ArticlePDF Available

Evaluation of professional bra fitting criteria for bra selection and fitting in the UK

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

A correctly fitting bra is essential for good health; this study investigates the use of professional bra fitting criteria to establish best-fit in an underwire bra commonly sold in the UK. A comparison was made between women's bra size as measured by the traditional bra fitting method with their recommended bra size based on professional bra fitting criteria. Forty-five female participants were recruited; their mode self-reported bra size was 34DD. Participants were measured in their own bra using the traditional bra-fitting method to establish their ‘traditional size’. A ‘best-fit’ bra size was recorded for participants based on professional bra fitting criteria. Significant differences were found between traditional and best-fit cup and band sizes (p < 0.001); the traditional method of bra fitting overestimated band size and underestimated cup size. As band size increased the traditional method also became more inaccurate (p < 0.001). It is recommended that women are educated in assessing their own bra fit using professional bra fitting criteria and less emphasis placed on determining absolute bra size. Practitioner Summary: This is the first study to investigate using professional bra fitting criteria to establish best-fit in an underwired bra commonly sold in the UK. The traditional method of bra fitting was found to be inadequate, especially for larger-breasted women; the use of professional bra fitting criteria should be encouraged.
Content may be subject to copyright.
This article was downloaded by: [University of Portsmouth], [Miss J. White]
On: 08 March 2012, At: 03:51
Publisher: Taylor & Francis
Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House,
37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK
Ergonomics
Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/terg20
Evaluation of professional bra fitting criteria for bra
selection and fitting in the UK
J. White a & J. Scurr a
a Department of Sport and Exercise Science, University of Portsmouth, Spinnaker Building,
Cambridge Road, Portsmouth, PO1 2ER, UK
Available online: 08 Mar 2012
To cite this article: J. White & J. Scurr (2012): Evaluation of professional bra fitting criteria for bra selection and fitting in
the UK, Ergonomics, DOI:10.1080/00140139.2011.647096
To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00140139.2011.647096
PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE
Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to
anyone is expressly forbidden.
The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents
will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae, and drug doses should
be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims,
proceedings, demand, or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in
connection with or arising out of the use of this material.
Evaluation of professional bra fitting criteria for bra selection and fitting in the UK
J. White* and J. Scurr
Department of Sport and Exercise Science, University of Portsmouth, Spinnaker Building, Cambridge Road, Portsmouth,
PO1 2ER, UK
(Received 28 March 2011; final version received 1 December 2011)
A correctly fitting bra is essential for good health; this study investigates the use of professional bra fitting criteria to
establish best-fit in an underwire bra commonly sold in the UK. A comparison was made between women’s bra size
as measured by the traditional bra fitting method with their recommended bra size based on professional bra fitting
criteria. Forty-five female participants were recruited; their mode self-reported bra size was 34DD. Participants were
measured in their own bra using the traditional bra-fitting method to establish their ‘traditional size’. A ‘best-fit’ bra
size was recorded for participants based on professional bra fitting criteria. Significant differences were found
between traditional and best-fit cup and band sizes (p50.001); the traditional method of bra fitting overestimated
band size and underestimated cup size. As band size increased the traditional method also became more inaccurate
(p50.001). It is recommended that women are educated in assessing their own bra fit using professional bra fitting
criteria and less emphasis placed on determining absolute bra size.
Practitioner Summary: This is the first study to investigate using professional bra fitting criteria to establish best-fit in
an underwired bra commonly sold in the UK. The traditional method of bra fitting was found to be inadequate,
especially for larger-breasted women; the use of professional bra fitting criteria should be encouraged.
Keywords: sizing; fit; bra; women; education
1. Introduction
The brassiere (bra) is one of the closest fitting garments worn by women, designed to support and mold the soft tissues
of the upper female form (Hardaker and Fozzard 1997). Regardless of how good the design of the bra, if the size is
wrong, then it will not provide effective support (Page and Steele 1999). Despite this, it has been suggested that 70 to
100% of women are wearing the wrong-sized bra (Pechter 1998, Greenbaum et al.2003,Woodet al. 2008, McGhee and
Steele 2010). A correctly fitting and supporting bra is essential to good health; it can alleviate breast pain (Wilson and
Sellwood 1976, BeLieu 1994, Hadi 2000, Smith et al. 2004), allow women to exercise in greater comfort (Mason et al.
1999, White et al. 2009) and reduce the need for breast reduction surgery (Greenbaum et al. 2003).
In 1935, an American company (Warner
1
) incorporated breast volume into the bra size specification and the
alphabet bra was launched, with cup sizes from A to D; this system forms the basis of the modern bra sizing
standard we know today (Pechter 1998, Zheng et al. 2006). A simple way of communicating bra sizing was necessary
for customers, retailers, manufacturers and designers. Two major bra-sizing systems have therefore been universally
used since the introduction of Warner’s
1
alphabetic bra sizes; the imperial and metric system. The size interval and
cup grading of both systems is very similar; the imperial method has been adopted in the UK, whereas most other
European, American and Asian countries use the metric system (Zheng et al. 2006).
The traditional method of bra fitting using the imperial system relates chest circumference (immediately below
the breasts at the infra-mammary fold) to the circumference of the chest around the fullest part of the breasts. To
determine band size, an arbitrary number (4 or 5) is added to the under-bust chest circumference (inches). Cup size
is then established by calculating the difference between the band size measurement and the over-the-bust
measurement (Wright 2002, McGhee and Steele 2006, Zheng et al. 2006). Manufacturers often use the cross-grading
method when designing bras (Hardaker and Fozzard 1997); this method assumes that adjacent cup sizes across base
size ranges are equivalent (e.g. the 34B cup is equivalent to the 36A and 32C, etc.). McGhee and Steele (2006, 2010)
and Wright (2002) criticised the traditional bra fitting method as small errors due to rounding numbers up or down
in the initial band and cup measurements were calculated to lead to an error of up to three cup sizes; please refer to
Wright (2002) for an in-depth review of how bra sizes are calculated.
