ArticlePublisher preview available

Correlation between Visual Disembedding and Basketball Shooting by Male and Female Varsity College Athletes

SAGE Publications Inc
Perceptual and Motor Skills
Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.
Perceptual and Motor Skills,
1975, 41,956.
@
Perceptual and Motor Skills 1975
CORRELATION BETWEEN VISUAL DISEMBEDDING
AND
BASKETBALL SHOOTING BY MALE
AND
FEMALE
VARSITY COLLEGE ATHLETES
DAVID PARGMAN PETER BENDER PAUL DESHAIES
Florida State University John Abbott College University of Sherbrooke
The delineation of visual attributes related to the qualiry of athletic performance
is
not yet clearly established. Research suggccts that basketball shooting performance is
meaningfully related to distance
perception
(3)
and dynamic visual acuity
(I),
while
relarively unrelated to measures of depth perception
(4)
and visual imagery (5). Other
properties such as visual disembedding have yet to be considered in relation to successful
basketball shooting. Visual disembedding refers to the ability to break up an organized
visual field in order to keep a part of it separate from its surroundings. The task is
static like those used for depth perception and imagery and is c!aimed to be the core trait
of
globs!-analytic
cognitive style (6).
To estimate the correlation between efficiency of basketball shooting and ability to
disembed a complex visual field. 11 male
(M,,,,
=
20.7 yr.,
SD
=
1.01), and
9
female
(M...
=
20.5.
SD
=
1.93) sophomore and junior varsity basketball players, enrolled
at Florida State University were administered the Group Hidden-figures Test, an adapta-
tion of the Gottschaldt Figures Test (2). The task required subjects to determine which
of five simple figures was embedded in a more comp'ex pattern. The test was admin-
istered midway in the basketball season. Scores were correlated with the seasonal field-
goal and free-throw shooring efficiency of each subject. Efficiency ratings were the ratio
of successful shots to the total attempts during competition. A minimum of 20 and
10 attempts in the field-goal and free-throw caregories respectively were established as
criteria for including subjects' data. Mean number of field-goal attempts
=
184.3,
SD
=
115.1 for the males, and 138.6.
SD
=
72.4
for the females; mean number of free-
throw attempts
=
47.3,
SD
=
20.9 for the males, and
M
=
60.2,
SD
=
34.9
for the
females.
The Group Hidden-figures Test scores were not significantly correlated
with
either
percentages of free throws (males -.41; females -.05) or field goals (males .16;
females --.21). While
a
number of competition variables might be considered, these
calculations
clearly suggest that the ability to disembed a static visual field is not a vari-
able of concern in the understanding of the dynamic visual properties which relate to
basketball shooting.
REFERENCES
1.
BEALS,
R.
P.,
MAWASI, A. M., TEMPLBTON,
A.
E.,
&
JOHNSTON,
W.
L.
The relation-
ship between basketball shooting performance and certain visual attributes.
American Journal of Optometry and Archives of American Academy of Optometry,
197 1,48, 585-590.
2.
JACKSON, D.
N.
A short form of Witkin's Embedded Figures Test.
Journal of
Abnormal Psychology,
1956, 53, 254-255.
3.
MURPHEY, P. The utilization of standard motor skills in the field of athletics. Un-
published thesis. Iowa State Univer., 1930.
4. SHICK,
J.
Relationship between depth perception and hand-eye dominance and free-
throw shooting in college women.
Pcrceptrral and Motor Skills,
1971, 33, 539-
542.
5. TURNELL, A. The relationship of visual imagery to the ability to learn certain game
skills. Unpublished thesis, Iowa State Univer., 1949.
6.
WITKIN,
H.
A.,
DYK,
R.
B.,
FATERSON,
H.
F., GOODENOUGH,
D.
R.,
&
KARP, S.
A.
Prychological differentiation.
New York: Wiley, 1962.
Accepted November
20,
1975.
... Williams and Thirer (1975) found no significant relationship between figure-ground perception and fencing skills. I n a related study, Pargman, Bender, and Deshaies (1975) reported s i d a r results while analyzing basketball shooting skills. Deshaies and Pargman (1976) concluded that perception is not significantly related to level of athletic performance in college football players. ...
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of this article is to illustrate the significance of the cognitive system in sport expertise. Consideration of visual-perceptual abilities, along with cognitive factors and their relationship with sport expertise, suggest that level of sport performance can be reliably differentiated on several cognitive dimensions. Information is given concerning the cognitive requirements of sports skills. It is argued that, although visual-perceptual abilities are inherent in all levels of sport performance, cognitive factors are essential for sport expertise.
