ArticlePDF Available

Xerosis of the feet: A comparative study on the effectiveness of two moisturizers

MA Healthcare
British Journal of Community Nursing
Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The treatment for xerosis (dry skin) is the repeated use of moisturizers to hydrate the skin. Their use is based on sound evidence of the importance of maintaining the skin's water content. Although the skin on the plantar surface of the foot is very thick, it is highly visco-elastic and copes with high levels of frictional, compressive and shear stresses applied to it by being supple and well hydrated. Problems arise when the skin becomes dry and loses its elastic properties. Fissures can occur which are often painful and can act as portals for infection. This article describes a double-blind clinical study to evaluate and compare the effectiveness of two commonly used moisturizers and to see if one was significantly better than the other at hydrating the skin of the feet. The two creams used were Aqueous Cream BP and CCS Foot Care Cream. Skin hydration levels were measured before any application of moisturizer and again after two weeks of twice daily application. Results showed that the regular use of both moisturizers had a significant hydrating effect on the skin. However, CCS Foot Care Cream had a significantly greater hydrating effect than Aqueous Cream BP.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Title two-deck
Xerosis of the feet: a comparative study
on the effectiveness of two moisturizers
Paul Baalham, Ivan Birch, Maria Young, Clare Beale
Paul Baalham is a podiatrist working in private practice, Sheerness, Kent; Ivan Birch is Pro Dean of the Faculty of Health &
Human Sciences, Thames Valley University; Maria Young is Senior lecturer BSc(Hons) Podiatry, School of Health Professions,
University of Brighton; Clare Beale is a podiatrist working in private practice, Horsted Keynes, West Sussex
Email: paulbaalham@aol.com
ABSTRACT
The treatment for xerosis (dry skin) is the repeated use of moisturizers to
hydrate the skin. Their use is based on sound evidence of the importance
of maintaining the skin’s water content. Although the skin on the plantar
surface of the foot is very thick, it is highly visco-elastic and copes with
high levels of frictional, compressive and shear stresses applied to it by
being supple and well hydrated. Problems arise when the skin becomes dry
and loses its elastic properties. Fissures can occur which are often painful
and can act as portals for infection. This article describes a double-blind
clinical study to evaluate and compare the effectiveness of two commonly
used moisturizers and to see if one was significantly better than the other at
hydrating the skin of the feet. The two creams used were Aqueous Cream
BP and CCS Foot Care Cream. Skin hydration levels were measured before
any application of moisturizer and again after two weeks of twice daily
application. Results showed that the regular use of both moisturizers had a
significant hydrating effect on the skin. However, CCS Foot Care Cream had
a significantly greater hydrating effect than Aqueous Cream BP.
KEY WORDS
Xerosis w Skin w Moisturizer w Feet w Podiatry w Hydration
The use of moistur izers is based on sound evidence
of the importance of maintaining the water con-
tent of the skin (Rees, 2002). Dry skin can be
treated with a range of creams and ointments, and normally
aqueous cream or Diprobase is the first line of treatment
(Nazarko, 2007). These products are described as being light
and easily absorbed but people with very dry skin may
require different preparations. Choice is often made on the
basis of patient preference, or according to the health pro-
fessional’s individual choice (Holden et al, 2002). Decisive
factors can include how the emollient feels, or simply its
cost. Moistur izers with emollients should be promoted as a
preventative measure to keep the epidermal barr ier intact
(Peters, 2006). Emollients support the integrity of the lipid
barrier, potentially reducing immunoglobulin-triggered
events including infections (Peters, 2006).
Making decisions regarding the choice of which topi-
cal preparation to use as a moisturizer is difficult for the
health professional and patient alike, owing to the lack of
good quality evidence on their effectiveness or an adequate
comparison of the various compositions (Rees, 2002;
Clark, 2004).
Xerosis of the feet
Xerosis is the medical term for dry skin, and almost eve-
ryone will suffer episodes of xerosis at some stage in their
life (Voegli, 2007). It is associated with both skin thick-
ening and skin thinning, and is triggered by exogenous
(e.g. climate, environment, lifestyle) and endogenous (e.g.
medication, hormone fluctuations, organ disease) factors
(Chiodo, 2008).
Because the hydration of the surface tissue on the plantar
aspect of the foot relies solely on the secretions from the
sweat glands (Baird et al, 2003; Wood et al, 2008), it is
evident that any disturbance or lack of sweat production
would be problematic. A person who has a decrease or
loss of function of the sweat glands on the plantar surface
of the foot will experience xerosis of the feet (Pham et al,
2002). Xerosis is the main complication associated with
anhydrosis, an abnormal condition characterized by inad-
equate perspiration causing the skin to become excessively
dry (Anderson, 1998). Many instances of anhydrosis result
from poor peripheral blood supply in the elderly or in
diabetic patients with autonomic neuropathy (Pham et al,
2002; Tyrrell, 2002). Where this is the cause, O’Donnell et al
(2002) stated that there is little more that can be done other
than to apply emollients regularly. It is generally believed
that decreased autonomic function in the feet can lead to
drying, cracking, fissure formation (Figure 1), infection and
possible ulcer formation. Lubrication of the feet is impor-
tant to prevent this from happening (Greene et al, 1999).
British Journal of Community Nursing Vol 16, No 12 591
CLINICAL FOCUS
Figure 1. Heel fissures (cracks) due to xerosis
DermNetNZ.org
TOPIC HEADER
592 British Journal of Community Nursing Vol ?, No
CLINICAL FOCUS
592 British Journal of Community Nursing Vol 16, No 12
Xerosis can become a considerable problem causing much
pain and disability.
The differences between xerosis and healthy skin are
evident on examination. Dry skin will appear dull, often
with a flaky surface and patchy white areas. If severely dry,
cracks and fissures may be visible and the surrounding skin
may appear red indicating the presence of inflammation
and possibly secondary infection. Dry skin feels rough and
uneven, and the patient may experience a feeling of tight-
ness; this may be accompanied by sensory changes such as
tingling, itching or even stinging pain (Voegli, 2007).
