ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

Recently, path equations have been obtained for charged, spinning objects in brane world models, using a modified Bazanski Lagrangian. In this study, path deviation equations of extended objects are derived. The significance of moving extended objects in brane world models is examined. Motion in non- symmetric brane world models is also considered.
arXiv:0708.2015v2 [gr-qc] 20 Aug 2007
Motion in Brane World Models: The Bazanski Approach
M.E.Kahil
1
Abstract
Recently, path equations have been obtained for charged, spinning objects in
brane world models, using a modified Bazanski Lagrangian. In this study, path
deviation equations of extended objects are derived. The significance of movin g
extended objects in brane world models is examined. Motion in non- symmetric
brane world mo dels is also considered.
The Bazanski Approach in Riemannian Geometry
Geodesic and geodesic deviation equations can be obtained simultaneously by ap-
plying the action principle on the Bazanski Lagrangian [1]:
L = g
αβ
U
α
DΨ
β
Ds
, (1)
where
D
D s
is the covariant derivative. By taking the variation with respect to the
deviation vector Ψ
ρ
one obtains the geodesic equation. Taking the variation with
respect to the unit tangent vector U
ρ
, one obtains its geodesic deviation equation
respectively :
dU
α
ds
+
(
α
µν
)
U
µ
U
ν
= 0, (2)
D
2
Ψ
α
Ds
2
= R
α
γδ
U
β
U
γ
Ψ
δ
, (3)
where
α
µν
is the Christoffel symbol of the second kind R
α
βγδ
is the Riemann-
Christoffel curvature tensor.
It is worth mentioning that the Bazanski approach has been successfully applied
in geometries different from the Riemannian one [2],[3]. Also, the Lagrangian (1)
can be amended to describe path and path deviation equations of spinning charged
particles [4] by introd ucing the following Lagrangian:
L = g
αβ
U
α
DΨ
β
Ds
+ (
e
m
F
αβ
U
β
+
1
2m
R
αβγδ
S
γδ
U
α
µ
(4)
to give
dU
α
ds
+
(
α
µν
)
U
µ
U
ν
=
e
m
F
µ
U
ν
+
1
2m
R
α
.µνρ
S
νρ
U
µ
. (5)
Its spinning charged deviation equation becomes:
D
2
Ψ
α
Ds
2
= R
α
.µνρ
U
µ
U
ν
Ψ
ρ
+
e
m
(F
α
DΨ
ν
Ds
+ F
α
;ρ
U
ν
Ψ
ρ
)
+
1
2m
(R
α
.µνρ
S
νρ
DΨ
ν
Ds
+ R
α
µνλ
S
νλ
.;ρ
U
µ
Ψ
ρ
+ R
α
µνλ;ρ
S
νλ
U
µ
Ψ
ρ
), (6)
where F
µ
is the electromagnetic eld tensor and S
γδ
is the spin tensor .
1
Mathematics Department, Modern Sciences and Arts University, Giza, EGYPT
e.mail: kahil@aucegypt.edu
1
The Bazanski Approach in Brane World Models
It is well known that in the Brane world scenario our universe can be described
in terms of a 4+N dimensional, with N 1 and the 4D space-time p art of it is
embedded in a 4+N manifold [5]. Accordingly, the bulk geodesic motion is observed
by a four d imen sional observer to reproduce the physics of 4D space-time [6]. Con-
sequently, it is vital to derive the path and the path deviation equations for a test
particle on a brane u s ing the following L agrangian [7] :
L = g
µν
(x
ρ
, y)U
µ
DΨ
ν
Ds
+ f
µ
Ψ
µ
, (7)
where g
µν
(x
ρ
, y) is the induced metric andf
µ
=
1
2
U
ρ
U
σ
g
ρσ
y
dy
ds
U
µ
describes a parallel
force due to the effect of non-compactified extra dimension. The variation of the
Lagrangian gives [8]:
dU
µ
ds
+
(
µ
αβ
)
U
α
U
β
= (
1
2
U
ρ
U
σ
g
ρσ
)
g
ρσ
y
dy
ds
U
µ
. (8)
As in the brane world models, one can express
1
2
g
ρσ
y
in terms of the extrinsic
curvature
ρσ
i.e.
