kati
Author content
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Vassiliki I Kati
Content may be subject to copyright.
Kati etal (2010) Towards ecol heterogeneity to design reserv.
...pdf
Content uploaded by Stefan Schindler
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Stefan Schindler
Content may be subject to copyright.
2010-HeteroReserve-BiodCo
ns.pdf
Content uploaded by Vassiliki I Kati
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Vassiliki I Kati
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... In this sense, the Mixed Algerian Oak Forest is particularly beneficial for butterflies finding favorable conditions. The heterogeneity and quality of the habitat play a discriminant role in the persistence of the Rhopalocerean populations since the richest sites of Rhopalocera, in terms of diversity of species, are those belonging to a heterogeneous landscape (Gonseth 1994;Kati et al. 2010;Rocchini et al. 2010;Lang 2019). On the other hand, the Maritime Pine Forest is a poor habitat dominated by the Maritime Pine, which opposite the Cork Oak, does not allow the installation of the undergrowth or a floristic procession that directly affects the richness of Rhopalocera. ...
Diversity and status of day butterflies (Lepidoptera: Rhopalocera) in different plant associations of the Edough Forest Massif (Northeastern Algeria) NARIMAN LAREF, RANIA REZZAG-BEDIDA, MEHDI BOUKHEROUFA, RYM SAKRAOUI, RANIA LINA IKRAM HENADA, RACHAD HADIBY, FERIEL SAKRAOUI
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2022
Laref N, Rezzag-Beddida R, Boukheroufa M, Sakraoui R, Henada RLI, Hadiby R, Sakraoui F. 2022. Diversity and status of day butterflies (Lepidoptera: Rhopalocera) in different plant associations of the Edough Forest Massif (Northeastern Algeria). Biodiversitas 23: 954-961. The current study seeks to evaluate the biodiversity and the structure of the Lepidoptera, Rhopalocera stand in the Edough mountain range, Northeastern Algeria. The main objective is to analyse specific and dynamic fluctuations depending on the forest species and assess their functional role. The resulting work was conducted during the 2021 spring season at the Ain Bocal Natural Site, characterized by a succession of four forest species in a sampling corridor approximately 2 km long. The sampling strategy was based on the linear transect method derived from the British BMS Butterflies Monitoring Scheme method, where 390 individuals were counted to calculate and analyse the stand structure parameters. We were also able to carry out the taxonomic identification of 13 species belonging to four families, Pieridae, Nymphalidae, Lycaenidae and Papilionidae. Overall, the results revealed that the Mixed Algerian Oak Forest (Zean Oak Forest) is the richest in species, followed by Cork Oak Forest, Algerian Oak Forest and Maritime Pine Forest. The forest of the Edough, by its composition in habitats and ecological niches, allows the installation of the lepidopterological biodiversity.
View
... The loss of heterogeneity in this mountainous landscape, on the other hand, has been reported to have detrimental effects on local biodiversity since it affects both species that depend on open habitats for feeding and nesting and species that depend on the abundance of the previous ones. As suggested by Kati et al. [61] landscape heterogeneity can be considered as a surrogate of biodiversity, with increased levels of heterogeneity being related to increased biodiversity. Several studies suggest a negative relationship between loss of open habitats and biodiversity. ...
Long-Term Monitoring of Vegetation Dynamics in the Rhodopi Mountain Range National Park-Greece
Article
Full-text available
  • Feb 2022
While deforestation is a major environmental issue in the tropics, with thousands of hectares converted to agricultural land every year, in Europe the opposite trend is observed, with land abandonment in mountainous and semi-mountainous areas allowing the afforestation of former agricultural and pastoral land. This trend allows semi-natural ecosystems to recover after a prolonged period of exploitation and often over-exploitation, but it may also lead to significant loss of landscape heterogeneity with potentially detrimental effects on biodiversity. The current study aims to monitor changes in the vegetation coverage across a period of 35 years (between 1984 and 2019) in the Rhodopi Mountains range National Park in northern Greece. A time series of LANDSAT TM (16 images), LANDSAT ETM + (1 image) and LANDSAT 8 OLI/TIRS (4 images) were employed. One data transformation method was applied (TCT), and five vegetation indices (NDVI, NDWI, SAVI, EVI2 and BSI) were calculated to capture the land cover transition during the study period. The obtained results and all used indices suggest that over the study period there was a continuous trend of vegetation cover increasing, with open areas decreasing. The observed trend was further confirmed using Object Oriented Image Analysis on two pairs of images sensed in 1984 and 2019, respectively. The results suggest that almost 22.000 ha of open habitats have been lost to broadleaved and conifer woodlands, while the former also appear to be advancing into conifer-covered areas. This trend has led to significant loss of landscape heterogeneity and to a broadleaf-dominated landscape. The results are discussed in relation to their driving forces, the potential implications on biodiversity and the risk of wildfires in the near future.