Treatments for xerosis
Dry skin can be treated with a range of moisturizing prod-
ucts. Moisturizers contain varying combinations of emol-
lients, occlusives, and humectants to achieve their beneficial
effects (Kraft and Lynde, 2005). They are used to replace
natural skin oils, to cover tiny fissures, and to provide a
soothing protective film (Lynde, 2001).
Although water is the principal plasticizer of the stra-
tum corneum, the water within a topical moisturizer only
delivers a transient moisturization effect; it is the other
components of the product that truly define the level of
benefit to the hydration and health of the skin (Rawlings
et al, 2004). The terms moisturizer (to add moisture) and
emollient (to soften), appear to be interchangeable in com-
mon usage as they both serve to hydrate the skin (Chiodo,
2008). However, moisturizers often contain emollients and,
together with occlusives and humectants, are the mainstay
ingredients in cosmetic treatment preparations (Rawlings
et al, 2004).
Emollients sooth, smooth and hydrate the skin and are
indicated for all dry skin and scaling disorders (British
National Formulary (BNF), 2005). They are mainly lipids
and oils that hydrate and improve the skin’s appearance by
contributing to the skin’s softness, enhanced flexibility, and
smoothness (Kraft and Lynde, 2005). However, their effec-
tiveness is short-lived and they must be applied frequently
even after the skin improves (BNF, 2005).
Occlusives reduce transepidermal water loss (TEWL)
by physically blocking and creating a hydrophobic (water-
repelling) barrier over the stratum corneum and contrib-
uting to the matrix between corneocytes (Lynde, 2001).
Occlusives are most effective when applied to dampened
skin (Kraft and Lynde, 2005). They provide the skin with
a layer of oil to slow the rate of TEWL owing to evapora-
tion, and thus, increase the water content of the stratum
corneum (Chiodo, 2008).
Humectants have the ability to attract and hold water in
the skin. They enhance water absorption by acting on the
inside out, from the dermis to the epidermis and ultimately
the stratum corneum. They also enhance water absorption
from the outside in, drawing moisture from the external
environment to the skin (Rawlings et al, 2004; Kraft and
Lynde, 2005).
Common humectants used in emollients are:
w Glycerin (glycerol)
w Urea
w Lactic acid
w Propylene glycol
w Sodium pyrrolidone carboxylic acid
w Ammonium lactate
w Potassium lactate
w Sorbitol.
While aqueous (i.e. water-based) creams and emollients
are often the first line of treatment, urea-based creams have
been shown to significantly improve skin hydration (Baird
et al, 2003; Baker and Rayman, 2008). CCS Foot Care
Cream contains 10% urea. Both CCS Foot Care Cream
and Aqueous Cream BP can be bought without prescrip-
tion from chemists.
Aims of the study
The objective of this double-blind quantitative study was
to evaluate and compare the effectiveness of two read-
ily available moisturizers: Aqueous Cream BP (Pinewood
Laboratories Ltd, Tipperary, Ireland) and CCS Foot Care
Cream (EC DeWitt & Co Ltd, Warrington, England) in the
treatment of xerosis of the feet.
Figure 2. The Digital Moisture Monitor for Skin (Shenzhen Jinsuifeng
Plastic Model Manufacture Co, Ltd).
Figure 3. Site of measurement
TOPIC HEADER
594 British Journal of Community Nursing Vol 16, No 12
CLINICAL FOCUS
It aimed to determine:
w If each moisturizer had a significant hydrating effect on
the skin of the feet
w If one moisturizer produced a significantly greater
hydrating effect than the other moisturizer on the skin
of the feet, or
w If neither moisturizer had a significant hydrating effect
on the skin of the feet.
The sample group comprised 15 female patients with
xerosis of the feet who attended the researcher’s private
clinic in Sheerness, Kent, UK. Participation in the trial was
wholly voluntary and patients were recruited from those
who responded to a poster placed in the clinic explaining
that volunteers were required to test the efficacy of two
different types of foot cream in the treatment of dry skin.
Participants were asked to apply one moisturizer to one
foot and another moisturizer to the other foot twice daily
for a period of two weeks. Skin hydration levels were
measured prior to starting the regime and again afterwards.
Comparisons were made pre- and post-application to
determine the differences, if any, on the effectiveness of the
two creams in terms of skin hydration.
Ethical approval was obtained from the University of
Brighton School of Health Professions, School Research
Ethics and Governance Panel (SREGP).
For inclusion in the trial, patients had to be adult, present
with bilateral xerosis of the feet (determined by visual
appearance) and be clinically healthy. Patients with known
allergies, skin disease and lesions on the feet were excluded.
The hydration level of the stratum cor neum was meas-
ured with a digital moisture monitor for skin (Figure 2).
This device works by measuring the skin’s electrical resist-
ance, or what the manufacturers call bioelectric imped-
ance analysis (BIA) technology. It gives a digital reading in
percentages of the skin’s water content and has a range of
0–99.9%. It has a claimed accuracy of 0.5% and is powered
by two AAA batteries. Other measur ing instruments were
considered but were simply outside the price range for
this project. The digital moisture monitor was found to be
inexpensive, easy to use and adequate for the purpose of
this trial.
The raw data from the hydration measurements taken
from the left (L) and right (R) feet pre and post two weeks
of twice daily moisturizer application were entered into
tables in an Excel spreadsheet on a computer for analysis.
The means and standard deviations were calculated to
show the statistical average (norm) and the range of disper-
sion of the raw data. The student t-test was chosen as a way
of testing the null hypothesis; in this case the null hypoth-
esis was that there is no significant difference between the
effectiveness of two different moisturizers in the treatment
of xerosis of the feet. The t-test assesses whether the means
of two groups are statistically different from each other.