*Corresponding author. Email: jenny.white@port.ac.uk
Ergonomics
2012, 1–8, iFirst article
ISSN 0014-0139 print/ISSN 1366-5847 online
Ó2012 Taylor & Francis
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00140139.2011.647096
http://www.tandfonline.com
Downloaded by [University of Portsmouth], [Miss J. White] at 03:51 08 March 2012
The traditional bra fitting method is undertaken in a bra and is still used today by popular retailers (such as
Marks & Spencer
1
, LaSenza
1
and Victoria’s Secret
1
). However, body sizes have changed substantially since the
introduction of the alphabet bra, with many UK women now purchasing a D cup bra or larger (Greenbaum et al.
2003). As the traditional method of bra fitting was only established for cup sizes up to a D cup (Pechter 1998), the
accuracy of this method with sizes larger than a D cup is uncertain.
Bra size itself is difficult to measure and accuracy can be affected by breathing, posture and physical
characteristics (McGhee and Steele 2006, Zheng et al. 2006, Chen et al. 2010, Pandarum et al. 2011). International
standards suggest that measuring should take place over a well-fitted, unpadded and thin bra, with minimum
accessories and support (Zheng et al. 2006). Most women are likely to be fitted in a shop whilst wearing their own
bra, regardless of whether it meets these international standards; therefore the measurements are not meaningful if
the consumer’s own bra does not fit appropriately (Greenbaum et al. 2003). Bras produced by different
manufacturers are also inconsistent in their size (McGhee and Steele 2006), with bra companies using their own size
charts and grading methods to size garments (Hardaker and Fozzard 1997).
Breast size and age are two factors that may influence the accuracy of the traditional method. It is particularly
important for larger-breasted women (D cup and above) to wear a well-fitted and supportive bra, yet they are more
likely to have an incorrect fit due to their breasts being ptotic and bulbous (Pechter 1998, Greenbaum et al. 2003,
McGhee et al. 2006, Wood et al. 2008). It is not clear whether there is a relationship between a woman’s age and the
effectiveness of the traditional bra fitting method. However, ageing causes inferior migration of the nipple (Brown
et al. 1999) and progressively reduces the relative density of the breast (Soares et al. 2002, Haars et al. 2005). There is
rationale to evaluate whether the traditional bra fitting method becomes less reliable compared to professional bra
fitting criteria as a woman gets older and as breast size increases.
McGhee and Steele (2010) presented the first study to challenge methods used to assess bra fit; this study
systematically determined the best method for women to independently choose a well-fitted sports bra. The authors
compared bra sizes determined using professional bra fitting criteria, with participant’s self-selected bra size and one
determined by the traditional bra fitting method. The study found that women have a poor ability to independently
choose a well-fitted bra and the use of professional bra fitting criteria was promoted by the authors. However, the
professional bra fitting criteria presented by McGhee and Steele (2010) have not been compared to the traditional
method of bra fitting with an underwired bra commonly sold in the UK.
Larger-breasted women especially may feel self-conscious about being professionally measured and so attempt
to fit their own bras; however most women are not trained in this area (Wood et al. 2008). Unfortunately, bra fitters
within shops have varied experience and there is no agreed level of competency or qualification in the UK
(Greenbaum et al. 2003). With a lack of knowledge and consistency between manufacturers, it is easy to understand
why so many women may be wearing the wrong-sized bra. Limited progress has been made to educate the general
public on good bra fit practice in the UK despite the existence of professional bra fitting criteria like that published
by McGhee and Steele (2010). McGhee et al. (2010) completed a successful intervention with young female athletes
where bra fit knowledge increased after receiving an educational booklet. Knowledge of cross-grading has been
highlighted in educational material (McGhee et al. 2008) but it is not widely available; this information would be
useful for women to aid good bra fit practice. Information on common bra fitting mistakes, as well as a clear set of
simple criteria to follow to achieve an optimum bra fit, would be valuable.
Therefore, the first aim of this study was to compare women’s bra size based on the professional bra fitting
criteria (best-fit size) to women’s bra size resulting from the traditional method of bra fitting (traditional size). The
second aim was to determine the accuracy of the traditional size against the best-fit size as breast size increased. It is
hoped that the results of this study will identify common bra fitting mistakes made by UK women, based on
differences found between the best-fit and traditional bra sizes. The final aim was to establish the accuracy of the
traditional size against the best-fit size as age increased. It was hypothesised that there would be significant
differences between participant’s best-fit and traditional bra sizes. Secondly, it was hypothesised that as bra size
increased the discrepancy between the best-fit and traditional bra size would increase. Thirdly, it was hypothesised
that as age increased the discrepancy between the best-fit and traditional bra size would increase.
2. Method
2.1. Participants
Following institutional ethical approval, forty-five female volunteers from a university staff and student population
(mean +SD: age 32 +11.37 years, height 1.65 +0.06 m, body mass 67.42 +13.02 kg) were recruited for the
study via posters and email communication. All participants were aged over 18 years (range: 19 to 58 years), had not
2J. White and J. Scurr
Downloaded by [University of Portsmouth], [Miss J. White] at 03:51 08 March 2012
been pregnant or breast-fed within the last year, or had any previous breast surgery; no restrictions were put on the
upper age limit or ethnicity of the participants recruited. Participants were asked to attend a single fitting session
and to arrive wearing one of their everyday bras (they were not reimbursed for their time).
