ArticlePDF Available

Comparison between needed competencies of academic librarians and LIS curricula in Pakistan

Authors:

Abstract

Rapidly growing academic libraries are the major consumers of the product of seven LIS schools in Pakistan. The changing environment of academic life demands new competencies in academic librarians. This paper reviews the literature on the competencies needed for academic librarians in the Asia/Pacific region and discusses the changing environment of academic librarianship in Pakistan. It provides a list of competencies needed for entry-level academic librarians, first prepared on the basis of a literature review and, then, validated by 70 chief librarians of universities and postgraduate level colleges from the public and private sector. The validated list of competencies is compared with the curricula of LIS programs. The paper highlights the deficiencies in the curricula and their implementation and recommendations are given to improve the situation.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... The exponential growth of information technology has put a significant burden on librarians, as evidenced by research conducted by (Kupersmith, 2006). Fleet and Wallace (2003) point out that the implementation of virtual reference services has caused certain librarians to undergo a sense of personal identity loss. ...
... Sinha (2012) says staff suffering by technostress express low productivity and job satisfaction. Learning new technological advancements can be complicated by various factors, including age, level of technological proficiency, reluctance of workers to embrace new technology, stress management programs, information and communication technology (ICT) skill acquisition overload, job insecurity, job responsibilities, financial constraints, work-life balance, relevance of newly acquired skills, necessary abilities, and courses taken in Library and Information Science (LIS) schools (Ameen, 2008;Mahmood, 2003;Ragu-Nathan, Tarafdar, Ragu-Nathan, & Tu, 2008;Tarafdar et al., 2007). According to Ahsan, Abdullah, Fie, and Alam (2009) a correlation exists between stress and job satisfaction. ...
... Findings of Khan et al. (2013) found that job satisfaction was negatively impacted by technostress. Mahmood (2003); Warraich (2008) presented that the course contents of LIS are outdated and no longer pertinent. Ameen (2008) reported various issues arises in learning technological innovations. ...
Article
Full-text available
Rapid changes in technology have affected all walks of life. Role of Techno-stress in job performance of academic librarians is the facts and impact on employees with higher stress levels. This paper studies four dimensions of techno-stress among academic librarians of Public and Private Colleges of Lahore in Punjab Province. Quantitative approach for this study was used with survey method and non-probability sampling technique was employed on population. Those 50 public and private colleges in Lahore were chosen, from which 180 academic librarians were the part of study. Online survey questionnaire was conducted. Frequencies, percentage, mean, standard deviation, correlation, t-test and regression was used for data analysis through SPSS. Results of this research carried out to study techno-stress, it described college librarians experienced moderate level of techno-stress in their job performance. There was particular difference found between male and female college librarians in terms of techno stress. The findings, however, show that techno-overload and techno uncertainty has negative effect on job-performance of female librarians.
... Furthermore, there were no studies that evaluated the presence of validated skills in the curricula of the country's LIS/IM education programs. Mahmood (2003) conducted the only study on the topic "A comparison between needed competencies of academic librarians and LIS curricula in Pakistan." This study, however, does not emphasize RSS and was performed over two decades ago. ...
... At the national level, curriculum development has not received priority. Practitioners have long criticized Pakistani library schools for failing to produce qualified personnel (Mahmood, 2003). In another study, Mahmood (2012) found that LIS graduates lacked several essential skills and there were differences between library needs as a result of the quick changes in library technology and the country's LIS/IM curricula offerings. ...
Article
The primary goal of this study was to identify gaps in curriculum coverage and required skills for research support services (RSS) in university libraries in the Punjab province of Pakistan. A convergent parallel mixed methods design was used to meet its objective. To collect data for the quantitative strand, a cross-sectional survey with a closed-ended questionnaire was conducted. The population for the cross-sectional survey was reference/research librarians working in university libraries in the Punjab province. SPSS was used to analyze quantitative data. In the qualitative strand, the curriculum documents of seven LIS/IM schools in the Punjab province were examined by using the content analysis technique. Results of both strands were compared for gap analysis. The findings revealed a gap between the skills required for RSS and the offerings of LIS/IM schools. The findings have practical implications for LIS/IM schools that will help to realign their curricula to meet market needs.