Once a t value is determined, a probability (p value) can
be found. By looking for significance of p<0.05 we have a
95% chance of the means being significantly different, thus
allowing the null hypothesis to be rejected.
A significant difference was looked for in:
w The difference between the hydration levels L and R pre
two weeks of cream application
w The difference between the hydration levels pre and post
two weeks of cream application L
w The difference between the hydration levels pre and
post two weeks of cream application R
w The difference between the hydration levels L and R
post two weeks of cream application.
Method
Participants were asked to confirm they had not applied any
topical preparations to their feet for seven days. This was to
ensure that the first measurements were taken with the skin
in its natural, uncontaminated condition. Participants were
allowed to wash their feet as usual.
Before measurements were taken, participants were
requested to remove their footwear and allow their feet to
be exposed to the air for 15 minutes. This was to allow any
surface sweat to evaporate.
Skin hydration measurements were then taken using the
digital moisture monitor on both feet.
All measurements were taken from as near possible the
same site on all the patients (Figure 3). The centre of the
dorsal aspect of the foot was chosen as this proved to be
the most reliable in obtaining repeatable readings with the
digital moisture monitor.
Participants were given a tube of both the test moistur-
izers and instructed to apply the creams twice daily for
a period of two weeks, then return to the clinic. A two-
week period of application was felt to be adequate for this
trial. Baird et al (2003) used a six-week period for their
trial comparing two types of urea-based creams. However,
Lodén and Wessman (2001) measured a significant increase
in skin hydration using a moisturizer containing glycer ine
after only ten days.
To make this a double-blind trial a third party had previ-
ously masked the names on the tubes of creams with tape
and relabelled them ‘R’ (‘right’) and ‘L (‘left’). Information
regarding which cream was in which tube was kept in a
locked cabinet. Only after the trial was it revealed which
cream was used on which foot.
To prevent cross-contamination when applying the
creams, patients were requested to apply the cream labelled
L to the left foot with the right hand, and the cream
labelled R to the right foot with the left hand
After 14 days of twice-daily moistur izer application, the
participants returned to the clinic to have their skin hydra-
tion measurements taken, again after allowing the feet to be
exposed to the air for 15 minutes.
Results
On completion of the trial it was revealed that the cream
applied to the left feet was CCS Foot Care Cream, and the
cream applied to the right feet was Aqueous Cream BP.
All measurements were taken using the digital moisture
monitor, which measured skin hydration and gave readings
TOPIC HEADER
British Journal of Community Nursing Vol 16, No12 595
TOPIC HEADERTOPIC HEADER CLINICAL FOCUS
as percentages of water content in the stratum corneum
(SC).
The means and standard deviations were calculated from
the raw data. Statistical comparisons were made using the
one tailed, paired student’s t-test in Microsoft Office Excel
and significance was set at p<0.05.
Baseline skin hydration measurements were taken at
the start of the trial prior to the first application of any
moisturizer.
Table 1 shows the mean, standard deviation and t-test
results of the percentage readings of SC water content taken
from the left and right feet pre-moisturizer application.
Analysis of the differences between left and right base-
line measurements taken at the start of the tr ial showed a
p value of 0.393 (p>0.05) and therefore, no significant dif-
ference between left and right feet was seen in the subjects
before the first application of any moisturizer.
Figure 4 shows the percentage readings of SC water
content taken pre-cream application of the left and right
feet for each participant. No significant difference was seen
between the left and right feet prior to the first application
of moisturizer (p>0.05).
Skin hydration measurements were taken after two weeks
of twice-daily cream application and compared against the
baseline measurements. There was a significant increase
(p<0.05) in skin hydration seen in both feet.
Comparisons were made between skin hydration meas-
urements of the left feet after two weeks of twice-daily
application of CCS Foot Care Cream and the right feet
after two weeks of twice daily application of Aqueous
Cream BP.
Table 2 shows the mean, standard deviation and t-test
results of the percentage readings of SC water content of
both feet after two weeks of twice-daily application of
creams.
Figure 5 shows the percentage readings of SC water con-
tent of the left and right feet post two weeks of twice-daily
application of cream. Hydration percentages were found to
be higher in the left foot of every subject after two weeks’
moisturizer use.
The results show that both CCS Foot Care Cream and
Aqueous BP cream significantly improved skin hydration,
with the differences between baseline measurements and
post-application measurements giving a p value of <0.05.
However, after comparing the differences in measurements
of both feet after two weeks of twice-daily moisturizer
application, it was found that the CCS Foot Care Cream,
which had been applied to the left feet, had a significantly
greater hydrating effect than Aqueous Cream BP which
had been applied to the right.
The results indicate that there is a significant difference
between the effectiveness of two different moisturizers in
the treatment of xerosis of the feet.
Discussion
Comparing the results
Both Aqueous Cream BP and CCS Foot Care Cream
resulted in a significant increase in skin hydration. However,
the CCS Foot Care Cream increased skin hydration signifi-
cantly more than the Aqueous Cream BP.
The application of both creams showing significant
improvement in skin hydration (p<0.05) after two weeks
of twice-daily application would seem to agree with
O’Donnell et al (2002) when they say that the choice
of emollient for the treatment of xerosis matters little,
as the purpose is to prevent moisture loss from the skin,
and it is the regular daily application that is important.
Schwartz et al (2009) agreed, saying that almost any
emollient will provide symptomatic relief for mild xero-
sis, but added that for moderate xerosis, humectant and
occlusive systems may provide a more active mechanism
to hydrate the stratum corneum. They also stated that for
moderate to severe xerosis, alpha hydroxyl acids (AHAs)
and/or lactate offer the superior therapy. Although
effective moisturizers/emollients can improve dry skin
conditions immediately, their effects are often thought
of as being transient, because the materials applied to
the stratum corneum are easily shed from the skin sur-
face by the daily desquamation process. However, there
is some clinical, as well as experimental, evidence sug-
gesting that, once application of effective moisturizers is
repeated daily, it may produce persistent effects without
being influenced by the desquamation of the skin surface
(Tabata et al, 2000).