2.2. Experimental design
Participants were given a verbal explanation of procedures and an opportunity to ask questions. When fully briefed,
participants gave written informed consent. Participants then completed a questionnaire, where they reported their
age, current bra size and how often they were professionally fitted for bras.
The participant’s body mass and height were recorded before the bra fitting commenced. In a private area,
participants were then asked to remove their upper body clothing (apart from their bra). Due to the sensitive nature
of the topic, participants were measured individually and all procedures were carried out by two trained and
experienced female bra fitters who had attended a professional course in bra fitting. If there was a discrepancy in bra
sizes between bra fitters, sizing and fitting was repeated until an agreement was reached.
Participants were first measured using the traditional method (Zheng et al. 2006); the traditional bra size was
established in the participant’s own bra (regardless of whether their own bra fitted appropriately) as this reflects
procedures undertaken when women are fitted for a bra in a retail outlet. Chest circumference (inches) was measured
at the infra-mammary fold with a plastic anthropometric tape (Rosscraft, Canada). Measurements were taken when
the participant reached relaxed end expiration (McGhee and Steele 2006). To derive band size, 4 inches were added to
an even chest circumference measurement and 5 inches were added to an odd chest circumference measurement
(Zheng et al. 2006). Cup size was calculated by measuring the circumference of the chest over the fullest part of the
breast (bust girth, inches); the difference between bust girth and the band size then dictated cup size (Table 1). To
ensure a consistent approach, when participants were measured between two cup sizes the larger cup size was always
recorded and when participants were measured between two band sizes the smaller band size was recorded.
The professional bra fitting criteria established by McGhee and Steele (2010) were used to assess the best-fit size
for all participants (Table 2). Participants were given the best-selling plain, non-padded, underwired t-shirt bra from
the UK’s leading lingerie retailer (Marks & Spencer
1
; made from 88% Polyamide and 22% elastane Lycra
1
) in the
size indicated by the traditional measurement method. One bra style and brand was used to minimise the error
associated with fit discrepancy between brands (Hardaker and Fozzard 1997). The fit of this bra was then assessed
using professional bra fitting criteria (Table 2). If an adjustment in bra size was needed, the bra was changed until
the fit was assessed as correct by both the trained bra fitters using the professional bra fitting criteria.
Figure 1 illustrates some examples of inappropriate bra fit. The most difficult criteria to achieve were the cup and
underwire; once the band size was established, a cup size that encased the breast without any bulging, gaping, or
Table 1. Cup size conversion table (Zheng et al. 2006).
Bust girth-band size 7100 000 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800
Cup size AA A B C D E F FF G GG
Table 2. Professional bra fitting criteria (McGhee and Steele 2010).
Band ¤Too tight: flesh bulging over top of band: subjective discomfort ‘‘feels too tight’’
¤Too loose band lifts when arms are moved above head, posterior band not level with
inframammary fold
Cup ¤Too big: wrinkles in cup fabric
¤Too small: breast tissue bulging above, below or at the sides
Underwire ¤Incorrect shape: underwire sitting on breast tissue laterally (under armit) or anterior midline;
subjective complaint of discomfort
Straps ¤Too tight: digging in; subjective complaint of discomfort; carrying too much of the weight of
the breast
¤Too loose: sliding down off shoulder with no ability to adjust the length
Front band ¤Not all in contact with the sternum
Rating of bra fit ¤Pass: no errors or if hooks or straps can be adjusted to allow correct fit
¤Fail: any other tricks
Ergonomics 3
Downloaded by [University of Portsmouth], [Miss J. White] at 03:51 08 March 2012
underwire resting on breast tissue was identified. For some participants, four or five different bra sizes were tried
before both bra fitters were confident that the fit met all the criteria in Table 2.
2.3. Data analysis
For analysis, participant’s traditional and best-fit bra sizes were converted into numerical scores; cup sizes (range:
AA to GG) were allocated numerical scores from 1 to 11 (AA ¼1, A ¼2, B ¼3, etc.) and band sizes (range: 30 to
44 inches) were allocated numerical scores from 1 to 8 (30 ¼1, 32 ¼2, 34 ¼3, etc.). To address hypothesis two,
scores for the differential between the best-fit and traditional cup and band sizes (traditional size minus best-fit size)
were also calculated for each participant. The differential score was negative if the traditional cup or band size were
smaller than the best-fit size, and positive if the traditional cup or band sizes were greater than the best-fit size. Band
size differentials ranged from 71 to 5, and cup size differentials ranged from 78 to 2. Self-reported bra sizes are
Figure 1. Examples of ill-fitting bras; (i) Band not level; (ii) Band too tight; (iii) Cup too small; (iv) Cup too baggy; (v)
Underwire resting on breast tissue; (vi) Underwire resting too low; (vii) Front of bra pulling away from the chest; (viii)
Shoulder straps digging in.
4J. White and J. Scurr
Downloaded by [University of Portsmouth], [Miss J. White] at 03:51 08 March 2012
presented but data were not statistically compared with the traditional and best-fit bra sizes obtained due to the
variety of bra makes/styles worn by participants.
Statistical analyses of the data were undertaken using Predictive Analytics Software (2009). Data were checked
for normality, homogeneity of variance and sphericity. Paired-samples t-tests were used to assess differences
between traditional and best-fit cup and band sizes. To determine whether the cup and band differential scores
(traditional size minus best-fit size) increased as participant’s traditional bra size increased, a Spearman’s correlation
coefficient matrix established the relationships between the traditional cup and band size data and differential
scores. A Spearman’s correlation coefficient matrix was also used to establish whether the participant’s age was
related to cup and band size differential scores. An r
s
40.7 indicated a strong correlation and r
s
40.4 a moderate
correlation (Fallowfield et al. 2005). The alpha level was set to 0.05.