View
... Habitat loss through wildfires and increased canopy cover has been found to affect golden eagle populations and particularly pairs in areas of high density that cannot compensate for this loss through range expansion [99,100]. Habitat management such as grazing and prescribed burning [101,102] promoting habitat mosaics will thus reduce megafire incidence [103], and the associated biodiversity benefits will promote both the main and alternative prey availability [104][105][106]. ...
Pronounced Seasonal Diet Diversity Expansion of Golden Eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) in Northern Greece during the Non-Breeding Season: The Role of Tortoises
Article
Full-text available
Golden Eagles are resident in Greece and known to feed mainly on tortoises when breeding. However, information on alternative prey is scarce, especially during the tortoise brumation, that roughly coincides with the eagles’ non-breeding season. We analyzed 827 prey items collected from 12 territories over five territory years and 84 records of eagles hunting or feeding behavior. Tortoises dominated the breeding season diet (71% of prey categories on average) and over half of all hunting/feeding observations. While no spatial structure was evident, habitat variables such as forest canopy cover were important associates in golden eagle diet seasonally. A significant seasonal pattern emerged in diet diversity, using a subset of six territories with at least 10 samples per season. Eagles shifted from a narrow, reptile- based breeding season diet dominated by tortoises to a broader non-breeding season diet, that included more carrion, mammals and birds. Breeding season specialization on ectothermic prey is a trait usually associated with migratory raptors in the Western Palearctic. The observed dietary diversity expansion accompanied by residency in the absence of ectothermic prey, highlights the adaptability of the golden eagle, a generalist predator. Tortoise populations in Greece are of conservation concern and land use changes as well as climate change, such as development and land abandonment may increase the prevalence of catastrophic megafires, exacerbating the threats to the golden eagle’s main prey when breeding. We discuss this and other diet related conservation implications for the species in northern Greece.
View
... Moreover, fires also increase the spatial and seasonal heterogeneity of bird communities, which was shown to be higher in burnt than in unburnt patches (Herrando et al. , 2003Sitters et al. 2015). Finally, spatial variations in fire extent and intensity greatly contribute to Mediterranean landscape heterogeneity, creating landscape mosaics necessary to maintain bird diversity Tews et al. 2004;Kati et al. 2010;Zozaya et al. 2012). Climate changes are therefore likely to induce large-scale indirect effects on birds via large-scale changes in perturbation regimes linked to extreme climate events (Brotons et al. 2012). ...
View
... Habitat quality can be quantified within a patch by measuring tree species richness and structural complexity of vegetation. Structurally rich residual forest habitats are important refuges for avian species diversity (Blake and Karr 1984), and bird species richness increases with high structural diversity in forests (MacArthur and MacArthur 1961;Díaz et al. 2005;Kati et al. 2010;Culbert et al. 2013) and forest islands specifically (Freemark and Merriam 1986). Accordingly, we expected the increased species richness to be reflected in a subset of soniferous organisms which we can monitor (birds), and subsequent increased bird species richness to produce higher acoustic diversity. ...