Table 1. Water content readings pre-moisturization
Left feet pre moisturizer application Right feet pre moisturizer application
Mean 19.02 19.13
Standard deviation 2.29 2.82
p value 0.393
Table 2. Water content readings after two weeks of twice-daily moisturization
Left feet post-moisturizer application Right feet post-moisturizer application
Mean 32.61 27.53
Standard deviation 6.59 4.97
p value <0.001
TOPIC HEADER
596 British Journal of Community Nursing Vol 16, No 12
CLINICAL FOCUS
Serup et al (1989) also report a long-lasting hydrating
effect after twice-daily applications of a moisturizer for
seven days, reporting an increase in hydration even after
one week of the last moisturizer application. This trial
showed that both creams significantly improved skin hydra-
tion of the feet but it did not show how long the hydrating
effect lasted.
Central to their efficacy, moisturizers are designed to
improve stratum corneum hydration (Crowther et al, 2008).
Although both the test creams gave a significant improve-
ment in skin hydration, CCS Foot Care Cream had a sig-
nificantly greater hydrating effect which could potentially
be attributed to the cream’s ingredients.
Active ingredients
The active ingredients in Aqueous Cream BP are liquid
paraffin 6% w/w and white soft paraffin 15% w/w; these
act as occlusives that physically block and slow the rate of
transepidermal water loss. They also have emollient proper-
ties that smooth the skin by filling in the spaces between
the corneocytes (Schwartz et al, 2009). Cetostearyl alco-
hol and sodium laurilsulfate are other ingredients and are
emulsifiers which also have emollient properties. Aqueous
Cream BP contains no listed humectant.
The active ingredients of CCS Foot Care Cream are
paraffinum liquidum (liquid paraffin) 18.5%, which is an
occlusive, and glycerin 13.32% and urea 10% which are
humectants. It also contains an unpublished percentage of
lactic acid which acts as a pH regulator and is often found
in moisturizers in the form of alpha hydroxyl acid (AHA).
Alpha hydroxyl acid is a good humectant and exfoliating
agent of the epidermis that sloughs off the dry skin cells
and promotes new skin growth (Pham et al, 2002; Schwartz
et al, 2009).
CCS also contains cetyl alcohol and stearyl alcohol,
which are both emulsifiers with emollient properties.
Both creams contained preservatives which are includ-
ed in formulations to kill or inhibit the growth of
microorganisms introduced during use or manufacturing
(Lodén, 2005). Only CCS cream contained any fragrance
(Eucalyptus globulus and limonene).
Most moisturizers contain a combination of emollients,
occlusives and humectants. When occlusives and humect-
ants are combined, the water-holding capacity of the skin
is enhanced (Kraft and Lynde, 2005). Moisturizers serve
to return water to the skin, not only by the water con-
tent contained within the formulation, but also through
the humectants attracting water from the lower layers of
the epidermis into the stratum corneum, and occlusive
ingredients preventing transepidermal water loss (Flynn et
al, 2001).
Both creams used in this trial contained similar amounts
of occlusive and emollient ingredients. Aqueous Cream BP
had 21% (made up of liquid and soft white paraffin) and
CCS Foot Care Cream had slightly less at 18.5% (liquid
paraffin). The important difference between the creams
was the humectant ingredients in the CCS Foot Care
Cream. From the small sample used in this trial it appears
that a cream which contains a combination of humectants,
exfoliating agent (AHA), emollients and occlusives is bet-
ter at hydrating the skin than a moisturizer containing just
occlusives and emollients.
Limitations
It is recognized that not all of the participants may have
stuck rigidly to the protocol for the application of the
cream, even though all reported that they had, and this may
have some influence on the results. It is also recognized that
the trial is underpowered regarding the subject numbers.
The importance of moisturizers
Lodén (2005) states that many health professionals and
patients overlook the importance of moisturizers in main-
taining an intact healthy skin and do not consider them to
be ‘active treatments’. She goes on to say that the health
professional’s role should emphasize continuity of care,
patient satisfaction and product selection, which are all
Figure 4. Hydration levels before moisturization
Figure 5. Hydration levels after 2 weeks of moisturization
British Journal of Community Nursing Vol 16, No 12 597
TOPIC HEADERCLINICAL FOCUS
vital to protecting skin integrity and enhancing the qual-
ity of life. The frequent use of moisturizers supports the
epidermal barrier and reduces the potential for infection
and inflammation.
Although moisturizers play an important (but underesti-
mated) role in the treatment and ongoing management of
dry skin conditions (Voegli, 2007), choosing a moisturizer
can be difficult for both the health professional and patient
alike owing to the huge array of moisturizers in the mar-
ketplace (Kraft and Lynde, 2005). This study has shown that
regular application of a moisturizer is beneficial in hydrat-
ing the skin in patients with xerosis and that difference
in the formulations can have a greater or lesser hydrating
effect. The more understanding the health professional has
regarding the actions of the various ingredients within for-
mulations, the better equipped they will be in prescribing
what is most suitable for the patient with xerosis.
Conclusion
This study achieved its aims by showing that there is a
significant difference between the effectiveness of two dif-
ferent moisturizers in the treatment of xerosis of the feet
in women. The results showed that CCS Foot Care Cream
had a significantly greater hydrating affect than Aqueous
Cream BP. However, what was also demonstrated clearly in
the results was that both moisturizers achieved significant
improvement in skin hydration when applied frequently.
It can be suggested from the results of this study that for
mild cases of xerosis of the feet, either of the two creams
trialled may be suitable if applied frequently. However, for
drier skin conditions CCS Foot Care Cream, with its com-
bination of humectant, emollient and occlusive ingredients,
would be more suitable due to its higher hydrating effect.
