ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

Psychological Stress occurs when an individual perceives that environmental demands tax or exceed his or her adaptive capacity. Following this view, that underlines the role of the situated experience of the patient in experiencing a stressor, the European Union funded Interstress project (http://www.interstress.eu) is exploring the possible use of the virtual simulation technology offered by SecondLife (http://www.secondlife.com) to administer a stress management experiential training. The structure of the environment and the contents of the course are described and discussed.
Learning Island: The Development of a
Virtual reality System for the Experiential
Training of Stress Management
Giuseppe RIVA 1-2, Cinzia VIGNA1, Alessandra GRASSI 1-2
Simona RASPELLI 1, Pietro CIPRESSO 1-2, Federica PALLAVICINI 1
Silvia SERINO 1-2, Andrea GAGGIOLI 1-2
1 Applied Technology for Neuro-Psychology Lab, Istituto Auxologico Italiano,
Milan, Italy
2 Psychology Department, Catholic University of Milan, Italy
Abstract. Psychological Stress occurs when an individual perceives that
environmental demands tax or exceed his or her adaptive capacity. Following this
view, that underlines the role of the situated experience of the patient in
experiencing a stressor, the European Union funded Interstress project
(http://www.interstress.eu) is exploring the possible use of the virtual simulation
technology offered by SecondLife (http://www.secondlife.com) to administer a
stress management experiential training. The structure of the environment and the
contents of the course are described and discussed.
Keywords: Stress-Management, SecondLife, Experiential training
1. Introduction
According to Cohen and colleagues [1], “Psychological Stress” occurs when an
individual perceives that environmental demands tax or exceed his or her adaptive
capacity. In this view, stressful experiences depend a great deal on how the person
experiencing a stressor is put together psychologically and physically. So the focus
for assessment, prediction and treatment has to be the situated experience of the patient.
2. The Interstress project
To reach this goal, he European project Interstress (http://www.interstress.eu) is
using a totally new paradigm for stress managment interreality that integrates
training, assessment and treatment within a hybrid environment, bridging physical and
virtual world [2, 3]. Within this paradigm, a critical role is played by the “Learning
Island”, a shared online virtual world, used for the experiential training of stress coping
skills (Figure 1; see this YouTube video for a walkthrough of the Island:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Yo2D-X8xe4).
Figure 1. An overview of the Learning Island
3. Developing the Learning Island
Second Life (SL) is a virtual three-dimensional platform that has been used for
medical education [4]. In the Interstress project we are exploring the potential of using
SL virtual simulation technology through the development of an interactive course to
administer experiential training of stress management. Specifically, we plan to use the
motivation and the engagement provided by a shared virtual experience to teach the
users about how to improve their stress knowledge and management skills.
The Learning Island is organized around different learning areas both without and
with teachers (classes). In this island the users:
Learn the main causes of stress and how to recognize stress symptoms.
Learn stressor-focused strategies (e.g., resource optimization and better
planning)
Learn some stress relieving exercises (e.g., relaxation training or
diaphragmatic breathing, use of emotional support)
Get the information needed to succeed, with daily tips and expert ideas.
Following a constructivist approach we organized the Learning Island around
different learning areas both without and with supervision (see Figure 2):
1) Area 1: Discover the causes of stress (individual, unsupervised)
2) Area 2: Discover the emotional and physical symptoms of stress (individual and
shared, unsupervised)
3) Area 3: Interact with different stress resources (individual, unsupervised)
4) Area 4: Experience different challenges (individual, supervised by the therapist)
5) Area 5: Coping skills training (individual and shared, supervised by the therapist)
6) Area 6: Discuss with the therapist and other patients.
4. Future steps
Future goals of this study are to:
1) explore the potential of the virtual world, Second Life, stress management training
(SMT);
2) determine possible instructional design approaches for using SL for SMT;
3) understand the limitations of SL for SMT activities; and
4) measure participant learning outcomes and feedback.
Figure 2. The structure of the training environment
5. Acknowledgements
This paper was partially supported by the FP7 European funded projects “Interstress -
Interreality in the management and treatment of stress-related disorders FP7-247685l
http://www.interstress.eu”.
6. References
[1] Cohen S, Janicki-Deverts D, Miller GE, Psychological Stress and Disease. JAMA. 2007; 298:1685-1687.
