ArticlePDF Available

Law and Borders - The rise of law in Cyberspace.

Authors:
David R. Johnson
David R. Johnson
David G. Post at Volokh Conspiracy
David G. Post
  • Volokh Conspiracy
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

Global computer-based communications cut across territorial borders, creating a new realm of human activity and undermining the feasibility--and legitimacy--of applying laws based on geographic boundaries. While these electronic communications play havoc with geographic boundaries, a new boundary, made up of the screens and passwords that separate the virtual world from the real world of atoms, emerges. This new boundary defines a distinct Cyberspace that needs and can create new law and legal institutions of its own. Territorially-based law-making and law-enforcing authorities find this new environment deeply threatening. But established territorial authorities may yet learn to defer to the self-regulatory efforts of Cyberspace participants who care most deeply about this new digital trade in ideas, information, and services. Separated from doctrine tied to territorial jurisdictions, new rules will emerge, in a variety of on-line spaces, to govern a wide range of new phenomena that have no clear parallel in the nonvirtual world. These new rules will play the role of law by defining legal personhood and property, resolving disputes, and crystallizing a collective conversation about core values.
Content uploaded by David R. Johnson
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by David R. Johnson on Oct 07, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
Electronic copy of this paper is available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=535
Electronic copy of this paper is available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=535
... Additionally, it is crucial to grasp the distinctions among the three variations of electronic commerce: e-commerce involving physical items, e-commerce centered on intangible products, and e-commerce revolving around services. Johnson & Post, (1996) assert that all categories of electronic commerce share a global nature, operating across the world without strict adherence to national borders. Ecommerce effectively transcends or even eradicates geographical boundaries. ...
Base Erosion and Profit Shifting in Taxation: A Deep Dive into The Two-Pillar Solution in Tanzania
Article
  • Jan 2024
This study explores the phenomenon of Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) within the framework of Tanzanian taxation. It places a specific focus on the intricate Two-Pillar Solution proposed by the OECD to tackle BEPS-related challenges. The analysis encompasses an in-depth investigation of BEPS itself and a thorough examination of the OECD's Two-Pillar Solution, which encompasses the novel nexus and profit allocation rules under Pillar One and the proposition of a minimum global tax under Pillar Two. Furthermore, the study delves into the evolving global trend toward multilateralism in the realm of international taxation. The research concludes by presenting recommended solutions and offering insights into the future landscape of BEPS-related issues, while also providing valuable observations on the subject matter. This paper adopts a doctrinal approach and draws upon primary and secondary sources of literature, including Tanzanian tax laws, OECD guidelines, and other international principles. It is expected to be a valuable resource for policymakers, academics, think tanks, the academic community, tax departments, international trade entities, digital taxation stakeholders, online businesses, and the judiciary, facilitating a deeper understanding of BEPS and its implications.
View
... Additionally, it is crucial to grasp the distinctions among the three variations of electronic commerce: e-commerce involving physical items, e-commerce centered on intangible products, and e-commerce revolving around services. Johnson & Post, (1996) assert that all categories of electronic commerce share a global nature, operating across the world without strict adherence to national borders. Ecommerce effectively transcends or even eradicates geographical boundaries. ...
The conundrum of the notion of Permanent Establishment (PE) in Taxation of Tanzania's e-commerce
Article
  • Jun 2024
Purpose: To understand how Tanzania taxes digital commerce transactions, this paper explores the complex terrain of Permanent Establishment (PE). Design/Methodology/Approach: This study is analytical descriptive legal research. Secondary data sources encompass primary, secondary, and tertiary materials were used. Findings: The review's outcome has revealed that this traditional notion of PE has historically worked well for taxing conventional businesses; however, the concept of PE, as defined by the Tanzanian Income Tax Act, has failed to address and cover e-commerce issues. Hence, the concept of PE requires substantial modifications to align with the contemporary and future challenges of e-commerce. Research Limitations: The study's primary constraint is its restriction to a thorough review. Managerial Application: This study's results are poised to provide significant guidance for reshaping tax legislation in Tanzania to align with modern challenges. Moreover, the study seeks to heighten public awareness regarding the Permanent Establishment and the taxation of digital commerce transactions while also serving as a valuable reference for future research ventures within the same domain. Originality/Value: This study offers a novel perspective on Tanzanian taxes and the connection between online transactions and permanent establishments.
View
View
A literature review of the evolution of sovereignty and borders concepts in cyberspace
Article
Full-text available
  • Apr 2024
The enormous amount of data exchanged daily in cyberspace has directed states to review and implement different types of surveillance mechanisms to defend their national interests against harmful cyber activities. The implementation of security requirements by states implies the extension of the concepts of borders and sovereignty from the real world to cyberspace, which means developing a suitable interpretation of these concepts to adapt their traditional legal notions to the technical nature of cyberspace, since the traditional interpretation of these concepts contradicts the rapidly changing nature of cyberspace. The research seeks to elaborate on the scholarly evolution concerning conceptualising borders and sovereignty in cyberspace. Therefore, it contributes to knowledge by providing an acceptable legal interpretation of the concepts of borders and sovereignty in cyberspace and proving their adaptability to the particular nature of this technological sphere of universal interaction. To achieve this objective, the research adopts a doctrinal approach that reviews relevant literature to conclude scholarly interpretations of these concepts in cyberspace.
View
CYBERCRIME IN A CYBER-DEPENDENT WORLD: ENLISTING THE DEVELOPING WORLD IN ADDRESSING THE GROWING PROBLEM OF CYBERCRIME