On the basis of this study, it is recommended by the
researcher that regular applications of CCS Foot Care
Cream be used for the treatment of xerosis of the feet, in
preference to Aqueous Cream BP. BJCN
Anderson KN (1998) Mosby’s Medical, Nursing, and Allied Health Dictionary. 5th edn.
Mosby-Year Book Inc, USA
Baird SA, Skinner CM, Trail S, Frankis JS (2003) Anhydrosis in the diabetic foot: a
comparison of two urea creams. Diabet Foot J 6(3): 122–36
Baker N, Rayman G (2008) Effects of a urea-based moisturizer on foot xerosis in
people with diabetes. Diabet Foot J 11(2): 179–82
British Medical Association and Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain
(2005) British National Formulary, Number 50. BMJ/RPSGB, London
Chiodo B (2008) The use of emollients in dry skin therapy. J Community Nurs
22(10): 22–6
Clark C (2004) How to choose a suitable emollient. Pharm J 273: 351–3
Crowther JM, Sieg A, Blenkiron P et al (2008) Measuring the effects of topical
moisturizers on changes in stratum corneum thickness, water gradients and
hydration in vivo. Br J Dermatol 159(3): 567–77
Flynn TC, Petros J, Clark RE, Vieham GE (2001) Dry skin and moisturizers. Clin
Dermatol 19(4): 387–92
Greene DA, Stevens MJ, Feldman EL (1999) Diabetic neuropathy: scope of the
syndrome. Am J Med 107(2B): 2S–8S
Holden C, English J, Hoare C et al (2002) Advised best practice for the use of emol-
lients in eczema and other dry skin conditions. J Dermatolog Treat 13(3): 103–6
Kraft JN, Lynde CW (2005) Moisturizers: what they are and a practical approach to
product selection. Skin Therapy Lett 10(5): 1–8
Lodén M (2005) The clinical benefit of moisturizers. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol
19(6): 672–88
Lodén M, Wessman C (2001) The influence of a cream containing 20% glycerin
and its vehicle on skin barrier properties. Int J Cosmet Sci 23(2): 115–19
Lynde CW (2001) Moisturizers: what they are and how they work. Skin Therapy
Lett 6(13): 3–5
Nazarko L (2007) Maintaining the condition of aging skin. Nurs Resid Care 9(4):
160–3
O’Donnell M, Lorimer DL, Forster MSK (2002) Clinical Therapeutics. In: Lorimer
D L, French G, O’Donnell M, Burrow J G, eds. Neal’s Disorders of the Foot: diagno-
sis and management. 6th edn. Churchill Livingstone, London: 431
Peters J (2006) Exploring the use of emollient therapy in dermatological nursing.
Br J Community Nurs 11(5): 194–201
Pham HT, Exelbert L, Segal-Owens AC, Veves A (2002) A prospective, randomized,
controlled double-blind study of a moisturizer for xerosis of the feet in patients
with diabetes. Ostomy Wound Manage 48(5): 30–6
Rawlings AV, Canestrari DA, Dobkowski B (2004) Moisturizer technology versus
clinical performance. Dermatol Ther 17(s1): 49–56
Rees M (2002) Managing atopic eczema. Prim Health Care 12(8): 27–37
Schwartz AR, Centurion SA, Thomas I (2009) Moisturizers. eMedicine
Dermatology http://tinyurl.com/7zcgjrt (accessed 17 November 2011)
Serup J, Winther A, Blichman CW (1989) Effects of repeated application of a mois-
turizer. Acta Derm Venereol 69(5): 457–9
Tabata N, O’Goshi K, Zhen YX, Kligman AM, Tagami H (2000) Biophysical assess-
ment of persistent effects of moisturizers after their daily applications: evaluation
of corneotherapy. Dermatology 200(4): 308–13
Tyrrell W (2002) Podiatric Management Of The Elderly. In: Lorimer DL, French G,
O’Donnell M, Burrow JG, eds. Neal’s Disorders of the Foot: diagnosis and manage-
ment. 6th edn. Churchill Livingstone, London: 187
Voegli D (2007) The role of emollients in the care of patients with dry skin. Nurs
Stand 22(7): 62–8
Wood BC, Kirman CN, Molnar JA (2008) Skin, Grafts. eMedicine http://tinyurl.
com/cy6kdcx (accessed 17 November 2011)
LEARNING POINTS
w Xerosis of the feet can cause cracks (fissures) around the heels and under
the big toe which can often be painful and lead to infection
w Frequent use of moisturizers help maintain the skin’s barrier function,
reducing the potential for infection and inflammation by improving its
hydration
w A moisturizer containing a humectant, such as urea, was shown to be
significantly better at hydrating the skin of the feet than a cream without
w A greater understanding of the various ingredients found in moisturizers
could help health professionals provide their patients with advice on
appropriate moisturizer selection
... 75 Treatment with moisturizers has been shown to be an efficient means of maintaining water content to avoid loss of elasticity, skin cracks, and onset of infectious local wounds. 76 The study by Nasiri et al 51 on the healing effect of olive oil in patients with DFUs demonstrates successful wound healing in part as the result of modulation of skin moisture content. Herbal oils such as canola oil (Brassica napus L.) and sunflower oil (Helianthus ...
