ChapterPDF Available

La pasividad de los deprimidos les protege de la ilusión de control

January 2008

In book: Emoción y Motivación: Contribuciones actuales (Vol. 2) (pp.79-91)
Publisher: Asociación de Motivación y Emoción
Editors: I. Etxebarria, A. Aritzeta, E. Barberá, M. Chóliz, M. Jiménez, F. Martínez-Sánchez, P. Mateos, D. Páez

Authors:

Fernando Blanco

University of Granada

University of Deusto

Miguel A. Vadillo

Universidad Autónoma de Madrid

Content uploaded by Miguel A. Vadillo

Content may be subject to copyright.

Blanco, F., Vadillo, M. A., & Matute, H. (2008). La

pasividad de los depresivos les protege de la ilusión de

control. En I. Etxebarria et al. (Eds.), Emoción y

motivación: Contribuciones actuales (Vol. 2, pp. 79-90).

San Sebastián: Asociación de Motivación y Emoción.

ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.

ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.

Project

The dubious reliability of implicit cognition research: Current problems and ways forward

The study of unconscious cognitive processes is becoming one of the most vibrant and promising areas of research in psychological science. Many of these studies adopt the view, supported by a large volume of research, that elementary learning and memory processes demand few cognitive resources and can take place in the absence of awareness. This includes popular effects like sequence learning, artificial grammar learning, or visual statistical learning. The most common strategy to show that these effects are unconscious relies on a simple dissociation: After repeated exposure to a set of materials, participants become faster or more accurate at responding to these stimuli, revealing successful learning. However, when asked whether they recognise having been exposed to these stimuli in the past, they say no or they seem to be unable to discriminate between the stimuli they have seen and completely new stimuli. Furthermore, their score in this awareness test seems to be uncorrelated with performance in the learning task. In all cases, the lack of awareness is inferred from a null statistical result. In previous studies, we have claimed that this strategy is methodologically unsound because null results have an ambiguous interpretation in traditional, null hypothesis significance testing: They can mean that the null hypothesis is true or simply that the data are not sensitive enough to discriminate between the null and the alternative hypothesis. In the present project, we will highlight an additional problem in the interpretation of these results: The limited reliability of the dependent measures used to quantify learning and awareness. Our preliminary results suggest that, at least in the case of contextual cueing –an increasingly popular implicit learning paradigm– these reliabilities might be in the order of .10 to .20. The main goal of the present proposal is to explore and ameliorate the impact of low reliability in implicit cognition research. We will conduct several large-scale studies to estimate the reliability of the measures collected in contextual cueing and other implicit learning paradigms (probabilistic cueing of visual attention and multiple-cue probability learning). This information will allow us to use cutting-edge meta-analytic methods designed to correct for the attenuating effect of low reliability. The results of these meta-analyses can change dramatically our understanding of implicit learning, revealing, for instance, that the contribution of awareness to these effects is much larger than previously thought. If these reliabilities turn out to be as low as we expect, then it also follows that much of the applied research showing large and significant correlations between implicit learning processes and personal characteristics, like specific language impairment or dyslexia, must be biased, possibly due to selective publication or selective reporting. Our research will explore this possibility by using new methods for the detection and correction of these biases. Finally, the present proposal will devise new analytic methods, based on Bayesian hypothesis testing and computational modeling, to overcome the limitations of previous research on implicit learning. ... [more]

Project

Biases and reproducibility problems in psychological research

Miguel A. Vadillo

Muchos resultados de investigación están profundamente sesgados por la publicación selectiva de hallazgos estadísticamente significativos y por prácticas cuestionables de investigación (PCIs) adoptadas por los científicos en su intento por colocar sus investigaciones en las revistas más prestigiosas. La gran prevalencia de estos problemas supone que buena parte de los resultados que leemos en las revistas científicas pueden ser falsos positivos. La escasa fiabilidad y replicabilidad de los resultados científicos supone un enorme coste económico, frena el avance de la ciencia y la colaboración cienciaempresa, y afecta negativamente a la percepción pública de la ciencia. El presente proyecto de investigación tiene por objetivo diseñar nuevos métodos para la detección de estos sesgos y su aplicación a diversas áreas de psicología experimental y toma de decisiones que se cree que pueden estar especialmente comprometidos. La validez de estos métodos se comprobará no sólo mediante simulaciones computacionales, sino también contrastando sus predicciones con los resultados de experimentos ManyLabs realizados simultáneamente en varios laboratorios europeos. Los resultados no sólo arrojarán luz sobre la validez de la investigación realizada en estas áreas concretas (área científica prioritaria 7), sino que también proporcionará técnicas valiosas (y de uso accesible) para la exploración de sesgos en otras disciplinas biomédicas (área científica prioritaria 5). ... [more]

Article

Effet Charlie et réactions émotionnelles inconscientes. Intérêt et limite d’une expérience psychophy...