[2] Riva G, Interreality: A New Paradigm for E-health. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2009;144:3-7.
[3] Gaggioli A, Raspelli S, Grassi A, Pallavicini F, Cipresso P, Wiederhold BK, Riva G. Ubiquitous health in
practice: the interreality paradigm. Stud Health Technol Inform. 2011;163:185-91.
[4] Wiecha J, Heyden R, Sternthal E, Merialdi M, Learning in a Virtual World: Experience With Using
Second Life for Medical Education. J Med Internet Res 2010;12(1):e1
... This seems important since mental health literacy, defined as knowledge and beliefs about mental disorders, which aid their recognition, management, or prevention [33], is an essential facilitator of formal help-seeking behavior [34,35], and it is the first step intervention for the management of stress and anxiety [36,37]. However, to date, there is limited knowledge on this topic (e.g., [30,[38][39][40]). Therefore, we developed and tested in a sample of healthcare workers MIND-VR, a VR-based psychoeducational experience on stress and anxiety [31]. ...
... Psychoeducational material on Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) was created also as part of the STress Resilience In Virtual Environments (STRIVE) project, which aimed to made a set of multi-episode interactive narrative experiences for delivering PTSD exposure therapy for military personnel [40]. Furthermore, within Second Life, an online multimedia platform launched in 2003 and accessible from PCs that allows people to interact in an online virtual world using avatars, psychoeducational content on social anxiety (i.e., Drexel Island) [38], and for stress management (i.e., Learning Island) has been successfully tested [39]. ...
... Improvement in symptoms awareness has significant consequences for clinical outcomes in terms of treatment-seeking, treatment adherence, and achieving recovery [126,127]. The results of this study support what has also been observed in previous studies about the potential of VR for psychoeducation, both on stress and anxiety [39,40] and on other types of mental disorders, such as depression [30]. In past research, however, passive virtual experiences had been tested. ...
Article
Full-text available
Virtual reality can help individuals to manage stress and anxiety. In addition to its efficacy in reducing stress and anxiety through relaxation, virtual reality can be helpful for psychoeducational. However, to date, few studies have explored this topic. Therefore, this mixed-methods sequential explanatory study aimed to investigate the usability, sense of presence, emotional response, and effect on learning of MIND-VR, a psychoeducational virtual experience created to offer information on stress and anxiety. Twenty healthcare workers (60% female; mean age 43 10) tried MIND-VR. Psychometric outcomes served as quantitative variables, while participant interviews provided qualitative data. Results showed that the virtual reality psychoeducational experience: (a) was highly usable and satisfying; (b) increased positive emotions (i.e., happiness and surprise) and decreased negative emotions (i.e., fear, sadness) and state anxiety; (c) elicited a strong sense of presence, especially spatial presence; and (d) was practical, simple, motivating, and engaging for learning information about stress and anxiety. These findings offer promising insights into that virtual reality may be an effective tool to provide psychoeducation.
... Despite the important role that virtual reality could play in providing information regarding mental suffering conditions, only a few previous studies to date have investigated the possibilities of virtual reality for psychoeducation (Rizzo et al., 2009Riva et al., 2012;Tielman et al., 2017;Migoya-Borja et al., 2020). For example, a virtual environment called "Learning Island" and developed in Second Life, was created to host an interactive course on stress management (Riva et al., 2012). ...
... Despite the important role that virtual reality could play in providing information regarding mental suffering conditions, only a few previous studies to date have investigated the possibilities of virtual reality for psychoeducation (Rizzo et al., 2009Riva et al., 2012;Tielman et al., 2017;Migoya-Borja et al., 2020). For example, a virtual environment called "Learning Island" and developed in Second Life, was created to host an interactive course on stress management (Riva et al., 2012). Also, a virtual reality-based psychoeducational tool for individuals suffering from depression called "VRight" has been shown to increase depressive symptoms awareness (Migoya-Borja et al., 2020). ...
