Conference Paper

Quadratic: Manipulating algebraic expressions on an interactive tabletop

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the author.

Abstract

This paper introduces Quadratic---a virtual manipulative for two people to explore algebraic expressions on an interactive tabletop. Users assemble rectangles out of fundamental components: 1, x, and x2. As the area of a rectangle is both the product of its sides and the sum of its components, users can explore how the product of two linear expressions (the rectangle's sides) equals a quadratic equation (the rectangle's area). This virtual manipulative adds several important features to the previously existing physical manipulative: 1) negative pieces; 2) multiple palettes; 3) multiple linked representations between the visual elements, the equivalent algebraic expression, and the graph of that expression; 4) the ability to provide feedback on posed challenges.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the author.

... By designing for these mechanisms one can achieve higher collaborative outcomes [34]. For example, while working together and sharing insights and problems with each other, the peers might benefit from a reflection tool [76]. ...
Article
Collaboration and engagement while coding are vital elements for children, yet very little is known about how children's engagement and collaboration impact their attitudes toward coding activities. The goal of the study is to investigate how collaboration and engagement moderate children's attitudes about coding activities. To do so, we designed an study with 44 children (between 8 and 17 years old) who participated in a full-day coding activity. We measured their engagement and collaboration during the activity by recording their gaze, and their attitudes in relation to their learning, enjoyment, team-work and intention by post-activity survey instruments. Our analysis shows that there is a significant moderating effect of collaboration and engagement on children's attitudes. In other words, highly engaging and collaborative coding activities significantly moderate children's attitudes. Our findings highlight the importance of designing highly collaborative and engaging coding activities for children and quantifies how those two elements moderate children's attitudes.
... Examples for using tangibles for math learning have been provided by Falcaō et al. [6], Girouard et al. [7], Manches and O'Malley [14], and Marichal et al. [15], amongst many others. Others, like Rick [22], have incorporated touch to be able to directly manipulate math objects presented on a screen. Research about how tangibles can support learning or how learning theories can inform tangible development has for example been presented by the "Tangible Interaction Framework" by Hornecker and Buur [9] or the "Tangible Learning Design Framework" by Antle and Wise [1]. ...
Article
Full-text available
While manipulatives have played an important role in children’s mathematics development for decades, employing tangible objects together with digital systems in the classroom has been rarely explored yet. In a transdisciplinary research project with computer scientists, mathematics educators and a textbook publisher, we investigate the potentials of using tangible user interfaces for algebra learning and develop as well as evaluate a scalable system for different use cases. In this paper, we present design implications for tangible user interfaces for algebra learning that were derived from a comprehensive field study in a grade 9 classroom and an expert study with textbook authors, who also are teachers. Furthermore, we present and discuss the resulting system design.
... Examples for using tangibles for math learning have been provided by Falcāo et al. [5], Girouard et al. [6], Manches and O'Malley [12], and Marichal et al. [13], amongst many others. Others like Rick [19] incorporate touch to be able to directly manipulate math objects presented on a screen. Research about how tangibles can support learning or how learning theories can inform tangible development is for example presented by the "Tangible Interaction Framework" by Hornecker and Buur [7] or the "Tangible Learning Design Framework" by Antle and Wise [1]. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
This workshop position paper presents ongoing research on using smart tangible objects for algebra learning. While mathematical manipulatives have played an important role in children's mathematics development for decades, employing tangible objects in the classroom has been rarely explored yet. In our work, we investigate the potentials of using smart objects for algebra learning. Our smart tiles are based on traditional algebra tiles, passive mathematical manipulatives used in many schools in Northern America, and we currently extend these by 1.) multimodal input and output capabilities, 2.) dynamic constraints and 3.) adaptivity and feedback. In this paper, we give an overview on the overall system concept, the interaction with the tangible objects and their current design, as well as on the potentials of actuated smart objects for future interaction.
... Then there are tabletop applications that focus on learning numbers and sorting (Khandelwal and Mazalek, 2007) and concept mapping (Son Do-Lenh et al., 2009). Quadratic (Rick, 2010) is another educational Tabletop application which allows learners to explore algebraic expressions on a tabletop. Bryce and Robertson (1985) observed that in majority of the schools the assessment of science lab work is nonhands in nature with much more focus on the report writing skills. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Within the context of Roger’s Diffusion of Innovation theory we propose a pedagogical framework for attributes that can significantly affect student adoption of collaborative learning environment like multi-user, multi-touch tabletop. We investigated the learning outcomes of secondary school students in India collaboratively using OLabs on a tabletop (EG1 = 30) vs. individually using at desktops (EG2 = 92). We analyzed the nature of communication, touch and non-touch gesture actions, position around the tabletop, focus group interviews, and pre and post test scores. Using Bass model the study also accounts for the inter influence of related group of potential adopter teachers who are likely to exert positive influence on students. The results revealed that learning outcomes on tabletop are strongly associated with innovation attributes like Relative Advantage, Compatibility, Ease of Use, Perceived Enjoyment, Perceived usefulness and Teachers support. Overall students expressed much more positive attitude to adopt tabletop technology for learning vs. desktop. We find that the mean group performance gain is significant with collaboration using tabletop and significantly greater than the group using desktops. We also find that the group interactions with the tabletop area significant factor that contributes to the group’s average performance gain. However, the total time spent in while using the tabletop is surprisingly not a significant factor in the performance gain. Our findings contribute to the design of new pedagogical models for science learning that maximizes the collaborative learning potential of tabletops.
... Studies have suggested that interactive tabletops have the potential to be productive tools for collaboration and learning [2,10,14,17]. Specific applications have included: biodiversity, reading, fractions, the physics of light, quadratic equations, language learning, and genomics [5,9,11,13,14,17,18]. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
In this paper we describe NetTango, an agent-based modeling environment designed for elementary school students to use on a multi-touch tabletop surface. We review literature on the use of interactive tabletops for learning and present examples from an exploratory study that we conducted with 28 children (ages 6--10). We also discuss two design challenges that emerged during our study and consider possible solutions.
Conference Paper
In this paper we describe the design and implementation of a tangible balance beam that we created for early algebra education. We also present data from an exploratory study with seven children (ages 9--10 years) in a local elementary summer school classroom. Our results provide insight into how students solve algebra problems using our tangible interface, how they coordinate multiple representations (both digital and physical) in the problem solving process, and how they understand the concept of algebraic equality in this context. The data suggests that our interface helps students think about equations in a relational context, which has been shown to be an important skill for understanding more advanced concepts in algebra. Whether or not the combination of physical and digital representations provided by our interface helps students apply this relational understanding to equations written using standard algebraic notation is an open question that we hope to investigate in future work.
Article
Full-text available
The abstract for this document is available on CSA Illumina.To view the Abstract, click the Abstract button above the document title.
Article
Full-text available
This paper presents a study that investigated collaborative activity in a tangible tabletop environment to support learning about the physics of light. In co-located groups of three, children performed exploratory activities, using tangible artefacts, to find out about light. Analysis suggests that the environment can support various collaborative activities, but of central interest, demonstrated the role of peer interference in learning activities. Verbal negotiation and synchronization of actions emerged as conflict-resolution strategies and an implicit agreement by the children for sharing the physical and virtual resources of the system was noticed. The physicality and 'present at hand' nature of the input devices contributed to balanced levels of participation, particularly through action. Overall, the interference-prone tabletop environment contributed to creating a highly collaborative environment in which individual exploration was discouraged, leading the group through a productive process of collective exploration and knowledge construction.
Article
Full-text available
Augmented tabletops can be used to create multi-modal and collaborative environments in which natural interactions with tangible objects that represent virtual (digital) information can be performed. Such environments are considered potentially interesting for many different applications. In this paper, we address the question of whether or not it makes sense to use such environments to design learning experiences for young children. More specifically, we present the "Read-It" application that we have created to illustrate how augmented tabletops can support the development of reading skills. Children of five-to-seven-years old were actively involved in designing and testing this application. A pilot experiment was conducted with a prototype of the Read-It application, in order to confirm that it does indeed meet the a priori expectations. We hope that the Read-It application will inspire the development of more tabletop applications that are targeted at specific user groups and activities.
Article
Full-text available
This article introduces medium-based design—an approach to creating exploratory learning environments using the method of extending a medium. First, the character-istics of exploratory learning environments and medium-based design are described and grounded in related work. Particular attention is given to extending a medium— medium-based design's core method. Then, the product and process of two envi-ronments are detailed to show how medium-based design enables the creation of ex-ploratory learning environments. Finally, a study compares medium-based design to a conventional design process to test the hypothesis that medium-based design is partic-ularly effective in creating exploratory learning environments.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