αβ
=
1
2
g
ρσ
y
[9]. Thus, equation (8) becomes:
dU
µ
ds
+
(
µ
αβ
)
U
α
U
β
= 2(
1
2
U
µ
U
σ
g
µσ
)Ω
ρσ
dy
ds
U
ρ
. (9)
And its corresponding deviation equ ation is
D
2
Ψ
α
Ds
2
= R
α
.µνρ
U
µ
U
ν
Ψ
ρ
+(U
α
U
σ
U
ν
)Ω
σν
y
dy
ds
)
;ρ
Ψ
ρ
+2((
1
2
U
α
U
σ
g
ασ
)Ω
ρσ
dy
ds
U
ρ
)
;δ
Ψ
δ
(10)
Also, applying th e bazanski approach in brane world models, we obtain the path
and path deviation equations for a spinning charged object, respectively
dU
α
ds
+
(
α
µν
)
U
µ
U
ν
=
e
m
F
α
ν
U
ν
+
1
2m
R
α
βµν
S
µν
U
β
+ 2(
1
2
U
α
U
ρ
g
α
ρ)Ω
ρδ
dy
ds
U
δ
(11)
and
D
2
Ψ
α
Ds
2
= R
α
.µνρ
U
µ
U
ν
Ψ
ρ
+
1
2m
(R
α
.µνρ
S
νρ
DΨ
µ
Ds
+ R
α
µνλ
S
νλ
.;ρ
U
µ
Ψ
ρ
+ R
α
µνλ;ρ
S
νλ
U
µ
Ψ
ρ
)
+
e
m
(F
α
ρ
Ψ
ρ
+ F
α
ρ
DΨ
ρ
Ds
) + (
1
2
U
α
U
σ
U
ν
)Ω
σν
dy
ds
)
;ρ
Ψ
ρ
+ (
1
2
U
α
U
σ
g
ασ
)Ω
σν
dy
ds
DΨ
ν
Ds
.
(12)
Thus, equations (11) and (12) are derived from the following Lagrangian
L = g
µν
(x
ρ
, y)U
µ
DΨ
ν
Ds
+ 2(
1
2m
R
µνρσ
S
ρσ
U
ν
+
ρσ
yU
ρ
U
σ
U
µ
dy
ds
µ
, (13)
2
Path & Path Deviation Equations of Non-Symmetric
Geometries in Brane World Models
Path equation and Path deviation equations in Brane World Models defined in
non-symmetric geometries can be obtained by suggesting the following Lagrangian:
L = g
µν
U
µ
DΨ
ν
Dτ
+ λf
[µν]
U
µ
Ψ
ν
+
1
2
U
α
U
β
U
ρ
g
αβ
s
dy
ds
, (14)
where g
µν
= g
(µν)
+ g
[µν]
,λ is a parameter and, f
[µν]
=
ˆ
A
µ,ν
ˆ
A
ν,µ
is a skew
symmetric tensor related to the Yukawa force [10].
Applying the Bazanski ap proach we obtain the path equation
dU
α
ds
+
(
α
µν
)
U
µ
U
ν
= λg
αµ
f
[µν]
U
ν
+ g
ασ
g
[νσ];ρ
U
ν
U
ρ
+ (
1
2
U
ρ
U
σ
g
ρσ
)
g
ρσ
y
dy
ds
U
µ
.
(15)
and its path deviation equation:
D
2
Ψ
α
Ds
2
= R
α
.µνρ
U
µ
U
ν
Ψ
ρ
+ 2g
σα
(g
[ν[σ];ρ]
)
DΨ
ν
Ds
U
ρ
+ λ(f
α
DΨ
ν
Ds
+ f
α
;ρ
U
ν
Ψ
ρ
).
+ ((
1
2
U
α
U
ρ
g
αρ
)
g
δρ
dy
U
δ
dy
ds
)
;ν
Ψ
ν
+ (
1
2
U
α
U
µ
g
µν
dy
dy
ds
)
DΨ
ν
Ds
(16)
The Bazanski Approach in Curved Clifford Space
It is well known that extended objects can be expressed by p-branes[11]. This type
of representation is defined in curved Clifford Space. The advantage of this space is
to show that extended objects are purely poly-geodesics satisfying a metamorphic
transformation.[12].