3. Results
Notably, out of the 45 participants, 69% (31) had either never or rarely been professionally bra fitted. Self-reported
band sizes ranged from 32 to 44 inches (mode 34 inches) and self-reported cup sizes ranged from AA to GG (mode
DD cup).
The traditional method reports a significantly smaller average cup size of around a D cup, compared to almost
an E cup established using the best-fit size (t(44) ¼77.143, p50.001). A significant difference in band size
(t(44) ¼7.187, p50.001) was also found between the traditional and best-fit size. For 76% (34) of participants,
the best-fit band size was smaller than that measured by the traditional method.
The traditional and best-fit band sizes and the traditional and best-fit cup sizes for each participant are
displayed in Figures 2 and 3 in size order (based on the best-fit size). The relationship between the traditional
cup and band size scores and the cup and band size differential scores were investigated to determine whether
the accuracy of the traditional method was affected by bra size. A significant strong correlation (r
s
¼0.72,
p50.001) was found between the traditional band size and the band size differential, showing that the
Figure 2. Traditional and best-fit band sizes (participants ordered by best-fit band size).
Ergonomics 5
Downloaded by [University of Portsmouth], [Miss J. White] at 03:51 08 March 2012
traditional band size increased as the band size differential increased. This suggests that the traditional bra
fitting method became more inaccurate compared to using professional bra fitting criteria as band size
increased. However, no significant correlation was found between the traditional cup size and the cup size
differential (r
s
¼70.256, p¼0.089). Therefore, unlike band size, the traditional cup size was inaccurate
compared to the best-fit cup size across all cup sizes.
No significant correlations were found between the age of the participants and the traditional or best-fit cup size
(r
s
¼0.050, p¼0.746) or band size (r
s
¼70.060, p¼0.693) differentials, suggesting that the traditional bra fitting
method was inaccurate across all ages and did not become more inaccurate as age increased.
4. Discussion
This was the first study to compare professional bra fitting criteria with the traditional method of bra fitting in an
underwired bra commonly sold in the UK. Significant differences (p50.001) were identified between bra fitting
methods, confirming findings by McGhee and Steele (2010) in an Australian population and accepting hypothesis
one. The best-fit size determined by the professional bra fitting criteria was, on average, one cup size larger and one
band size smaller than the bra size determined by the traditional bra fitting method. Similar to McGhee and Steele’s
(2010) findings, a large percentage (69%) of women in the present study had either never or rarely had a professional
bra fitting, therefore suggesting that it is important that women are educated in the criteria of a good fitting bra so
they can determine their own bra fit.
Ryan (2000) reported that breast mass should be removed from the shoulders to eliminate pectoral girdle
myalgia; therefore a firm, but not uncomfortable, band should be recommended to provide the primary support for
the breasts. However, in this study, the traditional method of bra fitting overestimated band size in 76% of women
compared to the best-fit band size. This result has implications for women when purchasing a bra after being fitted
by the traditional method. Wearing bras with less support in the band will reduce the ability of the bra to support
the breasts (Page and Steele 1999).
Due to the relationship between band and cup size, determined by the cross-grading method, wearing a bra with
a loose under band may mean that the cup size is too small. This is supported by the results of this study as the
traditional method of bra fitting underestimated cup size in 84% of women. An incorrect fit in the cup area may
Figure 3. Traditional and best-fit cup sizes (participants ordered by best-fit cup size).
6J. White and J. Scurr
Downloaded by [University of Portsmouth], [Miss J. White] at 03:51 08 March 2012
cause irritation if the bra impinges on the breast tissue (Page and Steele 1999). Educating women on bra cross-
grading, so that they understand that when they move up or down a band size their cup size will be affected, may
therefore reduce band and cup fit mistakes (McGhee et al. 2010).
It has previously been reported in the literature that women were often wearing bras that were too tight in the
band and too loose in the cup when comparing the self-reported and traditional bra size (Greenbaum et al. 2003,
McGhee and Steele 2006, Wood et al. 2008); however, the efficacy of studies that have compared these two bra sizes
is questionable. Firstly, studies that have utilised the traditional method of bra fitting as a ‘gold standard’ are
problematic as this study has confirmed that the traditional method of bra fitting is not accurate when compared to
published best-fit criteria (Pechter 1998, Greenbaum et al. 2003, Wood et al. 2008, McGhee and Steele 2010).
Furthermore, self-reported bra sizes are redundant when 85% of women have been reported to wear the wrong-
sized bra when compared to professional bra fitting criteria (McGhee and Steele 2010).
Findings also showed that the larger the band size measured, the greater the difference between the best-fit band
size and the traditional band size (r
s
¼0.72), partially accepting hypothesis two. This suggests that the larger the
woman’s band size (as assessed using professional bra fitting criteria), the more erroneous the traditional method
became. Perhaps excess flesh around the chest in larger women increased the subjectivity of the tape measure reading.
This is contrary to earlier findings by Greenbaum et al. (2003) who suggested that larger-breasted women were
wearing bras that were too tight in the band; yet their ‘best-fit bra size’ was measured using the traditional bra fitting
method.
Inaccuracies in cup size using the traditional method of bra fitting compared to using professional bra fitting
criteria were found across all bra sizes, highlighting the need for women of all bra sizes to be wary of using traditional
bra fitting techniques to assess their bra fit. This result may not be surprising, considering individual variation in size,
contour and density of breasts (Hoffman 2001). It was hypothesised that as participant’s age increased, the ability of
the traditional method to accurately measure cup and band size would decrease. The results of this study found no
relationship between age and fit method, rejecting hypothesis three and suggesting that women of all ages should be
encouraged to use professional bra fitting criteria.