Article
A diabetic foot ulcer (DFU) is a chronic, nonhealing wound that occurs in approximately 15% to 25% of patients with diabetes, and amputation is necessary in approximately 5% to 24% of these patients. Medicinal plants have demonstrated promising wound healing activities in animal models of DFUs as well as in clinical studies. These plants, which are described as medicinal in different regions of the world, are not considered to be standard medicinal treatments in Western medicine at this time. Some medicinal products, such as bromelain-an herbal protease currently used for enzymatic debridement of wounds-have been obtained from plants, showing the important role of these natural products as sources of wound healing agents. This paper aims to review clinical studies on the effects of medicinal plants in patients with DFUs based on the improvement of local and systemic parameters related to wound healing. Electronic databases including PubMed, Scopus, and Cochrane Library were searched for studies from inception through May 2019 using the keywords "diabetic foot ulcer" and "plant," "phytochemical," "extract," or "herb." Inclusion criteria were controlled or before-after clinical studies with English-language full-text in which topical or systemic herbal preparations for DFUs were evaluated by considering outcomes such as reduction of wound healing time and wound area, markers of inflammation and oxidative stress, and number of cases requiring amputation. Studies on non-herbal materials and human studies other than clinical trials were excluded. Fourteen studies were included in the present review. Herbal medicines were administered as add-on therapy to standard wound care in the form of topical (cream, gel, oil) or systemic (capsule, decoction, injection) preparations. Parameters such as ulcer width and depth, phagocytic function, tumor necrosis factor α level, epithelialization, vascularization, and wound closure were evaluated in clinical trials, several of which were significantly improved in patients compared with their baseline values or control group. Per the studies included in this review, medicinal plants can be recommended as promising adjuvant therapies to conventional wound care to accelerate wound healing in patients with DFUs.
... In a review by Parker et al. [64], urea at a concentration of 10-25 % (in some cases, 35-40 %) was associated with impressive outcomes in the treatment of xerosis of the feet: the combination of urea 10 % with paraffin was superior to a purely paraffin-based emollient [65,66]. The combination of urea 10 % with other NMF components, lactate, glycerol, glyceryl glucoside and ceramides has been shown to be superior to treatment with the vehicle alone [67]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background and rationale: Xerosis cutis (also referred to as xeroderma, dry skin, asteatosis) affects more than 10 million individuals in Germany. It is among the most common dermatological diagnoses and a cardinal symptom of many dermatological, internal and neurological diseases. Even though it has been established that basic skin care plays a significant role in the management of patients with xerosis cutis, there are as yet no evidence-based algorithms for diagnosis and treatment. Objective: The present position paper provides physicians across all specialties with a practical, symptom-based approach to the prevention, diagnosis and treatment of xerosis cutis. Methods: Within a structured decision-making process, a panel of experienced dermatologists first defined questions relevant to everyday clinical practice, which were then addressed by a systematic review of the literature. Based on the evidence available as well as expert consensus, diagnostic and treatment algorithms were subsequently developed and agreed upon. Results: Xerosis cutis is generally diagnosed on clinical grounds. Possible trigger factors must be avoided, and comorbidities should be adequately and specifically treated. Suitable skin care products should be chosen with a view to improving skin hydration and restoring its barrier function. They should therefore contain both rehydrating and lipid-replenishing components. The "drier" the skin appears, the greater the lipid content should be (preferably using water-in-oil formulations). The choice of ingredients is based on a patient's individual symptoms, such as scaling (e.g., urea), fissures/rhagades (e.g., urea or dexpanthenol), erythema (e.g., licochalcone A) and pruritus (e.g., polidocanol). Other factors to be considered include the site affected and patient age. Ingredients or rather combinations thereof for which there is good clinical evidence should be preferentially used. The best evidence by far is available for urea, whose efficacy in the treatment of xerosis is further enhanced by combining it with other natural moisturizing components and ceramides. The "xerosimeter" is a tool developed in an effort to facilitate patient management and for training purposes. It not only includes practical tools for diagnosis and follow-up but also a classification of ingredients and a structured treatment algorithm. Conclusion: The structured symptom- and evidence-based approach proposed herein contains a road map for diagnosis and treatment of xerosis cutis. It aims to raise awareness in terms of prevention and early treatment of this condition and may thus improve quality of life and prevent potential sequelae.
... Bei der Therapie der Xerosis pedum zeigte Urea in einer Übersichtsarbeit von Parker et al. [ 64 ] in Konzentration meist von 10-25 % (vereinzelt auch 35-40 %) beeindruckende Ergebnisse: Die Kombination von 10 % Urea mit Paraffi n war einer reinen, Paraffi n-basierten Pfl ege überlegen [ 65,66 ]. Die Kombination von 10 % Urea mit anderen NMF Komponenten, Laktat, Glycerin, Glycerylglucosid und Ceramiden war einer Pfl ege mit dem reinen Vehikel überlegen [ 67 ]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Zusammenfassung 1 Hintergrund und Rationale Die Xerosis cutis (Synonym: Xerodermie, trockene Haut, hydrolipidarme Haut) ist mit > 10 Millionen Betroffenen nicht nur eine der häufigsten dermatologischen Diagnosen in Deutschland, sondern auch Leitsymptom vieler dermatologischer, internistischer und neurologischer Erkrankungen. Trotz der medizinischen Relevanz der topischen Basistherapie für die Xerosis cutis gibt es in Deutschland für ihr Management bisher keinen wissenschaftlich belegten Diagnostik‐ und Therapiealgorithmus. 2 Ziel Dieses Positionspapier vermittelt Ärzten fachübergreifend einen an individuellen Symptomen orientierten, praxisnahen Leitfaden für die Prävention, Diagnostik und Therapie der Xerosis cutis. 3 Methodik Im Rahmen eines strukturierten Entscheidungsprozesses wurden von erfahrenen dermatologischen Experten zunächst praxisrelevante Fragestellungen definiert und systematisch aufgearbeitet. Auf der Basis von Evidenz und Expertenkonsens wurden daraus diagnostische und therapeutische Algorithmen mit Empfehlungen für die Praxis entwickelt und konsentiert. 4 Ergebnis Die Xerosis cutis kann grundsätzlich klinisch diagnostiziert werden. Auslöser und/oder Grunderkrankungen müssen abgeklärt und vermieden bzw. spezifisch behandelt werden. Bei der Wahl der geeigneten Basistherapie ist es wichtig, dass nicht nur die Hauthydratation verbessert, sondern auch die Barrierefunktion der Haut wiederhergestellt wird. Sie sollte daher aus einer Kombination von rückfeuchtenden und rückfettenden Inhaltsstoffen bestehen. Je trockener die Haut, desto lipidhaltiger sollte die Hautpflege sein (bevorzugt Wasser‐in‐Öl‐Formulierungen). Die individuelle Auswahl der Inhaltsstoffe orientiert sich nach kausaler Prüfung an den Symptomen Schuppung (v.a. Urea), Fissuren/Rhagaden (v.a. Urea oder Dexpanthenol), Rötung (v.a. Licochalcone A) und Pruritus (v.a. Polidocanol), sowie an der Lokalisation und dem Alter der Patienten. Inhaltsstoffe bzw. Inhaltsstoffkombinationen mit guter Studienevidenz sind zu bevorzugen. Die mit Abstand beste Evidenz bei der Xerosis cutis weist Urea auf, dessen Wirksamkeit in Kombination mit anderen natürlichen Feuchthalte‐Komponenten und Ceramiden noch gesteigert werden kann. Zur Arbeitserleichterung am Patienten und zum besseren Erlernen wurde das Xerosimeter entwickelt, das die praktische Umsetzung der Diagnostik und Verlaufskontrolle, eine Klassifikation der Inhaltsstoffe und einen strukturierten Therapiealgorithmus enthält. 5 Schlussfolgerung Das hier vorgeschlagene strukturierte symptom‐ und evidenzorientierte Vorgehen mit Diagnostik‐ und Behandlungspfad soll für die Prävention und frühzeitige Behandlung der Xerosis cutis sensibilisieren. Damit können die Lebensqualität verbessert und Folgeerkrankungen verhindert werden.