Ecoacoustics of small forest patches in agricultural landscapes: acoustic diversity and bird richness increase with patch size
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2020
The species–area relationship is well documented across species in multiple ecosystems, and as such is widely accepted as one of ecology’s key patterns. Although acoustic diversity has generally been correlated with species richness, the response of acoustic diversity to habitat size is unknown. Thus, we tested the transferability of the species–area relationship to a broader ‘biodiversity–area relationship’, investigating if acoustic diversity increases with habitat size. Twenty-two forest patches of increasing size (0.01–4.7 ha) in an agricultural area were inventoried for structural characteristics and bird richness. Plots were acoustically monitored over three time periods. Acoustic diversity values were related to habitat size, vegetation structural diversity and bird richness using linear regression analysis. We confirmed that acoustic diversity increased with forest patch size. When tested in separate models, bird richness and forest structural parameters explained variations in acoustic diversity equally well as forest patch size. Although the relative effects of patch size, bird richness and habitat heterogeneity are difficult to disentangle, acoustic diversity can be a useful proxy to study effects of forest fragmentation as it is subjected to a similar combination of drivers as traditionally surveyed metrics of biodiversity. • Key policy insights • This study provides evidence that indices on acoustic diversity relate to vocalizing species diversity and forest structure, making these indices a useful tool to study biodiversity processes. • This study confirms that decreasing habitat size correlates with decreasing biodiversity, for the first time including acoustic diversity as one aspect of biodiversity. • This study underlines the importance of preserving forest patches in agricultural landscapes as refuges for biodiversity. Biodiversity can be enhanced by increasing forest patch size, reducing fragmentation and increasing habitat quality through enhancing structural diversity.
View
View
Landscape metrics as indicators of avian community structures – A state of the art review
Article
Full-text available
In this state-of-the-art review, we investigate the use of landscape metrics in landscape ecology studies to predict structure of avian communities. We reviewed papers published in international peer-reviewed journals indexed by Web of Science Core, from January 2010 to December 2021. We give an overview of the study methods used in the past twelve years, the type of landscapes investigated, and the most important landscape metrics that show a significant influence on the ecological parameters of bird community distribution. We demonstrate that study designs are highly variable and thus only comparable to a limited extent. We identify multiple factors of spatial data usage that are important in determining the characterisation of landscape pattern and affect the outcome of analysis in landscape ecology that need to be standardised to allow simplification and generalization of results. Few empirical studies exist which describe the indicator value of landscape metrics comprehensively, taking into account different spatial scales, thematic resolution, landscapes and species, and the need for conducting such surveys in order to be able to use landscape metrics as a biodiversity monitoring tool in a targeted way.
View
Biodiversité potentielle dans les forêts du Vercors : une approche hiérarchique pour la conservation des espaces forestiers
Thesis
  • Jan 2012
Le déclin de la biodiversité lié à l’augmentation des pressions sur les ressources naturelles, fait l’objet d’un large consensus. Cette situation souligne un besoin urgent de développer des outils de diagnostic et de suivi de l’état de la biodiversité qui soient spatialisés, rapides à mettre en ½uvre, peu coûteux et qui permettent de réaliser des expertises à l’échelle des territoires. Une des hypothèses centrales en écologie est qu’il existe des relations positives entre l’hétérogénéité spatiale mesurée dans la mosaïque paysagère et la richesse en espèces qui peut y cohabiter à différentes échelles. Dans ce travail, nous nous appuyons sur cette hypothèse pour développer un Indice de Biodiversité Spécifique Potentielle afin de réaliser un diagnostic de l’état de la biodiversité dans la mosaïque paysagère intra-forestière à différentes échelles, en prenant l’exemple du massif du Vercors. Cet indice s’appuie sur des indicateurs et des critères capables de refléter le niveau de biodiversité potentiellement présente dans une zone géographique donnée, et permet d’approfondir les connaissances sur les relations entre la structure des peuplements, les caractéristiques de la mosaïque forestière et la richesse ou la répartition géographique des espèces. Les étapes clés de la méthodologie et de son évaluation sont valorisées sous forme d’articles. La représentation spatiale de la biodiversité potentielle à différentes échelles permet d’envisager de nombreuses applications dans les domaines de la conservation et de la gestion forestière multifonctionnelle.