... According to field dependence-independence theory, it may be hypothesized that field-independent individuals should have less difficulty in acquiring motor skills for which body orientation and proprioceptive and kinesthetic cues like those previously mentioned are crucial. Although some researchers have found no significant differences on field independence among players and nonplayers of basketball (5) and hockey (2) or between successful free shots in basketball and perceptual style (8), others have noted that skills in motor activities may be positively related to field-independence. I t appears that individuals who play sports are more field-independent than those who do not, and individuals who play individual sports that require an internal orientation such as swimming or gymnastics are more field-independent than those who play team sports such as volleyball or soccer (6). ...
Article
Full-text available
The relation between spatial ability (body orientation and body awareness) and field dependence/independence was assessed by measuring performance on the Embedded Figures Test and WISC or WAIS Block Design at four different training levels in classical ballet, beginners to advanced, and a control group with no training in ballet, gymnastics, or sports (n = 70). No significant correlation was found between perceptual style or Block Design performance and body orientation or body awareness at any of the four levels of training. No significant differences were observed between the advanced group and the control group. Training in a particular type of spatial skill such as orientation within surrounding space was not related to the skill required to manipulate an abstractly represented space.
... T h e tennis players of high abilii-y were significantly more field-dependent than players of medium ability. Pargman, Bender, and Deshaies ( 1975) reported n o relationship between two basketball shooting skills and perceptual styles on the Group Hidden Figures Test. I n a study of fencers of varying ability, Williams (1975) found no significant differences in their performance on a measure of field-dependence. ...
Article
Full-text available
The aim of the present study is to test two hypotheses, (1) Witkin and Goodenough's 1982 assumption that participation in a structured physical activity increases field-independence and (2) that subjects characterized by high field-independence would show greater gains than subjects with high field-dependence on ice hockey skills. An adaptation of Oltman, Raskin, and Witkin's Group Embedded Figures Test (GEFT) was given to measure field-dependency and standardized tests were used to evaluate the players' skill. An experimental group of 26 boys (M = 11.27 yr.) were members of an ice hockey training program; 18 boys of a control group (M = 11.93 yr.) participated in no programmed physical activity. A pretest (field-dependency and skill) was administered 21 weeks prior to the posttest; no significant differences were found for scores on embedded figures between groups; Witkin and Goodenough's hypothesis was not supported, but field-independent subjects tended to learn more.
Article
Full-text available
The purpose of the study was to examine differences in depth perception of students classified according to their gross locomotor skills. The seven qualitative gross locomotor tasks of Ulrich's Test of Gross and Motor Development were used to classify 162 students as either motor impaired (n1 = 27) or nonimpaired (n2 = 135). The Howard Dollman Apparatus was used to measure depth perception. Analysis showed that the motor-impaired group scored significantly lower than the nonimpaired group on depth perception. Discriminant function analysis indicated that only the running task separated the students by depth perception scores. Subsequent multiple regression analysis confirmed that the running task, along with sliding and galloping, were significant predictors of the students' perception of the third dimension. Physical educators working with students with gross locomotor impairments or low perception of the third dimension need to adjust their teaching and offer opportunities for successful involvement in physical education classes and sports.
Article
Full-text available
The relationship between physical fitness and field independence was assessed by measuring embedded-figures test performance in the following four groups of children in Grades 4 through 6: (1) 93 boys high in physical fitness, (2) 92 girls high in physical fitness, (3) 67 boys low in physical fitness, and (4) 77 girls low in physical fitness. The group of girls low in physical fitness was significantly more field dependent than the other three groups. No significant differences were found among the other three groups. It appears that skill in physical activities may be related to the embedded-figures test performance of girls, but not boys. In fact, girls skilled in physical activities may be as field independent as boys.
Chapter
Vision is recognized as an important element of sports performance. Which visual factors are important and how to most effectively assess visual performance is the source of much debate. This chapter presents an evidence-based review of the common visual performance factors assessed in athletes. Updates on commercially available instrumentation to assess various visual performance abilities is presented.