When participant’s breast size was measured in this study, the common bra fitting mistakes (when compared to
professional bra fitting criteria) were that the under band of the bra was too loose and the cup was too tight. The
same bra fitting mistakes were reported by McGhee and Steele (2010) for Australian women when self-selecting a
bra. Women are therefore urged to ensure they are wearing a bra with a firm under band, and that if they decrease
their band size then they may need to increase their cup size. It is important that women realise there may be
discrepancies in bra sizing between manufacturers (Hardaker and Fozzard 1997) and that their body shape may
influence bra fit (Chen et al. 2010, Pandarum et al. 2011). A woman’s breasts will change size and shape throughout
the menstrual cycle and throughout the life cycle (McCool et al. 1998, Page and Steele 1999), so frequent evaluation
of bra fit is necessary.
To help women select appropriately fitting bras McGhee and Steele (2006) suggested that a new reliable bra
sizing system should be developed, which standardises the procedure for calculating cup and band sizes. Currently,
bra manufacturers in the UK use their own size charts (Hardaker and Fozzard 2007) and ‘fit’ varies for marketing
and branding purposes, similar to shoe manufacturers (Greenbaum et al. 2003). Therefore, insisting all bra
manufacturers use the same sizing procedures is difficult, if not impossible, as this would lead to manufacturers
losing their identity in the market.
An intervention study in Australia (McGhee et al. 2010) confirmed that an education booklet (McGhee
et al. 2008) given to female athletes significantly improved knowledge of sports bra fit. Future research should
look at ways to educate consumers and retailers in the UK on good practice in bra fitting. There is scope to
utilise the professional bra fitting criteria within educational material to achieve this aim, perhaps as part of
display material in changing cubicles at retail outlets or delivered to school-age children so knowledge of bra
fitting is gained at an early age. Future research should also assess to what extent an ill-fitting bra may affect
the amount of breast support and breast comfort provided by the bra.
This is the first study to scientifically compare professional bra fitting criteria with the traditional method of bra
fitting in an underwired bra commonly sold in the UK. It is recommended that as the traditional method of bra
fitting underestimated cup size and overestimated band size in the majority of participants compared with using
best-fit criteria, women should subjectively assess their own bra fit using professional bra fitting criteria (Table 2).
Larger-breasted women in particular should be wary of using the traditional method of bra fitting to dictate
absolute bra size, due to greater inaccuracies in band size as this measure increases. More education is needed so
that women can accurately assess their own bra fit. This study recommends that women follow professional bra
fitting criteria for appropriate bra fit.
Ergonomics 7
Downloaded by [University of Portsmouth], [Miss J. White] at 03:51 08 March 2012
References
BeLieu, R.M., 1994. Mastodynia. Obstetrics and Gynaecology Clinics of North America, 21 (3), 461–477.
Brown, T.P., Ringrose, C., Hyland, R.E., Cole, A.A., and Brotherston, T.M., 1999. A method of assessing female breast
morphometry and it’s clinical application. British Journal of Plastic Surgery, 52 (5), 355–359.
Chen, C-M., LaBat, K., and Bye, E., 2010. Physical characteristics related to bra fit. Ergonomics, 53 (4), 514–524.
Fallowfield, J.L., Hale, B.J., and Wilkinson, D.M., 2005. Using statistics in sport and exercise science research. Chichester, UK:
Lotus Publishing.
Greenbaum, A.R., Heslop, T., Morris, J., and Dunn, K.W., 2003. An investigation of the suitability of bra fit in women referred
for reduction mammaplasty. British Journal of Plastic Surgery, 56, 230–236.
Haars, G., van Noord, P.A.H., van Gils, C.H., Grobbee, D.E., and Peeters, P.H.M., 2005. Measurements of breast density: no
ratio for a ratio. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention, 14, 2634–2640.
Hadi, M.S.A.A., 2000. Sports brassiere: is it a solution for mastalgia? The Breast Journal, 6 (6), 407–409.
Hardaker, C.M. and Fozzard, G.W., 1997. Communications: the bra design process a study of professional practice.
International Journal of Clothing Science and Technology, 9 (4), 311–325.
Hoffman, S.J., 2001. Breast health in active and athletic women. In: N. Swedan, ed. Women’s sports medicine and rehabilitation.
Gaithersburg, Maryland: Aspen Publishers, Inc, 250–258.
Mason, B.R., Page, K., and Fallon, K., 1999. An analysis of movement and discomfort of the female breast during exercise and
the effects of breast support in three cases. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 2 (2), 134–144.
McCool, W.F., Stone-Condry, M., and Bradford, H.M., 1998. Breast health care: a review. Journal of Nurse-Midwifery, 43 (6),
406–430.
McGhee, D.E. and Steele, J.R., 2006. How do respiratory state and measurement method affect bra size calculations? British
Journal of Sports Medicine, 40, 970–974.
McGhee, D.E. and Steele, J.R., 2010. Optimising breast support in female patients through correct bra fit: a cross-sectional
study. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 13 (6), 568–572.
McGhee, D.E., Steele, J.R., and Munro, B.J., 2008. Sports bra fitness. Wollongong (NSW): Breast Research Australia.
McGhee, D.E., Steele, J.R., and Munro, B.J., 2010. Education improves bra knowledge and fit, and level of breast support in
adolescent female athletes: a cluster-randomised trial. Journal of Physiotherapy, 56, 19–24.
Page, K. and Steele, J.R., 1999. Breast motion and sports brassiere design. Sports Medicine, 27 (4), 205–211.
Pandarum, R., Yu, W., and Hunter, L., 2011. 3-D breast anthropometry of plus-sized women in South Africa. Ergonomics,54
(9), 866–875.
Pechter, E.A., 1998. A new method for determining bra size and predicting postaugmentation breast size. Plastic and
Reconstructive Surgery, 102 (4), 1259–1265.