Thus, we suggest the following Lagrangian:
L = g
AB
P
α
φ
β
τ
+
1
2
S
αβ
φ
αβ
τ
, (17)
such that
φ
α
τ
=
α
+ Γ
α
βρ
U
ρ
φ
β
+
1
2m
ˆ
R
α
γδ
S
γδ
φ
β
+
1
2m
S
ω
γ
ασ
µω
U
µ
+
1
2m
S
ρβ
ασ
ρβω
),
where Γ
α
βρ
is the Cartan connection,
ˆ
R
α
γδ
is the Cartan curvature and the two other
metamorphic connections Ξ
αδ
βρ
&Ωβργ
αδ
existed due to the presence of bivector
quantities. By taking variation with respect to its deviation vector φ
δ
we get
U
α
τ
= 0 (18)
and taking the variation with respect to its deviation bivector φ
δρ
we obtain
S
αβ
τ
= 0 (19)
3
In the case of a charged particle described by a polyvector we can find that the
corresponding linear momentum equation becomes [12]
U
α
τ
=
e
m
F
α
β
U
β
(20)
and its angular momentum equation takes the followin g form
S
αβ
τ
= F
α
ν
S
νβ
F
β
ν
S
να
(21)
We suggest the following Lagrangian to derive (20) and (21)
L = g
µν
P
µ
φ
ν
τ
+
1
2
S
µν
τφ
µν
τ
+ F
µν
U
ν
φ
µ
+
1
2
(F
µρ
S
ρ
ν
F
ρ
ν
S
ρµ
)φ
µν
. (22)
If we put the flavor of Kaluza-Klein in curved C lifford space for combin ing gravity
and electromagnetism, i.e, increasing the spatial dimension by a compacted one,
then equations (20),(21) can be derived from the following Lagrangian:
L = g
AB
P
A
φ
B
ˆτ
+
1
2
S
AB
φ
AB
ˆτ
, (23)
where A = 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 to become
U
α
ˆτ
= 0 (24)
and
S
αβ
ˆτ
= 0 (25)
which means th at the path of a charged spinning particle defined in Riemannain
geometry behave like as a test particle in 5D curved Clifford space.
Discussion and Concluding Remarks
In this s tu dy, we have derived path and path deviation equations for test par-
ticles and spinn ing charged test objects in Brane World Models from one single
Lagrangian. Also, the procedure has been used to derive path and path deviation
equations for a test particle existing in non-symmetric th eory of gravity and exam-
ined how the extrinsic curvature term would be amended due to the existence of
non-symmetric terms of gravitational eld. Thus, we can find that the added term
appeared in the extrinsic curvature of non-symmetric part may be connected to the
spin. Finally, we have dealt with extended objects as p-br anes defined in curved
Clifford space [13]. This type of space has a deeper understanding of physics, i.e.,
quantities in nature could be defined by polyvectors. From this pers pective we have
developed its correspon ding Bazanski Lagrangian to include deviation bi-vectors to-
gether with deviation vectors. The importance of this approach is that we can derive
from one Lagrangian(17) two simultaneous quantities responsible for conservation
of momentum (18) and angular momentum (19) respectively. Using this mecha-
nism, we have found that the Dixon-Souriau equations in Riemannian geometry
could be seen like equations for ch arged object and their angular momentum part
4
defined in curved clifford spaces. In addition, if we have the flavor of Kaluza-Klein
of unifying gravity and electromagnetism in curved Clifford space, we must increase
the dimension of this space by an extra compacted dimension to pr eserve the con-
servation of charges. Consequ ently, from equations (24) and (25) we can find that
charged spinning particles behave like test particles defined in higher dimensional
curved clifford space. To conclude this study, we must take into consideration that
unification processes can be achieved if we increase the number of dimensions and
extend the geometries to geometrize all quantities that appeared in our approach .
Acknowlgements
The author would like to thank Professors M.I. Wanas, M. Abdel-Megied , G.S.
Hall, T. Harko, G. De Young and Mr. W.S. El-Hanafy for their useful comments.
A word of thanks should be addressed to Professors A. Rajantie and F.H. Stoica
for their su ppport and help to pariticapate in PAS COS07. A very special word of
thankfulness should be sent to Dr. N. El-Degwi and Professor K . Abdel Hamid for
helping me to get a grant to represent MSA University at this confenence.
References
[1] Bazanski, S.L. (1989) J . Math. Phys., 30, 1018.
