This document proposes a Sonoran Desert Park in the Rio Nuevo downtown redevelopment and revitalization district. The proposed park site lies north of 22nd Street / Starr Pass Boulevard, astride the Santa Cruz River between Sentinel Peak and neighborhoods west of Interstate Highway 10. A large portion of the land contains a historic landfill that makes the site highly problematic for any more intensive use that would involve construction.
The primary benefits of the proposed natural open space park, in the downtown area, would include:
• Providing service to local, city-wide, and tourist constituencies with:
o A desert and desert-riparian experience
o Interpretation complementary to the Origin Park
o Varied recreational opportunities
• Park development options including:
o Natural areas for hiking and picnicking
o Biking/equestrian/bird-watching trails and/or connections
o More active youth recreational facilities.
• Key biodiversity connectivity for urban wildlife
Potential benefits of a natural park at the site are increased by association with adjoining and nearby natural, cultural, and recreational facilities and amenities:
• Tucson Origins Heritage Park including immediately adjacent restorations and re-creations of:
o Mission Gardens
o S’chuk Son Village
o Carillo House
o San August Mission
• Natural open spaces and trail systems:
o River Park and Urban Loop Trail system
o Sentinel Peak Park
o Santa Cruz River corridor, including:
o Santa Cruz River
o West Branch reserve
o Paseo de las Iglesias Phase 1
Park development at this site would significant enhance quality of life in the urban core of the city. It will contribute to tourism related to the revitalization of downtown Tucson.
There are major logistical constraints and challenges at the proposed site, which are described and explained in detail in the report:
• Existing large, inactive landfill waste underlying major parts of the available area:
o Restrictions on water use to avoid wetting the waste in the landfill and causing rapid decomposition and possible aquifer contamination
o High costs to remediate, remove, or re-contour the landfill
o Costs to provide proper soils for plants and human use of the surface
o Settling and methane production within the landfill, affecting any structures constructed in the landfill
o Utility lines within the waste
• Infrastructure needed for people to cross the river arroyo to access the entire park
• Linking the park with Sentinel Peak and Tucson Mountain Park requires traffic crossing provision for S Grande Avenue, which is the western margin of the proposed park area
This report contains detailed historical and current information on biodiversity, ecology, biodiversity connectivity, trail connectivity, historic land use, infrastructure, and logistic issues related to the proposed park property and nearby sites.
The document presents three conceptual design alternatives spanning a range of complexity, interest, difficulty, and logistical constraints and challenges:
• Alternative 1 – Desert Arroyo Park. This is the least costly alternative par design, with the least added soil and water and the least modification to the landfill. Desert plants like those that grew naturally on the landfill would be used, with added species using seed, plantings, and irrigation for initial plant establishment. However, with species diversity and vegetation structure lower than in other alternative designs, interest and aesthetic quality would also be less than in the other alternatives.
• Alternative 2 – Sonoran Desert Region Botanical Park. This alternative would reproduce the Sonoran Desert landscape (rock slope → gravelly upper bajada →loamy lower bajada → creosote flat → saltbush flat) and, optionally, include multiple smaller vignette gardens presenting diverse aspects of the vegetation and ecology of the Sonoran Desert region of the United States. Deeper, more precisely textured soils would be required, and contouring the landfill surface would likely be required, adding significant cost. Species diversity, shade, interest, and aesthetic value would be high.
• Alternative 3 – Bosque Park. This very rich, attractive, and shady alternative design would reproduce the original mesquite-dominated floodplain forest that drew people to Tucson originally. The water and soil requirements of this ecosystem would require nearly complete mitigation of the A Mountain landfill, which would be very costly. Species diversity would be similar to Alternative 2, but aesthetic value, shade, and interest would be significantly greater. Following landfill remediation, the bosque could be sustainable using runoff captured from Sentinel Peak.
Each alternative is presented with detailed information on appropriate plant species and vegetation structure, along with information on expected animal biodiversity and logistical constraints. Final designs are not presented here: some elements of the three alternatives might to some extent be combined in a final design for construction.
Elements common to all three design alternatives include:
• Interpretive vignettes with signage covering:
o Natural and cultural history
o Environmental history
o Urban biodiversity
o Riparian degradation and restoration
o Landfill issues
o Sustainability and alternative futures
• Trails and signage
• Picnic tables, benches, and barbeque grills
• Shade ramadas
• Access and comfort station facilities
• Pedestrian bridge(s) crossing the river (optional)
• Water feature (optional)
• Enhanced desert riparian planting along river paths and elsewhere away from the landfill waste