ArticlePDF Available

Depletion of tumour versus normal glutathione by buthionine sulphoximine

Authors:
  • Angex Pharmaceuticals, United States, New Jersey

Abstract

We have investigated in detail the effects of buthionine sulfoximine (BSO), a selective glutathione (GSH) depleting agent, on the GSH contents of a number of normal tissues and three experimental tumours in mice. Significant variations in the rate and degree of GSH depletion and recovery were observed among the normal tissues. Following a dose of 2.5 mmol kg-1 BSO, GSH nadirs were reached by approximately 5 h for the liver and kidney, 8 h for the lung and bone marrow, 12 h for red blood cells (RBCs) and by 24 h for the heart. The degree of depletion was greatest for the kidney (80%), liver (74%) and bone marrow (83%), intermediate for the heart (54%) and lung (40%), and least for RBCs (13%). Recovery of GSH content was fastest for the liver followed in descending order by the kidney, the lung, the bone marrow, RBCs and the heart. In contrast, the rate and extent of GSH depletion and recovery showed considerably less variation among the 3 murine tumours. In the tumours GSH nadirs were reached by 10-12 h. The extent of depletion was about 55-65%. Recovery of GSH levels in the tumours required 48 h or more, a longer period than required by the liver, kidney and lung but shorter than that needed for the bone marrow, heart and RBCs. Attempts to preferentially deplete tumour GSH by exploiting the differences in recovery rates between normal tissues and tumours were only partially successful. Multiple BSO dosing at 16 h intervals allowed the liver to recover between doses, but the recovery in the kidney, lung and bone marrow was only partial and no recovery was seen in the heart. Finally, dose-depletion relationship investigations showed that, with the exception of the lungs, GSH depletion could be achieved in tumours with doses of BSO lower than those required for normal tissues.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... This drug can induce a substantial reduction in cellular oxygen consumption rate and is less likely to induce lactic acidosis than other regulators [16]. Buthionine sulfoximine (BSO) was chosen as a γ-glutamylcysteine synthetase (γ-GCS) inhibitor, which can block GSH replenishment by inhibiting the biosynthetic route at the source [17]. Therefore, we described a metabolic pre-intervention (MPI) strategy toward the intrinsic metabolic pathway based on a nano-vehicle consisting of a PDT skeleton and inhibitor molecules (Scheme 1A). ...
Article
Full-text available
Rationale: Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a clinically approved anticancer treatment with a promising therapeutic prospect, however, usually suffers from the unfavorable intracellular environment including cellular hypoxia and excessive glutathione (GSH). Comprehensive and long-term modulation of tumor intracellular environment is crucial for optimizing therapeutic outcomes. However, current strategies do not enable such requirements, mainly limited by flexible networks of intracellular metabolic avenues. Methods: A metabolic pre-intervention (MPI) strategy that targets critical pathways of cellular metabolism, ensuring long-term modulation of the intracellular environment. A versatile lipid-coating photosensitive metal-organic framework (MOF) nano-vehicle encapsulating aerobic respiration inhibitor metformin (Met) and GSH biosynthesis inhibitor buthionine sulfoximine (BSO) (termed PBMLR) was developed for comprehensive sustainable hypoxia alleviation and GSH downregulating. Results: Since MPI could effectively circumvent the compensatory accessory pathway, PBMLR, therefore functioned as an efficient singlet oxygen (¹O2) radical generator during the subsequent laser irradiation process and enhanced PDT anti-tumor efficiency. We emphasized the concordance of long-term hypoxia alleviation, persistent GSH depletion, and tumor enrichment of photosensitizers, which is very meaningful for a broad therapeutic time window and the successful enhancement of PDT. Conclusion: Our findings indicate that maintaining the sensitivity of tumor cells via MPI could enhance anti-tumor PDT, and may be applied to other dynamic therapies such as radiodynamic therapy and sonodynamic therapy.