Article
Full-text available
To ensure the continuity of healthcare and to counter the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic, doctors and nursing staff at hospitals must face an insidious, invisible danger that is stretching the healthcare system far past its capacity. Excessive workload, inadequate protection from contamination, the need to manage patients experiencing extreme suffering and being kept apart from their families put medical personnel at high risk to experience stress and anxiety. Numerous scientific studies have shown that, among various therapeutic programs, virtual reality represents a highly specialized and effective tool for the prevention and treatment of stress and anxiety. However, the solutions developed using this technology for the management of stress and anxiety induced by the COVID-19 pandemic are still very limited, and none of these have been developed specifically for use with healthcare professionals. Therefore, this paper will detail the design and evaluation protocol of MIND-VR, a virtual reality-based psychoeducational experience on stress and anxiety developed following a user-centered design approach. The virtual experience will be tested on a sample of Italian hospital healthcare personnel involved in the COVID-19 pandemic emergency. MIND-VR is available free of charge, both in Italian and English, on the project website ( https://mind-vr.com/ ).
... First of all, VR represents a very useful interactive tool in psychoeducation programs for learning the basic elements of stress and PTSD, including causes and effects, 43 with the aim of making the patient more competent and aware of his/her problem, with a view to individual empowerment. 44,45 The greater effectiveness of this type of intervention compared with classic educational programs (e.g., classroom lessons or books) is mainly linked to the higher user involvement in the learning process. ...
Article
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic is a global health emergency requiring clinicians to be prepared to cope with the increase in the future incidence of trauma and stress-related psychopathological symptoms. The early detection of psychological distress and timely intervention are strongly recommended. Clinicians should also consider integrating new technologies such as virtual reality (VR) in the treatment of these trauma and stress-related psychopathological symptoms. Here we provide a brief overview of how VR can help to cope with the potential short-term and long-term mental health consequences related to this global emergency.
... The projects target depression (Help4Mood, ICT4Depression, Optimi), psychosocial stress (Interstress), and bipolar disorder (Monarca, Psyche) and make use of mobile technologies (smartphone or computer), virtual reality (avatar), and biosensors (monitoring) [21,101]. Help4Mood, Interstress, and Optimi provide a new outlook on the use of new technologies for psychotherapy generally and cognitive behavioral therapy in particular [102][103][104][105][106]. Other projects rely on wearable biosensor devices for monitoring physiological parameters and on electronic selfassessment of mood so that the early warning signs of relapse into depression (ICT4Depression: [107]) or bipolar disorder (Monarca: [45] and Psyche: [22,108]) can be better recognized. ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper reviews what we know about prediction in relation to mood disorders from the perspective of clinical, biological, and physiological markers. It then also presents how information and communication technologies have developed in the field of mood disorders, from the first steps, for example, the transition from paper and pencil to more sophisticated methods, to the development of ecological momentary assessment methods and, more recently, wearable systems. These recent developments have paved the way for the use of integrative approaches capable of assessing multiple variables. The PSYCHE project stands for Personalised monitoring SYstems for Care in mental HEalth.
Chapter
The emerging convergence of new technologies and health care is offering a new approach to support effective interventions. This chapter aims to describe how Positive Technology can help people cope with stress in several contexts. On the one hand, the potential capacity of sensor technologies to offer individuals the technology with which to monitor certain biological signals known to be associated with stress might serve to promote engagement with a mediated experience for stress management. On the other hand, the chapter focuses on the hedonic and eudaimonic experiences supported by technology in terms of inducing positive affective states and supporting personal growth by teaching strategies to reduce stress and enhance well-being. To further connect mediated experiences with real ones, the Interreality approach (IR) allows for the combination of assessment and intervention as inseparable parts of the general process of coping with stress.
Chapter
This chapter explores how immersion in virtual reality (VR) evokes emotional states similar to those of the real world, and how deliberate immersion in high-stress situations can help teach individuals affective strategies to remain in control of their emotions. Psychological skills training programs teach techniques and strategies to assess, monitor, and adjust thoughts and feelings to cope with stress. VR allows an individual to put these skills to the test through the opportunity to practice coping with their emotional states while immersed in difficult scenarios. Keeping a clear head, ignoring fear when fear isn't useful, learning how to draw on an optimal blend of emotion and reason in times of crisis are all crucial skills for work and life. Affective Control Theory (ACT) proposes that affective strategies that typically strengthen and support performance are skills and that these skills are integral to stress management. Due to its key role in performance, recent research in psychology confirms affect as a crucial variable to consider in interventions in workplace stress.