... There is extensive literature on librarianship, but very few studies on academic library leadership (Ammons-Stephens et al., 2009;Ashiq et al., 2019;Hernon, 2017). Some research on library leadership has been done in Pakistan Ameen, 2006;Ashiq et al., 2018;Bashir, 2014;Haider, 2004;Mahmood, 2003;. The present study has been undertaken to expose the leadership practices adopted by university libraries in the Twin Cities of Pakistan. ...
... Majority of them stressed innovation, communication, interpersonal skills, communication skills, technology acceptance and team building as the most required competencies for 21st century leader. Ameen (2006) and Mahmood (2003) in their study demonstrated the needed competencies for library leaders, including ICT skills, management skills; communication skills; marketing skills and so on. In the same vein, (Aslam, 2018;Wong & Chan, 2018) stressed that providing satisfactory library services is the most required competency in this age of transition. ...
... For improving the performance of libraries, web tools helped in the dissemination of information and providing current awareness services in health sciences libraries (Tella & Soluoku, 2016). Mahmood (2003) revealed that, to meet the requirements of libraries, Library and Information schools (LIS) have to change the syllabus for the improvement of library professionals' skills and competencies. The contemporary era of the digital environment provides opportunities for librarians to be involved with data related activities to utilise the analytical tools and improve the resources and services of libraries. ...
Article
The study is a part of a student research project on performance-based evaluation of big data application in health sciences libraries. It presents a theoretical framework of the performance-based evaluation system for health institutes' libraries in the digital environment. The health sciences libraries' systematic approach was judged based on the five main components (data culture, organisational infrastructure, responsibilities, skills and technology competence) of big data analytics (BDA). A comprehensive literature review of the published studies was undertaken related to BDA, including the diffusion of innovation theory, and the theoretical background of the technology acceptance model to produce an application-based big data development framework for the health sciences libraries. The application-based evaluation model integrates BDA in health sciences libraries for improving library services and performance. The study proposed a need for skilled professionals with the knowledge and experience both professionally and technically. Finally, the study proposed a model that will help to measure the organisation's ability to analyse vast amounts of data to empirically validate the association concerning big data analysis and analytical practices in health libraries. Keywords: competencies; information and communication technologies (ICTs); libraries, health science
... She aspires to change the perception of individuals towards the importance and significance of TVET education. There is a huge technological and skill-gap in Pakistan which can be filled by installing the TVET education in youth (Chamadia & Shahid, 2018;Mahmood, 2003). In foreign countries, there is no difference between urban and rural areas in terms of infrastructure. ...
Article
Full-text available
Subject Area of the Teaching Case. Managing Organizational Change, A Multiple Perspective Approach 3rd Edition Student level (e.g., BA level) and proposed courses the teaching case can be used on. This case could be helpful to discover, build, design and sustain the change and innovation in organizations for both undergraduates and graduates' students of BBA and MBA. Brief overview of the teaching case. This case-based on change managing organizational change course, i.e. appreciative inquiry 4D-cycle. This case could be helpful to discover, Dream (build), design and Destiney to sustain the change and innovation in organizations for both undergraduate and graduate students in their elective course. This case can be used as a motivational story in a short seminar to bring and sustain the change effectively and efficiently. Expected learning outcomes. To highlight the major issues which need to be discovered or appreciation for the best of what is current practice in technical and vocational institute in developing country; such as Pakistan. Based on the available knowledge students need to envision (or dream) about what the future could be. To explore the influence of leader in designing or co-constructing (through collective dialogue) and overcome the specified issues in ZABTech (iTVE). Students should identify the actions taken by leader to sustaining the organization's destiny or future.