... GCLC is a rate-limiting enzyme that generates γ-Glu-Cys from Glu and Cys to produce GSH [32]. BSO, a GCLC inhibitor, is used as a drug to deplete GSH, but this drug results in GSH reduction, not only in cancers, but also in normal tissues [33]. Moreover, a phase I study did not achieve an adequate reduction of GSH levels [34] and no phase II clinical trials have been conducted to date. ...
Article
Full-text available
Glutathione is an antioxidant that has an important role in chemotherapeutic drug resistance in cancer. Cysteine is synthesized from cystine and is transported into the cell via the xCT antiporter. Another pathway for synthesizing cysteine involves intracellular methionine. We determined whether targeting the xCT represents a promising strategy for the treatment of endometrial cancer and identified factors that predict efficacy of this treatment strategy. In uterine serous carcinoma (USC) cell lines, the combination of cisplatin and the xCT inhibitor, sulfasalazine, significantly inhibited cell growth compared with single-agent cisplatin or sulfasalazine. Sulfasalazine treatment significantly decreased intracellular glutathione levels and induced apoptosis when combined with cisplatin in USC cell lines. On the one hand, the effectiveness of combined cisplatin and sulfasalazine was not evident in endometrioid carcinoma. USC cell lines exhibited increased expression of xCT and decreased expression of cystathionine gamma lyase (CGL), which is an enzyme involved in the synthesis of cysteine from methionine. On the other hand, endometrioid carcinoma cell lines exhibited increased CGL expression or decreased xCT expression. These findings suggest that using a glutathione synthesis pathway-based approach for selecting subjects for sulfasalazine treatment may be an effective strategy for circumventing glutathione-related chemotherapeutic drug resistance in endometrial carcinoma.
... Interestingly, the heart showed a slower depletion of mitochondrial GSH, yet only recovered to 50% of control levels after 7 days, suggesting tissue-specific differences in repletion of the mitochondrial glutathione pool. This is consistent with the slow recovery of the total heart GSH pool after GSH depletion in mice (Lee et al., 1987;Gerard-Monnier et al., 1992). In contrast to mitochondrial GSH the total GSH levels in the tissues were not depleted, but actually increased by 20%-70% in all tissues 24 hr after MitoCDNB injection. ...
Article
Full-text available
Mitochondrial glutathione (GSH) and thioredoxin (Trx) systems function independently of the rest of the cell. While maintenance of mitochondrial thiol redox state is thought vital for cell survival, this was not testable due to the difficulty of manipulating the organelle's thiol systems independently of those in other cell compartments. To overcome this constraint we modified the glutathione S-transferase substrate and Trx reductase (TrxR) inhibitor, 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (CDNB) by conjugation to the mitochondria-targeting triphenylphosphonium cation. The result, MitoCDNB, is taken up by mitochondria where it selectively depletes the mitochondrial GSH pool, catalyzed by glutathione S-transferases, and directly inhibits mitochondrial TrxR2 and peroxiredoxin 3, a peroxidase. Importantly, MitoCDNB inactivates mitochondrial thiol redox homeostasis in isolated cells and in vivo, without affecting that of the cytosol. Consequently, MitoCDNB enables assessment of the biomedical importance of mitochondrial thiol homeostasis in reactive oxygen species production, organelle dynamics, redox signaling, and cell death in cells and in vivo. It has been difficult to selectively disrupt mitochondrial redox state, independently of that in the rest of the cell. Here, Booty et al. introduce MitoCDNB to deplete mitochondrial glutathione and selectively inhibit key enzymatic components of mitochondrial thiol redox status in cells and in vivo.