Article
Over the past 16 years, new theories and models have emerged in the stress and anxiety knowledge base regarding the unique forms associated with performance. Existing theories have been applied in creative and helpful ways to better explicate relationships between stress and anxiety with performance. Recently, more sophisticated statistical strategies have been applied to data collected with performers, and additional, safe and expedient strategies for managing stress and anxiety have surfaced. Despite these new advances, the field has been lacking an up-to-date and practical text for undergraduate and graduate students in performing or performance-mentoring programs. Managing Performance Stress examines psychological and psychophysiological models and theories that explain causes of anxiety and stress. An easy-to-use reference work for athletes, musicians, dancers and actors as well as those who devise and conduct their training programs, the book presents exercises, coaching devices, and strategies for conquering stress and anxiety. It is an invaluable resource for those who are performers, will be performers, or who are preparing to mentor, coach or teach performers. The principles enunciated in Managing Performance Stress apply equally to the musician holding an oboe and the athlete holding a baseball bat. The issues explored and the theories, principles, models, hypotheses discussed all bear upon and clarify arousal, stress and anxiety related to artistic and sport performance, irrespective of its kind.
Article
From basic eye care services to visual performance enhancement training, this evidence-based resource explores a wide range of sports vision services, addressing many of the questions you may have regarding assessment and treatment procedures, outcome expectations, and applications to sport. You'll find a thorough review and discussion of the role of vision care in an athlete's performance, as well as practical recommendations for applying current research findings to clinical practice. The accompanying CD-ROM enables you to easily print your own copies and versions of evaluation forms, screening forms, sample profiles, and patient handouts, plus other samples and resources used in client assessment and training! Evidence-based information covers a wide range of sports vision services. A task analysis approach used throughout the text allows the reader to develop solid reasoning skills and evaluate information needed for clinical practice. Coverage of goals, expectations, and strategies assists in determining the treatment options for a multitude of sports. Practical, clinically oriented chapters on assessment, prescribing, and ocular injuries provide the essential information needed for clinical practice in an easy-to-use reference. Addresses vision training from the certified athletic trainers (ATC) perspective, reflecting the collaboration between athletic trainers, optometrists, and ophthalmologists in managing athletes. Visual aids including photographs, tables, and boxed text help to clarify important concepts and allow ease of access to important information. A CD-ROM is included allowing quick access to important resources used in client assessment and training.
Article
Full-text available
Witkin, Dyk, Faterson, Goodenough, and Karp in 1962 suggested two polar extremes of perceptual ability, field dependence and field-independence, which were seen as relatively permanent personality characteristics. Rudin (1968) suggested a more general concept to explain Witkin's results which was designated “ego autonomy.” Rudin demonstrated that field-independence was related to the ability to change perceptual set. Jones (1973) suggested that game players should be more field-independent than nongame players and be capable of shifting perceptual set. This study was designed to determine whether male and female basketball players were more field-independent than nonbasketball players and whether basketball players were capable of changing perceptual set. Analysis of data demonstrated that male and female basketball players were not significantly more field-independent than nonbasketball players. Among the male basketball players and the combined male basketball and nonbasketball players, the more field-independent subjects were able to change perceptual set. It was concluded that there may be consistent differences between males and females in ability to change perceptual set. Male basketball players' ability to change perceptual set may be related to the level of field-independence. The basketball players in this study were not more field-independent than nonbasketball players.
Article
Full-text available
32 Ss took a total of 50 free throws, with 10 shots on each of five days. Depth perception measures used were the stereopsis test for the Bausch and Lomb Master Ortho-Rater and a modified version of the Howard-Dohlman apparatus. Eye dominance was determined by the “hole-in-card-test”; handedness by the preferred hand for performing basketball skills. No statistically significant results were found when comparing free-throw records with either measure of depth perception. With reference to dominance, no significant difference was found in free-throw success between unilaterally dominant Ss and those of mixed dominance. Although no statistically significant difference was found between the groups for percentage of errors toward the dominant hand; toward the non-dominant, a significant F resulted. The mixed dominance group had the higher percentage.
Article
Full-text available
A short form of Witkin's Embedded-figures Test is presented as a good alterative to the longer form which sometimes may require more than an hour and a half for its administration. The short form correlates .99 with the entire scale, based upon a sample of 50 college students. "It thus appears that the 12-item short form with a 3-minute limit gives a very good approximation of results obtained from the entire Witkin embedded-figures test while requiring only half as much administration time." (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2006 APA, all rights reserved).
Article
: A study was made to determine the degree of correlation between the shooting accuracy of nine varsity basketball players and the visual attributes of static visual acuity, dynamic visual acuity, depth perception, and size constancy. The data were subjected to a principal-component analysis, followed by a linear regression model, using a digital computer. The results indicate that basket shooting accuracy is significantly dependent upon dynamic visual acuity, and that individual shooting performances from both the field and free-throw line can be predicted within an error of 4% using the multiple regression model developed in this study.
The utilization of standard motor skills in the field of athletics
  • P. Murphey
The relationship of visual imagery to the ability to learn certain game skills
  • A. Turnell