In this paper we compare the affordances of presenting educational material on a tabletop display with presenting the same material using traditional paper handouts. Ten pairs of undergraduate students used digital or paper materials to prepare for exams during four one-hour study sessions over the course of a term. Students studying with the tabletop display solved problems on their own before resorting to answer keys and repeated activities more often than students studying with paper documents. We summarize study activities and discuss the benefits and drawbacks of each medium. Author Keywords Tabletop, paper, education, affordance, collaboration, study
Conference Paper
Full-text available
This paper introduces a new framework for thinking about tangible interfaces in education, with specific focus on abstract problem domains. Manipulatives are physical objects specifically designed to foster learning. We offer a new classification of Manipulatives: "Froebel-inspired Manipulatives" (FiMs) and "Montessori-inspired Manipulatives" (MiMs). We argue that FiMs are design materials, fostering modeling of real-world structures, while MiMs foster modeling of more abstract structures. We show that our classification extends to computationally enhanced versions of manipulatives. We present Digital MiMs -- computationally enhanced building blocks. We describe two prototypical members of the Digital MiMs class: FlowBlocks and SystemBlocks, physical, modular interactive systems that serve as general-purpose modeling and simulation tools for dynamic behavior. We present findings from qualitative studies, and conclude that digital MiMs are accessible to young children, engaging, and encourage learning of abstract structures of dynamic behavior through an iterative process of hands-on modeling, simulating, and analogizing.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
A technique for creating a touch-sensitive input device is proposed which allows multiple, simultaneous users to interact in an intuitive fashion. Touch location information is determined independently for each user, allowing each touch on a common surface to be associated with a particular user. The surface generates location dependent, modulated electric fields which are capacitively coupled through the users to receivers installed in the work environment. We describe the design of these systems and their applications. Finally, we present results we have obtained with a small prototype device.
Article
Full-text available
The potential of tabletops to enable groups of people to simultaneously touch and manipulate a shared tabletop interface provides new possibilities for supporting collaborative learning. However, findings from the few studies carried out to date have tended to show small or insignificant effects compared with other technologies. We present the Collaborative Learning Mechanisms framework used to examine the coupling of verbal interactions and physical actions in collaboration around the tabletop and reveal subtle mechanisms at play. Analysis in this way revealed that what might be considered undesirable or harmful interactions and intrusions in general collaborative settings, might be beneficial for collaborative learning. We discuss the implications of these findings for how tabletops may be used to support children's collaboration, and the value of considering verbal and physical aspects of interaction together in this way.
Article
Full-text available
New technologies, such as multi-touch tables, increasingly provide shareable interfaces where multiple people can simultaneously interact, enabling co-located groups to collaborate more flexibly than using single personal computers. Soon, these technologies will make their way into the classroom. However, little is known about what kinds of learning activities they will effectively support that other technologies, such as mobile devices, whiteboards, and personal computers, are currently unable to do. We suggest that one of the most promising uses of shareable interfaces is to support learning through exploration and creation. We present our work on DigiTile as a case study of how shareable interfaces can enable these forms of learning by doing. We demonstrate how DigiTile supports collaboration, present a field study on its learning benefits, and show how it can fit into a larger computing ecology.
Article
Full-text available
In many educational settings, manipulative materials (such as Cuisenaire Rods and Pattern Blocks) play an important role in children's learning, enabling children to explore mathematical and scientific concepts (such as number and shape) through direct manipulation of physical objects. Our group at the MIT Media Lab has developed a new generation of "digital manipulatives"---computationallyenhanced versions of traditional children's toys. These new manipulatives enable children to explore a new set of concepts (in particular, "systems concepts" such as feedback and emergence) that have previously been considered "too advanced" for children to learn. In this paper, we discuss four of our digital manipulatives---computationallyaugmented versions of blocks, beads, balls, and badges. Keywords Education, learning, children, augmented reality INTRODUCTION Walk into any kindergarten, and you are likely to see a diverse collection of "manipulative materials." You might see a set of Cuisena...
Article
The stereo has many attractions: it is easier to play and it provides immediate access to a wide range of music. But "ease of use" should not be the only criterion. Playing the piano can be a much richer experience. By learning to play the piano, you can become a creator (not just a consumer) of music, expressing yourself musically in ever-more complex ways. As a result, you can develop a much deeper relationship with (and deeper understanding of) music. So too with computers. In the field of educational technology, there has been too much emphasis on the equivalent of stereos and CDs, and not enough emphasis on computational pianos. In our research group at the MIT Media Lab, we are developing a new generation of "computational construction kits" that, like pianos, enable people to express themselves in ever-more complex ways, deepening their relationships with new domains of knowledge.
Concrete' manipulatives, concrete ideas Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood
  • D H Clements
Research agenda for mathematics education: Research issues in the learning and teaching of algebra
  • J Kaput
  • Kaput J.