View
Influence des indicateurs paysagers et de leur échelle d’intégration sur l’habitat d’une espèce avienne : conséquences sur la modélisation de la qualité de l’habitat de la Gélinotte des bois dans une perspective de gestion conservatoire
Thesis
  • Jan 2012
Dans le contexte du changement global et de la perte de la biodiversité, la prise en compte de cette dernière dans la gestion forestière reste encore très générale (embryonnaire). Les démarches ne sont pas encore opérationnelles alors que les gestionnaires ont besoin d'outils destinés directement à la planification. Ainsi, il est devenu urgent d'améliorer les approches d'évaluation et de suivi de la biodiversité et de développer un cadre conceptuel à partir des indicateurs biologiques qui puissent servir dans la prise de décisions. Ce travail repose sur une approche associant l'enjeu de conservation d'une espèce sauvage patrimoniale dans un paysage de montagne à la maîtrise d'une gestion forestière qui détermine la qualité de son habitat. Dans le cadre concret de la gestion forestière d'un Parc Naturel Régional où les enjeux sont multiples (écologiques, économiques, touristiques), les acteurs concernés s'interrogent moins sur le "comment gérer" que sur le "où gérer" ; en d'autres termes, définir les périmètres de bonne qualité d'habitat est nécessaire afin d'optimiser la gestion à l'échelle optimale. Notre travail est de procurer des outils aux gestionnaires et de poser les jalons scientifiques d'une approche holistique inspirée de l'écologie du paysage. Nous partons ainsi de l'hypothèse selon laquelle les variables environnementales ainsi que la structure du paysage influencent la présence d'une espèce indicatrice de la diversité biologique d'un milieu. Dans ce travail nous nous appuyons sur cette hypothèse pour développer une démarche spatialement explicite qui permettrait d'atteindre l'objectif de conservation dans le cadre d'un processus de gestion forestière adaptative, en étudiant le cas de la gélinotte des bois (Tetrastes bonasia L. 1758) dans le Parc Naturel Régional de Grande Chartreuse (Alpes françaises). Ce modèle prédictif de l'occurrence de la Gélinotte des bois en Chartreuse s'appuie sur des indicateurs environnementaux et paysagers aisément mesurables et spatialisables. Ceci permettra d'établir un diagnostic de la qualité de l'habitat, d'approfondir les connaissances sur les relations entre la structure du paysage et l'espèce à différentes échelles et de déterminer les secteurs d'habitat qui sont les plus appropriés à la Gélinotte des bois en zone de montagne. La représentation spatiale de l'hétérogénéité à différentes échelles permet d'envisager de nombreuses applications dans les domaines de la conservation et de la gestion forestière multifonctionnelle. Nos résultats, relevant d'une approche spatialement explicite, valident l'hypothèse selon laquelle la qualité de l'habitat de la Gélinotte peut être modélisée avec une précision acceptable uniquement à partir d'indices paysagers, s'ils sont calculés sur la bonne étendue. Ils constituent donc une avancée pour une aide à la gestion, puisqu'ils préfigurent un outil permettant la localisation de zones prioritaires sur lesquelles la conservation de la Gélinotte (Tetrastes bonasia) peut être optimisée.
View
Caractérisation de l’hétérogénéité spatiale de milieux naturels à partir d’imagerie optique très haute résolution spatiale : cas d’application aux milieux méditerranéens de garrigue
Thesis
Full-text available
  • May 2019
La préservation de la biodiversité est un enjeu prioritaire, identifié aussi bien au niveau national qu’au niveau européen et international. L’hétérogénéité spatiale des milieux naturels est l’une des composantes clefs pour l’étude de la biodiversité et permet de comprendre le fonctionnement des écosystèmes. Le bassin Méditerranéen est un hotspot de biodiversité pour lequel le lien entre biodiversité et hétérogénéité spatiale des paysages s’illustre particulièrement bien. Les milieux méditerranéens s'organisent en mosaïques hétérogènes de quatre strates verticales: le sol nu, l’herbe, les ligneux bas et les ligneux hauts. La biodiversité de ces milieux est aujourd'hui menacée par une fermeture de milieux naturels qui entraîne la disparition de certains habitats et l’homogénéisation des paysages, homogénéisation qui entraîne elle-même une augmentation des risques d’incendies.Cette thèse se propose de développer des indices caractérisant l’hétérogénéité spatiale des milieux naturels dans un contexte méditerranéen à partir d’images de télédétection à très haute résolution. Parmi les différentes méthodes permettant de caractériser l'hétérogénéité, la méthode FOTO (FOurier Based Textural Ordination) est particulièrement intéressante car elle produit de façon non supervisée un nombre limité de gradients de texture non corrélés, à partir desquels il est possible de décrire les