Chapter
Skin barrier function is dependent on the integrity of the stratum corneum. Xerotic and hyperkeratotic disorders are the result of barrier dysfunction. Hydration and free fatty acids contribute to skin integrity. Increased transepidermal water loss causes dehydration of the stratum corneum. Loss of free fatty acids accompanies the aging process and is accentuated by frequent bathing and harsh detergents. Decreased free fatty acids and dehydration lead to cell contracture. Corneocytes curl upwards creating the clinical appearance of scale.KeywordsCornCallusScaleIPKIchthyosisKeratoderma
Article
Full-text available
Objetivo: analisar a produção científica em enfermagem acerca dos cuidados para a avaliação, prevenção e tratamento da xerose cutânea em idosos.Método: revisão integrativa realizada nas bases Literatura Latino-Americana e do Caribe em Ciências da Saúde, Biblioteca Virtual Scientific Eletronic Library Online, PubMed Central e Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, no período de agosto a dezembro de 2017. Resultados: foram analisados 14 artigos dos quais emergiram três categorias: A hidratação oral e tópica para o cuidado do idoso com xerose cutânea; A utilização de instrumentos e o cuidado a xerose relacionada aos pés; e por fim Medidas de higiene e processos de escolha/indicação de produtos. Conclusão: os cuidados de enfermagem devem estar voltados à educação para o autocuidado com ênfase na hidratação dos pés bem como na indicação e orientação acerca do uso de produtos com a finalidade de minimizar as complicações oriundas da xerose.
Article
Full-text available
El Peu, ISSN 0212-7709, Vol. 37, Nº. 2, 2016, págs. 22-25
Article
Background:: Xerosis (dryness) of the foot is commonly encountered in clinical care and can lead to discomfort, pain, and predisposition to infection. Many moisturizing products are available, with little definitive research to recommend any particular formulation. Methods:: We compared two commonly prescribed moisturizing products from different ends of the price spectrum (sorbolene and 25% urea cream) for their effectiveness in reducing xerosis signs using the Specified Symptom Sum Score. A randomized clinical trial of parallel design was conducted over 28 days (February-May 2015) on 41 participants with simple xerosis. Participants, therapists, assessors, and data entry personnel were blinded to treatment, and allocation was determined via a randomization table. Results:: Thirty-four participants completed the study (19 urea and 15 sorbolene), with one reporting minor adverse effects. There were statistically significant improvements in both groups after 28 days. Mean differences between pre and post scores were 3.50 (95% confidence interval [CI], 2.80 to 4.20) for the urea group and 2.90 (95% CI, 2.00 to 3.80) for the sorbolene group. There was a slightly lower mean posttreatment score in the urea group (1.16; 95% CI, 0.67 to 1.64) than in the sorbolene group (1.80; 95% CI, 1.25 to 2.35), but this difference was not significant ( P ≤ .09). Effect size of difference was -0.48 (95% CI, -1.16 to 0.22). Conclusions:: In this study, there was no difference between using sorbolene or 25% urea cream to treat symptoms of foot xerosis. A recommendation, therefore, cannot be made based on efficacy alone; however, sorbolene treatments are invariably cheaper than urea-based ones.
Thesis
Full-text available
Background: Current studies show a diversity of applied clinical scales for the quantification of xerosis cutis. The use of different scales for the assessment of dry skin aggravates the interpretation and comparison of study results. The objective of this systematic review was to summarize and to systematically evaluate the evidence about the validity and reliability of existing scales for the assessment of xerosis cutis. The primary outcome are measurement properties of the clinical scales and scoring systems for the measurement of xerosis cutis. We included studies in which at least one measurement property has been investigated and reported. Methods: A systematic search was conducted on Embase and MEDLINE, the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials and clinicaltrial.gov. Grey literature was searched and identified through the Mednar, The Grey literature report, Opengrey, GlaxoSmithKline and clinictrials.eu. Reference lists of included articles were screened and forward searches were conducted through Web of Science. Empirical studies evaluating clinical scales and/or clinical scoring systems by at least one measurement property or more were included. Subjects had to be 18 years or older. This includes investigator or patient-reported outcomes. Consensus-based Standards for the Evaluation of Measurement properties were used for the assessment of the methodological quality of studies included and for assessing the quality of investigated measurement properties. Results: Initial findings in MEDLINE, Embase and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials resulted in a set of 2863 records (without duplicates) of which 52 studies were considered eligible for full-text analysis. The application of the COSMIN-checklist on the methodological quality of the studies as well as on the quality of measurement properties of studies with good and excellent rating resulted in a final subset of 3 studies and 5 clinical scales for the assessment of xerosis cutis, including one patient-reported outcome instrument. 7 measurement properties of clinical scales have been investigated and reported of which one met the quality criteria for the selection of health measurement Instruments. Conclusion: The final results show that the major part of scales/scoring systems in use for clinical trials and research purposes have not been investigated before on their aspects of validity and reliability. These findings underline the necessity for further testing of existing scales under the prerequisite of good methodological quality according to COSMIN.