April 2016 · Journal de Thérapie Comportementale et Cognitive

Alain Mouchès

Résumé Ce travail explore l’intérêt de l’utilisation d’une technique électrophysiologique (la réponse électrodermale [RED]) pour évaluer les effets émotionnels en lien aux souvenirs des attentats de janvier 2015 à Paris. L’analyse des résultats obtenus permet de pointer les limites et l’impact de l’interprétation des paramètres psychophysiologiques appliqués en psychologie expérimentale. Ce ... [Show full abstract] travail conclut sur l’importance de stimuler l’esprit critique des futurs psychologues, face à la fascination qu’exercent certains outils psychophysiologiques.

Article

Full-text available

Making the Uncontrollable Seem Controllable: the Role of Action in the Illusion of Control

March 2011 · Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology (2006)

It is well known that certain variables can bias judgements about the perceived contingency between an action and an outcome, making them depart from the normative predictions. For instance, previous studies have proven that the activity level or probability of responding, P(R), is a crucial variable that can affect these judgements in objectively noncontingent situations. A possible account for ... [Show full abstract] the P(R) effect is based on the differential exposure to actual contingencies during the training phase, which is in turn presumably produced by individual differences in participants' P(R). The current two experiments replicate the P(R) effect in a free-response paradigm, and show that participants' judgements are better predicted by P(R) than by the actual contingency to which they expose themselves. Besides, both experiments converge with previous empirical data, showing a persistent bias that does not vanish as training proceeds. These findings contrast with the preasymptotic and transitory effect predicted by several theoretical models.

Article

Full-text available

Depressive Realism: Wiser or Quieter?

September 2009 · The Psychological record

Depressive realism consists of the lower personal control over uncontrollable events perceived by depressed as compared to nondepressed individuals. In this article, we propose that the realism of depressed individuals is caused not by an increased accuracy in perception, but by their more comprehensive exposure to the actual environmental contingencies, which in turn is due to their more ... [Show full abstract] pas-sive pattern of responding. To test this hypothesis, dysphoric and nondysphoric participants were exposed to an uncontrollable task and both their probability of responding and their judgment of control were assessed. As was expected, higher levels of depression correlated negatively with probability of responding and with the illusion of control. Implications for a therapy of depression are discussed.

Article

Fighting the Illusion of Control: How to Make Use of Cue Competition and Alternative Explanations

May 2013 · Universitas Psychologica

Misperceptions of causality are at the heart of superstitious thinking and pseudoscience. The main goal of the present work is to show how our knowledge about the mechanisms involved in causal induction can be used to hinder the development of these beliefs. Available evidence shows that people sometimes perceive causal relationships that do not really exist. We suggest that this might be ... [Show full abstract] partly due to their failing to take into account alternative factors that might be playing an important causal role. The present experiment shows that providing accurate and difficult-to-ignore information about other candidate causes can be a good strategy for reducing misattributions of causality, such as illusions of control.

Article

Full-text available

Mediating Role of Activity Level in the Depressive Realism Effect

September 2012 · PLoS ONE

Several classic studies have concluded that the accuracy of identifying uncontrollable situations depends heavily on depressive mood. Nondepressed participants tend to exhibit an optimistic illusion of control, whereas depressed participants tend to better detect a lack of control. Recently, we suggested that the different activity levels (measured as the probability of responding during a ... [Show full abstract] contingency learning task) exhibited by depressed and nondepressed individuals is partly responsible for this effect. The two studies presented in this paper provide further support for this mediational hypothesis, in which mood is the distal cause of the illusion of control operating through activity level, the proximal cause. In Study 1, the probability of responding, P(R), was found to be a mediator variable between the depressive symptoms and the judgments of control. In Study 2, we intervened directly on the mediator variable: The P(R) for both depressed and nondepressed participants was manipulated through instructions. Our results confirm that P(R) manipulation produced differences in the participants' perceptions of uncontrollability. Importantly, the intervention on the mediator variable cancelled the effect of the distal cause; the participants' judgments of control were no longer mood dependent when the P(R) was manipulated. This result supports the hypothesis that the so-called depressive realism effect is actually mediated by the probability of responding.

Last Updated: 05 Jul 2022