Thesis
  • Sep 2019
The internet and its attendant benefits have brought about remarkable positive transformation in every sphere of the human enterprise, adding speed and efficiency through the availability and ease in transferring information without any obstruction by jurisdiction, time and cost. The inherent advantage that the ubiquitous nature of the internet brings also emphasises the need for proper and effective regulation of this “world without borders” if the world will not experience a breakdown of order. This will involve the combined efforts of both developed and developing countries. The reality is that developed countries are taking proactive steps to tackle cybercrime, while developing countries are apathetic and are taking few or no steps to participate in the efforts to address cybercrime. This will hamper the measures put in place by developed countries to address cybercrime because of the ubiquitous nature of the internet. This thesis examines the steps that may be embarked upon to get developing countries involved in addressing the growing problem of cybercrime. The efforts already undertaken by developed countries in their drive to halt cybercrime are highlighted. This research will be focused on objectively evaluating the response of developing countries in the fight against cybercrime, evolving ways to pull developing countries out of their inherent apathy in the growing spate of cybercriminal activities and to get them actively involved in tackling cybercrime. This thesis therefore looks at the prevailing legislative, regulatory and law enforcement initiatives put in place by both developed and developing countries, identifies its inadequacies and proffers solutions on how both divides can be on the same page to effectively tackle cybercrime. This research proposes the emergence of harmonised legislation, harmonised law enforcement and adjudicatory systems that will accommodate and propel the active participation of both developed and developing countries in the fight against cybercrime. The thesis further identifies the debilitating effects of various socio-economic factors on the ability of developing countries to effectively address cybercrime, and thus proffers a number of socio-economic strategies that will cure same. The thesis also accesses the existing regulatory and internet governance schemes which discourage the participation of developing countries and suggests the emergence of an effective regulatory structure that encourages universal participation. Any effective effort that will lead to the participation of developing countries in tackling cybercrime will encompass several strategic legal approaches and non-legal approaches which will cut through some law-making and decision-making, law enforcement and prosecution, and socio-economic strategies. It is important that both developed and developing countries start taking steps to ensure that the menace of cybercrime does not get out of hand.
View
Electronic Extortion Crime: Understanding Internet Criminals' Tactics, Strategies, and Ways to Confront Them
Conference Paper
Full-text available
  • May 2023
This study aims to address and analyze the crime of electronic extortion, focusing on the advanced strategies and tactics used by internet criminals in their repeated threats to users. The study also seeks to uncover the various forms of electronic extortion, the most vulnerable victims, and to propose counter-strategies to maintain information security and protect users from risks and threats they face, as well as to deal with this digital crime, particularly for individuals and companies, by taking proactive steps to protect themselves and their personal data. The importance of this study lies in its valuable contribution to the field of cybersecurity, as a reminder of the need to maintain information security practices in the cyberspace, especially in light of the dominance of advanced attacks, data breaches, the widespread use of ransomware and various aggressive viruses, against the fragility of users and excessive identity detection. Keywords: cyber-crime, Electronic extortion, Cybersecurity, Trojan horse, Ransomware, Worms.
View
Is Online Moral Outrage Outrageous? Rethinking the Indignation Machine
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2023
  • SCI ENG ETHICS
Moral outrage is often characterized as a corrosive emotion, but it can also inspire collective action. In this article we aim to deepen our understanding of the dual nature of online moral outrage which divides people and contributes to inclusivist moral reform. We argue that the specifics of violating different types of moral norms will influence the effects of moral outrage: moral outrage against violating harm-based norms is less antagonistic than moral outrage against violating loyalty and purity/identity norms. We identify which features of social media platforms shape our moral lives. Connectivity, omniculturalism, online exposure, increased group identification and fostering what we call “expressionist experiences”, all change how moral outrage is expressed in the digital realm. Finally, we propose changing the design of social media platforms and raise the issue of moral disillusion when ample moral protest in the online environment does not have the expected effects on the offline world.
View
View
Bibliography
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Jan 2022
Despite the century-long reiteration of the principle of territorial sovereignty, States are increasingly resorting to extraterritorial jurisdiction. This book comparatively analyses this phenomenon in US and European practice in the areas of economic sanctions, export control, anti-corruption and business & human rights. It makes the case that the territoriality-based system of jurisdiction is inadequate for allocating regulatory competences between States in international practice. As a result, this book proposes a new approach to conceptualizing jurisdiction by moving away from formal territoriality and towards considering extraterritorial jurisdiction from its function as an exercise of public authority.
View
Reconceiving Extraterritorial Jurisdiction: From Formality to Function
Book
Full-text available
  • Jan 2022
Despite the century-long reiteration of the principle of territorial sovereignty, States are increasingly resorting to extraterritorial jurisdiction. This book comparatively analyses this phenomenon in US and European practice in the areas of economic sanctions, export control, anti-corruption and business & human rights. It makes the case that the territoriality-based system of jurisdiction is inadequate for allocating regulatory competences between States in international practice. As a result, this book proposes a new approach to conceptualizing jurisdiction by moving away from formal territoriality and towards considering extraterritorial jurisdiction from its function as an exercise of public authority.
View
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.