Ryan, E.L., 2000. Pectoral girdle myalgia in women: a 5-year study in a clinical setting. The Clinical Journal of Pain, 16, 298–303.
Smith, R.L., Pruthi, S., and Fitzpatrick, L.A., 2004. Evaluation and management of breast pain. Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 79,
353–372.
Soares, D., Reid, M., and James, M., 2002. Ages as a predictive factor of mammographic breast density in Jamaican women.
Clinical Radiology, 57 (6), 472–476.
White, J., Scurr, J., and Smith, N., 2009. The effect of breast support on kinetics during overground running performance.
Ergonomics, 52 (4), 492–498.
Wilson, M.C. and Sellwood, R.A., 1976. Therapeutic value of a supporting brassiere in mastodynia. British Medical Journal,2,
90.
Wood, K., Cameron, M., and Fitzgerald, K., 2008. Breast size, bra fit and thoracic pain in young women: a correlational study.
Chiropractic and Osteopathy, 16 (1), 1–7.
Wright, M.C.M., 2002. Graphical analysis of bra size calculation procedures. International Journal of clothing Science and
Technology, 14 (1), 41–45.
Zheng, R., Yu, W., and Fan, J., 2006. Breast measurement and sizing. In: W. Yu, et al., eds. Innovation and technology of women’s
intimate apparel. Cambridge: Woodhead Publishing Ltd, 28–58.
8J. White and J. Scurr
Downloaded by [University of Portsmouth], [Miss J. White] at 03:51 08 March 2012
... As part of their results, the author reported that keeping the breast in position, especially during intense activities like exercising, is important. As echoed by White & Scurr [53] and Sharland [6], keeping the breast in position can significantly reduce breast pain intensity caused by motion. It becomes more critical for individuals with large breasts [54]. ...
... Customization is popular in suit making and less common in other forms of clothing [112]. This is due to certain limitations such as time, design and labor [53,112]. However, customized garments have been proven to offer better fit and clothing satisfaction [113]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Individuals with atypical breast shape/size often find it quite challenging to obtain a comfortable, supportive, and fitted bra off-the-shelf. They include people with very large breasts, who have significant breast asymmetry, and/or have undergone mastectomy or mammoplasty. This paper provides insights in their challenges and attempts to fill the gap in terms of critical review of the current state of knowledge around the topic of bras. Poor and ill fitted bras are associated with breast, chest and shoulder pain, embarrassment, and an overall reduction in quality of life among others. Building upon the advantages and limitations of solutions to improve the fit, support and comfort of bras found in the literature, this paper proposes strategies to solve these challenges. As the problem is multidisciplinary, a human-centered interdisciplinary approach is key to ensure that all aspects are considered at all stages of the process. A modular design allows selecting the fabric characteristics based on the requirements of each bra part. In terms of materials, stretch woven fabrics offer a large potential in the production of bras to enhance the support provided by areas such as the under band and back panels. Bespoke manufacturing takes into account the specificities of each individual. The road map proposed here will contribute to enhance the quality of life of individuals with atypical breast shape/size.
... A sports bra is one kind of the closest fitting body garments for females and the appearance and fit of that are demanding ( ). According to , a significant Hardaker and Fozzard 1997 White and Scurr (2012) proportion (69%) of females were swayed by breast discomfort because of wearing inaccurate fitting lingerie. This considerably decreases their health and quality of life. ...
... When talks about sports bra, the first thought comes into mind might be straps, pressure, fit and pattern. Up to 85% of females wear the wrong size bra because of the poor knowledge of body measurement and bra fitting (White & Scurr, 2012). Hence, the focuses of sports bra design were straps, pressure, fit and pattern. ...
Article
Full-text available
As a sports facility category, a sports bra is regarded as an enabling technology garment with advanced functions and new cultural meanings. Women, particularly elderly women, are encouraged to wear a sports bra during physical activity because wearing a sports bra can not only prevent them from exercise-induced injuries but also increase the acceptance of their bodies. However, most studies usually targeted younger women. The requirements and expectations of elderly women on sports bras differ from younger individuals. Hence, this study aims to advance and explore the design demands, providing insights into age-friendly sports bra design by using more permeable physical and psychological boundaries based on conceptual frameworks. The sports bra evaluation words were extracted and calculated to construct the network. The appearance frequency of keywords, closeness centrality, betweenness centrality, and interconnection between every pair of words were illustrated and analyzed by using semantic-based network analysis. Network analysis deduced that the discomfort of sports bras was closely related with the support, tightness, cup design, and strap design. Beside, thermal management contributes significantly to the comfort. The outlook of a sports bra was associated with cup design. The Page-rank result showed that cup, tightness, hot, straps and quality were the top five important design attributes. The unobservable mechanisms underlying the keywords provide an alternative model, which can help to explore the key improvements for sports bra design.
... Their average and standard deviation of height and weight are 154.8 ± 5.1 cm and 60.2 ± 5.6 kg, respectively. The selection criteria are: (1) bra cup size of 75C to 90F based on the metric sizing system [37], and (2) no previous breast surgeries. The experiment was approved by the Human Participants Ethics Sub-Committee of the first author's university (Reference number: HSEARS20200205001). ...
Article
Full-text available
The measurement and prediction of breast skin deformation are key research directions in health-related research areas, such as cosmetic and reconstructive surgery and sports biomechanics. However, few studies have provided a systematic analysis on the deformations of aging breasts. Thus, this study has developed a model order reduction approach to predict the real-time strain of the breast skin of seniors during movement. Twenty-two women who are on average 62 years old participated in motion capture experiments, in which eight body variables were first extracted by using the gray relational method. Then, backpropagation artificial neural networks were built to predict the strain of the breast skin. After optimization, the R-value for the neural network model reached 0.99, which is within acceptable accuracy. The computer-aided system of this study is validated as a robust simulation approach for conducting biomechanical analyses and predicting breast deformation.