[2] Wanas, M.I., Melek, M. and Kahil, M.E.(1995) Astrophys. Space Sci.,228, 273.;
gr-qc/0207113.
[3] Wanas, M.I. and Kahil, M.E.(1999) Gen. Rel. Grav., 31, 1921. ; gr-qc/9912007
[4] Kahil, M.E. (2006), J. Math. Physics 47,052501.
[5] Liu, H. an d Mashhoon, B. (2000), Phys. Lett. A, 272,26 ; gr-qc/0005079
[6] Youm, D. (2000) P hys.Rev.D62, 084002; hep-th/0004144
[7] Kahil, M.E. (2006) a p aper presented at the Eleventh meeting of
Marcel Grosmann, Berlin 23-30 July 2006; gr-qc/0701015
[8]Ponce de Leon, J. (2001) Phys Lett B, 523 ;gr-qc/0110063
[9]Dick, R. Class. Quant. Grav.(2001), 18, R1.
[10] Legar´e, J. and Moffat, J.W. (1996), Gen. Rel. Grav., 26, 1221.
[11]Castro, C. and Pavsic, M. (2002) Phys. Lett B 539, 133; hep-th/0110079
[12] Pizzaglia, W.M. (1999) gr-qc/9912025
[13]Castro,C. (2002) physics/0011040
5
... This led many authors to derive them by various methods, one of the most applicable ones is the Bazanski approach [27] in which from one single Lagrangian one can obtain simultaneously equation of geodesic and geodesic deviations which has been applied in different theories of gravity [4][5][6][7][8][9],and [28][29][30]. Thus, by analogy this technique in case of Poly-vectors to become [31], ...
Article
Full-text available
Article
Full-text available
We examine the question of whether violation of 4D physics is an inevitable consequence of existence of an extra non-compactified dimension. Recent investigations in membrane and Kaluza–Klein theory indicate that when the metric of the spacetime is allowed to depend on the extra coordinate, i.e., the cilindricity condition is dropped, the equation describing the trajectory of a particle in one lower dimension has an extra force with some abnormal properties. Among them, a force term parallel to the four-velocity of the particle and, what is perhaps more surprising, uμfμ≠uμfμ. These properties violate basic concepts in 4D physics. In this Letter we argue that these abnormal properties are not consequence of the extra dimension, but result from the formalism used. We propose a new definition for the force, from the extra dimension, which is free of any contradictions and consistent with usual 4D physics. We show, using warp metrics, that this new definition is also more consistent with our physical intuition. The effects of this force could be detected observing objects moving with high speed, near black holes and/or in cosmological situations.
Article
Full-text available
We start from a new theory (discussed earlier) in which the arena for physics is not spacetime, but its straightforward extension-the so called Clifford space (C-space), a manifold of points, lines, areas, etc..; physical quantities are Clifford algebra valued objects, called polyvectors. This provides a natural framework for description of supersymmetry, since spinors are just left or right minimal ideals of Clifford algebra. The geometry of curved C-space is investigated. It is shown that the curvature in C-space contains higher orders of the curvature in the underlying ordinary space. A C-space is parametrized not only by 1-vector coordinates xμx^\mu but also by the 2-vector coordinates σμν\sigma^{\mu \nu}, 3-vector coordinates σμνρ\sigma^{\mu \nu \rho}, etc., called also {\it holographic coordinates}, since they describe the holographic projections of 1-lines, 2-loops, 3-loops, etc., onto the coordinate planes. A remarkable relation between the "area" derivative \p/ \p \sigma^{\mu \nu} and the curvature and torsion is found: if a scalar valued quantity depends on the coordinates σμν\sigma^{\mu \nu} this indicates the presence of torsion, and if a vector valued quantity depends so, this implies non vanishing curvature. We argue that such a deeper understanding of the C-space geometry is a prerequisite for a further development of this new theory which in our opinion will lead us towards a natural and elegant formulation of M-theory.