... The current conflicting responses of both cell lines upon treatment with BSO and paracetamol combination might be attributed to their different cellular GSH content. This depends on the variability in GSH depleting ability of BSO between tumor and normal tissues [23]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The burgeoning prodrug strategy offers a promising avenue toward improving the efficacy and specificity of cytotoxic drugs. Elevated intracellular levels of glutathione (GSH) have been regarded as a hallmark of tumor cells and characteristic feature of the tumor microenvironment. Considering the pivotal involvement of elevated GSH in the tumorigenic process, a diverse repertoire of GSH‐triggered prodrugs has been developed for cancer therapy, facilitating the attenuation of deleterious side effects associated with conventional chemotherapeutic agents and/or the attainment of more efficacious therapeutic outcomes. These prodrug formulations encompass a spectrum of architectures, spanning from small molecules to polymer‐based and organic–inorganic nanomaterial constructs. Although the GSH‐triggered prodrugs have been gaining increasing interests, a comprehensive review of the advancements made in the field is still lacking. To fill the existing lacuna, this review undertakes a retrospective analysis of noteworthy research endeavors, based on a categorization of these molecules by their diverse recognition units (i.e., disulfides, diselenides, Michael acceptors, and sulfonamides/sulfonates). This review also focuses on explaining the distinct benefits of employing various chemical architecture strategies in the design of these prodrug agents. Furthermore, we highlight the potential for synergistic functionality by incorporating multiple‐targeting conjugates, theranostic entities, and combinational treatment modalities, all of which rely on the GSH‐triggering. Overall, an extensive overview of the emerging field is presented in this review, highlighting the obstacles and opportunities that lie ahead. Our overarching goal is to furnish methodological guidance for the development of more efficacious GSH‐triggered prodrugs in the future. By assessing the pros and cons of current GSH‐triggered prodrugs, we expect that this review will be a handful reference for prodrug design, and would provide a guidance for improving the properties of prodrugs and discovering novel trigger scaffolds for constructing GSH‐triggered prodrugs.
Article
Increasing numbers of disulfide linkage-employing polymeric drug carriers that utilize the reversible peculiarity of this unique covalent bond have been reported. The reduction-sensitive disulfide bond is usually employed as a linkage between hydrophilic and hydrophobic polymers, polymers and drugs, or as cross-linkers in polymeric drug carriers. These polymeric drug carriers are designed to exploit the significant redox potential difference between the reducing intracellular environments and relatively oxidizing extracellular spaces. In addition, these drug carriers can release a considerable amount of anticancer drug in response to the reducing environment when they reach tumor tissues, effectively improving antitumor efficacy. This review focuses on various disulfide linkage-employing polymeric drug carriers. Important redox thiol pools, including GSH/GSSG, Cys/CySS, and Trx1, as well as redox environments in mammals, will be introduced.
Chapter
Bone marrow is the production site for all types of blood cells, which are released into the peripheral blood according to the needs of the body, mediated through different feedback mechanisms. The production occurs as a combination of cell proliferation and gradual maturation, until the end stage is reached with a population of mature cells that can exert their specialized functions but are no longer capable of cell proliferation [1]. It takes approximately 14 days from immature stem cells starting proliferation until mature cells result [2].
Article
Glutathione (GSH) depletion is a common method for examining the role of oxidative stress in, the toxicity of novel compounds. Several treatment regimens for inducing hepatic GSH depletion in rats were examined for their suitability for use in a 7-day repeated-dose paradigm. Male Wistar rats (5/treatment) were administered either 2,6-dimethyl-2,5-heptadien-4-one (phorone, 250 mg/kg ip) diethylmaleate (DEM, 600 mg/kg ip), ethanol in drinking water (150 mL/L), or L-buthionine-SR-sulfoximine (BSO) in drinking water (4.446 g/L) with and without supplemental ip administration (890 mg/kg bid) for 7 days. Additional groups of 5 animals were given. phorone or DEM and sacrificed 2 h after dose. Significant body weight gain suppression relative to control was evident in all treated groups but only animals given the ip/water BSO treatment resulted in mean weight loss (4%). Liver weights were significantly increased by 7 days of phorone treatment and decreased by ip/water BSO treatment. No clinically significant effects were noted on hepatic serum chemistry parameters. No hepatic histopathology was produced by any treatment, but phorone produced increased hepatocellular mitoses. BSO administered in the drinking water without supplemental ip administration appeared to be the most suitable model for routine assessment of hepatic GSH depletion in mechanistic models The model was practical, did not induce hepatic pathology, and produced marked decreases in hepatic cytosolic GSH and moderate decreases in hepatic mitochondrial GSH.