... The study found higher levels of personal competencies, such as effective communication, mutual respect and trust, broad perspective, acknowledging others', and creative thinking. In a study conducted by Mahmood (2003), a list of competencies was developed through a literature review and subsequently validated by chief librarians of various universities. The study concluded that leadership and communication competencies were identified as the highly sought-after skills by university library administrators. ...
... The study found higher levels of personal competencies, such as effective communication, mutual respect and trust, broad perspective, acknowledging others', and creative thinking. In a study conducted by Mahmood (2003), a list of competencies was developed through a literature review and subsequently validated by chief librarians of various universities. The study concluded that leadership and communication competencies were identified as the highly sought-after skills by university library administrators. ...
Article
This investigation aimed to assess the perceived level of interpersonal competencies possessed by academic librarians working in public and private sector universities across Pakistan. The study also examined differences in perceived interpersonal competencies of academic librarians based on demographic characteristics. A quantitative survey method was opted to collect data from 276 academic librarians selected through proportionate stratified simple random sampling technique. A total of 257 (92.4%) responses were received back that were analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS-23). The findings showed that academic librarians’ perceived collaboration, communication, customer service, ethics & values, leadership, and learning & innovation were at very skilled level. On the basis of age and professional experience, there were no significant differences in respondents’ opinions; however academic librarians from private universities were found to be more skillful about interpersonal competencies than those from public universities. Female respondents thought they were more adept at interpersonal skills than male respondents. Further, the respondents having MS/MPhil degrees were more interpersonal competent than those having BS (Hons.)/MLIS/MA degrees. Strong interpersonal abilities enable university librarians to play a significant role that support social and political well-being of the university. In local scenario, they could organize lectures and training sessions to help other academic librarians develop their skills. They could join statutory groups that develop laws to advance the field of librarianship. Moreover, the present study suggested the development a comprehensive instrument in assessing the interpersonal competencies of academic librarians based on the competency index for the library field prepared by OCLC web junction in 2014.
... As asserted by previous studies [21][22]33], to what extent, the paradigm of scientific communication, the dissemination of research findings includes the formats, methods and methodologies of referencing have brought to great changes. The development and emergence of the Internet, alertness of copyright, plagiarism and the scientific value of research are some of the vital aspects that motivate both researchers and publishers to promote accurate material in academic writing. ...
Article
Full-text available
Referencing competencies are the knowledge, skills, and ability to effectively managing individual's reference sources. The importance of referencing competencies has been widely regarded in the literature. However, there is a scarcity of research focusing on referencing competencies; research is focusing on general competencies of users. Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to develop and validate an instrument to measure referencing competencies and its impact on individual performance. The research was conducted on several empirical phases. First, list of predictors and dependent variables was formulated based on previous similar studies. Second, a pilot instrument was developed based on the variables that has been identified. Third, the instrument was validated by an expert review process. Finally, the face validity and reliability analysis was conducted among potential respondents. As a result, a valid instrument to measure referencing competencies and individual performance was produced, consisting of 5 variables and 24-items. The instrument could be employed to measure the level of referencing competencies among undergraduate and postgraduate students, as well as measuring the impact towards individual performance.
Article
This study intends to examine the impact of using Digital resources on enhancement of quality of Social researches in public and private universities of Sindh. Researcher made five objectives to fulfill the purpose of the study. He framed five hypotheses based on the objectives to compare public and private universities in following the selected variables in order to measure the productivity of the digital resources. The nature of the research was causal comparative in which, researcher intends to examine the impact of already existed variable on other variables. Adopted research design was survey. Approach of the study was quantitative. Close-ended questionnaire based on 5 points likerts was the instrument for collecting the data. Population of the study was novice research scholars who were enrolled in postgraduate programs (Maters, MS/Phil and PhD) in departments of social sciences of private and public universities in Karachi after 2015. Adopted sampling technique was cluster sampling technique; one of the probability techniques. Sample size was 350 respondents. Data was analyzed statistically using inferential statistics for analyzing the hypotheses through using SPSS25.All hypotheses were accepted and proved that the provided facility of digital resources impacted the social researches significantly. It improved the quality of research articles of the novice researchers. It also helped in enhancing the research skills of researchers by providing international exposure.
