Integrated Dynamic Modeling of Contaminant Fate and Transport within a Soil–Plant System

Vadose Zone Journal (Impact Factor: 1.78). 11/2011; 10(4):1130-1150. DOI: 10.2136/vzj2010.0123


Contaminants found in the soil and in the atmosphere frequently find their way into plants. Because plants are at the bottom of the food chain, analysis of this pathway contributes to health risk assessment studies. On the other hand, plants that exist at a contaminated site have a potential effect on contaminant transformation and migration within the soil or the atmosphere. In this study, a modeling framework was developed to integrate the plant pathway into soil contaminant transport models. A soil–plant system model was developed by coupling soil moisture distribution, contaminant transport, plant life cycle, and plant pathway models. The outcome unifies single-medium continuous models with multimedia compartmental models in a flexible framework. The framework recognizes that plants are dynamic biologic systems that regulate their life cycle in interaction with existing conditions in the ambient environment, which significantly influence the dynamics of the overall complex system. The model developed was applied to a hypothetical contamination scenario where the effect of plants on contaminant migration within the system was investigated. Also, the outcome of the plant pathway as it responds to water flow and contaminant transport dynamics was analyzed. A mass balance analysis found that the processes of volatilization and root water uptake are very critical in determining the contaminant fate within the system. A sensitivity analysis showed that the contaminant concentration within the plant is significantly affected by the variation in the values of the retardation factor, transpiration stream concentration factor, and contaminant half-life within the plant. The outcome of these applications reflects the effect of multiple levels of complexity associated with plant growth and root water uptake representations within the soil.

Download full-text


Available from: Recep Kaya Göktaş
  • Source
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Solute active transport or exclusion by plants can be identified by the values of the Transpiration Stream Concentration Factor (TSCF=xylem:solution solute concentration ratio). The aim of this study was to estimate this parameter for Ni uptake by the Ni-hyperaccumulator Leptoplax emarginata or the Ni-excluder Triticum aestivum cultivar 'Fidel'. The Intact Plant TSCF for nickel (IPTSCF(Ni)) was calculated as the ratio between the nickel mass accumulation in the leaves and the nickel concentration in solution per volume of water transpired. Predominantly, Ni active transport occurred for L. emarginata, with IPTSCF(Ni) values of 4.7-7.2 and convective component proportions of the root Ni uptake flow of only 15-20% for a range of Ni concentrations in solutions of 2-16 µmol Ni l(-1), regardless of the growth period and the time of Ni uptake. Hyperaccumulator roots were permeable to both water and nickel (mean reflection coefficient for Ni, σ(Ni), of 0.06), which was mainly attributed to an absence of exodermis. Results provide a new view of the mechanisms of Ni hyperaccumulation. By contrast, the wheat excluder was characterized by an extremely low mean IPTSCF(Ni) value of 0.006, characterizing a predominantly Ni sequestration in roots. From a methodological viewpoint, the 'microscopic' TSCF(Ni), measured directly on excised plants was 2.4 times larger than its recommended 'macroscopic' IPTSCF(Ni) counterpart. Overall, IPTSCF and σ determined on intact transpiring plants appeared to be very useful biophysical parameters in the study of the mechanisms involved in metal uptake and accumulation by plants, and in their modelling.
    Full-text · Article · Sep 2012 · Journal of Experimental Botany
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Aims The aim of the present study was to predict kinetics of both Ni concentration in soil solution and leaf Ni mass for the Ni-hyperaccumulator Leptoplax emarginata cultivated on a fertilized and Ni-contaminated sandy topsoil. Methods The 0-D (independent of space) one-site rate-limited desorption model proposed by Ingwersen et al. (J Environ Qual 35:2055–2065, 2006) was modified. The plant sink term of the model was approximated by the biophysical equation which assumes that the leaf nickel mass is equal to the triple product of the Intact Plant Transpiration Stream Concentration Factor for Ni IPTSCFNi (xylem:solution Ni concentration ratio), Ni concentration in solution and the volume of transpired water. The model input variables were the constant mean IPTSCFNi value, determined from independent leaf Ni accumulation kinetics, and the exponential law fitting the transpiration rate kinetics. Using the best calibration, the model was validated and a sensitivity analysis was carried out thereafter. Models were formulated as sets of ordinary differential equation systems which were solved using the fourth-order Runge–Kutta method. Results The best model calibration was the joint parameter optimization: the two parameters of the Freundlich Ni adsorption isotherm and of the Ni desorption rate coefficient are obtained using the kinetics of Ni concentrations in the soil solutions for the reference unplanted Ni-contaminated topsoils. The model was validated reasonably well for both Ni concentration in soil solution and leaf Ni mass. Conclusions The joint parameter optimization of the two parameters of the Freundlich nickel sorption isotherm and of the Ni desorption rate was successful whereas the Freundlich batch Ni sorption isotherm dramatically overestimated Ni sorption. This joint approach is therefore recommended for any plant metal uptake model. The 0-D one-site rate-limited desorption model linked to a biophysical coupled Ni and water uptake model reasonably validated the kinetics of both Ni concentration in solution and leaf Ni mass. This promising simplified model for predicting both metal concentration in solution and leaf metal mass for metal needs further validations in culture chambers and further improvements in order to use it in the field as a one-dimensional model, taking into account soil moisture dynamics.
    No preview · Article · Jan 2014 · Plant and Soil
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Crops irrigated with reclaimed wastewater or grown in biosolids-amended soils may take up pharmaceutical and personal care product ingredients (PPCPs) through their roots. However, the uptake pathways followed by PPCPs and the likelihood that these compounds bioaccumulate in food crops are still not well understood. Comparison of results from descriptive studies indicates that more than just the lipophilicity of the contaminant governs uptake, yet discrepancies in methodology and reporting have so far hindered development of models to predict plant uptake of these compounds. Current predictive models do not account for many important plant and environmental processes, and are often designed solely for nonpolar, neutral organic contaminants. Here, we review pertinent plant biology, published literature on uptake of PPCPs by specific crops, and models for plant uptake of organic contaminants. We conducted several analyses of literature data for PPCP uptake and found that molecular descriptors used to predict transmembrane migration and in drug discovery did not correlate strongly with plant uptake. We conclude with suggestions of how future study can help to develop and validate better predictive models for plant uptake of current and future PPCPs.
    No preview · Article · Nov 2015 · Environmental Science & Technology