Chapter
Although the use of chemotherapy as a major form of treatment for malignant disease is in its infancy, its introduction 40 years ago has led to significant advances in treatment of certain forms of cancer. However, for many types of cancer, the spectre of treatment failure is all too familiar. Cancer treatment frequently involves a combination of local therapy, i.e. surgery and/or radiotherapy, and systemic therapy, i.e. chemotherapy and/or hormone therapy. Treatment failure, the failure of systemic therapy to control tumour growth, appears in a variety of ways. These range from rapid tumour growth with little evidence of impact of any treatment leading to death within months, to a much more prolonged natural history in which systemic treatment may initially appear effective, but in which disease relapse may occur years later. This chapter will focus on failure of cytotoxic drug therapy, and, in particular, on the role of cellular drug resistance. This frequent and frustrating problem is attracting increasing attention from many research groups. Their aim is to acquire a better insight into the mechanisms involved, as a result of which rational strategies aimed at circumvention of resistance can be developed.
Article
Full-text available
Levels of glutathione, glutathione reductase and glutathione S-transferase activities in rat lung and liver have been investigated. After perfusing the lung to remove contaminating blood, this organ was found to have an apparent concentration of glutathione (2mM) which is approx. 20% of that found in the liver. Both organs contain very low levels of glutathione disulfide. Neither phenobarbital nor methylcholanthrene had a significant effect on the levels of reduced glutathione in lung and liver. In addition, the activities of some glutathione-metabolizing enzymes--glutathione reductase and glutathione S-transferase activity assayed with four different substrates--were observed to be 5-to 60-fold lower in lung tissue than in the liver.
Article
Glutathione is translocated out of cells; cells that have membrane-bound gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase can utilize translocated glutathione, whereas glutathione exported from cells that do not have appreciable transpeptidase enters the blood plasma. Glutathione is removed from the plasma by the kidney and other organs that have transpeptidase. Studies in which mice and rats were treated with buthionine sulfoximine, a selective and potent inhibitor of gamma-glutamylcysteine synthetase and therefore of glutathione synthesis, show that glutathione turns over at a significant rate in many tissues, especially kidney, liver, and pancreas; the rate of turnover in mouse skeletal muscle is about 60% of that in the kidney. Experiments on rats surgically deprived of one or both kidneys and treated with the gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase inhibitor D-gamma-glutamyl-(o-carboxy)phenylhydrazide establish that extrarenal gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase activity accounts for the utilization of about one-third of the total blood plasma glutathione. Normal animals treated with the transpeptidase inhibitor excrete large amounts of glutathione in their urine. They also excrete gamma-glutamylcysteine, suggesting that cleavage of glutathione at the cysteinylglycine bond may be of metabolic significance. The present and earlier findings lead to a tentative scheme (presented here) for the metabolism and translocation of glutathione, gamma-glutamyl amino acids, and related compounds.
Article
A mammary adenocarcinoma (16/C) was isolated and maintained in serial passage by transplantation of metastatic lung foci. This tumor originated as a spontaneous mammary adenocarcinoma in a C3H/He female mouse. It was selected as a model from greater than 50 mammary tumors studied because it was highly metastatic and because it responded to most of the agents reported to be active against breast cancer in women. Sc implanted 16/C tumors (in the 300--1000-mg range) metastasized to the lungs in greater than 75% of the mice and to the axillary lymph nodes in greater than 30%. This tumor has been tested for sensitivity to greater than 40 clinically used agents. Adriamycin was the most active single agent. Other active agents included cyclophosphamide, 5-fluorouracil, vincristine, melphalan, dibromodulcitol, maytansine, neocarzinostatin, palmO-ara-C, vinblastine, and VP-16-213. Agents most active against 40--1000-mg tumours were also most active against micrometastatic disease (eg, adriamycin). The converse was also true; agents inactive or marginally active against 40--1000-mg tumors were at best marginally active against micrometastatic disease (eg, BCNU). Tumors greater than 20 mg were not curable by chemotherapy alone, although adriamycin treatment caused complete regressions of 100--400-mg tumors in greater than 80% of the mice. Surgical removal of 300--1000-mg tumors plus therapy with adriamycin resulted in 40%--72% cures as compared to 0--26% cures with surgery only. Data resulting from treatment with other agents, singly and in combination, are presented.