Article
The history of Library and Information Science in Pakistan is traced back to the arrival of W. A. Broaden and Asa Don Dickinson to Sub-continent in 1911 and 1916 respectively. This piece of document tends to explore the history of library and library science education, library activities and role of professional associations in promotion of library culture in North-West part of Pakistan. This study is basically historical in nature. The paper is broadly divided into three parts that is library science education, library developments through ages and library associations and their role in the promotion of libraries in Khyber Pakhtunkhawa. Efforts were made to elaborate the growth of libraries in different eras over the passage of time. The role of Muslims and British in the promotion of library culture is also discussed. It is reflected that both nations have made no stone left un-turned for the establishment of libraries in this part of sub-continent. It is also evident from the pages of history that the introduction of Library and Information Science education was not that late here as compared to the rest of the world. University of Punjab is the third in the race of ranking after Germany and United States to offer this program. Various associations had also played their roles in this regard. They had worked hard for the promotion of library culture. The role of Pakistan Library Association (PLA) is observant and praise worthy in the said context. It is concluded that future of libraries and their education is bright in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa as library schools, senior professionals and associations are playing their due role with zeal and favor.
Article
Full-text available
Defines and validates competences for entry-level professionals of academic libraries in Malaysia keeping in view the needs of the next five years. Top and middle managers of all the university libraries and two other academic libraries participated in the study. A scale of perceived importance of each competence was used for validation of competences organized in the six areas of foundation, cataloguing, circulation, information services, collection development, and serial control. A distinct emphasis is noted for contextual, managerial, technological and service competences. The validated competences can be used for the evaluation and revision of the curricula of formal education programmes.
Article
A survey of professional leadership of library and information organizations in Malaysia was conducted to gather their perceptions about the trends in the field during the next 10 years, the extent of preparedness of entry-level professionals and the strategies they proposed for an improvement in education and development programmes. A total of 148 top- and middle-managers from 30 organizations, equally divided among the three strata of academic, public and special libraries, were interviewed for filling in an open-ended questionnaire. A qualitative analysis of the responses revealed that the participants strongly felt that future libraries would be electronically inter-connected, would have a variety of media to access and would undergo organizational changes. They noted major discrepancies in the demands and preparedness of the entry-level professional in the areas of information technology, management capabilities and behavioural dimensions. A number of measures were proposed for improvement in formal education, continuing education activities and the role of the professional association.
Article
Unplanned expansion of library education facilities has affected the quality of library manpower. Various constraints encountered by library schools in their effort to improve the situation are discussed and suggestions are offered. Bright students are not attracted to library schools because of low status according to librarians in the society. Traditional courses dominate the curriculum, with very little emphasis on computer and media courses. The existing faculty lacks competence for the teaching of courses relating to information technology. The teaching methodology is primarily characterized by traditional class-room lecture, supported by practical work. The existing facilities for conducting practicals are not satisfactory with few bibliographical and reference tools available together with a lack of equipment. The most recently published books are seldom available, while there is an absence of periodical literature. Continuing education is confined to the organization of courses in computer applications by the Pakistan Library Association and its branches. The distance education programme needs improvement in order to avoid further criticism. Both M.Phil. and Ph.D. programmes are still in their initial phases and are under scrutiny constantly by academics.
Article
A study was conducted to identify sets of competencies which could become the basis for the design of information study programs for the two levels of undergraduate and graduate education. A list of 70 competencies was used to gather responses from the middle and top managers of the Gulf libraries about the manpower needs of the profession in the next five to ten years. The perceptions of the respondents were also collected about different aspects of information studies at the two levels. The results have indicated that the respondents prefer to have the two levels of programs designed differently around specific sets of competencies with an appreciation of the distinct roles the graduates from the two types of programs have to play.