Book
Full-text available
Digital fashion is a multidisciplinary field, and the technological innovations that are making it possible can be clustered under following four themes: (1) digital design and e-prototyping, (2) digital business and promotion, (3) digital human and metaverse, and (4) phygital apparel and smart wearable technology. The technical areas associated with these four themes are further explored in this chapter, and descriptive snapshots of the state-of-the-art developments are presented.
Chapter
Full-text available
Digital fashion is a multidisciplinary field, and the technological innovations that are making it possible can be clustered under following four themes: (1) digital design and e-prototyping, (2) digital business and promotion, (3) digital human and metaverse, and (4) phygital apparel and smart wearable technology. The technical areas associated with these four themes are further explored in this chapter, and descriptive snapshots of the state-of-the-art developments are presented.
Article
Comfortable and well-fitting bras are necessary for good quality of life but hard to find for women who undergo reconstruction after breast cancer treatment. This study aimed to provide data to inform bra designs for breast cancer survivors. We measured anatomical distances used in bra design on 3D clinical photographs of patients who underwent unilateral and bilateral implant-based reconstruction to quantify changes after reconstruction relative to the measured values before the person underwent surgery. We performed additional assessments of symmetry before surgery and after reconstruction, and we used regression analyses to identify associations between the measurements and patient characteristics, such as BMI. Overall, almost all measurements changed significantly in implant-based reconstructed breasts relative to native breasts. We highlight several aspects of ergonomic bra design that will be impacted by the changes in anatomical distances. Practitioner summary: Implant-based breast reconstruction surgery changes the breast so that off-the-rack bras are inadequate. This study provides designers with measurement data from women who underwent implant-based reconstruction to inform bra designs for this population. The key factor designers need to account for is the semi-spherical shape of the reconstructed breast.
Article
Breast pain is a common symptom in most women during their lifetime, and many times is self-limited. Mastalgia is categorized into 3 main groups: cyclic, noncyclic and extramammary. A good history, examination and targeted imaging can help to delineate the underlying cause of mastalgia and therefore guide treatment options. Diet, medications, stress, hormonal fluctuations, and an ill-fitting bra can be contributing factors for physiologic causes of mastalgia. Breast cancer is rarely a cause but should be excluded. Reassurance, support, dietary changes, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and occasionally hormonal medications are options to help with improving breast pain.
Article
Within the apparel industry, new technologies, environmental concerns and even a global pandemic have significantly altered how fashion products are developed, merchandised and purchased. The expanding e-commerce segment of the industry is requiring that brands reimagine how consumers choose products to purchase without a physical garment to touch, feel and try on their bodies. Communicating product information accurately, especially fit, is necessary as fit has been established as a critical component of customer satisfaction and reduces costs of returned product. Returns in the apparel industry have increased significantly due to the increase in online sales, suggesting that improved product fit and size communication is needed to improve consumer trust and satisfaction as well as increase profit margins and reduce environmental impact. Technology such as virtual fitting rooms, custom consumer avatars and body-scanning are all possible solutions to clearly convey fit and size information to the consumer before purchase. Brands within the lingerie and foundations market have been some of the earliest adopters of these virtual fit technologies with varying degrees of success, as they allow consumers to shop in privacy and offer an opportunity to educate the customer in less intrusive formats such as videos and charts. In this article, several of these early adopters in the lingerie e-commerce market will be evaluated to identify what has affected their successful or failed implementation and consumer acceptance to outline possible future improvement and application.
Article
Full-text available
Exploratory retail studies in South Africa indicate that plus-sized women experience problems and dissatisfaction with poorly fitting bras. The lack of 3-D anthropometric studies for the plus-size women's bra market initiated this research. 3-D body torso measurements were collected from a convenience sample of 176 plus-sized women in South Africa. 3-D breast measurements extracted from the TC² NX12–3-D body scanner ‘breast module’ software were compared with traditional tape measurements. Regression equations show that the two methods of measurement were highly correlated although, on average, the bra cup size determining factor ‘bust minus underbust’ obtained from the 3-D method is approximately 11% smaller than that of the manual method. It was concluded that the total bust volume correlated with the quadrant volume (r = 0.81), cup length, bust length and bust prominence, should be selected as the overall measure of bust size and not the traditional bust girth and the underbust measurement. Statement of Relevance: This study contributes new data and adds to the knowledge base of anthropometry and consumer ergonomics on bra fit and support, published in this, the Ergonomics Journal, by Chen et al. (2010) on bra fit and White et al. (2009) on breast support during overground running.