variations continues de l’hétérogénéité spatiale, et ce, à plusieurs échelles spatiales. Ainsi le premier objectif de cette thèse est de tester le potentiel des gradients de texture issus de la méthode FOTO pour la caractérisation de l’hétérogénéité spatiale relative aux quatre strates verticales caractéristiques des milieux méditerranéens. Le deuxième objectif est de tester la sensibilité de l’approche développée à des facteurs techniques et environnementaux, afin de s’assurer de sa réplicabilité pour favoriser son utilisation dans un contexte opérationnel de suivi des milieux méditerranéens. Enfin, le dernier objectif est de valider la pertinence écologique des indices d’hétérogénéité développés à travers un cas d’application~: la caractérisation de la répartition spatiale d’espèces d’oiseaux sensibles à l’hétérogénéité de la végétation.Combinés avec un indice de végétation, le NDVI, les indices de texture issus de la méthode FOTO ont pu être interprétés en termes d'hétérogénéité spatiale et ont permis de caractériser la composition et l'organisation des quatre strates verticales étudiées. Ces indices sont influencés par la présence de surfaces anthropisées comme les cultures ainsi que par la nature de l'information radiométrique des images de télédétection utilisées, qui impacte le contraste apparent des strates de végétation. Ainsi, l'application de la méthode sur une bande panchromatique est plus sensible aux motifs liés à l'alternance de sol nu et d'herbe tandis que l'application de la méthode sur le NDVI est plus sensible aux motifs lié à l'alternance des ligneux avec la strate herbacée. Enfin, nous avons montré l’intérêt de l’approche développée pour la prédiction de plusieurs espèces d’oiseaux à fort enjeux de conservation. Les indices d’hétérogénéité ont permis de mettre en évidence des structures de la végétation particulièrement favorables à certaines espèces d’oiseaux.L'approche développée dans cette thèse est particulièrement intéressante car elle permet la production non supervisée de trois indices complémentaires caractérisant plusieurs composantes de l'hétérogénéité spatiale relatives à quatre strates. Des efforts sont encore nécessaires pour améliorer i) notre compréhension de la contribution de facteurs environnementaux et instrumentaux sur la stabilité de l'approche et ii) son automatisation en vue d'une application dans un contexte opérationnel pour la cartographie et le suivi de l'état de conservation des habitats naturels et de l'avifaune.
View
View
View
A Physiognomic and Structural Analysis of Vegetation
Chapter
  • Jan 1988
This chapter presents a system of analyzing the physiognomy and structure of vegetation in detail as it is used by the Vegetation mapper.
View
The Theory of Island Biogeography
Article
  • Jan 1967
This book had its origin when, about five years ago, an ecologist (MacArthur) and a taxonomist and zoogeographer (Wilson) began a dialogue about common interests in biogeography. The ideas and the language of the two specialties seemed initially so different as to cast doubt on the usefulness of the endeavor. But we had faith in the ultimate unity of population biology, and this book is the result. Now we both call ourselves biogeographers and are unable to see any real distinction between biogeography and ecology.
View
View
The problems with multi-species conservation: do hotspots, ideal reserves and existing reserves coincide?
Article
  • Jan 1995
The investigation of six vertebrate taxa (viz freshwater fish, frogs, tortoises and terrapins, snakes, birds, and various mammal orders) at a national scale reveals that hotspots of species richness, endemism and rarity are not coincident within taxa. In order to design a more representative reserve system to protect all vertebrate species, a complementarity algorithm was applied to all taxa, combined and separately. The combined analysis yielded more efficient results (66 reserves are required to represent all 1074 species at least once) than the separate analyses (97 reserves). Many of these representative reserves coincide with both hotspots and existing reserves, and over 85% of the hotspots of most taxa coincide with existing reserves; thus South Africa's vertebrate fauna could be more effectively protected with only moderate acquisition of new, well-sited reserves. -from Author
View
View
FRAGSTATS—Spatial Pattern Analysis Program for Quantifying Landscape Structure
Article
  • Aug 1995
This report describes a program, FRAGSTATS, developed to quantify landscape structure. Two separate versions of FRAGSTATS exist: one for vector images and one for raster images. In this report, each metric calculated by GRAGSTATS is described in terms of its ecological application and limitations. Example landscapes are included, and a discussion is provided of each metric as it relates to the sample landscapes. -from Authors
View
View
View