Article
Levels of glutathione, glutathione reductase and glutathione S-transferase activities in rat lung and liver have been investigated. After perfusing the lung to remove contaminating blood, this organ was found to have an apparent concentration of glutathione (2mM) which is approx. 20% of that found in the liver. Both organs contain very low levels of glutathione disulfide. Neither phenobarbital nor methylcholanthrene had a significant effect on the levels of reduced glutathione in lung and liver. In addition, the activities of some glutathione-metabolizing enzymes--glutathione reductase and glutathione S-transferase activity assayed with four different substrates--were observed to be 5-to 60-fold lower in lung tissue than in the liver.
Article
We have examined the effect of L-buthionine sulfoximine (BSO) treatment on the subsequent cytotoxicity of mitomycin C (Mit C) and cyclophosphamide (CYC) in EMT6/SF tumors growing in Balb/c mice. GSH content in tumors decreased to a minimum level (less than 30% of control) 12 hr after a single injection of 5 mmole/kg of BSO. The recovery of tumor GSH was protracted and did not reach control levels up to 24 hr following BSO administration. Mit C and CYC were administered 12 hr after BSO injection. Tumor cell survival reached almost the same minimum level (SF = 0.050-0.06%) 1 hour after Mit C (10 mg/kg) treatment with or without BSO. However, 24 hr after Mit C treatment, survival had increased 36-fold (SF = 1.9%) in non-BSO-treated tumors compared to only 4-fold (SF = 0.3%) in the BSO-treated tumors. A dose modifying factor (DMF) of 1.4-1.8 was observed for BSO-pretreated tumors assayed 24 hr after Mit C administration. In CYC-treated tumors, minimum surviving fractions were found 4 hr after CYC treatment with or without BSO treatment. These minimum survival levels were almost the same in BSO-treated tumors following 100 mg/kg CYC (SF = 0.03%) as in control tumors treated with 150 mg/kg CYC (SF = 0.04%). The same increase in cell survival was observed when tumor excision and assay were delayed 24 hr following CYC administration with or without prior BSO treatment. BSO treatment enhanced the cytotoxicity of CYC by DMFs of 1.6-1.9 based on the 24 hr excision assay. Depletion of tumor GSH by BSO caused enhancement of tumor cell killing by the two chemotherapy agents studied, either by increasing cytotoxicity, in the case of CYC or by decreasing PLD recovery following Mit C.
Article
The role of glutathione (GSH) as a determinant of cellular sensitivity to the cytotoxic and DNA-damaging effects of cyclophosphamide (CP) was studied in a dual culture system of rat hepatocytes and K562 human chronic myeloid leukemia cells, which have elevated aldehyde dehydrogenase activity with a corresponding insensitivity to activated CP. Exposure of K562 cells to 50 microM DL-buthionine-S,R-sulfoximine for 24 h resulted in a depletion of cellular GSH content to 10% of control values without toxicity. Subsequent 1-h exposure of GSH-depleted cells to activated cyclophosphamide, obtained by incubation of CP with suspension cultures of rat hepatocytes, resulted in a 5-fold potentiation of the cytotoxicity of CP. Alkaline elution analysis of cellular DNA demonstrated that the level of apparent interstrand cross-linking was 3 to 4 times higher in GSH-depleted cells than in nondepleted cells. GSH-depleted cells were, in addition, more sensitive to induction of DNA single strand breaks than nondepleted cells. Depletion of GSH content did not increase cellular sensitivity to the cytotoxicity of phosphoramide mustard. Preincubation of K562 cells with 1 mM cysteine for 4 h resulted in an approximately 60% increase in cellular GSH content, which was accompanied by decreased sensitivity to the cytotoxicity of hepatocyte-activated CP. Exposure of nondepleted cells to clinically relevant concentrations of hepatocyte-activated CP resulted in depletion of cellular GSH content. Replenishment of GSH content in these cells was relatively slow following CP exposure. Acrolein was highly effective at depleting cellular GSH content, whereas phosphoramide mustard had no effect on cellular GSH content. The depletion of GSH by intracellularly released acrolein may be important in the mechanism of cytotoxicity of CP.