Article
This study ascertains the attitudes of library school alumni regarding the value of including various competencies in an M.L.S. program in order to facilitate curriculum planning. A total of 736 alumni rated a list of fifty-five competencies. Twenty-five percent of alumni had been out of library school less than three years; 60 percent had been out less than ten years. The largest category of respondents is represented by public librarians (39 percent), followed by academic librarians (20 percent), school librarians (19 percent), special librarians (10 percent), and those in nonlibrary settings (12 percent). There was a significant relationship between the type of library course taken during library school and the type of library in which the respondent found employment. Children's and young adult literature was the most popular "type of literature" course taken. The five competencies ranked most frequently as essential include: knowledge of sources, collection management skills, conducting a reference interview, communicating effectively in writing, and the ability to apply critical thinking skills to library problems. Rating of competencies was also analyzed by beginning librarians. Competencies valued also differed as a function of setting. Findings were compared to those of an earlier study conducted by the authors in 1987.
Article
Faculty evaluation criteria were scrutinized utilizing the following variables: academic qualifications, professional experience, and research and publication credentials. The faculty of six graduate programs of library education in Pakistan were evaluated using these variables in order to examine their preparedness. Data were collected by administering two questionnaires to obtain faculty profiles and bio-bibliographic information. It was found that the number of faculty was inadequate in many departments, senior positions were either unavailable or remained unfilled, few teachers had obtained the doctorate, many teachers lacked experience in the areas in which they taught courses, and research and publication credentials were weak. Remedial measures proposed to improve the situation include creating additional positions, providing opportunities for doctoral study, improving recruitment policies, and sharpening research and publication skills of faculty through specialized programs.
Article
A survey of professional leadership of library and information organizations in Malaysia was conducted to gather their perceptions about the trends in the field during the next 10 years, the extent of preparedness of entry-level professionals and the strategies they proposed for an improvement in education and development programmes. A total of 148 top- and middle-managers from 30 organizations, equally divided among the three strata of academic, public and special libraries, were interviewed for filling in an open-ended questionnaire. A qualitative analysis of the responses revealed that the participants strongly felt that future libraries would be electronically inter-connected, would have a variety of media to access and would undergo organizational changes. They noted major discrepancies in the demands and preparedness of the entry-level professional in the areas of information technology, management capabilities and behavioural dimensions. A number of measures were proposed for improvement in formal education, continuing education activities and the role of the professional association.
Article
The rapid changes in higher education in the UK are prompting library and information professionals to reflect on the nature of the services they provide and on the appropriateness of their skills. Explores the kinds of skills which will be required by academic - and, in particular, subject - librarians in the foreseeable future. Notes that, while technological developments clearly have important implications for libraries, they should not overshadow the more people-oriented skills which are equally essential for organizing and providing effective services. Makes practical suggestions concerning specific groups of skills including improving credibility with academic staff, giving guidance on teaching information skills, focusing on particular IT-related skills and acquiring key management skills such as managing change, finance and strategic awareness. Finally, addresses the responsibilities of the library’s management and the individual to ensure that skills are harnessed through co-ordination and continuity. In this way they will benefit both individual staff and the wider academic community.
Article
These curriculum guidelines are intended to offer some quality control for: programs just beginning with their curriculum development and other academic considerations; programs already in existence which are struggling to upgrade the content of their programs; and agencies which are administratively and financially responsible for implementing and supporting information policy and information services development. The document begins by considering the nature and characteristics of the information societies that are emerging in the Asia and the Pacific Region. From this it is possible to identify the range of skills and competencies that will be required in the future. The present education and training arrangements within the Region are briefly reviewed, and weaknesses and deficiencies in the present system are identified. Finally, a draft curriculum is outlined that can be regarded as the starting point for discussion and development of syllabi that reflect the local conditions. (AEF)
Article
Describes characteristics of core competencies. Examines the competencies a librarian should possess. Discusses types of competence and reviews advantages of developing and improving core competencies. Looks at core competencies in terms of the major service areas of public libraries. Presents several steps for building core competencies. (Contains 17 references.) (AEF)