Long-term abstinence from alcohol in patients receiving aversion therapy as part of a multimodal inpatient program

Schick Shadel Hospital, Seattle, Washington, United States
Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment (Impact Factor: 3.14). 02/1990; 7(2):77-82. DOI: 10.1016/0740-5472(90)90002-8
Source: PubMed


A sample of 200 patients who had been treated for alcoholism in a multimodal inpatient program that used aversion therapy as a treatment component was selected for outcome evaluation. One hundred sixty (80%) were located. A minimum of 13 months had elapsed since treatment (mean 20.5 months) collateral reports were used to verify self-reports in 36% of the cases. Abstinence status was determined for the first 12 months since treatment, the entire elapsed time since treatment (range 13 to 25 months, mean 20.5 months), and "current abstinence" (last 6 months). The abstinence rate for the first 12 months was 71.3%; for the total period since treatment, the rate was 65% (mean 20.5 months); the current abstinence rate was 78.1%. The data was also viewed from other perspectives. The findings of this study suggest that a multimodal alcoholism treatment program utilizing aversion conditioning is at least as acceptable to patients as counseling centered programs and can be expected to yield favorable abstinence rates.

Download full-text


Available from: Patrick Joseph Frawley
  • Source
    • "These findings may support the concept of neurocircuitry of pathological craving in AD (Koob & Volkow, 2010; Volkow et al., 2011). Previous studies have demonstrated that aversive treatment is effective in decreasing craving in alcohol-dependent individuals (Howard & Jenson, 1990; Lee et al., 2009; Smith & Frawley, 1990). Elkins reported that alcohol-dependent individuals who experienced aversive therapy sessions maintained about 60% of 1-year abstinence rates. "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Virtual reality therapy (VRT) uses multimodal stimulation that includes visual, auditory, olfactory, and gustatory stimuli. The aim of this study was to assess the effectiveness of VRT in treating subjects with alcohol dependence (AD) by evaluating changes in brain metabolism. The VRT protocol consisted of three steps: relaxation, presentation of a high-risk situation, and presentation of an aversive situation. Twelve alcohol-dependent subjects underwent 10 sessions of VRT. The alcohol-dependent subjects were assessed with 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography images before and after VRT, whereas the control group underwent imaging according to the same protocol only at baseline. Compared with the healthy control group, AD subjects showed higher metabolism in the right lentiform nucleus and right temporal lobe (BA20) at baseline (PFDR < .05 = .026). In addition, the metabolism in the left anterior cingulate was lower in subjects with AD (Puncorr = .001). After VRT, alcohol-dependent subjects showed decreased brain metabolism in the right lentiform nucleus (PFDR < .05 = .026) and right temporal lobe (BA38, PFDR < .05 = .032) relative to that at baseline. Our results suggest a neurobiological imbalance, notably, a high sensitivity to stimuli, in the limbic system in subjects with AD. Furthermore, we determined that metabolism decreased in the basal ganglia after VRT, which may explain the limbic-regulated responses of reward and regulation. Therefore, we tentatively recommend VRT to treat AD through its regulating effect on limbic circuits.
    Full-text · Article · Jul 2015 · Journal of studies on alcohol and drugs
  • Source
    • "The addition of these treatments extended the length of stay by 1-6 days. For stimulants, a " cocaine or amphetamine substitute " was paired with an aversive stimulus in 5 treatment sessions in addition to the alcohol aversion treatments (Frawley & Smith, 1990). For marijuana, a " marijuana substitute " was paired with the aversive stimulus in addition to the alcohol aversion treatments (Smith, Schmeling, & Knowles, 1988). "
    [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: A sample of 600 patients treated in a multimodal treatment program using aversion therapy and narcotherapy at three Schick freestanding addiction treatment hospitals and one Schick unit in a general hospital were followed-up. Contact was made a minimum of 12 months and as many as 20 months after completion of treatment (mean 14.7 mos.). Telephone contact was made by an independent research organization with 427 of the patients (71.2%). Of these, 65.1% were totally abstinent for 1 year after treatment and 60.2% were abstinent until follow-up a mean of 14.7 months later. Fifty-two percent of the alcoholics were using or dependent on other drugs at admission. Seventy-five of these treated for cocaine dependence and 47 treated for marijuana dependence. The cocaine 12 month and "total" abstinence (mean 14.7 mos.) rates for the 49 contacted patients were 83.7% and 81.6%, respectively. The marijuana 12 month and "total" abstinence (mean 14.7 mos.) rates for the 30 contacted patients was 70.0% for both groups. Abstinence rates for alcohol and/or other drugs were also calculated including noncontacted patients who had chart documented evidence of relapse. The most powerful predictor of success was whether or not all urges to drink or use had been eliminated (presumably by aversion therapy). Of additional importance was the use of support groups and reinforcement treatments after completion of the initial hospitalization. The two most prominent factors initiating a relapse were "intrapersonal determinants" such as stress from work or marriage/family relationships and "interpersonal determinants" such as being around others who were drinking/using or being at a celebration or special event. The two factors were of equal importance in the alcoholics. However, interpersonal determinants were far more important in the cocaine and marijuana treated patients. Increased utilization of reinforcement treatments was associated with decreased urges to drink/use and increased abstinence rates. In contrast, increased frequency of support group utilization was associated with increased urges to drink/use and lower abstinence rates. This suggests the need to take seriously patient reports of "urges" in the first year after treatment and to carefully assess the cause and initiate or update an individualized plan of treatment. Such treatment may include increased reinforcement treatments, treatment of depression, and additional assistance in coping with intrapersonal and interpersonal determinants of relapse.
    Full-text · Article · Jul 1993 · Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment
  • [Show abstract] [Hide abstract]
    ABSTRACT: Commentators have repeatedly attacked the traditional view that alcoholism is a disease. Their arguments that alcoholism is a central aspect of life, a deviant life style, or a form of learned behavior are examined in the light of the history and philosophy of medicine as well as current bio-behavioral research. Our conclusion is that alcoholism, as a lawful pattern of observable signs and symptoms that deviate significantly from a norm of health, is a bio-psychosocial disease.
    No preview · Article · Jul 1991 · Integrative Physiological and Behavioral Science
Show more