Article
The effect of giving buthionine sulfoximine (BSO), 0.0265 g/mouse (6 mM), at 12 and 6 hr before treatment with melphalan--0.0 mg, 3 mg, 6 mg, and 9 mg/kg, was studied in C3H mice, and was compared with control groups that received normal saline 12 and 6 hr before identical melphalan treatment. BSO treatment resulted in depletion of GSH levels in bone marrow, liver, and muscle to 65, 13, and 41% of control levels, respectively. Hematological toxicity was assessed by measurement of CFU-S survival and peripheral white cell counts. CFU-S survival decreased with increasing doses of melphalan, but no difference was observed with BSO pre-treatment. Likewise, WBC counts following melphalan 9 mg/kg, were similar irrespective of BSO pre-treatment. These data suggest that the marrow toxicity seen with melphalan is not worsened by pre-treatment with BSO and that if tumors can be pre-sensitized with BSO, there may be a clinical role for melphalan/BSO drug combination.
Article
The development of acquired resistance to antineoplastic drugs and the associated broad cross-resistance to other agents frequently limits the effectiveness of chemotherapy. Ling and coworkers have demonstrated that Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells develop the phenotype of pleiotropic drug resistance which is manifest by a decrease in drug accumulation in these cells and hence a decrease in cytotoxicity (1). The role of drug accumulation and membrane glycoproteins in the expression of primary resistance and cross-resistance in human tumors is an area of active investigation (2–4). We have developed a series of human ovarian cancer cell lines with acquired resistance to melphalan, cisplatin, or adriamycin (5). These cell lines exhibit sensitivity/resistance profiles characteristic of pleiotropic drug resistance. In addition, the melphalan and cisplatin resistant variants are also cross-resistant to irradiation (6). Both the primary resistance to melphalan and the cross-resistance to irradiation in these cell lines can be reversed by lowering glutathione (GSH) levels in the cells with buthionine sulfoximine (BSO) (6,7). In the present study, the role of GSH in the expression of sensitivity to agents other than melphalan was examined by BSO-mediated depletion of GSH. In addition, the patterns of both primary resistance and cross-resistance were compared following GSH depletion in these cell lines.
Article
The cardiotoxic effects of adriamycin were studied in 399 patients treated for far-advanced carcimma. Forty-five patients (11%) exhibited transient electrocardiographs changes. Eleven others developed severe congestive heart failure. Eight of these latter patients died within 3 weeks of the onset of the cardiac decompensation. The diffuse nature of this myocardiopathy was suggested by: 1. a conspicuous decrease in the QRS voltage on the electrocardiograms; 2. rapidly occurring cardiac dilatation and ventricular failure, and 3. refractoriness to inoiropic drugs and mechanical ventricular assistance. Postmortem examination of the hearts in two cases showed a striking decrease in the number of cardiac: muscle cells present, degeneration of the remaining myocardial cells, loss o contractile substance, mitochondrial swelling, and intramitochondrial dense inclusion bodies. Congestive heart failure occurred only once in the 366 patients who were treated with less than 550 mg/m2 of adriamycin (0.27%), but there were 10 cases of cardiac failure in the 33 patients who received more than 550 mg/m2 of this drug (30%). Therefore, until more direct means are established to prevent adriamycin-induced congestive heart failure, it is suggested that the total dose of adriamycin should be limited to less than 550 mg/m2 to permit safer use of this efficacious cancer chemotherapeutic agent.