Article
Full-text available
This is an introductory review of gravity on branes with an emphasis on codimension 1 models. However, for a new result it is also pointed out that the cosmological evolution of the 3-brane in the model of Dvali, Gabadadze and Porrati may follow the standard Friedmann equation. Contents: 1. Introduction 2. Conventions 3. The Lanczos-Israel matching conditions 4. The action principle with codimension 1 hypersurfaces: Need for the Gibbons-Hawking term 5. The Newtonian limit on thin branes 6. A remark on black holes in the model of Dvali, Gabadadze and Porrati 7. The cosmology of codimension 1 brane worlds Comment: 25 pages
Article
Full-text available
Paths in an appropriate geometry are usually used as trajectories of test particles in geometric theories of gravity. It is shown that non-symmetric geometries possess some interesting quantum features. Without carrying out any quantization schemes, paths in such geometries are naturally quantized. Two different non-symmetric geometries are examined for these features. It is proved that, whatever the non-symmetric geometry is, we always get the same quantum features. It is shown that these features appear only in the pure torsion term (the anti-symmetric part of the affine connection) of the path equations. The vanishing of the torsion leads to the disappearance of these features, regardless of the symmetric part of the connection. It is suggested that, in order to be consistent with the results of experiments and observations, torsion term in path equations should be parametrized using an appropriate parameter.
Article
Full-text available
We study the problem of test-particle motion in the Nonsymmetric Gravitational Theory (NGT) assuming the four-velocity of the particle is parallel-transported along the trajectory. The predicted motion is studied on a static, spherically symmetric background field, with particular attention paid to radial and circular motions. Interestingly, it is found that the proper time taken to travel between any two non-zero radial positions is finite. It is also found that circular orbits can be supported at lower radii than in General Relativity for certain forms of motion. We present three interactions which could be used as alternate methods for coupling a test-particle to the antisymmetric components of the NGT field. One of these takes the form of a Yukawa force in the weak-field limit of a static, spherically symmetric field, which could lead to interesting phenomenology.
Article
Full-text available
The Bazanski approach, for deriving the geodesic equations in Riemannian geometry, is generalized in the absolute parallelism geometry. As a consequence of this generalization three path equations are obtained. A striking feature in the derived equations is the appearance of a torsion term with a numerical coefficients that jumps by a step of one half from equation to another. This is tempting to speculate that the paths in absolute parallelism geometry might admit a quantum feature. Comment: 4 pages Latex file Journal Reference: Astrophysics and space science 228, 273, (1995)
Article
A formalism of integrating the equations of geodesics and of geodesic deviation is examined based upon the Hamilton–Jacobi equation for geodesics. The latter equation has been extended to the case of geodesic deviation and theorems analogous to Jacobi’s theorem on the complete integral has been proved. As a result, a straightforward algorithm of integrating the geodesic deviation equations on Riemannian (or pseudo‐Riemannian) manifolds is obtained.
Article
Path and path deviation equations for charged, spinning and spinning charged objects in different versions of Kaluza-Klein (KK) theory using a modified Bazanski Lagrangian have been derived. The significance of motion in five dimensions, especially for a charged spinning object, has been examined. We have also extended the modified Bazanski approach to derive the path and path deviation equations of a test particle in a version of non-symmetric KK theory.
Article
By carefully analyzing the geodesic motion of a test particle in the bulk of brane worlds, we identify an extra force which is recognized in spacetime of one lower dimensions as a non-gravitational force acting on the particle. Such extra force acts on the particle in such a way that the conventional particle mechanics in one lower dimensions is violated, thereby hinting at the higher-dimensional origin of embedded spacetime in the brane world scenario. We obtain the explicit equations describing the motion of the bulk test particle as observed in one lower dimensions for general gravitating configurations in brane worlds and identify the extra non-gravitational force acting on the particle measured in one lower dimensions. Comment: 21 pages, LaTeX, version to appear in Phys. Rev. D, minor corrections
Article
A solution to the 50 year old problem of a spinning particle in curved space has been recently derived using an extension of Clifford calculus in which each geometric element has its own coordinate. This leads us to propose that all the laws of physics should obey new polydimensional metaprinciples, for which Clifford algebra is the natural language of expression, just as tensors were for general relativity. Specifically, phenomena and physical laws should be invariant under local automorphism transformations which reshuffle the physical geometry. This leads to a new generalized unified basis for classical mechanics, which includes string theory, membrane theory and the hypergravity formulation of Crawford[J. Math. Phys., {\bf 35}, 2701-2718 (1994)]. Most important is that the broad themes presented can be exploited by nearly everyone in the field as a framework to generalize both the Clifford calculus and multivector physics.