Chapter
Full-text available
The emerging convergence of new technologies and health care is offering a new approach to support effective interventions. This chapter aims to describe how Positive Technology can help people cope with stress in several contexts. On the one hand, the potential capacity of sensor technologies to offer individuals the technology with which to monitor certain biological signals known to be associated with stress might serve to promote engagement with a mediated experience for stress management. On the other hand, the chapter focuses on the hedonic and eudaimonic experiences supported by technology in terms of inducing positive affective states and supporting personal growth by teaching strategies to reduce stress and enhance well-being. To further connect mediated experiences with real ones, the Interreality approach (IR) allows for the combination of assessment and intervention as inseparable parts of the general process of coping with stress.
Chapter
This chapter explores how immersion in virtual reality (VR) evokes emotional states similar to those of the real world, and how deliberate immersion in high-stress situations can help teach individuals affective strategies to remain in control of their emotions. Psychological skills training programs teach techniques and strategies to assess, monitor, and adjust thoughts and feelings to cope with stress. VR allows an individual to put these skills to the test through the opportunity to practice coping with their emotional states while immersed in difficult scenarios. Keeping a clear head, ignoring fear when fear isn't useful, learning how to draw on an optimal blend of emotion and reason in times of crisis are all crucial skills for work and life. Affective Control Theory (ACT) proposes that affective strategies that typically strengthen and support performance are skills and that these skills are integral to stress management. Due to its key role in performance, recent research in psychology confirms affect as a crucial variable to consider in interventions in workplace stress.
Article
Full-text available
In recent years, Virtual Reality technologies have emerged as assessment and treatment tools in neuropsychology. In this chapter, we will explore the possibility of using VR to improve the traditional neuropsychological assessment of executive functions. First, we will discuss the advantages offered by Virtual Reality may over the more traditional approaches. Then, the chapter details the characteristics of the Virtual Multiple Errands Test (VMET), a virtual reality tool developed using NeuroVR (http://www.neurovr.org) -a free virtual reality platform for the assessment and neurorehabilitation -and used for the neuropsychological eval-uation of executive functions. Specifically, the VMET is an assessment protocol of executive functions, where participants are required to navi-gate a virtual supermarket, completing tasks that abide by certain rules. In the chapter we will be present the detailed description of its clinical
Chapter
In this paper we present studies on biological and health effects of electromagnetic fields emphasizing the aspects related with measurement of the aggressing electromagnetic fields. A brief review of literature on electromagnetic environment is presented, together with some methods aiming to control and eliminate the electromagnetic interferences on medical instrumentation used in the acquisition of the biological signals (electroencephalography – EEG, electrocardiography – ECG). We performed analysis of electromagnetic fields in order to determine the induced current/field and the specific absorption rate in models of human body and also to correlate the exposure fields with some alterations of the biological signals acquired from a subject laid in various electromagnetic environments. The main goal of this research is to design a method for accurate identification and characterization of the aggressing electromagnetic fields on biological signals and human health.
Article
Full-text available
In this paper we introduce a new ubiquitous computing paradigm for behavioral health care: "Interreality". Interreality integrates assessment and treatment within a hybrid environment, that creates a bridge between the physical and virtual worlds. Our claim is that bridging virtual experiences (fully controlled by the therapist, used to learn coping skills and emotional regulation) with real experiences (allowing both the identification of any critical stressors and the assessment of what has been learned) using advanced technologies (virtual worlds, advanced sensors and PDA/mobile phones) may improve existing psychological treatment. To illustrate the proposed concept, a clinical scenario is also presented and discussed: Daniela, a 40 years old teacher, with a mother affected by Alzheimer's disease.
