Intrinsic Gene Expression Subsets of Diffuse Cutaneous Systemic Sclerosis Are Stable in Serial Skin Biopsies

Department of Genetics, Dartmouth Medical School, Hanover, New Hampshire 03755, USA.
Journal of Investigative Dermatology (Impact Factor: 7.22). 02/2012; 132(5):1363-73. DOI: 10.1038/jid.2011.472
Source: PubMed


Skin biopsy gene expression was analyzed by DNA microarray from 13 diffuse cutaneous systemic sclerosis (dSSc) patients enrolled in an open-label study of rituximab, 9 dSSc patients not treated with rituximab, and 9 healthy controls. These data recapitulate the patient "intrinsic" gene expression subsets described previously, including fibroproliferative, inflammatory, and normal-like groups. Serial skin biopsies showed consistent and non-progressing gene expression over time, and importantly, the patients in the inflammatory subset do not move to the fibroproliferative subset, and vice versa. We were unable to detect significant differences in gene expression before and after rituximab treatment, consistent with an apparent lack of clinical response. Serial biopsies from each patient stayed within the same gene expression subset, regardless of treatment regimen or the time point at which they were taken. Collectively, these data emphasize the heterogeneous nature of SSc and demonstrate that the intrinsic subsets are an inherent, reproducible, and stable feature of the disease that is independent of disease duration. Moreover, these data have fundamental importance for the future development of personalized therapy for SSc; drugs targeting inflammation are likely to benefit those patients with an inflammatory signature, whereas drugs targeting fibrosis are likely to benefit those with a fibroproliferative signature.

  • Source
    • "Indeed, earlier works by the Whitfield group and collaborators have shown reproducible, disease-specific gene expression signatures in scleroderma skin when compared with healthy controls and have also shown that, surprisingly, the disease-specific gene expression profiles are shared by lesional and nonlesional skin (Whitfield et al., 2003). More recently, Whitfield and collaborators analyzed the gene expression profile of skin biopsy samples from 17 patients with dSSc, 10 patients with lSSc and morphea, and 6 healthy controls (Milano et al., 2008). Cluster analysis of the gene profiles derived from these biopsies revealed three groups: (1) a normallike group, which included the healthy controls and some dSSc and lSSc patients; (2) an inflammatory group, which included a small subset of dSSc patients as well as patients with lSSc and morphea; and (3) a diffuse-proliferation (fibrotic) group, which was composed solely of dSSc patients. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: There is no universally agreed-upon treatment for the fibrosis of scleroderma. Recently, much information has been generated relating to the fundamental mechanisms underlying this disease. Partly based on these observations, both anti-inflammatory and anti-fibrotic agents have been considered as possible therapies. However, this information has not been successfully translated into clinical practice. In this issue, Pendergrass et al. use genome-wide expression profiling to provide valuable insights into scleroderma. Previously, the authors showed that morphea and "limited" scleroderma patients and a small subset of diffuse scleroderma (dSSc) patients express an "inflammatory" profile, whereas the majority of dSSc patients express a "fibroproliferative" profile. In the current study, the investigators show that the gene expression profile of these patients is fixed over time; i.e., in contrast to a previously held belief, the inflammatory patients do not go on to become fibrotic, and vice versa. These data suggest that expression profiling might be used to design clinical trials for scleroderma. The inflammatory patients might be treated with anti-inflammatory agents, whereas fibroproliferative patients might be treated with antifibrotic agents.
    Preview · Article · May 2012 · Journal of Investigative Dermatology
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Development of personalized treatment regimens is hampered by lack of insight into how individual animal models reflect subsets of human disease, and autoimmune and inflammatory conditions have proven resistant to such efforts. Scleroderma is a lethal autoimmune disease characterized by fibrosis, with no effective therapy. Comparative gene expression profiling showed that murine sclerodermatous graft-versus-host disease (sclGVHD) approximates an inflammatory subset of scleroderma estimated at 17% to 36% of patients analyzed with diffuse, 28% with limited, and 100% with localized scleroderma. Both sclGVHD and the inflammatory subset demonstrated IL-13 cytokine pathway activation. Host dermal myeloid cells and graft T cells were identified as sources of IL-13 in the model, and genetic deficiency of either IL-13 or IL-4Rα, an IL-13 signal transducer, protected the host from disease. To identify therapeutic targets, we explored the intersection of genes coordinately up-regulated in sclGVHD, the human inflammatory subset, and IL-13-treated fibroblasts; we identified chemokine CCL2 as a potential target. Treatment with anti-CCL2 antibodies prevented sclGVHD. Last, we showed that IL-13 pathway activation in scleroderma patients correlated with clinical skin scores, a marker of disease severity. Thus, an inflammatory subset of scleroderma is driven by IL-13 and may benefit from IL-13 or CCL2 blockade. This approach serves as a model for personalized translational medicine, in which well-characterized animal models are matched to molecularly stratified patient subsets.
    Full-text · Article · Mar 2012 · American Journal Of Pathology
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: The fundamental mechanisms that drive the pathogenesis of systemic sclerosis (SSc) remain elusive, despite over 50 years of investigation. Here, we review recent progress in the understanding of the immunopathogenesis of SSc. In particular, we consider interleukin-13 (IL13), and its upstream and downstream pathways, as an example of an immune system-derived mediator involved in fibrotic and vascular pathology. Emerging results linking pattern-recognition receptors and interferon pathways to SSc are also stressed. We discuss genetic data linking the immune system to SSc risk and efforts to apply animal models to subsets of patients recently resolved by gene expression profiling. These developments will help build a context for better understanding of previous observations and design of the next generation of studies that may eventually lead to effective treatment.
    No preview · Article · Jan 2013 · Current Rheumatology Reports
Show more