Article
This article explores how nurse prescribing has enabled patients with dry itchy skin to choose the product most suitable for the severity of their dry skin with the nurse. This is done through education, negotiation and trial of emollients. Health practitioners should ensure that patients understand how the environment challenges the skin, the processes of inflammation and ageing and how emollients used on a regular basis can support the epidermal barrier. Practical advice on technique of application is as essential to the concordance of the treatment as is the choice of product to be prescribed.
Article
Ageing skin is more vulnerable to damage and infection. Effective skin and dermatology training can prevent problems from occurring and improve quality of care.
Article
Epidermal hydration following repeated application of an oil in water emulsion was studied on the forearm skin of 16 healthy females by non-invasive methods. The lotion was applied twice daily for 7 days, and values were followed 7 days after cessation of treatment. The opposite forearm served as an untreated control. Electrical conductance and capacitance showed similar results, i.e. increased values (p less than 0.001) after 2 days of application, reaching a plateau during further applications. Two days after cessation, values were still increased (p less than 0.001), and the conductance was also increased 7 days after cessation of treatment. The water evaporation and the cutaneous blood flow did not change, i.e. indicating no mild irritant effect. Skin surface lipids did not change, i.e. indicating that no significant amounts of emulsion oil remained on the skin at the time of recording. Probably components of the oil phase of the emulsion are absorbed into the epidermis, which is associated with improved hydration as a later event.
Article
Diabetic neuropathy is a common complication of diabetes that may be disabling and even contribute to mortality. Diabetic peripheral neuropathy encompasses a group of clinical and subclinical syndromes, each characterized by diffuse or focal damage to peripheral somatic or autonomic nerve fibers. None of these syndromes is pathognomonic for diabetes, and they may occur idiopathically or in association with other disorders in nondiabetic persons. Distal symmetric sensorimotor polyneuropathy is the most common form of peripheral neuropathy and is the leading cause of lower limb amputation. The characteristic slowing of sensory and motor nerve conduction velocities and advancing distal symmetric sensorimotor deficits are ascribed to an underlying insidious, chronically progressive, length-dependent, distal axonopathy of the dying-back type primarily, but not exclusively, affecting sensory nerve fibers. The cumulative prevalence of clinical diabetic neuropathy parallels the degree and duration of antecedent hyperglycemia, and the Diabetes Control and Complications Trial definitively established an important role of improved metabolic control in the primary prevention of clinical neuropathy. Improved blood glucose control substantially reduces the risk of developing diabetic polyneuropathy in type 1 diabetes mellitus, thereby strongly implicating hyperglycemia as the important causative factor in this degenerative disease process. Studies in experimental animal models reveal several glucose-related metabolic mechanisms that could initiate neurochemical, neurotrophic, and/or neurovascular defects culminating in a peripheral sensorimotor and autonomic neuropathy. Other than improved blood glucose control, therapy for diabetic neuropathy remains palliative and supportive, although this is expected to change radically as new insights into the pathogenetic mechanisms of diabetic neuropathy give rise to specific new mechanism-based therapies.
Article
Although effective moisturizers can improve xerotic skin changes immediately, their effects are only transient, because the materials applied to the stratum corneum (SC) are easily shed from the skin surface by the daily desquamation process. However, there are a few lines of clinical as well as experimental evidence suggesting that, once application of effective moisturizers is repeated daily, they may produce persistent effects without being influenced by the desquamation of the skin surface. If we can expect such pharmacological effects by simple repeated applications of moisturizers on the skin surface, it will provide a great motivation for the introduction of corneotherapy into the treatment of xerotic skin problems. This study was designed not only to confirm the feasibility of corneotherapy but to propose a practical method to assess such long-lasting effects of moisturizers by using biophysical methods. We conducted applications of various moisturizers twice daily to different areas of the flexor surface of the forearms for the initial 5 days of the first week. Thereafter, we performed biophysical measurements of the SC of these areas in the second week, namely 3, 5 and 7 days after their last applications. Daily repeated applications of moisturizers did not induce any change in the water barrier function of the SC or in the size of desquamating corneocytes, a parameter for turnover rate of the SC. However, they substantially increased high-frequency conductance, a parameter for the hydration state of the skin surface, for several days in both normal individuals and patients with atopic xerosis, although the lasting effects were shorter in the latter. The obtained data enabled us to rank the efficacy of moisturizers either according to the duration of the lasting effects or the magnitude of an increase in the hydration levels of the SC. The present results confirmed the feasibility of corneotherapy, in which even simple application of moisturizers targeted at the SC can produce unexpected persistent clinical effects after their repeated treatments. The method described in this study constitutes a practical assay system to evaluate the efficacy of topical agents used for dry skin problems objectively and quantitatively.
Article
Moisturizers are widely used in various dermatologic and cosmetic skin therapies. Different classes of moisturizers are based on their mechanism of action, including occlusives, humectants, emollients and protein rejuvenators. Commercially available moisturizers often utilize components of each of these classes to provide their beneficial effect. Dry skin (xerosis) is the major indication of use. Others include atopic dermatitis, irritant contact dermatitis, ichthyosis, and dermatoheliosis. Although generally efficacious, moisturizers can cause a number of unwanted side-effects, including occlusive folliculitis, irritation, allergic contact dermatitis and contact urticaria.