Article
Full-text available
Virtual worlds are rapidly becoming part of the educational technology landscape. Second Life (SL) is one of the best known of these environments. Although the potential of SL has been noted for health professions education, a search of the world's literature and of the World Wide Web revealed a limited number of formal applications of SL for this purpose and minimal evaluation of educational outcomes. Similarly, the use of virtual worlds for continuing health professional development appears to be largely unreported. We designed and delivered a pilot postgraduate medical education program in the virtual world, Second Life. Our objectives were to: (1) explore the potential of a virtual world for delivering continuing medical education (CME) designed for physicians; (2) determine possible instructional designs using SL for CME; (3) understand the limitations of SL for CME; (4) understand the barriers, solutions, and costs associated with using SL, including required training; and (5) measure participant learning outcomes and feedback. We trained and enrolled 14 primary care physicians in an hour-long, highly interactive event in SL on the topic of type 2 diabetes. Participants completed surveys to measure change in confidence and performance on test cases to assess learning. The post survey also assessed participants' attitudes toward the virtual learning environment. Of the 14 participant physicians, 12 rated the course experience, 10 completed the pre and post confidence surveys, and 10 completed both the pre and post case studies. On a seven-point Likert scale (1, strongly disagree to 7, strongly agree), participants' mean reported confidence increased from pre to post SL event with respect to: selecting insulin for patients with type 2 diabetes (pre = 4.9 to post = 6.5, P= .002); initiating insulin (pre = 5.0 to post = 6.2, P= .02); and adjusting insulin dosing (pre = 5.2 to post = 6.2, P= .02). On test cases, the percent of participants providing a correct insulin initiation plan increased from 60% (6 of 10) pre to 90% (9 of 10) post (P= .2), and the percent of participants providing correct initiation of mealtime insulin increased from 40% (4 of 10) pre to 80% (8 of 10) post (P= .09). All participants (12 of 12) agreed that this experience in SL was an effective method of medical education, that the virtual world approach to CME was superior to other methods of online CME, that they would enroll in another such event in SL, and that they would recommend that their colleagues participate in an SL CME course. Only 17% (2 of 12) disagreed with the statement that this potential Second Life method of CME is superior to face-to-face CME. The results of this pilot suggest that virtual worlds offer the potential of a new medical education pedagogy to enhance learning outcomes beyond that provided by more traditional online or face-to-face postgraduate professional development activities. Obvious potential exists for application of these methods at the medical school and residency levels as well.
Article
Full-text available
Despite widespread public belief that psychological stress leads to disease, the biomedical community remains skeptical of this conclusion. In this Commentary, we discuss the plausibility of the belief that stress contributes to a variety of disease processes and summarize the role of stress in 4 major diseases: clinical depression, cardiovascular disease (CVD), human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)/AIDS, and cancer.Corresponding Author: Sheldon Cohen, PhD, Department of Psychology, Carnegie Mellon University, 5000 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15213 (scohen@cmu.edu).Financial Disclosures: Dr Cohen reported consulting for Johnson & Johnson Consumer Companies Inc on issues of stress measurement. None of the other authors reported any financial disclosures.Role of the Sponsor: This article is based on a paper commissioned by the Institute of Medicine Committee on Psychosocial Services to Cancer Patients and Families in Community Settings. The Institute of Medicine suggested the topic but played no role in structuring the paper; in the collection, management, and interpretation of the data; or the preparation, review, or approval of the manuscript.Additional Contributions: We thank David Krantz, PhD (Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences), Margaret Kemeny, PhD (School of Medicine, University of California at San Francisco), Stephen Manuck, PhD, and Karen Matthews, PhD (University of Pittsburgh), and Scott Monroe, PhD (Notre Dame University), for their comments on an earlier draft; the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation Network on Socioeconomic Status and Health and members of the Pittsburgh Mind-Body Center (HL65111, HL65112) for their intellectual support; and Ellen Conser, MA, Ashleigh Molz, and Wesley Barnhart, BS (Carnegie Mellon University), for assistance in preparing the manuscript. None of these individuals received any extra compensation for their contributions.
"Interreality" is a personalized immersive e-therapy whose main novelty is a hybrid, closed-loop empowering experience bridging physical and virtual worlds. The main feature of interreality is a twofold link between the virtual and the real world: (a) behavior in the physical world influences the experience in the virtual one; (b) behavior in the virtual world influences the experience in the real one. This is achieved through: (1) 3D Shared Virtual Worlds: role-playing experiences in which one or more users interact with one another within a 3D world; (2) Bio and Activity Sensors (From the Real to the Virtual World): They are used to track the emotional/health/activity status of the user and to influence his/her experience in the virtual world (aspect, activity and access); (3) Mobile Internet Appliances (From the Virtual to the Real One): In interreality, the social and individual user activity in the virtual world has a direct link with the users' life through a mobile phone/digital assistant. The different technologies that are involved in the interreality vision and its clinical rationale are addressed and discussed.