Article
The most important factors in the evaluation and treatment of breast pain consist of a thorough history, physical, and radiologic evaluation. These can be used to reassure the patient that she does not have breast cancer. In the 15% of mastalgia patients who have life-altering pain and still request treatment, therapy may consist of a well-fitting bra, a decrease in dietary fat intake, and discontinuance of oral contraceptives or hormone replacement therapy. Those women still resistant to therapy may experience relief from evening primrose oil supplements, bromocriptine, tamoxifen, or GnRH analogues. Predicting which treatment will be most useful for any particular woman may be challenging. No differences in success rates were found to be associated with factors such as reproductive history, presenting complaint, personal or family history of breast disease, or subsequent need for breast surgery.¹⁶ The peak (but not basal) serum prolactin levels in response to thyrotropin releasing hormone stimulus has been predictive of success for hormonal treatment but is relatively invasive.²⁶ A survey of treatments actually used was obtained from 276 consultant surgeons in Britain in 1990.⁴⁷ Of those, 75% prescribed danazol. Others used analgesia (21%), diuretics (18%), local excision (18%), bromocriptine (15%), evening primrose oil (13%), tamoxifen (9%), a well-fitting bra (3%), and no treatment (10%). Breast specialists were more likely to begin treatment with primrose oil, tamoxifen, vitamin B6, and analgesia, reserving other hormonal therapies for more difficult cases. To further evaluate the women who have severe mastalgia but do not complete treatment regimens, a questionnaire was sent to 79 patients who failed to return to the Longmore Breast Unit of Western General Hospital, Edinburgh. Seventy-one women responded. Of these, 36 said they felt better, 19 said they felt no more could be done, 18 learned to live with it, 14 were not worried even if the pain recurred, 2 were pregnant, 10 were postmenopausal, and 5 were still taking the medications previously prescribed. The prognosis for women with breast pain is not always predictable. Women with cyclic breast pain often are relieved by events that alter their hormonal milieu, whereas noncyclic breast pain may last only 1 to 2 years. Sitruk-Ware and colleagues⁶² conducted a study of French women with fibroadenomas. They found an association between fibroadenomas and cyclic mastalgia occurring more than 1 year prior to the first full-term pregnancy. A retrospective, case-control study to determine if cyclic mastalgia was a risk factor for breast cancer was conducted on 210 newly diagnosed women with breast cancer. A prior history of cyclic mastalgia was found to be a significant risk factor, even after controlling for oral contraceptive use, family history of breast cancer, geographic area, race, and a personal history of benign breast disease. Further studies will be required to support these findings. It is hoped that the future will bring a clearer picture of the various causes of breast pain to provide our patients with more specific and more successful treatment regimens. Until then, most women will be responsive to an attentive, supportive physician who carefully attempts to rule out breast cancer and offers reassurance.
Book
Advances in Women’s Intimate Apparel Technology discusses the design and manufacture of intimate apparel and how the industry is increasingly embracing novel materials, new technologies, and innovations in sizing and fit. The book reviews the ways in which new materials and methods are improving the range, function, and quality of intimate apparel, with particular focus on brassiere design. Part One introduces the advanced materials used for intimate apparel, including novel fabrics and dyes and finishes, along with materials for wiring and embellishments. Part Two discusses the role of seamless technology in intimate apparel production, covering lamination, moulding, and seamless knitting. Finally, Part Three reviews advances in design, fit, and performance.
Article
Exercise usually results in a large displacement of the breasts, often leading to breast pain. Although breast pain is a common concern of exercising females, little research has been conducted in the area of breast pain. It has been suggested that a cause of breast pain is excessive breast motion. As the female breast does not contain strong intrinsic structural support, this breast motion is difficult to reduce. It is suggested that the primary anatomical support for the breast is the Cooper’s ligaments; however, their true functional properties are unknown. Because of the lack of internal breast support it has been suggested that the skin covering the breast may also act as a support structure for the breast, but this has not been quantified. In an attempt to reduce breast motion, external breast supports (brassieres) have been developed. This article discusses components of current sports brassieres with implications for future research required to improve brassiere design and performance.
Article
A widely used procedure for calculating bra size from body measurements is analysed graphically. It is shown that arbitrarily small variations in the body measurements can cause a difference of up to three cup sizes in the calculated bra size. Some implications are discussed and improved procedures suggested.
Article
States that bra design is a highly specialized process requiring a combination of design creativity, precision pattern making skills and a detailed knowledge of fabric performance. Although there is substantial published material cataloguing the historical origins of the garment, there is little information documenting the bra design and manufacture. Examines the design process, following a survey of professional designers. Describes a common framework along with the variations in individual working methods. Emphasizes the high dependence on heuristic knowledge and the reliance on physical prototyping in the design cycle.
Article
A series of reproducible measurements have been developed with reference to a single midline datum that describe the position of key landmarks on the female breast. Measurements were made on a 'normal' population of 60 subjects content with their breast shape in order to (1) produce 'normal' reference data for breast shape in a population of varying weight and height; and (2) to evaluate factors which may influence the measurements. The findings show that the vertical positions of the measurements migrate inferiorly with increasing age. With increasing weight, the landmarks (except the medial end of the inframammary crease) migrate inferolaterally. Areolar diameter decreases with increasing age and increases with increasing weight. Only one of the 12 bilateral breast measurement parameters shows a significant mean difference between the right and left breast. However, in a proportion of subjects, individual measurements show fluctuating asymmetry. Subsequently, measurements were made of the breasts of women attending with requests for either reduction (n = 25) or augmentation (n = 6) mammaplasty. Compared with the 'normal' population, the group requesting reduction mammaplasty differed significantly in the majority of measurements. The group of patients requesting breast augmentation showed fewer differences compared with the 'normal' population. The average BMI of women requesting augmentation mammaplasty was significantly less and that of women requesting reduction mammaplasty significantly greater than the normal population. In conclusion, a simple and reproducible method of morphometric measurement of the female breast is described. Application of this method suggests that patients requesting reduction or augmentation mammaplasty on the NHS represent a significant deviation from 'normal' morphometry and do not simply have a subjective distortion of their own body image.
Article
Breast health care was rarely acknowledged in the health and science fields prior to this century and has only begun, in recent years, to receive attention outside of pregnancy/lactation or cancer screening and treatment. Yet much health care is involved with regard to this reproductive and sexual organ. With any group of clients, practitioners of women's health care must address an assortment of breast health matters. This article offers an overview of the history of breast health care, the epidemiology of benign breast conditions and cancer, the anatomy and physiology of the breast, and breast development over the lifespan. Also presented are a review of breast assessment and examination, suggestions for routine care of the breast, and an overview of major health issues related to this reproductive organ. Health issues addressed include, among others, nodular and cystic changes, nipple discharge, breast/nipple pain, mastitis, elective alterations, and cancer. Discussion is focused on the latest approaches to optimal breast health care.